Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THERMAL TECHNOLOGY
B
urner-to-burner interaction is a observed in the field and suggests The occurrence of this phenomenon is
phenomenon that is characterised modifications that were successfully indicated by the formation of a large,
by the creation of a dense fire implemented and led to the elimination bright yellow fire cloud and by an
cloud, an increase in NOx emissions and of burner-to-burner interaction. Specific increase in NOx emissions compared to
an altered heat flux distribution in the rules of thumb, which are based on single-burner performance. Although
furnace. It occurs frequently in multiple- experience, are given to predict the this problem has been observed in all
burner heaters, where vertical cylinder likelihood of interactions in ethylene- types of multi-burner heaters, it is much
heaters have been observed to have the cracking furnaces. more severe in vertical cylindrical heaters
severest interactions. Although this compared to other types such as cabin
problem has been around for a while, it The problem heaters.
has not been well understood. Only ad- In response to the increased demand to It would be desirable to obtain a
hoc solutions have been introduced to reduce NOx emissions from industrial simple rule of thumb to characterise and
mitigate it. However, a comprehensive heaters, new burner technologies have predict the onset of BtoB interaction.
study has now been completed, which been developed to meet the more However, the complexity of the problem
1
reveals a dimensionless interaction stringent emissions regulations. Most of limits the application of each rule to the
parameter that could identify conditions these technologies use some type of specific case from which it was deduced.
that are likely to produce burner-to- furnace gas recirculation (Figure 1) to Some of the BtoB interaction rules that
burner interaction. Observations of reduce the flame temperature, so that have been proposed for vertical
interactions were made on lab-scale, thermal NOx emissions can be reduced cylindrical heaters are based on the
2
small-scale and full-scale burners to substantially. However, diluting the fuel- heat-release rate and the geometrical
validate the parameter. air mixture with furnace gases results in dimensions of the furnace. The rule
Two case studies are presented using lower burning rates, which often makes usually takes the form of a criterion
CFD modelling. The first study shows the flames significantly longer. Both value that demarcates the absence of
that interaction was unlikely in a longer flames and increased volumetric interaction from the onset of
3
vertical cylindrical furnace where the heat release density (Btu/hr/ft or interaction. Figure 2 shows the
3
spacing between burners was decreased. MW/m ) in the newer multi-burner dimensions discussed in the following
The other study confirms interaction industrial furnaces have led to frequent rules. One such rule uses the heat release
occurrences of of a single burner per unit distance
a phenomenon between two adjacent burners (Btu/hr/ft
often referred to as or MW/m). A second rule uses the total
burner-to-burner heat release of the heater per unit area
2 2
(BtoB) interaction. (Btu/hr/ft or MW/m ) of the outermost
1
P T Q Q2 2006
w w w. e p t q . c o m
jzink.qxd 6/6/06 10:20 AM Page 2
THERMAL TECHNOLOGY
Figure 3 Condition of interaction between two adjacent diffusion flames. Lf < Zc (no flame interaction); Lf > Zc (flame interaction)
burner circle, which is the circle that medium, but also to the combustion criterion for identifying interaction in
passes through the centres of the itself, which creates eddies that can vertical cylindrical heaters. Details of
outermost burners. A third rule uses the affect neighbouring flames. that investigation are given elsewhere.3
total heat release of the heater per unit In vertical cylindrical heaters, the The developed criterion depends on
2 2
area (Btu/hr/ft or MW/m ) of the tube BtoB spacing is more critical than in box- both physical and chemical parameters;
circle, which is the circle that passes type heaters, because the burner spacing namely, the geometry of the burners
through the centres of the heater has an impact on the flue gas flow into and the fuel composition. Interaction is
process tubes. A fourth rule uses the the centre of the furnace. If the spacing defined here as the influence of flames
total heat release per unit volume of the between burners is too small, the on each other that leads to the creation
3 3
heater (Btu/hr/ft or MW/m ). interaction of the flames can actually of a yellow flame cloud (due to the
In extreme cases, when the criterion block the flow of flue gases from the formation of soot particles) between
value is close to zero for no interaction circumference of the furnace into the burners. A dimensionless number was
and relatively large for full interaction, centre. This generates a low-pressure developed that can be used as a measure
these rules can correctly predict the zone in the centre of the furnace that for the interaction strength. Both lab-
performance of a multi-burner heater. can effectively pull the flames toward scale and small-scale burners were used
However, predicting the accurate the centre of the furnace. This increases in the experimental investigation.
