Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BEING A BY -LAW to authorize the Corporation of the City of Timmins to enter into an
agreement with Genivar Ontario Inc. for consulting services respecting the painting and coating
WHEREAS the Council of The Corporation of the City of Timmins considers it desirable to enter
NOW THEREFORE the Council of The Corporation of the City of Timmins enacts the following
as a By -law:
1. THAT the Corporation of the City of Timmins enter into an agreement with Genivar
Ontario Inc. respecting the painting and coating of the Hollinger Standpipe, in the City of
Timmins, a copy of which agreement is attached hereto and marked as Schedule "A" to
2. THAT the Mayor and Clerk be and are hereby authorized to execute the said agreement
on behalf of the Corporation and to affix thereto the Official Seal of the Corporation.
READ a first, second and third time and finally passed this 18`" day of March, 2013.
MAYOR
CLERK
M. E. A. C
/ . E. O.
CLIENT /CONSULTANT AGREEMENT
FOR
MUNICIPAL WORKS
2006
AGREEMENT CONTENTS
Page
Form of Agreement 10
AGREEMENT
FOR
A. D. 2013
BETWEEN-
AND-
GENIVAR Inc.
hereinafter called the ' Project' and has requested the Consultant to furnish professional services in
connection therewith;
NOW THEREFORE WITNESSETH that in consideration of the covenants contained herein, the Client
and the Consultant mutually agree as follows:
1. 01 Retainer
The Client hereby retains the services of the Consultant in connection with the Project and the
Consultant hereby agrees to provide the services described herein under the general direction and
control of the Client.
In this Agreement the word Consultant shall mean professionals and other specialists engaged by the
Client directly and whose names are party to this Agreement.
1. 02 Services
The services to be provided by the Consultant and by the Client for the Project are set forth in Article 2
and such services as changed, altered or added to under Section 1. 08 are hereinafter called the
Services'.
1. 03 Compensation
The Client shall pay the Consultant in accordance with the provisions set forth in Article 3. For
purposes of this agreement, the basis of payment shall be as specified in Articles 3. 2. 2 and 3. 2. 4.
The Consultant shall perform the services under this agreement with that degree of care, skill and
diligence normally provided in the performance of such services as contemplated by the agreement at
the time such services are rendered and as required by the Professional Engineers Act ( RSO 1990,
Chapter P. 28) and regulations therein. The Consultant shall employ only competent staff who will be
under the supervision of a senior member of the Consultant's staff.
Subject to Section 3. 2. 4 of Article 3, drawings and documents or copies thereof required for the
Project shall be exchanged between the parties on a reciprocal basis. Documents prepared by the
Consultant for the Client, including record drawings, may be used by the Client, for the Project herein
described. In accordance with Article 1. 06, the client indemnifies the Consultant for unauthorized use
of the documents and deliverables.
1. 06 Intellectual Property
All concepts, products or processes produced by or resulting from the Services rendered by the
Consultant in connection with the Project, or which are otherwise developed or first reduced to
practice by the Consultant in the performance of his Services, and which are patentable, capable of
trademark or otherwise, shall be considered as Intellectual Property and remain the property of the
Consultant.
The Client shall have permanent non -exclusive royalty -free license to use any concept, product or
process, which is patentable, capable of trademark or otherwise produced by or resulting from the
Services rendered by the Consultant in connection with the Project and for no other purpose or
project.
a) In order to provide data for the calculation of fees on a time basis, the Consultant shall keep
a detailed record of the hours worked by staff employed for the Project.
b) The Client may inspect timesheets and record of expenses and disbursements of the
Consultant during regular office hours with respect to any item which the Client is required to
pay on a time scale or disbursement basis as a result of this Agreement.
c) The Consultant, when requested by the Client, shall provide copies of receipts with respect to
any disbursement for which the Consultant claims payment under this Agreement.
With the consent of the Consultant the Client may in writing at any time after the execution of the
Agreement or the commencement of the Services delete, extend, increase, vary or otherwise alter the
Services forming the subject of the Agreement, and if such action by the Client necessitates additional
staff or services, the Consultant shall be paid in accordance with Section 3. 2. 1 for such additional staff
employed directly thereon, together with such expenses and disbursements as allowed under Section
3. 2. 4. In the event that the client delays the project then the Consultant shall have the right to
renegotiate the Agreement.
1. 09 Suspension or Termination
Either party may at any time by notice in writing to the other party, suspend or terminate the Services
or any portion thereof at any stage of the project. Upon receipt of such written notice, the Consultant
shall perform no further Services other than those reasonably necessary to close out his Services. In
such an event, the Consultant shall be entitled to payment in accordance with Section 3. 2. for any of
the Consultant's staff employed directly thereon together with such expenses and disbursements
allowed under Section 3. 2.
If the Consultant is practicing as an individual and dies before his Services have been completed, this
Agreement shall terminate as of the date of his death, and the Client shall pay for the Services
rendered and disbursements incurred by the Consultant to the date of such termination.
1. 10 Indemnification
The Consultant shall indemnify and save harmless the Client from and against all claims, actions,
losses, expenses, costs or damages of every nature and kind whatsoever which the Client, his
employees, officers or agents may suffer, to the extent the Consultant is legally liable as a result of the
negligent acts of the Consultant, his employees, officers or agents in the performance of this
Agreement.
The Client agrees to hold harmless, indemnify and defend the Consultant from and against any and all
claim, losses, damages, liability and costs of defense arising out of or in any way connected with the
presence, discharge, release or escape of contaminants of any kind, excluding only such liability as
may arise out of the negligent acts of the Consultant in the performance of consulting services to the
Client within this project.
1. 11 Insurance
The Client will accept the insurance coverage amount specified in this clause section ( a) as the
aggregate limit of liability of the Consultant and its employees for the Client' s damages.
The Insurance Coverage shall be $ 2, 000,000 per occurrence and in the aggregate for
general liability and $ 2 000 000 for automobile insurance. When requested, the
Consultant shall provide the Client with proof of Comprehensive General Liability and
Automobile Insurance ( Inclusive Limits) for both owned and non -owned vehicles.
The Insurance Coverage shall be in the amount of $ 2 000, 000 per claim and in the
aggregate. When requested, the Consultant shall provide to the Client proof of Professional
Liability Insurance carried by the Consultant, and in accordance with the Professional
Engineers Act ( RSO 1990, Chapter P. 28) and regulations therein.
c) Change in Coverage
If the Client requests to have the amount of coverage increased or to obtain other special
insurance for this Project then the Consultant shall endeavour forthwith to obtain such
increased or special insurance at the Client' s expense as a disbursement allowed under
Section 3. 2.
Neither the Consultant nor any person, firm or corporation associated or affiliated with or subsidiary to
the Consultant shall tender for the construction of the Project, or have an interest either directly or
indirectly in the construction of the Project.
1. 13 Assignment
Neither party may assign this Agreement without the prior consent in writing of the other.
1. 14 Previous Agreements
This Agreement supersedes all previous agreements, arrangements or understandings between the
parties whether written or oral in connection with or incidental to the Project.
Unless otherwise provided in this Agreement, where the work of the Consultant is subject to the
approval or review of an authority, department of government, or agency other than the Client, such
applications for approval or review shall be the responsibility of the Consultant, but shall be submitted
through the offices of the Client and unless authorized by the Client in writing, such applications for
approval or review shall not be obtained by direct contact by the Consultant with such other authority,
department of government or agency.
1. 16 Principals and Executives
The use of Principals and Executives on a time basis by the Consultant will be in accordance with
Section 1. 23. 1 ( c).
1. 17 Sub- Consultants
The Consultant may engage others as sub -consultants for specialized services provided that prior
approval is obtained, in writing, from the Client and may add a mark -up of not more than 5% of the
cost of such services to cover office administration costs when claiming reimbursement from the Client
plus the cost of the additional insurance incurred by the Consultant for the specialized services.
1. 18 Inspection
The client, or persons authorized by the Client, shall have the right, at all reasonable times, to inspect
or otherwise review the Services performed, or being performed, under the Project and the premises
where they are being performed.
1. 19 Publication
The Consultant agrees to obtain the consent in writing of the Client before publishing or issuing any
information regarding the Project.
1. 20 Confidential Data
The Consultant shall not divulge any specific information identified as confidential, communicated to or
acquired by him, or disclosed by the client in the course of carrying out the Services provided for
herein. These obligations of confidentiality shall not apply to information which is in the public domain,
which is provided to the Consultant by a third party without obligation of confidentiality which is
independently developed by the Consultant without access to the Client' s information, or which is
required to be disclosed by law or by court order. No such information shall be used by the Consultant
on any other project without the approval in writing of the client.
a) If requested in writing by either the Client or the Consultant, the Client and the Consultant
shall attempt to resolve any dispute between them arising out of or in connection with this
Agreement by entering into structured non -binding negotiations with the assistance of a
mediator on a without prejudice basis. The mediator shall be appointed by agreement of the
parties. If a dispute cannot be settled within a period of ninety (90) calendar days with the
mediator, the dispute shall be referred to and finally resolved by arbitration under the rules of
the province having jurisdiction or by an arbitrator appointed by the agreement of the parties.
b) No person shall be appointed to act as mediator or arbitrator who is in any way interested,
financially or otherwise, in the conduct of the work on the Project or in the business or other
affairs of either the Client or the Consultant.
c) The award of the arbitrator, including an award for costs if applicable, shall be final and
binding upon the parties.
d) The provisions of The Arbitration' s Act, R. S. O., 1991, Chapter 17, as amended shall apply.
1. 22 Time
The Consultant shall perform the Services expeditiously to meet the requirements of the Client and
shall complete any portion or portions of the Services in such order as the Client may require..
The Client shall give due consideration to all designs, drawings, plans, specifications, reports, tenders,
proposals and other information submitted by the Consultant, and shall make any decisions which he
is required to make in connection therewith within a reasonable time so as not to delay the work of the
Consultant.
When requested by the Client, and where payment is calculated on a time basis, the Consultant shall
provide, for approval by the Client:
c) A Staff list showing the number, classifications and hourly rate ranges for staff, Principals and
Executives, for which the Consultant will seek payment on a time basis. The Consultant shall
relate such information to the particular type of work that such staff is to perform, while
employed on the Project. Such list shall designate the member of the Consultant's staff who
is to be the liaison person between the Consultant and the Client.
1. 23. 2 Subsequent Changes in the Estimate of Fees, Schedule of Prowess and Staff List
The Consultant will require prior written approval, from the Client for any of the following changes:
a) Any increase in the estimated fees beyond those approved under Subsection 1. 23. 1 ( a).
b) Any change in the schedule at progress which results in a longer period than provided in
Subsection 1. 23. 1 ( b).
c) Any change in the number, classification and hourly rate ranges of the staff provided under
Subsection 1. 23. 1 ( c).
