Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Global Perspectives
20 October 2017
Terrorism is arguably a greater threat than ever before. In recent years, it has claimed
markedly more lives compared to a few decades ago. Opinions vary on whether there is a
correlation between refugees (particularly middle-eastern) being admitted and the number and
intensity of terror attacks. Some analysts even believe that more restrictive immigration laws has
led to an increase in terror attacks. Others argue that admittance of refugees is a positive event
for a country.
The National Review warns that the refugee program in America is a clear and present
danger that is practically an invitation for radicals to enter with ease. We must reevaluate our
policy regarding refugee resettlement to protect the safety, freedom, and liberty we value as
American citizens. Our current program is a Trojan horse allowing ISIS and other terrorist
groups an open invitation to immigrate into the U.S. and establish bases of operation legally and
at taxpayer expense, warns Brian Babin, a United States Representative and advocate for reform
of the American refugee program. Babin has introduced legislation to stop what he calls the
presidents reckless plan to bring in tens of thousands of refugees from Syria and other radical
Islamic hotspots. Babin goes on to cite FBI director James Comey. President Obamas own
FBI director has warned that he cannot properly screen refugees coming from troubled terrorist
hotspots such as Syria, Babin claims. Babin emphasizes that it takes nothing more than common
sense to realize the danger and stop allowing the enemy to walk right up to our doorstep. Babin
uses Europe as an example of what not to do. recent German intelligence reported this week in
2
the U.S. shows irrefutable evidence that ISIS hit squads infiltrated Syrian refugees, he
mentions. He suggests that placing refugees in safe zones near their homelands is the right path
The assumption that restrictive immigration laws and extremely thorough background
checks of refugees are effective in reducing amount of terror attacks is superficial. Although
immigration laws are becoming increasingly restrictive worldwide, incidences of terrorism are
increasing (Sanger-Katz, 2016). Penetrating the refugee flow is a very inefficient way for radical
Islamic terrorists to gain access to a country (Dearden, 2016). Ben Emmerson, a United Nations
investigator and counter-terrorism and human rights expert found little evidence that ISIS and
other terror groups use refugee flows or that asylum seekers are prone to radicalization. In his
introduced because of terrorism concerns are not justified and may in fact be damaging to state
security. Emmersons report suggested that policies which criminalize irregular migration
may lead to an increased risk of terror attacks and decreased state security. Furthermore, analysts
have forewarned that these policies are seen as oppressive to Muslims, and feed radical Islamic
propaganda and have the potential to increase the intensity of terror attacks. Emmerson closes his
speech by reiterating that policies that hold accountability, justice, and human rights in high
sovereign states, building walls and the extremely strict vetting of refugees is superfluous.
Through the entire duration of Americas refugee program (about four decades), arguably no
through the refugee flow is extremely inefficient in most instances, and radical Islamists are
3
much more likely to gain access to a country through visas and fake passports (Russell, 2002).
The Paris terror attacks (November 2015) were not executed by refugees. Contrary to popular
belief, according to Newsweek, the attackers exploited non-refugee migration routes (Bier, 2015).
ISIS themselves consider Syrian refugees traitors to the radical Islamic cause. A September
2017 ISIS video states that It is correct for Muslims to leave the lands of the infidel for the
lands of Islam but not vice versa. Newsweek has found that Nearly 90 percent of displaced
Syrians in Turkey have no sympathy for ISIS at all, even though ISIS is fighting the person who
most refugees see as their main enemy. One dead attacker of the November 2015 Paris attack
allegedly had a fake Syrian passport near his body, suggesting he exploited the refugee flow. As
aforementioned. Some have speculated that the attacker purposely placed the passport near his
body to make the west more inclined to deny Syrian refugees. Syrian refugees being turned away
benefits ISISs cause. Studies have shown that terrorism is increased around refugee camps near
the zone of conflict. When refugees are resettled away from the zone of conflict, this is not the
case (Bier, 2015). It seems almost to be a complete disregard for human rights to allow refugees
to live in the turbulent conditions of a refugee camp than to resettle them elsewhere. The United
Nations has warned that the lives of tens of thousands of refugees fleeing war and persecution
are at risk from growing xenophobia (Schlein, 2016). United Nations refugee chief Filippo
Grandi has stated that the right to asylum is being undermined by the xenophobia and the
tendency to surmise that refugee populations are riddled with radical Islamists. The arrival of
large numbers of refugees and migrants has created panic and political instability in the global
north, fueled by irresponsible politicians. Restrictions in the laws governing asylum are being
enforced in many countries, even among those with a proud tradition of refugee protection and
human rights, he said. United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon has convicted the world
4
for not responsibly addressing the extremely dire refugee situation, which has caused death and
injury to incalculable men, women, and children. Those who are not physically wounded have
sustained psychological damage. The situation in Syria is one of the most dramatic and tragic in
the world. And, we must also remember the millions of other refugees from Yemen,
Afghanistan, Burundi, Central African Republic, South Sudan and beyond. More than six
With the millions upon millions of refugees and internally displaced persons in the world,
it is nearly impossible to resettle them all. Providing aid to internally displaced persons and
refugees in the form of amenities and cash is a life-changing way to improve the quality of life of
those who have no choice but to live in the tumultuous refugee camps. The Guardian proposes
an effective way to provide aid to such persons. There are four critical elements to a better
approach, writes David Miliband and Ravi Gurumurthy, critics of the current approach to
dealing with the global refugee crisis. David Miliband is president and CEO of the International
Rescue Committee. Ravi Gurumurthy is vice president, strategy and innovation. Instead of
creating parallel systems, humanitarians need to strengthen water, sanitation, housing, healthcare
and education systems so that displaced people can access the services they need, alongside host
populations. At the same time development actors must keep humanitarian goals in mind,
ensuring that vulnerable individuals are able to access services and basic needs, Miliband and
Gurumurthy write. Miliband and Gurumurthy believe that refugees should not be isolated from
host populations, but rather assimilated into them. In places like Lebanon, where 20% of the
population are refugees, there is a tremendous amount of strain put on infrastructure that
critique the type of aid that is provided to areas with functioning economies. Second, in urban
5
areas where economic markets are still functioning, most refugees do not need to be given food,
clothing and blankets, they need cash. Supporting the economy of such areas is an effective way
to get refugees back on their feet, working and functioning as they would have before calamity
struck their homeland. Instead of offering supplies, offering cash is a more permanent solution
that allows refugees to become more independent and able to sustain themselves. Cash allows
them to choose what to buy, slashes the costs for NGOs of transporting bulky goods, and boosts
local economies, Miliband and Gurumurthy comment (Miliband & Ravi Gurumurthy, 2015).
In 2015, Officials privately noted they were seeing a rise in Syrian immigrants trying to
cross the border. "Over the past eighteen months there has been an increase of Syrian and
Lebanese Nationals attempting to enter the United States along the southwest international
border via Mexico," the report found. "A majority of these individuals have arrived at major land
ports of entry in the U.S. claiming credible fear of returning to their home countries, CNBCs
Eamon Javers reported. The fact that refugees were claiming credible fear of returning to their
home countries is a testament to how poor the conditions they had to live in were. It is also a
testament to the fact that living in such conditions takes a psychological toll on them (Javers,
2017).
second thought. They cannot escape this stigma as long as people are ignorant. Refugees are
human beings, and this demands that they are treated as such. They have inalienable rights as
humans, and to grant them asylum and provide aid is the least we can do to improve the quality
of their poor, oppressed lives. The United Nations Refugee Agency defines refugees as such:
Refugees are people fleeing conflict or persecution. They are defined and protected in
international law, and must not be expelled or returned to situations where their life and freedom
6
are at risk. It is inhumane to reject refugees and force them to return to situations where
not even have a history of carrying out terrorist attacks. It is an international responsibility to
deal with this issue, and sweeping it under the rug will not suffice. The way aid is currently
extended to refugees and internally displaced persons alike is not a permanent solution, and it
doesnt help refugees get back on their feet. The aid we do provide to refugee camps is not the
best way to help them become independent. We need to support their local economies rather than
just provide supplies. Suggestions to aid refugees in safe zones near the zone of conflict are not
viable; completely resettling refugees away from the zone of conflict is the most effective way to
rescue people from their confusing and unfortunate situations. Assimilating refugees into the
host population of a safe country away from the zone of conflict is the best way to help these
people get back to normal lives, and to live independent and without fear. If we want to aid these
fellow human beings, we need to think about how we can restore normalcy to their lives, where
Works Cited
Babin, B. (2016, August 18). Americas Refugee Program: A Clear and Present Danger .
Retrieved from National Review: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/439122/syrian-
refugee-program-dangerous-americans-we-must-reform-it-now
Bier, D. (2015, November 17). SIX GOOD REASONS ITS WRONG TO TURN AWAY
REFUGEES. Retrieved from Newsweek: http://www.newsweek.com/six-good-reasons-
its-wrong-turn-away-refugees-395467
Dearden, L. (2016, October 24). UN report finds no evidence migration causes terror attacks
and warns anti-refugee laws could worsen risk. Retrieved from Independent:
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/refugee-crisis-terrorism-link-
migration-un-expert-report-no-evidence-isis-uses-route-human-rights-a7377961.html
Javers, E. (2017, June 7). 'A dangerous world': What's at stake when Syrian refugees are
smuggled to US. Retrieved from CNBC: https://www.cnbc.com/2016/06/06/a-dangerous-
world-whats-at-stake-when-syrian-refugees-are-smuggled-to-us.html
Miliband, D., & Ravi Gurumurthy. (2015, December 7). We need to radically rethink how we
help refugees. Retrieved from The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/global-
development-professionals-network/2015/dec/07/we-need-to-radically-rethink-how-we-
help-refugees
Refugees. (n.d.). Retrieved from United Nations Refugee Agency: http://www.unhcr.org/en-
us/refugees.html
Russell, S. S. (2002, November 1). Refugees: Risks and Challenges Worldwide. Retrieved from
Migration Policy Institute: https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/refugees-risks-and-
challenges-worldwide
Sanger-Katz, M. (2016, August 16). Is Terrorism Getting Worse? In the West, Yes. In the World,
No. Retrieved from TheUpshot: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/16/upshot/is-
terrorism-getting-worse-in-the-west-yes-in-the-world-no.html
Schlein, L. (2016, October 3). UN: Growing Xenophobia Undermining Protection for Refugees.
Retrieved from Voanews: https://www.voanews.com/a/growing-xenophobia-
undermining-protection-for-refugees/3534625.html