Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PHARMACEUTICAL SCIENCES
http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1129407
Please cite this article in press as Dashtbozorgi B et al., Comparison of Mental Health of Military Personnel and
Soldiers in One of the Army Units in Ahvaz. Iran., Indo Am. J. P. Sci, 2017; 4(12).
accompanied by adaptation and consistency, the provided them with competent authorities, the
probability of the formation of young psychosocial necessary mental health promotion for these forces
problems is provided [16]. Military jobs are among can be planned.
the tough jobs in which suicide and self-harm are
increasing. According to World Health Organization MATERIALS AND METHODS:
The present study is a cross-sectional descriptive
estimates, in 2020, roughly 1530000 people die of
analytical study that, in this study, the mental health
suicide and 10 to 20 times this number suicide. These
of the cadre and private staff of the military units in
figures indicate that, on average, every 20 seconds
the city of Ahwaz was compared in 2016. The
someone dies of suicide and every 1 to 2 seconds
statistical population of this study consists of all
someone suicides [17]. 12 successful suicide among
cadre and private personnel of the military in Ahvaz
military personnel and 9 per 100000 were reported
who served during this research period. In this study,
among civilians. Although there are no detailed
the research environment was the same military unit
statistics on suicide in the army of Iran, but reports
in Ahwaz, the reason for choosing this environment
indicate a high incidence of suicide among soldiers
was easy access to research samples. To determine
[18-19]. The American Army's Behavioral Sciences
the sample size, a pilot study was initially carried out
Research Center reported that suicide is the third
on 50 cadre staff members and 50 privates and with
most common cause of death among American
the help of pilot study data, the final sample size was
soldiers. The report also stated that 48 percent of
250 [125 cadre members of 125 private soldiers] who
suicides occur among soldiers between the ages of
were selected from the research community based on
18-24 [20].
entry characteristics and randomly and after
Research has shown that 84 percent of soldiers who obtaining consent, they entered the study. Inclusion
commit suicide have psychiatric disorders and there criteria include: Passing for at least 4 months from
is a high correlation between low mental health and the duration of service for private soldiers and having
suicide attempt [21]. Fear of violence and behavioral at least 5 years of service for cadres and exclusion
punishment, conflict with commanders, being away criteria include incomplete filled questionnaires.
from the family, are the causes of suicide attempts.
Data collection was done using demographic
Suicide and suicide attempt are among the most
information form and GHQ-28 general health
important indicators of the mental health of
questionnaire. The demographic information form
individuals in a community [22]. The incidence of
contained demographic information of the units
maladaptive behaviors in military personnel, whether
studied included age, marital status, education level,
cadre personnel or private soldiers, depends on
type of residence [native and non-native], and
stressors and how to deal with the stresses in the
duration of military service. GHQ-28 General Health
environment [23-24]. Some researches on stressors
Questionnaire is of the screening tools used in the
and coping strategies have examined the effect of
epidemiological studies of mental disorders
these factors on mental and physical health [25-26].
developed by Goldberg in 1972 and the purpose of
The role of military units in the Khuzestan province the design was to detect and diagnose mental
is important for defending the southwestern borders disorders in health centers and in various situations.
of the country and a large number of personnel are 28-question form of General Health Questionnaire
serving as cadre and private staff in the province and has been developed by the Goldberg and Hiller in
considering the necessity of maintaining the country's 1979 which consists of 28 questions and 4 sub-scales,
security with physically and mentally capable and each scale has 7 questions. Questions examine
personnel, taking into account the occupation of the the mental health status of a person in the past month.
military forces and the stresses on them and because Each dimension has 7 questions which are
in Khuzestan province no quantitative studies were respectively physical symptoms [question 1-7],
conducted to assess the mental health problems of the anxiety [question 8-14], disorder in social functioning
military, the researchers decided to conduct a study [15-21] and depression [question 22-28]. The Likert
aimed at comparing the mental health of cadre and scoring method [0-1-2-3] has been used for scoring,
private staff members in one of the Ahvaz military with a maximum score of 84. Since this tool is used
units so in this way, information about the mental to screen and identify people with a disorder, a higher
health of the armed forces can be obtained and score in the test indicates a disorder. The overall cut-
off point for the questionnaire is 23 and the cut-off
mental health status, in both groups of the cadre (9%) differences between the two groups in the subscales
and the private soldiers (48.8%) are related to the of anxiety symptoms (P-value = 0.130), social
subscales of anxiety symptoms and sleep disorders. function disorder (P-value = 0.270) and depression
The results of the T-test show that, there is a (P-value = 0.196). Also, the results of the T-test show
statistically significant difference between the two that, there is a statistically significant difference
groups of cadre and private soldier in terms of mean between the two groups of cadre and private
scores of the subscale of physical symptoms (P-value personnel in terms of the mean total score of mental
= 0.002). However, there were no significant health (P-value = 0.004) (Table 4).