When requested by the Client, the Consultant shall provide the Client with a written report showing the
portion of the Services completed in the preceding month.
1. 24 Additional Conditions
The services to be provided by Consultant for the completion of the Tender Development for Painting /Coating
the Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir are as described in, and in accordance with, the City' s Request for Proposal
ENG- 2013 -01 for Engineering Services for the Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe
Reservoir, issued January 21 , 2013 and GENIVAR Inc.' s Proposal ( P13- 99999 -95) dated February 14, 2013.
The aforementioned GENIVAR Inc. Proposal is incorporated by reference in this Agreement, as if written in full
in this paragraph.
The services to be provided by Client for the completion of the Tender Development for Painting /Coating the
Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir are as described in, and in accordance with, the City' s Request for Proposal
ENG- 2013 -01 for Engineering Services for the Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe
Reservoir, issued January 21 t, 2013. The aforementioned City Request for Proposal ENG -2013 -01 is
incorporated by reference in this Agreement, as if written in full in this paragraph.
3. 1 Definitions
For the purpose of this Agreement, the following definitions shall apply:
i) The " Cost of the Work" shall mean the total cost of the Project including all materials,
equipment, sales taxes, labour and contractor' s overhead and profit, necessary to
complete the work for which the Consultant prepares designs, drawings or specifications,
for which he is responsible. Where sales taxes are not included in the cost of the work,
the fee shall be adjusted upwards by the factor equivalent to the sales taxes. The
adjusted fee may be computed to the nearest one -tenth of one percent ( 1/ 10 %).
ii) Wherever the client furnishes labour or other service which is incorporated in the work, the
current price of labour or other service when the work was executed shall be used to
compute the Cost of the Work.
iii) Whenever used materials or equipment is furnished by or on behalf of the Client, the fair
market value of such materials or equipment, as though it was purchased new, shall be
used to compute the Cost of the Work.
iv) In computing the Cost of the Work, no deductions shall be made on account of any
penalties or damages claimed by the Client from any contractor or on account of any other
sum withheld from any contractor.
v) The Cost of the Work shall not include any fees and disbursements due to the Consultant,
the Client' s engineering and office expenses, or cost of land.
b) Site:
Site includes the actual work site and other locations where the checking of materials, equipment
and workmanship is carried out.
Ct CU JION OF FEE
2EnCE1NTnCE
lv E CF & 61;44 S
The Client shall pay the Consultant a fee, calculated on a time basis, up to a maximum of the Upset
Cost Limit, per the Consultants proposal referred to in Article 2. Fees on a time basis for all staff shall
be hourly rates as outlined in the Consultants proposal referred to in Article 2.
3. 2. 2. 2 Time Expended
All time expended on the assignment, whether in the Consultant's office, at the Client's premises, or
elsewhere, and including travel time, shall be chargeable up to the Upset Cost Limit per the
Consultants proposal referred to in Article 2. This also includes, but is not limited to, stenographic and
clerical staff engaged in the preparation of documents such as reports and specifications.
3. 2. 4 Reimbursable Expenses
In addition to the fee, the Consultant shall be reimbursed at cost plus an administrative charge of 5%,
plus the cost of additional insurance incurred by the Consultant, for all expenses properly incurred by
him in connection with the project, including but not limited to: vehicle use charges, travelling and
living expenses, long distance telephone charges, facsimile transmission charges, printing and
reproductions, progress photography, advertising for tenders, special delivery and express charges,
overtime premium costs, and the cost of providing and maintaining site offices, supplies and
equipment, chemical and physical tests. Reimbursable Expenses will not exceed the Upset Cost Limit
provided in the Disbursements section of the Fee Schedule in the Consultants proposal referred to in
Article 2.
3. 3 Payment
The Consultant shall submit an invoice to the Client for all Services completed in the immediately
preceding month. Interest at the annual rate of 3 percent (0. 25 percent monthly) will be paid on the
total outstanding unpaid balance commencing 30 days after the Client has received the Consultant's
invoice.
in the presence of )
GENIVAR Inc.
The signatory shall have the authority to bind the corporation or company for purposes of this Agreement
Michelle Albert
Name)
CLERK
ou de
Legal /
Name/ sociale Tim ns
Apelation comerial entrpu princal
Princpal Trade raison
et
l'
of
City
Unit
cDescripton/ lasifton entrpu MANGET OFICES ENGI RS
Contrac Clasifcton descripton CONSTRUI PROJ
de 000: 000:
and Unite de 7 52 - OF
l'
41 -
1
of
L3R
Adres /
1
de
Legal / ou
INC
Name/ sociale
decharge Contrac Apelation comerial entrpu GENIVAR
de
Trade raison l'
Certifca
Certifca /
wsob cspa t Clearnc
GPI_ assurance inc.
1550 Metcalfe Sheet, # 902
Montreal, Quebec H3A 1X6
Tel: ( 514) 7884445 / (800) 315 -4450
This certificate is issued in favour of any company to whom GENIVAR GENIVAR Inc.
Inc. must confirm insurance coverage. 1600 Rene -Levesque Blvd. West, 16th Floor
Montreal, QC H3H 1P9
Umbrella Liability Zurich Insurance 8840933 April 1, 2013 In excess of the 1, 000, 000 Each occurrence and in
underlying Commercial the aggregate
Company to
Professional GEE / Lloyd' s P2033919 November 1, 2012 Coverage is subject to 2,000, 000 Per claim and in the
aggregate
Indemnity Syndicate 1886 to policy terms, limitations
Insurance November 1, 2013 and exclusions, as they The aggregate limit is the total insurance
now exist or may available for all covered claims made and
CANCELLATION: Should any of the above described policies be cancelled or modified before the expiration date thereof, the Insurer(s) will mail a n/ a
days written notice to the Certificate Holder.
iiY
ti.
F E B R U A R Y 14, 2 0 1 3 2: 00 p. m.
GENIVAR Inc. 600 Cochrane Drive, 5th Floor, Markham, Ontario L3R 5K3
T: 905- 475 -7270 - F: 905- 475 -5114 - www.genivar com
Contact Michelle Albert P. Eng. E -mail: michelle. albert@genivar. com
GENIVAR
P13- 99999 -95
GENIVAR is pleased to respond to the City's Request for Proposal ENG- 2013 -01 for Engineering
Services for Tender Development for Painting /Coating the Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir. Enclosed are
six ( 6) hardcopies of our Technical Proposal and two ( 2) copies of our Financial Proposal for the City' s
consideration. Our proposal was prepared in accordance with the Request For Proposal ( RFP) and
Addendum No. 1.
The project will be delivered from GENIVAR's Markham and Timmins offices, and will be led by Alec
Cranmer as the overall Project Manager and Cory Goulet from our Timmins Office as the Contract
Administrator and Site Inspector. Alec Cranmer has designed and constructed numerous elevated
water tanks and is familiar with all aspects of tank design regulations, best practices and coatings. Our
proposed expert sub -consultant for the coating systems analysis, contractor pre -qualification and
development of contract specifications will be Jim Stone of G. L. Stone Consulting Ltd.
GENIVAR is also pleased to have the opportunity to include some additional information regarding the
importance of tank mixing. The primary challenge of any distribution system reservoir is to ensure
adequate mixing and turnover to minimize the loss of disinfectant residual and maintain water quality. As
an industry -leader in 3D- hydraulic modeling, GENIVAR is able to simulate the mixing patterns in any
shaped tank and design a mixing system which will optimize daily tank drawdown and ensure water
quality is maintained.
We welcome the opportunity to assist the City in this project and our Team will be dedicated to the project
for its duration.
We would be pleased to discuss any aspect of our Proposal with you at any time.
Respectfully submitted,
GENIVAR Inc.
i,
Michelle Albert, Eng.
Manager of Water and Wastewater Operations
Alec Cranmer, M. A. Sc., P. Eng.
Discipline Lead Water Infrastructure
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Transmittal Letter
Table of Contents
1. INTRODUCTION 1
3. SCOPE OF WORK 5
4. PROJECT SCHEDULE 9
5. QA/ QC SYSTEM 10
6. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 10
GENIVAR
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01 Table of Contents
LIST OF TABLES
Table 2 -1 Project Team Members and Qualifications 3
Table 3 -1 Major Project Deliverables 9
Table 4 -1 Milestones and Deliverables 9
APPENDICES
Appendix A Corporate Profiles, Policies and Service Sheets
Appendix B Project Profiles
Appendix F Addenda
GENIVAR
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
1. INTR DUCTION
1. 1 Background and Understanding of the Project
The 10. 5 ML Hollinger Standpipe, constructed in 1970, is centrally located in the City of Timmins. The
18. 2 m ( 60 ft) diameter and 39. 6 m ( 130 ft) high steel tank is the only floating water storage in the City.
The Standpipe was last painted in 1992 and the interior and exterior coatings are in need of replacement.
The City is therefore requesting proposals from engineering consulting firms to assist them with the
development of Tender Documents to re -coat the tank as well as assist them in pre -qualifying and
selecting a contractor to complete the work. The City will be an active member of the design and tender
process and the project is to be completed as a joint City -Consultant cooperative effort.
The available volume of this reservoir provides critical water storage to the City and its temporary removal
from service will significantly impact the City' s ability to provide water during peak demand periods.
Therefore, shutdowns and maintenance periods must be well planned and with a suitable contingency
plan.
The scope of work described in the Request For Proposals ( RFP) includes a Technical Report to review
alternative coating systems, pre -qualification of contractors, tendering, construction contract
administration and coating system inspections. GENIVAR's expertise in both new and retrofit tank design
and construction, our overall coatings knowledge, and our attention to detail will ensure that the City
achieves its goal of ensuring a sufficient, secure and reliable source of drinking water to its residents and
businesses.
GENIVAR' s team in Ontario includes over 500 engineers, designers, architects, scientists,
hydrogeologists, and construction managers located in seven offices including Markham and Timmins.
The proposed Team Members have worked together in various capacities on numerous projects, most
recently on the Kitchener -Waterloo Zone 6 Elevated Tank, currently under construction.
Our proposed sub -consultant coatings expert is G. L. Stone G. L. Stone Consulting Ltd.
Consulting Ltd. ( GLS). Founded in 1969, the GLS consultants PROTECTIVE COATINGS CONSULTANTS
QUALITY ASSURANCE INSPECTORS
are active members of the National Association of Corrosion
Engineers ( NACE) and the Society for Protective Coatings ( SPC) and have extensive knowledge of
coatings chemistry to specify the correct products for each application. GLS have been involved in over
200 water tank projects, including recent elevated tanks in Waterloo, Toronto, York Region, Hamilton,
Halton Region and Kingston. Additional corporate information can be found in Appendix A.
