CITATIONS 1 DMMMSU COLLEGE OF LAW CASE CITATIONS: LABOR RELATIONS 20 SEMESTER SY 2017-2018 Pros. Florence Marie A. Gacad-Ulep Labor Dispute 1. Gr 132400 Marifo, etal. and STFU Vs. Gamilla, Etal. 31 January 2005 Second Division 2. 3rd Division CIRTEK Employees Labor Union-Federation Of Free Workers - Vs. - CIRTEK Electronics, Inc, G.R. No. 190515 June 6, 2011 Katarungang Pambarangay 3. Second Division G.R. No. 82211-12March 21, 1989 Teresita Montoya, Vs. Teresita Escayo, Et.al. Four-Fold Test Of An Employer-Employee Relationship ‘4. Second Division G.R. No. 204944-45 December 3, 2014 Fuji Television Network, Inc, Vs. Arlene S. Espintu 5. Caurdanetaan Pieceworkers Union Vs. Laguesma February 24, 1998: First Division (G.R. No. 113542 ‘Types Of Employees 6. En Banc GR. No. 122226 March 25, 1998 United Pepsi-Cola Supervisory Union (UPSU), Vs. Laguesma And Pepsi- Cola Products, Phiippines, Inc. Compromise Agreements 7. Special Second Division G.R. No. 180147. January 14, 2015 Sara Lee Philippines, Inc., Vs. Emilinda D. Macatiang, et. al. X---X GR. No. 180148 Aris Philippines, Inc., Vs. Emilinda D, Macatiang, etal... X ---X G.R. No. 180149 Sara Lee Corporation, Vs. Emilinda D. Macatlang, et.al. X --- XG.R. No. 180150 Cesar C. Cruz, Vs. Emilinda D. Macatang,etal..X ---XG.R. No, 180319 Fashion Accessories Phil. Inc, Vs. Emilinda D. Macalang, et.al. X --- X GR, No. 180685 Emilinda D. Maca Tlang, et.al.. Vs. NLRC, Aris Philippines, Inc., Fashion Accessories Phils, Inc., ‘Sara Lee Corporation, Sara Lee Philippines, nc, Calin Beal And At. CasarC. Cruz, Employees Eigible To Become Union Members 8. GRN 122226 March 25, 1998 United Pepsi-Cola Supervisory Union (Upsu), Vs. Laguesma En Banc, Employees Excluded From Union Membership 9. GRN 110399 August 15, 1997 San Miguel Corporation Supervisors And Exempt Union And Emesto L. Ponce, Vs. Laguesma 10. 3° Division [ G.R. No. 193798, September 09, 2015 ] Coca-Cola Bottlers Philippines, Inc, Vs. locas Professional and Technical Employees Union (IPTEU) 11. 1st Division Sta. Lucia East Commercial Corp,, vs. Secretary of Labor and Employment etc. GR 162355 August 14, 2009 112. 2» Division San Miguel Corporation Supervisors and Exempt Union Corporation Supervisors And Exempt Union Vs. Laguesma Gr110399 Aug 15,1997: 13. GRN 79025 December 29, 1989.BENECO Vs. Ferrer-Callja, 14, Second Division G.R. No. 85750 September 28, 1990 Intemational Catholic Immigration Commission, Vs. Hon. Pura Calleja 15. G.R. No. 89331 September 28, 1990 Kapisanan Ng Manggagawa Sa IRRI-Organized Labor Association In Line Industies ‘And Agricuture, vs. Secretary of Labor and Employment And Intemational Rice Research Institute, Inc., 16. First Division G.R. No. 82914 June 20, 1988 Kapatiran sa Meat and Canning Division (TUPAS Local Chapter No. 1027), Vs. The Honorable BLR Director Pura Ferrer Calleja, Etal, 17. En Banc (GR. No. 124678. July 31, 1997] Delia Bangalisan, et al. vs. Hon. Court Of Appeals, Etc. Mixed Membership In A Union 18. 3rd Division G.R. No. 183317 December 21, 2009 Mariwasa Siam Ceramics, Inc, Vs. The Secretary of the Department of Labor and EmploymentCITATIONS Ir termination Page [2 18. GR No. 181531 July 31, 208 National Union of Workers in Hoes, Restaurants and lied Industies- Manila Pavilion Hotel Chapter, Vs. Secretary of Labor and Employment Rights And Conditions Of Union Membership 20. 1stDivsion G.R, No, 85333 February 26, 1990 Carmelio L. Palacol, ELA, Vs. Pura Ferer-Caleja 21. 