Table 1: Demographic characteristics of the research units divided into two groups of cadre personnel and
private soldiers
Service type
Personnel Soldiers
Demographic Variables
frequency Percent frequency Percent
18- 28 42 33.6 120 96
age 29-39 60 48 4 3.2
40-50 23 18.4 1 0.8
Total 125 100 125 100
marital status Single 41 32.8 82 65.6
married 84 67.2 43 34.4
Total 125 100 125 100
Under
42 33.6 82 65.6
the diploma
education
High school
83 66.4 43 34.4
diploma
Total 125 100 125 100
type native 47 37.6 67 53.6
of residence Non-native 78 62.4 58 46.4
Total 125 100 125 100
Table 2: Frequency distribution and percentage of research units based on mental health status
State of P - value
mental health
Healthy Unhealthy Total
Service type
frequency Percent frequency Percent frequency Percent
Table 3: Frequency distribution and percentage of mental problems in the studied units have unhealthy
mental status
Level of
Mental Mild Moderate Sevier Total
P - value
problem
Service type
Personnel 73 59.8 41 33.6 8 6.6 122 100
Soldiers 87 70.7 31 25 5 4.3 123 100 0.87
Total 160 64 72 28.8 13 7.2 245 100
Table 4: The comparison of mean and standard deviation of sub-scales of GHQ-28 mental health
questionnaire in the studied units divided into two groups of cadre personnel and private soldiers
Personnel Soldiers
P - value
Mental health
sub-scale of GHQ-28 Mean ± SD Mean ± SD
Somatization 9.68 ± 4.4 8.16 ± 3.3 0.002
Anxiety & Insomnia 9 ± 4.39 7.48 ± 3.75 0.130
Social dysfunction 11.46 ± 2.81 12.52 ± 3.11 0.270
Depression 10.12 ± 5.34 8.10 ± 4.74 0.196
Total mean score
40.27 ± 12.5 36.3 ± 9.1 0.004
GHQ- 28
the high level of psychological problems in these anxiety symptoms and sleep disorders and, in the
forces. Today, soldiers are more likely to go to private soldier group, the most common problem is
counseling centers than before. In addition, their associated with the sub-scales of social dysfunction,
problems have become more complex and have been physical symptoms, depression, and anxiety and
plagued by a lot of social damage [32]. Soldiers are sleep disturbances. In the study of Khedri et al.
in their special period of life, and in so-called (2014), in Tehran, in terms of subscales of Mental
"transition" period and military service, therefore, Health Dimensions, private soldiers had the most
they are always exposed to stress and experience reported problems associated with physical
many stressors that affect their mental health. symptoms, anxiety symptoms and sleep disorders,
Military personnel are at high risk of traumatic events depression and social dysfunction [34]. Also, in the
during engagement in war, military operations and study of Mehdi Shahbazi who studied the mental
maneuvers [33]. Over the past two decades, evidence health and self-esteem of the first and last year
has shown that the development of military students of a military school (2012), in terms of the
operations has been accompanied by an increase in subscales of mental health dimensions, the private
mental disorders. The military faces more soldiers had the most problems of the subscales of
occupational issues in terms of professional missions anxiety symptoms and sleep disorders, physical
which has more psychological problems than those of symptoms, depression, and social dysfunction [35].
other occupations. The mental stress caused by the Due to the temporary nature of the private forces,
type of occupation, the complex missions, the hard they are struggling with the stresses created in the
laws, the probability of captivity of injury and military environment and avoid pressures and do not
disability, and even death, are some of the issues let the situation have a negative impact on them.
which are much higher than in military jobs than in Serving in a military environment in the long run has
civilian jobs. Comparing the results of this research put a lot of psychological pressure on the cadre
with other researches and those obtained in the civil personnel and reduces their mental health. The
society in Iran shows that the prevalence of mental stresses in military occupations create a major and
disorder in the military community is higher than significant outcome causing problems in the family,
civil society. reducing the ability of the responsible military
Also, in terms of comparing general mental health personnel, and predisposition to mental problems.
and the status of its sub-scales among cadre Because of the special sensitivity and dangers present
personnel and private soldiers, the results of the study in military centers, the context of stress and mental
showed that general mental health of the two groups pressure increases [36].