GENIVAR and GLS have successfully collaborated on numerous elevated tank projects, for both new
tanks and recoating projects. Our close relationship will provide the City with a seamlessly integrated
project team, who are committed to dedicating their expertise and enthusiasm to achieve the project
goals.
GENIVAR 1
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
Our proposed Project Manager, Alec Cranmer, has worked on several recent elevated tank projects.
Through the detailed design of numerous composite elevated tanks throughout Ontario, Alec has
developed intimate technical and practical knowledge of the latest applicable design standards,
construction methods and operational features available to the owner, including tank coating
requirements, mixing systems to maintain water quality, and safety devices to simplify operations and
minimize maintenance efforts.
GENIVAR' s QA/QC lead for this project, Ron Cariglia, is Director of GENIVAR's Structural Department
and is our resident coatings expert. Ron has worked on a numerous structural steel and concrete
projects where protective coatings are required. His coatings experience also extends into other sectors
such as mining and hydro -electric generation where the extended life of structures is also critically
important. His strategic input at various stages of the project will ensure quality submissions.
Our proposed coatings sub -consultant is Jim Stone from G. L. Stone Consulting Ltd. ( GLS), who will be
responsible for providing technical expertise in tank coatings and will assist with the technical report on
coating systems, development of the coating system specifications, assist with contractor pre -qualification
and provide coating shop drawing reviews prior to construction.
2. 2 Project Manager
Alec Cranmer, M.A.Sc., P. Eng. is a Discipline Lead Water Infrastructure at GENIVAR with over 15
years of experience in all aspects of project management, environmental assessment, approvals,
planning, process evaluation, condition assessment, detailed facility and process design, approvals,
construction contract administration, supervision during construction and commissioning of projects. Alec
has successfully designed and constructed numerous water storage reservoirs, water treatment facilities,
pumping stations, watermains, sewers and forcemains during his career; however, more particularly, he
has also successfully designed, administered, managed and commissioned numerous elevated tank
projects throughout the province.
Alec is experienced in leading and managing multi -disciplined teams and has proven his leadership,
communication and technical skills on the design and construction of the following recent elevated tank
projects:
4 Kitchener-Waterloo Zone 6 Elevated Tank, Detailed Design and Contract Administration ( on- going)
4 Aurora East Elevated Tank Facility, Class EA and Preliminary Design ( 2011)
York PD9 Elevated Tank No. 2, Class EA and Detailed Design ( 2009)
4 North Richmond Hill Elevated Tank, Class EA, Detailed Design and Contract Administration ( 2008)
4 Minden Elevated Tank, Class EA, Detailed Design ( 2008)
Kingston West Elevated Tank, Detailed Design and Contract Administration ( 2007)
As the Project Manager, Alec will be the primary contact person with the City' s Project Manager. Alec will
be responsible for overall project management throughout the entire project duration from Project
Initiation to Substantial Performance, including all aspects of detailed design, tendering and all
deliverables.
Alec will work closely with Ron Cariglia to ensure that the project meets the Project Management and
QA/ QC requirements as outlined in this proposal.
GENIVAR 2
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
Phillip Saudino, P. Eng. A native of Timmins, Phil is a Project Engineer with over 10 years of engineering service
and has managed water and wastewater projects for various municipal clients. He has
Project Coordination,
been responsible for the completion of water treatment plant upgrades, hydraulic
Process Design,
Permits and Approvals modeling studies, transmission main design, and pumping station design and
construction. He has worked on projects from conceptual design through to detailed
design, construction, start-up and commissioning. As Project Coordinator, Phil will be
involved in all aspects of the project and will ensure the multidisciplinary team work
closely together to achieve the project objectives. He will assist Alec Cranmer as required,
assuming the PM role as required in Alec' s absence thereby ensuring the City has a key
point of contact at all time.
Cory Goulet, E. I. T. Cory is a Project Manager in our local Timmins office with 7 years of inspection and
contract administration experience on various multi -million dollar projects for private,
Construction Contract
Administration & municipal and provincial clients. Cory has experience in the inspection and monitoring of
Structural Site sandblasting, including the applications of protective coatings on MTO bridge projects in
Inspection the Southern -Ontario region, including the Burlington Bay Skyway Bridge. Cory' s most
recent contract administration and inspection projects for the City of Timmins include the
City of Timmins Airport Parking Lot Expansion Project and Phase I of the McChesney
Sewer Project.
H. J. Stone Jim is President of G. L. Stone Consulting Ltd. and has worked on numerous elevated
NACE 111 Coatings tank and standpipe recoating projects. As President and Technical Director, Jim is
Inspector responsible for supervision of inspection projects, performing failure analysis and
SSPC Certified
troubleshooting, specification writing and Quality Assurance /Quality Control inspection.
Protective Coatings
Specialist
GENIVAR has a robust team of designers, CAD technicians, and other technical support professionals
who will be ready and able to assist with any existing or additional project requirement at short notice.
GENIVAR commits to the City that all members of our Project Team for this assignment will be available
and committed to work on this Project as indicated in our Team Organizational Chart included with this
submission. GENIVAR is not aware of any potential conflict of interest by any members of the Project
Team at the time of this submission.
Our Project Team has demonstrated a long history of successfully completing many elevated tank re-
coating projects. Descriptions of some of the most recent elevated tanks completed by members of our
design team are as follows:
GENIVAR 3
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
Alec Cranmer is the Project Manager and Design Engineer responsible for the
detailed design and construction contract administration for a 7. 2 ML elevated
tank located in the City of Waterloo to service both Kitchener Zone 6 and
Waterloo Zone 6. Design features include separate Valve, Electrical and
Chemical rooms inside the support pedestal, a washroom, separate inlet and
outlet risers process valves, overflow piping including a detention pond, a re-
circulation pump and passive tank mixing system, chlorine residual and flow
monitoring equipment, a top -up chlorination system and internal and external
protective tank coatings. Public consultation prior to construction included a
presentation and Public Information Session.
As part of this assignment, a coatings workshop was conducted with the coatings manufacturer,
applicator, and the Region' s Management and Operations staff to develop a coatings evaluation matrix to
determine the most appropriate coatings options for the Region.
Client Reference: Jerry Borovicka, CET, Project Manager, Region of Waterloo, 519. 575.4092
Rouge Tank Exterior and Interior Painting, Safety Upgrades and Modifications
Scarborough, ON
Ron Cariglia was the Project Manager for the Rouge Tank Upgrades for the City of
Toronto. The project included significant upgrades, modifications, and exterior and
interior painting on the 43m high elevated water storage tank in Scarborough.
Deliverables required included a condition assessment, detailed design including
recoating, safety upgrades, new instrumentation, cathodic protection, new office
space and architectural upgrades, interior HVAC and dehumidification, as well as
contract administration and on -site supervision. In addition, GENIVAR completed
specifications, on -site supervision and contract administration for re- paving the
access roadway and parking lot areas.
Client Reference: Kenny Ching, P.Eng., Project Manager, City of Toronto,
905.825. 6000 ext. 7436
Interior and Exterior Painting & Upgrades of Leslie Elevated Water Storage
Tank.
The Ontario Police College Tank Upgrade and Recoating, Aylmer, Ontario
The Ontario Police College located in Aylmer has a potable water system
consisting of a water tower capable of storing 75, 000 imperial gallons and an in-
ground reservoir capable of storing 206, 000 imperial gallons, which had been
identified as requiring several upgrades, including the interior and exterior
recoating of the water tower and upgrades to the access hatches to the in-
ground reservoir.
GENIVAP 4
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
assess over -coating possibilities instead of performing a full exterior recoat. Specifications for the interior
and exterior coatings of the tower, replacement of the hatches, pipe work and concrete repairs for the
reservoir were developed as necessary. Based on the site investigation, specifications and design
drawings were developed for the necessary upgrades for tendering. Ron Cariglia was responsible for the
execution of this project for CB Richard Ellis.
Client Reference: Patrick Davis, CB Richard Ellis, Patrick. davis @cbre. com
Alec Cranmer was the Project Manager, EA Specialist and Design Engineer
responsible for the completion of the Schedule ' B' Municipal Class
Environmental Assessment and detailed design for a 7. 55 NIL elevated tank
located in the Oak Ridges Moraine, to service York Region Pressure District
9. Design features included separate valve, electrical and chemical rooms
inside the support pedestal, separate inlet and outlet risers, process valves including an altitude /flow
control valve, a tank mixing system including a re- circulation pump, a re- chloramination system, chlorine
residual and flow monitoring equipment, and internal and external protective tank coatings. Site works
included removal of the existing standpipe and extensive site restoration and naturalization.
Client Reference: Claudio Micelli, P.Eng., PMP, Senior Project Manager, York Region, 905. 895. 1200, ext.
5047
3. SCOPE OF WORK
As requested in the City's RFP document, the following sections detail the key components of the project
approach and methodology, in order for us to provide the City with technical guidance for sandblasting
and recoating of the Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir.
3. 1 Development of Contract Documents and Specifications
We propose to utilize our most recent contract documents and specifications for both new and recoating
projects to develop a basis for the Hollinger Standpipe contract documents and specifications for
sandblasting and painting. We will also review the contract specifications and shop drawings provided by
the City for the 1992 Standpipe Re- coating Project, which may provide insight into the existing coatings
chemistry and specific conditions that are particular to the City of Timmins and its unique climate.
Once an initial draft documents are developed, a Project Team Workshop will be conducted in order to
discuss the general conditions and identify special provisions. The Workshop will be a cooperative effort
and will enable individual Team Members to express concerns and identify any potential special
provisions which may be necessary within the contract specifications. The City's staff contributions will be
essential to identifying and addressing local requirements, priorities, and concerns.
The final Tender Documents will incorporate the comments from the Project Team Workshop.
3. 2 Technical Report on Coating /Painting Systems
GENIVAR will provide the City with a detailed technical report on the various combinations of
paint/coating systems suitable for both the interior and exterior of the Standpipe. The key considerations
to be addressed in the report will include the following:
NSF 61 Certified Coating: The Inside Coatings Systems ( ICS) identified, evaluated and specified will
meet the requirements of ANSI /NSF 61 Drinking Water System Components -Health Effects for materials
in contact with potable water. The coating systems will also be required to meet the requirements of
AWWA Standard D102 -11 Coating Steel Water- Storage Tanks and the 2008 MOE Design Guidelines
for Drinking -Water Systems. The Outside Coating System ( OCS) is not required to be NSF 61 certified,
unless specifically requested by the City.
GENIVAR 5
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
Non- Destructive and /or Harmful: GENIVAR will evaluate and specify that all products ( i. e. blast media,
cleaning solvents, etc.) utilized in the preparation of the tank shall not be harmful to the structural steel
and integrity of the tank. All materials in contact with potable water shall be NSF 61 certified. GENIVAR
will further specify the handling procedures for the products used during the project and ensure that none
will present any immediate and inherent physical dangers to workers.
