You are on page 1of 14

 

Economic  Development  
Education  as  main  element  of  economic  development  
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,  International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  
Edmund  Gibson,  student  number  500658340  
 
   

 
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

 
1. Research  Question  
 
To  what  extent  is  economic  development  influenced  by  education?    
 
 
2. Introduction  
 
Education  is  the  foundation  for  economic  development,  and  it  is  the  reason  why  
investment  in  human  capital  is  of  serious  importance  to  any  country.  Education  
of  the  human  brains  creates  social  benefits  and  can  create  a  competitive  
advantage.    
 
In  many  of  the  developing  countries  this  is  the  area  that  is  often  underdeveloped.  
The  facilities  for  education  are  always  a  point  of  issue,  because  schools  are  
lacking  and  general  knowledge  in  the  society  to  educate  the  students  is  either  not  
available,  so  the  possibilities  for  education  are  really  limited.  Therefore  they  need  
to  get  assistance  from  other  countries.  However  transferring  money  has  until  
now  not  have  had  the  expected  results,  because  giving  the  poor  people  money  is  
not  the  solution  for  helping  them  to  develop.  For  these  developing  countries  
really  to  get  the  right  assistance,  others  should  educate  them.  In  recent  years  this  
is  an  upcoming  trend  of  development  aid.    
 
Poverty  is  a  result  of  lacking  facilities  in  education.  Labour  productivity  can  be  
optimized  and  influenced  when  people  are  educated.  Also  the  improvement  of  
technology  is  the  result  of  the  knowledge  forthcoming  from  more  education.  
Living  standards  will  be  improved  due  to  better  health  conditions.  Hygiene  was  
first  even  not  known,  but  because  of  education  our  life  expectancy  has  grown  
over  the  eras.  These  are  some  of  the  facts  that  are  related  to  education.  
 
Differences  between  economic  developed  countries  and  underdeveloped  
countries  are  measurable.  The  main  element  of  these  measurements,  which  is  
lacking  in  underdeveloped  countries,  is  often  education.  Economic  development  
is  a  process  where  nations  develop  several  areas  as  the  economy,  politics  and  
social  well-­‐being  of  people.  Nation  wide  problems  try  to  be  solved  by  different  
solutions.  Money  is  often  seen  as  a  resource  to  solve  the  internal  problems  of  a  
country,  but  in  many  cases  it  is  a  result  of  development.  First  the  real  cause  of  
underdevelopment  should  be  analyzed,  because  the  attention  spent  to  education  
is  in  many  areas  still  not  enough,  and  it  seems  in  many  cases  to  be  the  real  
structural  problem.  
 
In  this  paper  I  will  discuss  all  elements  that  lead  to  economic  development,  
because  solely  education  of  course  is  not  the  only  important  factor.  Still  the  
relation  between  education  and  the  development  of  an  economy  is  primarily  
discussed,  as  it  is  crucial  for  the  foundation  of  an  economy.    
 
For  this  paper  I  will  mainly  apply  a  theoretical  analysis  from  literature  review  
and  small  parts  are  an  empirical  analysis.  As  references  I  will  several  times  use  
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

different  case  studies  to  compare  and  discuss  the  outcomes  for  answering  the  
research  question  
 
3. History  of  measuring  economic  development  
 
Adam  Smith  is  seen  as  the  first  person  who  introduced  the  termination  of  the  
modern  economy  in  his  work  ‘An  Inquiry  into  the  Nature  and  Causes  of  the  
Wealth  of  Nations’,  published  in  1776  in  the  eve  of  the  industrial  revolution.  His  
work  for  economics  is  comparable  to  Sir  Isaac  Newton  for  physics.  His  work  
touches  upon  topics  as  the  division  of  labour  productivity  and  free  markets.  The  
most  contrasting  view  he  discussed,  was  the  second  variable  for  measuring  value.  
In  his  work  he  did  not  clarify  it,  but  he  posed  the  question  to  be  solved  in  a  future  
discussion.  The  perceived  value  of  a  product  was,  until  his  work,  weighted  to  the  
functionality  it  could  have  for  someone.  In  his  contrasting  view  he  explained  the  
difference  in  value  between  diamonds  and  water.  Water  in  our  case  should  be  of  
a  higher  value  than  a  diamond,  because  water  is  a  primary  good.  Without  it  you  
are  not  able  to  survive.  However  a  diamond  is  worth  more  economically  spoken,  
because  the  search  for  it  takes  a  long  period,  and  searching  costs  is  one  of  the  
variables  that  bounds  value.  Next  to  that,  to  shape  a  diamond,  it  will  cost  you  a  lot  
of  energy,  which  is  seen  as  added  value  and  also  calculated  as  a  variable  in  the  
real  economic  value.    
 
Thus  the  amount  of  time  you  spent  on  search  cost  for  this  product  and  the  energy  
that  it  will  need  to  be  shaped  or  adjusted,  are  variables  of  the  formula  to  calculate  
the  value.  Already  mentioned  that  a  diamond,  while  it  is  not  a  primary  good,  is  of  
a  higher  value  than  water,  which  you  will  need  to  survive  because  of  physical  
dependency.  
 