was different and in this regard, private soldiers have
a higher mental health level (P-value = 0.004). There The limitation of this research is the psychological
is a difference between the cadre personnel and state and the individual and mental characteristics of
private soldiers only in the sub-scale of physical the research units when completing the
symptoms (P-value = 0.002) that, the results indicate questionnaires, which may affect research results.
that private soldiers have less physical problems than CONCLUSION:
cadre personnel. There are no differences in the other Overall, the results of this study showed that most of
subscales of mental health between the two groups, the military personnel surveyed in the unhealthy state
and in this regard, the two groups are the same. Since of mental health, but most of them have a mild
the pressures caused by military occupation in the mental illness. Private soldiers had higher levels of
long run have a negative impact on the body and mental health that, this will require more attention to
spirit of military personnel, the difference observed the mental health of military environments, especially
in this regard is justified. In both groups of cadre in the case of cadre personnel.
personnel and private soldiers, the most mental health
disorder is associated with the subscale of social
function disorder and the lowest mental health ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
disorder is associated with the subscale of anxiety These study results from researches by register
symptoms and sleep disorders. In the cadre personnel number of U-95054 and which is registered in
group, in terms of mental health subscales, the most research and technology development assistant of
common problem was associated with social medical science university of Jundishapur of Ahvaz-
dysfunction, depression, physical symptoms and Iran. Hereby, researchers express their complete
thanks and acknowledgement from all people and Combat Duty in Iraq and Afghanistan, Mental Health
organizations that help us in this investigation. Problems, and Barriers to Care. Journal of medicine,
351, 13-22
REFERENCES: 14.Farsi Z; MSc1, Jabari Morouei M; MD2, Ebadi A.
1. Boden MA. The creative mind: Myths and General health assessment of Army soldiers seen in a
mechanisms. Psychology Press; 2004. military medical outpatient clinic in Tehran.JAUMS
2. Saif AA. Educational measurement, assessment Volume 4 Number 3 Autumn 2006
and evaluation. Tehran: Doran Publications. 2004; 15.Anisi J, Rahmati Najarkolaei F, Esmaeeli A,
128. Hagghi A.Evaluate the effect of problem solving
3. Aponte HJ. Political bias, moral values, and skills to reduction of suicidal ideation of soldiers.
spirituality in the training of psychotherapists. Ebnesina - IRIAF Health Administration / Vol. 16,
Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic. 1996; Vol 60; No No. 1-2, Serial 46, 47 Spring &Summer 2014.
4: 488. 16. Sareen J, Cox BJ, Afifi TO, de Graaf R,
4. Dabashi M ،Talebi M. The study of mental health Asmundson GJ, ten Have M, et al. Anxiety disorders
staff training center Shahid Khazraei air. Journal of and risk for suicidal ideation and suicide attempts: a
Ibn Sina / Health Administration Air Force. Eleventh population-based longitudinal study of adults. Arch.
year, the first issue, autumn 1387, Issue 29 Gen. Psychiatry. 2005; 62(11):1249-1257.
5. Farhangi AA. Basics of human communication. 17.Hyman J, Ireland R, Frost L, Cottrell L. Suicide
Tehran: Pub Tehran Times, 2009. (Persian) incidence and risk factors in an active duty US
6. Parslow RA, Jorm AF, Christensen H, et.al. The military population . American journal of public
impact of employee level and work stress on mental health. 2012; 102 Suppl 1:S138-146.
health & GP services use: an analysis of a sample of 18. Sadock BJ, Sadock VA. Kaplan and Sadock's
Australian government employee. BMC Public synopsis of psychiatry behavioral science clinical
Health. 2004; Sep, 304 :( 4).p:41. psychiatry. Philadelphia: Williams and Wilkins
7. Salim H، Azad Marzabad E، Abedi Darzi M. Publication; 2007.
Check the status of mental health and its relationship 19.Nosratabadi M, Dabbaghi P. Evaluation of
with burnout and life satisfaction among the staff of a suicidal thoughts based on substance abuse and social
military university in 1389.Journal of Military support in soldiers, Ebnesina - IRIAF Health
Medicine 2010; 25:30-33. Administration / Vol. 16, No 3, Serial 48 Autumn
8. Shahbazi M، Vazini taher A. Survey to the Mental 2014.Iranian Journal of Military Medicine18-Vol. 14,
Health and Self-esteem of freshmen and seniors at a No. 2, Summer 2012 .Pages: 99-103.
Military University. Journal of Military 20. Helm k. Suicides in the military: 1980 –1992. Mil
Medicine2013; 15(2):103-110. Med. 1995; 160(2):45-50.