3rd Division (G.R. No, 170112, April 30, 2008] Del Pilar Academy Vs. Del Pilar Academy Employees Union: ‘The Statutory Rights Of Legitimate Labor Unions 22. Third Division [G.R. No, 146073, January 13, 2003] Jery E. Acedera, Ec. Vs. Intemational Container Terminal Services, Inc. (lots), Et. 23, Third Division [G.R. No. 131235, November 16, 1999] Ust Facuty Union (Ustu), Eta. Vs. Dir. Benedicto Emesto R. Bitonio Jr. Etal. Employee Representation And Participation 24. Meraleo Vs. Quisumbing Gr 127598 January 27,1999: 25. GR. No, 96189 July 14, 1992 University of the Philippines, vs. Hon, Pura Ferre-Calleja, 26. GR. No. 181531 July 31, 2009 National Union Of Workers In Hoel, Restaurants And Aled Industries: Manla Paviion Hotel Chapter, Vs. Secretary of Labor and Employment 27. 1 Division Sta, Lucia Esat Commercial Corp, Vs. Secretary of Labor and Employment Etc. GR162355 August 14, 2009 28. Third Dvision{ G.R. No. 193798, September 09, 2015 ] Coca-Cola Batters Philippines nc. , Vs. loos Professional ‘And Technical Employees Union 29. Third Division Republic Of The Philippines, Represented by Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE), versus Kawashima Textile Mig., Piippines, Inc, July 23, 2008 G.R. No. 160352 Collective Bargaining Duty 30. 2nd Division G.R. No. L-64334 January 22, 1966 Kiok Loy Sweden ioe Cream Plant, Vs. NLRC Etal. Cuevas, J: Petition For Certorai ‘Two Terms of a CBA 31. G.R.No. 111262 September 19, 1996 San Miguel Corporation Employees Union-Pigwo Vs. Hon. Ma. Nieves D. Confesor, Eta 32. First Division G.R. No. L-87672 October 13, 1989 Wise And Co,,Inc., Vs. Wise & Co., Inc, Employees Union-NATU. ‘and Honorable Bienvenido G. Laguesma ‘33, Substtuionary Doctrine 1st Division G.R. No, L-41955 December 29, 1977 Elisco-Elirol Labor Union (Naflu) Vs. Carmelo Noriel Grievance Machinery And VA 34, 3rd Division G.R. No, 186557 August 25, 2010 Negros Metal Corporation, Vs. Armelo J. Lamayo 35, 3 Division [G.R. No. 148303. October 17, 2002] Union Of Nestle Workers Cagayan De Oro Factory Represented By Its President Yur P. Bertufo And Officers, Vs. Neste Philppines, Inc. 36. 3rd Division G.R. No, 186557 August 25, 2010 Negros Metal Corporation, Vs. Armelo J. Lamayo, Unfair Labor Practice 37. Special 3d Division [6.R. Nos. 158930-31, March 03, 2008] Union Of Fipro Employees - Drug, Food And Aled industies ‘Unions -Kilusang Mayo Uno (Ufe- Dfe-Kmu), Vs. Neste Philippines, Incorporated, [GR Non 88004] Nate Philippines, Incorporated V's. Union Of Fipro Employees - Drug, Food And Alied industies Unions -Kilusang Mayo Uno 38. 2nd Division G.R. No. 114974 June 16, 2004 Standard Chartered Bank Employees Union (Nube), Vs. Ma. Nieves R. Confesor |Totatty Of Conduct Doctrine 39 GR No 170007 Apri 7. 2014 Tabangan Shell Refinery Empioynes Association. Vs. Pliginas Shed Petroleum (Corporation Union Securty Came 40. Second Onision GR No 160828 August 9.2010 PICOP Resources, Incorporated (PRI) Vs. Anacleto L. Tafeca, ELal 41, Fant Orson GR. No. 149652 March 10,2010 General Miling Corporation. Vs Emesio Casio, Etat 42 Univer of San Agustin, Inc - Vernun - University Of San Agustin Employees Union: FFW. GR. No. 177504 July 23, 2008 ty 23, 2009 ‘Sees And Lockout 43. 552 Pht 432 Frat Division | G.R. No. 180058, June 22. 2007 | Plipino Telephone Corporation Vs. Piipino Telephone Employees Association (PILTEA), Etal/ [GR No. 180084) Plipino Telephone Employees Associaton (PILTEA), Eta Vi National Labor Ratattons Commission And Piipino Telephone Corporation 44 2nd Divsion GR. No. 155109 September 29, 2010. Atcantara & Sons, inc. Vs. Court Of Appeals, ELal. GR. No. 155136 'Naghahwusang Mamumuo Sa Alsore-SPFL (NAMAAL-SPFL) Etat VC Alcantara & Sons, nc. Etal GR No. 179720 Naghatwssang Mamumuo Sa Aiscrs-Spl (NAMAAL SPFL), Vi. C. Alcantara & Sons, inc Retum-To- Work Order 45. Thrd Onvaion September 14, 2015 GR. Nos. 178085 - 178086 University Of The Immaculate Conception, Vs. Office OF The Secretary of Labor and Employment Eta Vaid Sirke ‘46. 3" Division GR. No. 170830 August 11, 2010 PHIMCO industries, Inc, V8 PHIMCO Industries Labor Association (PILA), Eta ‘47. 