During  the  20th  century  more  theories  of  economic  development  were  created.  
Smith  was  in  this  sense  an  inspiration  for  famous  economic  scientists  like:  Jean-­‐
Baptiste  Say,  Thomas  Malthus,  Ludwig  von  Mises  and  later  on  even  Karl  Marx.  
The  way  development  was  measured  changed  through  time.    In  earlier  models  
education  was  not  yet  set  as  one  of  the  founding  elements  for  economic  
development.  The  way  of  measuring  development  was  unilateral,  where  GNI  was  
taken  as  the  only  indicator  of  economic  development.  Nowadays  still  one  of  the  
elements  that  repeatedly  is  coming  back  in  articles  about  this  topic  is  the  relation  
between  economic  growth  and  economic  development.  Only  we  start  realizing  
more  and  more  where  economic  growth  comes  from,  can  we  see  it  as  a  deriving  
from  education.  
 
However,  to  explain  what  education  does  with  economic  development,  we  should  
know  more  about  the  history  of  economic  development  and  how  economic  
development  is  measured.    
 
Previously  in  the  models  of  economic  development  where  GNI  was  linked  to  
economic  development,  a  raise  in  the  GNI  did  not  led  to  better  social  standards.  
Although  GNI  was  growing,  poverty  was  not  decreasing.  Poverty  is  mentioned  as  
one  of  the  elements  that  now  is  being  used  as  measure.  It  is  still  a  derivation  of  
the  GNI  per  capita,  because  below  a  certain  limit  of  GNI  it  is  referred  to  poverty.  
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

When  we  are  measuring  economic  development  by  poverty,  unemployment  and  
inequality,  we  have  a  more  multidimensional  view  on  development,  but  the  
multidimensional  approach  in  reality  is  differently  formulated.  
 
The  multidimensional  approach  in  contrast  with  the  unilateral  approach  on  
economic  development  is  comprised  of  three  dimensions,  which  are:  HDI  (human  
development  index),  Development  as  Freedom,  and  the  Happiness  Index.  In  turn  
the  dimension  index  HDI  is  comprised  of  another  three  dimension  indices:  GDP  
index,  education  index  and  life  expectancy  index.  The  indicator  of  the  GDP  index  
is  GNI  or  GDP  per  capita,  for  the  education  index  the  indicators  have  been  
recently  changed  from  adult  literacy  rate  and  gross  enrolment  ratio  towards  
mean  years  of  schooling  and  expected  years  of  schooling,  and  for  life  expectancy  
index  this  is  the  life  expectancy  at  birth.  We  can  conclude  that  education  is  a  
determinant  of  the  HDI  that  has  two  indicators,  which  says  something  about  the  
extent  of  this  element.  These  determinants  are  part  of  the  new  approach  of  
measuring  economic  development.    
 
The  unilateral  approach  had  several  drawbacks,  one  I  have  already  mentioned:  
the  inequality  between  people  is  hidden,  because  the  growth  in  GNI  does  not  say  
anything  about  the  income  distribution  of  a  country.  Poverty  is  measured  by  GNI,  
while  the  average  income  per  capita  might  be  high,  if  only  a  minor  part  of  the  
population  has  the  major  part  of  income,  the  majority  can  live  in  poverty.  Another  
one  is  that  it  does  not  capture  large  informal  economies,  and  these  economies  of  
developing  countries  are  usually  large  informal  economies,  due  to  the  
minimalistic  registration  of  personal  enterprises.  The  reason  for  the  lack  of  
registration  is  avoiding  taxes,  but  this  is  a  negative  symptom  for  the  national  
economies,  as  government  investments  fail  to  grow,  when  income  taxes  are  
staying  at  a  minimum.  
 
Nowadays  development  is  not  only  measured  by  means  of  money,  but  also  via  the  
happiness,  welfare  and  freedom  people  enjoy.  Amartya  Sen  who  defined  
development  as  freedom  explained  that  development  is  the  process  of  expanding  
freedoms  that  people  enjoy.  Money  or  growth  in  GNI  can  improve  such  freedoms,  
only  freedom  depends  also  on  other  determinants  like  social  and  economic  
arrangements  as  health  and  education,  but  also  political  and  civil  rights.    
 
Now  the  improvement  of  humanity  as  social-­‐being  is  reached  by  the  development  
of  freedom,  which  requires  the  removal  of  major  opression.  In  the  developing  
countries  tyranny,  poverty,  social  deprivation  and  neglecting  public  facilities  are  
markers  of  a  civilization  that  is  still  living  in  opression.  Acting  against  it  should  
create  a  better  and  more  equal  world.  Although  the  majority  of  our  world  lives  in  
poverty  and  inequality,  the  acting  against  it  is  relative  small  with  regards  to  the  
scale.  Our  contribution  should  be  a  lot  higher  and  new  ways  of  offering  
development  aid  should  be  applied  like  structural  solutions  that  match  the  
environmental  situation:  the  increase  of  total  production,  the  distribution  of  
incomes,  improvements  in  education  and  health,  and  enhancing  social  and  
political  freedoms  people  enjoy.  
 
