You are on page 1of 50

1

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control

Chapter 2:
Modeling in the Frequency Domain
Chapter 2: Modeling in the Frequency Domain

2
Outline
Laplace Transform Review

Electrical Network Transfer Function

Translational Mechanical Systems Transfer Function

Rotational Mechanical Systems Transfer Function

Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

Linearization

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
Chapter 2: Modeling in the Frequency Domain
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears
3

Outline
o Gears Fundamentals
o Reflecting Torques
o Reflecting Impedances
o Gear Trains
o Examples

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

4
Gears Fundamental Relations

T- Torque
- angular displacement
N- number of teeth
r- radius

Gears are assumed to be


lossless, namely, the
input and output power
are assumed to be equal

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears
Reflecting Torques from one Shaft to another
5

Write the equation of motion in 2(s)

(Js2 + Ds + K) 2(s) = T2(s)

Where T2(s)=T1(s) N2 / N1
(Js2 + Ds + K) 2(s) = T1(s) N2 / N1

A torque can be reflected from one


shaft to another by multiplying by
the ratio:

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears
Reflecting Impedances from one Shaft to another
6

(Js2 + Ds + K) 2(s) = T1(s) N2 / N1

Write the equation of motion in 1(s)

We know that 2(s) = 1(s) N1 / N2

(Js2 + Ds + K) 1(s) N1 / N2= T1(s) N2 / N1

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears
Reflecting Impedances from one Shaft to another
7

Impedances can be reflected from one shaft to another by


multiplying by the ratio:

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

8
Example 21
2 (s)
Find the transfer function for the system shown
T1 (s)

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

9
Example 21
Procedure

o Reflect torque T1(s) from shaft 1 to shaft 2


o Reflect J1 and D1 to shaft 2
o Express the equivalent moment of inertia Je on shaft 2
o Express the equivalent damping coefficient De on shaft 2
o Express the equivalent spring constant Ke on shaft 2
o Finally, express the transfer function and draw a block diagram

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

10
Example 21
Solution

source shaft destination shaft

o Reflecting T1(s) from shaft 1 to shaft 2, we obtain:

N2 destination shaft
T1 (s)
N1 source shaft
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

11
Example 21
Solution

source shaft destination shaft

o Reflecting J1 from shaft 1 to shaft 2, we obtain


2
N destination shaft
J1 2
N1 source shaft
o Reflecting D1 from shaft 1 to shaft 2, we obtain
2
N
D1 2
N1
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

12
Example 21
Solution
2
N
J e = J1 2 + J 2
N1

2
N
De = D1 2 + D2
N1

Ke = K2

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

13
Example 21
Solution
Equation of motion:
N2
( 2
)
J e s + De s + K e 2 (s) = T1 (s)
N1
2
N2
J e
= J 1 + J 2
N
1

2
N
De = D1 2 + D2
N1

Ke = K2
Block diagram:
Transfer function:
2 (s) N 2 N1
G(s) = =
T1 (s) (
J e s 2 + De s + K e
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control
)
Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

14
Gear Trains Relations

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

15
Gear Trains Relations
Example 22
For the gear train shown:
1 (s)
o Find
T1 (s)

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

16
Gear Trains Relations
Example 22 Solution
1 (s)
o Find
T1 (s)

2 2
N N N
J e = J1 + ( J 2 + J 3 ) 1 + ( J 4 + J 5 ) 3 1
N2 N4 N2
2
N
De = D1 + D2 1
N2
Ke = 0

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

17
Gear Trains Relations
Example 22 Solution
Equation of motion in 1(s):

( )
J e s 2 + De s 1 (s) = T1 (s)
2 2
N N N
J e = J1 + ( J 2 + J 3 ) 1 + ( J 4 + J 5 ) 3 1
N2 N4 N2
2
N
De = D1 + D2 1
N2
Block diagram:
Transfer function:
1 (s) 1
G(s) = =
T1 (s) (
J e s 2 + De s )
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

18
Gear Trains Relations
Example 22
For the gear train shown:
3 (s)
o Find
T1 (s)

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

19
Gear Trains Relations
3 (s) Example 22 Solution
o Find
T1 (s)
Reflecting torque T1(s) from shaft 1 to
shaft 3, we obtain:
N N
T1 (s) 2 4
N1 N 3
2 2
N N N
J e = J1 2 4 + ( J 2 + J 3 ) 4 + J 4 + J 5
N1 N 3 N3
2 2
N N N
De = D1 2 4 + D2 4
N1 N 3 N3
Ke = 0
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

20
Gear Trains Relations
Example 22 Solution
Equation of motion in 1(s):
N N
( 2
)
J e s + De s 3 (s) = T1 (s) 2 4
N1 N 3

Transfer function:
N2 N4
3 (s) N1 N 3
G(s) = =
T1 (s) (
J e s 2 + De s )

