You are on page 1of 8

Calculation Sheet

Project title Calc no


Client Proj no
Calculation title Phase/CTR
Path Page of

1.0 Introduction

The purpose of this calculation is to document the design of a padeye. This spreadsheet was developed primarily to satisfy the
requirements of Reference 1, Edwin P Russo and Rudolph A Hall, " Systematic Approach to Lifting Eye Design"

1.1 Applied Loading

The lifting loads were determined from a lift analysis which considered a load factor of 2.0 applied to the structure gravity loads,
in order to determine the design load to be used for the padeye design.
From SACS analysis of bridge lift:
Padeye design load 72.2 kips

2.0 Padeye Configuration

The principal features of the padeye are shown below, while details have been included on drawing INSERT DRAWING
NUMBER.

r R SWL SWL
Sw

R
2r
b

b c

B a B Rh g

A A
h t Tp t

T
where:
SWL = safe working load
b = angle from horizontal
Rh = Hole radius
r = Cheek plate radius
R = Main plate radius
Tp = Main plate thickness
t = Cheek plate thickness
T = Total plate thickness
h = Base width
b = Distance from edge of taper to center of hole
c = Distance from base of plate to center of hole

Sw = Cheek plate weld leg


e = Main plate to cheek plate clearance
a = Taper angle
p = Shackle pin diameter

The dimension T should equal 60 - 85% of shackle jaw width.


Calculation Sheet

Project title Calc no


Client Proj no
Calculation title Phase/CTR
Path Page of

The pin hole diameter, d, should be 1/8" greater than the selected shackle pin size
The main plate radius is approximately R = 3 Rh
Cheek plate radius is approximately r = R - 1.5t
The cheek plate thickness (t) should be less than or equal to the plate thickness (Tp).

Shackle load 36.1 kips = 18.05 short tons


Use G-2130 Crosby 2-inch shackle, capacity 17 tons, shackle pin size 1.63 inches
Refer to http://catalog.thecrosbygroup.com/maininterface.htm

Shackle jaw width A = 2.382 in


Total padeye width should be between 1.429 > and < 2.025 in

Shackle pin size D = 1.630 in


Pin hole diameter should be 2.063 in
Hole radius = 1.031 in
so main plate radius should be approximately 3.094 in
Say main plate radius = 2.938 in
Cheek plate radius = 2.375 in

Rh = 1.031 in Hole radius


r = 2.375 in Cheek plate radius
R = 2.938 in Main plate radius
Tp = 1.000 in Main plate thickness
t = 0.625 in Cheek plate thickness
T = 2.250 in Total plate thickness
h = 14.750 in Base width
b = 0.000 in Distance from edge of taper to center of hole
c = 3.938 in Distance from base of plate to center of hole
e = 0.563 in Main plate to cheek plate clearance
a = 90 degrees = 1.571 radians
p = 1.630 in 200 ton shackle
Fy = 36 ksi Yield strength of padeye material

3.0 Stress Checks

The following stress checks are performed in this analysis

Bearing Stress - determines the average bearing stress of pin on hole.


Shear Stress - two planes from pin hole to plate edge in load direction.
Tensile Stress - calculated on the net area through plate.
Weld Stress - calculated around cheek plate
Combined Stress - determined at the base of padeye plate and at various points along padeye plate

Taper Angle - check on value of taper angle


Out-of-plane bending - check combined tension, in-plane bending and out-of-plane bending

3.1 Load

P = 72.2 kips Design Load (max from Table 1.1-1)


b = 60 degrees = 1.047 radians
Ph = 36.1 kips Horizontal In-Plane Component
Pv = 62.5 kips Vertical In-Plane Component

3.2 Design Stresses


Calculation Sheet

Project title Calc no


Client Proj no
Calculation title Phase/CTR
Path Page of

Bearing Stress
Bearing = 19.7 ksi Bearing = P/(T*p)
Allowable = 32.4 ksi Allowable = 0.9Fy
UC1 = 0.608 OK

Shear Stress
Shear = 10.1 ksi Shear = P/(4(r-Rh)*t+2(R-Rh)*Tp)
Allowable = 14.4 ksi Allowable = 0.4Fy
UC2 = 0.699 OK

Tensile Stress
From Section D3.2 of AISC, the distance used in calculations, across the hole, is the minimum of 4 times the plate
thickness at the pinhole or 1.6 times the hole diameter.