 
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

 
 
4. The  importance  of  education  for  economic  development  
 
4.1. Education  and  labour  productivity  
 
Viewing  the  economy  on  a  micro  level,  and  looking  at  our  personal  situation  with  
regards  to  development,  there  is  a  direct  link  between  education  and  economic  
development.  1When  you  are  higher  educated  the  possibilities  for  getting  a  
decent  job  with  a  better  income  are  considerably  higher  than  when  you  are  
illiterate.  The  less  educated  people,  according  to  statistics,  have  lower  scaled  and  
lower  paid  jobs.  Clearly  the  provision  of  educational  opens  ways  for  increasing  
income  due  to  the  fact  that  it  is  one  of  the  determinants,  which  impact  on  labour  
productivity.    Besides  that  it  functions  as  an  important  ingredient  of  growth  and  
contributes  towards  development  in  a  country  with  regard  to  the  adaptation  and  
acquisition  of  technology  
 
To  elaborate,  there  are  several  layers  of  education,  which  improve  the  labour  
productivity,  like  primary,  secondary  and  tertiary  education.  Primary  education  
together  with  health  and  nutrition  all  are  relevant  in  the  first  place  for  a  raise  in  
the  productivity  of  workers  in  rural  and  urban  environments.  Secondary  
education  will  improve  managerial  skills  by  acquisition  of  the  vocational  
knowledge.  Tertiary  education  is  beneficial  to  the  selection  of  the  right  
technology  as  it  affects  basic  science  and  therefore  is  related  to  key  institutions  
as  governments,  financial  enterprises  and  the  law.  All  these  institutions  
contribute  in  different  ways  to  the  growth  of  an  economy.  
 
When  we  analyze  the  macro  economy  of  developing  markets  we  can  also  detect  
the  correlation  between  education  and  labour  productivity,  described  in  the  
previous  paragraph.  For  instance,  consider  Brazil,  which  is  a  developing  country,  
where  GDP  appears  to  have  been  rising  in  recent  last  years,  if  we  disregard  the  
inflation  –  which  remains  a  serious  problem.  In  the  past  we  would  have  regarded  
this  as  economic  development.  Only  now  we  see  this  differently,  because  
currently  there  are  serious  problems  with  the  productivity  of  workers.  
 
According  to  statistics  in  Brazil  about  labour  productivity  we  see  an  opposite  
movement  compared  with  the  average  labour  productivity  of  the  world’s  
development.  Apart  from  a  brief  spurt  in  between  the  1960s  and  1970s  the  
labour  productivity  or  output  per  worker  has  stagnated  over  the  half  past  
century.  In  fact  it  has  even  slipped,  the  total-­‐factor  labour  productivity  is  now  
even  lower  than  it  was  in  1980  (see  figure  4.1).  
 
2Although  Brazil’s  GDP  grew  between  1990  and  2012,  the  labour  productivity  

accounted  only  for  40%  of  this  growth,  which  in  comparison  with  China  91%  and  
India  67%  is  rather  low.  Also  the  investments  of  Brazil  in  infrastructure  are  only  

                                                                                                               
1  Behrman,  Jere  R.  (1990),  Human  Resource  Led  Development,  Review  of  Issues  and  Development,  Ned  Delhi,  India:  
2  The  Economist,  The  50  year  Snooze,  http://www.economist.com/news/americas/21600983-­‐brazilian-­‐workers-­‐are-­‐

gloriously-­‐unproductive-­‐economy-­‐grow-­‐they-­‐must-­‐snap-­‐out,  retrieved  on:  6/7/14  


University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

2.2%  of  the  GDP.  Compared  to  the  developing-­‐world  this  is  less  than  half  the  
average  investment  of  5.1%.  
 
Data  from  the  278  thousand  patents  granted  last  year  shows  that  only  254  
patents  (3  %)  are  accounted  for  inventors  from  Brazil.  These  patents  contribute  
to  the  world’s  output  and  people.  It  is  very  clear  that  the  spending  on  education  
in  Brazil  has  not  had  the  right  direction  and  attention.  The  investment  in  the  
provision  of  educational  institutions  has  grown  to  a  level  similar  to  that  of  rich-­‐
world  nations.  However  the  quality  still  leaves  a  lot  to  be  desired.  
 
Central  problems  that  currently  arise  are  caused  by  the  shifting  towards  irregular  
enterprises  outside  of  the  formal  economy,  due  to  the  preferential  tax  treatment  
for  small  companies  with  turnovers  less  than  $  1.6  million.  This  discourages  
companies  to  grow  any  further.  Also  the  vicious  circle  here  is  that  these  
companies  will  gain  advantages  through  optimizing  efficiency.  This  will  require  
fewer  workers.  The  companies  however  retain  their  low  skilled  workers  as  they  
are  more  easily  trusted,  and  the  risk  they  see  in  a  better-­‐qualified  stranger  will  
hold  them  back  from  employing  them.  Companies  are  wary  of  being  sued  for  
flouting  notoriously  worker-­‐friendly  labour  laws.  Consequently  the  average  skills  
of  the  workforce  are  decreasing  and  the  problem  is  getting  bigger.  
 
