Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effect of rice husk ash on the strength and durability characteristics of concrete
Hwang Chao-Lung , Bui Le Anh-Tuan, Chen Chun-Tsun
Department of Construction Engineering, National Taiwan University of Science and Technology, 43, Keelung Rd., Sec. 4, Taipei 106, Taiwan
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This work investigates the effects of adding residual rice husk ash (RHA) from South Vietnam, generated
Received 23 December 2010 when burning rice husk pellets in the boiler, to cement. To improve pozzolanic reactivity, RHA was
Received in revised form 14 March 2011 ground for 1 h. The non-ground RHA and ground RHA were used to test strength activity index according
Accepted 11 April 2011
to ASTM C311. The properties of the concrete were investigated, including compressive strength, concrete
Available online 4 May 2011
electrical resistivity, and ultrasonic pulse velocity. Results show that the non-ground RHA can be applied
as a pozzolanic material. Decreasing the non-ground RHA average particle size provides a positive effect
Keywords:
on the compressive strength of mortar. Compressive strength of cylindrical concrete in the 4766 MPa
Rice husk ash (RHA)
Concrete
range was obtained in this study. The results also indicate that up to 20% of ground RHA could be advan-
Compressive strength tageously blended with cement without adversely affecting the strength and durability properties of
Durability concrete.
2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0950-0618/$ - see front matter 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2011.04.009
H. Chao-Lung et al. / Construction and Building Materials 25 (2011) 37683772 3769
2. Materials and experimental methods ground RHA mortar at the age of 7 and 28 days is 82% and 97% of that of the OPC mor-
tar at the same age, respectively. These indexes are 32% and 35% higher than those of
2.1. RHA characteristics non-ground RHA at 7 and 28 days, respectively. On the other hand, to develop poz-
zolanic activity in the presence of lime or Portland cement, the RHA particles need
The residual RHA as shown in Fig. 2 was collected at Saigon Ve Wong Co., Ltd., Ho not to be very ne. This is because the source of high surface area in RHA is in the
Chi Minh city, Vietnam. Rice husk pellets (Fig. 1) were burnt in a steam boiler at tem- microporous structure of individual particles. RHA particles, in the 1075 lm range,
peratures varying from 600 to 800 C. Fig. 3 provides the X-ray power diffraction exhibit satisfactory pozzolanic behavior [3,10].
(XRD) pattern of RHA. As can be seen, RHA is mostly amorphous silica and partially
crystalline silica. It can be seen from Fig. 4 that RHA has a porous cellular structure 2.2. Materials used in concretes
and consists of irregular-shaped particles. Average particle size of RHA is 87 lm in
diameter, as was measured using Mastersizer 2000. To increase the nesses, RHA In the type I Portland cement produced by Taiwan Cement Company. The phys-
was ground by a ball mill for 1 h. By this way, the average particle size of RHA can ical and chemical characteristics of Portland cement are given in Table 1. Crushed
be decreased to 12 lm as shown in Fig. 5. Rukzon et al. [5] concluded that the differ- coarse aggregate (19 mm maximum size, density 2.67 and absorption capacity
ences in chemical composition of RHA with different nenesses from the same batch 1.4%) and natural sand (modulus of neness 3.0, density 2.65 and absorption capac-
are small. Therefore, chemical analysis was performed on the ground RHA. The ity 1.2%) were provided from local quarries. The mixing water was local tap water.
chemical composition of RHA was presented in Table 1. High value of silica content Type-G superplasticizer, having 43% solid content with specic gravity of 1.18, was
and loss on ignition (presented the amount of residual carbon) can be observed. used to achieve the desired workability for all concrete mixtures. All materials con-
In order to assess the pozzolanic reactivity of the ashes, strength activity index form to the related ASTM standards.
