Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Quora
Searchforquestions,people,andtopics SignIn
Thecostsavingsiscompletelyoutthewindowonceyouloseasingledayofproduction Ihave2yearsofexperienceasaPLCprogrammer.
becauseofanissuethattookyou10timesaslongtofixbecauseoftheengineeringhurdle. Whicharethetopcollegesforamaster'sinindustrial
automationintheUS?Isitreallyw...
It'snotdesignedtoworkinafailsafescenario,althoughallyoursafetyshouldnotevenbe
WhichPLC(ProgrammableLogicController)isbetter:
trustedbyanonsafetyPLCduetolackofredundancyinafailurescenario.
SIEMENSorAllenBradley?
It'salsonotdesignedtoruncontinuouslyina90Fdegreepanel,24hoursaday,365days WhyisnegativelogicprevalentinJapanese
ayearfor10years. programmablelogiccontrollers(PLCs)andelectronics
comparedtosimilarusageinEuropeorAmeri...
Finally,engineeringandtechniciantimeisvaluable.Budget$50200+perhour,not
WhyarePLCspreferredovermicrocontrollersinthe
includinglosttimeandequipmentlife.Howmuchmoneyareyoureallygoingtosave? automationindustries?
Written27Feb2015ViewUpvotes
Arethereanygoodoffcampus
(online/correspondence)mastersdegreeprogrammes
foranIndustrialAutomationEngineer?
RelatedQuestions
MoreAnswersBelow
Whyisprogrammingintheprocesscontrolindustry(e.g.ladderlogic)soantiquatedwhen
comparedtomodernsoftwaredevelopmenttools?
HowtomakeProgrammableLogicControllertrainingkit?
Whichprogrammablelogiccontrollers(PLCs)areusedinwhichmilitaryvehicles?
WhatwillbethenameofdifferentpositionsinaIndustrialControlandHomeautomation
startup?
Whatbasicskillsareneededtobeinautomationindustry?
AjinkyaKamat,DesigningRobotBrainsforaliving.
5.5kViewsUpvotedbyBenMordecai,EngineerinIndustrialAutomation
Noway.
Firstly,PLCandArduinoaretotallydifferentintermsofapplications.Onceyougetthe
hangofusingaPLCandreplacingitwithanArduinowillseemdifficultandpointless.
OnemayarguethataruggedArduinoBoardcouldbedesignedtowithstandtheharsh
environmentsofafactoryfloor.Howevertruethismaybewhenyoudesignarugged
Arduinoboard,whatyouareessentiallydoingisdevelopinganindustrialproductaround
Atmel'sAtmegamicroprocessor.SoletusgiveourfriendsatAtmelsomecreditandstop
callingsuchproductsArduinos.AndbelievemeIhaveopenedupafewindustrialgrade
productsmyself,particularlypowerfactorcontrollers,energymetersandgenset
controllers.ManyofthemdouseAtmelproducts.IamanAtmelfanmyself.
So,therealquestionisaremicrocontrollersreplacingPLCinindustries.
Theansweragainisno.
Yousee.PLCsandmicrocontrollersarebuiltfordifferentkindsofendusers.
https://www.quora.com/AutomationIsArduinoreplacingprogrammablelogiccontrollerinindustries 1/4
4/5/2016 Automation:IsArduinoreplacingprogrammablelogiccontrollerinindustries?Quora
Microcontrollersareusedbyproductdeveloperswhowilldesignanddevelopindustrial
equipmentliketemperaturecontrollers,panelmeters,sensormodules,transducers,
actuatorsetc.
PLCaretargetedforusebysystemintegratorswhowilluseproductsdevelopedbyother
companiestobuildanentireassemblyline.Fortheirapplicationwritingcodeusing
LadderLogicismuchmoreconvenientandoptimal.
Written5Nov2014ViewUpvotes
PiyushRamraika,CFALevel1candidate,ElectricalEngineer
4.3kViewsUpvotedbyBenMordecai,EngineerinIndustrialAutomation
YoushouldnoteventhinkofreplacingPLCswithArduino.Thereisimmensedifference
betweenarduinoandplc.
PLCsaremadetoworkinruggedandindustrialenvironmentandArudinoare
notreliableforsuchanenvironment.