Tensile stress = 9.7 ksi Tensile = P/(Effective width * plate thickness)


Effective width = 3.3 in
Plate thickness = 2.3 in
Allowable stress = 16.2 ksi Allowable = 0.45Fy
UC3 = 0.600 OK

Weld Stress
Load on one weld = 36.1 kips Weld load F = P/2 (assume each weld takes full load)
Weld Shear = 6.8 ksi Weld Shear = F/(2pr*(0.707*Sw))
Sw = 0.500 in fillet weld size
Allowable = 21.0 ksi Allowable = 0.3Fuw
Fw = 70.0 ksi E70XX Electrodes, ultimate strength
UC4 = 0.326 OK

Combined Stress
The axial stress due to uniform tension along a section is given by:

fa = P sinb / TP h

The elemental bending stress which is linearly distributed along the section B-B may be expressed as:

fb = 12PC (b cosb - 0.5 h sinb + R sinb) / TP h2

where C represents the distance of an element from the neutral axis. For Section A-A, b should be replaced by c in
the above equation.

The shearing stress varies parabolically along the length of the padeye and is given as:

fV = 1.5P cosb (1 - 4C2) / TP h

The maximum principal stress that exists on an element is given by:

fmax = ((fa + fb)/2) + [((fa + fb)/2)2 + fv2]1/2

and the maximum principal shear stress on an element is given by:

fmax = [((fa + fb)/2)2 + fv2]1/2


Calculation Sheet

Project title Calc no


Client Proj no
Calculation title Phase/CTR
Path Page of

The following table shows the values of the axial stress, bending stress, shear stress, principal stress and maximum shear
stress at various points along the length of the plate.

The allowable stresses are:

Tension Allowable = 21.6 ksi Allowable = 0.6Fy


Shear Allowable = 14.4 ksi Allowable = 0.4Fy

Stresses calculated at Section B-B. Stresses calculated at Section A-A.


Tension Shear Tension Shear
C fa fb fv fmax UC fvmax UC C fa fb fv fmax UC fvmax UC
(in) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (in) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi)
0.00 4.2 0.0 3.7 6.4 0.29 4.2 0.29 0.00 4.2 0.0 3.7 6.4 0.29 4.2 0.29
0.10 4.2 -1.5 3.5 5.1 0.24 3.8 0.26 0.10 4.2 -0.7 3.5 5.7 0.26 3.9 0.27
0.20 4.2 -3.1 3.1 3.7 0.17 3.1 0.22 0.20 4.2 -1.5 3.1 4.7 0.22 3.4 0.23
0.30 4.2 -4.6 2.3 2.2 0.10 2.4 0.16 0.30 4.2 -2.2 2.3 3.6 0.16 2.6 0.18
0.40 4.2 -6.1 1.3 0.7 0.03 1.6 0.11 0.40 4.2 -3.0 1.3 2.1 0.10 1.5 0.10
0.50 4.2 -7.7 0.0 0.0 0.00 1.7 0.12 0.50 4.2 -3.7 0.0 0.5 0.02 0.3 0.02
MAX 0.29 0.29 0.29 0.29

Out-of Plane Bending


Check out-of plane bending at section A-A, which is the worst case scenario, ignoring the gusset plates. In addition as the
padeyes are aligned with the slings, take a minimum load of 5% of the total applied load. Note that this out of plane stress
is combined with the inplane bending stress and tensile stress calculated above.

Out-of-plane load PL = 3.6 kips (P / 20)


Lever arm, c = 3.9 in
Bending moment, M = 14.2 in-kips (PL c)
Section modulus S = 2.5 in3 (1/6 hT2p)
Out-of-plane bending stress = 5.8 ksi (M / S)
Allowable = 27.0 ksi (0.75 Fy)
Out-of-plane bending stress / allowable = 0.21 OK

Maximum tensile stress = 4.2 ksi


Allowable = 21.6 ksi (0.6 Fy)
Tensile stress / allowable = 0.20 OK

Maximum in-plane bending stress = 0.0 ksi


Allowable = 23.8 ksi (0.66 Fy)
In-plane bending stress / allowable = 0.00 OK

Sum of ratios = 0.41 OK

For out-of-plane bending at the B-B axis, the out-of-plane bending moment is reduced by the ratio of the lever arms and
therefore, is not critical. Consequently, no analysis of this section is required.
Calculation Sheet