9. Ahmadi Kh. Psychology of tension Bagheeatollah 21. Nori R, Fathi A, Salimi H. Study of relationship
medical science university.Gth chapter. 1385; 205- between and coping styles and mental about soldiers
206. doing suicide in the on military unit, Military
10. Rah nejat A ،Bahamhn .Gh ،Sajadian. R ، psychology. 2011.5:47-55.
donyavi. V. Epidemiological Study of Psychological 22. Fortinash KM, Holoday-Worret PA. Psychiatric
Disorders in One of the Ground units Military forces mental health nursing. Mosby; 2008.
of Islamic Republic of Iran .Journal of Military 23. Anisi J, Fathi-Ashtiani A, Salimi SH, Ahmadi
Psychology .Volume 2, Number 6, summer KH. Evaluation of Reliability and validity of Beck
2011.Page: 27-36. Suicide Scale Ideation in Solders. Journal of Military
11.Anisi J, Akbari F, Majdian M, Atashkar M, Medicine. 2005; 7(1): 33-37. [Persian]
Ghorbani Z. Standardization of mentaldisorders 24. Fathi Ashtiyani A, Eslami SH. Evaluation of
Symptoms Checklist 90 Revised (SCL-90 -R)in psychopathology factors and suicide causes in
Army Staffs.Journal of Military Psychology. solders. Journal of Military Medicine. 2002; 3(4):
Volume 2, Number 5, spring 2011, Page: 29-37 245-249. [Persian]
12.Iversen, A. C., Staden , L. v., Hughes ,J. H., 25. Kitty K, Lam D. The relationship between daily
Browne, T., Hull , L., Hall , J., Greenberg,N.,Rona , stress and health. Journal of psychology and health,
R. J., H, M., Wessely , S., and Fear , N. T.(2009). 1993; 8(5), 329-344.
The prevalence of common mental disorders and 26. Livneh H, Sheldon M, Kaplan J. The relationship
PTSD in the UK military: using data from a clinical between anxiety and coping modes. Journal of human
interview-based study. Journal of BMC Psychiatry, 9, behavior, 1991; 36(3).325-329.
1-12 27. Roberto Rona. The Contribution of Prior
13.Hoge ,C.W., Castro ,C.A., Messer , S. C., McGurk Psychological Symptoms and Combat Exposure to
, D., Cotting ,D. I., and Koffman ,R. L. (2004). Post Iraq Deployment Mental Health in the UK
Military King’s College London, King Centre for Association of Student, Personnel Administrators,
Military Health Research. Journal of Traumatic Denver, Colorado. University of Texas at Arlington,
Stress, Vol. 22, No. 1, February 2009, pp. 11–19 (C _ 2004.61:121-190.
2009) 33. Bramsen I, Dirkzwager AJ, van der Ploeg HM.
28. Noorbala AA, Bagheri Yazdi SA, Yasamy MT, Predeployment personality traits and exposureto
Mohammad K. Mental health survey of the adult trauma as predictors of posttraumatic stress
population in Iran. Br J Psychiatry 2004; 184:70-7. symptoms: a prospective study of former
29. Hosseini Ghadamgahy J. The quality of social peacekeepers. Am J Psychiatry. 2000; 157(7):1115-
relation and rate of stress and its coping strategies in 1119.
heart coroner patients [MSc Thesis]. Tehran, Iran: 34. Khedri B ،Dabaghi P. Coping Styles and Mental
Tehran Institute of Psychiatry. Tehran University of Health soldiers. Journal of Nurse and Physician
Medical Science; 1996. p. 70-80. within War/ Issue 5 / second year / winter 2014.
30. Mohamadzade A. The Five Factor Model and 35. Shahbazi M,Vazini A. Investigation of mental
Impulsivity: Using a Structural Model health and self-esteem of students in the first year and
Of Cope Style to Understand Impulsivity. Pers Indiv at the end a military schools. Journal of Military
Differ 2001; 30: 669-689. Medicine .Volume 51, Issue 2, summer 5312. Pages:
31. Nouri R, Fathi -Ashtiani, Salimi S., Soltani 551-513.
Nejad.Effective factors of suicide in soldiers of a 36. Dehbash A, Talebi M. Study of mental health in
military force. Iranian Journal of Military Medicine- the office employees of the Shahid Khazraei military
25Vol. 13, No. 2, summer 2010 .Pages: 100-106. educational center. Journal of IRIAF Health
32. Snyder, M.B. Senior Student Affairs Officer Administration / Vol. 11, No. 1, Serial 29, autumn
Round Table: Hottest Topics in StudentAffairs, 2008.
Session Held at the Annual Meeting of the National