test was prepared according to ASTM C311 [15]. The results show that the water
requirements of the mortars with non-ground RHA and ground RHA added are
117% and 110%, respectively. The decrease in the particle size of RHA decreases 2.3. Testing program
the water demand of the mixture. Similar approach was also reported by some
investigations [5,16]. The compressive strength of the mortar containing non- The ground RHA was used as a pozzolanic material in concrete. The concrete
ground RHA is lower than that of the control mortar (OPC) at all ages. At 28 days, was tested for compressive strength and durability properties. Mixture proportions
the compressive strength of non-ground RHA is 72% of that of the OPC mortar at of concrete were based on the ACI 211.1 [19]. Three water-to-binder ratios (w/b):
the same age. The compressive strength of the non-ground RHA might be able to in- 0.23; 0.35; and 0.47; with the same 10% RHA replacement by weight of cement,
crease after 28 days. This is because of the low pozzolanic reaction of RHA [4,17]. were done in this investigation. In order to assess the effect of RHA replacements
According to ASTM C618 [18], y ash and natural pozzolans should have a strength on concrete properties, w/b ratio of 0.35 were selected. The mixtures were prepared
activity index of at least 75% of the control mortar at the age of 28 days when they by replacing 0%, 10%, 20% and 30% of cement with RHA. Table 2 shows the mixture
are used as mineral admixture to replace Portland cement at the rate of 20% by proportions in weight of materials. The slump of concrete was measured according
weight of binder. Therefore, the non-ground RHA can be used as a pozzolanic mate- to ASTM C143 [20]. The slump of concrete was controlled in the 80100 mm range.
rial in concrete. In general, the pozzolanic effect depends not only on the pozzolanic The preparation of concrete specimens for cylinder compressive strength, concrete
reaction but also on the physical or ller effect of the smaller particles in the mixture electrical resistivity, and the ultrasonic pulse velocity test follow ASTM C192 [21],
[11]. Hence, one of the most common methods for improving the pozzolanic activity and those specimens were cured in saturated limewater at the temperature of
of mineral admixtures is to decrease their particle size. The ner particles of pozzo- 23 2.0 C. According to ASTM C39 [22], the concrete cylinders with dimension of
lans had a greater pozzolanic reaction and the smaller particles could also ll in the / 100 200 mm were tested for compressive strength. A concrete electrical resis-
voids of the sample, thus the compressive strength of mortar could be improved tivity meter manufactured by the CNS Company in UK is used in this study for con-
[4,5,8,9,11]. This is obvious in the ground RHA case. A high strength reactivity index ducting the concrete electrical resistivity test to measure the concrete electrical
was achieved using RHA that was ground for 60 min. The compressive strength of resistivity under saturated condition. The ultrasonic pulse velocity test was con-
ducted according to ASTM-597 [23]. The tests for hardened concrete were carried
out at the age of 1, 3, 7, 14, 28, 56 and 91 days.
The pulse velocity methods have been used to assess the unifor-
mity and relative quality of concrete, to indicate the presence of
voids and cracks, and to evaluate the effectiveness of crack repairs
[23]. Generally, high pulse velocity reading in concrete is indicative
of concrete of good quality. Malhotra [27] has suggested that con-
crete has good durability when its pulse velocity value is in the
Fig. 5. SEM image of ground RHA. range of 36604575 m/s. Table 5 illustrates the effect of water-to-
binder ratio on UPV of ground RHA concrete. The trend with regard
is less compact, causing the strength to be lower than that of the to the hardening properties of ground RHA concrete is: the lower
specimen without ground RHA added. After 28 days, pozzolanic the w/b ratio the higher the UPV [28,29]. During the hydration per-
reaction starts to proceed, decreasing the amount of CH and improv- iod, the volume of the solid/liquid phase with the high water-to-
ing the densication [24]. Consequently, the compressive strength is binder ratio is smaller and the distance between grains is a little
enhanced in the later phase. Comparison of the data for 56 and greater. At the same time, it takes a longer time to ll pore space
91 days of curing ages shows that the compressive strength of con- with hydrates of low cement content than of high cement content.
cretes with up to 20% ground RHA attain values equivalent to that Table 5 also shows that the effect of ground RHA content on UPV
control concrete specimens. With water-to-binder ratio from 0.23 in concrete is to cure with age. An increase in ground RHA content
to 0.47, compressive strength at 28 days of RHA concrete in the tends to lower the UPV curve. In the long run, the addition of ground
4766 MPa range is obtained in this investigation. RHA up to 20% will nally reach the same UPV values as in the con-
H. Chao-Lung et al. / Construction and Building Materials 25 (2011) 37683772 3771
Table 1 [30]. Such an occurrence may be explained by the fact that the
Physical and chemical analysis of cement and RHA. control concrete contains greater quantities of cement than does
Item Cement Ground RHA RHA cement paste and has higher hydrate content at the same age.
Physical properties Specic gravity 3.15 2.06 On the other hand, due to the much more porous structure and lower
specic gravity of RHA particles compared to the cement, the grains
Chemical compositions (%)
SiO2 22.01 91 of RHA are not as dense as those of cement. However, at 28 days, UPV
Al2O3 5.51 0.35 of all specimens is higher than 3660 m/s, therefore, the specimens
Fe2O3 3.44 0.41 might be considered to be durable concrete [27].