Another  problem  is  that  the  government  is  protecting  the  weak  firms  with  
various  forms  of  protectionism.  For  example  high  tariffs  on  imported  technology  
are  set,  which  makes  it  almost  impossible  to  import  productivity-­‐enhancing  
equipment  due  to  the  prohibitive  expense.  Better  and  cheaper  products  with  a  
higher  quality  cannot  be  imported  and  lower  quality  products  continue  to  be  
produced  by  local  firms  with  poor  equipment.  This  system  is  not  beneficial  to  the  
labour  productivity.    
 
Education  alone,  of  course  cannot  transform  an  economy.  However  getting  the  
right  people  at  the  right  places  can  have  a  considerable  impact  on  a  system.  The  
tertiary  education  is  focused  on  basic  science  and  is  desirable  for  the  
development  of  key  institutions  like  the  governments  and  the  financial  systems.  
Economic  politics  have  to  be  changed  in  a  nation  as  Brazil,  because  now  they  just  
impede  the  development  process  instead  of  improving.  Once  the  decision  makers  
gain  the  required  knowledge,  many  solutions  can  be  introduced.    
 
Remedies  for  their  situation  are  for  instance:  reducing  the  role  of  state  by  
privatization,  reforming  and  streamlining  of  tax  system,  reducing  inefficient  
regulations,  remove  barriers  to  entrepreneurship,  remove  the  rigidities  in  the  
labour  market  which  discourage  employment  of  the  higher  educated,  and  lastly  
reforming  the  pension  system.  At  the  moment  many  of  the  beneficiaries  never  
contribute  to  their  own  pensions.  Unfortunately  decisions  necessary  to  
implement  the  above  remedies  will  not  be  taken  as  long  the  new  higher  educated  
are  not  the  ones  in  charge.      
 
From  a  macro  perspective  the  new  methods  for  economic  development  
emphasize  research  and  development  and  learning,  next  to  education.  As  the  
level  of  education  becomes  higher  the  work  force  related  productivity  of  capital  
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

will  also  rise.  This  will  have  an  effect  on  the  extent  in  how  far  innovations  will  
develop,  because  the  higher  educated  are  more  likely  to  innovate.  This  will  
benefit  the  overall  productivity.    
 
3In  similar  models  there  is  a  relation  between  the  increase  in  education  and  the  

productivity  of  the  individual’s  environment.  The  productivity  of  the  people  with  
whom  the  individual  interacts  will  be  commensurate  to  the  rise  of  the  
individual’s  level  of  education.  So  this  means  that  cooperating  with  individuals  
who  are  increasing  their  level  of  educational  will  to  a  certain  extent  reflect  on  
your  own  level  of  education.  Therefore  in  Brazil  they  should  allow  and  accept  
more  of  the  higher  educated  in  the  workforce  in  order  to  generate  a  positive  viral  
effect  on  the  lower  skilled  workers  that  currently  are  employed.    
 
The  impact  on  the  nature  and  growth  is  another  way  in  which  human  
development  influences  macro  performance  and  strengthen  the  trade  position  of  
a  country.  In  addition  it  is  argued  that  even  the  unskilled  workers  in  a  modern  
factory  normally  need  the  same  educational  skills  like  literacy,  numeracy  and  
discipline  to  levelers  offered  by  primary  and  lower  secondary  school.    
 
4.2. Education  and  income  
 
4According  to  Rostow’s  Model  ‘The  Stages  of  Economic  Development’  every  

country  will  pass  through  5  stages  of  economic  development.  It  starts  in  the  first  
stage  the  ‘Traditional  Society’.  The  first  manner  of  development  has  to  do  with  
trade  in  the  agriculture  sector  where  subsistence  is  realized  through  barter.  
Income  is  not  a  subject  in  this  stage,  as  a  barter  deal  for  primary  goods  is  
sufficient.  A  barter  deal  is  an  exchange  of  products  where  no  money  is  involved  
or  an  extra-­‐added  transactional  value..  
 
Following  the  process  of  developing  and  processing  to  the  second  stage,  the  
‘Transitional  Stage’,  we  encounter  the  first  signs  of  generating  income.  Through  
the  process  of  specialization  surpluses  and  scarcities  are  created  which  lead  to  
trade  at  this  stage.  Due  to  specialization  not  all  goods  or  services  will  be  
available  at  every  location.  The  need  for  transport  arises.  In  the  same  stage  the  
infrastructure  also  is  improving,  which  leads  to  a  higher  productivity  rate.  Many  
of  the  first  civilized  cities  are  in  the  vicinity  of  water.  The  main  reason  is  the  
availability  of  a  rather  direct  connection  to  transport  and  of  course  water  is  one  
of  the  basic  needs.    
 