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

21
Gear Trains Relations
Example 22
For the gear train shown:
2 (s)
o Find
T1 (s)

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

22
Gear Trains Relations
2 (s) Example 22 Solution
o Find
T1 (s)
Reflecting torque T1(s) from shaft 1 to
shaft 2, we obtain:
N
T1 (s) 2
N1
2 2
N N
J e = J1 2 + J 2 + J 3 + ( J 4 + J 5 ) 3
N1 N4
2
N
De = D1 2 + D2
N1
Ke = 0
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

23
Gear Trains Relations
Example 22 Solution
Equation of motion in 2(s):
N
( 2
)
J e s + De s 3 (s) = T1 (s) 2
N1

Transfer function:

2 (s) N 2 N1
G(s) = =
T1 (s) (
J e s 2 + De s )

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.5 - Transfer Functions for Systems with Gears

24
Gear Trains Relations
Skill-Assessment Exercise 2.10
2 (s)
For the system shown, find the transfer function
T1 (s)

Answer:
2 (s) 12
= 2
T1 (s) s + s +1
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
Chapter 2: Modeling in the Frequency Domain
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
25

Outline
o Electromechanical Systems
o Typical Example: Motor
o Armature-controlled DC motor Transfer Function
o Mechanical and Electrical Constants
o Equivalent Inertia and Damping
o Torque-Speed Curves
o Summary
o Problems

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

26
Electromechanical Systems
o Systems that are hybrid of electrical and mechanical variables

o Robot controls, disk drive position control, sun and star tracker,
etc.

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

27
Typical Example: Motor
Electrical input Mechanical output
(voltage) (angular displacement)

Objective: Determine the transfer function relating the input


voltage to the output displacement

Stationary permanent magnets

Armature-controlled DC servomotor
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

28
Force within the Motor
The armature, carrying the current ia(t), is rotating in the fixed
magnetic field to generate force within the motor equal to:

F = l B ia(t) B, magnetic field strength
l, length of the conductor

The resulting torque turns the rotor.

In turn, a conductor moving at right angles to the magnetic field


generates a voltage to the terminals of the conductor equal to:

e, voltage
= v, velocity of the conductor normal to the magnetic field

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

29
Armature Circuit Loop Equation
Ra I a (s) + La sI a (s) +Vb (s) = Ea (s)
Voltage is proportional to velocity:
d m (t)
vb (t) = K b
dt

vb, back electromotive force emf


Vb (s) = K bs m (s) Kb, back emf constant
dm/dt angular velocity of the motor

Torque is proportional to armature current:


Tm (s)
Tm (s) = K t I a (s) I a (s) =
Kt
motor torque constant
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

30
Armature Circuit Loop Equation

Ra I a (s) + La sI a (s) +Vb (s) = Ea (s)


Vb (s) = K bs m (s) Tm (s)
Tm (s)
( Ra + Las) K + K bs m (s) = Ea (s)
I a (s) = t
Kt
We still need Tm(s) in terms of m(s)
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Equivalent Mechanical Loading on a Motor
31

( )
Tm (s) = J ms 2 + Dms m (s)

Equivalent inertia at the armature


(armature inertia + reflected inertia)

Tm (s)
( Ra + Las) K + K bs m (s) = Ea (s)
t
+ L s J s (
2
)
( a a ) m + Dms m (s) + K s (s) = E (s)
R
b m a
Kt
Note that for DC motors, La is negligible compared to Ra
R
( J ms + Dm ) + K b s m (s) = Ea (s)
a

Kt
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

32
Transfer Function
R
a ( J ms + Dm ) + K b s m (s) = Ea (s)
Kt
After simplification:

m (s) K t ( Ra J m ) K
= =
Ea (s) 1 K t K b s ( s + )
s s + Dm +
Jm Ra

Note: Kt is in N-m/A (Newton-meters/Ampere)


Kb is in V-s/rad (Volt-seconds/radian)
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

33
Mechanical and Electrical Constants
(s)
m
K (R J ) t a m
=
Ea (s) 1 K t K b
s s + Dm +
Jm Ra

Mechanical constants:
Obtained by reflecting impedances to the
Jm, Dm
armature

Electrical Constants:
Obtained through a dynamometer test of
the motor
Kt/Ra , Kb
Torque-speed curve for a constant
applied voltage ea
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Equivalent Inertia and Damping at the Armature
34

( )
Tm (s) = J ms 2 + Dms m (s)

Equivalent inertia at the armature


(armature inertia + reflected inertia)

N
2 inertia of the
Jm = Ja + J L 1 mechanical load
N2 driven by the motor
2
N
Dm = Da + DL 1
N2

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

35
Torque-Speed Relationship
Back to the armature loop equation
Tm (s)
( Ra + Las) K + K bs m (s) = Ea (s)
t

Since La is negligible, the equation becomes


Ra
Tm (s) + K bs m (s) = Ea (s)
Kt
L 1 d m (t)
L {s m (s)} =
1
= m (t)
dt
Ra
Tm (t) + K b m (t) = ea (t)
Kt constant applied DC voltage
K b Kt Kt
Tm = m + ea
Ra Ra
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

