Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content
in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.
For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Organization of American Historians is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Journal of
American History.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistoriansand the Crisisin
AmericanHistory,1959-1980
JonathanM. Wiener
Mosthistorians profess
tobelieveinthepursuit oftruth, butasmembers ofa profes-
siontheyarealsoengagedin thelegitimation ofknowledge, in thedefinition of
whoisa historian andwhoisnot,whathistory isandwhatitisnot.Thedefinitions
themselves areproducts ofhistoricalforces.Overtimetheychange.The purpose
ofthisarticleistoexamine thatprocess byfocusing ontheprofession's initialrejec-
tionoftheschoolthatcalleditself"radicalhistory"inthe1960s,andthesubsequent
limitedacceptance ofthatschoolin the1970sand 1980s.
Duringthesixties, a newgeneration ofscholars, a newintellectual community,
formed outofitsownexperiences
itself andconcerns -notably thecivilrights and
antiwar movements. Amongtheprominent members of thatcommunity were
historianswhodeveloped a critiqueof,and an alternative to,thewaysAmerican
history had beenconstructed.Someintellectual leadersofthegroupmadeself-
conscious useofMarxisttheory,
organizing theirwork aroundissuesofclassrelations
andideology. Themajority did not,butall tookthoseissuesseriously. In general
radicalhistorianshavefocusedon issuesofexploitation, domination, andoppres-
sion;theyhavearguedthatexisting patternsofdomination arenotnatural orim-
mutable, butratherhavehistoricalorigins;thustheycanbe abolished. In seeking
thosehistorical theyhavefocused
origins, on ordinary peoplerather thanpolitical
elites,ongroups ratherthanindividuals, andonhumanagency ratherthanon ab-
stractor generalprocessesofchange.Fiercedebateshavesometimes brokenout
amongradicalhistorians. Newsubjects andmethods developed in response to in-
tellectualandpolitical
changesduring thesixtiesandseventies, andonetaskofthis
paperis totracethewayradicalhistorians' definitionsoftheirworkhavechanged.
Marxist ithasbeenwritten,
historians, are"obsessed byan . . . exclusivelyeco-
nomicinterpretation" ofhistory. They"forceevidenceto fittheirpre-conceived
opinions" and"ignore suchmaterials as do notsupport pointofview."
[their] They
ofhistory
JonathanM. Wieneris professor ofCalifornia,
at theUniversity Irvine.An earlierversionofthisarticle
waspresentedat the 1983annualmeetingoftheOrganizationofAmericanHistorians.Researchsupportforthis
articlewas providedbytheAmericanCouncilofLearnedSocieties.The authorwishesto thankEricFoner,Sean
Wilentz,JesseLemisch,ChristineStansell,PerryAnderson,MichaelP.Johnson,Daniel J. Walkowitz, and Peter
Novickfortheircomments, SusanArmeny oftheJAHfor herediting,and BillBillingsley
forhisresearch
assistance.
399
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
400 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 401
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
402 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
6 On Hofstadter's
Communistpartyexperience, see SusanStoutBaker,RadicalBeginnings: RichardHofstadter
and the 1930s(Westport,1985).
7JohnHigham,History:Professional Scholarshipin America(Baltimore,1965), 221. Louis Hartzlamented
America'suniformity;
Daniel Boorstincelebratedit. The professionincludedcriticsofconsensusscholarship:
John
Higham,"The Cultofthe'American Commentary,
Consensus,"' 27 (Feb. 1959),93-100;C. VannWoodward, "The
PopulistHeritageand the Intellectual,"
AmericanScholar,29 (Winter1959-1960),55-72.
8 SigmundDiamond,"The Arrangement: The FBI and HarvardUniversity in theMcCarthy Period,"inBeyond
theHiss Case: TheFBI, Congress,and the Cold War,ed. AthanG. Theoharis(Philadelphia,1982), 341-71;Sig-
mund Diamond, "HeelingforHoover:God and the F.B.I. at Yale,"Nation,April 12, 1980,pp. 423-28; Ellen
No IvoryTower:McCarthyism
Schrecker, and the Universities
(New York,1986).
