You are on page 1of 17

ISSN 1597 – 8842 Vol.1 No.

45
Contents

• Executive Summary
03
o Background Highlights from Previous Reports
o The Expectations of Management in 2010 – An Insight

• Fundamental Analysis
05

• Technical Analysis
13

• The Analyst Opinion


15

ISSN 1597 – 8842 Vol.1 No. 45

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 2


Access Bank Plc
ISSN 1597 – 8842 Vol.1 No. 45
STOCK FAST DATA
August 26, 2010 – Latest Updates

Overview:
Industry: Fin. Institutions
This snapshot serves as an extension of our earlier NSE Symbol: Access
comprehensive analyst report on Access Bank Plc FYE: December
published on April 30th, 2010. Latest Results: Q2 2010
(http://www.proshareng.com/reports/view.php?id=2607). YTD Returns: 6.09 %
Year High: N11.21
In our analyst report referred to above, the following
Year Low: N7.55
issues were raised for consideration by the
management in the interest of the shareholders of Year’s Ave. Price: N8.95
the entity and to improve on the profile of the bank Shares in issue: 17.888bn
in the market, and as a comparison with its peers. Market Cap: N144.828b
Last Traded Price: N8.01

Background Highlights from Previous Reports


20 Days MA: N8.37
• The management’s claim of an improvement 50 Days MA: N8.31
on operating expenses was confirmed to be 200 Days MA: N8.63
true only for the bank. The group results
recorded a monthly average of N3.99bn for nine months period compared with
N3.25bn for the comparative twelve months period.

• Having been cleared by the CBN, it was generally expected that the bank would
be spared the burden of the need for additional loan loss provisions or provision
for risky assets to the tune of N16.65bn; except in the course of normal business
during the period under review.

• Improvements were recorded on the bank’s non-performing loan outlook in the


Q1 2010 figures; hence the coverage ratio thinned down to 9% from 19% of the
preceding reported period. The bank achieved an improvement in the capital
adequacy ratio (CAR) and liquidity ratio.

• We raised an issue with the treatment of dividend and the issuance of a


scrip/bonus of 1 for every 10 shares held given to investors at the end of the
financial year – to ‘reward’ investors in the bank who might have been worried by
the negative returns the bank posted in its common year end result. Our position
on this was that the scrip issue, just as with other banks, will put more pressure
on the earnings distribution to investors in the days ahead (though number of
shares outstanding remains relative).

• The technical analysis conducted in the report indicated that for the fifteen
months to April 23, 2010 – the stocks recorded an appreciation of +30.55%
(over 60% change in value year on year) making it one of the Top five (5) stocks
in the banking sector which have recorded price appreciations above their
January 02, 2009 price levels.

According to the Group Managing Director of Access Bank Plc, in his presentation to the
investing public (http://www.proshareng.com/reports/view.php?id=2849) for the period under

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 3


reference; it was reported that Access Bank Plc had returned to a strong profitability
base, driven by an increased lending to the bank’s target clients.

In the said reported, the CEO stated that the Management has maintained a strategy of
balance sheet expansion with lending growing by 15% quarter on quarter. He further
stated that during the reporting period under review, Access Bank Management
continued to deploy the bank’s value chain strategy and its one-bank customer
proposition to expand its market share of high quality assets and low cost deposits.
Further highlights raised in the Managing Director’s speech are as follows:

• Championing International Financial Reporting Standards adoption in Nigeria;

• Introduction of 1 year fixed rate term deposit product in Nigeria;

• Launching of the Group’s International Private Banking Service;

• Growing exposure to Real Economy risk assets leveraging on government


sponsored lending programs; and

• Standard & Poor’s (S&P) Nigerian A- rating affirmed

The Expectations of Management in 2010

Management Expectation Expressed Our Assessment/Evaluation


• Expansion of the bank’s market This could not be seen in the gross
share of the top corporate segment earnings of the bank
• Maintaining a high level of capital
and liquidity. The liquidity ratio dipped from 41% to 40%
• Cost of risk reduction The loan loss provision declare could not
support this
• Developing further leading role in
talent acquisition and talent development.
• Maintaining leading role in Treasury,
Trade Finance and Electronic cash
management.
• Building further on the cost The cost to income ratio trend seems to
efficiency of the Group. support this
• Eliminating the negative The claim of improvement in the
performance contributions of our Banking subsidiaries contribution seems to support
subsidiaries through the bank’s “One Bank” this.
strategy.

This edition of the Access Bank Plc equity snapshot focuses on its H1 2010 results for the
period ended 30th June, 2010; recently released.

