Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISBN 978604821338-1
ABSTRACT
A vast number of researches in landscape genetics of river have been focused on how habitat fragmentation or
exogenous invasion ascribed to dam or stocking degrades native genetic diversity. However, there still is an unsolved
question in this arena; how are physical habitat characteristics related to genetic diversity. As the habitat nature arguably
contributes to not only faunal structure but intra-specific trait through gene flow, drift and selection, this association
needs to be revealed for future river management plan with a conservation perspective. In this study, we evaluated the
linkage between genetic diversity and habitat suitability index (HSI) of aquatic animals including freshwater fishes,
amphibians and macroinvertebrates in the Natori River basin located at the middle of Miyagi prefecture. The HSI has
been structured by hydraulic and thermal variables calculated from a distributed hydro-thermal model and GIS based
geographical variables. We found a strong positive correlation between genetic diversity and HSI in one caddisfly
(Hydropsychidae), indicating that a prospective habitat (i.e., locality which has high HSI) might contribute to increase in
genetic diversity. The genetic diversity of one caddisfly (Hydropsychidae) had significant positive correlations with the
HSIs of predatory fishes and aquatic insects. This result suggests that exposures to predation pressure can enhance
genetic diversity. We derived negative correlations between genetic diversity and the HSIs within niche competitors,
suggesting inter-species selective pressure constrains intra-species genetic diversity.
Keywords: distributed runoff model, functional feeding group, HSI, habitat value, landscape genetics, life types, Trichoptera
1
competition or prey-predation balance within given The distributed runoff model was separated into the slant
benthic community. and river parts (Kazama et al., 2007). For the slant part
In this paper, we examined relationships between genetic
diversity of four stream invertebrates and HSIs of more
than 50 taxa. The genetic diversity of invertebrates has
been observed in Watanabe et al. (2014) and the HSI
models of benthic community, fishes and amphibians
have been developed using a distributed hydrological
model for a temperate basin in north-east Japan
(Nukazawa et al., 2011; Takase et al., 2013). Analyzing
relationship between genetic diversity and HSI, we aim
to reveal how habitat quality contributes to genetic
structure and which group of feedings or life types
relates to genetic diversity. Another goal is to clearly
shape usefulness of our approach to use HSI using
hydrological model for biodiversity evaluation
framework. them.
2. METHODS
distributed presence/absence of more than 1,000 animal Ho and Sm, distributed broadly (present at 26 and 20 of
species in each grid with 250 m resolution was carried the 39 sampling sites), Ha and Ej were merely sampled at
out by experts in ecological field. upstream regions and small tributaries in the study basin.
All species occur throughout Japan except some remote
The HSI can provide the physical value of
islands (e.g., Okinawa island) and have analogous habit
habitat suitability (i.e., potential of occurrence) in focal
in feeding flowing particle organic matter (<1mm
organisms along local environmental heterogeneity. As a
diameter) in streams or accumulated on streambeds.
general procedure the HSI is synthesized with the set of
suitability index (SI) hinging on biological information We calculated three genetic diversity indicators in
(e.g., numeric number of focal species and frequency) population level from the AFLP data. Proportion of
along an environmental gradient or classifications. Here polymorphic loci (%P) was quantified using AFLP-SURV
we employed predictor variables for structuring SI; slope, v 1.0 (Vekemans 2002). Heterozygosity (He) was
vegetation type, land-use, % urban, distance to urbanized computed at each locus from: He=1-ri2 , where r is
area, distance to forested area, distance to waterfront, allele frequency at locus i estimated by the Bayesian
annual metrics (see Environmental data) of current method with a uniform prior distribution of allele
velocity, water depth and water temperature. We frequencies (Zhivotovsky 1999) using AFLP-SURV v 1.0.
structured frequency distribution graphs with the We employed a theta estimator (theta pi ()) (Tajima
numerical numbers of grid in which both presence and 1983), as a genetic diversity indicator using Arlequin v
absence in focal animals and the ranges (e.g., 0.0-0.2 m 3.0 (Excoffier et al. 2005).
for annual mean depth) or type (e.g., agricultural zone)
in the predictors. Subsequently, SIs were developed after 2.5 Correlation analysis
the frequencies in each range were normalized as 0-1 (0:
We derived Pearsons and Spearmans correlation
not suitable, 1: most suitable). The HSIs for the studied
coefficients between habitat suitability of 53 aquatic taxa
taxa were then calculated by means of geometric mean of
(49 taxa of benthic invertebrates, 3 taxa of fishes and 1
the SIs for each predictor;
taxa of amphibian) and genetic diversity of 4
invertebrates using SPSS Statistics 17.0 (SPSS Inc.). The
results of benthic invertebrates were classified to
functional feeding groups (PR: predator, SH: shredder,
where SIxyi indicates suitability index in an environment FC: filterer-collector, GS: grazer-scraper, GC: gatherer-
predictor i and p indicates numerical number of the collector) (FFGs) and life types (CR: crawler excluding
predictors (=15) at the grid (x, y). glider, AT: attacher excluding net-spinner, NS: net-
spinner, GL: glider, BR: brawler, SW: swimmer) for
2.4 Genetic diversity further discussion. Also, we applied multiple regression
analysis assigning the genetic diversity as objective
We used the empirical AFLP genetic data for three
variable and HSI of 25 invertebrate taxa validated in
caddisflies (Insecta: Trichoptera), Hydropsyche orientalis
Takase et al. (2013) as predictor variable.
(Ho), Stenopsyche marmorata (Sm) and Hydropsyche
albicephala (Ha), and a mayfly (Insecta:
3
3. RESULTS correlated with HSIs of niche competitors (i.e., FC and
NS) (Table 1 & 2).
We found positive moderate correlation between genetic
diversity (%P: proportion of polymorphic loci) and HSI Multiple regression analysis revealed the genetic
in Hydropsyche albicephala (Ha) (R=0.50, P<0.10), while diversity of Ho has negative correlation with the HSI of
correlations in other 3 species did not exhibit clear trend Psepheridae taxon, which frequently dominates benthic
(Fig.2). community and have similar longitudinal pattern of
Table 1 Correlations between genetic diversity of four aquatic insects and habitat suitability index
classified to five categories of functional feeding groups (FFGs) (Merrit and Cummins, 1996) (PR:
predator, SH: shredder, FC: filter feeder, GS: scraper, GC: collector-gatherer). Bracketed numeric
values following each FFG acronym indicate number of taxon belonging to each FFG. Numeric
values and following bracketed numeric values indicate number of significant correlation (P<0.05)
and its symbol (+: positive, -: negative), and upper and lower hands indicate results from
Pearsons correlation analysis and Spearmans correlation analysis.
Table 2 Correlations between genetic diversity of four aquatic insects and habitat suitability index
classified to six categories of life types (Merrit and Cummins, 1996) (CR: crawler, AT: attacher,
NS: net-spinner, GL: glinder, BR: burrower, SW: swimmer). Bracketed numeric values following
each life type indicate number of taxon belonging to each life type. See caption of Table 1 for
instructions of numeric values and following bracketed numeric values.
Correlations between genetic diversity (He: inhabitation and microhabitat preference to Ho.
heterozygosity, Tp: theta pi) of Hydropsyche orientalis
(Ho) and the HSIs in benthic assemblage classified in line 4. DISCUSSION
with FFGs and fishes, clearly underlined strong positive
In principle, population density of focal species is
connection (P<0.05) of the genetic diversity and HSI of
probably high in which habitat seems to be preferable for
predatory invertebrates and fishes (Table 1). This result
this species (i.e., HSI is high). Simultaneously, effect of
implies genetic diversity of Ho is relatively high in
genetic drift causing decline of genetic diversity can be
habitat having strong predation pressure. Furthermore,
small where density of local population is large. Given
we found the genetic diversity of Ho negatively
intra-specific diversity is mainly /partly characterized by
4
Table 3 Correlations between genetic diversity of 2
aquatic insects and 4 aquatic taxa (3 freshwater fish
species and 1 taxon of frog). Symbol indicates significant
positive (+) or negative (-) correlation found with
habitat suitability, the theoretical process driven by Pearsons correlation analysis (upper hand) and
genetic drift is probably dominant in natural local Spearmans correlation analysis (lower hand). Number of
population of focal species. On the one hand, exploring symbol (1 or 2) indicates level of significance (1: P<0.10,
relationship between genetic diversity of a species and 2: P<0.05).
HSI of other species, genetic variation mediated by biotic
interactions can be revealed.
5
The positive correlations of the genetic diversity with the salmon, Salmo salar. Regulated River, Vol.12, pp.273-
HSIs of GC express that preferable habitat with low flow 285, 1996.
velocity potentially storing much fine organic matters Liggett J., Chapter 2: Basic equations of unsteady flow. In:
enhance the genetic diversity of Ej. Unsteady Flow in Open Channels, 1975.
Liggett J., Cunge J., Chapter 4: Numerical methods of
5. CONCLUSIONS solution of the unsteady flow equations. In: Unsteady
Flow in Open Channels, 1975.
In this paper, we evaluated association between genetic Lighthill G.B., Whitham M.J., On kinematic waves. I.
diversity of four stream insects and habitat suitability of Flood movement in long rivers. Proceedings of The
around 50 aquatic taxa including fishes and invertebrates. Royal Society A, Vol.229, pp.281316, 1955a.
Habitat suitability model based on a hydrological model Lighthill G.B., Whitham M.J., On kinematic waves. II. A
enabled us to test the relationship in basin scale. theory of traffic flow on long crowded roads.
Furthermore, habitat suitability of benthic assemblage Proceedings of The Royal Society A, Vol.229, pp.317
classified to functional feeding groups and life types 345, 1955b.
revealed cryptic attributes of niche competitions and Manel S., Schwartz MK., Luikart G., Taberlet P.,
prey-predators to genetic diversity. This study will be a Landscape genetics: combining landscape ecology
significant implication of future modeling frameworks and population genetics, Trends in Ecology and
which aim to take biotic interactions into account. Evolution, Vol.18 (4), pp.189-197, 2003.
Merritt RW., Cummins KW. (eds), An introduction to the
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS aquatic insects of North America (3rd ed.).
This research was partially supported by the Ministry of Kendall/Hunt, Dubuque, lowa, 1996.
Education, Science, Sports and Culture through a Grant- Muhlfeld CC, Jones L, Kotter D, Miller WJ, Geise D,
in-Aid for Scientific Research (grant #: 24254003, Tohtz J, Marotz B, Assessing the impacts of river
25241024, 26820196, 26630247) and Japan Society for the regulation on native bull trout (Salvelinus
Promotion of Science (JSPS) Research Fellowship (grant confluentus) and westslope cutthroat trout
#: 256493). (Oncorhynchus clarkii lewisi) habitats in the upper
Flathead River, Montana, USA. River Research and
REFERENCES Applications, Vol.28(7), pp.940-959, 2011.
Nash J., Sutcliffe J., River flow forecasting through
Deiner K., Garza JC., Coey R., Girman DJ., Population conceptual models part I A discussion of
structure and genetic diversity of trout principles. Journal of Hydrology, Vol.10, pp.282290,
(Oncorhynchus mykiss) above and below natural and 1970.
man-made barriers in the Russian River, California, Nukazawa K., Shiraiwa J., Kazama S., Evaluations of
Conservation Genetics, Vol.8, pp.437-454, 2007. seasonal habitat variations of freshwater fishes,
Excoffier L., Laval G., Schneider S., Arlequin (version fireflies, and frogs using a habitat suitability index
3.0): an integrated software package for population model that includes river water temperature.
genetics data analysis. Evolutionary Bioinformatics Ecological Modelling, Vol.222, pp.37183726, 2011.