Arduinocannotbetrustedinthelifesavingsituationasoccurinindustries.
Arduinoisdesignedforrandomhobbyistuseandsometimescangiveerrorwhichcan
beverydangerousforthelifeandpropertyoftheindustry.
PLCsusesimpleLadderLogicProgrammingsoitiseasytotroubleshootthemin
caseoferrorbutarduinoareprogrammedwithC++whichisforeginforplant
technicians.
ArduinoisprovidedwithResetbuttonassometimesitgetslockedupwhichisnot
goodforindustries.
ArduinohasfewI/OpinsandanalogpinsascomparedtoPLCswherepinscanbe
hundreds.
Soarduinoisgoodtoplayandprogramathomeandlabsitisnotreadytobeusedin
industrialarena.
Written31Oct2014ViewUpvotes
AdityaShakya,Tinkererbydesign,Artistbychoice.
4.2kViews
Ithinkitis.
ArduinoIsntJustForHackersPaulMFurley
ButIhavemixedfeelingsaboutextensivelyusingArduinoinmainstreamIndustrial
applicationsandwhenitcomestoreplacingPLCsandDCSs,Ihavetopainfully(coziama
fanofArduinoandembeditinallmyprojects)saythat,NoArduinoisnevergoingto
replacePLCs.Youaskwhy?
Firstofallifyoufollowlinkaboutyou'llfindthattheindustrialprintersinthelink
aboutuse5arduinos,andwhyisthat,becausetheyhavelowI/Ocount.Eventthe
mostadvancedarduinohasI/Osthatmaxoutataround100150(approx).Buteven
asmallindustrywilleasilyhavemorethan100I/Os.Nowyoumaysaywecanusea
numberofArduinostosufficeforlackofI/Os,yeswecan,butaskyourselfwhatwill
beeasytomanage(debugorprogram),PLCwithasingleCPU(thereisalwaysa
secondstandbyCPUinthem!!)whichwillhavealltheprogramor,Anumberof
arduinoswiththewholeprogramdividedintoeachandtheyallcommunicateand
synchronizeusingprotocolslikeI2C,SPIoratmaxSerialat115200baud,whichis
horriblyslowerthanthoseusedbyPLClikeModbus.
Secondproblemiscommunicationprotocolsavailable,andproblembeingtheyare
slow.Why?Because,whenyouhaveatleast1000I/Ostohandlethenyouwillhave
around2000+processparametersthatneedtobecommunicatedtotheOperator
consoleatatleast100to10Hzrate.Andatthesametimetheyalsoneedtobe
communicatedtocontrolequipment/hardware/deviceatmuchhigherfrequencies
liketensofthousandstime.Andwithslowcommunicationsavailableitwillmostlikely
resultinablownupBoileroraTurbinebreakingduetoexcessivevibrationandall
thatnotcountingthelifecasualtiesandmonetarylossandallsortsofaccidental
hazards.
ThirdpointbeingReliability.WhatifjustoneoftheArduinomalfunctionswhichisa
veryobviouspossibilitybecauseweneedtoresetitwhenithangsandagainitworks
perfect,butthisisnottolerablewhenyouarecontrollingmachinesworthBillionsof
https://www.quora.com/AutomationIsArduinoreplacingprogrammablelogiccontrollerinindustries 2/4
4/5/2016 Automation:IsArduinoreplacingprogrammablelogiccontrollerinindustries?Quora
rupees/dollars.PLCalwayshaveastandbyCPUthattakesoverwhenprimaryCPU
failsorstartsmisbehaving.
Fourthreasonbeing,PLCisprogrammedusingladderlogicwhichhasbeen
understoodandusedbyengineersandtechniciansfordecades,butontheother
handArduinohasitsownlanguage(notevenC).Andyetagainladderlogicbeing
graphicaliseasytoeditanddebug.TeachinganewlanguagelikeArduinowillbe
cumbersome.
Fifthreasonbeingthat,ifyouaresettingupanindustrialplantworthmillionsof
dollarsthenyouwouldn'twanttogiveitscontrolinthehandsofadevicethatcome
under100$!!.Soitsthetrustfactoratlast,PLCshavebeenhereforlongandtheyare
goingtostay.