A comparison of the results with the bank’s first quarter results for the period ended 31st
March, 2010 was conducted as an aide memoiré, as well as a review with the previous
year’s comparable period results for the period ended 31st March, 2009.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 4


In arriving at our objective conclusion, we employed fundamental and technical analysis
approaches to examine in a snapshot, the bank's financials as well as its price trend. A
general review of the comments made above by the CEO was validated with the results
released and the analyst’s presentation - http://www.proshareng.com/reports/view.php?id=2851.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 5


Fundamental Analysis

Peer Gross Earnings & PA


Second Q
Curre
Gros
Company Earnin
Access Bank Plc 49,
Diamond Bank Plc Peer Assesm 46,
FCMB
Banks
Market Price - 1729,
Aug
Fidelity Bank Plc 27,
Access Bank Plc 8.32
First Bank
Diamond NigPlc
Bank Plc 6.90122,
Guaranty Trust Bank Plc 7.1582,
Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 6
FCMB
Fidelity Bank Plc Bank Plc
Intercontinental 2.5542,
Financials Reviewed

ACCESS BANK P

ASSETS:
Cash and balances with CBN
Treasury bills
Due from other banks
Loan and advances
On-Lending Facilities
advances under finance lease
Investment securities
Investment in Subsidiaries
Investment Properties
Investment In Associates
Other Assets
Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 7

Deferred Tax Asset


ACCESS

Profit and Loss Account

Gross Earnings
Revenue and Profitability: Gross earnings in Q2 recorded a decline by -19.47% to

Interest and Similar Income


close at N49.409bn from N61.351bn recorded in June 30th, 2009; and against the growth
by +4.34%; to close at N27.778bn posted in Q1 of the period ended 31st March, 2010.
The decline recorded in the gross earnings could be attributed to the differing rates of

Interest and Similar Expenses


decline recorded in almost all the income components.

We hope this will be reversed in the coming periods, given the reason provided by the

Net Interest Income


bank as the foundational basis for the drop in gross earnings - the slow economic
recovery and tight credit conditions.

Other Income
Operating Income
Operating Expenses
Loan loss Expenses
Write back/(allowances) for other assets
Group's share of associate's (loss)/profit
Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 8

Profit/(loss) Before Taxation


The profitability outlook of the bank however improved quite significantly during the
period - profit after tax grew by +155.78% to close at N6.667bn, an outstanding
recovery from the loss of N11.952bn recorded in the preceding year comparable period.

The profit should have been higher but for the allowances made for assets and
investments (loan loss provisions) to the tune of N23.821bn made in Q2. The bank
eventually doled out a N0.20k interim dividend to its numerous shareholders.

Improvements in the company’s profit margin (according to the management) could also
be traced to the benefit of its one-bank strategy which, it was claimed, added to the
bottom line. Subsidiaries with marginal losses are also expected to break-even by end of
the year, according to the management.

The profit after tax (PAT) declared in Q2 reflected a drag when compared with the
N4.021bn reported in Q1 to March 31st, 2010.

Cost to Income Ratio: The bank’s efficiency ratio measured by cost to income ratio
(exclusive of loan loss provisions) showed a level of improvement to stand at 79%
compared with 81.54% reported as at 31st March 2010. The rate closed at 106.66% as
at December 31st 2009.

The improvement recorded could be spotted in interest expenses components which


declined by -39.87%. The management of the bank will have to do a lot more to trim
down this as a means to profitability boost in the coming periods.

The improvement recorded, according to the Management, was attributed to the benefit
accruing from the cost and revenue synergies of the bank’s regional expansion even as
expense growth rate decelerated from an average of 40% to 11% in H1 2010.

The Management has expressed its commitment to bringing down the cost to income
ratio to 60% by the end of the year.

We are of the view that actualisation of this objective will be a plus for the bank and its
entire shareholders as such would translate to higher profit/returns.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 9


Return on Assets and Equities: Access Bank’s Return on Assets (ROA) and Return on
Equity in the period under review closed higher at +0.90% and +3.82% respectively
compared with +0.60% and +2.37% reported at the end of Q1 2010.

Capital Adequacy Ratio

Capital adequacy ratio measures the capital strength of the bank for continuity, relating
to its business obligations and liabilities. Access Bank Plc’s capital adequacy ratio (CAR)
assumed a decline to 29% in Q1 2010 from 34% recorded in the half year reporting
period of H1 2009. It therefore declined by 28% in June 2010.

The continuous loan loss provision could be the cause for this trend. If the bank
intensifies work on its risk-based management of its assets; it might need to retain a
focus on the components of its asset quality that contributes to its strong CAR. Though
according to the management, the CAR is strong and well in excess of regulatory
minimum, and is adequate to support business growth and expansion.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 10


Liquidty Ratio

This measures the liquidity position against immediate obligation and liabilities of the
bank. The ratio declined from 41% in Q1 to 40% as at June 30 th, 2010. Meanwhile, the
bank’s liquidity outlook was considerably maintained at 40% achieved this quarter
against 27% growth recorded in half year 2009.