Coating Application Requirements: GENIVAR will estimate the costs for the various coating systems and
also review the application specifications for each coating with each manufacturer. The success of
coatings application is extremely weather -dependent. Consideration will be given to the coating' s
tolerance to temperature, precipitation, humidity, wind, UV radiation, etc. The time period between re-
applications of the systems will also be evaluated.
We will also review the compatibility of the proposed exterior coating system with the existing coatings to
determine if sandblasting will be required. If the Standpipe cannot be recoated due to existing conditions
and requires sandblasting, scaffolding and containment hoarding will be required to be constructed, which
will greatly increase the cost and schedule for the proposed recoating.
Life Cycle Evaluation: The coating systems will be evaluated for their anticipated overall performance
and life expectancy. Although coating products are continually evolving, an evaluation of coating
chemistries ( zinc -rich primers, epoxies, polyurethanes, fluorourethanes, etc.) and thicknesses will be
provided to compare expected performance and potential recoating /maintenance frequency. Additional
factors including long -term gloss and colour retention and graffiti resistance will also be considered.
Contingency Plan: The Report will include recommendations to address and mitigate schedule and cost
impacts should any structural repairs be required. Given the aggressive schedule to recoat the standpipe
within six weeks, any required structural repairs within the tank will likely cause significant impacts to the
schedule as exterior recoating cannot occur simultaneously with pit or striation repairs on the inside of the
tank due to the heat from welding.
Pit Repairs: Once the interior coating is removed we recommend that the plate thicknesses be
confirmed and measurement of the extent to which pits have penetrated the wall be completed. Should
the pitting be shallow and not affect the structural stability of the tank walls, the interior coating itself can
be used to fill the pits. For these shallow pits, a thin layer of coating is applied and trowelled into the
prepared pits. For deeper pits, puddle welding may be required. Pit repairs of this type could take 1 - 2
weeks and no painting of the interior or exterior could occur during this time.
Striation Repairs and Tank Venting: The striations identified in the inspection reports are evidence of a
process referred to as " tin canning." The plastic- induced stress deformation exhibited by the rolled steel
is caused by expansion and contraction of the tank walls with the daily fluctuations in the tank level, which
may be exacerbated by inadequate tank venting. Therefore, we recommend that the existing tank
venting system be upgraded to a stainless steel combination vent and vacuum relief system, which will
help to minimize or eliminate this effect. Structural repairs identified outside of the tank could potentially
be completed prior to the tank coating to avoid schedule impacts.
Schedule Mitigation: If exterior scaffolding and containment shrouding is deemed to be required, the
contractor will be required to install the scaffolding prior to tank shutdown as this operation could take 2 -3
weeks.
Cost Mitigation: If structural repairs to the standpipe are of a significant duration, the coatings applicator
may claim for delays, re- blasting, providing dehumidification or require compensation for additional
demobilization and remobilization. To avoid potentially costly change orders, GENIVAR can include
provisional items in the bid form for demobilization and remobilization costs, as well as daily
dehumidification and reblasting costs. The extent of the structural repair work will determine whether it is
more cost effective to provide constant dehumidification during the structural repairs or re -blast after the
repairs are complete.
Specifications for Minor Repairs: Included in the report will be GENIVAR' s corrosion repair specification,
updated from previous water tank recoating projects. Discussion on repair procedures and the
specification will be included on the agenda for the Coatings review meeting with the City' s Project Team,
provisionally scheduled for March 21', 2013.
cENIVAR 6
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
Once the Draft Coatings Systems Technical Report is reviewed by the City, a Workshop will be held with
the City's Project Team to review and discuss the various coating options available as well as the
principle coating manufacturers in Ontario. The coating manufacturers capable of meeting the above
standards include Amercoat Canada, Carboline Company, Devoe /ICI Products and Tnemec Company
Inc.
The tank interior and exterior coating options will be identified, evaluated, and compared according to
initial costs, service level, and lifecycle costs of overcoating and coating replacement. Considerations will
also include the ease of future recoating, ability to withstand weathering, UV- resistance, and the ability to
maintain colour and lustre.
Note that our coatings specification requires that each coatings applicator must be certified by the
coatings manufacturer. Every product application procedure is different and therefore applicators must
be trained and knowledgeable of each particular product. BY limiting coatings applicators, we may be
limiting coating manufacturers. In some cases, a particular applicator may be certified to apply more than
one coating manufacturer.
WHMIS
4 Fall Protection
GENIVAR will provide the City with a complete digital set of tender documents including design
specifications and drawings. It is anticipated that the City will provide the necessary front -end documents
which would be reflective of the City' s purchasing policies. GENIVAR will provide answers to questions
during the tender period, prepare a construction cost estimate, and provide the City with a tender analysis
and recommendation. Addenda shall be issued by the City.
Our Contract Administration and Site Inspection services will be provided principally through GENIVAR's
Timmins office and Cory Goulet. Cory will be responsible for managing the daily contract administrative
duties with technical and managerial assistance to be provided as required from the Markham office.
Cory has worked as a site inspector on many M. T. O. projects but also most recently as the site inspector
on the City of Timmins Airport Parking Lot Expansion Project and Phase I of the McChesney Road
Sanitary Sewer Project.
Contract administration services will include a Pre- Construction Meeting, weekly site meetings, shop
drawing reviews, payment certificates, commissioning and all other deliverables noted in the RFP. The
approximate start date for construction is mid -August with completion by September 24th as noted in the
RFP.
GENIVAR 7
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
Although not requested in the RFP, GENIVAR typically recommends full -time inspection by a certified
National Association of Corrosion Engineers ( NACE) inspector during the coatings application to ensure
quality control of the coatings application. GLS has several certified NACE Level II Inspectors who can
provide this service and will provide inspection reports confirming the coating application has been
completed in accordance with the contract specifications and applicable standards.
3. 6 Develop Protocols /Procedures Minimizing Work Impacts on Related
Infrastructure and the Public
Communication: GENIVAR will work with the City's Project
Team and Communications /IT Department, to ensure that
continuity of communications is maintained throughout the
project. This will include the identification of any special
requirements or contingencies which may be included in the
Contract Documents.
3. 8 Project Deliverables
i1 GENIVAR 8
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
4. PROJECT SCHEDULE
The Project milestones and deliverables as outlined in the RFP are included in the proposed Project
Schedule Gantt Chart included in Appendix D. The City's proposed schedule for the Technical Report on
Coating /Painting Systems is considered to be aggressive with the draft report to be submitted less than 2
weeks from award. The analysis is dependent on the ability of the coatings manufacturers to provide the
required information. The following table lists the critical milestones and deliverable dates required to
achieve the proposed completion date.
Review of Contract Documents with City Personnel Thursday April 11th, 2013
Issue Contract Documents Thursday April 18th, 2013
Tender Close Monday May 6th, 2013
Tender Recommendation Letter Wednesday May 81M1, 2013
Contract Award Monday May 27th, 2013
Substantial Performance Tuesday September 24th, 2013
The proposal schedule is based on tank exterior overcoat and interior lining replacement.
Based on our knowledge and our experience with constructing and recoating elevated tanks, coupled with
our preliminary review of the facilities, an initial list of potential issues, concerns and constraints which
may impact the proposed schedule is as follows:
9 Recoating - If the Standpipe exterior cannot be recoated due to existing conditions and requires
sandblasting and recoating, scaffolding and hoarding will be required to be constructed and the time
required to complete the works will be greatly increased as well as significantly more expensive
500, 000.00+)
4 Coatings Compatibility - If the recommended Standpipe exterior coatings are incompatible with the
existing coatings, then sandblasting, scaffolding and hoarding will be required to remove the existing
GENIVAR 9
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
coating.
Facility Shutdown As the Standpipe is a critical water storage facility, the City must confirm that
the pipe can be taken out of service for 8 -10 weeks to perform the required Works.
4 A continuous review and checking of design decisions and calculations by a senior specialist in
each engineering discipline; and
4 QA/ QC by senior level company personnel at all design stages.
Our Quality Assurance ( QA) program at the design stage will apply to all those actions required to ensure
that the works are designed and constructed in accordance with applicable codes, guidelines, standards
and specifications. The QA review by senior staff members will ensure that the design work has been
performed in accordance with the following criteria:
4 City Design Standards 4 Practical layout of equipment from an operation and
maintenance perspective
4 Good engineering practice
The Quality Control ( QC) program will provide for the review of the services provided and the work to be
done, together with management and documentation necessary to demonstrate that these services and
works meet contractual and regulatory requirements. Reviews are documented by mark -up of design
documents, reports, specifications, etc., and reviewed documents are filed until corrected or superseded
by a subsequent submission.
GENIVAR 10
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
evaluate and compare both active and passive mixing systems and compare their application for the
Standpipe. The evaluation will include initial cost, lifecycle cost, mixing effectiveness, ability to integrate
into the existing tank, and operating and maintenance complexity.
GENIVAR is uniquely qualified to evaluate and provide insight into current municipal water industry
mixing technologies for elevated tanks and standpipes as we have in -house capabilities to optimize tank
mixing using 3 -D Computational Fluid Dynamics ( CFD) modelling using FLUENT. Custom modelling of
the mixing system is critical to minimize water age and loss of chlorine residual and determine optimal
daily drawdown. The design of the tank mixing system may incorporate a re- circulation system to help
promote mixing during low demand periods and minimize freezing in winter.
This technology and knowledge also provides us with the capability to evaluate pre- engineered package
mixing systems, which are often specified for tank retrofit projects. Should the City wish to investigate this
optional service, the mixing system evaluation will be summarized in a Technical Memorandum.
6. 2 NACE Certified Inspector
Based on our experience in designing, specifying and inspecting tank coating operations, we typically
recommend full -time inspection by a certified National Association of Corrosion Engineers ( NACE)
inspector during the coatings application to ensure quality control of the coatings application. GLS has
several certified NACE Level II and III Inspectors who can provide this service and will provide inspection
reports confirming the coating application has been completed in accordance with the contract
specifications and applicable standards.
GENIVAR 11
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
GENFVAR 12
Appendix A
Corporate Profiles
Corporate Profiles
GENIVAR is one of the largest professional services firms in Canada with over 5, 000 employees working in more than 100 cities
in Canada and overseas. Since 1959, GENIVAR has provided private and public sector clients with a full range of professional
services through all phases of a project, from planning to commissioning. GENIVAR' s experts plan, design and bring to completion
a vast array of award -winning regional and international projects in engineering, architecture and project management.