2nd Onision (GR. Nos. 158786 & 158789, October 19, 2007] Toyota Motor Phils. Corp. Workers Association (Tmpcwa), Etat Vs NLRC, Etal ‘48, Toyota Motor Philippines Corporation Vs. Toyota Motor Philippines Corp. Workers Association (TMPCWA) Termination OF Employment Revrement 49. 3rd Drvsion GR. No. 152991 July 21, 2008 Abberto P. Oxales, V's. United Laboratories, inc., ‘50. Second Division G.R.No. 163512 February 28, 2007 Daisy B. Tu, Vs. Platnum Plans Phil, inc. S51, tt Divsion G.R. No. 163269 Apr 19, 2005 Rotando C. Rovera, Vs. Soidbank Corporation, 52. 2nd Oiaion GR. No. 199654 February 18, 2015 Zenaida Paz. Vs. Northem Tobacco Redrying Co. ne., And/Or ‘Angeio Ang Termination Or ‘53. Second Dession | G.R. No. 195466, duty 02, 2014 } Ariel L. Dawid, Doing Business Under The Name And Siye “Yiels ‘Hog Dealer" Vs. John G. Macasio ‘54. Exigency Of The Business Second Division | G.R. No. 207253, August 20, 2014 | Crispin B. Lopez, V8. irvine ‘Construction Corp. And Tomas Sy Santos 55. Changing Economic Conditions 491 Pht. 256 Third Onision | G.R. No. 149090, February 11, 2005) Benedicto A. Capcom Vi Vs. Tp Phitppines Cement Corporation, Etat ‘56. ness OF Employee 708 Phi 596 Third Diision | G.R.No. 193756, Aprl 10,2013 ] Venancio S. Reyes, Etal. Vs. RP Guardians Secunty Agency, ine. 57, Fist Division G.R. No. 97189 May 11, 1983 Jtsscor independent Union Vs. Hon. Ruben Torres And Bienvenido E Laguesma, Etatatio ac $8 Fraud En Banc GR No.L-13778 Apri 29, 1960 Philippine Education Co. Inc., V8. Union Of Philippine Education Employees (Nu) And The Court Of industrial Relations 58, En Banc GR No L-15171 Apel 29, 1961 Lepanto Consolidated Mning Company And Charles B. Foster, Vs. The ‘Court OF Appeals, And Leonardo Arca, 60. Gross Neglect Second Division GR. No. 140853 February 27, 2003 Ariel A. Tres Reyes, Vs. Maxim's Tea House And ‘ecetyn Poon 161, Habitual Neglect Second Division G.R.No. 109390 March 7, 1996 Jgb And Associates, Inc., Vs. National Labor Relations Commission 662. insubordination Second Division G.R. No. 199549 Ap 7, 2014 Civil Service Commission And Department Of Science [And Technology, Regional Office No. V, Vs. Marilyn G. Arandia 663. Installaton Of Labor-Saving Devices En Banc G.R. No. L-2028 April 28, 1949 Philippine Sheet Metal Workers’ Union (Clo), Vs. The Court OF industrial Relations, Philigpine Can Company 64, Loss Of Confidence Second Division GR. No. 173012 June 13, 2012 Dolores T. Esquerra, Vs. Valle Verde Country ‘Chub, ne. And Emesto Vilakuna 65. Redundancy Third Division GR. No. 82249 February 7, 1991 Witshire File Co. nc., Vs. The National Labor Relations ‘Commission And Vicente T. Ong 66. Retrenchment Second Division G.R.No. 127516 May 28, 1999 Attante Gulf And Pacific Company Of Manila, inc (Ag8P), Vs. National Labor Relations Commission 667, Reasonable Period Third Division G.R. No. 201701 June 3, 2013 Unilever Philippines, Inc., Vs. Maria Ruby M. Rivera, ‘68. Ample Opportunity To Be Heard En Banc G.R. No. 152048 April 7, 2009 Felix B. Perez And Amante G. Doria, Vs. Philippine Telegraph And Telephone Company And Jose Luis Santiago 69. Serious Misconduct Fighting Within Company Premises Second Division G.R. No. 187605 April 13, 2010 Technol Eight Philippines Corporation, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission And Dennis Amular 70. Uttering Obscene Words Second Division G.R. No. 117453 June 26, 1996 Autobus Workers’ Union (Awu) And, Ricardo Escanlar, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission And Mr. Robert Ong 71. Fabrication Of Time Records Second Division G.R. No. 142007 March 28, 2001 Manuel C. Felix, Vs. Enertech ‘Systems industries, Inc. And Court Of Appeals 72. Using Employer S' Equipment For Personal Use First Division G.R. No. 111110 August 2, 1994 Zenco Sales Inc ‘And/Or Zenco Footstep, Vs. National Labor Relabons Commission, Etal, 