Project title Calc no


Client Proj no
Calculation title Phase/CTR
Path Page of

1.0 Introduction

The purpose of this calculation is to document the design of a padeye. This spreadsheet was developed primarily to satisfy the
requirements of Reference 1, Edwin P Russo and Rudolph A Hall, " Systematic Approach to Lifting Eye Design"

1.1 Applied Loading

The lifting loads were determined from a lift analysis which considered a load factor of 2.0 applied to the structure gravity loads,
in order to determine the design load to be used for the padeye design.
From SACS analysis of bridge lift:
Padeye design load, P 7.04 kips

2.0 Padeye Configuration

The principal features of the padeye are shown below, while details have been included on drawing INSERT DRAWING
NUMBER.

r R SWL SWL
Sw

R
2r
b

b c

B a B Rh g

A A
h t Tp t

T
where:
SWL = safe working load
b = angle from horizontal
Rh = Hole radius
r = Cheek plate radius
R = Main plate radius
Tp = Main plate thickness
t = Cheek plate thickness
T = Total plate thickness
h = Base width
b = Distance from edge of taper to center of hole
c = Distance from base of plate to center of hole

Sw = Cheek plate weld leg


e = Main plate to cheek plate clearance
a = Taper angle
p = Shackle pin diameter

The dimension T should equal 60 - 85% of shackle jaw width.


Calculation Sheet

Project title Calc no


Client Proj no
Calculation title Phase/CTR
Path Page of

The pin hole diameter, d, should be 1/8" greater than the selected shackle pin size
The main plate radius is approximately R = 3 Rh
Cheek plate radius is approximately r = R - 1.5t
The cheek plate thickness (t) should be less than or equal to the plate thickness (Tp).

Shackle load SWL 3.52 kips = 1.76 short tons


Use G-2130 Crosby 2-inch shackle, capacity 35 tons, shackle pin size 2.3 inches
Refer to http://catalog.thecrosbygroup.com/maininterface.htm

Shackle jaw width A = 3.250 in


Total padeye width should be between 1.950 > and < 2.763 in

Shackle pin size D = 2.300 in


Pin hole diameter should be 2.500 in
Hole radius = 1.250 in
so main plate radius should be approximately 3.750 in
Say main plate radius = 5.000 in
Cheek plate radius = 4.000 in

Rh = 0.433 in Hole radius


r = 0.984 in Cheek plate radius
R = 1.378 in Main plate radius
Tp = 0.472 in Main plate thickness
t = 0.236 in Cheek plate thickness
T = 0.945 in Total plate thickness
h = 4.528 in Base width
b = 1.772 in Distance from edge of taper to center of hole
c = 1.772 in Distance from base of plate to center of hole
e = 0.394 in Main plate to cheek plate clearance
a = 35 degrees = 0.611 radians
p = 2.300 in 200 ton shackle
Fy = 50 ksi Yield strength of padeye material

3.0 Stress Checks

The following stress checks are performed in this analysis

Bearing Stress - determines the average bearing stress of pin on hole.


Shear Stress - two planes from pin hole to plate edge in load direction.
Tensile Stress - calculated on the net area through plate.
Weld Stress - calculated around cheek plate
Combined Stress - determined at the base of padeye plate and at various points along padeye plate

Taper Angle - check on value of taper angle


Out-of-plane bending - check combined tension, in-plane bending and out-of-plane bending

3.1 Load

P = 7.0 kips Design Load (max from Table 1.1-1)


b = 60 degrees = 1.047 radians
Ph = 3.5 kips Horizontal In-Plane Component
Pv = 6.1 kips Vertical In-Plane Component

3.2 Design Stresses


Calculation Sheet

Project title Calc no


Client Proj no
Calculation title Phase/CTR
Path Page of

Bearing Stress
Bearing = 3.2 ksi Bearing = P/(T*p)
Allowable = 45.0 ksi Allowable = 0.9Fy
UC1 = 0.072 OK

Shear Stress
Shear = 5.0 ksi Shear = P/(4(r-Rh)*t+2(R-Rh)*Tp)
Allowable = 20.0 ksi Allowable = 0.4Fy
UC2 = 0.249 OK

Tensile Stress
From Section D3.2 of AISC, the distance used in calculations, across the hole, is the minimum of 4 times the plate
thickness at the pinhole or 1.6 times the hole diameter.

