Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
A. Governing Law
1. The law governing wills and intestate succession developed from the common law and has largely
been codified in the statutes of the 50 states, the District of Columbia, and the territories.
2. Where the law has not been codified in statute, those states have typically adopted the Uniform
Probate Code (UPC), either in whole or in part.
a. Another important source is the Restatement (Third) of Property: Wills and Other Donative
Transfers.
B. Definitions
2. A decedents estate is the real and personal property the decedent leaves at death.
3. A person who dies without a will dies intestate; one who dies leaving a will dies testate.
5. If the party deceases with a valid will, the personal representative is known as:
6. Issue includes all lineal descendants from an ancestor in any degree, e.g., children, grandchildren,
etc.
II. INTESTATE DISTRIBUTION
A. In General
1. A person who dies without a will dies intestate; his estate is an intestate estate.
2. Property of the estate that, for some reason, does not pass under a will passes according to the
intestacy laws, which are called the laws of descent and distribution.
B. Statutory Provisions
1. Spouse Survives
a. If there is no surviving descendant or parents, the entire estate goes to the surviving spouse.
(1) In some instances (e.g., divorce or annulment), a spouse is disqualified from taking
pursuant to the laws of intestacy.
b. If there are surviving descendants of the decedent, all of whom are issue of the surviving
spouse, and the surviving spouse has one or more surviving descendants who are not
descendants of the decedent, the first $225,000 plus one-half of the balance of the intestate
estate goes to the surviving spouse.
(1) The remaining portion of the estate is divided among the descendants.
c. If there are surviving descendants of the decedent, one or more of whom are not issue of the
surviving spouse:
(1) If the decedent leaves behind children, but one or more of those children has died, then
the surviving children of the decedent-child will take the decedent-childs share by
representation.
3. Escheat
a. If there is no spouse or other person entitled to inherit under the statute, the property
escheats (passes) to the state.
a. If the time of death of the decedent or the heir, or both, cannot be determined so as to
establish that the decedent survived the heir by 120 hours, the otherwise heir will be deemed
to have failed to survive the 120-hour period.
b. The UPC further adds a clear and convincing evidence standardof proof. Thus, a person who
cannot be established by clear and convincing evidence to have survived the decedent by
120 hours is deemed to have predeceased the decedent.
c. Under the UPC, the 120-hour requirement of survival applies not only to probate transfers,
but also to:
C. Special Problems of Intestate Distribution
2. Adopted Children
a. If the natural parent remarries and consents to the adoption of his child by his new spouse,
the right of the adopted child to inherit from bothof his natural parents is not affected. A
parent-child relationship exists between an individual who is adopted by the spouse of either
natural parent and:
(1) the genetic parent whose spouse adopted the individual; and
(2) the other genetic parent, but only for the purpose of the right of the adoptee or a
descendant of the adoptee to inherit from or through the other genetic parent.
3. Stepchildren
4. Half-Blood Relatives
a. Half-blood relatives are siblings of the decedent by only one of his parents; their
representatives take equally with relatives of the whole blood and their representatives.
5. Nonmarital Children
a. A child born out of wedlock is considered the child of his mother and her kindred for purposes
of intestate inheritance.
b. A child born out of wedlock is considered to be the child of his father when the identity of the
father is determined in any one of the following ways:
(1) the parents marry each other;
(2) during the lifetime of the child, the father openly holds out the child to be his and
receives the child into his home, or openly holds the child out to be his and provides
support for the child; or
(3)
c. A father who has refused to acknowledge paternity should be barred from inheriting from or
through the child.
6. Posthumous Children
a. Children already in utero at the time of the fathers death are entitled to inherit from the
father, assuming they are born within 10 months of the fathers death.
D. Advancements
1. Under the UPC, if a person dies intestate as to all or any part of his estate, property that he gave
to an heir in his lifetime is treated as an advancement against the estate only if:
b. the decedents contemporaneous writing or the heirs written acknowledgement indicate that
the gift is to be taken into account in computing the division and distribution of the
decedents intestate estate.
