Professional Documents
Culture Documents
sections or spans, the guard wires are connected to the supports, or This is equivalent to consider in (1) the average values of self
isolated from them, or are absent. Parametric analysis is given for
and mutual impedances:
lines 220 kV and 400 kV, which shows the extent of the errors made
with traditional methods of calculation.
Z c = ( Z 11 + Z 22 + Z 33) / 3 Instead of Z11, Z22, Z33
KeywordsOverhead line, power system, zero sequence, wire Z mc = ( Z 12 + Z 13 + Z 23 ) / 3 Instead of Z12, Z13, Z23
guard, grounding.
Z mcf = ( Z 14 + Z 24 + Z 24 ) / 3 Instead of Z14, Z24, Z34
I. INTRODUCTION Z f = Z 44 (2)
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 7(6) 2013 750 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/8395
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Vol:7, No:6, 2013
from 1-2 to fractions of ohms in the case of stations of HV. II. EFFECT OF EARTH RESISTANCES OF SUPPORT AND
The zero sequence currents in phase conductors on FG induce STATION ON THE ZERO SEQUENCE IMPEDANCE LINES
an e.m.f which a current is flowing in the wire of the same The (1.6) is not exact because it ignores the line in
entity employee from Rp and Rs. throughout its length and does not take into account the
To better illustrate this, consider the circuit of Fig. 1(a), in resistances Ground the FG terminal stations which are
which are represented the three phase conductors of a span of normally connected. To calculate more accurately Zo you can
length c paths from zero sequence currents and the FG use the equivalent circuit of the system conductors-FG-
connected to two supports of equal ground resistance Rp. It is resistance ground of the supports of Fig. 1 [5,6,7,8], where it
reasonable to neglecting the transverse admittance of the was considered the conductance of the ground of supports
conductors. For each phase conductor and for the FG can be per unit length, gp (x), suppository evenly distributed and
written the following equations: defined by the relation (ci the length of the span on the i-th
wind support):
E ' c0 E c0 = ( Z c + 2Z mc )cI 0 + Z mcf cI f
3Z mcf cI 0 = (2 R p + Z f c) I f (5) g p ( x) = 1 R pi ci = 1 r p ( x) (9)
The second equation gives:
In general the magnitudes gp (x) and rp (x) are variables
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:7, No:6, 2013 waset.org/Publication/8395
I f = 3Z mcf cI 0 (2 R p + Z f c) (6) along the line, depending on the resistance of the ground
individual support, Rpi, and c the length of the span.
However, for the purposes of the calculation of Zo, is often
which substituted in the first equation gives: lawful replace gp (x) and rp (x) by the average values
calculated for the whole line, gm and rm.
Z 0 = (E ' E ) I 0 c = If we neglect the transverse admittance to the land of phase
(7)
( Z c + 2 Z mc ) 3 Z mcf (( 2 R p / c) + Z f ) conductors, the zero sequence current Io the same is constant
at all points of the line. Writing the equations of the
The (6) and (7) show the influence of the resistances of elementary network Fig. 1 and integrating between the two
ground of the supports on the value of the current flowing in ends of the line obtain the equations of the two-port equivalent
FG and then the Z0. In fact for Rp = 0, the current circulating the zero sequence of the entire line. From them finally obtains
in FG closes through the ground and is limited to only the the equivalent circuit of Fig. 2, which takes account of the
impedance of the cable: resistance grounding of the supports and in which were also
reported resistors ground of the two stations at the ends of the
I f = 3I 0 Z mcf Z f (8) line, Rs1 and Rs2.
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 7(6) 2013 751 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/8395
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Vol:7, No:6, 2013
From the expression of VO above, using analytical Where the e.m.f induced by the currents flowing in the FG
developments, we obtain: on the phase conductor, Voi, are different from zero only in
sections where FG are attached to the supports.
[
V0 = 3(Z mcf Z f ) Z f a (1 (Ys12 + 1 / B)) I 0 ] (10) The i-th section of the length in which the rope is
connected to the supports, Vo is equal to:
Ys1 series of the admittances Y p1 = Y + 1 / Rs1 and
[
V0 = 3( Z mcf Z f ) Z f a i (1 (Ysi + 1 / Bi )) I 0] (13)
Y p 2 = Y + 1 / Rs2 ;
Therefore, the following expression is obtained zero In addition it has:
sequence impedance Z0 or overhead line with FG:
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:7, No:6, 2013 waset.org/Publication/8395
( )(
Z0 = (Zc + 2Zmc) 3 Z mcf Z f a (Z f a) ((Y / 2) + (1/ B) )
in the latter case, for long lines and / or equipped with low
Rp , resulting in | cosh (Kf a) | >> 1 then (2.3) becomes in the
simplest:
( )(
Z 0 = (Z c + 2Z mc ) 3 Z mcf Z f a (Z f a) (2Z Of ) )
Zof is the characteristic impedance of the system of wire
guard-resistance grounding of the supports;
If the FG is not connected to the supports or are not
present in some sections of the line, consider the circuit
equivalent of Fig. 3.