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
and theCrisisin American
RadicalHistorians History 403
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
404 TheJournal History
ofAmerican
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 405
Duringthesixties, inresponsetothesocialandpoliticalupheavalsthatsweptAmer-
ican societyand politics,new groupsof historiansformed;the worktheydid
presented notso muchnewfactsas a different setofsignificant problemsrequiring
study,and different notionsof whatconstituted a solution.Theyproposeda new
radicalhistory.Theychallengednotonlythemainstream oftheprofession butalso
thescholarship producedbyhistorians withtiesto the Communistparty.The re-
ceivedorthodoxy of historicalmaterialism,and the interpretation of historythat
wentwithit, had been unquestionedin the party.The model of the disciplined
Bolshevik calledfora sternand woodenstyle.The partyhad no firmlineon Amer-
ican history,but itspoliticalshiftsrequiredshifting interpretations of thehistory
ofpopularstruggle, intentions
classalliances,and ruling-class and capabilities.The
subjectsof Soviethistory, partyhistory, twentieth-century labor history, and the
workofMarxist historiansunconnected withthepartyreceivedthemostdogmatic
treatments
The NewLefthistory thatwouldchallengetheprofession duringthesixtiesbegan
withtheshattering oftheCommunist party.And themostpowerful blowsto Com-
munistorthodoxy in theUnitedStateswerestruck, notbyHUAC orJoeMcCarthy,
but byNikitaKhrushchev. His 1956 acknowledgment of the crimesof Stalin,to-
getherwith the Soviet army'sinvasionof Hungary,destroyedAmericanCom-
munists'intellectualworld.18
The EnglishMarxisthistorianE. P. Thompson,whosebook TheMakingofthe
EnglishWorking Classhasbeenthemostimportant exemplar ofradicalhistory since
its publicationin 1964,has describedthe conditionsunderwhichan alternative
community of radicalscholarscould flourish:"some territory whichis, without
qualification,theirown: theirownjournals,theirown . . . centers:placeswhere
no one worksforgradesor fortenurebut forthetransformation ofsociety:places
wherecriticisms and self-criticism
arefierce,butalsomutualhelpand theexchange
oftheoretical and practicalknowledge; placeswhichpre-figure in somewaystheso-
cietyof the future."19
An alternative community beganto takeshape after1956,
of radicalhistorians
whenintellectuals leavingtheCommunistpartyjoinedwithleadingindependent
radicalscholars.ForAmericanhistorians In 1957
we can locateitsoriginsprecisely.
WilliamApplemanWilliamscameto theUniversity ofWisconsinin Madison;his
graduateseminarprovidedtheintellectual arenain whichNew Lefthistory in the
for
UnitedStatesfirstdeveloped.If radicalstudentsat Wisconsinworked grades,
theyalso engagedin themutualhelp,community building,and politicalthinking
Thompsondescribedas essentialto the developmentof radicalscholarship.
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
406 The Journalof AmericanHistory
i _,~~~~A
11:'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Warren Gutmanin Madison,Wisconsin,
JudithGutman,and Herbert
Susman, May1951.
CourtesyMrs.Warren
Susman.
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 407
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
408 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 409
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
410 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistoriansand the Crisisin AmericanHistory 411
DavidMontgomery fromleft)demonstrating
(fifth withUnited
Radio,and Machine
Electrical, Workers 4 againstthe
(UE) District
HouseCommittee on Un-AmericanActivities
in Newark,NewJersey, 1956.
