Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Structural Design Engineer Predrag Error an engineer from former Yugoslavia and now
practicing in Middle East after gaining experience in Australia and Europe
Check and Certifying Engineer Thishan Jayasinghe A chartered engineer can certify only
up to four floors and beyond that needs a special permit.
Only the experienced members of Institution of Engineers, Sri Lanka with post graduate
degree in structural engineering can certify tall building having more than 20 floors needs a
special permission and name on the directory of structural engineers published annually and
used by the Urban Development Authority for approval
Coordinating Engineers Deepal Wickramasinghe and Bimal Fernando
Other tall apartment buildings Clearpoint
Vertical garden needed cantilevers up
to 4.8 m to plant trees not obstructed
by columns made possible with PT
Price Rs 35 to 40 million or
175,000 to 200,000 GB pounds
Will be affordable only if having
property in a more expensive country
Run by a management committee one
year after the sale of more than 80% of
the apartments
Inspiration from bridges 5.0 m cantilevers in pier capping
beam post-tensioned in two stages
During construction beams kept on pier capping beams
during construction
After completion where slender looking cantilevers carrying
heavy beams and highway traffic up to 45 units of HB
In use after completion of the 4 lane flyover
Other bridges with I girders of 25 m length with five and
three spans completed within a short period of 4 months
The concrete bridge with minimum carbon foot print cost is
only 10 GB pounds per sq ft, 300ft long and 10 ft wide
Bridge must assure that cultural pageants with elephants can use
the bridge so as construction vehicles can cross it hence
designed for 25 units of HB as for BS5400: Part2: 1978
Other buildings Fairmount and Sky-garden
Crescat Monarch in Colombo
Peak temperature variation of various concrete mixes with a placing temperature of 32oC
and 0% fly-ash
Use of charts to determine the likely temperature rise 15% fly
ash to replace the cement and hence cementatious content
Peak temperature variation of various concrete mixes with a placing temperature of 32oC
and 15% fly-ash
Use of charts to determine the likely temperature rise with 25%
fly ash the maximum that is used with confidence
Peak temperature variation of various concrete mixes with a placing temperature of 32oC
and 25% fly-ash
Use of transfer floors
Transfer floors will be very robust due to the large thickness
This will allow a massive torsional capacity since torsional shear stress can flow
in all directions within the slab
Hence very safe irrespective of the location of loads from above
However, punching shear could be a danger
Can be prevented easily be providing vertical properly anchored bars around
the critical perimeters
It is usual to anyway have H16 or H20 bars at 400 mm to 500 mm centers to
ensure a proper support for the top reinforcement mat
These r/f can act in shear once the concrete is hardened
The weight of the transfer floor is the biggest challenge
Will need a number of floors with shoring to take the load
Casting in two stages could be a better solution the solution adopted for
Crescat Monarch
The first stage could be a 350 to 400 mm slab which is propped again after the
removal of formwork to ensure that the bottom reinforcement will be stressed
to a lesser degree during casting of the remaining portion of transfer plate
The transfer floor of Crescat Monarch
Solution in Cinnamon Red Hotel
The construction was awarded to a leading construction firm in Sri Lanka on
fixed price design and built basis for a very high specification
The in-house design team (my students) designed the building working with the
architect nominated by the client
Due to car parks, restaurants, gymnasium, meeting rooms, etc. needed before
the start of the hotel floors, transfer floor was needed at the 10th floor level
The cost was becoming too much for the fixed price contract and I invited the
design team to go for a value engineering solution
The solid transfer plate of 1.5 m thickness was converted to a cellular structure
with top and bottom slab still looked like a solid slab, but it was hollow
The bottom slab of 350 mm thickness facilitated the construction and the top
slab of 250 assured flanged beam action
This solution resulted in a very significant reduction in the total concrete
volume and thus the weight of the super structure
The saving in the reinforcement was also very significant
The contractor was able to break even in this fixed price project due to the
massive savings possible with the value engineering solution
26 storey, 3 star city hotel with five star facilities
Cellular Transfer Plates Optimization
It needs a bottom slab of 350 or 400 mm acting as a flat slab initially
Can have shoring when the beams and the top slab is cast although slab alone
can take all the loads
This is for better composite action and also to assure that the reinforcement in
the slab can be reduced
Cheaper formwork not suitable for quality work can be utilized to form the
beams and the top slab since formwork cannot be recovered
Bottom slab must have two mats of reinforcement
The beams can be wide, but will not need to carry torsion
Hence, a width of 600 mm will be sufficient
The torsional shear will flow through the top and bottom slabs
Hence, a top slab of minimum 200 mm is needed and must be provided with
two mats of reinforcement
For deeper transfer cellular transfer plates or 2.0 m or 2.5 m depth, it is
advisable to use a top slab thickness of 250 mm and provided with adequate
reinforcement sometimes using H12 or H16 at critical locations to provide
adequate robustness and assure neutral axis remains in the top and bottom
flanges when subjected to flexure
Piles
A good understanding of the pile capacities is very useful
Rules of thumb 900 mm piles 3000 kN, 1000 mm 4000 kN
1200 mm 6500 kN, 1500 mm 10500 kN, 1800 mm 14000 kN, etc.