When  we  are  analyzing  the  process  of  specialization  we  find  the  origin  of  
education  in  the  need  to  share  of  knowledge.  From  an  empirical  perspective,  
going  far  back  to  basics,  once  we  have  found  out  that  we  could  specialize  with  
the  resources  that  were  at  hand,  we  acquired  more  knowledge  about  the  
production  of  agriculture  and  the  possibilities.  This  knowledge  translated  in  
education  is  shared  during  the  process  of  specialization.  
 
                                                                                                               
3  Perotti,  R.,  (1993),  “Political  Equilibrium  Income  Distribution,  and  Growth”  Review  of  Economic  Studies,  p.  60  
4  Submited  by  Bized  on  1/1/2001,  Rostow’s  Model,  http://www.bized.co.uk/virtual/dc/copper/theory/th9.htm,  

retrieved  on  6/8/2014  


University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

Moreover  Rostow’s  views  development  requires  substantial  growth  in  


investments  of  capital.  Economies  as  LDC’s  will  obtain  the  right  conditions  and  
are  likely  to  gain  rapid  growth  when  direct  investments  by  foreign  aid  are  
coming  in  stage  three.    
 
Stage  three  is  the  ‘Take  Off’  stage,  but  before  LDC’s  has  reached  this  stage  they  
first  need  to  move  along  the  second  stage.  If  the  second  stage  has  not  been  
completed,  substantial  capital  investments,  which  we  often  see  with  foreign  aid,  
will  fail  to  contribute  to  the  development  of  a  country.  The  argument  for  failure  
with  this  kind  of  aid  is  caused  by  a  lack  of  education  on  the  industries  that  need  
to  be  developed.  Corruption  is  then  in  many  cases  a  result  of  the  incorrect  
application  of  foreign  aid.  
 
During  the  Take  Off  stage  industrialization  is  the  main  element  characterizing  
this  period  of  economic  development.  Following  the  timeline  from  the  past,  the  
Industrial  Revolution  came  right  after  the  Age  of  Enlightenment.    
 
5  The  Age  of  Enlightenment  was  a  cultural  movement  in  late  17th-­‐century  where  

Europe  was  emphasizing  reason  and  individualism.  The  movement  aimed  to  
change  society  and  challenge  ideas,  following  a  scientific  method.  Promotion  of  
scientific  thought,  skepticism  and  the  interchange  of  intellect  were  distinctive  for  
this  era.  Logically  the  Industrial  Revolution  followed  up  this  era  of  scientific  
reasoning  and  the  exchange  of  knowledge,  which  was  in  fact  the  changing  
process  of  education.  The  attention  devoted  to  education  led  to  a  process  of  
economic  development.    
 
First  in  the  Take  Off  stage  the  investment  in  human  capital  stimulates  the  
investments  in  the  production  process  by  applying  the  technology,  which  is  
acquired  during  the  prior  period  of  enlightenment.  Second  political  change  will  
take  place  after  regional  growth  is  realized.  For  this  realization  process  
requirements  like  well-­‐functioning  markets,  developed  infrastructure,  efficient  
government  and  educated  population,  need  to  be  met.  An  efficient  government  
will  develop  only  from  the  moment  that  corruption  is  reduced  through  the  
employment  of  skilled  and  reliable  workers.  
 
The  fourth  stage  is  the  ‘Drive  to  Maturity’  stage  that  encompasses  diversification,  
innovation,  less  reliance  on  imports  and  more  investments.  Diversification  is  a  
result  of  competition  stimulated  by  learning.  Knowing  about  the  competition  
creates  new  opportunities  by  differing  from  them.  From  the  same  perspective  
innovation  is  also  inherent  in  education,  because  through  research  and  
development  new  ideas  will  occur.  The  role  of  education  in  development  is  seen  
from  almost  all  perspectives.  
 
The  last  stage  of  Rostow’s  Model,  the  ‘High  Mass  Consumption’  is  about  the  
consumer  orientation,  durable  goods  and  the  service  industry.  All  these  
elements  generate  income,  however  in  the  second  stage  generating  income  
already  began.  The  relation  in  the  transitional  stage  between  specialization  and  

                                                                                                               
5  “Enlightenment”.  Oxford  Dictionaries.  Oxford  University  Press,  n.d.  Web.  19  September  2013  
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

surpluses  is  the  same  as  personal  development  and  getting  employed.  In  the  end  
it  will  generate  income.  
 
Although  I  have  already  mentioned  that  education  is  not  the  only  solution  for  
evolution,  it  does  take  a  major  part  in  the  development  of  an  economy.  Economic  
growth  is  often  taken  as  a  requirement  for  economic  development,  and  to  an  
important  extent  we  can  attain  economic  growth  through  investments  in  
education.  At  least,  we  do  believe  this  is  true.    
 
6  However  there  is  a  study  of  this  theory,  which  illustrates  disparities  in  the  way  

that  a  higher  level  of  investments  in  education  can  affect  the  economic  growth  
path.    
 