29 Herbert SearchforPower
'The Workers'
Gutman, in theGildedAge,'in TheGildedAge:A Reappraisal,
ed. H. Wayne
Morgan 1963),31-53.Gutman
(Syracuse, calledhimself
a socialist,
butnota Marxist,
in"AnInter-
viewwithHerbert RadicalHistory
Gutman:' Review,27 (May1983),205-6,214-15.Gutman wassubpoenaedby
HUACin1953andquizzedabouthismembership intheCommunist hisparticipation
party, inthe1948presiden-
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
412 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
and theCrisisin American
RadicalHistorians History 413
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
414 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
as Activists
Historians
LeonLitwack
(aboveleft)introducing
HenryWallace
atanoff-campus peace
| t ;' ' 1. ofCalifornia,
at theUniversity
.eft?rmeeting>;*4ps'"^X!F
Berkeley, in 1949.EslandaRobeson(Paul
:.. T Robeson's S. Lester
wife), Hutchinson,
M.P.,
.r
Ij6** ~ 5TI*-sar { rh 3 and SenatorMicheleGuia ofItalyare
behind
Litwack
andWallace.
. .. oanWallach
Scott onthesteps
(aboveright)
t oftheMemorial
Unionat theUniversity
of
_ Madison,
Wisconsin, ata
1963,speaking
rally the
against VietnamWar.
PhotographbyC. ClarkKissinger.
(left)infront
EricFoner ofColumbia
LowLibrary.
University's Thisphotograph
of
students tonuclear
opposed testing
appeared
intheColumbia circa1962.
DailySpectator
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Radical Historiansand the Crisisin AmericanHistory 415
JohnHigham,Arthur
JohnHope Franklin, Mann,andWilliamLeuchtenburg
demonstrators
withothercivilrights
(leftto right)marched
fromSelmato Montgomery,Alabama,in March1965.
byDennisHopper.
Photograph
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 417
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
418 ofAmerican
TheJournal History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Radical Historiansand the Crisisin AmericanHistory 419
a 1ImIcA:u4
MC-j
4ll
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
420 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
and theCrisisin American
RadicalHistorians History 421
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
422 TheJournal History
ofAmerican
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 423
En 'I'd v_
' ,
w as
Ax | Of _ . : tmi tg
xtE I SS 1 0
_S s.f . #ss
- ' Hess
All"''' |
r _?s- A_ _sB_ ' 1
^ _
. x
A b|_e ' _
All_'
_ =
_v
__ I
__
.__ 1
__ ,
I__ _,_S
_ r + __ a
_r __ s
a___ _
JesseLemischtalking
toUniversity
ofChicagostudents
during
a
sit-in
against
thedraft attheadministration
building
inMay1966.
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
424 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 425
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
426 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 427
A turningpointin theprofession's
recognition
ofradicalhistory camein 1967,when
theAHR publishedan entirearticleattackingradicalhistory, IrwinUnger's"The
'New Left'and AmericanHistory." The editorshad solicitedthe adviceof David
Donald, whoarguedthatitshouldnotbe publishedbecause"thehistorians whose
work[Unger]discussedwerenotofsufficient consequenceto meritextendedcon-
in thepagesofourmajorprofessional
sideration journal."63The historians
included
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
428 TheJournal History
ofAmerican
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RadicalHistorians
and theCrisisin American
History 429
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
430 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
69 Hofstadter,ProgressiveHistorians,459, 465.
70 David Potter,"The Artof Comity," New YorkReviewofBooks,Dec. 5, 1968,pp. 46-48.
71 Studieson the Left,1 (Spring1960), 5.
72 C. VannWoodward, "Commenton Genovese,"Studieson theLeft,6 (Nov.-Dec. 1966),36, 38, 40. Wood-
wardsubsequently led a fightto preventHerbertApthekerfromteachinga student-initiated
one-term seminar
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
and theCrisisin American
RadicalHistorians History 431
beingbranded'establishment' or 'consensus,"'
he declaredthatit wouldbe a "mis-
take"forthe profession to ignoreor dismissthe radicalhistorians. "Theydeserve
a fullhearingand a closereading," he wrote."Theyhavemuchto saythatis relevant
to thecorrectionof a complacentand nationalistic readingof ourpast."In one of
hismostmemorablestatements, Woodwardconcludedthat,iftheradicalhistorians
sometimes"opposedtheinevitable"in Americansociety,"theinevitableneedsall
the oppositionit can get."73
Otherestablishedhistorians joinedin redefiningthefieldto includeradicalhis-
tory.The editorsof newjournalslaunchedto overcomethelimitations of existing
scholarship adoptededitorialpoliciesdifferent fromthoseof the officialjournals.
