Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Distribution Transformers
Webcast Presentation
Purpose
Explain how to use and apply the spreadsheet tools before the
public meeting
2
Webcast Protocol
Agenda
1 Rulemaking Overview
2 Product Classes
3 Engineering Analysis
4
Procedural Steps
Stakeholder Participation
Rulemaking Overview
Standards Rulemaking
Today
Stakeholder Participation
6
Rulemaking Overview
Market &
Markups for
Technology Engineering Equipment
Analysis Price
Screening
Determination
Analysis Life-Cycle
Cost and
Payback
Energy Use & Period Analyses
National
End Use Load
Impact
Characterization
Analysis
Shipments
Analysis
Rulemaking Overview
8
Rulemaking Overview Summary
Comments
1 Rulemaking Overview
2 Product Classes
3 Engineering Analysis
11
Transformer Characteristics
Type
Type Liquid-immersed
Liquid-immersedor
orDry-type
Dry-type
Phase
Phase Single
Singleor
orThree-phase
Three-phase
Voltage
Voltage Low
Lowor
orMedium
MediumVoltage
Voltage(Dry-type
(Dry-typeonly)
only)
BIL
BIL Basic
BasicImpulse
ImpulseInsulation
InsulationLevel
Level(Dry-type
(Dry-typeMV
MVonly)
only)
13
Transformer Characteristics
Liquid- Dry-Type
Immersed
1 2
Phase
Single Three
(LV / MV)
Voltage
3 4
Dry, LV Medium-Voltage Dry, LV Medium-Voltage
Single Three
5 7 9 6 8 10
Dry, MV Dry, MV Dry, MV Dry, MV Dry, MV Dry, MV
(kV)
BIL
In total there are 115 kVA ratings across the ten product classes
15
Agenda
1 Rulemaking Overview
2 Product Classes
3 Engineering Analysis
16
Engineering Analysis
Market &
Markups for
Technology Engineering Equipment
Analysis Price
Screening
Determination
Analysis Life-Cycle
Cost and
Payback
Energy Use & Period Analyses
National
End Use Load
Impact
Characterization
Analysis
Shipments
Analysis
17
Engineering Analysis
Price-Efficiency Curves
Price - Efficiency
Rulemaking Analyses
Relationship
Life-Cycle Cost
Manufacturers
Selling Price
(ANOPR Analysis)
Manufacturer Impact
(NOPR Analysis)
Employment Impact
(NOPR Analysis)
Product Efficiency
18
Engineering Analysis
19
Engineering Analysis
115 Ratings Start with 10 product classes and 115 discrete kVA ratings
20
Engineering Analysis
21
Engineering Analysis
Liquid-Immersed
Product Class to Design Line Mapping
22
Engineering Analysis
Dry-Type Low-Voltage
Product Class to Design Line Mapping
23
Engineering Analysis
Dry-Type Medium-Voltage
Product Class to Design Line Mapping
24
Engineering Analysis
TSD Chapter 5
Table 5.2.2 on page 5-4
25
Engineering Analysis
26
Engineering Analysis
27
Engineering Analysis
2800
SA1CuCu
2600 M2CuAl
M2CuCu
M3AlAl
2400
M3CuAl
M3CuCu
Manufacturer Price ($)
2200
M6AlAl
M6CuAl
2000
ZDMH(US)CuCu
1800
1600
1400
1200
1000
98.40% 98.60% 98.80% 99.00% 99.20% 99.40% 99.60% 99.80%
Transformer Efficiency at 50% Load
28
Agenda
1 Rulemaking Overview
2 Product Classes
3 Engineering Analysis
29
Market &
Markups for
Technology Engineering Equipment
Analysis Price
Screening
Determination
Analysis Life-Cycle
Cost and
Payback
Period Analyses
Energy Use & National
End Use Load Impact
Characterization Analysis
Shipments
Analysis
30
Life-cycle Cost (LCC) Analysis
31
LCC Results
32
LCC Analysis
33
LCC Analysis
http://www.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/commercial/
distribution_transformers_spreadsheets.html
34
Simplified LCC Spreadsheet Flowchart
Transformer Design
Calculate Markup and
and Cost from Installation Cost
Engineering Analysis
Results: LCC
Savings and Payback
35
Engineering Analysis
2800
SA1CuCu
M2CuAl
2600 M2CuCu
M3AlAl
2400 M3CuAl
M3CuCu
2200
M6AlAl
Manufacturer Price ($)
M6CuAl
ZDMH(US)CuCu
2000
1800
1600
1400
1200
1000
98.40% 98.60% 98.80% 99.00% 99.20% 99.40% 99.60% 99.80%
Transformer Efficiency at 50% Load
36
LCC Analysis
37
LCC Analysis
38
Simplified LCC Spreadsheet Flowchart
Transformer Design
and Cost from Select Transformer Design
Engineering Analysis
39
LCC Analysis
Electricity Cost
Liquid-immersed distribution transformers
40
LCC Analysis
Transformer Loading
References
41
Transformer Design
and Cost from Select Transformer Design
Engineering Analysis
42
LCC Analysis
Discount Rates
43
Transformer Design
and Cost from Select Transformer Design
Engineering Analysis
44
LCC Analysis
Customer Variation
45
LCC Analysis
.283
.141
.000 0
($1,000) ($500) $0 $500 $1,000
Certainty is 99.50% from $0 to +Infinity $
46
LCC Analysis
.046 456.7
.030 304.5
.015 152.2
.000 0
($1,000) ($500) $0 $500 $1,000
Certainty is 41.41% from $0 to +Infinity $
47
LCC Analysis
48
DL1 at 50% Load Example Design Selection
600
600
Non-compliant
500
500
400
400
(Watts)
Losses(Watts)
Load Losses
300
300
Load
200
200
100
100
Compliant
00
00 50
50 100
100 150
150 200
200 250
250 300
300
No-Load
No-Load Losses (Watts)
Losses (Watts)
Available Designs
Available Designs Selected Designs,
Available Designs Base
Selected Base Selected Designs,
Designs,Designs
Available Standard
Selected Selected
Designs, Designs,
Base Standard Level
Standard
49
Transformer Load Growth / Year Med (1%) No-load Losses @100% load 172.7 140.6
Load Losses @100% load 447.7 442.9
Transformer Loading (relative to current estimate) Med (0%) First Cost $1,500 $1,551 $51
Cost Minimization Data U.S. Only Payback Period (years) n/a 5.8
Transformer Lifetime (years) 32.0 32.0
Efficiency Standard Effective Date 2007
* Average A & B values for those customers that evaluate transformer losses during purchase.
** PWF is the Present Worth Factor of losses. The PWF is defined as the present value of loss
expenses divided by the rated losses. The PWF has units of $/watt.
50
Summary Sheet from Spreadsheet
Transformer Load Growth / Year Med (1%) No-load Losses @100% load 172.7 140.6
Load Losses @100% load 447.7 442.9
Transformer Loading (relative to current estimate) Med (0%) First Cost $1,500 $1,551 $51
Cost Minimization Data U.S. Only Payback Period (years) n/a 5.8
Transformer Lifetime (years) 32.0 32.0
Efficiency Standard Effective Date 2007
* Average A & B values for those customers that evaluate transformer losses during purchase.
** PWF is the Present Worth Factor of losses. The PWF is defined as the present value of loss
expenses divided by the rated losses. The PWF has units of $/watt.
51
Transformer Load Growth / Year Med (1%) No-load Losses @100% load 172.7 140.6
Load Losses @100% load 447.7 442.9
Transformer Loading (relative to current estimate) Med (0%) First Cost $1,500 $1,551 $51
Cost Minimization Data U.S. Only Payback Period (years) n/a 5.8
Transformer Lifetime (years) 32.0 32.0
Efficiency Standard Effective Date 2007
* Average A & B values for those customers that evaluate transformer losses during purchase.
** PWF is the Present Worth Factor of losses. The PWF is defined as the present value of loss
expenses divided by the rated losses. The PWF has units of $/watt.
52
Summary Sheet from Spreadsheet
Transformer Load Growth / Year Med (1%) No-load Losses @100% load 172.7 140.6
Load Losses @100% load 447.7 442.9
Transformer Loading (relative to current estimate) Med (0%) First Cost $1,500 $1,551 $51
Cost Minimization Data U.S. Only Payback Period (years) n/a 5.8
Transformer Lifetime (years) 32.0 32.0
Efficiency Standard Effective Date 2007
* Average A & B values for those customers that evaluate transformer losses during purchase.
** PWF is the Present Worth Factor of losses. The PWF is defined as the present value of loss
expenses divided by the rated losses. The PWF has units of $/watt.
53
Transformer Load Growth / Year Med (1%) No-load Losses @100% load 172.7 140.6
Load Losses @100% load 447.7 442.9
Transformer Loading (relative to current estimate) Med (0%) First Cost $1,500 $1,551 $51
Cost Minimization Data U.S. Only Payback Period (years) n/a 5.8
Transformer Lifetime (years) 32.0 32.0
Efficiency Standard Effective Date 2007
* Average A & B values for those customers that evaluate transformer losses during purchase.
** PWF is the Present Worth Factor of losses. The PWF is defined as the present value of loss
expenses divided by the rated losses. The PWF has units of $/watt.
54
Summary Sheet from Spreadsheet
Transformer Load Growth / Year Med (1%) No-load Losses @100% load 172.7 140.6
Load Losses @100% load 447.7 442.9
Transformer Loading (relative to current estimate) Med (0%) First Cost $1,500 $1,551 $51
Cost Minimization Data U.S. Only Payback Period (years) n/a 5.8
Transformer Lifetime (years) 32.0 32.0
Efficiency Standard Effective Date 2007
* Average A & B values for those customers that evaluate transformer losses during purchase.
** PWF is the Present Worth Factor of losses. The PWF is defined as the present value of loss
expenses divided by the rated losses. The PWF has units of $/watt.
55
56
Summary Sheet from Spreadsheet
57
Questions?
58
Agenda
1 Rulemaking Overview
2 Product Classes
3 Engineering Analysis
59
Rulemaking Overview
1 Market & 3 4
Markups for
Technology Engineering Equipment
2 Screening Analysis Price
Determination 6
Analysis Life-Cycle
Cost and
5 Payback
Period Analyses 8
Energy Use &
National
End Use Load
Impact
Characterization
7 Analysis
Shipments
Analysis
60
The Need for National Impact Analysis
Q. Why isnt the LCC the end of the economic analysis for the nation?
61
A. Specifically,
1. Transformers come in many sizes
2. Not all transformers are replaced at once
3. The energy consumed at the site is not the energy consumed
at the power plant
62
National Impact Analysis
Purpose
Estimate national energy savings (NES) (Quads primary)
Estimate national economic impacts (national NPV)
Method
Spreadsheet-based tool
Annual time series
National summations
Projected to the future
Purchases to 2035
Energy impact to 2035 (source)
Economic impact to 2070
63
http://www.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/commercial/
distribution_transformers_spreadsheets.html
64
National Energy Savings: Simplified Flowchart
Site-to-Source
Conversion
National Energy
Savings
65
LCC Transformer
Results Loading
Site-to-Source
Conversion
National Energy
Savings
67
Shipments Model
Affected Stock
68
Shipments Model: Simplified Flowchart
Input Data
2001 shipments
BEA quantity index Total Shipments
EIA Elec market share
69
140000 140000
2005 2005 2015 2015
120000 120000
Affected Stock: 0% Affected Stock: 20%
100000 100000
Capacity(MVA)
Capacity(MVA)
80000 80000
60000 60000
40000 40000
20000 20000
0 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
Age (years) Age (years)
140000 140000
2025 2025 2035 2035
120000 120000
Affected Stock: 60% Affected Stock: 90%
100000 100000
Capacity(MVA)
Capacity(MVA)
80000 80000
60000 60000
40000 40000
20000 20000
0 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
Age (years) Age (years)
70
Affected Stock Unaffected Stock
National Energy Savings: Simplified Flowchart
Site-to-Source
Conversion
National Energy
Savings
71
72
National Energy Savings: Simplified Flowchart
Site-to-Source
Conversion
National Energy
Savings
73
Site-to-Source Conversion
Energy consumed at the site does not equal energy at the power
plant
Conversion losses
74
National Energy Savings: Simplified Flowchart
Site-to-Source
Conversion
National Energy
Savings
75
LCC Transformer
Results Loading
Product class-specific
77
LCC Transformer
Results Loading
79
Discount Rate
National average
OMB Mandated 3%
80
National Net Present Value: Simplified Flowchart
LCC Transformer
Results Loading
NES Spreadsheet
82
NES Spreadsheet
83
NES Spreadsheet
84
NES Spreadsheet
85
NES Spreadsheet
86
National Impact Analysis
Questions?
87
Contact Information
Navigant Consulting
88