III. EXECUTION OF ORDINARY WILLS
A. In General
1. A will is a document executed by a testator that takes effect on the death of the testator.
1. Age
2. Mental Capacity
a. In addition to meeting the age requirement, a testator must be of sound mind in order to
make a valid will.
b. Generally speaking, of sound mind means that the testator, at the time the will is executed,
must have the ability to understand:
(1) the nature, condition, and extent of his property;
(2) the nature of the disposition that he is making of his property; and
(3)
a. in writing;
b. signed by the testator or in the testators name by some other individual in the testators
conscious presence and by the testators direction; and
(1) There is no requirement that the testators signature be at the end of the will. Thus, if the
testator writes his name in the body of the will and intends it to be his signature, the
statute is satisfied.
c. either:
(1) signed by at least two individuals, each of whom signed within a reasonable time after
the individual witnessed either the signing of the will or the testators acknowledgement
of that signature or acknowledgment of the will; or
(2) acknowledged by the testator before a notary public or other individual authorized by
law to take acknowledgments.
(a) Under the UPC, a witness may be:
2. A fully effective will must also show the indispensable element of testamentary intent.
a. To be a will, the document must be executed with testamentary intentthat is, the decedent
must intend the document to be a will or to become operative at the decedents death.
D. Probate of Will
1. The proving of a will involves the process by which the testators signature is established.
2. Self-Proving Will
a. If the will is self-proved, the will satisfies the requirements for execution without the
testimony of any attesting witness upon the filing of the will and the acknowledgment and
affidavits annexed or attached to it, unless there is evidence of fraud or forgery affecting the
acknowledgment or affidavit. Thus, execution of a self-proving will avoids problems with
hostile or unavailable witnesses.
IV. SPECIAL WILLS, CODICILS, AND WILL PROVISIONS
A. Types of Wills
1. Holographic Wills
b. It must be signed (and dated) by the testator at the end. There need be no witnesses.
2. Conditional Wills
a. In a conditional will, a testator may choose to make a particular gift, or a will, conditional on
the occurrence or non-occurrence of a specific event.
b. If the event comes and goes without a problem:
B. Codicils
1. A codicil is an instrument that is executed subsequent to a will by which the will is altered,
explained, added to, subtracted from, or confirmed by way of republication.
3. If a testator revokes his will, all of the codicils to the will are revoked as well.
4. However, if a testator revokes a codicil, it has no effect on the original will to which the codicil is
attached.
1. A specific devise is a gift by will of a specific article or other real or personal property.
2. A general legacy is one payable out of the general assets of the decedents estate, and not in any
way separated or distinguished from other things of like kind.
3. A devise is demonstrative when it is a bequest of a certain sum to be paid out of a particular fund.
1. A surviving spouse has the right to decline to take under the will or pursuant to the intestacy
statute, and instead may choose to take an elective share amount equal to 50% of the value of
the marital-property portion of the augmented estate.
a. The surviving spouse must make his election by filing in the court and mailing or delivering to
the personal representative, if any, a petition for the elective share within nine months after
the date of the decedents death, or within six months after the probate of the decedents
will, whichever limitation later expires.
a. The augmented estate consists of the sum of all property, whether real or personal, movable
or immovable, tangible or intangible, and wherever situated, that constitutes:
(1) the decedents net probate estate;
(2) the decedents non-probate transfers to persons other than the surviving spouse;
(3) the decedents non-probate transfers to the surviving spouse; and
(4) the value of the surviving spouses net assets at the decedents death, plus the surviving
spouses non-probate transfers to others.
b. Under the UPC, the amount of the surviving spouses elective share is calculated by applying
a specified percentage tothe augmented estate. The percentage increases with the lengthof
the marriage until it reaches a maximum of 50%, which is the percentage applicable to a
marriage that has lasted 15 years or longer.
c. The principal feature of the elective share under the UPC that distinguishes it from other
elective share statutes is that it seeks to implement the economic-partnership theory of
marriage by equalizing marital assets at death.
d. The UPC also provides for an amount of a supplemental elective share, a special feature for
small estates that is designed to bring the surviving spouses assets up to at least $75,000,
or as close to that figure as the value of the assets permits.
a. Any transfer that was supported by adequate and full consideration in money or moneys
worth, as well as any transfer that was made with the written consent or joinder of the
surviving spouse, is excluded from the augmented estate.
b. The right of election of a surviving spouse may be waived, wholly or partially, before or after
marriage, by a written contract, agreement, or waiver signed by the surviving spouse.
a. Omitted heirs are children of the testator, living at the time of the execution of the testators
last will, who are neither mentioned nor provided for in the will and would have inherited from
the testator had he died intestate.