Such knowledge will allow easy selection of number of piles when the
column loads are known under service conditions
Must consider the effects of wind in all the critical directions
Earthquake resistance is gained by using ground beams to connect all the
individual pile caps
Ground beams can support the ground slab as well
Ground slab also can be about 200 mm thick and provided with a double
mats of reinforcement with H10 or H12 bars to assure a somewhat rigid
diaphragm at the ground floor level
Ground beams can be 800 mm to 1000 mm deep to give sufficient stiffness
to ensure the rotation at the ground level is almost zero
Ground beams are provided with little extra reinforcement to ensure extra
capacity for extreme events like earthquakes
Can we exceed the above capacities for piles? Can we optimize?
Piles carry vertical loads in end bearing and skin friction
End bearing will not generally exceed 5 N/mm2, but in very strong rock with
RQD close to 100%, can go up to 7 N/mm2
Hence the maximum capacity is limited
However, in very tall buildings, the above capacities can be totally
inadequate
In Altair, 1200 mm pile carried 11000 kN and 1500 mm diameter bored pile
carried 17000 kN
This is achieved by having 10 m socketing into the fractured rock where
almost all the load will be transferred via skin friction developed within the
severely fractured rock available over a significant depth
The geotechnical engineers general advice was not taken since it was too
conservative and would only suit a building not as tall as Altair
Test piles of 1200 mm diameter took 20000 kN without any settlement once
allowed for axial shortening
However, geotechnical engineers contribution was taken for the other
structures needed for shoring to facilitate the basement construction where
advanced 3D FEM modeling ensured minimum effect on adjacent structures
Lateral stability of piles and the building
Deep piles in very weak peaty soils can buckle and fail individually
This possibility must be considered and if it could happen, then use large
diameter piles that will never buckle (sometimes, more than 2.0 m and up to 2.5
m which will need BG 30 machines by Baur, Germony)
Lateral loads on the building can be resisted by the piles acting as a group since
connected by pile caps and ground beams
The behavior can be simulated by having lateral springs
A proper spring constant has to be used
For very weak cohesive soils, it could be 200 to 300 kN/m3
For sandy or laterite soils of tropical climates, it varies with the depth and can
even exceed 200,000 kN/m3 at a depth of 15-20 m
Piles are generally provided with 0.8% r/f at the top 12.0 m and can be reduced
or no r/f below this
Very close links (H10 at 125 mm spiral) in the top part of the piles
Pile caps must be designed properly with adequate reinforcement
A good practice to provide reinforcement in excess of minimum specified in the
standards along with some vertical reinforcement that can enhance shear
capacity that would be very useful during extreme events like earthquakes
BG 30 from Bauer up to 2.5 m diameter, easily 30 m or more depth with piles
completed within 24 hours due to efficient tools for breaking the rock for
socketing up to 2.0 m or more and adequate supply of concrete with truck
mixers generally, a 6 m3 truck is finished in less than 10 minutes
A model with super structure and sub-structure together with
soil represented by springs
The role of Euro Codes for Tall Buildings
Effects of axial shortening must be considered
Modern software like Midas Gen can easily handle that
Even ETABS models can be imported to Midas Gen and checked for axial
shortening
Effect of construction sequence must be considered
Even SAP 2000 allows simulation of staged construction
The forces and moments in Transfer Beams and Transfer Floors are adversely
affected by staged construction (Easily handled by ETABS and Midas Gen)
It could cause an increase of about 15-20% in the bending moments, about 10-
15% increase in shear
The effect on torsion may generally be less than 5%
The standards like Euro Codes may not be adequate sometimes since those are
written for normal structures and tall building fall to the very limit of the scope
covered with a general risk assessment
The designer must have his/her own rules that can be more stringent than what
is given in codes written for normal buildings where special attention is given to
assess the high risks and special precautions are taken to ensure absolute safety
