Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In The Case Against The Case Against Pop Music, the author, James Maclaren, disagrees with
Paul Watsons video against todays pop music. Although Watson argues that todays music is
homogenized that results in the narrowing of the range in chord progression and instrumentation,
the author recognizes that the genre of popular music is based on the relationship between
producers and customers. In other words, popular music is influenced by what customers want to
hear: upbeat and catchy tunes. In addition, Maclaren acknowledges the differences in music
throughout the decades, which results in a different crowds of different tastes in music.
Maclarens purpose is to inform audiences that popular music is all about what it makes the
listener feel.
Evaluation:
Maclaren has shown the complexity of pop music, which stems from the music in previous
decades. It would be a great addition to a piece about the history of pop music as it looks into
what popular music is defined as, despite the hatred it may be receiving in the 21st century. It is
convincing to the point where it can relate to the reader, because Maclaren informs the audience
that all music is a form of sound; it only takes an interested listener to appreciate an artists work
of their liking.
Reflection:
The overall takeaway from this article is the definition of popular music. Technically speaking,
when regarding to the genre of popular music, it has an umbrella that consists of a variety of
genres including rock, disco, blues, soul, hip hop, rap, and much more. Pop is not a genre that
differentiates from another, but is rather a category that is widely accepted by the population.
With that being said, not all individuals will enjoy listening to a certain genre within pop music,
because everyone will always have their own opinions on it.
Evaluation:
With its accreditation from a university, it is useful in a sense that it covers the history of music
starting back from the late 19th century with the inventions of musical equipment, such as the
gramophone and sheet music. Further into the text, the author includes the inventions of the
radio, tape recorders, discs, and the television, which influenced the rise of different genres. The
organization of the text is in a chronological timeline of influential moments that resulted with
what is known as pop musics history. The sources abundance of information can further
present the details in a piece focusing on the evolution of pop music.
Reflection:
Sections of this text shows a better understanding of how popular music genres influence one
another; they are all related in some way. It has shown that physical inventions, such as the
television, can influence an audience to be more interested in a genre of music. In this case
specifically, the television presented the show, MTV2, which highlighted hip hop and rap music.
Because of this, the population tuned in on their televisions to listen to this form of music,
making it more popular. With this texts thoroughness, it can be concluded that popular music
has a long, complex, history.
Evaluation:
The text is considered credible with actual researchers who classified the causes of certain
genres. The author recognizes how the three major revolutions of rock, soul, disco, hip hop, and
rap gained popularity in the society. This source would be a useful addition to a project on the
evolution of popular music as it presents the shifts between music throughout the decades.
Reflection:
From this piece, the audience is informed of popular music with an overall view in a concise
manner. The evolution of pop music occurs with three major revolutions in which the musical
genres of rock, soul, disco, and hip hop are widely appealed to the public. This text has shown
that every decade or two focus on different types of genres, which shows popular musics
complexity.
Evaluation:
Snows use of visuals to convey his message gives a better understanding for the audience, being
easier to follow. It would be a helpful analysis when studying the evolution of pop music as it
recognizes the specific lyrics, ethnicities, genres, and topics that artists wrote about throughout
the past century. As a whole, the author recognizes the differences of pop music within the
previous decades as generative differences in which the diversity of people and ideas create a
better quality and sound.
Reflection:
From this text, it is acknowledged that the differences of music are much more accepted in this
generations compared to the past. More people start to accept their differences over time. As a
result, there is a rise in collaboration between different musicians and backgrounds creating a
beautiful variety of music. The potential historic phenomena in the second half of the 20th
century may have influenced the idea of respecting others differences, which also caused a
change in music.
Evaluation:
This audio clip can be used as a differentiating form of a text that still focuses on the evolution of
music with a concise analysis of musical revolutions. The discussion between Grimm and Bard
convey the importance in appreciating different types of music as they widely appeal to the
public at different times. It is compared to the biological evolution in that music has an origin
that branches out into different genres. Because of these revolutions full of uniqueness, it has
resulted todays music to be more diverse and multi-faceted.
Reflection:
From this podcast, it is shown that the evolution of pop music is still appreciated and recognized
through audio clips. It is emphasized in a sense that popular music will always be diverse,
because there have been multiple revolutions that influence what pop music is today. It is also
considered mathematical, because genres can result with the combination of more than one
genre, further emphasizing its complexity.
Evaluation:
In this scientific journal, researchers have shown that the evolution of music is influenced from a
human cultural trait that is measurable through digital recordings. The fact that researchers
implicated the evolution of music through a study shows that the text is much more credible with
a closer look into musical influences. This text can be utilized as a distinct approach to analyzing
the evolution of pop music with the technical principles of sound waves and musical properties.
Reflection:
The main takeaway from this text is the idea of pop music evolving due to the process of
modifying existing music. It is interpreted in a way that a style is inherited from a previous one.
Popular music is heavily influenced by the changes in culture, especially social impacts. From
this research, it is understood that the changes of popular music can be analyzed into more depth
as it can focus on the different frequencies of sound waves. From that, conclusions about the
publics appeal can be made.