Mostimportant wastheJournalofSocialHistory, whichbeganpublishingin 1967
underthe editorship of PeterStearns.The foundingeditorialboardincludednot
only committedopponentsof radical history,notablyOscar Handlin, Nathan
Glazer,and RobertNisbet,butalso Genovese,GeorgeRude,and ReginaldZelnick.
The board'scompositionand severalessaysin the firsttwovolumesmade it clear
thatradicalhistory waspartofsocialhistory.74 LaborHistoryand theJournal ofIn-
terdisciplinaryHistoryalso published the best radical workas part of social
history-and criticized it as such.Theireditors -Milton Cantorin theformer case,
RobertRotbergand TheodoreRabbin thelatter-played a crucialrolein redefining
the field.
As thebarriersbegantofall,somehistorians whohad insistedthatradicalhistory
wasnothistory abandonedthatposition.Donald wasthemostimportant. His own
workunderwent a striking transformation:thefirst volumeofhis CharlesSumner
biography, publishedin 1960,portrayed Sumneras psychologically disturbed;itre-
ceiveda greatdeal of criticism fromradicalhistorians. The secondvolume,pub-
lishedin 1970,portrayed Sumneras a heroicfighter forblackrights.Laterhe praised
Litwack'sBeen in the StormSo Long and otherradicalhistories of the post-Civil
War South.75
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
432 ofAmerican
TheJournal History
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Radical Historiansand the Crisisin AmericanHistory 433
. s _X W - ~~~~~~~N. s
FP E -t
r 41 OkeE_ _
', ~
t ......_i
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
434 TheJournal
ofAmerican
History
78 On the
debatebetweenMarxist humanismand structuralism, seeJonWiener,"Marxist Theoryand History:
Thompsonand Althusser," SocialistReview,10 (July-Aug.1980), 136-44. On Gutmanand Genovese,see Ira
Berlin,"HerbertG. Gutmanand theAmericanWorking Class,"in HerbertG. Gutman,Powerand Culture:Essays
on theAmericanWorking Class(New York,1987),46-52, 55-59; EugeneD. Genovese,"Solidarity and Servitude,"
TimesLiterary Supplement,Feb. 25, 1977,pp. 198-99;EugeneD. Genovese,"The Debate overTimeon theCross:
A CritiqueofBourgeoisCriticism," inElizabethFox-Genovese and EugeneD. Genovese,FruitsofMerchant Capital
(New York,1983),136-71.Around13% ofhistorians describedtheirpoliticalorientation
as "left"in a 1984survey.
See StephenH. Balchand HerbertI. London,"The TenuredLeft,"Commentary, 54 (Oct. 1986),43. KentBlaser
arguesthatradicalhistorians havefailedto formand transmit a newparadigm,but his criteria forsuccessare so
highthatno schoolofhistory has attainedit: "fortheschoolto be successfulor hegemonic. . . it mustbe able
to socializefollowersoverseveralgenerations." Kent Blaser,"What Happened to New LeftHistory?:Part1, An
Institutional Approach,"SouthAtlanticQuarterly, 85 (Summer1986), 283-96, esp. 289.
79 E. P. Thompson,"AgendasforRadicalHistory," RadicalHistoryReview(no. 36, 1986),41-42.
This content downloaded from 128.122.253.228 on Fri, 24 Apr 2015 20:29:18 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions