You are on page 1of 18

See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/265387304

Solid waste management in the hospitality


industry: A review

Article in Journal of Environmental Management December 2014


DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2014.07.038

CITATIONS READS

24 14,510

2 authors:

Sanaa Pirani Hassan A. Arafat


Masdar Institute of Science and Technology Masdar Institute of Science and Technology
8 PUBLICATIONS 91 CITATIONS 138 PUBLICATIONS 2,273 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

creative spacers for reduced fouling in RO and MD systems View project

CFD modeling of MD View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Hassan A. Arafat on 16 October 2017.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Journal of Environmental Management


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jenvman

Review

Solid waste management in the hospitality industry: A review


Sanaa I. Pirani, Hassan A. Arafat*
Institute Center for Water and Environment (iWater), Department of Chemical and Environmental Engineering, Masdar Institute of Science and Technology,
P.O. Box 54224, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: Solid waste management is a key aspect of the environmental management of establishments belonging
Received 21 April 2014 to the hospitality sector. In this study, we reviewed literature in this area, examining the current status of
Received in revised form waste management for the hospitality sector, in general, with a focus on food waste management in
23 July 2014
particular. We specically examined the for-prot subdivision of the hospitality sector, comprising pri-
Accepted 26 July 2014
Available online
marily of hotels and restaurants. An account is given of the causes of the different types of waste
encountered in this sector and what strategies may be used to reduce them. These strategies are further
highlighted in terms of initiatives and practices which are already being implemented around the world
Keywords:
Waste management
to facilitate sustainable waste management. We also recommended a general waste management pro-
Food waste cedure to be followed by properties of the hospitality sector and described how waste mapping, an
Hospitality industry innovative yet simple strategy, can signicantly reduce the waste generation of a hotel. Generally, we
Hotels found that not many scholarly publications are available in this area of research. More studies need to be
Restaurants carried out on the implementation of sustainable waste management for the hospitality industry in
Ecolabels different parts of the world and the challenges and opportunities involved.
2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction (International Hotel Environmental Initiative, 2002), and this


amounts to millions of tons of waste being generated worldwide
The hospitality industry in many parts of the world is expected annually. Therefore, the importance of studying the hospitality
to see signicant rates of growth in the next few years. For example, sector in order to facilitate more efcient waste management
Revenue Per Available Room (RevPAR) is expected to grow by 6% in procedures cannot be overemphasized.
2014 in the United States (Berman, 2014) and by up to 5% in some In the late 1990s, generally speaking, establishments of the
European cities during 2014 and 2015 (Milburn and Hall, 2014). In hospitality industry were not very concerned with their environ-
the Middle East, the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries are mental impact and a sustainable way of dealing with their waste
expected to see a boom in hotel revenue by 2016, which implies a was not given much priority (Radwan et al., 2010). However, the
Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 6.93% (MeetMiddleEast, current situation is very different. There is much more environ-
2013). Indeed, while exploring the various literature concerning the mental awareness, which is clear from the booming number of
global outlook for the hospitality industry, it is clear that, in most ecolabels that are being used as a means of certication for many
parts of the world, this sector is recovering from its nancial losses hospitality sector properties around the world. Most of these
after the 2008 global economic crisis and a positive outlook and properties are getting certied voluntarily. This is also an indication
favorable transaction climate are anticipated in 2014 for the global of the heightened interest of guests/visitors in environmental is-
lodging industry (Fishbin, 2014). sues. As a result, waste management processes adopted by many
This expansion in hospitality sector operations is complemented hotels and restaurants have changed from what they were 15 years
by an expansion in its waste management operations. More waste ago and various waste reduction strategies are being implemented,
usually translates into a greater environmental footprint and including those which address food waste. In fact, with effective
therefore more harm to the ecosystem. For example, a hotel guest is waste management, a mid-size hotel can produce one-fourth the
estimated to generate up to 1 kg of waste per day on average waste generated by a similar hotel which is not implementing the
same waste management strategies (WWF-UK and International
Business Leaders Forum (IBLF), 2005).
* Corresponding author. Tel.: 971 2 810 9119; fax: 971 2 810 9901.
For a hospitality business, the cost of solid waste management
E-mail address: harafat@masdar.ac.ae (H.A. Arafat). includes various factors such as the disposal and transport of waste,

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2014.07.038
0301-4797/ 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336 321

as well as associated labor costs (Todd and Hawkins, 2003). Table 1


Therefore, more efcient waste management can help lead to sig- Types of non-hazardous waste in the hotel industry [based on the work of Zein et al.,
2008].
nicant savings for the business depending on where the business
is located and the waste management regulations in that area. Non-hazardous Components Source
Other benets of ecofriendly waste management include an Waste Type

improved business image, reduced carbon emissions from the Household Food/kitchen Hotel's different
decreased transportation of waste, reduced costs due to smaller wastes waste, used or departments
dirty paper and
order requirements from suppliers, improved relations with
wrapping, plastic
stakeholders, reduced risks and liabilities, and health and safety wrapping or bags,
benets (Ball and Abou Taleb, 2010). composite wrappers
Not much literature is available on waste management in the Cardboard Packaging Hotel's purchasing and
other departments
hospitality industry. For example, a 2012 review of environment-
Paper Printed documents, Administration, reception,
related research articles published in major hospitality journals brochures, menus, guest rooms, restaurants
accounted for only 58 articles in the period from 2000 to 2010 maps, magazines,
(Myung et al., 2012). These articles were not only exclusively newspaper
focused on waste management, but also discussed other types of Plastic Bags, bottles (that Kitchen, restaurants,
did not contain bars, guest rooms,
environment-related research. Likewise, a 2013 review paper
hazardous administration
which accounted for publications from all over the world on food material), household
waste prevention in the food supply chain mentioned only one goods, individual portion
publication about cafeterias in Brazil, two publications about the wrappers for various
hospitality sector in general (one with reference to the UK and the products
Metal Tin cans, jar lids, Kitchen, restaurants,
other with reference to the Nordic countries), and one publication soda cans, food bars, guest rooms
about hotel restaurants in Norway (Schneider, 2013). When re- containers, mayonnaise,
sources can be found which discuss environmental management in mustard and tomato
the hospitality sector, they tend to lack the focus on the waste puree tubes, aluminum
packaging
management aspect of environmental management. And when
Glass Bottles, jars, asks Kitchen, restaurants,
these resources do discuss waste management in detail, they tend bars, guest rooms
to be in the form of reports which express strategies as recom- Cloth Tablecloths, bed-linen, Kitchen, restaurants,
mendations; with few having shown the effects of carrying out napkins, clothes, rags bars, bathrooms, guest rooms
such strategies. Moreover, reports concerning waste in the hospi- Wood Wooden packaging, pallets Purchasing department
Organic waste Fruit and vegetable Kitchen, restaurants,
tality industry tend to lack data specically on food waste peelings, owers and bars, guest rooms, gardens
(Marthinsen et al., 2012). plants, branches, leaves, grass
In this work, our goal is to provide a comprehensive review and
analysis of the status and practices of waste management in today's
hospitality sector may be further divided into for-prot and not-
hospitality industry. Such a review will be of relevance and benet
for-prot divisions (Partt et al., 2013). However, for the sake of
to management in the global hospitality industry, environmental
this study, by hospitality sector, the establishments being referred
organizations seeking to help green this major economic sector and
to are the hotels, restaurants, and cafeterias which operate on a for-
minimize its ecological footprint, as well as to decision makers and
prot basis. They are included in the Horeca subdivision of the
government ofcials desiring to benchmark the performance of
hospitality sector. Horeca stands for hotels, restaurants and cafe s
their local hospitality industry. A number of subjects is covered.
(Marthinsen et al., 2012). We have decided to consider this as the
First, a range of denitions used in this eld is elaborated. Then, the
scope of this paper since the waste management practices at all of
quantities of waste generated in the global hospitality industry, as
these institutions are quite similar, and collectively they account for
well as the composition of this waste are discussed. Generally
a very signicant proportion of waste generated for the hospitality
speaking, waste from the hospitality industry consists of both wet
industry (Partt et al., 2013).
(organic/biodegradable) and dry waste. The wet waste consists
Food waste is any food that is not consumed by humans and can
primarily of food waste (Wagh, 2008), which can account for more
be generated at any level within the food chain (Okazaki et al.,
than 50% of the hospitality waste (Curry, 2012) and up to one third
2008). For the purpose of this study, food waste is dened as any
of all the food served within the hospitality sector (Marthinsen
food discarded as part of operations in the hospitality sector. This
et al., 2012). Therefore, food waste in the hospitality industry is
could be packaged food that is thrown away as it has passed its
given special attention in this review. Then, studies reporting on
expiration date, food preparation/processing wastes, and waste
initiatives for waste reduction in the hospitality industry are
from serving dishes and guests' plates. Food waste can further be
reviewed and the impacts of these initiatives are assessed. Simi-
divided into avoidable (food that was edible before it was thrown
larly, key global organizations working on minimizing food waste in
away), possibly avoidable (food that is eaten by some but not by
the hospitality industry are reviewed and their approaches and
others, or a single type of food that may or may not be waste
strategies (and the success thereof) are discussed. Next, today's
depending on how it was prepared) and unavoidable waste. The
international ecolabeling systems for the hospitality industry are
avoidable and possibly unavoidable waste may therefore be
reviewed, contrasting their method of certication and regions of
considered to be edible (Partt et al., 2010).
application. Finally, the challenges associated with implementing
waste management in the hospitality industry are discussed.
3. Characterization and quantication of waste in the
2. Key denitions hospitality industry

The hospitality sector, in general, can be dened as businesses Waste generation is considered by some to be the most
such as hotels, bars, and restaurants that offer people food, drink, or noticeable effect which the hospitality sector has on the environ-
a place to sleep (Cambridge Dictionaries Online, 2014). The ment, especially due to the fact that many of the establishments
322 S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

which make up this sector, such as hotels, use large quantities of kitchen produced about 0.45 kg of waste per guest meal served
consumer goods as part of their operations (Bohdanowicz, 2005). (Axler, 1973). On comparison with Shanklin et al. (1991), it can be
The large amounts of food waste generated by the hospitality initially perceived that the daily waste generated per room has
sector can also not be ignored. halved from 1973 to 1991. However, if the waste generated on
Various studies have shed some light on the typical waste types checkout days is considered, then the rates from both studies
generated at hotels. For instance, aluminum, plastics, glass, steel, become similar. On the other hand, Earle and Townsend (1991)
cardboard and food waste were cited as being the main compo- reported the waste generated daily per room to vary from 1.81 to
nents of hotel waste in some studies (Axler, 1973; Kirk, 1995). As per 3.18 kg. In the same paper, Earle and Townsend (1991) mention a
another study (Zein et al., 2008), the components of hotel waste waste audit conducted prior to their study, through which it was
along with their sources are shown in Tables 1 and 2, which show found that the waste production in guest rooms in the Orlando area
non-hazardous and hazardous types of waste, respectively. It must ranged from 0.23 to 12.93 kg per day. A third publication mentions
be remembered, though, that these are not exhaustive lists of the how, on the global scale, a hotel guest produces about 1 kg of waste
components, although they do mention all of the most signicant per day (Losanwe, 2013). All these values, in general, and the values
components. For instance, sometimes hotels produce other types of obtained from Earle and Townsend (1991) in particular, explain
wastes, such as bulky items (e.g. furniture), construction and de- how there is much variation between hotels when it comes to how
molition waste (e.g. concrete, pipes, etc.), discarded electronics and much waste per room they are generating on a daily basis. This is
ofce appliances, and used refrigerating equipment (Zein et al., because the waste generation rate depends on many variables such
2008). It is also clear from Table 1 that multiple types of waste as the hotel type, guest attributes, guest and employee activities,
tend to be generated at individual locations. This is a concept which and occupancy rate (Snarr and Pezza, 2000). All the studies
will be elaborated further when discussing waste mapping. mentioned here collectively account for a large time span. Although
The relative percentage of each of these different waste types signicant variation has been observed in the results, the most
also varies by establishment. The waste composition values, pro- common value was around 0.45e0.91 kg per day per room. How-
vided by different publications in chronological order, are pre- ever, it must be mentioned that, as observed from the second part
sented in the rst section of Table 3. Only publications which have of Table 3, there is not much diversity when it comes to the region
specically reported quantities for waste types constituting hos- of the studies. It would be interesting to see how these values for
pitality waste are mentioned. It can be noticed that the percentage specic waste generation and composition would be different for
of organic/food waste is decreasing over the years. This is similar to properties in, for example, Asia or the Middle East, for which no
the trend noticed for municipal solid waste in the United States such values were found.
during the mid-1900s. As the standard of living in the USA The last part of Table 3 specically refers to restaurants. About
increased, its municipal solid waste (MSW) composition changed 95% of a restaurant's general waste could typically be recycled or
and reected an increased use of plastic and paper packaging composted (Nielsen and Green Restaurant Association, 2004), and
(Louis, 2004). Nevertheless, the fact that the relative percentage of as is clear from the solid waste breakdown, the fraction of organics
organic waste was going down does not indicate that less food in restaurant waste is almost double that of hotels. Since hotels
waste was being generated. With the growth of the hospitality have more expansive operations, it is expected that they would
industry (from 1990 to 2000, the number of hotel and lodging generate a greater proportion of other types of wastes such as paper
properties in the United States grew from 45,020 to 53,500 and plastics, than restaurants. Additionally, the two entries in the
(American Hotel & Lodging Association (AH&LA), 2014)), the last part of Table 3 show how organics are a more signicant
amount of organic/food waste also increased. However, the rate of component of the waste from restaurants in Malaysia than of the
increase of organic waste was not as high as that of packaging and waste from restaurants in Chicago. This is paralleled by many
thus the relative percentage of organic/food waste decreased. studies which show a greater proportion of organics in the
The second part of Table 3 shows reported estimations of waste municipal solid waste generated in developing countries
generated daily in a hotel guest room. An older source published in (Hoornweg and Bhada-Tata, 2012; Karak et al., 2012). Last but not
1973 mentioned how, in general, guest rooms generated about least, Swedish best practice has shown that efcient waste man-
0.91 kg of waste per day, while quality dining rooms and the hotel agement can reduce the quantity of unsorted waste per guest-night
to only 50 g (Bohdanowicz, 2006). This is much smaller than the
values reported in Table 3 and so gives an idea of how much room
Table 2 for improvement there is.
Types of hazardous waste in the hotel industry [based on the wok of Zein et al.,
2008]. 4. Solid waste management in the hospitality industry
Hazardous Waste Type Source
From a sustainability perspective, the improvement of waste
Frying oil Kitchen, restaurants
Mineral oil Maintenance service management practices of the hospitality industry is a pivotal part of
Pain and solvent residues Maintenance service its overall green strategy. This issue must be addressed not only by
Flammable material Kitchen, garden, the staff of the establishments at the different stages of operation
(gas, petrol, etc.) maintenance service (front-of-house, back-of-house, etc.), but also the administration
Fertilizers and chemicals Garden
(insecticides, fungicides,
must draw out strategies which would encourage guests to
herbicides) generate less waste. Though the latter is addressed more easily in
Cleaning chemicals Maintenance service some places than others, due to the nature of the guests fre-
Ink cartridges Administration quenting the property and their ecofriendly tendencies, this is
IT Disks and CD's Administration, guest rooms
something which eventually needs to be addressed by hotels and
Batteries Maintenance
service, administration, guest rooms restaurants all over the world. This is especially true when
Cleaning chemicals and Laundry room considering food waste, due to the fact that it is a type of waste that
solvents used in dry cleaning is very difcult to reuse, and so once generated by the guest, there is
Fluorescent lights, neon tunes Maintenance service little the staff can do to reuse it. Yes, it may be used to produce
and long-life bulbs
compost or renewable energy, but this is generally not considered
S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336 323

Table 3
Results from various studies on quantiers and composition of hospitality waste. The top section presents waste composition values, the middle section shows reported
estimations of waste generated daily in a guest room, and the bottom section shows data on waste generation and composition in restaurants.

Reference Study location Study period Waste quantities/calculation Data source

(Shanklin et al., 1991) Toronto 1990 46.4% food waste (dened as leftovers and returns from Study of 1 hotel
restaurant), 26.5% glass, 11% newspaper, 9.17% cardboard,
and 7% plastic
(Winter and New York Not dated 39.9% paper, 27.8% food/organics, 7.6% glass, 7.0% plastic, Waste composition analysis
Azimi, 1996) 6.7% yard waste, 6.1% metal, 4.3% other, 0.2% hazardous waste for the New York City hotel industry
(Alexander, 2002; Los Angeles 1991e1993 46% food waste, 25.3% paper, 11.7% cardboard, 6.7% plastics, Study of 25 hotels
Evans, 2008) 5.6% glass, and 4.5% metals
(WRAP UK, 2012a,b) UK 2009e2010 41% food waste, 13% paper, 9% cardboard, 10% plastics, 14% glass, Study of 138 hospitality
and 13% other industry businesses
(Partt et al., 2013) UK 2012 37% food waste, 18% paper, 7% cardboard, 15% plastics, 10% glass, Study of 35 hotels
and 13% other

(Earle and Florida 1990e1991 Average rate of waste generation during the study ranged from Study of six properties
Townsend, 1991) 60.2 kg per room per month for the Comfort Inn to 99.9 kg per room
per month in the upscale Hilton at Walt Disney World Village
(Shanklin et al., 1991) Chicago 1991 Room waste/night 0.45 kg per room and 0.91 kg per suite on non- Study of one hotel
checkout days. These rates doubled on checkout days

(Majid, 2007) Malaysia 2006 71.73% organic waste [food wastes]; 5.77% paper; 8.06% cans; Study of 10 restaurants
5.07% plastics [bottles/bags]; 2.68% glass; 5.13% yard wastes; on the island
1.56% other
(VanWaning, 2010) Chicago 2009 60.3% organic waste; 19.6% paper; 6.7% plastics; 4.1% construction Sample of 20 outlets
& demolition waste; 6.2% glass; 1.8% metal; 0.8% textiles;
0.4% beverage containers; 0.1% inorganics

as favorable an alternative as being used to feed people, as (Smerecnik and Andersen, 2011). In terms of the perceived benets
emphasized by the food use hierarchy (European Union of green business practices from the perspective of a property
Committee, 2014). manager/owner, another study carried out in the USA (Nicholls and
There are many factors which affect how a certain property Kang, 2012) found that the most important benets were the
processes its waste and to what extent it implements recycling. improvement of the property's image, the improvement in the
These factors include the location of the property, the type of ma- relationship with the local community, an increase in customer
terials being recycled, and the availability of sorting/recycling satisfaction, the marketing advantage over competitors, increased
facilities in its locality. Once implemented, the success of a recycling protability, and the increase in employee satisfaction, in
program depends on factors such as the availability of buy-back descending order of importance. Yet another study involving 190
centers, waste management contractors' willingness to partici- Vietnamese hotel managers found that innovation characteristics
pate in recycling programs, and effective employee education and external environment characteristics such as observability
programs (Shanklin and Hackes, 2001). The adoption of environ- and perceived competition, respectively, had a greater effect on the
mental practices by a hotel also depends on factors such as the adoption of environmental practices by hotel managers. In contrast,
hotel size, age, the chain it belongs to, and stakeholder pressure characteristics such as the size of the hotel and its location weakly

(Alvarez Gil et al., 2001). For example, the Radisson SAS hotels have inuenced the adoption of environmental practices (Le et al., 2006).
reported an average of 3.1 kg of unsorted waste/guest-night chain- In addition, with respect to how hotel executives rate the impor-
wide. This is much greater than the chain-wide average for Scandic tance of different issues when it comes to implementing a solid
Hotels (located in Sweden, Denmark, Finland, Norway, Germany, waste program, a study carried out in the United States found that,
the Netherlands, Belgium and Poland), which reported an average among several factors, waste disposal fees was the most important
of 0.515 kg of unsorted waste/guest-night (Bohdanowicz, 2006). factor. This was followed by a positive public image and then leg-
In addition, a study of 52 hotels in Ghana found that larger prop- islative restrictions. The least important factors were corporate
erties with higher stars ratings were found to implement policy and guest/community demands (Shanklin et al., 1991).
environmentally-friendly strategies to a greater extent than smaller Moreover, though sustainable practices are becoming more and
properties (Mensah, 2006). more popular, changes in policy and regulation, followed by proper
Another study investigated the policies at eight properties in enforcement and monitoring, are still seen as the most effective
Mexico, four of which were owned by Mexicans and four by ways to bring about measurable change throughout an entire
Americans. The managers of these hotels answered surveys country (Ball and Abou Taleb, 2010). As an example, restaurateurs
through which it was found that the American-owned hotels had in Japan have urged the state to be more proactive if they would like
implemented more environmental strategies, such as those related to see the restaurants implement ecofriendly practices in a more
to waste management, earlier than the Mexican-owned hotels. The effective manner (Kasim and Ismail, 2012).
hotels owned by Mexicans seemed to have put such environmental
policies into practice mainly in response to legal pressure (Revilla 4.1. Waste minimization in the hospitality industry
et al., 2001). A study which looked into the implementation of
environmental sustainability innovations in 49 hotels and ski re- When one thinks of waste management, terms such as recycling
sorts in North America found that simpler innovations were more and waste-to-energy are often remembered. However, it is the
often implemented and persuasive property managers were found waste management hierarchy which helps hotel and restaurant
to have the greatest effect on the implementation of such in- administrations make decisions in terms of which waste manage-
novations. Other signicant factors were the perceived relative ment strategies should be employed under different situations. It is
benets of the innovation and the hotel's general innovativeness not wise to consider only one option such as recycling to solve a
324 S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

property's waste management problems. Rigidly set recycling tar- waste service provider offers and at what cost. A waste audit must
gets may not lead to the environmental advantages expected. For also be carried out by the establishment at regular intervals, in
example, to recycle a particular material, the hotel may have to addition to the daily waste generation statistics it keeps a record of.
send it very far, and this would actually lead to a carbon footprint It is the results of such audits which enable the hotel/restaurant to
much greater than the savings from the actual recycling. It is actually calculate the cost of different waste treatment options.
therefore recommended that when using tools to decide on waste The process outlined in Fig. 1 integrates green purchasing as one
management options, each situation should be assessed individu- of its steps. Green purchasing (also referred to as purchasing with
ally by the hospitality property administration from the environ- Eco-Intelligence (Cummings, 1997)) is dened as the purchase of
mental, social and nancial perspectives (Chertow, 2000). products and services that have a lesser or reduced effect on human
The waste management hierarchy is only one step of the waste health and the environment when compared with competing
management process pursued in the hospitality industry. Fig. 1 products and services that serve the same purpose (Remolador,
shows a proposed version of this waste management process. We 2011). Green purchasing can be applied in the hospitality sector
compiled this gure after consulting various literature, primarily for products such as ofce supplies and cleaning products. Using
Radwan et al. (2010, 2012). As is evident, various factors such as such green products also tends to lead to a smaller amount of waste
prevalent legislative and economic constraints affect the decisions generation due to the fact that they are not as packaging-intensive
made by the hospitality property management when it comes to and the packaging that they do have is recyclable. For example, in
how they should deal with their waste. For effective waste man- the case of most types of paper, it is advisable to buy products with
agement, the establishment must have a good relationship with its a minimum of 20% post-consumer content (Snarr and Pezza, 2000).
waste services provider, and what waste treatment operations the Yet another notable feature of the process described in Fig. 1 is the
property decides to have on site, if any, depend on what facilities its fact that it clearly makes it compulsory for the hotel/restaurant staff

Fig. 1. SWM practices model for the hospitality sector [based on the work of Radwan et al., 2012, 2010].
S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336 325

Table 4
Global studies on waste reduction in the hospitality industry.

Reference Country Initiative/Impact Conditions of the study/Comments

(Shanklin United States Practices implemented most frequently included collapsing cardboard boxes Study of 13 hotel corporations and
et al., 1991) (55.6%), sorting waste (46.7%), crushing glass and aluminum (55.6%), and baling 32 individual properties
paper and cardboard (28.9%). The materials being recycled most frequently
included computer and ofce paper (61.1%), aluminum cans (55.6%), glass
(33.3%), cardboard (27.8%), newspaper print (11.1%), and grease and fat (11.1%).
Other materials being recycled included magazines, guest soap, steel and
overhead transparencies.
(Cummings, United The resort's recycling efforts helped it divert an estimated 401 tons of materials Study of a mega-resort in
1997) States from the local landll during 10 months. The resort permits employees to take Las Vegas.
home the empty plastic buckets in which the pastry shop receives cream
toppings and its cooperation with a local creamery has resulted in the reuse of
hundreds of plastic ice cream tubs each month. The resort also has impact
printing ribbons re-inked and laser printer cartridges re-lled.
(Knowles et al., United Over 90% of respondents said that they had taken action to reduce their effect on Study of 150 London hotels
1999) Kingdom the environment. 64% of the sample claimed that they were taking steps that
were intended to reduce consumption of resources. About 50% said they were
exploiting reusable items. 67% of the sample had taken action to recycle
materials; 64% cited recycled glass, 42% paper and 25% metal. Recycling of
cardboard and plastics was reported by 19% of respondents.
(Trung and Vietnam About 60% of the surveyed hotels indicated that their food waste is sold to local Survey of 50 hotels
Kumar, collectors as animal feed, while about 10e30% of solid waste is sold to local
2005) collectors for recycling. The recyclable dry solid wastes (plastic bottles, paper,
carton boxes, and cans), which account for 10e30% of total waste, are sold to
local scrap collectors for recycling. Common good practices observed in the
surveyed hotels included avoiding unnecessary photocopying, using double-
sided copying, reusing carton boxes for storage purposes, reusing remaining
toilet paper rolls and soaps from guest rooms for internal use, relling used laser
printers cartridges and shampoo bottles, purchasing products (e.g. shampoo,
soft-drink) in bulk, and checking the quantity of food products still available
before issuing a purchase requisition.
(Bohdanowicz, Sweden and In Sweden 80% of hotels and in Poland 30.6% of hotels had an active waste 349 hoteliers participated in an
2006) Poland sorting and recycling program. Other waste minimization strategies included email-based survey
donation of hotel furniture and equipment (60% for Sweden, 50.8% for Poland),
reusable food and detergent packaging (61.8% for Sweden, 50% for Poland), and
donation of leftover, good quality food (17.3% for Sweden, 32.3% for Poland).
(Szuchnicki, United States The Grille Zone has reduced their total waste per day to half of a 55-gallon This is a certied green casual
2009) trashcan whereas a restaurant of similar size, without recycling procedure dining restaurant located in Boston.
would produce 10e12 bags of garbage per day.
(McAdams Canada A compost program was created to help divert organic material from landll. Study associated with
and Massow, 2013) The restaurant eliminated the use of drinking straws in the restaurant in order the restaurant at the University
to reduce its use of petroleum based plastics. of Guelph's School of Hospitality
& Tourism Management

to be trained about the property's waste management strategy. using clear plastic garbage bags so that the waste type may be
Indeed, a green waste management strategy cannot be executed effectively identied, including information in each room about the
without the cooperation of the staff, and so they must be trained property's waste reduction policies, using less packaging in the
accordingly. breakfast buffet by serving yoghurt and jam in dishes and butter in
small portions on plates, collecting unused toiletries from guest
4.2. Initiatives for waste reduction in the hospitality industry with accommodation to be used by staff (Repak, 2011), replacing bottled
global examples water with ltered water, and using modular mattresses so that the
hotel would only have to replace the mattress tops (Ruben, 2011).
Table 4 presents a compilation of studies carried out in different Moreover, waste can be decreased by using better designed prod-
parts of the world on the subject of waste reduction in the hospi- ucts. This could be facilitated as a result of partnerships between
tality industry. All of the references cited in Table 4 are scholarly hospitality service providers and product manufacturers (Nicholls
publications which have been listed in chronological order. The last and Nystuen, 1993). Along with the input of the end user, such
two studies are specically concerning restaurants, while the rest of partnerships can help the manufacturers develop their products
the studies were conducted on hotels. Almost all of the studies cited and design them in more ecofriendly ways, making it a winewin
the implementation of waste reduction strategies in the form of situation for all parties involved. In the following subsections, we
segregating waste and recycling. discuss the waste reduction initiatives by continent.
Yet other strategies mentioned in the table are waste volume
reducing strategies such as collapsing cardboard boxes, crushing 4.2.1. Europe
glass and aluminum, and baling paper and cardboard; making use Waste management policy and legislation is quite advanced in
of reusable items; donation of hotel furniture and equipment; Europe as a result of the efforts of the European Union. The Waste
printing/copying double-sided; donating leftover food or selling it Framework Directive requires waste management, as per the waste
to be used as animal feed or turning it into compost; purchasing hierarchy, to rst focus on waste prevention and then on reuse and
goods in bulk; and eliminating the use of drinking straws in the recycling or other recovery, through composting or waste-to-
restaurants. Other strategies not mentioned in the table include energy processes. What is more, the Landll Directive requires EU
color-coding bins for easy training of staff and clear segregation, member states to divert biodegradable waste from landlls. It is
326 S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

also required that recyclable materials are collected separately (Estes, 2000). Similarly, The Hotel at Kirkwood Center, located in
(Owen et al., 2013). Cedar Rapids, Iowa, United States, has been able to divert over 45
The United Kingdom is quite ahead when it comes to waste tons of food waste as a result of a program which the management
management and a signicant factor contributing to this is WRAP put into place in May 2012. The program was the result of an audit
(Waste & Resources Action Programme). WRAP UK aims to achieve conducted at the hotel which showed that about 80% of the hotel's
a circular economy by working with various businesses, individuals trash could be diverted from the landll through composting (Iowa
and communities. This not-for-prot rm helps its clients to reduce Waste Reduction Center (IWRC), 2013).
waste, develop sustainable products and use resources efciently. According to a 2011 article on the adoption of environmental
The company also publishes statistics related to the hospitality initiatives in the lodging sector of Michigan, USA, the academic
sector in the UK. Its 2011 study found that in the area of on-site focus on the greening of the accommodation sector appears to be
treatment of waste, the most common technology used by hospi- especially lacking in the US (Nicholls and Kang, 2012). What our
tality establishments in the UK was the macerator, which is an in- study has shown so far, however, does not seem to corroborate this
sink grinder that enables food waste to be ushed away to the opinion. Though the academic focus on waste management in the
sewer (Kelly, 2011), though even this was only used by 7% of hospitality sector in the United States could benet from more
businesses. The next most common technologies were balers (4%), studies, relatively speaking, quite a few US studies on this subject
compactors (2%) and glass crushers (1%) (Kelly, 2011). All of these can be found in literature, as compared to other parts of the world
technologies help reduce the volume of the waste, which helps the such as Africa and Australia.
businesses by potentially reducing the amount they need to spend As shown by the study mentioned in Table 4 which was con-
on waste disposal. It also helps ensure maximum return on re- ducted at a Las Vegas resort, waste management programs, when
cyclables and raises the number of vendors willing to accept the carried out properly, have the potential to divert hundreds of tons
materials (Estes, 2000). The 2011 WRAP UK study also found that a of waste from landlls and even save properties thousands of
number of UK businesses actually claimed having policies in place dollars every month in disposal fees. With respect to the Las Vegas
which addressed waste minimization. These policies were most case, this is the result of the mega-resort's modest recycling pro-
commonly in the form of an informal commitment to reducing gram, which consisted of a recycling compactor for clean paper,
waste (27%), followed by an environmental policy statement (25%), paperboard, and metal, and a small bin for clear glass alongside
supplier take back programs (11%), targets for recycling (3%), and general purpose dumpsters (Cummings, 1997). Therefore, if a
nally a waste management strategy (3%) (Kelly, 2011). Therefore, more extensive waste management process was being carried out,
relatively speaking, the UK has been able to achieve quite a bit it can be assumed that the benets for both the resort and the
where waste management for the hospitality industry is concerned. environment would be much greater.
Indeed, as part of a study which screened 42 hotels in London,
Knowles et al. (1999) found out that 94% of the hotels indicated 4.2.3. Asia
implementing some ecofriendly strategies. Nevertheless, the actual When discussing literature related to waste management for the
adoption of these strategies was noticeably lower; for example, hospitality sector in Asia, Vietnam stands out as a good example. In
only 67% of the respondent hotels recycled their waste (Nicholls a span of just two years, two studies were published on this subject,
and Kang, 2012). by two independent groups. One of these studies is mentioned in
The study mentioned in Table 4 which was carried out in Swe- Table 4. Though the data presented in the study has been collected
den and Poland shows the great attention given to waste sorting as a result of only interviews and approximations made by the hotel
and recycling in Sweden, which reects the importance of this issue staff, such studies show a heightened awareness of green practices
for the Scandinavian countries, in general. In contrast, the lower in the country and are denitely a step in the right direction. Green
popularity of waste sorting in Poland could be the result of the practices by the Vietnamese hotels, in addition to the ones similar
shortage of sorting facilities in some parts of that country to those in hotels in other parts the world, include displaying signs
(Bohdanowicz, 2006). in the bathrooms of some 4- and 3-star hotels and resorts, urging
guests to conserve water. Also, some hotels are purchasing more
4.2.2. North America ecofriendly non-CFC refrigerators (Trung and Kumar, 2005).
There are a number of publications which shed light on the state Regarding other parts of Asia, it has been reported that food
of waste management for the hospitality sector in North America. wastage in Hong Kong's restaurants and hotels has more than
For instance, the thesis Examining the Inuence of Restaurant Green doubled in recent years (Mackenzie et al., 2011). In addition, a study
Practices on Customer Return Intention mentions how the Grille conducted at a small-scale Indonesian restaurant in Singapore
Zone, a sustainability-certied restaurant in Boston, has decreased showed how the recyclable waste generated by the restaurant was
its total waste to half of a 55-gallon garbage can per day. This is of an insignicant amount and that sorting of the restaurant's
much less than the 10e12 55-gallon garbage bags per day which waste by the restaurant staff on site would not be economically
would be generated by a similar restaurant that doesn't practice viable. The study consequently expressed a need for the munici-
waste sorting and recycling (Nicholls, 2008; Szuchnicki, 2009). pality to get more involved so that waste from multiple venues
With regards to hotels, a report by the Environmental Protection could be collected at one location and subsequently be sorted and
Agency (EPA) of the United States describes waste reduction tips for recycled so that economies of scale may be benetted from (Bay
hotels and casinos in Indian Country (tribally-owned properties). It et al., 2009).
has the example of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians of North
Carolina casino and restaurants which compost approximately 4.3. Waste mapping
544 kg of food waste per day. The compost is distributed to sites
where it can be used for growing plants and vegetation both on and Waste mapping is a relatively new strategy which is being
off the reservation. Yet another example is the Foxwoods Resort increasingly used by organizations to facilitate more effective waste
and Casino in Connecticut which uses dewatering equipment to management. It helps the establishments understand where and
remove water from its waste, and, as of 2000, was planning to how waste occurs, and how much it is really costing them (WRAP
establish two materials recovery facilities on site which would UK, 2013a,b). With respect to the hospitality sector, waste mapping
process both the resort's waste and waste from surrounding areas involves monitoring waste generation at a property in terms of
S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336 327

which types of waste are generated, in what amounts, and in which cost (Envirowise, 2009). With regards to the hospitality sector in
locations. A waste map is subsequently created to reect this data. particular, though examples of waste mapping have been cited
The property can subsequently plan its waste management oper- (Owen et al., 2013), it is difcult to nd any documents which
ations in a more efcient manner. report the precise impacts of having implemented waste mapping.
Fig. 2 shows an example of a waste map for a part of a typical This is to be expected as a result of the fact that this is a relatively
hotel property. The colored boxes show which types of waste are new trend in the area of waste management. Food waste mapping
being generated in various locations, as explained in the map key. can also specically be used to reduce the waste generated by a
The waste mapping process, in terms of how the map can be used property. The data collected as part of the food waste mapping
once generated, is explained in more detail in Fig. 3. Areas where process would account for the spoilage, preparation waste, over-
the maximum amounts of waste are generated may be focused on produced food, and plate scrapings associated with each meal/
in order to make the most signicant difference in the amount of mealtime (Owen et al., 2013).
waste sent to the landll by the hotel. The inputs refer to the
products and goods entering into the system at that particular 5. Food waste management in the hospitality industry
location in the hotel while the outputs refer to the factors which
contribute to waste generation at that particular location as well. By Food waste is reported to account for about 56% of the garbage
analyzing the inputs and outputs, the ow of resources can be from restaurants and 28% of the garbage from hotels (Iowa Waste
comprehended and any hidden costs associated with the waste can Reduction Center (IWRC), 2013). These values clearly show how
be identied and calculated. This would make possible the identi- signicant food waste is as a component of the waste stream of the
cation of strategies which may be employed to achieve both hospitality sector. Therefore, no ecofriendly waste management
nancial and environmental benets. Once these benets have solution for the hospitality sector can be complete without some
been quantied, they may be arranged in order of priority and then policy and/or action plan related to food waste.
integrated into the hotel's future waste management strategy It is known that of all the different types of waste, food waste is
accordingly. Through waste mapping, opportunities for collabora- one of the most important materials to divert from landlls due to
tion between different sections of the hotel which produce similar the fact that it decomposes to create methane, a potent green-
waste can also be highlighted. house gas which signicantly contributes to climate change
Waste mapping for all types or organizations is gaining popu- (United States Environmental Protection Agency, 2012). As an
larity around the world, from places such as India (Green Yatra example, it is estimated that if food scraps were removed from
NGO, 2014) to South Australia (Blue Environment Pty Ltd and landlls in the UK, the level of greenhouse gas abatement achieved
Tonkin Consulting, 2012) and Finland (Pa iva
rinta et al., 2004). would be equivalent to that resulting from removing off the roads
Various publications are available online which have outlined the one-fth of all the cars in the UK (Gunders, 2012). Minimizing food
benets of waste mapping and how it may be implemented (Cox, waste has economic benets as well. For instance, if the United
2002; WRAP UK, 2013a,b). It is reported that with waste map- Kingdom hospitality sector reduces its food waste by only 5% by
ping, an organization can usually be expected to reduce expenses the end of 2015, this can save the sector a total of 250 million over
by an amount equivalent to at least 1% of its turnover at little or no two years (Partt et al., 2013). From an ethical angle, food waste is

Fig. 2. A waste map for a part of a typical hotel (reproduced with permission from the Cyprus Sustainable Tourism Initiative; (Owen et al., 2013)).
328 S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

Fig. 3. The waste mapping procedure [based on the work of Owen et al., 2013].

a component of MSW that it is especially important to prevent UK hospitality and food service sector is equivalent to 1.3 billion
since so many people die of starvation every year. According to the meals (Partt et al., 2013).
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), as Quite a bit of research has been done on food losses in the global
of September 2010, 925 million people did not have access to food supply but not in the global food demand (Bender, 1994). Post-
sufcient food resources, a number greater than the population of harvest losses need to be considered more carefully. An exception is
many countries such as the USA and Canada (United Nations plate waste in food service institutions which tends to be more
World Food Programme, 2012). thoroughly examined than any other type of food loss; though in
As with other types of waste, wasting food also implies the this case, studies are mainly motivated by nutritional concerns
wastage of the resources used to create the food products in the m and Carlsson-Kanyama, 2004).
(Engstro
rst place. The Water-Food-Energy Nexus implies how water, food
and energy security are all interlinked (Wales, 2011). For instance, 5.1. Quantication of food waste in the hospitality industry
food waste now accounts for more than one quarter of the total
global freshwater consumption and approximately 300 million Various studies have accounted for the composition of food waste
barrels of oil per year (Hall et al., 2009). in the hospitality sector in terms of how much is preparation waste,
Much data can be found which accounts for the huge amounts of plate waste, etc. Other studies have mentioned formulae/estimations
food waste which is lost each year. For example, it is estimated that which give an indication of the scale of food waste generated in the
30e50% (or 1.2e2 billion tons) of all food produced around the hospitality sector. Some examples of these gures are:
world is lost before reaching a human stomach (Institution of
Mechanical Engineers, 2013). Moreover, of the 600,000 tons of - In Sweden, plate waste is the single largest source of loss, be-
food waste disposed of in the UK in 2009, two-thirds could have tween 11% and 13% of the amount of food served at food service
been eaten if the food had been better portioned, managed, stored m and Carlsson-Kanyama, 2004).
institutions (Engstro
and/or prepared (WRAP UK, 2012a,b). With regards to the United - In UK restaurants, 65% of food waste comes from preparation e
States, approximately 41 billion kg of food were lost by consumers peelings, off cuts and anything ruined while cooking; 30% of
and food services in 1995. This was 26% of all edible food available food waste comes back from customers' plates; 5% of food waste
for human consumption in the country during that year (Sarjahani is classied as spoilage e out-of-date or unusable items
et al., 2009). With respect to the hospitality sector in particular, (Sustainable Restaurant Association, 2010)
citing the example of the UK, 920,000 tons of food is wasted at - UK hospitality and food service sector: on average, 21% of food
hospitality sector outlets in the UK annually, 75% of which is waste arises from spoilage; 45% from food preparation and 34%
avoidable. What is more, the amount of food wasted annually in the from consumer plates (Partt et al., 2013).
S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336 329

- According to a Swiss report, a typical food portion weighing reasons are poor stock rotation, inappropriate storage of stock, over
300 g and served in the hotel industry can lead to a maximum of preparation, poor preparation, and inadequate portion control
835 g of waste material, 780 g preparation waste and 55 g upon techniques (Mackenzie et al., 2011). In addition, it follows that more
disposal (i.e. what remains of the portion after the guest has expansive foodservice operations mean greater waste, although in
eaten and is therefore disposed of) (Zein et al., 2008). such cases, the waste per meal tends to go down. There is also a
- In Finland, it was found that restaurants belonging to the relationship between the quality of the food served and the waste
catering sector discarded 19% of all produced and served food. Of generated. Fine dining outlets would serve smaller portions of high
this 6% was kitchen waste, 5% was service waste, and 7% was quality food, reducing food waste. At the same time, such outlets
leftovers. It was therefore concluded that food waste in licensed tend to cook dishes from scratch, leading to much more preparation
restaurants in Finland amounts to approximately 18e20 million waste on their premises (as compared to when food is procured half
kg annually (Silvennoinen et al., 2012). prepared, etc.).
- The National Solid Waste Management Association reported Yet another determinant of the amount of food waste in a
that, in the United States, cafeterias generate 0.45 kg of waste hospitality establishment is the frequency of delivery of ingredients
per meal served; and restaurants generate 0.68 kg per meal to the hotel/restaurant. More frequent deliveries mean smaller in-
served (Shanklin, 1993). ventories and less wastage due to spoilage. However, this leads to
- In the UK, an average of 0.48 kg of food waste is generated per greater costs for the property and so oftentimes the establishments
guest at a restaurant (Sustainable Restaurant Association, 2010). may have to choose buying in bulk despite the risk of greater waste.
- In the United States, restaurants produce an average of In addition, many high-end hospitality properties pride them-
45,360 kg of waste per outlet per year (Horovitz and USA Today, selves on the food variety they provide to their guests. More serving
2008; Jeong, 2010) dishes tend to lead to more waste. Moreover, this experimentation
- For resorts/conference properties: food waste (kg/yr) [in Mas- with new recipes may lead to more waste being generated in the
sachusetts and Connecticut, USA] 0.45 kg/meal*number of kitchen (throwing cooked food away directly as it did not turn out
meals/seat/day*number of seats*365 days/yr (Draper/Lennon, as good as expected). The control of portion sizes is also a very
Inc and Atlantic Geoscience Corp., 2001; Draper/Lennon, Inc, substantial factor. Hotels and restaurants must ensure that their
2002) serving sizes are big enough to please the customer, while not so
- For restaurants: Food waste (kg/year) [in Massachusetts and large that they cannot be nished and waste is generated. Of course,
Connecticut, USA] number of employees*1360.78 kg/ appetites vary from one person to another and so cooking the right
employee/yr (Draper/Lennon, Inc and Atlantic Geoscience Corp., amount in such a way that all guests are pleased is virtually
2001; Draper/Lennon, Inc, 2002) impossible.
Other factors which greatly contribute to the production of food
These various food waste formulae/estimations/calculators give waste in the hospitality sector include the style of food service and
an indication of the large variety of reported values for these the inaccurate forecasting of consumer demand. For instance, the a
different quantities. For example, plate waste due to spoilage varies la carte style of service is known to generate less waste than the
from 5 to 21%, though studies carried out at food service in- buffet style of service (Hackes et al., 1997). In terms of consumer
stitutions have shown that plate waste has the potential of being demand, while the establishments try to be as accurate as possible
eliminated almost completely (Engstro m and Carlsson-Kanyama, in their demand forecasts to avoid over-spending on ingredients,
2004). These variations are not only due to the different places not having enough food to fulll customer demand is not a risk
where, and times when, these studies have been carried out but most establishments are willing to take and so they prefer cooking
also may be due to varying denitions of what these categories an extra percentage of food to be safe. In the case of the number of
refer to exactly. Nevertheless these gures make the signicance of guests being greater than that expected, kitchen staff may have to
food waste in the hospitality industry clear. It is interesting that the cook dishes at the last minute, and this would also lead to food
nal equation in the above list relates the food waste generated to waste generation, occasionally more than that which would have
the number of employees at the restaurant though it is the guests been generated if the correct number of customers had been
who are the ones who actually generate more of the waste. Also, the cooked for in the rst place. Achieving the right balance is far from
equation relates the food waste amount to the number of em- straightforward (Mackenzie et al., 2011). This in turn depends on
ployees in general and not just the kitchen staff (as may be other aspects such as knowledge of past guest numbers and pre-
considered a natural consequence of the signicant proportion of dictability of the guest numbers. Predicting how much to cook can
preparation food waste). It can be inferred in such a situation that be done using computerized tools, although many chefs prefer to
the use of the number of employees as a variable provides more just rely on their own experience. However, it is not unusual for
reliability to the formula since this is a number which is more stable circumstances to change suddenly at the last minute rendering
in the sense that it does not change from one meal to another, while cooking quantities rather inaccurate (Mackenzie et al., 2011).
the number of guests at each meal does. Moreover, since the
quantity being calculated is being estimated over an extended 5.3. Food waste minimization strategies in the hospitality sector
period of time (i.e. on a yearly basis), considering a variable such as
the number of employees helps make the calculations less complex Hospitality establishments' administrations have increasingly
(if the number of guests was being used instead, the average become more and more aware of the need to reduce their food
number of guests during the year may need to be calculated rst, waste, not only from the environmental perspective, but also due to
etc.). the cost savings this can yield for their establishments.
Fig. 4 shows the general foodservice process followed in most
5.2. Causes of food waste generation in the hospitality industry hotels and restaurants, as compiled by us using various sources
(Amjadi and Hussain, 2005; National Food Service Management
Before strategies which minimize food waste generation in the Institute and United States Food and Nutrition Service, 2002).
hospitality sector can be discussed, it is important to shed some This diagram also points out the stages of the foodservice process
light on the reasons why so much food waste is generated in the where various groups of people (hotel/restaurant administrative
rst place and what factors affect this generation. Amongst these staff, hotel/restaurant food and beverage operations staff, or guests)
330 S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

may take action in order to reduce food waste. In the context of this reports oftentimes by government agencies, encouraging hospi-
gure, hotel/restaurant administrative staff basically refers to tality sector establishments to reduce their food waste and showing
more executive members of the kitchen staff such as the executive them how this is possible. Some examples are Creedon et al. (2010)
chef, etc. This gure provides hotel policy designers with an idea of and Integrated Waste Management Board (IWMB) (2001). How-
which groups of people can take steps to make a most signicant ever, Table 5 focuses on studies which quantied the impact of the
difference in the property's waste generation. To be most effective, proposed strategy. Menu engineering along with activity-based
this scheme can be used along with the waste map of a property to costing seem to be very effective at reducing food waste, so it
devise the most effective food waste minimization strategy. For seems that awareness about these tools needs to be increased.
instance, if a waste map reveals that much food waste is being Indeed, activity-based costing has been shown to be a very
generated in the area of the hotel where the ingredients are stored, powerful tool (Vaughn et al., 2010) that can even be used for the
this is an indication that ingredients are getting spoiled before use, buffet style of service (Raab and Mayer, 2007). When combined
which means that hotel/restaurant administrative staff must be with menu engineering, activity-based costing enables food prep-
engaged to revise their food-ordering strategy so that less waste is aration to become more predictable, making overproduction less
produced. likely (Boonyakiat, 2012). With regards to food waste tracking, the
A collection of strategies to minimize food waste generation in company mentioned in the table, LeanPath, is a US rm. The UK
hospitality establishments is summarized in Table 5. These strate- also has a company which provides similar services: Trim Trax
gies address food waste in terms of both source reduction (Compass Group UK & Ireland, 2012).
(e.g. menu engineering and activity-based costing) and post- Reducing plate size has also been shown to help decrease food
generation waste management (e.g. anaerobic digestion). There waste, though, if multiple plates are available for the guests to use,
are more references in the literature than those mentioned in this strategy may not cause the full improvement which it could
Table 5, which discuss food waste reduction strategies for the potentially achieve. In buffet-type restaurants, posting signs telling
hospitality sector. These references are usually in the form of guests that they can help themselves to the buffet more than once

Fig. 4. The foodservice process (compiled using Amjadi and Hussain, 2005; National Food Service Management Institute and United States Food and Nutrition Service, 2002).
S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336 331

can also lead to a decrease in food waste, since guests don't feel a cases, according to the manager, there is very close collaboration
need to overll their plates. Strategies such as ning guests for between the hotel administration and the program coordinators.
wasting food are usually not looked upon favorably by the hospi- Under this program, RCS staff go to hotels to collect and later
tality industry, and in the rare cases they are implemented, it is distribute leftover food whenever there is an event (e.g. wedding)
usually due to special reasons, including limitations on landll where a signicant amount of edible food leftovers is expected.
space available in the city/country, as is the case in Hong Kong Another remedy, anaerobic digestion, is quite a well-known
(Hong Kong Environment Bureau, 2013). Instead, some strategies strategy. But in this case, implementation tends to be done on a
are more successful in making a difference via targeting social large scale, and so the waste being generated must be sufcient to
norms which lead to food wastage. For instance, in the UK, asking nancially justify the procurement and operation of the digester.
the restaurant staff for doggy bags to pack up one's leftovers is not What is more, in places where the cost of natural gas is already
viewed positively socially. Therefore, a strategy has been imple- low, anaerobic digestion does not make economic sense that
mented in several UK restaurants which would have the restaurant easily. Another bio-treatment alternative, composting, is increas-
staff themselves take the initiative to give the doggy bag to the ingly gaining importance around the world, especially for hotels
customers if they notice much food left on their plates with extensive landscaping such as golf resorts, etc., since these
(Vijayaraghavan, 2011). hotels can use the compost for their own gardening needs (Wang,
The act of donating leftover food in hospitality establishments 2012).
can get somewhat complex as a result of considering how long the Other strategies to minimize food waste in the hospitality sector
food has been left outside. Hence, a tradeoff exists between can be implemented, besides those mentioned in Table 5. These
donating the extra food to feed someone (consequently avoiding include checking deliveries to ensure that food is free from con-
food waste) versus the risk of individuals getting sick from this taminants, packaging is not damaged, and perishable food has a
donated food and the establishment reputation being negatively sufciently long expiry date; sourcing ingredients locally where
affected as a consequence. Nevertheless, various organizations possible; ensuring that the rst-in-rst-out approach is applied for
around the world are engaging in collecting untouched leftover the ingredients inventory; storing all fruits and vegetables in wire
food from hospitality establishments and distributing that food crates to allow for air circulation; avoiding over trimming during
directly to individuals in need. Some examples, mentioned in preparation; and minimizing the quantity of bread and starters
Table S1, are the Annakshetra Foundation in India and the Hifth portions provided prior to the meal. In buffet-type restaurants,
an Ne'mah Program which is operated by the Red Crescent Society several strategies can also be implemented, such as serving the
(RCS) of the United Arab Emirates. We interviewed the manager of food in smaller dishes and replenishing them more often; freezing
the Hifth an Ne'mah Program and he informed us that this program food in portion sizes appropriate for later use; planning menus that
has successfully been in operation for the last 10 years. In many use food approaching its expiration date (Zeenny, 2013); rotating

Table 5
Global food waste reduction strategies for the hospitality sector (already implemented by hotels/restaurants).

Initiative Country Implementation details References


and impact

Menu Engineering Thailand Waste decreased by 45% during (Boonyakiat, 2012)


Activity-Based Costing the time period of the study.
Food waste tracking US (LeanPath) Helped customers cut food waste (LeanPath, 2013)
system by 80%
Changing from buffet to United Arab Emirates Implemented by a hotel and a Interviews by
a la carte service noticeable decrease in food waste the authors.
was the result.
Reducing plate size and Norway Reduced the amount of food waste (Kallbekken and
providing social cues in hotel restaurants by around 20%. Slen, 2013)
Decreasing portion sizes United States This study is the rst to show portion (Brochado and
size can be lowered 33% before it's noticed, Freedman, 2009)
and that reducing portion size reduces
overall plate waste.
Introducing a sign pointing Norway Reduces food waste by 20.5%. (Kallbekken and
out that guests can help Slen, 2013;
themselves more than once Sloan et al., 2009)
Fining guests for wasting food Hong Kong, Canada, The amount of waste reduced by nes (Blume, 2009)
at all-you-can-eat buffets Australia, Philippines is small, however.
Offering guests doggy boxes UK (Too Good To Waste) The initiative could cut down the amount of (Vijayaraghavan, 2011)
(more details in Table S2) food waste by at least 20% in every participating restaurant
Donate food (more detailed United Arab Emirates; The food can be given directly to charities (e.g. (Food and Agriculture
initiatives in Table S2) Germany, Austria, Hifth an Ne'mah which delivered z175,000 meals in Organization of
Switzerland 2012) or to foodsavers who pick up excess food from the United Nations (FAO)
restaurants and take them to organizations that support and Food Wastage
people in need (e.g. Through Foodsharing.de more than Footprint (Project), 2013;
30,000 people have shared 25,000 kg of food) Foodsharing e.V., 2013)
Anaerobic digestion UK This can be offsite (e.g. Cawleys Eco-eating which prevents (Cawleys, 2013;
the emissions of 905 kg of carbon per ton of food waste and Kenning, 2014)
feeds the biogas back into the national grid and the fertilizer
byproduct can be spread on the land to grow new crops) or on site
(e.g. Best Western Chilworth Manor Hotel where the digester
produces an average of 105 m3 of biogas per day, providing
approximately 57 MW of electricity annually).
Composting US From the start of the program in May of 2012, (Iowa Waste Reduction
the hotel has diverted over 45 tons of compostable food waste Center (IWRC), 2013)
332 S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

perishable stock at every delivery and cleaning coolers and freezers which launched the initiatives as well as the scope and impacts of
regularly to minimize wastage due to ingredients getting spoiled those initiatives. Some of the initiatives are specically for the
(Christensen, 2013). hospitality sector and others are addressing food waste in general,
Another factor of signicance where food waste generation is and so food waste within the hospitality industry is also included in
concerned is the types of guests who are being served. If data can be their scope of reach. This is not an exhaustive list; we have
collected concerning food waste generation trends when certain endeavored to include a variety of initiatives from all over the world
types of guests are in the majority (such as those belonging to a which are well-known, have had the greatest impacts, or are
particular profession), then this data can be analyzed and used for innovative in nature. The United Kingdom and the United States
more efcient planning when such guests visit the venue once have the greatest numbers of such initiates. It is clear that a wide
again (Go ssling et al., 2011). Similarly, for example, if it is known variety of establishments has gotten involved in the quest to
that the guests at the hotel during a certain season will be families decrease food waste whether they are governments or non-
with young children then the menu during this time can be government organizations (NGO) or even private individuals who
designed accordingly, as opposed to if the guests were going to be are looking to make a prot from the implementation of green
mostly sports players, etc. Simpler strategies such as keeping the technology. Many of the initiatives have been put into practice
skins on vegetables and reusing edible food items (e.g. using non- recently and so there is a lack of data regarding their success. The
served extra bakery items to make desserts) can also have a number and diversity of these initiatives is obviously indicative of a
noticeable impact on the amount of food waste generated heightened level of awareness regarding food waste management
(Sustainable Restaurant Association, 2010). in the hospitality sector.
A basic strategy which needs to be followed before any effective
food waste reduction can take place is waste monitoring. This 6. Ecolabeling in the hospitality industry
monitoring may be as simple as visual checks to as complex as
measuring the quantity of each type of food group which is thrown There are currently more than 100 ecolabeling systems world-
away. An example of how waste monitoring can make a difference wide which exclusively target the hospitality/tourism sectors, in
is presented by the Intel Company. The company's corporate cafe- addition to more general labels which can also be used for prop-
terias decreased their pre-consumer food waste by 47% as a result erties belonging to the hospitality sector. These ecolabels address
of the implementation of a waste monitoring system (Neary, 2010). the various aspects of the environmental management activities
It is also very important to address legislation in this area, since which should be taking place at an establishment, including waste
many a time hotels/restaurants do have great ideas concerning management. These labels can also be either global in their scope
what they can do to decrease the food waste they generate, but they (Table S2) or specic to a particular region or country (Table S3). For
are reluctant to implement these ideas since this could put them at example, more than 60 ecolabels exist in Europe alone. In terms of
a disadvantage relative to competing properties which do not the popularity of ecolabels, a study conducted in the UK found the
implement such measures. As a result, if there is a policy which level of awareness by hotel personnel of local green initiatives and
addresses these strategies, all properties would have to put them ecolabeling to be higher than that of international initiatives (Leslie,
into practice. Europe, in general, and the Nordic countries, in 2007).
particular, seems to be quite proactive where such legislation is Ecolabels are largely voluntary schemes which can be very
concerned. The Nordic Council of Ministers (2011) has a waste expensive for a property to acquire and, depending on what part of
prevention group which initiated a project on the prevention of the world the property is located in, have varying marketing power
food waste in the retail and wholesale sectors. In addition, 2014 has which is generally quite limited. After all, how much importance a
been declared the European Year against Food Waste (Bennett, tourist gives to environmental issues is highly dependent on where
2012) (more details can be found in Table S1). Moreover, a 2009 they are from. For instance, it has been reported that in the US
report recommended the following policies to the EU Commission alone, 43 million people consider themselves to be eco-tourists,
to be implemented in member states (Monier, 2010): who are willing to pay an 8.5% extra on average for environmen-
tally-friendly hospitality outlets (Cummings, 1997). However, this is
- Introducing food waste reporting requirements and a stan- not the case for tourists from many other places. As a result, hotels
dardization of methodologies for food waste calculation. also shape their environmental policies accordingly; putting more
- Standardization of food expiry date labels. green policies into place if they expect to have more guests for
- Establishing food waste prevention targets for each state. whom environmental issues take priority.
- Recommendation of collecting food waste/biodegradable waste As a result of having so many different certications to choose
from households and the food service sector separately. from, one would expect a property to go for the certication which
is the least demanding and/or expensive, although in such cases it
As an example, Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden have may be expected that the label does not have much value. The
already put into practice some regulative instruments. For example, Green Globe 21 and ISO 14001 certications both overcame these
in Sweden there is a proposed national food waste prevention issues and are gradually becoming more and more popular (Sloan
target and in Denmark there is a charter which can be voluntarily et al., 2009). This is clear from the numbers presented in
adopted by establishments as an indication of their commitment to Table S2. Most of the ecolabels mentioned in both Tables S1 and S2
food waste prevention (Marthinsen et al., 2012). Nevertheless, it were established during the 1990s. The ISO 14001 certication has
must be mentioned here that current laws are mostly concerned been awarded the most but it must be remembered that this is a
with food safety. Such laws have the potential of both supporting certication for environmental management, in general, and not
and hindering food waste reduction strategies (Marthinsen et al., only for establishments belonging to the hospitality sector. Some of
2012). the national ecolabels, such as those for Italy and Germany, have a
Table S1 shows an extensive list of different organizations and large number of certied entities. This is usually because they
companies around the world which have implemented various certify not only hotels but also tend to certify tourism operators,
strategies to target food waste. Many of the organizations tourist attractions, different lodging types, etc. On the global level,
mentioned in Table S1 employ one or more of the strategies specically with respect to the hospitality sector, the Green Key-
mentioned in Table 5. Table S1 accounts for the establishments related ecolabels seem to be the most advanced with the largest
S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336 333

numbers of certied entities. Green Key is supported by the World Cummings, 1990), and making their guests comfortable would
Tourism Organization and the UNEP (United Nations Environment have the highest priority.
Program) and is presently the largest global ecolabel for accom- As is clear from Tables S1 and S2, environmental management is
modation with a national administration center in each partici- increasingly becoming a standard part of policy in the hospitality
pating country (Losanwe, 2013). On the other hand, the Green sector. However, it is mainly the larger establishments which have
Globe certication seems to be ahead in terms of its geographic been implementing environmental management practices since
reach, with certied establishments in 74 countries. The Green smaller properties do not always have the nancial means or
Globe program was developed on the basis of Agenda 21 for the administrative structure to make it possible (Mowforth and Munt,
Travel and Tourism Industry: Toward Environmentally Sustainable 2008). Various studies have shown the managers of small proper-
Development, which was released in 1995 (Gordon, 2007). Agenda ties as being less interested in carrying out environmental man-
21's action plan specied that tourism operations be revised in agement, in general, and waste management, in particular, on their
many different areas including waste minimization, reuse, and premises. This is due to many different reasons such as the fact that
recycling. they are generating small quantities of waste which many waste
Finally, the Certied Green Restaurant must be mentioned as carriers are not interested in (Maclaren and Yu, 1997). Smaller es-
the only ecolabel in Tables S1 and S2 which is strictly applicable tablishments may also not have access to the relevant information
to restaurants. It is only active in the United States and Canada so and guidelines or may not have the time or motivation to imple-
far, but with no real competitor on the global scale it seems likely ment ecofriendly practices (Horobin and Long, 1996). This lack of
that it would expand its certication operations to other coun- motivation is due to issues such as managers feeling that the waste
tries very soon. With so many ecolabels, it is essential that quantities their properties generate are not signicant enough to
tourists and hotel guests be aware of greenwash which is a term make viable their spending of time and money on practices such as
used to describe efforts corporations use to portray themselves sorting and recycling, and feeling that it was more the re-
as environmentally responsible in order to mask environmental sponsibility of larger properties to implement environmental
wrongdoings (Sloan et al., 2009). It is interesting to mention management practices. Another study revealed that small-sized
that a study examining differences in the implementation of hospitality establishments' managers felt that more tools need to
green practices between properties in Germany with and without be provided to them by the local governments to assist them in the
environmental accreditation found that the difference in levels of implementation of different waste management options such as
implementation between the two groups was relatively minimal recycling. It was also felt that not enough support was provided by
(Chen et al., 2005). external stakeholders (Dewhurst and Thomas, 2003). Though it is
With regards to waste management in particular, many of the true that each small property does not generate a lot of waste,
different ecolabels mentioned earlier tend to have similar criteria relative to larger ones; collectively all these small properties
in terms of requiring the sorting of waste, recycling of waste generate very large amounts of waste and a large proportion of this
where possible, purchasing in bulk, avoiding the use of dispos- waste ends up in landlls. In fact, solid waste generation is
ables, etc. The Nordic Swan ecolabel is quite strict in this regard, considered to be one of the most disadvantageous environmental
limiting unsorted waste generation to 0.5e1.5 kg/guest-night effects caused by small hotels (International Hotel Environmental
(Bohdanowicz, 2006). Hotels certied by the EcoLabel Initiative, 2002). In order to address this issue, small hotels in
Luxembourg should sort waste into 8 fractions (Le  ge
re Hotel close proximity to one another may work together to achieve
Luxembourg, 2014). On the other hand, the European Ecolabel sustainable waste management targets. Composting is also a good
species that waste separation by guests must be facilitated option for small hotels to use for their organic waste since it can
(Zhang, 2010), while the Green Key Eco-Rating program requires easily be done on a small scale and the compost would be of use to
that food scraps and other organic waste be diverted from the the hotel for its gardens (Radwan et al., 2010). On the other hand,
regular waste stream and composted (Myers, 2011). Finally, the while it is more difcult for small hotels to conduct an overall
Green Seal, for its bronze certication, species that the default recycling program, it is interesting to note that these smaller
setting for copying should be double-sided and that the property properties are more likely to segregate and recycle the waste from
should donate leftover food to a local shelter or food bank where the guest rooms. This may be due to the fact that in large properties
programs are available and where permitted by local regulatory there is more waste generated collectively in the guest rooms and
agencies (Petruzzi, 2011). segregating all of it can become a tedious task (Nicholls and Kang,
2012).
7. Challenges facing waste management in the hospitality Yet another study which examined the challenges associated
industry with sustainable waste management has looked into the reasons
why hospitality sector staff in Hawaii were not recycling food. The
The aforementioned sections of this paper have presented the staff cited issues such as: segregating the waste and subcontracting
current status of waste management in the global hospitality waste operations to a separate food waste recycling company takes
sector along with real-world examples of how the sector is too much time and is expensive; storage, transportation, and
becoming more sustainable while giving recommendations which logistical problems; health and sanitation problems; liability is-
would make this possible as well. It is important to mention, sues; not generating enough food waste; being unaware that food
however, that implementing such green strategies is not neces- could be recycled; or not being allowed to recycle food waste
sarily a straightforward process. In some countries there are still (Okazaki et al., 2008). Yet another barrier to food reuse is the
no sufcient regulations to support such ecofriendly initiatives physical food characteristics and ensuring that the food complies
and, even if a supportive framework exists, implementing the with food safety regulations. This limits what can be done with
different strategies may not be judged to be in the best interest of leftover food obtained at the end of a meal, event, etc.
the property, either from a nancial, marketing, or social Indeed, change is easier said than done. The previous sections of
perspective, etc. For instance, a hotel may be aware of the fact that this paper have accounted for many initiatives being implemented
their guests, though concerned about the environment, are in the United States in the area of food waste reduction. Never-
accustomed to disposable toiletries (which usually carry more theless, as per 2013 statistics, only 3% of food waste in the United
waste) due to their convenience and functionality (Cummings and States was diverted from incinerators and landlls for use in
334 S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

composting (Iowa Waste Reduction Center (IWRC), 2013) leaving us Bay, D., Zhong, C.Y., Ting, G.X., He, H.W., Min, L.S., Ong, L., Boon, P.P., Wei, Q.J., Qin, S.T.S.,
Lip, T.K., Yue, Y., 2009. A Study into the Solid Waste Management in Restaurants
with an example of how much more work needs to be done in this
(CV4553 Solid Waste Management e Course Project Report). School of Civil &
area. Environmental Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore.
Bender, W.H., 1994. An end use analysis of global food requirements. Food Policy 19,
381e395.
8. Conclusion Bennett, A., 2012. 2014: The Year Against Food Waste [WWW Document]. The
Responsibility Project. http://responsibility-project.libertymutual.com/blog/
This study reviewed the literature currently available on solid 2014-the-year-against-food-waste (accessed 02.03.14.).
Berman, S.D., 2014. Hospitality Directions US: Our Updated Lodging Outlook
waste management in the hospitality sector. In general, there are [WWW Document]. Price Waterhouse Coopers. http://www.pwc.com/en_US/
not many scholarly publications on this area of research, with many us/asset-management/hospitality-leisure/publications/assets/pwc-hospitality-
references being in the form of practical reports published by directions-lodging-outlook.pdf (accessed 11.03.14.).
Blue Environment Pty Ltd, Tonkin Consulting, 2012. Regional Organic Waste Map-
different organizations. This paper focused on the for-prot ping in South Australia [WWW Document]. Zero Waste SA. http://www.
segment of the hospitality sector, comprising primarily of hotels zerowaste.sa.gov.au/upload/resource-centre/publications/compost/Regional%
and restaurants. The characterization and quantication of solid 20organic%20waste%20mapping%20in%20South%20Australia.pdf (accessed
17.04.14.).
waste in the hospitality sector was discussed and it was clear from Blume, C., 2009. Hong Kong Struggles to Cut Food Waste [WWW Document]. Voice
the studies mentioned that food waste is the most signicant of America. http://www.voanews.com/content/a-13-2007-05-08-voa11-
component of hospitality waste, being approximately 40% of the 66714397/560009.html (accessed 02.10.13.).
Bohdanowicz, P., 2005. European hoteliers' environmental attitudes: greening the
waste from hotels and 60% of the waste from restaurants. As a business. Cornell Hotel Restaur. Adm. Q. 46, 188e204. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/
result, various global organizations, initiatives, and legislations 0010880404273891.
targeting waste food reduction in the hospitality industry have Bohdanowicz, P., 2006. Environmental awareness and initiatives in the Swedish and
Polish hotel industriesdsurvey results. Int. J. Hosp. Manag. 25, 662e682. http://
been summarized in this paper. The majority of such initiatives is
dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhm.2005.06.006.
being implemented in Europe and the United States. These initia- Boonyakiat, K., 2012. Using the Buffet Monitoring Tool to Reduce Waste and Food
tives are mentioned along with general solid waste minimization Run-Out. Silpakorn University International College, Universite  de Perpignan
strategies which have been implemented in various parts of the Via Domitia.
Brochado, C.S., Freedman, M.R., 2009. Does reducing portion size reduce food intake
world. One such strategy is waste mapping which is a relatively and plate waste? J. Am. Diet. Assoc. 109, A47. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
new approach to waste management but has the potential to help j.jada.2009.06.139.
signicantly decrease the waste generated in the hospitality sector. Cambridge Dictionaries Online, 2014. Hospitality Industry Noun e Denition in the
Business English Dictionary [WWW Document]. http://dictionary.cambridge.
The waste mapping process is therefore described in detail in this org/dictionary/business-english/hospitality-industry (accessed 09.03.14.).
study along with the waste hierarchy which must be considered as Cawleys, 2013. Cawleys e Food Waste Recycling & Disposal [WWW Document].
part of the rst step of any environmentally sustainable waste http://www.cawleys.co.uk/recycling/ad_composting.php (accessed 02.10.13.).
Chen, J.S., Legrand, W., Sloan, P., 2005. Environmental performance analysis of
management policy. German hotels. Tourism Rev. Int. 9, 61e68. http://dx.doi.org/10.3727/
In this review, we have also shown how waste management in 154427205774791799.
the hospitality industry has improved considerably in the past 15 Chertow, M.R., 2000. Industrial symbiosis: literature and taxonomy. Annu. Rev.
Energy Environ. 25, 313e337. http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/
years. There is much more awareness and as a result, there are annurev.energy.25.1.313.
many more initiatives and ecolabels which address this matter. The Christensen, K., 2013. Information Sheet e Cutting Costs Through Waste Prevention
sustainability of the hospitality sector depends upon the managers [WWW Document]. WRAP, UK. http://www.wrap.org.uk/sites/les/wrap/
Information%20sheet.pdf (accessed 24.02.14.).
of the various establishments which make up this sector. They must
Compass Group UK & Ireland, 2012. Eliminating Kitchen Waste Case Study [WWW
be interested in the implementation of a triple bottom line Document]. WRAP, UK. http://www.wrap.org.uk/content/compass-group-uk-
approach and they must support it as well. Indeed, it must be a ireland-eliminating-kitchen-waste (accessed 25.02.14.).
fundamental part of their management strategy if sustainable Cox, P., 2002. Waste Mapping. University College Northampton.
Creedon, M., Cunningham, D., Hogan, J., 2010. Less Food Waste More Prot: A Guide
waste management is to be achieved. Swedish best practice has to Minimising Food Waste in the Catering Sector. Clean Technology Centre, Cork
shown that efcient waste management can reduce the quantity of Institute of Technology, Ireland.
unsorted waste per guest-night to only 50 g. This is much smaller Cummings, L.E., 1997. Waste minimisation supporting urban tourism sustainability:
a mega-resort case study. J. Sustain. Tour. 5, 93e108. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/
than current values of waste generated, as mentioned in this paper. 09669589708667279.
This gives an idea of how much room for improvement there is. Cummings, L.E., Cummings, W.T., 1990. Foodservice and solid waste policies: a view
in three dimensions. J. Hosp. Tourism Res. 14, 163e172. http://dx.doi.org/
10.1177/109634809001400218.
Appendix A. Supplementary data Curry, R., 2012. The Composition of Waste Disposed of by the UK Hospitality In-
dustry (No. RES093-001). Waste and Resources Action Programme (WRAP),
United Kingdom.
Supplementary data related to this article can be found at http:// Dewhurst, H., Thomas, R., 2003. Encouraging sustainable business practices in a
dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2014.07.038. non-regulatory environment: a case study of small tourism rms in a UK Na-
tional Park. J. Sustain. Tour. 11, 383e403. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/
09669580308667212.
References Draper/Lennon, Inc, Atlantic Geoscience Corp., 2001. Identifying, Quantifying, and
Mapping Food Residuals from Connecticut Businesses and Institutions: Final
Alexander, S., 2002. Green Hotels: Opportunities and Resources for Success [WWW Report. Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection.
Document]. Zero Waste Alliance. http://www.zerowaste.org/publications/ Draper/Lennon, Inc, 2002. Identication, Characterization, and Mapping of Food
GREEN_HO.PDF (accessed 03.10.13.). Waste and Food Waste Generators in Massachusetts: Final Report. Massachu-

Alvarez nez, J., Ce
Gil, M.J., Burgos Jime spedes Lorente, J.J., 2001. An analysis of setts Department of Environmental Protection.
environmental management, organizational context and performance of Earle, J.F.K., Townsend, J.M., 1991. Florida's Pilot Hotel/Motel Recycling Project e
Spanish hotels. Omega 29, 457e471. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0305-0483(01) Final Report. Central Florida Hotel and Motel Association, Gainesville, FL.
00033-0. Engstro m, R., Carlsson-Kanyama, A., 2004. Food losses in food service institutions
American Hotel & Lodging Association (AH&LA), 2014. History of Lodging [WWW examples from Sweden. Food Policy 29, 203e213. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
Document]. http://www.ahla.com/content.aspx?id4072 (accessed 11.03.14.). j.foodpol.2004.03.004.
Amjadi, K., Hussain, K., 2005. Integrating food hygiene into quantity food produc- Envirowise, 2009. Waste Mapping: Your Route to More Prot [WWW Document].
tion systems. Nutr. Food Sci. 35, 169e183. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/ http://www.enviroeu.com/online/le.php/1/eng-docs/EnviroWise_-_Waste_
00346650510594921. Mapping_Your_Route_To_More_Prot.pdf (accessed 17.04.14).
Axler, B.H., 1973. Sanitation, Safety, and Maintenance Management. Bobbs-Merrill, Estes, L., 2000. Waste Reduction Tips for Hotels and Casinos in Indian Country
Indianapolis. [WWW Document]. United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
Ball, S., Abou Taleb, M., 2010. Benchmarking waste disposal in the Egyptian hotel http://tribalp2.org/waste-reduction-tips-for-hotels-and-casinos-in-indian-
industry. Tourism Hosp. Res. 11, 1e18. http://dx.doi.org/10.1057/thr.2010.16. country (accessed 14.02.14.).
S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336 335

European Union Committee, 2014. Counting the Cost of Food Waste: EU Food Waste ge
Le re Hotel Luxembourg, 2014. EcoLabel [WWW Document]. http://www.legere-
Prevention (10th Report of Session 2013e14). Authority of the House of Lords, hotels-online.com/en/ecolabel-legere-hotel-luxembourg (accessed 08.03.14.).
London. Leslie, D., 2007. The missing component in the greening of tourism: the envi-
Evans, T., 2008. The Study of Environmental Awareness and Waste Minimization ronmental performance of the self-catering accommodation sector. Int. J. Hosp.
Approaches for Hotel Management in Belize. National Central University, Manag. 26, 310e322. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhm.2006.10.008.
Taiwan. Losanwe, I., 2013. Environmentally Friendly Luxury Hotel-Case: Grand Palace Hotel.
Fishbin, M., 2014. Global Hospitality Insights: Top Thoughts for 2014 [WWW Lahti University of Applied Sciences, Riga, Latvia.
Document]. Ernst & Young Global Limited. http://www.ey.com/Publication/ Louis, G.E., 2004. A historical context of municipal solid waste management in the
vwLUAssets/Top_thoughts_for_2013/$FILE/Top_thoughts_for_2013.pdf United States. Waste Manag. Res. 22, 306e322. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/
(accessed 11.03.14.). 0734242X04045425.
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), Food Wastage Mackenzie, M., Cheung, C., Law, R., 2011. The response of hotels to increasing food
Footprint (Project), 2013. Toolkit Reducing the Food Wastage Footprint. FAO, costs due to food shortages. Asia Pac. J. Tourism Res. 16, 395e416. http://
Rome. dx.doi.org/10.1080/10941665.2011.588869.
Foodsharing e.V, 2013. Online Platform Marks a Fruitful Year of Food Sharing Maclaren, V.W., Yu, C.C., 1997. Soiled waste recycling behavior of industrial-
[WWW Document]. Think, Eat, Save Reduce Your Footprint Campaign. http:// commercial-institutional establishments. Growth Change 28, 93e109. http://
www.thinkeatsave.org/index.php/multimedia/in-the-news/79-in-the-news/ dx.doi.org/10.1111/1468-2257.00051.
291-online-platform-marks-a-fruitful-year-of-food-sharing (accessed Majid, M.R., 2007. Sustainable solid waste management for island resorts: potential
02.03.14.). for Perhentian Island, Terengganu. In: Presented at the 1st International Con-
Gordon, K., 2007. Evaluation of Tools for Sustainability Assessment in Tourism. M.S.. ference on Built Environment in Developing Countries (ICBEDC 2007), Pulau
Oklahoma State University, Oklahoma, United States. Pinang, Malaysia.
Go ssling, S., Garrod, B., Aall, C., Hille, J., Peeters, P., 2011. Food management in Marthinsen, J., Kaysen, O., Kirkevaag, K., 2012. Prevention of Food Waste in Res-
tourism: reducing tourism's carbon foodprint. Tourism Manage. 32, 534e543. taurants, Hotels, Canteens and Catering. Nordic Council of Ministers, Copen-
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2010.04.006. hagen, Denmark.
Green Yatra NGO, 2014. Systematic Waste Management (SWM) [WWW Docu- McAdams, B., Massow, M. von, 2013. Enhancing students' learning in sustainable
ment]. http://greenyatra.org/Blog/plantatree/index.php?pswm (accessed practices by incorporating a triple bottom line approach in a restaurant oper-
17.04.14.). ations course. In: Presented at the 3rd International Conference on Tourism and
Gunders, D., 2012. Wasted: How America is Losing Up to 40 Percent of Its Food Hospitality Management, Athens, Greece.
from Farm to Fork to Landll [WWW Document]. Natural Resources De- MeetMiddleEast, 2013. Middle East: Gulf Cooperation Council Hotel Revenue Boom
fense Council. http://www.nrdc.org/food/les/wasted-food-IP.pdf (accessed Predicted by 2016 [WWW Document]. International Meetings Review. http://
19.01.13.). www.internationalmeetingsreview.com/middle-east-and-north-africa/middle-
Hackes, B.L., Shanklin, C.W., Kim, T., Su, A.Y., 1997. Tray service generates more food east-gulf-cooperation-council-hotel-revenue-boom-predicted-2016- (accessed
waste in dining areas of a continuing-care retirement community. J. Am. Diet. 10.03.14.).
Assoc. 97, 879e882. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0002-8223(97)00213-7. Mensah, I., 2006. Environmental management practices among hotels in the greater
Hall, K.D., Guo, J., Dore, M., Chow, C.C., 2009. The progressive increase of food waste Accra region. Int. J. Hosp. Manag. 25, 414e431. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
in America and its environmental impact. PLoS ONE 4, e7940. http://dx.doi.org/ j.ijhm.2005.02.003.
10.1371/journal.pone.0007940. Milburn, R., Hall, L., 2014. Room to Grow: European Cities Hotel Forecast for 2014
Hong Kong Environment Bureau, 2013. Hong Kong Blueprint for Sustainable Use of and 2015. 18 Gateway Cities, Amsterdam to Zurich [WWW Document]. Price
Resources 2013e2022 [WWW Document]. http://www.enb.gov.hk/sites/ Waterhouse Coopers. http://www.pwc.com/en_GX/gx/hospitality-leisure/pdf/
default/les/WastePlan-E.pdf (accessed 17.04.14.). pwc-european-cities-hotel-forecast-2014-and-2015.pdf (accessed 11.03.14.).
Hoornweg, D., Bhada-Tata, P., 2012. What A Waste: A Global Review of Solid Waste Monier, V., 2010. Preparatory Study on Food Waste Across EU 27. European Com-
Management. World Bank, Washington, DC, USA. mission, France.
Horobin, H., Long, J., 1996. Sustainable tourism: the role of the small rm. Int. J. Mowforth, M., Munt, I., 2008. Tourism and Sustainability: Development and New
Contemp. Hosp. Manage. 8, 15e19. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/ Tourism in the Third World, 3rd ed. Routledge, London.
09596119610126103. Myers, 2011. Green Key Self-Assessment Overview [WWW Document]. Green Key
Horovitz, B., USA Today, 2008. Can restaurants go green, earn green? [WWW Global. http://p2ric.org/business/pdfs/Green%20Key%20Self-Assessment.pdf
Document]. ABC News. http://abcnews.go.com/Business/story? (accessed 08.03.14.).
id4867994&page1 (accessed 17.04.14.). Myung, E., McClaren, A., Li, L., 2012. Environmentally related research in scholarly
Institution of Mechanical Engineers, 2013. Global Food: Waste Not, Want Not. hospitality journals: current status and future opportunities. Int. J. Hosp.
Institution of Mechanical Engineers, London. Manag. 31, 1264e1275. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhm.2012.03.006.
Integrated Waste Management Board (IWMB), 2001. Restaurant Guide To Waste National Food Service Management Institute, United States Food and Nutrition
Reduction And Recycling [WWW Document]. Calif. Environ. Prot. Agency. Service, 2002. A Guide to Centralized Foodservice Systems. National Food Ser-
http://www.calrecycle.ca.gov/Publications/Documents/BizWaste%5C44198016. vice Management Institute.
pdf (accessed 26.06.14.). Neary, M., 2010. Food Waste Prevention Case Study: Intel Corporation's Cafes
International Hotel Environmental Initiative IHEI, 2002. Hotels Care: Community [WWW Document]. City of Hillsboro and Oregon Department of Environmental
Action and Responsibility for the Environment. IHEI, London, UK. Quality. http://www.leanpath.com/docs/FoodWastePrevention_DEQ.pdf
Iowa Waste Reduction Center (IWRC), 2013. The Hotel at Kirkwood Center [WWW (accessed 19.03.14.).
Document]. http://iwrc.org/services/food-waste/case-studies/hotel-at- Nicholls, W., 2008. A tall order of green [WWW Document]. The Washington Post.
kirkwood (accessed 15.02.14.). http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/01/15/
Jeong, E., 2010. Customers' Perception of Green Practices in Restaurants. M.S.. AR2008011500755.html (accessed 16.03.14.).
Purdue University, Indiana, United States. Nicholls, L.L., Nystuen, C.W., 1993. Future foodservice waste management. J. Hosp.
Kallbekken, S., Slen, H., 2013. Nudging hotel guests to reduce food waste as a Tourism Res. 17, 231e241. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/109634809301700119.
winewin environmental measure. Econ. Lett. 119, 325e327. http://dx.doi.org/ Nicholls, S., Kang, S., 2012. Going green: the adoption of environmental initiatives in
10.1016/j.econlet.2013.03.019. Michigan's lodging sector. J. Sustain. Tour. 20, 953e974. http://dx.doi.org/
Karak, T., Bhagat, R.M., Bhattacharyya, P., 2012. Municipal solid waste generation, 10.1080/09669582.2011.645577.
composition, and management: the world scenario. Crit. Rev. Environ. Sci. Nielsen, B., Green Restaurant Association, 2004. Dining Green: A Guide to Creating
Technol. 42, 1509e1630. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10643389.2011.569871. Environmentally Sustainable Restaurants and Kitchens. Green Restaurant
Kasim, A., Ismail, A., 2012. Environmentally friendly practices among restaurants: Association.
drivers and barriers to change. J. Sustainable Tour. 20, 551e570. http:// Nordic Council of Ministers, 2011. Initiatives on Prevention of Food Waste in
dx.doi.org/10.1080/09669582.2011.621540. the Retail and Wholesale Trades d Nordic Cooperation [WWW Document].
Kelly, J., 2011. The Composition of Waste Disposed of by the UK Hospitality Industry. http://www.norden.org/en/publications/publikationer/2011-548 (accessed
WRAP, UK. 02.10.13.).
Kenning, T., 2014. On-site AD Eliminates Hotel's Food Waste Collection Costs Okazaki, W.K., Turn, S.Q., Flachsbart, P.G., 2008. Characterization of food waste
[WWW Document]. http://www.mrw.co.uk/news/on-site-ad-eliminates- generators: a Hawaii case study. Waste Manag. 28, 2483e2494. http://
hotels-food-waste-collection-costs/8659261.article (accessed 02.03.14.). dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2008.01.016.
Kirk, D., 1995. Environmental management in hotels. Int. J. Contemp. Hosp. Manage. Owen, N., Widdowson, S., Shields, L., 2013. Waste Mapping Guidance for Hotels in
7, 3e8. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/09596119510095325. Cyprus: Saving Money and Improving the Environment [WWW Document].
Knowles, T., Macmillan, S., Palmer, J., Grabowski, P., Hashimoto, A., 1999. The The Travel Foundation; Cyprus Sustainable Tourism Initiative. http://media.
development of environmental initiatives in tourism: responses from the visitcyprus.com/media/b2b_en/News_Releases/Waste_Mapping_Guidance_
London hotel sector. Int. J. Tourism Res. 1, 255e265. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ Hotels.pdf (accessed 18.02.14.).
(SICI)1522-1970(199907/08)1:4<255::AID-JTR170>3.0.CO;2-8. iva
Pa rinta, K., Yla
-Mella, J., Pongr
acz, E., 2004. Waste mapping in a SME electronics
Le, Y., Hollenhorst, S., Harris, C., McLaughlin, W., Shook, S., 2006. Environmental manufacturer. In: Presented at the Waste minimization and Resources Use
management: a study of Vietnamese hotels. Ann. Tourism Res. 33, 545e567. Optimization Conference. University of Oulu, Finland.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.annals.2006.01.002. Partt, J., Barthel, M., Macnaughton, S., 2010. Food waste within food supply chains:
LeanPath, 2013. LeanPath Automated Food Waste Prevention Tracking Systems quantication and potential for change to 2050. Philos. Trans. Roy. Soc. B 365,
[WWW Document]. LeanPath. http://www.leanpath.com (accessed 03.10.13.). 3065e3081. http://dx.doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2010.0126.
336 S.I. Pirani, H.A. Arafat / Journal of Environmental Management 146 (2014) 320e336

Partt, J., Eatherley, D., Hawkins, R., Prowse, G., 2013. Waste in the UK Hospitality Szuchnicki, A.L., 2009. Examining the Inuence of Restaurant Green Practices on
and Food Service Sector (Technical Report No. HFS001-00 6). Waste and Re- Customer Return Intention. M.S.. University of Nevada, Las Vegas, Nevada,
sources Action Programme (WRAP), UK. United States.
Petruzzi, M., 2011. Green Seal Bronze Certication Checklist for Lodging Properties Todd, M., Hawkins, R., 2003. Waste Counts: A Handbook for Accommodation Op-
[WWW Document]. http://www.greenseal.org/GreenBusiness/Certication/ erators. Oxford Brookes University, United Kingdom.
Getcertied/CerticationChecklists.aspx (accessed 08.03.14.). Trung, D.N., Kumar, S., 2005. Resource use and waste management in Vietnam hotel
Raab, C., Mayer, K., 2007. Menu engineering and activity-based costing e can they industry. J. Clean. Prod. 13, 109e116. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
work together in a restaurant? Int. J. Contemp. Hosp. Manage. 19, 43e52. http:// j.jclepro.2003.12.014.
dx.doi.org/10.1108/09596110710724152. United Nations World Food Programme, 2012. FAQsjWFP e Fighting Hunger
Radwan, H.R.I., Jones, E., Minoli, D., 2010. Managing solid waste in small hotels. Worldwide [WWW Document]. http://www.wfp.org/hunger/faqs (accessed
J. Sustain. Tour. 18, 175e190. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09669580903373946. 27.01.11.).
Radwan, H.R.I., Jones, E., Minoli, D., 2012. Solid waste management in small hotels: a United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), 2012. Turning Food Waste
comparison of green and non-green small hotels in Wales. J. Sustain. Tour. 20, into Energy (EBMUD) [WWW Document]. http://www.epa.gov/region9/waste/
533e550. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09669582.2011.621539. features/foodtoenergy (accessed 19.01.13.).
Remolador, M.A., 2011. Guide to Greening Hotels Through Waste Management & VanWaning, A., 2010. Waste Characterization Study [WWW Document]. Chicago
Green Purchasing [WWW Document]. Northeast Recycling Council, Inc. (NERC). Department of Environment. http://www.cityofchicago.org/dam/city/depts/
http://nerc.org/documents/green_hotels_guide.pdf (accessed 24.02.14.). doe/general/RecyclingAndWasteMgmt_PDFs/WasteAndDiversionStudy/
Repak, 2011. Prevent & Save: Best Practice Guidelines in Waste Management: Waste WasteCharacterizationReport.pdf (accessed 18.03.14.).
Management for the Hospitality Industry [WWW Document]. http://www. Vaughn, P., Raab, C., Nelson, K.B., 2010. The application of activity-based costing to a
preventandsave.ie/documents/Best%20Practic/Waste%20Management%20for% support kitchen in a Las Vegas casino. Int. J. Contemp. Hosp. Manage. 22,
20Hotels.pdf (accessed 24.02.14.). 1033e1047. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/09596111011066662.
Revilla, G., Dodd, T.H., Hoover, L.C., 2001. Environmental tactics used by hotel Vijayaraghavan, A., 2011. London Chefs Campaign to Reduce Food Waste [WWW
companies in Mexico. Int. J. Hosp. Tourism Admin. 1, 111e127. http://dx.doi.org/ Document]. Triple Pundit: People, Planet, Prot. http://www.triplepundit.com/
10.1300/J149v01n03_07. 2011/10/london-too-good-to-waste (accessed 23.12.12.).
Ruben, D., 2011. Waste Management for Hotels and Restaurants [WWW Document]. Wagh, V., 2008. Management of Hotel Waste [WWW Document]. Maharashtra
http://www.ct.gov/deep/lib/deep/p2/business_industry/hospitality/ Economic Development Council. http://www.karmayog.com/cleanliness/
fall2011workshop/waste_management_for_hotels_and_restaurants.pdf hotelwaste.htm (accessed 29.01.13.).
(accessed 24.02.14.). Wales, A., 2011. What is the Water-Food-Energy Nexus? About the NEXUS [WWW
Sarjahani, A., Serrano, E.L., Johnson, R., 2009. Food and non-edible, compostable Document]. Water Energy Food Nexus. http://www.water-energy-food.org
waste in a university dining facility. J. Hunger Environ. Nutr. 4, 95e102. http:// (accessed 01.03.13.).
dx.doi.org/10.1080/19320240802706874. Wang, R., 2012. Investigations of important and effective effects of green practices
Schneider, F., 2013. Review of food waste prevention on an international level. in restaurants. Proc. Soc. Behav. Sci. 40, 94e98. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
Waste Resour. Manag. 166, 187e203. http://dx.doi.org/10.1680/warm.13.00016. j.sbspro.2012.03.166.
Shanklin, C.W., 1993. Ecology age: implications for the hospitality and tourism in- Winter, J.P., Azimi, S.L., 1996. Less Garbage Overnight: A Waste Prevention Guide for
dustry. J. Hosp. Tourism Res. 17, 219e229. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/ the Lodging Industry [WWW Document]. http://infohouse.p2ric.org/ref/03/
109634809301700118. 02129.pdf (accessed 02.03.14.).
Shanklin, C.W., Hackes, B.L., 2001. Position of the American Dietetic Association: WRAP UK, 2012a. The Composition of Waste Disposed of by the UK Hospitality
dietetics professionals can implement practices to conserve natural resources Industry [WWW Document]. http://www.wrap.org.uk/content/composition-
and protect the environment: (Previously Titled Natural resource conservation waste-disposed-uk-hospitality-industry-1 (accessed 29.01.13.).
and waste management). J. Am. Diet. Assoc. 101, 1221e1227. http://dx.doi.org/ WRAP UK, 2012b. Company Structure and Governance [WWW Document]. http://
10.1016/S0002-8223(01)00299-1. www.wrap.org.uk/content/governance-1 (accessed 02.03.14.).
Shanklin, C.W., Petrillose, M.J., Pettay, A., 1991. Solid waste management practices in WRAP UK, 2013a. Waste Mapping: Your Route to More Prot. WRAP, Oxon, UK.
selected hotel chains and individual properties. J. Hosp. Tourism Res. 15, 59e74. WRAP UK, 2013b. The Hospitality and Food Service Agreement [WWW Document].
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/109634809101500106. http://www.wrap.org.uk/content/hospitality-and-food-service-agreement-3
Silvennoinen, K., Katajajuuri, J.M., Hartikainen, H., Jalkanen, L., Koivupuro, H.K., (accessed 02.10.13.).
Reinikainen, A., 2012. Food waste volume and composition in the nnish supply WWF-UK, International Business Leaders Forum (IBLF), 2005. Why Environmental
chain: special focus on food service sector. In: Proceedings Venice 2012. Pre- Benchmarking will Help Your Hotel: A Guide Produced by the International
sented at the Fourth International Symposium on Energy from Biomass and Business Leaders Forum's Travel and Tourism Program and WWF-UK.
Waste. Cini Foundation, CISA Publisher, Venice, Italy. [WWW Document]. http://www.tourismpartnership.org/downloads/WWF%
Sloan, P., Legrand, W., Chen, J.S., 2009. Sustainability in the Hospitality Industry: 20Benchmarking.pdf (accessed 11.03.14.).
Principles of Sustainable Operations. Routledge. Zeenny, T., 2013. Rotana EARTH Sustainability Programs: Food Waste Program.
Smerecnik, K.R., Andersen, P.A., 2011. The diffusion of environmental sustainability Rotana Hotel Management Corporation, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates.
innovations in North American hotels and ski resorts. J. Sustain. Tour. 19, Zein, K., Wazner, M.S., Meylan, G., 2008. Best Environmental Practices for the Hotel
171e196. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09669582.2010.517316. Industry [WWW Document]. Sustainable Business Associates. http://www.sba-
Snarr, J., Pezza, K., 2000. Recycling Guidebook for the Hospitality and Restaurant int.ch/spec/sba/download/BGH/SBABGEHOTELLERIEENG2008.pdf (accessed
Industry [WWW Document]. The Metropolitan Council of Government (COG). 24.02.14.).
http://infohouse.p2ric.org/ref/05/04032.pdf (accessed 18.02.14.). Zhang, Y., 2010. The EU Ecolabel for Tourist Accommodations [WWW Document].
Sustainable Restaurant Association, 2010. Too Good to Waste: Restaurant Food http://ec.europa.eu/environment/ecolabel/documents/hotels.pdf (accessed
Waste Survey Report. Sustainable Restaurant Association, UK. 08.03.14.).

View publication stats

You might also like