Barro  and  Lee  (1994)  explain  in  their  study  that  the  increase  in  students  who  
attended  secondary  school  between  1965  and  1985  caused  a  positive  effect  on  
the  economic  growth,  but  other  research  disputes  this  result.  For  instance  the  
studies  done  by  Benhabib  and  Spiegel  (1994)  and  Pritchett  (1996)  also  measure  
the  relation  between  economic  growths  as  a  result  of  a  higher  level  of  
investments  on  education.  In  their  case  however  they  use  an  aggregated  
production  function  with  various  measurements  of  human  capital,  including  the  
number  of  years  education,  literacy  rates,  and  secondary  enrolment  rates.  
Whatever  the  choice  of  measurements  for  education,  the  effect  of  the  associated  
coefficients  on  economic  growth  were  not  significant.  
 
Empirical  tests  show  us  that  education  is  an  important  factor  for  promoting  
economic  development;  countries  with  a  high  level  of  education  in  1960  have  
certainly  shown  significant  economic  development  40  years  later.  On  the  other  
hand  however,  whatever  the  different  models  for  measuring  human  capital  
variables  may  tend  to  predict,  there  is  a  yet  no  definite  proof  that  countries  
which  invest  more  in  education  universally  experience  a  higher  growth  rate.  The  
jury  is  still  out!  
 
Still,  these  contradictions,  disparities  or  call  it  uncertainty  about  this  relation  
might  exist,  they  do  not  take  in  account  for  this  measurement  factors  as  policy  
making,  migration  of  knowledge,  investment  in  physical  capital,  openness  to  
trade  and  investment,  and  the  overall  institutional  environment,  and  external  
shocks.  The  investment  in  education  on  its  own  does  not  one  on  one  directly  
supports  economic  growth,  but  it  is  a  combination  of  several  factors.  In  Brazil  
the  current  situation  is  a  reality  and  evidence  for  above-­‐mentioned  outcomes.  
They  have  economic  growth,  however  they  still  are  underdeveloped,  and  the  
high  educated  are  unemployed  (see  figure  4.2).  These  kinds  of  reasons  can  be  
the  cause  in  the  insignificance  of  the  results  from  Benhabib  and  Spiegel  (1994)  
and  Pritchett  (1996).  So  there  are  more  views  and  statements  about  this  
relation.  
 
When  we  would  educate  the  labor  force  instead  of  the  whole  society  we  are  able  
to  prove  the  relation,  because  according  to  a  study,  with  one  percent  increase  in  
                                                                                                               
6  Economic  Returns  to  Investment  in  Education  http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTMENA/Resources/EDU_02-­‐

Chap02-­‐Education.pdf  ,  p  42-­‐43,  retrieved  on  6/9/2014  


University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

the  labor  force  with  at  least  secondary  education,  we  can  find  results  of  an  
increase  in  the  share  of  income  of  the  bottom  40  and  60%  by  between  6  to  15%  
respectively  (Bourguignon  and  Morrison,  1990).  
 
4.3. Education  and  health  
 
One  clarification,  for  both  studies  discussed  in  the  last  paragraphs,  could  be  that  
education  may  reduce  fertility  when  women  are  the  ones  who  are  receiving  
education.  A  study  of  fourteen  African  countries  for  the  mid-­‐eighties  showed  a  
negative  correlation  between  women  who  entered  schools  and  the  fertility  in  all  
participating  countries.  With  primary  education  there  was  clearly  a  negative  
impact  in  about  half  the  countries  and  no  significant  effects  in  the  other  half,  
while  secondary  education  reduced  fertility  (Birdsall  1995,  Behraman  and  Wolfe  
1987).  The  three  success  countries,  where  the  reduction  of  fertility  were  high,  
Kenya,  Botswana,  and  Zimbabwe,  had  the  highest  levels  of  female  schooling  as  
well  as  the  lowest  child  mortality  rates  (Ainsworth,  1995).    
 
A  consequence  with  reducing  the  fertility  rate  is  that  economic  growth  will  rise,  
due  to  the  fact  that  the  GDP  is  divided  over  a  smaller  population.  More  education  
about  parenthood  will  lead  to  fewer  children,  as  the  attention  spent  per  child  is  
growing  when  the  educational  level  rises.  In  the  developing  markets  like  Taiwan,  
Hong  Kong,  Mexico  and  Poland  declining  birth  rates  characterizes  these  places.  
In  addition  education  on  the  fields  of  health  contributes  to  a  longer  life  
expectancy,  which  on  its  turn  leads  to  more  working  hours  per  capita.  
 
Moreover  the  education  of  women,  because  here  are  more  problems  than  just  
only  fertility.  7According  to  the  factsheet  of  the  United  Nations  women  are  more  
disadvantaged  than  men  when  it  comes  to  lacking  education.  In  the  most  OECD  
countries,  women  report  higher  incidents  of  disability  than  men.  Women  with  
disabilities  are  recognized  with  regards  to  disadvantage  to  be  on  a  multiply  
scale,  due  to  their  gender  and  their  disability.  In  India  they  are  vulnerable  to  
abuse.  In  2004  a  survey  found  that  virtually  all  of  the  woman  and  girls  were  
beaten  at  home,  25  percent  of  women  with  intellectual  disabilities  had  been  
raped  and  6  percent  of  them  had  been  sterilized.  
 