Tensile stress = 5.4 ksi Tensile = P/(Effective width * plate thickness)


Effective width = 1.4 in
Plate thickness = 0.9 in
Allowable stress = 22.5 ksi Allowable = 0.45Fy
UC3 = 0.239 OK

Weld Stress
Load on one weld = 3.5 kips Weld load F = P/2 (assume each weld takes full load)
Weld Shear = 1.6 ksi Weld Shear = F/(2pr*(0.707*Sw))
Sw = 0.500 in fillet weld size
Allowable = 21.0 ksi Allowable = 0.3Fuw
Fw = 70.0 ksi E70XX Electrodes, ultimate strength
UC4 = 0.077 OK

Combined Stress
The axial stress due to uniform tension along a section is given by:

fa = P sinb / TP h

The elemental bending stress which is linearly distributed along the section B-B may be expressed as:

fb = 12PC (b cosb - 0.5 h sinb + R sinb) / TP h2

where C represents the distance of an element from the neutral axis. For Section A-A, b should be replaced by c in
the above equation.

The shearing stress varies parabolically along the length of the padeye and is given as:

fV = 1.5P cosb (1 - 4C2) / TP h

The maximum principal stress that exists on an element is given by:

fmax = ((fa + fb)/2) + [((fa + fb)/2)2 + fv2]1/2

and the maximum principal shear stress on an element is given by:

fmax = [((fa + fb)/2)2 + fv2]1/2


Calculation Sheet

Project title Calc no


Client Proj no
Calculation title Phase/CTR
Path Page of

The following table shows the values of the axial stress, bending stress, shear stress, principal stress and maximum shear
stress at various points along the length of the plate.

The allowable stresses are:

Tension Allowable = 30.0 ksi Allowable = 0.6Fy


Shear Allowable = 20.0 ksi Allowable = 0.4Fy

Stresses calculated at Section B-B. Stresses calculated at Section A-A.


Tension Shear Tension Shear
C fa fb fv fmax UC fvmax UC C fa fb fv fmax UC fvmax UC
(in) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (in) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi) (ksi)
0.00 2.9 0.0 2.5 4.3 0.14 2.9 0.14 0.00 2.9 0.0 2.5 4.3 0.14 2.9 0.14
0.10 2.9 0.1 2.4 4.3 0.14 2.8 0.14 0.10 2.9 0.1 2.4 4.3 0.14 2.8 0.14
0.20 2.9 0.2 2.1 4.1 0.14 2.6 0.13 0.20 2.9 0.2 2.1 4.1 0.14 2.6 0.13
0.30 2.9 0.3 1.6 3.8 0.13 2.2 0.11 0.30 2.9 0.3 1.6 3.8 0.13 2.2 0.11
0.40 2.9 0.4 0.9 3.5 0.12 1.9 0.09 0.40 2.9 0.4 0.9 3.5 0.12 1.9 0.09
0.50 2.9 0.5 0.0 3.4 0.11 1.7 0.08 0.50 2.9 0.5 0.0 3.4 0.11 1.7 0.08
MAX 0.14 0.14 0.14 0.14

Out-of Plane Bending


Check out-of plane bending at section A-A, which is the worst case scenario, ignoring the gusset plates. In addition as the
padeyes are aligned with the slings, take a minimum load of 5% of the total applied load. Note that this out of plane stress
is combined with the inplane bending stress and tensile stress calculated above.

Out-of-plane load PL = 0.4 kips (P / 20)


Lever arm, c = 1.8 in
Bending moment, M = 0.6 in-kips (PL c)
Section modulus S = 0.2 in3 (1/6 hT2p)
Out-of-plane bending stress = 3.7 ksi (M / S)
Allowable = 37.5 ksi (0.75 Fy)
Out-of-plane bending stress / allowable = 0.10 OK

Maximum tensile stress = 2.9 ksi


Allowable = 30.0 ksi (0.6 Fy)
Tensile stress / allowable = 0.10 OK

Maximum in-plane bending stress = 0.5 ksi


Allowable = 33.0 ksi (0.66 Fy)
In-plane bending stress / allowable = 0.02 OK

Sum of ratios = 0.21 OK

For out-of-plane bending at the B-B axis, the out-of-plane bending moment is reduced by the ratio of the lever arms and
therefore, is not critical. Consequently, no analysis of this section is required.

You might also like