Municipal Infrastructure
OUR VALUES
Industrial, Energy & Telecommunications
Our values reflect who we are and how we interact with each
Transportation / Aviation
other, whether with colleagues, clients, unitholders or other
stakeholders.
OUR POLICIES
Client Focus
Quality Assurance / Quality Control
Respect
Sustainable Development
Empowerment
Training & Certification
Teamwork
Health & Safety
At GENIVAR, we work as partners with our clients at every stage Incorporating the principles of sustainable development is a
of their projects. Backed by our extensive project management daily commitment for us, whether we are involved in green or
experience, we ensure that our clients' interests and requirements LEED ( Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) certified
are met at every turn. We are highly committed to delivering buildings, transportation, municipal infrastructure, industrial or
projects on time and on budget, regardless of size or complexity. power -related projects. Our environmental specialists work in
multidisciplinary teams to ensure from inception to completion,
that our projects are economically, socially and environmentally
responsible.
BUILDINGS / ARCHITECTURE INDUSTRIAL, ENERGY & TELECOMMUNICATIONS
Designing Structures that Span the Ages Transforming Raw Material for our Daily Use
GENIVAR carries out projects of all sizes and complexities, ranging GENIVAR offers a complete range of engineering services
from new building developments, expansion and modernization sectors that include mining and mineral processing, metallurgy
of existing buildings to heritage buildings. Our multi -disciplinary and light metals, pulp and paper, chemicals and petroleum, and
team includes experts in the areas of building engineering, city pharmaceutical and biotechnology.
planning, economics, environmental protection, transportation and
related infrastructure. Our primary goal is to create a sustainable A Resource for Today and Tomorrow
environment in which safety and comfort are paramount, while GENIVAR has been an active player in the energy sector for several
minimizing operating costs. decades. Projects are undertaken in Canada and around the world
ENVIRONMENT
in hydroelectric and wind energy, biomass, ethanol and waste
materials energy, thermal power, and distribution and transmission
An Approach that Integrates Sustainable Development lines. Clients also benefit from GENIVAR' s recognized expertise
GENIVAR' s environmental division is made up of experienced in dam safety and retaining reservoir works.
professionals and technicians with a solid track record of
Solutions for Sustained Connections
achievements in the areas of impact studies, environmental
audits, environmental systems implementation and maintenance, GENIVAR provides state -of- the -art analysis, design and
maintenance services for wireless, microwave, broadcast and
water, air and soil characterizations and environmental monitoring.
Working in multidisciplinary teams alongside engineers, project mobile radio networks, and we have developed methods that
managers and other professionals, GENIVAR' s environmental extend the service life of towers and reduce ice buildup.
specialists develop innovative and wide -ranging solutions for
municipal, transportation, building, industrial and energy projects. TRANSPORTATION
www. genivar.com
02/ 2012
Innovative Solutions
For more than four decades, GENIVAR has partnered with
municipalities in finding innovative and economical
solutions for supplying potable water. Our vast experience
demonstrates the extent of our expertise and our ability to
design and manage, in a optimal way, urban hydraulic and
water -supply projects.
1. Installation of a Settling Tank, Potable Water Production Plant, Intermunicipal Board, Henryville- Venise. 12. Installation of a Pressure
Boosting Station, Saint -Regis Reservoir, Candiac. 13. Simulation of a Master Plan for a Waterworks System. 1 4. New Water Treatment
Plants, Beauport and Charleshourg, Quebec City.] 5. New Potable Water Treatment Plant, Lacolle. 16. Rehabilitation by Pipe Lining,
Watermain Pipe, Quarter international de Montreal 12 Installation of Process Engineering Works, Underground Fire Cistern and Potable
Water Treatment, Grosse -Ile and the Irish Memorial 1 B. Expansion of the Potable Water Treatment Plant, Mont -Carmel, Kamouraska.
9. Installation of Actifiltres Filtration Units, Lacolle. 110. Village of Crysler Water Supply and Treatment Plant, North Stormont.
11. Potable Water Supply System, Kuujjuarapik, Northern Quebec.
At GENIVAR we know that our success is based on our clients'
success. That's why we build long -term business relationships that
enable us to support our clients in their growth.
EXPERTISE
When clients choose us for their projects, they are able to access the experience of the entire firm.
Our work environment is flexible and that means communication and discussion between
employees is easy. As a result, our clients can count on superior services in every field because the
entire team is behind every job.
CONSTRUCTIVE APPROACH
But GENIVAR offers even more. Besides their technical expertise, innovative spirit and access to
state -of- the -art tools, our team members adopt a constructive approach, and that makes all the
difference. Our employees are observant. They listen closely to clients. They proactively anticipate
clients' needs and meet their requirements.
COMMITMENT
Our commitment results in real benefits for our clients, including:
Optimized structures.
The ability to provide " fast track delivery on special schedules while reducing any disruption to client operations.
On -line software to facilitate communication and the sharing of documents with our clients.
In -house centres of excellence available to our clients.
GENIVAR is a leader in the delivery of total solutions based on an integrated approach. Wth 1, 300 employees,
GEN IVAR offers a full range of engineering, construction, and environmental services, as well as organizational
development and training. GENIVAR professionals work closely with their clients through every stage of the project.
GENIVAR www.genivar.corn
constructive eop /e
05. 11
PS
t fpro dtEit112., .
and : x
rmW. e a cele - f 7 i::
w
b .: airttainin wat ".,
r.
u- i :. t , , L,
SERVICES OFFERED:
Simulation Modelling
Water Impoundment Dams
SERVICES OFFERED:
JJ iL /\4v1. _y
nYC'.
SERVICES OFFERED:
COMPANY PROFILE
G. L. Stone Consulting Limited (GLS) was founded in 1969 to provide consulting and inspection
services in the protective coatings field. We undertake domestic and international projects, and
coordinate projects from offices in Mississauga and Hamilton, Ontario.
The GLS team of consultants draw upon a sound background in coatings chemistry to specify the
correct products for each application, or solve painting problems. Our inspectors also have
backgrounds in the coatings industry, and specific training in coatings inspection.
In order to keep up with the latest technology we maintain active memberships in NACE and
SSPC, The Society for Protective Coatings, the most significant North American organizations
addressing coatings issues. We have been involved with the development or revision of many of
the standards referred to by painting specifications and used daily in our industry.
GLS provides services mainly where heavy duty corrosion resistant coatings are required. We
have worked in numerous industries where coatings are used, including bridges, water storage,
water treatment and waste water treatment facilities, rail cars, the petroleum industry ( including
offshore platforms, FPSOs, terminals, and refineries), and miscelaneous industrial applications.
Over the last 30 years GLS has been involved with well over 200 water tank painting projects.
GLS has developed a reputation well respected in the coatings industry by combining sound
coatings technology with an unbiased and practical approach to achieving optimum coating
system performance. Our continuing commitment to these basic principles assures that projects
involving GLS have better quality and lower costs for the life of the coatings than may
otherwise be possible.
Main Office
P. O. Box 1126 Station B
Mississauga, Ontario
LAY 3W4
Phone ( 905) 277 -8181
Jim Stone President
P. O. BOX 1126, STATION B, MISSISSAUGA, ON, L4Y 3W4 TEL: ( 905) 277 -8181 FAX: ( 905) 566 -1728
Appendix B
Project Profiles
Project Profiles
LOCATION
Scarborough, Ontario
CLIENT
City of Toronto
PROJECT VALUE
2 million
STATUS
Spring 2013
constructive people
GENIVAR
LOCATION
Toronto, Ontario
CLIENT
City of Toronto
PROJECT VALUE
2 million
STATUS
Spring 2013
Internal] and Extrna0
Paontong and Upgrades
of Lea Th r k
GENIVAR was retained by the City of Toronto to provide pre- design,
detailed design, tender, coating inspection and construction contract
administration services for the interior and exterior painting and upgrades
of the Leslie Tank. The project is currently in the construction phase and
features interior and exterior recoating as well upgrades such as safety
equipment, the addition of passive cathodic protection and repairs to the
valve house. Deliverables include a condition assessment and pre -
design inspection report, preparation of contract documents including
specifications and drawings, cost estimate and full -time coatings
supervision and contract administration.
constructive people
GENIVAR
LOCATION
The Ontario Police College,
Aylmer, Ontario
CLIENT
CB Richard Ellis Global
Corporate Services
CONTRACT VALUE
40,400
STATUS
Completion Date: Sept. 2011
ter Taw
r U r des
The Ontario Police College located in Alyme has a potable water system
consisting of a water tower capable of storing 75, 000 imperial gallons
and an in- ground reservoir capable of storing 206, 000 imperial gallons,
which had been identified as requiring several upgrades, including the
interior and exterior recoating of the water tower and upgrades to the
access hatches to the in- ground reservoir.
LOCATION
Waterloo, ON
CLIENT
Region of Waterloo
PROJECT VALUE
8 Million VQtchener =
Waterpoo Zone 6
STATUS
Construction ( 2012)
EDevated Tank
GENIVAR Inc. was retained by the Region of Waterloo to complete the
Detailed Design and provide Contract Administration and Site Inspection
services for a new 7. 2 ML elevated tank located in the City of Waterloo to
service Kitchener -Waterloo Zone 6. GENIVAR also conducted the site
due diligence and obtained all approvals for the project. The project
includes watermains, site services re- chloramination capabilities,
recirculation pump, tank mixing system and SCADA integration.
SERVICES
FEATURES
3 Tank Capacity: 7. 2 ML
Twin 450mm trunk watermains
constructive people
GENIVAR
LOCATION
Glencoe, Ontario
CLIENT
The Municipality of Southwest
Middlesex
PROJECT VALUE
3 million
STATUS
Design Completed on Schedule
Construction Scheduled for
Sept. 2011 Commissioning
KEY PERSONNEL
Jamie Witherspoon
Vaughn Ash
Andrew Tulk
Matt Morkem Glencoe A e Wt
ReseL1 W R pD ceme It
GENIVAR ROLE:
COMPONENTS
constructive people
GENIVAR Tank
Layout
Proposed
New Mixing
System
LOCATION
Bolton, ON
Waterloo Zone 6 Elevated) Tank
CLIENT
Region of Waterloo Mixing Analysis
PROJECT VALUE
61, 000 An Analysis of the proposed installation of a 3- nozzle duckbill valve in
the Waterloo Zone 6 Elevated Tank is currently underway. The purpose
STATUS
of this project is to evaluate the mixing and tank turnover /fluctuation with
Analysis & Design 2012
the intention of ensuring water quality.