The  principal  item  here  is  related  to  the  relation  between  education  and  the  
strength  of  its  position.  Education  on  health  can  help  teenagers  to  make  the  right  
decisions.  A  study  that  estimated  the  effects  of  a  program  that  experienced  with  
providing  vocational  training  and  information  about  risky  health  behaviors  to  
adolescent  girls,  Bandiera  et  al.  (2012),  led  to  both  an  increase  in  HIV-­‐related  
knowledge  and  condom-­‐use.  Also  are  more  positive  results  available  of  studies  
where  teenage  boys  are  informed  about  school-­‐return,  less  heavy  drinking  and  
fewer  smokers.  The  opposite  evidence  of  this  relation  is  in  the  United  States  
where  the  percentage  of  smokers  in  the  group  of  dropouts  is  extensively  larger  
than  in  the  groups  of  people  who  are  educated.  
 

                                                                                                               
7  United  Nations  Enable,  Factsheet  on  Persons  With  Disabilities  http://www.un.org/disabilities/default.asp?id=18  

retrieved  on  6/10/2014  


University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

Referring  back  to  the  stage  three  of  Rostow’s  model,  the  period  where  a  society  
starts  with  industrialization,  this  is  also  a  period  where  education  on  health  is  
becoming  to  play  a  bigger  role.  Reminding  you  the  second  phase  of  our  
Industrial  Revolution,  where  the  health  of  workers  due  to  proper  education  have  
positively  changed  through  the  ages,  which  accordingly  led  to  a  better  labour  
productivity  and  so  on  contributed  to  economic  growth  and  development  
 
4.4.    Education  and  the  external  environment:  trade,  policy  and  inequality  
 
Education  has  a  real  impact  on  economic  development,  and  in  all  areas  there  is  a  
link  to  education.  There  are  direct  and  indirect  links  to  income,  health  and  
safety,  but  it  is  not  the  only  factor  that  determines  economic  development.  The  
higher  the  level  of  education  gets,  the  more  it  contributes  to  the  economic  
development  of  a  society,  but  is  not  the  only  component  for  a  developing  market  
or  country.  Determinants  as  openness  to  trade,  policy  and  inequality  also  make  a  
significant  difference.    
 
For  instance  gender  or  racial  inequality  can  lead  to  hinder  when  applying  for  a  
job.  Women  will  get  pregnant  and  this  is  a  disadvantage  for  an  employer,  
because  it  can  cause  unnecessary  costs.  If  you  have  African  roots  bias  are  made,  
which  might  hinder  your  position  in  business  situations.  The  poor  people  
experience  also  inequality,  because  growing  up  in  a  family  that  lives  below  the  
poverty  line  will  minimalize  the  opportunities  and  provisions  to  proper  
education.  Besides,  in  the  developing  countries  children  are  often  only  taken  for  
participating  in  the  workforce.  These  are  regular  situations,  while  in  western  
world,  child  labour  is  even  forbidden.  So  education  might  help  to  a  certain  
extent,  but  these  factors  weigh  also  heavy  in  economic  development  
 
Openness  to  trade  can  also  limit  economic  development,  when  wrong  decisions  
are  made.  Systems  where  protectionism  is  applied  have  goals  to  make  the  
domestic  products  stronger,  however  there  are  more  examples  of  the  negative  
impact  on  development  than  positive.  In  Brazil  where  economic  growth  is  at  
hand,  development  is  lacking,  due  to  rules  of  protectionism.  Heavy  taxes  are  
applied  on  imports,  which  shackles  the  import  of  new  technologies,  so  the  labour  
productivity  stays  inefficient.  Instead  of  lowering  the  taxes,  and  stimulating  
development  according  to  a  higher  competition,  they  make  these  wrong  
decisions  
 
Another  example  of  other  factors  that  can  seriously  damage  and  hinder  the  
development  of  a  country  we  see  in  Nigeria.  In  many  countries  property  rights  
are  regularities,  however  in  Nigeria  people  have  no  property  rights.  All  
properties  belong  to  the  government,  and  getting  value  from  the  property  makes  
no  sense,  as  you  are  not  able  to  get  a  part  of  this  value  for  yourself.  To  stimulate  
economic  development  in  a  country  like  Nigeria  is  therefore  almost  impossible.  
According  to  a  study  Nigeria  has  an  IPRI  of  3.9  and  is  ranked  as  122  of  131  
rankings,  Hernando  de  Soto  Fellow  (2012).  The  IPRI  is  an  index  for  International  
Property  Rights  that  comprise  the  indicators:  LP(Legal  and  Political  
Environment),  PPR  (Physical  Property  Rights)  and  IPR  (Intellectual  Property  
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

Rights).  This  index  indicates  the  ranking  of  131  countries  that  account  for  98  
percent  of  world  Gross  Domestic  Product  and  93  percent  of  world  population.    
 