MgO 2.59 0.81
SO3 2.03 1.21
P2O5 0.05 0.98 3.5. Strength efciency of cement
Na2O 0.40 0.08
K2O 0.70 3.21 The strength efciency of cement implies the yielded strength
Loss on ignition (%) 0.51 8.5
per kilogram of cement and is denoted as MPa/kg cement. Fig. 6
shows that the higher amount of ground RHA content, the higher
Table 2
Mixture proportions of concrete.
Remark: 1. Mix no: Ab-c, b is w/b ratio; c is RHA content (%) by mass of cement, respectively. 2. Mix no: A represents the ACI 211.1 standard practice for selecting proportion
for concrete. 3. w/c: water-to-cement ratio.
Table 3
Strength development of RHA concrete.
Table 4
Development of electrical resistivity of RHA concrete.
Table 5
Development of ultrasonic pulse velocity of RHA concrete.
Mix w/b ratio RHA content (%) Ultrasonic pulse velocity (m/s)
1 day 3 days 7 days 14 days 28 days 56 days 91 days
A23-10 0.23 10 4205 4323 4525 4579 4606 4662 4788
A35-00 0.35 0 4121 4264 4443 4463 4515 4599 4642
A35-10 0.35 10 4146 4265 4436 4456 4530 4599 4637
A35-20 0.35 20 4086 4165 4361 4381 4446 4493 4611
A35-30 0.35 30 4047 4147 4342 4372 4417 4457 4611
A47-10 0.47 10 3795 4059 4237 4332 4452 4541 4579
trol concrete. Measurement shows that UPV continues to grow the strength efciency of cement. The 91-day strength efciency
when less cement is used, if more cement is used the UPV decreases of cement rises to 0.13, 0.15 and 0.16 MPa/kg/m3 corresponding
3772 H. Chao-Lung et al. / Construction and Building Materials 25 (2011) 37683772
References
[1] Zerbino R, Giaccio G, Isaia GC. Concrete incorporating rice-husk ash without
processing. Constr Build Mater 2011;25(1):3718.
[2] Gonalves MRF, Bergmann CP. Thermal insulators made with rice husk ashes:
production and correlation between properties and microstructure. Constr
Build Mater 2007;21(12):205965.
[3] Hwang CL, Chandra S. The use of rice husk ash in concrete. In: Satish C, editor.
Waste materials used in concrete manufacturing. Westwood, NJ: William
Andrew Publishing; 1996. p. 184234.
[4] Givi AN, Rashid SA, Aziz FNA, Salleh MAM. Assessment of the effects of rice
husk ash particle size on strength, water permeability and workability of
binary blended concrete. Constr Build Mater 2010;24(11):214550.
[5] Rukzon S, Chindaprasirt P, Mahachai R. Effect of grinding on chemical and
physical properties of rice husk ash. Int J Miner, Metall Mater
2009;16(2):2427.
[6] Rodrguez de Sensale G. Strength development of concrete with rice-husk ash.
Cem Concr Compos 2006;28(2):15860.
[7] Della VP, Khn I, Hotza D. Rice husk ash as an alternate source for active silica
Fig. 6. Effect of RHA content on strength efciency of cement. production. Mater Lett 2002;57(4):81821.
[8] Bui DD, Hu J, Stroeven P. Particle size effect on the strength of rice husk ash
blended gap-graded Portland cement concrete. Cem Concr Compos
to the ground RHA concrete with percentage replacement of ash of 2005;27(3):35766.
10%, 20% and 30%, respectively. The 91-day value is 1.21.5 times [9] Habeeb GA, Fayyadh MM. Rice husk ash concrete: the effect of rha average
particle size on mechanical properties and drying shrinkage. Aust J Basic Appl
higher than that of the control concrete (0.11 MPa/kg/m3). Such re- Sci 2009;3(3):161622.
sult indicates that the cement consumption is only about one quar- [10] Mehta PK. The chemistry and technology of cements made from rice husk ash.
ter of the normal usage based on the same compressive strength. In In: Proceeding of UNIDO/ESCAP/RCTT workshop on rice husk ash cement.
Pakistan; 1979. p. 113.
such manner, the cement consumption, the energy consumption
[11] Isaia GC, Gastaldini ALG, Moraes R. Physical and pozzolanic action of mineral
and the detrimental CO2 emission for the environment during additions on the mechanical strength of high-performance concrete. Cem
the production of cement can signicantly be reduced to environ- Concr Compos 2003;25(1):6976.