36
Torque-Speed Curves
K b Kt Kt
Tm = m + ea Equation of a straight line
Ra Ra stall torque
Kt
When m, T = Tstall = ea
Ra
ea
When T=0, m = noload =
Kb
no-load speed

K t Tstall
=
Ra ea
Finally, knowing ea, Tstall and no-load
we find the electrical constants ea
Kb =
noload
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer Function for Electromechanical Systems
37
Summary
m (s) K t ( Ra J m )
=
Ea (s) 1 K t K b
s s + Dm +
Jm Ra
2
N
K t Tstall Jm = Ja + J L 1
= N2
Ra ea
2
ea N
Kb = Dm = Da + DL 1
noload N2

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
38
Example 23

a) Find the transfer function


L (s)
Ea (s)
b) Determine the form of the transient response.

c) Given a unit step input ea(t)=u(t), determine the total response L(t)

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
39
Example 23 Solution
m (s) K t ( Ra J m )
a) First find =
Ea (s) 1 K t K b
s s + Dm +
Jm Ra

2 2
N 1
J m = J a + J L = 5+ 700 = 12
1

N2 10
2 2
N 1
Dm = Da + DL = 2 + 800 = 10
1

N2 10

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
40
Example 23 Solution
m (s) K t ( Ra J m )
a) First find =
Ea (s) 1 K t K b
s s + Dm +
Jm Ra

Tstall = 500, noload = 50, ea = 100

K t Tstall 500
= = =5
Ra ea 100
ea 100
Kb = = =2
noload 50
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
41
Example 23 Solution
m (s) K t ( Ra J m )
a) First find =
Ea (s) 1 K t K b
s s + Dm +
Jm Ra

K
t =5 J = 12
Ra m
Dm = 10
Kb = 2

m (s) 5 12 0.417
= =
Ea (s) 1 s ( s +1.667 )
ss +
12
(
10 + (5) ( 2) )

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
42
Example 23 Solution
L (s)
a) Then express
Ea (s)

100
L = m = 0.1 m
m (s) 0.417 1000 L (s) 0.0417
= =
Ea (s) s ( s +1.667 ) Ea (s) s ( s +1.667 )

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
43
Example 23 Solution
b) The form of the transient response depends on the roots of the
denominator of the transfer function (after simplification)

L transient (t) = A+ Be1.667t

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
44
Example 23 Solution
c) To determine the total solution, we first write L(s). Then, we
perform a partial fraction decomposition on L(s) and finally we
calculate its inverse Laplace transform L(t).

0.0417 ea(t) being a unit step input,


L (s) = Ea (s)
s ( s +1.667 ) Ea(s) is thus equal to 1/s

0.0417
L (s) = 2
s ( s +1.667 )

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
45
Example 23 Solution

0.0417 1 A B C
L (s) = 2 = 0.0417 2 = 0.0417 + 2+
s ( s +1.667 ) s ( s + 5 3) s+5 3 s s

1 9
A= 2 =
s s=
5 25
Because of 3

the double 1 3
root s=0 B= =
s + 5 3 s=0 5
d 1 1 9
C = = 2
=
ds s + 5 3
s=0 (s + 5 3) 25
s=0
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems
Transfer FunctionDC Motor and Load
46
Example 23 Solution

9 25 3 5 9 25
L (s) = 0.0417 + 2
s+5 3 s s

Inverse Laplace transform L 1

9 5t 3 9
L (t) = 0.0417 e 3 + t
25 5 25

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

47
Extra Problem
Find the transfer function L(s)/Ea(s), for the motor and load
shown. The Torque-speed curve is given by Tm=-8m+200 when
the input voltage is 100 volts.

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

48
Extra Problem - Solution
First find the transfer function relating m to Ea:
!! (!) !! /(!! !! )
=
!! ! 1 !! !!
! !+ ! +
!! ! !!
20 25 !
Mechanical constants: !! = 1 + 400 = 2 kg. m!
100 100
!
20 25
!! = 5 + 800 = 7 N. m. s/rad
100 100

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

49
Extra Problem - Solution
From the torque speed equation: Tm=-8m+200 ;

Tstall=200 N.m (obtained by setting m=0 in the equation)


no-load=25 rad/s (obtained by setting Tm=0 in the equation)

Accordingly, !! = !!"#$$ = 200 = 2


!! !! 100

!! 100
!! = = =4
!!"!!"#$ 25
Therefore,
!! (!) 2/2 1
= =
!! ! 1 !(! + 15/2)
! !+ 7+8
2
MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay
2.6 Transfer Functions for Electromechanical Systems

50
Extra Problem - Solution
Now find the transfer function relating L to Ea:

!! 20 25 1
= =
!! 100 100 20
Finally,

!! (!) 1 !! 1/20
= =
!! ! 20 !! (!) !(! + 15/2)

MCHE 511 - Dynamic Systems, Control Fall 2017-2018 Dr. Amine Abou Moughlbay

You might also like