b. The UPC allows disinheritance of these heirs by the testator, but disinheritance must be by
express language or necessary implication of the will.
c. If the child is in existence at the time of execution of the will, and the child is not mentioned
in the will, then the presumption is:
a. If the testator fails to provide in his will for a child born or adopted after making his will,
unless it appears from the will that the failure was intentional, the UPC protects such child
from unintentional disinheritance.
b. The UPC does not grant a share to an after-born or after-adopted child if the testator had one
or more children living when the will was executed, but the will did not make a devise to any
of the then-living children.
c. If the testator had one or more children living when the will was executed, and the will made
a devise to one or more of the then-living children, an omitted after-born or after-adopted
child is entitled to share in the portion of the testators estate devised to the testators then-
living children as if the child had been given an equal share of that portion of the estate.
d. If the testators will contains a class gift in favor of his children or descendants, any child who
is born or adopted after the execution of the will is provided for in the will, and thus does not
receive an additional share under an omitted child statute.
3. Special Applications
a. If a valid codicil is executed after the birth of the after-born child, the entire will is republished
as of that date. Thus, the child is not entitled to an intestate share.
1. Family Allowance
a. The surviving spouse and minor children whom the decedent was obligated to support are
entitled to a reasonable allowance in money out of the estate for their maintenance during
the period of administration.
2. The family allowance is intended to provide the family with enough money to pay their expenses
during the probate period.
1. Any rule that a charitable devise is invalid if it exceeds a certain proportion of the testators
estate or if it is contained in a will that was executed within a certain time before the testators
death is abolished.
VI. INTERPRETATION OF WILLS
A. In General
1. Wills are always to be construed in accordance with the discernible will of the testator.
B. Integration
1. Problems of integration arise when there is uncertainty as to precisely what papers and terms
were intended to be part of the will at the time of its execution.
C. Incorporation by Reference
1. The UPC recognizes the common law doctrine of incorporation by reference, which permits the
inclusion by reference of unattested documents as part of a will if:
a.
2. A list of personal property does not have to be in existence at the time of execution of the will, but
instead:
D. Facts of Independent Significance
1. Under the doctrine of facts of independent significance, a will may provide for the designation of a
beneficiary or the amount of a disposition by reference to some future unattested act occurring
after the execution of the will.
2. Thus, a will may dispose of property by reference to acts and events that have significance apart
from their effect upon the dispositions made by the will, whether they occur before or after the
execution of the will or before or after the testators death. The execution or revocation of another
individuals will is such an event.
b. Under the UPC, a devise to the trustee of an inter vivos trust is valid if the trust is identified in
the testators will and its termsare set forth in a written instrument, other than a will,
executed before, concurrently with, or after the execution of the testators will or in another
individuals will if that other individual has predeceased the testator, regardless of the
existence, size, or character of the corpus of the trust.
2. The Doctrine of Worthier Title is abolished as a rule of law and as a rule of construction.
A. Disqualifications
1. Slayer Act
a. Any person who participates, either as a principal, co-conspirator, or an accessory before the
fact, in the willful and unlawful killing of any other person:
b. The slayer rule applies if the killing was felonious and intentional.
c. If the decedent died intestate, the decedents intestate estate passes as if the killer
disclaimed his intestate share.
e. Distribution of Property
(1) The felonious and intentional killing of the decedent further severs the interests of the
decedent and killer in property held by them at the time of the killing as joint tenants
with the right of survivorship, transforming the interests of the decedent and killer into
equal tenancies in common.
(2) The slayer rule also applies to cases in which the property probably would have gone to
the slayer eventually. Thus, propertyin which the slayer held a reversion or vested
remainder, which would have become a present possession on the decedents death,
passes to the estate of the decedent.
g. Proceeds of Insurance
(1) If the slayer is the beneficiary or assignee of a policy insuring the life of the decedent, or
is the survivor of a joint life policy, the proceeds will be paid to the decedents estate, or,
if designated, to a contingent beneficiary, even if the contingent beneficiary is a relative
of the slayer.
2. Other Circumstances
B. Simultaneous Death
1. Under the UPC, a person who cannot be established by clear and convincing evidence to have
survived the decedent by 120 hours is deemed to have predeceased the decedent.
2. However, if a will contains language dealing explicitly with simultaneous deaths or deaths in a
common disaster, and if such language is operable under the facts of the case, the requirement of
survival by 120 hours does not apply.
a. If it is not established by clear and convincing evidence that one of two co-owners with right
of survivorship survived the other co-owner by 120 hours:
C. Disclaimer of Property Interests
e. be delivered or filed.
2. Effect of Disclaimer
b. The effect of a disclaimer is that the property passes as if the disclaiming party predeceased
the decedent.
VIII. CHANGES IN PROPERTY AND BENEFICIARIES
AFTER EXECUTION OF THE WILL
A. Ademption
1. Ademption by Extinction
a. The property a person leaves in his will may not be the same property he owned when he
executed his will.
(1) Ademption by extinction applies only to:
c. Ademption occurs even if the property has been exchanged for other property.
e. Stock
(1) Beneficiaries of stock get:
2. Ademption by Satisfaction
a. Any property given to a beneficiary of a will during the lifetime of the testator is said to be:
B. Encumbered Property
1. At common law, a person to whom the testator specifically devised real estate was entitled to
have any mortgage or lien outstanding on the property paid off out of the other assets of the
estate, leaving his devise unencumbered.
2. Under the UPC, the beneficiary of a devise or bequest under a will is entitled only to the interest
of the testator in the propertythat is, he takes the property subject to any lien or mortgage
outstanding at the testators death; there is no exoneration.
3. This general rule that liens will not be exonerated does not apply if the testator has provided,
expressly or by necessary implication, that the lien on the property should be paid off.
C. Abatement
1. If the assets of the testators estate are insufficient, after payment of all claims against the estate,
to satisfy all the bequests or devises, the beneficiaries shares will abate, or be reduced.
2. Absent contrary directions in the will, the shares of distributees abate in the following order:
b.
c.
d.
D. Lapse
1. Under the common law, a lapse occurs when a disposition fails because the beneficiary
predeceases the testator.
2. Anti-Lapse Statute
a. The UPC and most states say that if the deceased beneficiary is within a certain relationship
of kinship to the testator, then the anti-lapse statute will apply.
b. Typically, any relative who is a direct descendant of a grandparent of the testator qualifies to
receive protection under the anti-lapse statute.
c. This means that the descendant of the deceased beneficiary will inherit the gift in his place.
A. Methods of Revocation
a. physical act;
(1) This includes burning, tearing, canceling, obliterating, or destroying the will or any part
of it, whether or not the burn, tear, or cancellation touched any of the words on the will.
(2) If the testator does not perform the revocatory act, but directs another to perform the
act, the act is a sufficient revocatory act if the other individual performs it in the
testators conscious presence.
(3) The UPC allows for partial revocation by physical act.
c. operation of law.
(1) This occurs under two circumstances:
(a)
(b)
(2) Certain statutes will also revoke all gifts to relatives of an ex-spouse who are not also
related to the testator.
2. It is the law of second best, i.e., its application does not produce the result the testator actually
intended, but is designed to come as close as possible to that intent.
1. The UPC will uphold as valid a contract to dispose of by will all or part of a persons property,
whether real or personal.
2. A contract to make a will or devise, not to revoke a will or devise, or to die intestate may be
established only by:
b. an express reference in the decedents will to a contract and extrinsic evidence proving the
terms of the contract; or
1. In many states, when two persons execute a single document as their joint will, this gives rise to a
presumption that the parties had contracted not to revoke the will except by consent of both
2. Under the UPC, however, the execution of a joint will or mutual will does not create a presumption
of a contract not to revoke the will.
XI. PROBATE OF WILLS
A. In General
a.
b.
c.
3. The will needs to be filed in the county in which the decedent was domiciled at time of death.
a.
B. Proof of Wills
1. Burden of Proof
a. The burden of proving that a will was duly executed is always on the person offering the will
for probate. Thus, proponents of a will have the burden of establishing prima facie proof of
due execution in all cases.
b. Although proof of a will does not require any representation of testamentary capacity from
the witnesses, upon proof of the testators execution of the will, a presumption of
testamentary capacity arises and the burden of proof shifts to the contestant to overcome
the presumption by clear and compelling evidence.
1. Any will that is known to have been in the possession of the testator prior to his death, but then is
not found after his death, has been presumptively revoked voluntarily by the testator.