Installation 2012
SERVICES
FEATURES
constructive people
GENIVAR
LOCATION
Caledon, Ontario
CLIENT
PROJECT VALUE
4, 500, 000
STATUS
Completed Class EA: August 2008
r\v1 ayffieDdl West esell l i
Completed DD: April 2008
Completed Construction: June 2008 Melt agedTank
CLASS ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
The Maple Pumping Station was part of the Aurora Newmarket Water
Supply Project for the Region of York. The overall project included 17 km
of 1050 / 1200 mm diameter watermain, a 10 ML ground storage
reservoir and the Maple Pumping Station to supply the system. The
pumping station independently serves the Maple Community and
Richmond Hill ( Pressure District 7) and Aurora, Newmarket, Vaughan
and part of Richmond Hill ( Pressure District 8).
This fully- equipped pumping station serves two pressure districts with the
maximum capacity of 68. 2 MUD for PD7 and 150 MUD for PD8, in the
Region of York. The facility is complete with centrifugal pumps, a 1800
mm diameter suction header fed from two independent reservoir
connections for redundancy, independent discharge headers with
appropriate surge control, flow monitoring devices electrical / control
equipment, SCADA, and provision to install a re- chloramination system.
SERVICES
4 Preliminary Design
4 Detailed Design
constructive people
Appendix C
Resumes
Resumes
EDUCATION
ADDITIONAL TRAINING
PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
Professional Engineers Ontario, Member PEO
CAREER
constructive people
GENIVAR ALEC CRANMER, M. A.Sc., P. Eng.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
4 York PD9 Elevated Tank No. 2, York Region, ON ( 2007- 2009): Project
Manager, EA Specialist and Design Engineer for a new 7. 55 ML composite
elevated tank, including a Schedule ' B' Class EA, to service York Pressure
District 9. Project works included Site Plan approval, re- chloramination
disinfection facilities, tank mixing and re- circulation equipment, site servicing
and property acquisition.
4 North Richmond Hill Elevated Tank and Yonge Street Watermain, York
Region, ON ( 2006- 2008): Project Manager, Design Engineer and Contract
Administrator for a new 7. 55 ML composite elevated tank and approx. 2 km of
500 mm dia. CPP Watermain to service York Pressure District 9. Project works
included a Schedule ' B' Class EA, property acquisition and site servicing.
4 Minden Elevated Tank, Township of Minden Hills, ON ( 2008- 2009): Project
Manager, EA Specialist and Design Reviewer for the Schedule ' B' Class EA
and detailed design of a new 1. 5 ML composite elevated tank, including site
servicing and decommissioning of the existing storage reservoir.
4 Kingston West Elevated Tank and Booster Pumping Station, Utilities
Kingston, ON ( 2004 -2006): Project Engineer and Contract Administrator for a
new 6. 8 ML composite elevated tank and 90 L/ s booster pumping station to
service Kingston Zone 2. Design features included a bulk water depot,
temporary detention area, chemical feed system and tank circulation
equipment.
Page 2
GENIVAR ALEC CRANMER, M. A.Sc., P. Eng.
Page 3
GENIVAR ALEC CRANMER, M. A.Sc., P. Eng.
Page 4
GENIVAR ALEC CRANMER, M. A.Sc., P. Eng.
4 Carlisle Well ( FDC06) and Water Tower EA. Client: City of Hamilton
4 Aurora East Water Storage Facility EA. Client: York Region.
4 Minden Elevated Tank EA. Client: Minden Hills.
3 Cranmer, Alec J. and S. F. Mousavi, " Proving WATFLOOD: Modelling the Non -
Linearities of Hydrologic Response to Storm Intensities." Can. J. Civ. Eng. 28,
2001, 837 -855. http: / cjce.
/ nrc.ca
Page 5
GENIVAR MUNICIPAL INFRASTRUCTURE
E DUCATION
ADDITIONAL TRAINING
P ROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
CAREER
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Page 2 of 5
GENIVAR RON CARIGLIA, B. A.Sc., P. Eng.
Municipal Development
Page 3 of 5
GENIVAR RON CARIGLIA, B.A.Sc., P. Eng.
4 Ready -Mix Concrete Plant, Romeo, MI ( 2004): Project Manager and Lead
Engineer for Ready -Mix concrete plant featured in Concrete Producer
Magazine. Client: Theut Products. Project Value: $ 5M.
Page 4 of 5
GENIVAR RON CARIGLIA, B. A.Sc., P. Eng.
Page 5 of 5
GENIVAR MUNICIPAL INFRASTRUCTURE
English
EDUCATION
French
Italian Bachelor' s Education, Ottawa, ON
of University of 1998
Spanish
Bachelor's of Applied Science, Chemical Engineering, 1995
University of Ottawa, ON
P ROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
Professional Engineers of Ontario PEO
CAREER
P ROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
4 Woodward Avenue Water Treatment Plant ( WTP) Fluoridation Building
and Metering System Hamilton, ON ( 2009- 2012): Project Manager; managed
detail design and met with client for reviews, advised and managed tendering of
the work, provided construction management and commissioning assistance.
4 McChesney Road 1050mm Sewer Timmins ON ( 2011): Project Manager;
Completed pre -purchase, final design and tendering, as well as construction
management of a 1. 5 km long 1050mm sewer that passed through a critical
area of an operational lumber mill. Processed CofA application within 1 week in
order to take advantage of construction window opportunity at the mill.
3 Woodward High Lift Pumping Station Upgrades, Hamilton, ON ( 2009- 2012):
Project Manager; managed construction administration of Qty. 10 -32" valve
replacements on six ( 6) high lift pumps, lighting improvements, staircase
upgrades and other structural improvements.
Page 2 of 2
GENIVAR BUILDINGS
E DUCATION
AWARDS
P ROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS
Professional Engineers of Ontario PEO
CAREER
Building Permit Clerk, Planning and Building, City of Timmins 2006 2006
GENIVAR Cory Goulet, BEng, E. I. T. LEED Green Associate
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Structural Design
4 Hoyle Pond Admin. Dry Expansion, Hoyle Pond Mine, Ontario ( 2011):
Structural Design, Site Inspection, and Construction Administration. Client:
Goldcorp. Project Value: $ 54M
3 Moonbeam Infrastructure Project, Moonbeam, Ontario ( 2011): Structural
Design, Site Inspection, and Construction Administration. Client: Town of
Moonbeam. Project Value: $ O. 9M
4 Hearst Solar Array (Structural), Hearst, Ontario ( 2012): Structural design and
drafting of building reinforcement for wall integrated solar panels. Client: Town
of Hearst Project Value: $ 0. 3M
4 Val Rita -Harty Solar Array ( Structural), Val Rita -Harty, Ontario ( 2012):
Structural design and drafting of building reinforcement for wall integrated solar
panels. Client: Municipality of Val Rita -Harty. Project Value: $ o. 3M
Municipal Infrastructure
Page 2
GENIVAR Cory Goulet, B. Eng, E. I. T. LEED Green Associate
MTO Contract 2007 -2033, QEW Burlington Bay Skyway, Ontario ( 2007):
Senior Inspector Administration and Inspection of Hot Mix Paving, ATMS
and Structural Bridge Components. Construction Value: $6. 4M
MTO Contract 2005 -5123, Hwy 17 - North Bay, Ontario ( 2007): Junior
Inspector Administration and Inspection of Grading, Drainage, Granular
Base, Hot Mix Paving, Structure Rehabilitation. Construction Value: $ 12. 2M
MTO Contract 2006 -5156, Highway 69 - Nobel, Ontario ( 2006): Junior
Inspector Administration and Inspection of Grading, Drainage, Granular
Base, Hot Mix Paving and Structures (4). Construction Value: $s2.SM
n MTO Contract 2006 -5175, Hwy 144, Ontario ( 2006): Junior Inspector
Administration and Inspection of Grading, Drainage, Granular Base, Hot
Mix Paving, Structure Rehabilitation. Construction Value: $s.3M
Page 3
Est. 1969
H. J. STONE
Experience
1995 - President of G. L. Stone Consulting Ltd. Functions carried out as before, with
full responsibility for company administration.
1992 - 1995 G. L. Stone Consulting Ltd. Vice President and Technical Director.
Responsibilities include supervision of inspection projects, failure
analysis /troubleshooting, specification writing, Quality Assurance /Quality Control
inspection.
1987 - 1992 G. L. Stone Enterprises Ltd. Senior Technologist. Quality Assurance and Quality
Control inspection of heavy duty corrosion resistant coatings application projects,
particularly for railcar linings, sewage digesters and bridges. Inspection of
concrete rebar cathodic protection systems. Project supervision.
1987 Corrosion Service Company Ltd. Crew member installing cathodic protection
systems in underground parking garages.
1984 - 1987 G. L. Stone Enterprises Ltd. Senior Inspector. Performed Quality Control
inspection on various painting projects, petrochemical, ships, bridges, potable
water storage tanks, etc.
1979 - 1983 G. L. Stone Enterprises Ltd. Junior Inspector. Summers spent on various coating
inspection projects as an understudy to a Senior Inspector.
1978 Atlantic Sandblasting and Coatings Inc. Painter's helper during summer; lining
cargo tanks of M.V. Gulf Mackenzie and M.V. Gulf Gatineau.
Education
P. O. BOX 1126, STATION B, MISSISSAUGA, ON, L4Y 3W4 TEL: ( 905) 277 -8181 FAX: ( 905) 566 -1728
Est. 1969
Resolution of
Coating Failures - SSPC
Accreditations
Associations
SSPC
Member of technical committees
Current Secretary of Ontario Chapter
Past Chairman of SSPC Ontario Chapter
P. O. BOX 1126, STATION B, MISSISSAUGA, ON, L4Y 3W4 TEL: ( 905) 277 -8181 FAX: ( 905) 566 -1728
Est. 1969
Experience
Bridges .
New budge girder coatings inspection in shop environments. Projects required
inspection of all surface preparation and coating application activities, in addition to
inspection of cured coatings.
Training and Qualifications NACE International Certified Coating Inspector Level 2 Valid until 5/ 31/ 2014
Associations NACE
P. O. BOX 1126, STATION B, MISSISSAUGA, ON, L4Y 3W4 TEL: ( 905) 277 -8181 FAX: ( 905) 566 -1728
Appendix D
Schedule
July 30 6/
23
6/
16
6/
96/
GENIVAR
2
6/
June
26
5/
Deadline
19
5/
12
5/
0%
G ._
5/5
May 28
4/ Sum ary Task Mileston
2
4/ Project External External
1c
41 4
417
April 3131 4
3124 Proges
Mileston Sum ary Sum ary`
17
3/
10 fax 01
Tim ns 2013-
3/
3/3 314
March of
2124 ENG-
13 13 19 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 City
4/ 4/ 5/ 5/
316 13 131 3
6/
22/
312613 5/ 6/ 7/
26/ 11/ 4/ 16/ 16/ 18/ 18/ 18/ 5/ 5/ 27/ 27/ 13/ 24/ 27/
316/
Mileston
315/ 21/
The RFP#:
Resrvoi
3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 3/
3/ 3/ 3/ 3/ 4/ 4/ 4/ 4/ 4/ 4/ 5/ 5/ 8/ 9/ 9/
Duration 3 5 5 0 2 7 0 7 0 0 2 0 0 0
0 4
25 15 13 87 30
Standpie
14 14
145 144
Permits
Holinger S p e c i f a t o n s )
for
Proges
MSystem emorandu Memoradu Memorandu Specifaton Documents Specifatons) PProevisrmnali)ts( Aplicatons
Task Split " " " " T"a"s"k
Revi w
Coating
and
and and and Period
Design System
T e c h n i a l T e c h n i a l T e c h n i a l Drawings Contrac Drawings and Tendrig
and
Gathering Coating Drawings Documents
and
City
FINAL City Submit
to
SAward TANDPIE Background IPnirtoajeocnt ERexvisitwng Reviw Reviw Prepare Meting Prepare Prepare Meting Prepare Aplicatons Prepare
with Prepare DRAFT with FINAL and Servic s Techni al Close
Perfomanc Inspection
RProvide Tender ecomndati Servics Construci Construci Substanil Conduct
Devlopmnt
Final
and a a
Tender
1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 -
Is ue Tender
6 -
Paint g
Schedul SPurmojeacryt Project HOLINGER Task
1. 1. 1. 1. 1.
1.
01
Task Task Task Task Task
Name 2013 - Standpie 2/131/3
Tender Project Task
D; O 1 2 3 4 6 6 7 _
e ti
i
10 11_, 12 13 14 15 15 17 16 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
ENG- Wed
RFP: Date:Holinger
12/
12/
Decmbr
GENIVAR
1
12/
24
11/
17
11/
10
11/
Novembr
3
11/
27
Deadline
10/
20
10/
13
10/
10/
October 29
9/
8% 0%
Sum ary Tasks Mileston
Project External External
0%
912
I
15
9/
S_
j
8125 Proges
1
ef18 Mileston Sum ary Sum ary: 01
August 7128
8/
81 1
4
Tim ns 2013-
of
ENG-
City
Resrvoi Mileston
21
The RFP#:
7/
Split
7/14
Baselin , Baselin Baselin
days days days days day days days days days days days days days days days days wits days days days days days days days days! days days
1
Duration
5
0 3 5 5 D 2 7
Standpie
4 0 7 0 0 2 0 D 0
14 14 25 15 13 87 3D
145 144
Permits
Holinger S p e c i f a t o n s )
for
Proges -
MSystem emorandu Memoradu Memorandu Specifaton Documents Specifatons) PPreovrismnailt)s( Aplicatons
Task Split Task
Revi w
Coating and
Design Drawings
and
and
and and Period
Gathering System Coating Technial Technial Technial Drawings Contrac Drawings Documents Tendrig and
Paint g/
and
for
Reports, Coating Alternaiv Systems DRAFT Systems Design Documents( DRAFT Documents( Aprovals Requird Tend ri g During
PAINT G Informati Meting Studies, Coating Reviw Coating Contrac Reviw During Suport
Let er Construci Spat Proges
Alternaiv Evalute DRAFT for
Tender Submit
all
Documents During
Award Period Perfomanc Inspection
Critcal Critcal Critcal
STANDPIE Background PInriotjaecotn Existng Reviw FINAL Prepare DRAFT FINAL Aplicatons Services Tender Technial Close Recomndati Servics
to
Final to
City City
Devlopmnt Name
Project
1. 1.
Task
and a with a
1.
Task
with
1.
and
Schedul Sumary PArwoajercdt HOLINGER Task Reviw Reviw Prepare Meting Prepare Prepare Meting Prepare Task Prepare Provide Tender Tender Construci Construci Substanil Conduct
1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 -
1.
Task
Is ue
6 -
1.
Task
Final
01
2013- 131 3
Paint g
Standpie
Tender Project
2/
Organizational Chart
GENIVAR S.
ProtecARid- CangIia'
Lead / Ron
r'
w
a
QC
QA/ la
Ltd
Team
Inspection Consultig Team"
i
Phil Ron
Tim ns Manger Manger',:%!. Crpnmer and Jim G.
CADuport
Adminstrao Strucal Adminstrao&' Inspection Expert/'
of
City Project
Tender Holinger RFP.: Project
2 2 2 1 1 4
15
60 ' -
U
e.__.. _. _.
e_.,..
20
n 240
4
2471
201
1
of
t
Page
44 0 8 8
12 15 67
U
a._.._.. ___._.....
2 6
1 1 1
19
y
2 8 1 1 1 1 4 2
42
y
HQDRS
Standpie
Specifatons) Specifatons) Inspection)
Holinger p:
La,gig Descripton
Task
R
ew
e
Omrsan.
n
and
erns
vs Coati
Report Repod Documents Period
System Aelubena /Drawings Drawin
Technial Technial Contrac
and
nag
and and
s
Tendrig include
Inspection)
Site
in
include
Site
in
Coating
ins raw mp roc
oa 30
Construcion Adminstrao
to to via
Evalute DRAFT
n
DRAFT Wth FINAL Technial Tender Revi w Construci Drawing and Revi w lspecton
ter a City Final u
on
gre n. Inita on Existn and with
a
Inspect
a
ropers
Crtif C Project Reviw Reviw Prepare Me ting Prepare Me ting Prepare Provide Prepare Tender Monthly Contrac Shop Site Te th,' Struc al Final
Paint g/
Pre-
1 1 1.
3 55
To -11.1. 21.1. ask 11.2. 21.2. 3t.2. ast 11.3. 21.3. 31.3. as
11.4. 11.4. A3
1
as
1.15. 52 15. 1.5 15. 5.
1. 1.6 1.5 1.6a5.
i 1
for
Matrix Hours
Devlopmnt
s&
Hours
Tender Person/
Hourss&
Appendix F
Addenda
REQUEST FO PROPOSAL
Tender Development for Painting /Coating Hollinger Standpipe
Reservoir
RFP ENG- 2013 -01
ADDENDUM # 001
ADDENDUM # 001
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS:
Answer- the tower was inspected in 2006 and 2011 and both reports are accessible
through the RFP ( link is provided on page 7 of the RFP).
Answer- Under Section 3. 5 of the RFP ( Contract Administration and Inspection), the
successful proponent is required to inspect the tower after removal of the coatings.
However, the initial inspections have been done ( see question 1).
Answer- the interior of the tower would be classified as a recoat as we will have to
remove the coatings inside the tower. The exterior of the tower would be evaluated
during the project to determine how much of the original coatings /paint need to be
removed.
Answer- To the best of our knowledge, there is no lead pigments in the coatings.
The paint has not been tested.
5. Section 3 of Part B identifies the Evaluation Criteria for the Proposal; however there is
no breakdown for how the points are awarded. Can the City please provide a scoring
breakdown?
Answer- The City of Timmins uses a two envelope proposal evaluation system with
one "envelope" containing the Technical part of the Proposal and a second
envelope" with the financial or price part of the proposal. The City will not provide a
specific weighting breakdown of the categories listed in the RFP ( Understanding the
RFP, Experience / Qualifications of the project team, Project Implementation Plan,
Corporate Profile, and References) but will let you know that the Technical
component is worth 60% and the Cost component is 40 %.
6. Does the City require the services of a certified coating specialist ( NACE) to certify the
application of the coating to the tank?
Answer- The City did not request, or provide for a any specific coatings specialist
such as NACE. However, we would expect that the inspector provided to monitor
the progress and quality of the work by the contractor is an experienced person.
Providing a NACE certified specialist would likely enhance the overall technical
component of the RFP ( Experience /Qualifications section).
The proponent shall sign this addendum in the space provided below and
include it with their proposal.
F E B R U A R Y 14, 2 0 1 3- 2: 0 0 p. m.
GENIVAR Inc. 600 Cochrane Drive, 5th Floor, Markham, Ontario L3R 5K3
T. 905 -475 -7270 - F: 905 -475 -5114 - www.genivar.com
Contact: Michelle Albert P. Eng. E -mail: nnchelle. albert@genivar.com
GENIVAR
P13- 99999 -95
GENIVAR is pleased to submit two ( 2) copies of our financial proposal as part of our submission for the
Request for Proposal ENG- 2013 -01 for Engineering Services for Tender Development for
Painting /Coating the Hollinger Standpipe Reservoir.
The upset budget of $ 39, 960. 00, including labour and disbursements, but excluding HST is summarized
on the completed form of proposal as requested in the RFP document. Our budget breakdown is detailed
in the Person /Hours Matrix included with this financial proposal.
We appreciate and sincerely value the excellent working relationship we have enjoyed with City of
Timmins staff on key water and wastewater infrastructure projects over the last number of years. We very
much look forward to the opportunity to continue building on this solid foundation with the successful
delivery of the Hollinger Standpipe Painting /Coating Project.
We would be pleased to discuss any aspect of our submission with you and look forward to your
favourable consideration.
Respectfully submitted,
GENIVAR Inc.
Cam.
38610 810.
36
6 6 Q 9 3 S
40
87 H
7 6 1 2
24 0 4 4 910 9f0 of
1
0
Page
12 2 4
15 00 15 00
cost .
o 1
toc
650.
o
FVc 1850. 1
update
GENIVAR
240 4 000 00
18530
a
525.
0 tjQ V,.
o
1853 .
for
20 00 20 00
t
y
10. 10.
pthackigse
g
12_
o=
CN
m
67 00 67 00
Pnu $
h
g
S'en
2
1 1
2
41MISEC
S -.
4 4
1
6
2 8
810 .
19 00 19 00
100.
fi
565.
of
back
uU 1565. 3
Resrvoi
a:
the
FoPf
1
2 2 1 t 2
42 00 42 00
5610. 670.
cost .
at
aa.
loucpdaatteed
5
tt p
ORS HS
InrileM Excl.isd.
Matrix
for
Standpie FE SFE S
TO AL PROJECT
LIMIT
UPSET
Hpoackugres
this
Person/
of
Holinger i'"
Ikea
oq
an
Sathedi Sn4
TCoating echnial Technial Technial CIalbn
sytam
Report Report Report
and
Si
Gwedl
1
days)
as
TO AL back
therevis d
at
the
iLeluhcton Services Comisng
age'Iola '
Alternaiv Coating Reviw Coating
Coating Tendrig
On MO
locraetfeedr
to
iTCoar
t . (
1f 1
banktank
n
4;,.
rt#
a
1
o of
TNdLICVADPE SackgroundI
to A
co n
Inspection
s
21.
l
lrtS
HNotourse:
5 6 7
ra
HOL[ 11a1( nk 121 122 123 2A to
T 1.
Tas t-
5
1. 1. 1.
.