conditions for the onset of interaction is the tendency for the flames to merge Consider two diffusion flames, as
a challenge for any of these rules. In together and create a large fire cloud that shown in Figure 3, that are adjacent to
other words, it is easy to predict the can impinge on process tubes. Another each other. There is a critical height at
sufficient conditions (extreme cases) for effect is the creation of a reducing which jets interact (Zc). The flame
interaction, but it is difficult to predict (oxygen-deficient) atmosphere in the height is designated here as Lf. If the
the necessary conditions (onset centre of the furnace. Since the flue gases flame height is less than the critical
conditions) for the interaction. These are blocked, the O2 concentration height (Lf < Zc), no FtoF interaction will
rules fail for two reasons: decreases at the centre, leading to occur. If the flame height is greater than
oversimplification of the problem and increased CO formation on that side of the critical height (Lf > Zc), the flames
failure to account for all significant the flame and creating the potential for will interact. FtoF interaction of a group
parameters. For instance, during a increased flame lengths. Longer flames of diffusion flames arranged in a circle,
research study of this phenomenon, it can also alter the design heat flux as in a vertical cylindrical furnace, can
was observed that BtoB interaction distribution, as more heat is transferred be characterised in a similar manner.
depends on both fuel pressure and fuel higher in the furnace. NOx emissions
composition, while none of the above may also increase because there are Experimental study
rules account for such a dependence. insufficient flue gases on the inside of Twelve lab-scale burners were built. Each
BtoB interaction, sometimes referred the burner circle that can be pulled into was a single-jet burner with its diffusion
to as flame-to-flame interaction (FtoF), the flames. Many low-NOx burners use flame stabilised on a conical bluff body
is a complex phenomenon that makes furnace gas entrainment to reduce the downstream of the fuel jet. The objective
the behaviour of the multiple-flame flame temperature, which reduces NOx of testing with a simple lab-scale burner
configuration very different from that of emissions. was to study the FtoF interaction on a
an individual flame. Increased flame An extensive theoretical and fundamental basis and to verify the
length, increased NOx emissions, poor experimental investigation was interaction criterion for configurations
mixing, modified heat flux distribution completed to develop a suitable with a large number of burners. These
and decreased surrounding gas burners were tested in a small lab
entrainment are some of the results of furnace equipped with sensors for
FtoF interaction. While aerodynamic
“Computational fluid measuring fuel pressure, temperature,
interaction of the jets in a multiple-jet dynamics (CFD) is a flow rate, flue gas temperature, furnace
system is considered to be the most draft, wet and dry gas analysis of excess
important factor that governs FtoF
powerful tool for analysing oxygen, carbon monoxide and nitrogen
interaction, the presence of combustion complicated fluid flow oxides.
is also a major factor. In other words, the The parameters were varied to study
shape of the flame not only responds to problems in combustion” their effects on FtoF interaction
the turbulence in the surrounding independently. Interaction among the
2
P T Q Q2 2006
jzink.qxd 6/6/06 10:21 AM Page 3
THERMAL TECHNOLOGY
3
P T Q Q2 2006
jzink.qxd 6/6/06 10:22 AM Page 4
THERMAL TECHNOLOGY
Figure 7 Burner used in ethylene-cracking furnaces with fuel staging and (left) uncontrolled and (right) controlled furnace gas recirculation
4
P T Q Q2 2006
jzink.qxd 6/6/06 10:22 AM Page 5
THERMAL TECHNOLOGY
5
P T Q Q2 2006