AndatlastifyoudesignanIndustriallyrobustArduinobasedcontrollerfromscratch,
keepinginmindalltheindustrialnormsthenagainitwouldbenothingbutaPLCthatis
slowatcommunication,haslowprocessingpower,islessreliableandunderstandArduino
language.Itmaybeusefulforreallysmallindustrialapplicationlikeinsituationswhere
theapplicationisnotcriticalandreliabilityisnotbigadeal,Butyetagainitsfarfrom
replacingPLCs.
ItsnotthatIamagainstwholeArduinothing,actuallymymajorprojectwasan
IndustrialgradeDataAcquisitionandControlBoardwhichsupportbothDigitaland
AnalogI/OsofbothTTLlogiclevel(thoseusedbymicrocontrollerboardslikeArduino)
andPLClogiclevel024v.ItcanbeusedwithLABViewtomakeanycontrolsystembyjust
usingUSBconnectivity.ButthissaidIwouldneverhavesuggesteditsuseforanything
buteducationalpurposes.
Written13Nov2014ViewUpvotes
AnkurKaushal
2.8kViews
Wecanalsodesignarduinoforruggedorindustrialenvironment.
Howcansomeonesaysthatarduinogiveserrorinindustrialreqirement,asplcand
arduinobotharehavigmicrocontroller,whichworksaccordingtoprogramming.
ArduinoprogrammedinsimpleClanguagenotmorethan"if,else,than,for,while
etc"instructionseven7or8thstandardstudentcandoiteasily.
Resetisjustlikeon/offbutton,ifyoupoweroffplcitwillalsonotwork.
ifyoumaketemperaturecontrollerinindustriesusingplcitwillcostyounearabout
thousands$andifyouusearduinothiscostyouonlyfew$,sowhywepaymore.
Written2Nov2014ViewUpvotes
RelatedQuestions
Ihave2yearsofexperienceasaPLCprogrammer.Whicharethetopcollegesfora
master'sinindustrialautomationintheUS?Isitreallyw...
WhichPLC(ProgrammableLogicController)isbetter:SIEMENSorAllenBradley?
WhyisnegativelogicprevalentinJapaneseprogrammablelogiccontrollers(PLCs)and
electronicscomparedtosimilarusageinEuropeorAmeri...
WhyarePLCspreferredovermicrocontrollersintheautomationindustries?
Arethereanygoodoffcampus(online/correspondence)mastersdegreeprogrammesforan
IndustrialAutomationEngineer?
WhatisyourreviewofProgrammableLogicController(PLC)?
DoControlandAutomationengineersuseprogrammingalot?
WhatwouldhappenifMcDonald'sreplacedtheirworkerswithautomation?
WhatistheindustrialautomationscopeintheUSA?
Whatistheimportanceofautomationinindustries?
WhichmicrocontrollerisusedinVeraLitehomeautomation?
https://www.quora.com/AutomationIsArduinoreplacingprogrammablelogiccontrollerinindustries 3/4
4/5/2016 Automation:IsArduinoreplacingprogrammablelogiccontrollerinindustries?Quora
Howcanonepursuecareerinautomationindustry?
Currently,whatisthemosteasiestProgrammableLogicControlorPLCtoprogram?
WhichconsultingfirmsshouldIapplytoforcontrolsystems/industrialautomation
engineering?
Whataresomegoodbooksonindustrialautomation?
TopStories
Let'sassumethatthebeesandthebee
swarmarespherical.Thebulletwillswipea
cylindricalkillzonefromoneendofthe
swarmtotheother.Theradiusofthe
cylinderwillbe r
bullet+ 2r bee,sinceifabee
evengetsnickedbyabullet,it'sprobably
ReadMore ReadMore ReadMore
goingdown.Theportionofthevolumeof
What'snottolove?I'mdoingitrightnow.I Americawillloseitsstatusastheworld's
strongestwhen... theswarmtakenupbythekillzoneis
Sitemap # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
AboutCareersPrivacyTermsContact
https://www.quora.com/AutomationIsArduinoreplacingprogrammablelogiccontrollerinindustries 4/4