5. 5.
118
I-
1`
13 14 3i Hours
s&
for Person/
Matrix revisd
Devlopmnt Hours the
to
refer
Please
Tender Person/ Note: Hours
s&
City of Timmins
23. AUTHORIZATION
These terms of reference shall be signed and bound or accompany the submitted
proposal.
For further information regarding the Request for Proposal please contact:
Attach in a separate sealed envelope along with the Time Task Breakdown
showing the fee for all project activities and for each team member and
disbursements for each category.
Signed: '
Please be advised that Timmins City Council accepted your proposal as modified by your additional submissions for
consulting services for the coating and painting of the Hollinger Water Standpipe.
Please prepare an agreement to be signed by both parties. Please set up the Project initiation meeting as soon as
possible.
Hi Norm,
As discussed this morning, please find attached our revised fee schedule, which includes 500 hours of inspection by a
NACE certified inspector. The revisions assume approx. 10 weeks of coatings inspection and 12 weeks of total
construction duration.
We have also included a Condition Assessment of the existing coatings by Jim Stone, a NACE 111 Inspector. The
condition assessment will occur as soon as possible to determine lead content Of any), the extent of corrosion, adhesion
testing, etc., which will confirm if the existing coatings can be top- coated or if a complete removal and replacement is
required. We will also be able to estimate any impacts on the construction schedule and budget with this knowledge and
prepare the contract documents accordingly.
As mentioned in our proposal, we have also included a Provisional Amount for an analysis of the tank mixing and design
of a mixing system, in case this is something the City may be interested in pursuing at a later date.
Let us know if you have any questions or require any further revisions.
1
Thanks again,
GEN1VAR
Alec Cranmer, P. Eng.
Discipline Lead - Water Infrastructure
GENIVAR INC.
600 Cochrane Drive, 5th Floor, Markham, ON L3R 5K3
T 905 -475 -7270 # 18257 I F 905 -475 -5994 I C 416 -278 -4107 I www.genivar.com
Hello.
I received your revised Financial proposal.
I am concerned that the hours for the NACE inspector are too low.
We would be prepared to recommend accepting Genivar' s proposal to Council with an allowance of 500 hours for the
NACE inspector. This is because, as you point out in your submission, there are many possible delays that could take
place during the construction period and I do not want to go back to Council for additional funds if at all possible. With
this increase in the total cost of Genivars financial proposal , Genivar continues to have the top score from the Proposal
evaluators for this proposal.
Please call me to discuss this ASAP.
DISCLAIMER: This message may contain information that is privileged or confidential and is intended to be for the use of the
individual ( s) or entity named above. This material may contain confidential or personal information which may be subject to the
provisions of the Municipal Freedom of Information & Protection of Privacy Act. If you are not the intended recipient of this e- mail,
any use, review, retransmission, distribution, dissemination, copying, printing, or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance
upon this e- mail, is strictly prohibited. If you have received this e- mail in error, please contact the sender and delete the original and
any copy of this e- mail and any printout thereof, immediately. Your co- operation is appreciated.
2
d
in reliance shoe this e-
mail, Is strictly prohibited. If you have
nd
e - marl in error, please contact the sender and delete the or
any copy of this e- mail, and any pr: ntcur thereof, immediately. Y
cooperation is
CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING:
This message is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed, and may contain information which is privileged, confidential,
proprietary or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If you are not the intended recipient or the person responsible for delivering the message to the
intended recipient, you are strictly prohibited from disclosing, distributing, copying or in any way using this message. If you have received this communication in
error, please notify the sender, and destroy and delete any copies you may have received.
AVERTISSEMENT:
Ce message est destine uniquement a la personne ou A (' organisation a laquelle it est adresse et II peut contenir des informations privilegiees, confidentielles ou
non divulgables en vertu de la loi. Si vous n' etes pas le destinataire du present message ni la personne chargee de remettre le present message A son
destinataire, 11 vous est strictement interdit de le divulguer, de le distribuer, de le copier ou de ('utiliser de quelque facon que ce soil. Si vous avez repu la presente
communication par erreur, veuillez en aviser I' expediteur et detruire ou effacer tous les exemplaires que vous avez repus.
our webs
to ca/
3
Costa&Costa& 1. 1.
2.
0 51. 4
1. 3
1. 1.2 1
HOarsHOars 1, 1, 1. 1. 1. .
Person/ Tender
1. 1.1.1. 1.1. 1. 1.
2.
1
Task 5. 5.
50 55
5.
52 52
5.
Task 14. ,. 10. Task
4,
32
3.
Task 2A - , - - Task Task
HOLINGER
8 7 4 1 2 1 ' .. 1 0
1. 1.
1. 1. 1.
1 yk^'
2.
1 - 5 - 4 - 3. 2 1 -
P :.:
131te Pre- On-
Tank First
Struc al Testklg Drava CAMAontac Monthly Servics Services Me ting Prepare Prepare 1Tr 1. Reviw
T. Site
PAWN
inspecton Reviw inspecton Construci During raw.Ten-der Technial'During 7yl7R.* ; DRAFT Final NAL tai.^ Condit
T' e
end with l:
Revi w Construci
Ci
Model,
Servics Tank Com iseln SenAces( riabelon Marking acorn:., Dorax enh
of
Alternaiv
Iir.; Asemnt Coating Informati Hours
Mixng R e v i w
Interio Services( we ps Services Metings( Construci Tendrig DRAFT Documents( Drawings
Devlopmnt
I.
T^
rg 10
Dud . t'^;
System terns of
Ti_Goa . . .
Task
r
Dtewirgs and
Dascri.
Matrix for
In
Site
Coalinga
11:
Specifatons
and 12
a
In
Period and
Report r..
Revi w
Documents end
T.
ET " ion) j
47 1^
SpedBtalior) Certif d
Inspector
Paint g/
tr
ECT TO AL fin .
FE S
Excl. PROJECT Lead
7J
71 43
5.
605.
00 43
f
2,
2 4 I
8 2 8 2 I 1
8 i1
a m. L.1
c
F,
C Fm Coating
2565.
IKL ho ad
Holinger
00 19 5650 19 8 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
m
S
0.
r
6,
700. 700. La
00 67 00 67 6 8 4 4 4 4 15 2
8 fl
X. r
Standpie
1.
170 . 706. C
rq are
20 00 20 20
5
67
6.
0250
S
67 4 60 2
1
13
4
ca
y
moF SQaFm
o
C
41
Resrvoi
3.
m
0
10. 0 31 410 0
f
31 4 1 1 1
2
1 Out] tip
o$
art , H
37, 2 V tit
3750 . 500. c yra
cgtl
tip
160 747 747 560 16 12 8
S S
4 8 0
5
I 2
3
7 8 7 7 6
S
40 1-
5
15, 62, 1,
42. 1 1,
1 1.
3o
3025. 1080. 1025. 1825. 895. ti :
t:
14,
750. 600. 9250.
1- 60
GENIVAR
00 0050. 00 00 50. 0 50. 0 50. 0
F
50.00 1u
80 0 50 0 0.00 00 $
5 S
. S S S S
15,
000.
00
7.: -.77.
00 00 00
1
s , .
1.
:
50. 0 00
200.
i 00
720. 780.
00
s'..:
i
1 "'
9..
00 00
875. I1
TM
4
395.
00
1,
880.
00
o t`
0p
if!
PagePage
I
Iof1
of
1
CITY OF TIMMINS
BEING A BY- LAW to authorize the Corporation of the City of Timmins to enter into an
agreement with Genivar Ontario Inc. for consulting services respecting the painting and coating
WHEREAS the Council of The Corporation of the City of Timmins considers it desirable to enter
NOW THEREFORE the Council of The Corporation of the City of Timmins enacts the following
as a By- law:
1. THAT the Corporation of the City of Timmins enter into an agreement with Genivar
Ontario Inc. respecting the painting and coating of the Hollinger Standpipe, in the City of
Timmins, a copy of which agreement is attached hereto and marked as Schedule "A" to
this By- law, for a total cost of$ 77,455. 00 plus HST.
2. THAT the Mayor and Clerk be and are hereby authorized to execute the said agreement
on behalf of the Corporation and to affix thereto the Official Seal of the Corporation.
18th
READ a first, second and third time and finally passed this day of March, 2013.
SGD) R. J. WATSON
CLERK CLERK
EO 13
- 07
-
ADMINISTRATIVE
REPORT
SUBJECT
Presentation of results obtained from the Request for Proposal for Consultant Services.
PURPOSE
Receive Council approval for awarding a contract for consultant services in order to
undertake the Painting and Coating of the Hollinger Standpipe.
EXPLANATION
The Public Utilities Department has prepared, and completed, a detailed Request for
Proposal for engineering services for Painting and Coating of the exterior and interior of
the Hollinger (Water Storage) Standpipe. The City recognized the level of complexity in
this assignment and heavily favored the RFP process versus tendering.
The City of Timmins Request for Proposal consisted of the following scope;
Page 1 of 4
EO 13
- 07
-
A total of six ( 6)proposals were received and were each evaluated by a Technical
Selection Committee.
Based on the technical scoring results, the list of consultants was short -listed to five (5).
The financial contributions of the selected five (5)consultants were opened, evaluated and
scored. The overall scoring results provided the following final listing:
Final Standings
1. Genivar
2. R.V. Anderson
3. J.
L. Richards
4. CIMA
5. OCWA
Not applicable
Page 2 of 4
EO 13
- 07
-
The financial submissions of the five (5)short -listed candidate firms were opened. The
bids were examined in accordance to the terms of the proposal. The lowest bid was within
30% of the average financial price and the high bid was within 50% of the average. An
exceptionally low price can indicate a potential level of effort or quality that would be
unacceptable. A high price proposal can mean an inefficient method of doing the work or
lack of understanding of the scope of the project.
The financial proposal submitted by Genivar and which shall form the basis of the contract
for engineering services is in the amount of $00
77,
455.plus HST.
Please checkmark box to the left if this report has been reviewed by the Finance
Division and the funding source has been identified
This project is identified in our 2013 capital expenditure and is included in our 10 year
-
Water Capital Program. The project has a budgetary estimate of $1 million for all facets of
the work. Based on the budget estimate, we have determined the total engineering fee to
represent 7. 7% of the budget. This percentage is within the expected range (between 7%
to 15 %).
While the project will be managed by the consultant, the Public Utilities Department will
designate a project coordinator to ensure efficient communication between all parties. The
project coordinator accountabilities will be assigned internally to an existing staff member
to be determined).
We recommend to Council that they award this engineering contract to Genivar for the
amount stipulated in this report.
Page 3 of 4
EO 13
- 07
-
oxt-
Norm Bruce, P.Eng
Manager of Public Utilities
Comments:
Page 4 of 4