Online, Vol.1, pp.4750, 2005. Tajima F., Evolutionary relationship of DNA sequences in
Fread D., Chapter 10: Flow routing. In: Handbook of finite populations, Genetics, Vol.105, pp.437-460, 1983.
Hydrology, 1993. Excoffier L., Lavel G. and Schneider S., Arlequin
Hamamoto H., Kazama S., Watanabe K., Sawamoto M., ver.3.1 an integrated software package for
Omura T., Hierarchical spatial structure of species population genetics data analysis, Evolutionary
diversity of riverine benthic faunal community in Bioinformatics Online, Vol.1, pp.47-50, 2005.
south-central Miyagi prefecture, Annual J. of Takase A., Nukazawa K., Kazama S., Watanabe K.,
Hydraulic Engineering, Vol.52, pp.1171-1176, 2008. Evaluation of habitat and species diversities of
(in Japanese with English abstract) benthos using hydrological model and probability
Imanishi K., Mayflies from Japanese torrents. X. Life density function. Journal of JSCE, Ser. B1 (Hydraulic
forms and life zones of mayfly nymphs. II. Ecological Engineering), Vol.70, No.4, pp.I_1297-I_1302, 2013. (in
structure illustrated by life zone arrangement. Mem Japanese with English abstract)
Coll Sci Kyoto Imp Univ Ser B: 1-35, 1941. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Habitat evaluation
Kazama S., Matsumoto S., Ranjan SP., Hamamoto H., procedures (HEP). Ecological Services Manual 102,
Sawamoto M., Characterization of firefly habitat 1980.
using a geographical information system with U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Standards for
hydrological simulation. Ecological Modelling, development of HSI models. Ecological Services
Vol.209, pp.392400, 2007. Manual 103, 1981.
Kimura T. The P.W.R.I.M. of C., The flood runoff Vh J-P., Erkinaro J., Niemel E., Primmer CR., Life-
analysis method by the storage function model, 1961. history and habitat features influence the within-river
Kondo J., Ishida S., Sensible Heat Flux from the Earths genetic structure of Atlantic salmon, Molecular
Surface under Natural Convective Conditions. Journal Ecology, Vol.16, pp.2638-2654, 2007.
of the Atmospheric Sciences, Vol.54, pp.498509, 1977. Vekemans X., T. Beauwens, Lemaire M., Roldan-Ruiz I.:
Lankau RA., Strauss SY., Mutual feedbacks maintain both Data from amplified fragment length polymorphism
genetic and species diversity in a plant community, (AFLP) markers show indication of size homoplasy
Science, Vol.317, pp.15611563, 2007. and of a relationship between degree of homoplasy
Leclerc M, Boudreau P, Belzile L, Numerical method for and fragment size, Molecular Ecology, Vol.11, pp.139-
modelling spawning habitat dynamics of landlocked 151, 2002.
6
Wang Y.-H., Yang K.-C., Bridgman CL., Lin L.-K.,
Habitat suitability modelling to correlate gene flow
with landscape connectivity, Landscape Ecology,
Vol.23, pp.9891000, 2008.
Watanabe K., Kazama S., Omura T., Monaghan MT.,
Adaptive Genetic Divergence along Narrow
Environmental Gradients in Four Stream Insects, PLoS
ONE, 9(3), e93055, 2014.
Watanabe K., Omura T., Relationship between Reservoir
Size and Genetic Differentiation of the Stream
Caddisfly Stenopsyche marmorata, Biological
Conservation, Vol.136, pp.203-211, 2007.
Zhivotovsky LA., Estimating population structure in
diploids with multilocus dominant DNA markers,
Molecular Ecology, Vol.8, pp.907-913, 1999.