Moreover,  when  investments  would  be  done  in  education  for  a  country  as  
Nigeria,  the  quality  of  this  education  is  from  a  significant  lower  level  than  in  
countries  where  the  IPR  index  is  a  lot  higher,  because  the  education  will  not  be  
complete  in  the  sense  of  transparency,  propaganda,  censure  and  similar  areas  
like  these.  In  addition  the  political  stability  in  Nigeria  will  also  not  concur  to  an  
economic  healthy  situation  for  development.  
 
5. Conclusion  
 
So  in  conclusion  education  will  determine  a  main  part  of  the  foundation  for  
economic  development.  In  all  stages  of  Rostow’s  model  for  economic  
development,  education  is  to  a  certain  extent  a  significant  determinant  of  the  
composition  for  economic  growth.  Although  studies  have  shown  some  
disparities  in  the  relation  between  education  and  economic  growth,  empirical  
analysis  shows  that  there  is  undeniably  a  correlation.    
 
To  measure  economic  development,  there  are  three  indicators  that  form  the  
Human  Development  Index:  GDP  index,  education  index  and  life  expectancy  
index.  The  variables  for  measuring  of  the  GDP  and  life  expectancy  are  clearly  
stated  and  remain  unchanged  through  the  ages,  whereas  the  means  for  
measurement  of  the  education  index  has  been  changed.  This  change  leads  to  a  
heavier  weighting  for  the  education  index  in  the  overall  observation  of  the  HDI.  
 
However  we  explained  that  education  alone  is  not  the  only  cause  for  economic  
development.  The  Human  Development  Index,  Development  of  Freedom  and  
Happiness  Index  together  offer  a  measurement  the  amount  of  economic  
development  of  a  country.  Although  this  is  the  modern  way  of  measuring,  it  will  
continue  to  evolve.  
 
In  a  world  where  the  complexity  of  systems  continues  to  increase,  the  
development  of  the  formulas  we  need  to  monitor  the  systems  will  accordingly  
also  change.  The  trigger  for  this  change  can  only  be  provided  by  education.  
 
 
6. References  
 
http://www.economist.com/news/americas/21600983-­‐brazilian-­‐workers-­‐are-­‐
gloriously-­‐unproductive-­‐economy-­‐grow-­‐they-­‐must-­‐snap-­‐out  
 
http://mpra.ub.uni-­‐muenchen.de/9023/1/MPRA_paper_9023.pdf  
 
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTMENA/Resources/EDU_02-­‐Chap02-­‐
Education.pdf  
 
http://bib03.caspur.it/ojspadis/index.php/PSLQuarterlyReview/article/view/11520/1
1387  
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

 
http://www.princeton.edu/~tvogl/vogl_ed_health_review.pdf  
 
Ainsworth,  M.L.  Beegle  and  A.  Nyamete,  (1995),  The  Impact  of  Female  Schooling  on  
Fertility  and  Contraceptive,  LSMS  Working  Papers  110,  Washington,  DC:  World  Bank.  
 
Bandiera,  O.,  N.  Buehren,  R.  Burgess,  M.  Goldstein,  S.  Gulesci,  I.  Rasul  &  M.  Sulaiman.  
(2012).  “Empowering  adolescent  girls:  Evidence  from  a  randomized  control  trial  in  
Uganda.”  Mimeo,  London  School  of  Economics  
 
Barro,  Robert  J.,  and  Jong-­‐Wha  Lee.  1994.  “Sources  of  Economic  Growth.”  Carnegie  
Rochester  Conference  Series  on  Public  Policy  40  
 
Behrman,  Jere  R.  (1990),  Human  Resource  LedDevelopment,  Review  of  Issues  and  
Development,  Ned  Delhi,  India:  ARTEP/ILO.  
 
Benhabib,  Jess,  and  Mark  M.  Spiegel.  1994.  “The  Role  of  Human  Capital  in  Economic  
Development:  Evidence  for  Aggregate  Cross-­‐Country  Data.”  Journal  of  Monetary  
Economics  34:  143-­‐73  
 
Birdsall,  N.  (1993),  “Social  Development  in  Economic  Development”,  World  Bank  Policy  
research  working  Papers,  WPS  1123,  Washington  DC.  
 
Bourguinon,  F.  and  C.  Morrison  (1990),  “Income  Distribution,  Development  and  Foreign  
Trade:  A  Cross-­‐sectional  Analysis”,  European  Economic  Review,  34  
 
“Enlightment”.  Oxford  Dictionaries.  Oxford  University  Press,  n.d.  Web.  19  September  
2013  
 
Perotti,  R.,  (1993),  “Political  Equilibrium  Income  Distribution,  and  Growth”  Review  of  
Economic  Studies,  60  
 
Soto  Fellow,  Hernando  de.,  Francesco  Di  Lorenzo  (2012).  “2013  Report:  International  
Property  Rights  Index”.  
 
 
7. Graphs  and  Figures  
 
Figure  4.1  
 
University  of  Applied  Sciences  of  Amsterdam,    
International  Business  and  Management  Studies  Part  Time.  

 
 
Figure  4.2  
 

You might also like