Conclusions
Design of tall buildings is a very challenging task that involves a great deal of
risk assessment and taking additional precautions beyond normally
considered by standards
The designer can relax only if he is an expert and has an assurance that
his/her buildings are absolutely safe
Still, the analysis and design can be simplified significantly which will allow
optimization and must be very generous with the r/f of vertical members
Beams also need extra capacity in spans, but not over the supports
Transfer beams and transfer floors must be designed considering the loads as
for columns and also considering the additional moments due to construction
sequence
Pattern loading need not be considered for transfer beams and floors
Cellular transfer floors can easily replace more expensive thick solid slabs
that would be very difficult to construct due to weight and expensive due to
massive amount of concrete and reinforcement needed
Foundations need a very careful attention and modeling
Geotechnical engineer must advice, but structural engineer can work with
him/her to further optimize (joint work can bring better results)
Conclusions
The 3D computer model can be either a representation of the actual structure
(results in very heavy models that takes few hours or days to run) or
A very simple mathematical model that is very different to the actual structure,
but can give a very accurate simulation of behaviour and all the forces and
moments needed for design
My preference is for a mathematical model since I am a structural engineer
Architects are more interested in the real structure and its appearance since
they have to convince a lot of concerned parties like clients, authorities, etc.
However, some structural engineers like models that is appreciated and
understood by the architects/clients and hence produce very heavy models that
are very difficult to optimize
Sometimes, those heavy models are considered superior as well
However, the reality is that an accurate simple mathematical model which can
give answers in few seconds is the one that show the creativity of the structural
engineer and allow the rapid optimization as in a true design cycle where the
design engineer is expected to respond to the feedback obtained
We must understand the first principles very well to be successful as a tall
building designer and must have a well developed rules to handle situations,
most of which may be the structural engineers innovations
Acknowledgement
Excellent academic staff of University of Moratuwa who gave me a solid start
Prof Chris Burgoyne, my mentor and a brilliant engineer who showed me the way
forward when I read for Ph.D. at Engineering Department
Prof Christoper Calladine and other staff who made my life in Cambridge very
enjoyable and a life time experience and Cambridge Commonwealth Trust that
supported my scholarship
My very good friends, Prof Campbell Middleton and Prof Tim Ibell I am very lucky
to meet them in Cambridge as a student when they were also students and even today
that friendship continues with a deep understanding
Both, Cam and Tim and also my wife Chintha proof read my thesis and I was told
that there are no corrections after the viva by two top examiners, Prof Peter Waldron
from Bristol University and Dr Chris Morley from Cambridge University
The staff at University of Moratuwa for all the support and encouragement for career
development and generous funding for research and development
The Sri Lankan construction industry that allow us almost any wish we have to be
fulfilled with the research and development work with whole-hearted support
All my co-researchers for their hard work and support for research
Cambridge University Engineering Department academic and academic support staff
for their kind assistance to organize the lecture
Staff of University of Bath for facilitating our sabbatical leave at Bath
Opportunities for research collaborations
We have very strong links with the rapidly expanding construction industry in Sri Lanka
So, any joint research on tall buildings, highway bridges, box culverts, irrigation structures,
coastal structures, etc. would be possible
The model is that all the data collection to be in Sri Lanka and then data analysis, computer
modelling, etc. at Cambridge
Data collection can be by post graduate students reading for M.Sc. on fulltime or part-time
basis registered for M.Sc./M.Phil. degree at UOM
Split degrees are possible for those reading for Ph.D.
All the data collected will be made available in raw form to Cambridge
Instruments needed must be provided from Cambridge
A lot of funds are available to buy when can be used in future projects and hence less
burden on our overseas research partners if such equipment could be identified
So, we like to initiate a discussion on research collaboration with our friends at Engineering
Department, University of Cambridge
For example, every student of Faculty of Engineering of University of Moratuwa is entitled
to all the Midas software (Gen, Civil, FEA, GTS NX, Soil Works, NFX, NFX CFD, etc.)
on their laptops renewable on annual basis, so as all the staff for research and
developments, and teaching Midas is one of the best software platforms for structural
and geotechnical, but can be used in bio-medical, mechanical, robotics, air-craft, etc.
Such exceptional facilities are yet to become the norm even in advanced economies
Key words for searching on Internet about Sri Lanka (please see the images)
Altair Sri Lanka
Fairmount Rajagiriya
Sky-garden Rajagiriya
Clearpoint Rajagiriya
Elements Rajagiriya
Crescat Monarch
Heritanc, Kandalama, Cinnamon Bay, Beruwala Earls Regency, Kandy Citrus,
Wadduwa Magampura holiday resort Blue waters Wadduwa Rest house,
Polonnaruwa Jetwing Blue, Negambo
Ruins of Anuradhapura, Ruins of Polonnaruwa, Galle Fort, Sigiriya frescos
Dambulla rock temple, Yala Safari, Udawalawe Safari, Wilpattu Safari
Kandy perehera, Temple of tooth relic, Kandy, Colombo skyline
MAS Intimates Thurulie, Nelung Art Center (for green buildings)
Green projects in Sri Lanka
Solar revolution in Sri Lanka
Economic indicators for Sri Lanka
Architect Moshe Safdie the world famous architect of Altair
ICSECM 2017 The international conference on Structural Engineering and Construction
Management to be held on 7th, 8th and 9th of December, 2017 for the 8th consecutive year
Useful information about other projects of
Prof M T R Jayasinghe
B.Sc. Eng. (Moratuwa), Ph.D. (Cambridge), C.Eng., MIE (SL), MSSE (SL)
Senior Professor,
Department of Civil Engineering
University of Moratuwa
Moratuwa,
Sri Lanka
Few other useful products and
rapidly constructable systems
Initiatives by Prof M T R Jayasinghe to apply
the findings of the published research and
development carried out at Department of
Civil Engineering of University of Moratuwa
by himself and by his colleagues
Straw panels as a walling material where each board is 2.4 m
x 1.2 m where the flexural strength in 1.2 m direction
Testing on Durra panels (compressed straw panels) with model
testing and the construction of walls for the two storey house
Construction of a two storey house with straw panels as loadbearing
walls, slabs, and ceiling material
Method used to convince the general public of the load
carrying capacity of compressed straw panels by the
manufacturing company
The completed house with straw panels
The two storey house with the walls, floors and the ceiling all out of Durra
including bathroom areas
Use of precast prestressed concrete panels of 1.0 m width, 75 mm
thickness and up to 6.0 m length for concrete floors - Panels connected
with 40 mm thick reinforced chip concrete screed and also made
continuous over the steel beams with special arrangements
Pre-cast Pre-tensioned slabs spanning on steel beams with a reinforced in-situ topping on top
Precast prestressed concrete panels made continuous with
an innovative method to reduce vibrations in thin panels
A/C ducts of air conditioning system with 100% recharge mounted under the
structural members for the four operation theaters in the ground floor
Precast concrete floor completed with ceramic tiles and the ceiling erected
rapidly with Durra Panels (only two days were needed in this of 50 m length x
15 m width for the completion of the ceiling) the same Durra panels with
flexi-sheet mounting have been used for the interior skin of the walls to have
adequate water proofing capacity needed in a hospital to allow cleaning
Rapidly constructed buildings with alternative materials and
systems the background
Serious problem in a 8 storey building of a base hospital in Sri Lanka managed by the
Western Provincial Council
We issued the evacuation order after the investigation
The total area of the hospital was 110,000 sq ft
8 storey building had 70,000 sq ft
Hospital lost nearly 2/3 of space overnight
This created a very serious situation needing the GOSL Minister of Health to intervene
So, I promised 50,000 sq ft in 50 days out of which, 30,000 sq ft in 30 days at a total cost
of Rs 200 million (1,000,000 GB pounds or a good house close to Cambridge city with
2000 sq ft) to be constructed by a Semi Government Construction Company
We gave 58,000 sq ft in three numbers of two storey buildings (50 m x 15 m footprint
per two storey building) and a three storey building with 30 m x 12 m foot print) in 52
days
We also met the 30 day dead line by completing two numbers of two storey buildings
We used alternative materials and systems to achieve this
Most of the buildings came in prefabricated form which means when one Durra Panle
was fixed, an area of 1.2 m x 2.4 m is completed
One precast panel of 6.0 m length x 1.0 m width is placed as a slab, a total of 6.0 m2 of
slab would be ready receive the insitu cast screed to complete the upper floor
Alternative systems have resulted in a much shorter construction time at
Negambo hospital the progress at 6th of July at foundation level where a
foundation consisting of a cellular raft combined with isolated footings could
be completed only in two days covering an area of 50 m length x 15 m width
Progress 16th July the buildings with 3.0 m long eaves
to ensure adequate shading
23rd of July, 2015 Two storey buildings that can resist cyclones of probable
magnitude in Negambo and also an earthquake up to 7 on Richter scale
completed with actual work started on 24th of June, 2015 A classic example for
countries needing rapidly completed shelter for those displaced by natural events
Three story building the same concept can be used even in a tall
building once adequate attention is paid to detail the cost was Rs
3600/= per sq ft or 18 GB pounds per sq ft
Two storey house with light weight panels the structrue to be completed in 20
days for a two stoery house with living, dining, pantry, a bed room in ground
floor, a toilet and bath at ground and upper, a store room, three bed rooms in the
upper floor with one study room and a balcony and a roof top garden at the
second floor level with a water tank located over the staircase, floor to floor height
of 3.0 m cost of the structure to be Rs 3000 per sq ft or 15 GB pounds per sq ft
and also using a lot of waste materials
Staircase out of lightweight panels with a density of 600 kg/m3 due to the
use of recycled Expanded Poly-Styrene with cement, sand, fly-ash and fire
resistance given by the two cement fiber boards of 5 mm on wither side
Precast prestressed concrete beams used for slabs to give a light weight,
but very robust slab (in innovation by Dr A N S Kulasinghe, the eminent
civil engineer of Sri Lanka and now coordinated by the NERD center)
Placing of precast beams for the upper floor slab manufactured by Ekala
Concrete Works under license from NERD Center
https://www.construction360.lk/construction-company-srilanka/m5c=/Ekala_Prestressed_Concrete_Industries_(Pvt)_Ltd.html
Two storey house with the beams of roof slab placed prior to concreting Also shown is the
factory used for manufacturing the light weight panels and a heap of used EPS kept ready
for crushing to form individual beads to be mixed with cement, sand, fly-ash and admixture
to create foam concrete of very low density - This two storey house will be instrumented
and then load tested for both vertical and lateral loads to determine the behaviour under
service conditions and with limited overload as part of a final year undergraduate research
project of Department of Civil Engineering, University of Moratuwa, Moratuwa, Sri Lanka
Tiered house for areas prone to landslides where the foundation and retaining
walls constructed with cement stabilsed rammed earth (6% cement) and also
with cement stabilised earth blocks (CSEB), micro concrete tiles at a cost of 10
GB pounds per square foot (Rs 2000 per sq ft) for a CSR initiative of a
leading cement manufacturing company in Sri Lanka in year 2014
For further information or research
collaborations, please contact Prof M T R
Jayasinghe, Senior Professor, Department of
Civil Engineering, University of Moratuwa,
Moratuwa, Sri Lanka at
mtrjayasinghe@yahoo.com
http://www.civil.mrt.ac.lk/Academic_Profiles/mtrj/index.html