2014APEC21

APEC

PPP

( Public-

Private Partnerships, PPP )

PPP

20002

15

2004

1064

20081080

2011490

4No.106April, 2015


3.0

No.106April, 2015 5
1
INTERVIEW

6No.106April, 2015


2015121

BOT

5070

BOT
1

PPP

BOT BENZ

BOT

23 BOT No.106April, 2015 7



()

SARS90

2014

5070

2013

2015


8No.106April, 2015
(4) (3) (2) (1)

305070

101

No.106April, 2015 9


10No.106April, 2015
 1

No.106April, 2015 11
 PFI

LED

PFIPFI

LED

0.25

0.25

LED

PFILED

PFI

PFI
2014322

" infrastructure

financing, a long and winding road."

12No.106April, 2015
() ()

APEC2021

BOT

PPPAPEC

PPP

PPP

No.106April, 2015 13
 PPP

Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank,

AIIB

APEC

PPP

PPP

PPP

PPP

BOT

PPP

PPP

PPP

PPP

14No.106April, 2015
 1

(1) (2) () (2) (1)

No.106April, 2015 15
1
INTERVIEW

16No.106April, 2015



19851997

BOT2015

127

1
19

BOT(4

)OT

OT(7)
BOT(10

)




No.106April, 2015 17


2014

OT

(1) (2)

20146

201661111

OT

18No.106April, 2015
 (3) (2) (1)

400

269

28

No.106April, 2015 19


( BOT

) 20147
2020
ICT




--

2011

15

35

2400

2011

2007

20No.106April, 2015
 1

No.106April, 2015 21

1,064

2013

9201448

31,95332

2

214

20147BOT

22No.106April, 2015
 () ()

40~70

No.106April, 2015 23
 2014PFI(
)



PFI

PFI

PFI PFI

PFI

2015

1 (2014)1225

2015

(BOT)

24No.106April, 2015
 (1) (2) () (2) (1)

1007

775

PFI
1

No.106April, 2015 25
1
INTERVIEW

26No.106April, 2015


2015128

ROT

BOTOT
ROT

1
OT
OT
OT

OT
OT

BOT

(BOT) No.106April, 2015 27



ROT2015

(1) (2)

(BOT)

12-

(ROT)

(BOT)

28No.106April, 2015
 (3) (2) (1)

2000

BOT

BOT
1

BOT

BOT

BOT

BOT

No.106April, 2015 29


50%

OT
2








?

1 O T

BOT

ROTOT

2013

30No.106April, 2015
 1

No.106April, 2015 31
No.106


2-3

BOT

2014

BOT

2011

32No.106April, 2015
(1) (2) () (2) (1)

No.106April, 2015 33
2
ENGINEERING

ABSTRACT

GDP

34 No.106 April 2015

 1

2007

2011

2

2007
A9A12A13B5

No.106 April 2015 35

 2003512

2003718
20038~200625
20062~3
9
20066191
20
292006720
20061192
10
1820061221

21999,88820071
15
2007830

18

2

4

2013


36 No.106 April 2015

GDP

2013
10113 201477

201382


201426


9
2014

No.106 April 2015 37

3
SPECIAL REPORT

3.0
(Public-Private Partnerships, PPP)
(Value for Money, VFM)
(Private Finance Initiative, PFI)

38No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT

(Public-Private Partnerships)

()(

(Value for Money))

1 2 3

[6][7][8]
[9]
201421 PPP[10]
(APEC)[1] PPP
(
PPP)5() PPP
()
PPP PPP
3

()PPP
()PPP [10,11,12,13]Grimsey and Lewis[11]PPP
(PPP center) ()
()
()
()
PPP ()

PPP[2][3] ()
[4][5]
No.106April, 2015 39
 1998
12%201522.5%
4,400
(
)

() 1.0
()
20 19932
1995
BOTBOT 40%

PPP1990PFI(Private 19941251996115
Finance Initiative)2012 1.0
PF2[14]
19987

BOT
BOT

[15]17
1
PPP

1 199817
()
1,787 1993-2009
5,097 1998-2003

3 22 1991-1998

93 1993-1998
300 1998-2000
179 1997-1999
2,969 1996-2002
514 1996-2004
180 1999-2005
169
227 1998-2013
660 1998-2004
1,952
40No.106April, 2015
 ()
1,231 1994-2007
33 1993-2002
228 1997-2002
33 1991-2000

BOT 2002
2003
20073
201412
99.93%99.42%
29,70913.5
49.44%57.57% BOT
()()
()
()
BOTPPP
BOT

20012008
80%
(--)
2013

()
()
()
[17] 1998BOT
[17]()BOT()
3

BOT BOT
()BOT
1998 ()BOT

()BOT
789
568

50 [18]
No.106April, 2015 41






2.0


20002



2.0

2013 31
2008826
2003201522
[20]986
7,2207.3
98%
[19]



() 1OT
(

1
42No.106April, 2015
 2

2
)

ROT141
/
BOT
6 11,300,030
OT
11 3,594,380
OT
BOT 60 3,573,998

909 440,246
3,600
986 732,213
300

() 2 35.7
BOT
(
BOT(
)600
)

3

182 () 3
16.3 793

() 2
113
( 4.86
2.16
)35.9BOT
No.106April, 2015 43
 3

3
() 4

/

17 6,181,689

3 6 5,002,088

13 3,423,747
6 3,310,792 () 3

6 3,052,242

14 2,400,291
62

11 1,301,255
50
34
44 1,048,927

10 1,021,880

793 486,322
17
66 215,610
A15A18A20
986 732,213
44No.106April, 2015
 (A25)
740
700
30

() 4 () 6 2 0 0 6
6.29%5 200520132014
1,700 201220042014
24%5 20137
27 200420122014
6

() () 2006
890 2010
2011

4 5

/

20 2.03% 20 2,717,819

42 4.26% 42 2,753,015

924 93.71% 924 597,379

986 100.00% 986 732,213

5
No.106April, 2015 45
 6

2013 (600)2012
2014710980
573

() 2 004 A15A18A20
BOT
BOTETC BOT
BOT800 A195835
46No.106April, 2015
 8

2012
3

()  8
200520132012
2014
200420062009 ()  9200420062007

30.06%10.34%
9.92%
6080200
4002005
20082009 ()  1 0
No.106April, 2015 47
 10

11

()
12BOT
71
44
() 11 31
(

)

()
48No.106April, 2015
 732,213
406,474
768,892
1,005,000
1,591,290
2,871,194
3,081,111
4,391,391
7,090,007

- 1,000,000 2,000,000 3,000,000 4,000,000 5,000,000 6,000,000 7,000,000 8,000,000

()

12

[11]



PPP
()  7.32
PPP PPP
()
4.86 ()
()
17.42 ()[21]

() 
[22]
2009
3

6Jeffrey DelmonPPP
[23]
1.0
PPP


3.0

29
(Economic)(Social) BTO
No.106April, 2015 49
 6 PPP

PPP

PPP

VfM

PPP

 PPPPPP

PPP

13
(
Value for Money)




50No.106April, 2015

?

50% ?

13

()()
()4E
PPP (EmergencyEconomyEfficiencyEffectiveness)
PPP()
()() PPP
()() ()
() ((Value for
()[20] Money))

3

PPP
BOTBOT
PPPPPP PPP

PPP PPP
No.106April, 2015 51



7. http://www.ncppp.org/ppp-basics/7-keys

8. Recommendation of the Council on Principles
for Public Governance of Public-Private
Partnerships, OECD, May 2012

1. 21st APEC Finance Ministers Meeting Joint
Ministerial Statement: http://www.apec.
org/Meeting-Papers/Ministerial-Statements/
Finance/2014_finance.aspx
2. Public-Private Partnership Units: Lessons for
their Design and Use in Infrastructure. The
World Bank PPIAF Washington, D.C., U.S.A.,
October 2007
9.
[2014]76
Sept. 23rd, 2014
10. International Handbook on Public-Private
Partnerships. Graeme A. Hodge, Carsten
Greve and Anthony E. Boardman edsEdward
Elgar, Northampton, MA, USA, 2010
11. Public-Private Partnerships Principles of Policy
and Finance. E. R. Yescombe, Butterworth-
Heinemann, MA, USA,2007

3. Asian Development Bank: Public-Private
Partnership (PPP) Handbook, Asian Development
Bank, Manila, Philippines, 2008
4. European Commission: Guidelines for
Successful Public-Private Partnerships: 16,
12. Public Private Partnerships the Worldwide
Revolution in Infrastructure Provision and
Project Finance. Derrin Grimsey and Mervyn
K. Lewis, Edward Elgar, Northampton, MA
USA, 2004

3 March, 2003 13.

PPP
5. http://www.oecd.org/governance/oecdp Nov. , 2014
rinciplesforpublicgovernanceofpublic-
privatepartnerships.htm 14. PF2
26
6. http://www.pppcouncil.ca/resources/about- Feb.2013
ppp/definitions.html

52No.106April, 2015
15. 20. http://ppp.mof.gov.tw/PPP.Website/Case/
July 31st, 2008 CaseView.aspx

16. 21. PFI

Dec. 2013
15
May 1sy, 2013 22.
40Oct.2013
17.
23. Jeffrey Delmon: Public-Private Partnership
Projects in Infrastructure. An Essential Guide
1998 for Policy Makers. Cambridge University
Press NYUSA 2012
18.
80
Oct.2008

19. http://ppp.mof.gov.tw/PPP.Website/

No.106April, 2015 53
3
SPECIAL REPORT

 1

54No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT




200029 
()
201412
31
1218 3

No.106April, 2015 55







2009324X





()
2009112009
1231




( (
)() 20)

OT 1

5 A2000
A
20

3 A

600


(118
)

201011 2

56No.106April, 2015
 2001129


3030
11
A200511
A

A

A




A
() 49




1%
1. 
2.
1% 3.
4.

1 5.

()














()

22

No.106April, 2015 57
 11


() 
1. 
2007
2.
3. 
1. (
)


2.  221

() 
3. 

1. 55 ()

4. 



(1)
(2) 

(3) 

(4)

2. 56()


58No.106April, 2015


2
(
)

20080418

2


41()

31(
)

No.106April, 2015 59
 () 

A()D
A(

(
) )
(B/C-1)*100%
B
/
C(
)
D(1)


() 

1. 
E()D
E
(B/C-1)*100%
B
/
C(
)
D(1)

3 2. 

F (
)D
F
(B/C-1)*100%
B
/
C(
) 1
D(1)

60No.106April, 2015
 1
3
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00%
100 102 104.04 106.12 108.24 110.41

() 150 250 300 350 250

() 150 400 700 1050 1300
3.00% 2.00% 4.00% 2.00% 2.50%
100 103 105.06 109.26 111.45 114.24

() 154.5 255 312 357 255

() 154.5 409.5 721.5 1078.5 1333.5

1. A(2.5%)D
A-
(3)2010 1333.5()
201120162015 B-
114.24
2.5% C-
110.41
D-(1)15%
No.106April, 2015 61
 1 333.5*{[(114.24/110.41)1]*100% 1. 
2.5%}*(15%)13.5713.57 
A 841.72/4128.6420.39%
10%

10%

4
2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
0.00% 0.10% 0.10% 0.10% 0.10% 1.50%
100.00 100.10 100.20 100.30 100.40 101.91
() 150.00 150.15 150.30 150.45 150.60 152.86
() 150.00 300.15 450.45 600.90 751.50 904.36

0.00% 1.50% 1.50% 1.50% 1.50% 1.50%
100.00 101.50 103.02 104.57 106.14 107.73
() 750.00 761.25 772.67 784.26 796.02 807.96
() 750.00 1511.25 2283.92 3068.18 3864.20 4672.16
0% 2.4% 2.5% 2.7% 2.9%
100.00 102.40 104.96 107.79 110.92
() 160.00 163.84 167.94 172.47 177.47
() 160.00 323.84 491.78 664.25 841.72

0.0% 2.6% 2.6% 2.9% 3.0%
100.00 102.60 105.27 108.32 111.57
() 780.00 785.00 813.40 850.00 900.24
() 780.00 1565.00 2378.40 3228.40 4128.64

E2(10%)D
E2-()841.72()
(4)2010 B-
20172021 110.92

3 C-100.40

2.5% D-(1)15%
[(110.92/100.40)1]*100%10.48%
10% 10%
841.72*(10.48%10%)*(15%)
10% 4.24()
2. 
E(2.5%)D
E-()
4128.64()
B-
62No.106April, 2015
 111.57
C-106.14
D-(1)15%
4128.64*{[(111.57/106.14)1]*100%
2.5%}*(15%)113.40()


10%
2.5%

113.40
B




SOP

38





3

1.

No.106April, 2015 63
3
SPECIAL REPORT

64No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT

2013 15
1.5

()


3

2014

(
)


No.106April, 2015 65
 ()

7
146-5
10%

5%
10
14613 4,0003.5
14611 400
3 3,500
2001,750

(
)

3 6
(
)()

3 (

)
() (
)
1-5 () (
6 )
() (
)
() 
2014617
3 ()
66No.106April, 2015

8


() (
() 
) 7
() 
(
) 10%
() 5%
()
() 10%34
()
45%
20127
15 19
25%35%
2014617
15 7
42 35%45%

() [1]

46 () 
14613


14652
3

1465

1465




No.106April, 2015 67
 [2]

() [3] 1.  ()


( 2. 

)

1 BOT


3.1 3.1
1.  1. 

2. 11 2. 11

3.2
3.2.1 ()

1.

3
2.
3. 

4.
5. 

6. ()

3.2.2 ()52
53

68No.106April, 2015


10.10 10.10 ()
10.10.1 ()
(
)
1.  1. (
)
2.  2.  ()

3. 
3. ()

()
()
10.10.2 10.10.1()


1. ()

2. ()

BOT
[4]
1
2013621
1022551027020137 () 
171020141476
2014120

3

21



(132083)
(
9)(
)11
No.106April, 2015 69

70


[5]








() 

()

()
()

() 

3 () 

()  () 
70No.106April, 2015


1. http://www.
()  ib.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=35&parentpath=0,2
&mcustomize=multimessage_view.jsp&datase
rno=201406170001&aplistdn=ou=bulletin,ou
=multisite,ou=chinese,ou=ap_root,o=fsc,c=tw
&toolsflag=Y&dtable=Law(2014.06.17)

2. http://www.
()  ib.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=34&parentpath=0,2
&mcustomize=news_view.jsp&dataserno=201
210080002&aplistdn=ou=news,ou=multisite,
ou=chinese,ou=ap_root,o=fsc,c=tw&toolsflag=
Y(2012.10.08)

3.
(2013.09)

4. http://www.
3

ib.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=34&parentpath=0,2
&mcustomize=news_view.jsp&dataserno=201
305280003&aplistdn=ou=news,ou=multisite,
ou=chinese,ou=ap_root,o=fsc,c=tw&toolsflag=
Y(2013.05.28)

5. BOT 70
http://money.chinatimes.com/news/news-
content.aspx?id=20140121000069&cid=120
1465 6(2014.01.21)
No.106April, 2015 71
3
SPECIAL REPORT

36

72No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT

2009
636
2013627

1 2

[1]
3

(
)(
)(
)
1 (2)36

No.106April, 2015 73
 A9()
(3)








1

15()[2]

36

()


3 36
74No.106April, 2015


(
)()
(
)(
)(
)
4
4 36
2009620136

()

2015
57

5 36 Outlet Park

6 36 Outlet Park

7 36 Outlet Park
No.106April, 2015 75





() (78%)
(22%)

TVBSA8A9




() 





() 
Outlet Park



Outlet Park

3 () 

76No.106April, 2015






58.8
4.550
65.92,000[3]

1. 1021210

2. 3 6
(
) (2010)

3. http://www.ntpc.gov.tw/
ch/home.jsp?id=28&parentpath=0,6,27&mcust
omize=news_view.jsp&dataserno=201404250
024(2014.04.25)

No.106April, 2015 77
3
SPECIAL REPORT

78No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT

()20102013
-6(A25)
(A25)7826
()42
()(
)259

1 2

() 

A25
18,022m 2 (5,452)
()
40%
400%
(1)2014
3

166.5

() 

A25





No.106April, 2015 79
 () 
115,000m 2 (34,800)
6585




(
)


D 70004000

1 A25

2
80No.106April, 2015
() 
15%
12,600
9,081.48m2(2,747.15) 2225

(2) ()5%
()45%
250%201426.8
70%

() 


()
()

A

() 


()  3,883.68m2(1,174.81)
(3)
()
60%360%2014

3
No.106April, 2015 81
 12.7

() 

50%



()
()( A25
)()
() [1]
50


44
13

() 

() [2]
2014623
22,479m (6,800)
2
1
1012

4 A25
82No.106April, 2015
 () [4]
1728800 2014224
800 2
250

2274
65888056
80009880
7,500 16%
80

3,200
2,225
() [3]
3

70



() [5]
60


3*6

No.106April, 2015 83
 6

2 2023456789
14( 136800655456789
47.9%

) 1,500

50%

() [6]
20131226
3
2 1

3 1 A25

A25

m2 18,022.00 9,081.48 3,883.68

50 70 60

1,728,000 568,000 136,800

1,728,800 658,880 202,345

2014813(4) 2014416(5) 2014214(6)

84No.106April, 2015



A25

1.
6-
(2014)

2. http://www.dof.taipei.
gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=81129592&ctNode=401
83&mp=103007 (2014.08.13)

3.
7826
-(2014)

4. http://www.dof.taipei.
( gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=74572501&ctNode=401
) 83&mp=103007(2014.04.16)

5.
42-
(2013)

6. http://www.dof.taipei.
3

gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=72063657&ctNode=401
83&mp=103007 (2014.02.14)

No.106April, 2015 85
3
SPECIAL REPORT

BOT

, PMP 1

86No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT

BOT

(BOT)

1 2

61
54


( 54
)15
3

BOT()2004 62
54


54
54
6162


No.106April, 2015 87


[2]54







1

[3]
(
)
[2]
()


[4]
1.
2.
1
3.
4.

(2006)[5]
BOT
()

[1]
(2007)[6](Balanced
Score Card)
()


88No.106April, 2015
 (2012)[7]


3,394

BOT





(
) 14.2(3
4)75,000CMD
125
42BOT
20041020

()  5.7
BOT
(2) [8]
() 

2
No.106April, 2015 89
 3

() 




511
90No.106April, 2015
 () 
80%
20%
() 
70 BOT

70
30 
1
()  
2

()

2





3

()

No.106April, 2015 91






QA/QC

BOT
3

()(
/
)

92No.106April, 2015
 (AHP) 5.

145170(2006)

6.

(2007)
BOT
7.

(2012)

1. 8.
80 BOT
(1998) (2004)

2.


(2006)

3.

(2003)

4.
(2004)

No.106April, 2015 93
3
SPECIAL REPORT

PPPPFIPF2PSCVfM

1
, PMP 2

, PMP 3

94No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT
(Public Private Partnerships, PPP)

2012911()
4.PFI

PFI(Private Finance Initiatives)

PFI
VfM

1 2 3 4 5

2000
(PPP) ()


(World Bank)

PPP[1](1) ()
3

1 PPP
No.106April, 2015 95


[2][3] VfM
PFI

PFI2012911 VfM

() VfM
4.PFI



[4]

PFI
Value for Money(VfM) PPP
PFI
(Public Sector Comparator, PSC)
PFI (PFI)(Joint
VfMPFI[5] Ventures)(Concessions)
201112PFI (Outsourcing)(the sale of
equity stakes in state-owned businesses)
[7]PFI1990


PF2[6]

PFI

3 PF2

VfM





BOT

2 PFI
96No.106April, 2015



[7] VfM

20123PFI PF2[6]
2
VfM
[6]
PFIVfM[5]

()
2,000 PFI
2003 (viability)
PFI[5] (desirability)(achievability)
2003
PFI24% PFI
8%2PFI
70% PFI
PFI22%
PFI73%
[8]Partnerships UK 2006
96% 2006VfM Assessment Guidance[5]
79%
[9]PFI (Value for Money Quantitative Evaluation
Spreadsheet[10]34)


PFI
3

PFI2011 (Whole Life Costs)(Optimism Bias)

(1) (Premium Flexibility Factor)(Tax)
VfM(2)

(3)
(4)
(5) VfM
VfM
[6]2011
PFI
No.106April, 2015 97
 3 VfM

VfM

20032008
36

(BOT)





4 VfM [11]
98No.106April, 2015
 () 200812
2004 BOT

35
5 (BOT)


(BOT)VfM(
() 8.74%)(BOT)
[12]
36
8 ()  2 0 0 9 2
1[11] VfM

VfM

VfM
VfM
VfM 14.24%[13]

101914
No.106April, 2015 99
3 5

VfM VfM(Optimism Bias)

(Risk Register)

VfM

[13]

100No.106April, 2015

VfM
()




()

VfM

(
)

200112 (
)




[14]
(2)

No.106April, 2015 101





(Project Management Institute) (4)
PMBOK Guide 5 Edition[15]55
th

()
55(

3)1
[16]


3

PFI

(5)

VfM

C
( (
)

3 ()

() 25)
6
()
12.24%()
14.15%
VfM8.92%C




102No.106April, 2015
 4

6 C








3

PFI
VfM
PFI
VfM


(PFI) VfM
No.106April, 2015 103



VfM 1. World Bank GroupMain types of PPP,
http://www.ppiaf.org/sites/ppiaf.org/files/
documents/toolkits/highwaystoolkit/1/1-13.html
(PFI)VfM
2.


120-122(2006)

3.

VfM 88-95
(2007)

4.
http://www.ndc.gov.tw/m1.aspx?sN
o=0017594&ex=1&ic=0000015
(Risk Register)
5. HM Treasury, Value for Money Assessment
Guidance, HM Treasury, London,
PP.7(2006)

3 !

104No.106April, 2015
6. HM Treasury, A New Approach to Public 12.
Private Partnerships, HM Treasury, London, BOT
PP. 1-13(2012) (2008)

7. HM Treasury, Public Private Partnerships 13.

the Governments Approach, HM VfM
Treasury, London, PP.8-10(2000)
(2009)
8. National Audit Office, PFIConstruction
Performance, National Audit Office, 14.
London, PP.3(2003)

9. Partnerships UK, Report on Operational (2001)
PFI Projects, Partnerships UK, London,
PP.83(2006) 15. Project Management Institute, A guide
to project management body of knowledge
10. HM Treasury, Value for money quantitative PMBOK Guide) 5 th Edition, Project
evaluation spreadsheet, http://www.hm- Management Institute, PP.331(2013)
treasury.gov.uk/infrastructure_ppp_vfm.htm
16.
11. :

15-35(2011) 1-36
(2011)

No.106April, 2015 105

3
SPECIAL REPORT

PFI


PFI(Private Finance Initiative)(Public Private Partnerships;
PPP) (Facility Management) (Output
Specification)(Payment by Results; PbR)

106No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT
()

PFI(Private Finance Initiative)

20

(Public Private Partnerships; PPP)

PFI

1 2 3 4

PFI
80
(Margaret Thatcher) 90
(Compulsory
Competitive Tendering)
()

(John Major)1992PFI 1
PFI
1997 () (Hard Facilities Management)
700

()
PFI (
(Design)(Build)(Finance) )
(Operate)
No.106April, 2015 107
 1




2. 
(
()

(

)
KPMG[1]
(Integrated Facilities

Management)




(1) (Reduce Cost)
(2) (Streamline
() (Soft Facilities Management) Operations and Simplify
Processes)
(3) (Improve Operational
Efficiency)
(4) (Improve Service Delivery)
(5) (Reduce Management
Complexity)
()  (6) (Drive
Consistency across the Portfolio)
(7) (Gain Economies of Scale)
(8) (Enhance Ability to
Share Information)
(9) (Introduce Best Practices)

3 (10) (Improve Global

Delivery)
10 (11) (Improve Data,
Technology, and Reporting)
(12) (Drive Continuous
1.  Improvement)
(13) (Provide a
More Flexible, Scalable Delivery Model)

3. 

108No.106April, 2015


Carillion2005PME
Mowlem
2007Alfred McAlpine 1
PFI


4. (Web-Based Solutions) PFI
10

5. 

2008



1

PFI


PFI
2000(Payment by
Results; PbR) (Output Specification)


(Health White Paper)
3

PFI
(
)
(Putting People First)[2]

24




No.106April, 2015 109
 (
) (

)
2

2
20146

58,364
/ 44,26075.8%
1.6%
2
76.9%76.8%

66.9%3






[3]

2014
65

3


2,808,59011.99%(

http://www.ltcpa.org.tw/
100%)85.70%
1993
3
7%
()


2


55 5.29% 2,566 76.9%

967 92.27% 49,852 76.8%

25 2.39% 5,946 66.9%
2013
1047 99.9% 58,364 75.8%
3.121.46

110No.106April, 2015
 2003
1(0.46)







2007
~
(2007-2016)[4]2008-2011
2012-2015 () 
2016-2017 ()
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
()

10





3

10
No.106April, 2015 111
















(Outline Business Case)









PFI

:
PFI


112No.106April, 2015


() 
()  PFI
(Outcome-Based Contract)
PFI
()  PFI



() 

(latent defects)
()
() 
PFI

PFI


() 

() 



1. KPMG(2012), KPMG 2012 Global Real
Estate and Facilities Management(REFM)
Outsourcing Pulse Survey.
3

2. HM Government(2007), Putting people first:

PFI a shared vision and commitment to the
transformation of adult social care

3. (2009)


4. (2007) ---

No.106April, 2015 113
3
SPECIAL REPORT

114No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT

2012

()

(PCM)(

1 2 3

20083
(BOT)


2000

20013
2004114

2006
1
20121126

165.371
() 22.136
20063 ()
No.106April, 2015 115

()
(R13)(R6)
(O1) C1
C141
(O1)8.7
2013114
CAF(
, CONSTRUCCIONES Y AUXILIAR DE
FERROCARRILES, S.A.)

()(
())2013
218


()


(
)
1

1 C1C14


(C1)

(C2)

(C3)
(R6)

(C4)

(C5)

(C6)
COSTCOIKEA

(C7)

(C8)
85
116No.106April, 2015


(C9)

(10)

(C11)
()
18.18
(C12)

18.18
(C13)

(O1)(
(C14)
)
20141018C1-C14
C1C142015329

()

26


2



252

2
3



()
()


 BOT()


20082012BOT

BOTBOT

BOT

No.106April, 2015 117

 3



1. 


2. 

()
3





1

18
1416


() 2013430
(
 )(
)
5



BOT

()

() ()
()
()
118No.106April, 2015


() 
()2015


2019
(
) ()

( ()
)
() 
1. 


()  2. 2217

()

() 


() 

() 1. 20171231
()
2. 
2217
3

2()
2

() 

() 

2219


No.106April, 2015 119
 (2) 

513



() 
() 
1. 
2


2. 
5
() 
()
(1)
(2)

()  (201208)


() 


1. ()
1. 
103

3 (2

4
2. ()
(1) 


(

)


2
120No.106April, 2015
 5)
17 (SI)
18
2.  19
20
21
22
4 ()
23

24 ()
1
25
2
26
3 
4 ()
5

6
7 ()


8


() 
() ()

5


1 () 
2 1. 
3
4 2. 
5
6 () 161718
3

7 ()
8
9
10
() 
11

12
17

13

14
15
16
No.106April, 2015 121
 () 6

6





20130522
20130905

20131017

20131028- (
() 
1211 )

20140129-
() ()
0218

20140314

() 





()
() 
()

()

()

()C1C4

20151C1C4
20154
20141191116


(3)

201395
20131028
122No.106April, 2015

201412

()

1.
()
(2013)

2.
()
-14
()
(2013)

3.
http://mtbu.kcg.gov.tw/cht/project_LRT_circle.
php(2014)

4.
()
http://mtbu.kcg.gov.tw/cht/news_
content.php?sn=2014031401(2014.03.14)

5. C1C14
3

http://mtbu.kcg.gov.tw/cht/
LRT_C1C14_name/#(2014.10)

3
6.
C1-C14
http://mtbu.kcg.gov.tw/cht/news_content.
php?sn=2014101701(2014.10.17)

No.106April, 2015 123

3
SPECIAL REPORT

BOT
BOT

124No.106April, 2015

ABSTRACT

()BOT

()

1 2

2.5

400
3

(1)

590
591-1591-36776788156
59459581439
30,580.24
1,5373
1BOT(
)
google
1
No.106April, 2015 125
 (BOT)
201257
49930
3 100
1

1

2011/08/04
2011/08/042011/12/23
2011/08/042011/12/23 35%
2011/08/042012/01/19
2011/08/042012/08/07 (
2011/08/042012/08/14 2)2006
2011/08/042013/03/01 2012
2012/05/07

2012/02/172012/09/25
()2010630
2012/09/122013/06/30
0991871256
2013/03/012013/09/30
1
2013/09/012014/04/30

2013/12/012014/04/30

2013/12/102014/03/12

2014/03/142014/05/27 2010
2014/04/182014/05/28
1225
2014/05/292014/06/04
1001861459
2014/06/25

2014/06/30

2014/06/262014/07/24

2014/07/25

3 20101225

2010630
100 0991871256
14
313




126No.106April, 2015


20129





20145

24.8%(
S30%)67.06%
30%S55%
()32%
>55%0.94%

815
2
2012914
2012814




(102.09.12)243
(20129261012599012
3

262 2000
()

EL.1541 2714
35%
(S30%)38%
No.106April, 2015 127
 40%400%(
3)

(594
5958143)
2011107
3



3

201287785



2012122828

785 20129

()
2012917

2013
3 580
2,320

3 7

(12)


3,1002,300

128No.106April, 2015
 BOT
BOT
2014314BOT
5273
530
64625

2014725

20207 1. B O T ( h t t p : / /
6738 www.health.ntpc.gov.tw/informationlist.
1314 aspx?uid=310)(2014)
161,064
(4) 2. 1021225
BOT(2014)

3.

4 2014725

(BOT)
(2014)
3BOT
4. ( 1 ) h t t p : / /
www.health.ntpc.gov.tw/information.
aspx?uid=310&pid=4229(2)http://
www.health.ntpc.gov.tw/information.
aspx?uid=310&pid=3669
No.106April, 2015 129

400
SI

Word(
) ()5-6,0002.5312
1.5

l23







1
1

()6,000(A48())

12Table 1Figure 2

(l)
141-151
(1983)
BazantZ. P.and OhB. H.,Strain-rate effect in rapid triaxial loading of concreteJournal of
Engineering MechanicsASCEVol.108No.5, pp.764-782(1982).
(2)
177-184(1987)
Zienkiewicz, O. C.,The Finite Element Method, McGraw-Hill, London, pp.257-295(1977)
(3)
T71
25-30(1982)
Nasu, M. and Tamura, T.,Vibration test of the underground pipe with a comparatively large cross-section,
Proceedings of the Fifth World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Rome, Italy, pp.583-592(1973)
(4)
(1982)
Lin, C. H.,Rational for limits to reinforcement of tied concrete column,Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Civil
Engineering, University of Texas, Austin, Texas (1984).
(5)

No.53 (1983)
Thompson, J. P.,Fire resistance of reinforced concrete floorsPCA Report, Chicago, U.S.A., pp.1-15(1963).

130No.106April, 2015

2014APEC21PPP

106
PPP
PPP

PPP
PPP
PPP

7107

No.106April, 2015 131



11491
32310

107
2015731

132No.106April, 2015