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 7(6) 2013 752 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/8395
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Vol:7, No:6, 2013
Fig. 3 Equivalent circuit of the zero sequence line with FG in the non-earthed or not present
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:7, No:6, 2013 waset.org/Publication/8395
Fig. 5 equivalent circuit zero sequence for line (Zocc, i = Zcc,i +2 Z mc,i, where Zcc,i, and Zmc,i are the self and mutual impedance of the
phase of the i th bay)
[Tn 1 ] =
a) For the System Wire Guard-Support: 1 3Z f , n 1
(17)
O 1
E f 0P D B E fOa E
I = + I 0 (16)
b) For each Phase Conductor:
f 0 p C A I fOa F
n1 n1
Ec0 p = EcOa + Z0ccj I0 + ( 3ZmcfjI f 0 j )
D B n 1 j =1 j =1
C A = [Ti ] I fOj = I fj / 3 = C j E f 0 a + A j I f 0a + F j I O
i =1
D j B j n 1 E j n 1 i 1
E n 1 i 1
[ ]
F = [M 1 ] + T j [M i ] C = [T ]
A j i + j i
[ ]
F = M j + [Tk ][M i ]
i = 2 j =1 j j i = j +1 k = j
(18)
for i=1,,n-2 result:
We obtain
1 + ( Z fi R pi ) 3Z fi E = E c 0 p E c 0a =
[Ti ] = 1
1 3R fi
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 7(6) 2013 753 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/8395
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Vol:7, No:6, 2013
Length. 5 km 50 km
B[] 3.3318 + j 6.7079 (2.8611 + j 19.77) 10 6
Y [-1] 0.2581 -j 0.0406 0.3176 -j 0.1408
Yp1= 1.2581 -j 0.0406 1.3176 -j 0.1408
Yp2 [ -1]
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 7(6) 2013 754 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/8395
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Vol:7, No:6, 2013
Fig. 9 Line 400 kV-50 Hz with two safety cables in Al-Ac connected
to the earth station ((Rs1 = Rs2 = 0.5 ): performance of Xo
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:7, No:6, 2013 waset.org/Publication/8395
TABLE I
Fig. 7 Line 220 kV-50 Hz with FG in Al-Ac, connected to the earth VALUES OF RO AND XO OF THE LINES AT 170KV AND 420 KV
station (Rs1 = Rs2 = 1): performance of Xo and Ro vary the length CALCULATED ASSUMING THE FG AT GROUND POTENTIAL OR ISOLATED
of the line, for different values of Rp and t t R0,X0 Line at 220Kv Line at 400kV
[/km] State of FG State of FG
[/km] Vf=0 Ins Vf=0 Ins
50 R0 0.36 0.230 0.259 0.163
X0 1.085 1.292 0.739 1.073
100 R0 0.331 0.230 0.274 0.164
X0 1.121 1.357 0.759 1.136
500 R0 0.368 0.230 0.308 0.167
X0 1.200 1.509 0.802 1.285
1000 R0 0.392 0.230 0.323 0.167
X0 1.229 1.574 0.818 1.350
*) Values of Zo vary with the soil resistivity t since, varying the
depth of the ground return currents: vary the elements of the matrix of
kilometric impedance(self and mutual) of the line.
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 7(6) 2013 755 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/8395
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Vol:7, No:6, 2013
Considering the FG at ground potential are committed [4] FM Gatta, F. Iliceto-"Calculation of Current Flow in Grounding
Systems of substations and HV Line Towers, in Line Shield Wires and
errors percentages higher than in the case of FG connected to Cable Sheaths during Earth Faults "- ETEP, Vol.8, No.2, March / April
the mains earth substation. 1998.
For L = 10 km and Rp equal to 10, 20 and 100 will have [5] R. Benato, L. Caciolli: "Sequence impedances of insulated cables:
errors respectively -7.5%, -11% and -19% on the Xo. Measurements versus computations ", IEEE PES T & D Conference
2012, Orlando, Florida,.
Always for short lines (5-10 km), for values of Rp medium [6] IEC 60909-2: Short-circuit in three-phase ac systems. Part 2: Data of
- low (10-20 ), the maximum error of Ro is 18 to 19%, s electrical equipment for short circuit current calculations. Edition 2008.
committing more errors for values Rp elevated. [7] R.Benato, L. Caciolli, and E. Zaccone: Sequence impedance
computation by means of Multiconductor cell analysis. 8th International
- If the FG is high resistance and is connected the land Confrence on Insulated Power Cables, 2011.
substation, the errors made on Xo, considering the FG to [8] L.Fellin, R. Benato: Electrical Systems, UTET Technical Sciences,
ground potential are practically negligible, less than 1%. The 2010, ISBN 978-88-980618-9.
errors of R0 is a few percent for values of Rp Medium - Low;
become rather high ( 20%) to high Rp.
Line to 400 kV-50 Hz:
Equipped with two FG Al - Ac connected to the earth
stations with Rs1 = Rs2 = 0.5 : Xo and Ro decrease with
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:7, No:6, 2013 waset.org/Publication/8395
IV. CONCLUSIONS
The work proposes some formulas for better evaluation zero
sequence impedance overhead electrical lines equipped with
one or two FG. The formulas take into account: the average
value of the resistances of the earth of support, resistors to
ground substations two ends of the line, the connection or less
of FG to the ski ground stations and supports, the possible
cutting of FG in some support or absence of FG in some
sections of the line.
Considering the FG to ground potential is commit errors in
the calculation of Ro and Xo that reach only important for
short lines built on soils with a high resistivity, equipped with
wires guard of low resistance, and especially in the case in
which these are not connected to mains earth stations.
The calculation method illustrated can easily be extended
to the case of cable lines.
REFERENCES
[1] A. Paolucci: Lessons of electrical, first Part, CLEUP Publisher, March
1997.
[2] P.Nefzger, J.F. Nolasco, U. Kaintzyk, F.Kiessling: Overhead Power
Lines, Springer, 2003.
[3] F. Iliceto, FM Gatta, S. Lauria, GO-Dokyi "Three-Phase and Single-
Phase Electrification in Developing Countries Using the Insulated Shield
Wires of HV lines Energized at MV "- CIRED art. 5/10, Session of
1999.
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 7(6) 2013 756 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/8395