A. In General
1. In a will contest, a person interested in the distribution of the estate objects to the admission of
the will to probate on the grounds that the will is invalid for some reason.
a.
b.
c.
d.
a. Any adjudication of incapacity will serve as a presumption that the party involved did not
have the requisite capacity to execute a will, but it is rebuttable.
b. An insane delusion is defined as a mere figment of the imagination ora belief that is so
against the evidence and reason that it must be the product of derangement.
(1) A person who suffers from an insane delusion is not necessarily deprived of capacity to
make a donative transfer. A particular donative transfer is invalid, however, to the extent
that it was the product of an insane delusion.
3. Undue Influence
(3)
(4) there was a result appearing to be the effect of the undue influence.
d. In evaluating whether suspicious circumstances are present, all relevant factors may be
considered, including:
(1) the extent to which the donor was in a weakened condition physically, mentally, or both,
and therefore susceptible to undue influence;
(2) the extent to which the alleged wrongdoer participated in the preparation or
procurement of the will;
(3) whether the donor received independent advice from an attorney or from other
competent and disinterested advisors in preparing the will;
(4) whether the will was prepared in secrecy or in haste;
(5) whether the donors attitude toward others had changed by reason of his relationship
with the alleged wrongdoer;
(6) whether there is a decided discrepancy between new and previous wills of the donor;
(7) whether there was a continuity of purpose running through former wills indicating a
settled intent in the disposition of his property; and
(8) whether the disposition of the property is such that a reasonable person would regard it
as unnatural, unjust, or unfair.
e. If these factors are shown by clear and convincing evidence, the burden of proof returns to
the proponent of the will to show that the gift or bequest was not the product of undue
influence.
4. Mistake
a. As far as simple or innocent mistakes are concerned, generally the provisions of the will:
b. Mistake in the inducement is a mistake as to facts outside the will that induced the testator to
dispose of his property in a certain manner.
(1) Generally, provisions of a will cannot be set aside for mistakes in the inducement.
5. Fraud
a. Fraud in the inducement is established upon proof that a beneficiary made a knowingly false
representation to the testator for the purpose of inducing the testator to draw a will in his
favor, and that the testator made a different will than he would have made in the absence of
the representation.
c. In both of the above cases, the will, or the fraudulently induced part of it, will be denied
probate.
C. Ambiguity
1. Ambiguities are resolved by construing the text of the will in accordance with the donors
intention, to the extent that the donors intention is established by a preponderance of the
evidence.
b. Latent ambiguities refer to ambiguities arising when language of the will, otherwise clear, is
applied to the thing given or the person benefited under the will, and some extrinsic fact
necessitates interpretation or choice among two or more possible meanings.
3. Once an ambiguity, patent or latent, is established, both direct and circumstantial evidence of the
donors intention may be considered in resolving the ambiguity in accordance with the donors
intention.
1. The UPC allows an interested person to contest a will. Case law generally holds that standing to
contest a will requires that the party have a pecuniary interest that is directly and adversely
affected by a judgment of the validity of the will.
a. Generally, an in terrorem clause in a will attempts to disqualify anyone contesting the will
from taking under it.
a. Will provisions attempting to condition a bequest on a beneficiarys future behavior are often
said to be attempted instances of dead-hand control. Courts will refuse to enforce these if
they are found to be overly intrusive or disruptive to living persons contrary to public policy.
F. Universal Succession
1. The UPC permits the heirs of an intestate or residuary devisees of a testator to accept the estate
assets without administration by assuming responsibility for discharging those obligations that
normally would be discharged by the personal representative.
A. Gifts
1. Inter vivos gifts take effect during life, are immediate in nature, and are irrevocable.
a. donative intent;
b. delivery; and
3. Assuming all three elements are met, any inter vivos gift is:
4. A gift causa mortis is an inter vivos gift made with the understanding that the donee takes
possession upon delivery, but does not acquire title unless the donor dies of a feared imminent
threat of death.
B. Joint Tenancy
1. As a general rule, surviving joint tenants become the full owners of the joint tenancy property
because the deceased tenants interest is deemed to disappear upon his death.
2. This rule can also apply to joint bank accounts and payable-on-death accounts.
C. Power of Attorney
1. A power of attorney is a relationship wherein the principal appoints an agent to act on his behalf.
2. The power gives the agent the authority to deal with the principals property and execute
business transactions on behalf of the principal during the latters life.
a.
b.
1.