Deposit Growth

The deposit growth measures client’s patronage which translates to market share of the
entity within the industry. Access Bank’s deposit growth grew by 15% in Q2 for the
period ended June 30th 2010.

When compared with the 59% growth achieved in preceding year comparable period to
June 30th 2009. The decline in growth trend recorded in deposit growth negates top
objective set by the management for the year; we hope this can be improved on before
the financial year runs out.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 11


Loan and Advances

Loan and Advances remains one of the instruments considered to measure the lending
rate of a commercial bank, which further reveals the position of core business of the
bank. Access Bank Plc recorded negative growth of -4% in Q2 for the period ended June
30th 2010 as against a positive growth of 28% recorded in Q2 2009.

The gradual decline since half year 2008 revealed that the bank has not been active in
terms of lending most probably due to risk aversion. This must have impacted negatively
on net interest income generated for the period.

The chart below explains how the operational activities has been funded during the
period under review; deposit from customers represented the bulk of the funding
components with 59% contribution followed by shareholders fund with 23% stake in
contribution to funding. Other liabilities and dues to other banks had 10% and 8%
respectively.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 12


Non Performing Loan Ratio

The non performing loan ratio measures the ratio of loans that are on the doubtful or
bad category in the book of the bank. The chart below reveals the pictorial performance
of activities of the banks in its loan book. The spike in NPL ratio to 12% from 10%
recorded in Q1 still reveals issues in the loan quality of the bank.

The chart below highlights sectoral performance of the non-performing loans. This chart
revealed the sector(s) where the non performing loans were invested.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 13


Technical Analysis

The share price of Access Bank Plc in the last nineteen months has recorded a +9.73%
appreciations from the N7.30 price it attained at the end of January 2 nd, 2009 – closing
at N8.01 (as at Friday, 27th August, 2010). However, in the preceding year to the
period (2008), the company’s share price declined by -70.54% from N24.00 it closed at
the end of the first trading day of the year to close and ended up with N7.07 by
December 31st, 2008.

The share price of the company in the year 2009 reached the peak of N10.85 on June
1st 2009 while it touched the lowest point on February 2nd, 2009 at N3.54.

In the year 2009 alone, the stock price closed with +4.20% appreciations from N7.30 of
January 2nd, 2009 to close at N7.60 by December 31st, 2009. The year to date
appreciation of Access Bank Plc closed at +6.09% as at 26th August, 2010 to close at
N8.01 from N7.55 it closed on January 4th 2010. Access Bank Plc stock price
performance stands far below the performance of the NSE All-Share Index
which recorded a +16% YTD growth.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 14


In the year 2010 to date performance analysis, Access Bank Plc performed below the
ASI with +6.90% growth compared with +16% ASI appreciations for the same
comparable period.

Technically, and as can be seen from the graph below, Access Bank Plc share price now
trades below its 20 days, 50 days and 200 days moving averages of N8.37, N8.31 and
N8.63 respectively.

Thus, the Access Bank Plc share has to trade above its 200 days moving average and
sustain it to show indications that the stock is getting ready to assume a bullish
outlook/trend.

The stock price assumed a bearish trend on August 10th 2010 when it started trading
below its 200 days moving average and has been in the mode till date.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 15


Analyst Opinion:

Access Bank Plc’s Q2 2010 review showed that the bank is making progress in its
bottom-line, with profit growing on a quarter to quarter basis; recovering from N11.952
bn loss position to close at N6.653bn profit in Q2 2010 to June 30th, 2010.

As impressive as that seems, it would not be out of place to review the improvements in
earnings against the declines recorded in some of the income components of the entity.

The loan loss expense that appeared in the Q2 2010 report was unexpected; since the
management previously stated there had been full provisions for all known non-
performing loans. The only reason for this would have to be the CBN directive for
handling margin loans due to expire on September 1, 2010.

The continuous provisioning for risk(y) assets in its Q2 and as repeated in Q1 2010
return creates the impression of a judgment made in anticipation of a future loan loss; a
contradiction of sorts.

Be that as it may, we remain encouraged by the indices shown in the management


returns for the quarter and the plans/initiatives laid out by the banks’ management to
further strengthen the profitability drive in the coming periods.

We hope the management will make good its objective of trimming down the cost to
income ratio in the coming reporting periods as this will raise the profitability profile of
the entity and translate this to increasing returns to investors.

This we believe will further reposition the bank amongst the comity of banks in the
country.

End.