[12] Cordeiro G, Toledo Filho R, de Moraes Rego Fairbairn E. Use of ultrane rice
mental advantage.
husk ash with high-carbon content as pozzolan in high performance concrete.
Mater Struct 2009;42(7):98392.
4. Conclusions [13] Saraswathy V, Song H-W. Corrosion performance of rice husk ash blended
concrete. Constr Build Mater 2007;21(8):177984.
[14] Hwang CL, Wu D-S. Properties of cement paste containing rice husk ash. In:
According to the results in this study, a number of conclusions Malhotra VM, editor. Proceedings of the third CANMET/ACI international
can be drawn. conference on y ash silica fume, slag and natural pozzolans in concrete. ACI
SP114-35; 1989. p. 73362.
[15] ASTM-C311. Standard test methods for sampling and testing y ash or natural
1. The compressive strength of concretes with up to 20% ground pozzolans for use in Portland-cement concrete. Annual Book of ASTM Standard
RHA added attain values equivalent to that control concrete 04; 2002.
[16] Al-Khalaf MN, Yousif HA. Use of rice husk ash in concrete. Int J Cem Compos
after 28 days. On the other hand, although ground RHA presents
Lightweight Concr 1984;6(4):2418.
high carbon content, the experiments in the current study [17] Ismail MS, Waliuddin AM. Effect of rice husk ash on high strength concrete.
found that compressive strengths of the compounds and the Constr Build Mater 1996;10(7):5216.
reference were similar after 28 days, which indicates a possible [18] ASTM-C618. Standard specication for coal y ash and raw or calcined natural
pozzolan for use a mineral admixture in concrete. Annual Book of ASTM
use of the ground RHA as a partial Portland cement substitute. Standard; 2003 [04.02].
2. After 91 days of curing, the electrical resistance of all RHA con- [19] ACI 211.1. Standard practice for selecting proportions for normal,
crete becomes higher than 20 kX-cm. Similarly, for all RHA con- heavyweight, and mass concrete. ACI Manual of Concrete Practice; 1996.
[20] ASTM-C143. Standard test method for slump of hydraulic-cement concrete.
crete samples, the UPV are all higher 3660 m/s after 91 days of Annual Book of ASTM Standard 04; 2002.
curing. The strength efciency of cement in ground RHA con- [21] ASTM-C192/C192M. Standard practice for making and curing concrete test
crete is much higher than that of the control concrete. specimens in the laboratory. Annual Book of ASTM Standard 04; 2002.
[22] ASTM-C39/C39M. Standard test method for compressive strength of
cylindrical concrete specimens. Annual Book of ASTM Standard 04; 2002.
The results prove that it is possible to obtain RHA concrete [23] ASTM-C597. Standard test method for pulse velocity through concrete. Annual
with comparable or better properties than those of the control Book of ASTM Standard 04; 2002.
[24] Zhang MH, Lastra R, Malhotra VM. Rice-husk ash paste and concrete: some
specimen (without RHA) with a lower consumption of cement,
aspects of hydration and the microstructure of the interfacial zone between
thus reducing the CO2 emissions during the production of cement. the aggregate and paste. Cem Concr Res 1996;26(6):96377.
Moreover, while the results will be able to substantiate the viabil- [25] Hope BB, Ip AK, Manning DG. Corrosion and electrical impedance in concrete.
Cem Concr Res 1985;15(3):52534.
ity of application of RHA in concrete industry under the prevailing
[26] Buenfeld NR, Newman JB, Page CL. The resistivity of mortars immersed in sea-
conditions in Vietnam, they are also expected to be especially water. Cem Concr Res 1986;16(4):51124.
useful for future studies on RHA in a specic condition in this [27] Malhotra VM. Testing hardened concrete: nondestructure methods. American
country. Concrete Institute Monograph Series; 1976.
[28] Hwang CL. The theory and practice of high performance concrete. 3rd
ed. Taipei, Taiwan: Janes Book Publisher Co.; 2003.
Acknowledgement [29] Hwang CL, Lin JJ, Lee LS, Lin FY. Desied mixture design algorithm and early
properties of high-performance concrete. J Chinese Inst Civil Hydraulic Eng
1996;8(2):2179.
The authors thank the Ve Wong Corporation for RHA and the [30] Hwang C-L, Chang P-K, Peng Y-N. Application of high-performance concrete to
nancial support that made this publication possible. We are high-rise building in Taiwan. Adv Struct Eng 2001;4(2):6573.
grateful to Professor Lee-Kuo Lin, Professor Ta-Wui Cheng and