Access Bank Plc Equity Snapshot August 2010 www.proshareng.com Page 16


ADVICE TO USERS OF THIS REPORT
You are given the limited right to print this report and to Nothing published in this report and on our site should be
distribute it by any means. You can print out pages and use considered as investment advice. Any prediction made on
them in your private discussion groups as long as you the direction of the stock market or on the direction of
acknowledge PROSHARE and you do not alter the report i ndivi dual stocks may prove to be i ncorrect.
in any way. Most importantly, you should not charge for it. Readers/Users/visitors are expected to refer to other
investment resources to verify the accuracy of the data
Stock trading is inherently risky and you agree to assume published in the report on their own. Neither Proshare nor
complete and full responsibility for the outcomes of all its principals, agents, associates, employees or licensed
trading decisions that you make, including but not limited stockbrokers, are licensed to provide investment advice
to loss of capital. None of the stock tr ading calls made by through this publication.
Proshare, its analyst board, employees, contributing
partners and companies associated with it should be No materials in the report, either on behalf of Proshare, or
construed as an offer to buy or sell securities, nor advice to any participant in The Analyst Network should be taken as
do so. Proshare is not responsible for any errors, investment advice directly, indirectly, implicitly, or in any
omissions or representations on any of the pages in this manner whatsoever, including but not limited to trading of
report. Proshare does not endorse in anyway any stocks on a short term or long term basis, or trading of any
advertisers or firm(s) used as case studies in the report. financial instruments whatsoever. Past Performance Is
Please verify the veracity of all information on your own Not Indicative of Future Returns. All analyst commentary
before undertaking any alliance. provided in this report is provided for information purposes
only. This information is NOT a recommendation or
Our opinions and analyses are based on sources believed solicitation to buy or sell any securities. Your use of this
to be reliable and are written in good faith, but no and all information contained in this report is governed by
representation or warranty, expressed or implied, is made this Terms and Conditions of Use. This material is based
as to their accuracy or completeness. The information in upon information that we consider reliable, but we do not
this report is updated from time to time. Proshare however represent that it is accurate or complete, and that it should
excludes any warranties (whether expressed or implied), be relied upon, as such.
as to the quality, accuracy, efficacy, completeness,
performance, fitness or any of the contents of the report, You should not rely solely on the Information in making any
including (but not limited) to any comments, feedback, investment. Rather, you should use the Information only
interviews, articles reproduced and advertisements as a starting point for doing additional independent
contained in the report. research in order to allow you to form your own opinion
regarding investments. By using this report including any
All information contained in our report or on our website software and content contained therein, you agree that
should be independently verified with the companies use of the Service is entirely at your own risk. Any
mentioned. information, opinions, advice or offers posted

The editor and publisher are not responsible for errors or by any person or entity logged in to the Proshare website
omissions. You should consult a qualified broker or other or any of its associated sites is to be construed as public
financial advisor prior to making any actual investment or conversation only. Proshare makes no warranties and
trading decisions. You agree to not make actual stock gives no assurances r egarding the truth, timeliness,
trades based on comments in the report, nor on any reliability, or good faith of any material posted at Proshare.
techniques presented nor discussed in this report or any
other form of information presentation. All information is Proshare Nigeria is the country's premier investor
for educational and informational use only. You agree to relations/education and analyst services platform
consult with a registered investment advisor, which we are providing a critical role in ensuring that market confidence
not, prior to making any trading decision of any kind. & safety is enshrined in the conduct of/and market reliance
Hypothetical or simulated performance results have on the information and activities of firms quoted on the
certain inherent limitations. Unlike an actual performance Nigerian Stock Exchange; as a wealth creator for the
record, simulated results do not represent actual trading. investing public. In delivering this service, the firm works
Since the trades have not been executed, the results may with and thro ugh organisations with distinct service
have under or over compensated for the impact. No competencies in stock investment analysis, investor tools
representation is being made that any account will or is and solutions and capital market practices; all designed to
likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those shown in provide investors with a credible resource for intelligent
the report. decision making.

Proshare receives no compensation of any kind from any The firm takes extra steps to ensure that information
companies that may be mentioned in our reports or on our provided by it are accurate, fact checked and validated for
web site. Any opinions expressed are subject to change compliance with internationally acceptable standards and
without notice. Owners, employees and writers may hold practices. While this report is checked for accuracy, we are
positions in the securities that are discussed in our report not liable for any incorrect inform ation included. We
or on our web site. Any reference to a trade men tioned in recommend that you make enquiries based on your own
the report or website, e-mail, publication or material is circumstances and, if necessary, seek professional advice
hypothetical and is not an actual trade. Hypothetical before entering into transactions. We are always happy to
performances and results do not represent actual cost of a receive your comments on how we can improve our
trade. services and make it more meaningful to the investing
public. Should you be interested in contacting us for
We encourage all investors to use the information in the further discussions on how such reports can be made
report as a resource only to further their own research on more meaningful to you or your organisation/investment
Access Bank Plc
all featured Equity Snapshot
companies, stocks, August
sectors,2010
markets and www.proshareng.com
club; kindly contact analyst@proshareng.com Page 17
information presented in the report and on our site.

You might also like