3, Wil Disobedience Refusal To Transfer First Division G.R. No. 122488seplember 3, 1998 Sentinel Security Agency, lnc, Vs. National Labor Relatons Commission, El. 74. G.R.No. 122716 September 3, 1996 Philippine American Life Insurance Company, Vs. National Labor Relations ‘Commission, Eta. 75. Refusal To Report To New Assignment 2nd Division G.R. No. 121621may 3, 1999 Westin Philippine Plaza Hotel, Vs. "National Labor Relations Commission (Third Division) And Len Rodriguez 76. Gross/Habitual Neglect Of Duties Habitual Tardiness, Absenteeism And Abandonment 1st Division G.R. No. 110388 ‘September 14, 1995 Artemio Labor ELal., Vs. NLRC, etal 7. FraudMitful Breach Of Trust Supervisor ‘GR. No. L-65706december 11, 1992 Té oe ote Leading Boycott |, 1992 Top Form Mig. Co., 7B. Hablualy Absen! Manager First Division G.R. No. 100749 Apri 24, 1982 GT Printers AndiOr Trinidad G. Barba, V Naina Labor Ratabors Commision (th Oven) An Ean Rear a:CITATIONS Ir termination Page |S 79, Failure To Account For Shortage Second Division G.R. No. 88268 June 2, 1992 San Miguel Corporaton, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission And Franciso Divinagracia " ™ 0. Complicity In Cover-Up Of Piferage Second Division G.R. Nos. 76818-19 July 3, 1982 CDCP Tollways Operation Employees and Workers Union Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, ELal 8, Stealing Company Property Second Division GR. No. L-86768 December 20,1985 Zamboanga City Water District Vs Genaro A. Bartolome, Etal £82, Fecitous Company Requisition lps En Banc G.R. No, 80609 August 23, 1986 Philippine Long Distance Telephone ‘Company, Vs. The National Labor Relations Commission And Marlyn Abucay £83, Loss Of Confdence Second Dison GR. No. 97196 January 22,1998 China Ciy Resturant Corporation, Vs. "National Labor Relations Commission, Et 64, Fst Division GR. No, 111639 July 29,1996 Midas Touch Food Corpraion, Wison Chu & Ramon T.Luy, Vs National Labor Relations Commission £85, Commission Of A Crime/Ofiense Fist Division GR, No, L-56960-51 Soptember 30, 1982 M. Trucks, vs, The National Labor Relations Commission Eta. F. Violago Oiler Tank 86. itera n Selecting Second Division GR. No, 131108 March 25,1999 Asian Alcohol Corporation, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, 87. Proof Of Redundancy First Dison G.R. No. 181738 January 30, 2013 General Miling Corporation, Vs, Violeta. Viaiar, £88, Evidence Of Losses 3rd Division G.R. No. 85286 August 24, 1992 Basiio A. Balasbas, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission 89. Second Division G.R. No. 185449 November 12,2014 Goodyear Philippines, Inc, And Remegio M. Ramos Vs Marina LAngus 90. Fist Division G:R. No. 100092 December 29, 1995 Central Azucarera De La Carlota, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission ‘91. Closure/Cessation Second Division G.R. No. 122876 February 17, 2000 Cheniver Deco Print Technics Corporation, Vs. National Labor Relatons Commission Et Al 92. First Division GR, No. 106256 December 28, 1994 Maya Farms Employees Organization, Eta. Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Et. 93. Second Division G.R. No. 185449 November 12, 2014 Goodyear Philippines, inc. and Remegio M, Ramos vs. Marina L. ‘Angus (not cite in the Department Order) ‘94, Sexual Harassment 67 Phil. 180 Second Division | G.R. No. 123737, May 28, 1989 |Carlos G. Libres, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Eta Preventive Suspension 195. First Division G.R. No. 192582 April 7, 2014 Bluer Than Blue Joint Ventures Company/Mary Ann Dela Vega, Vs. Glyza Esteban (not cited in the Department Order) 96. First Division GR. No. 146779 January 23, 2006 Renato S. Gatbonton, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Etal. Austia-Marinez, JCOURSE OUTLINE labor ations JANZO18 | ‘COURSE OUTLINE: LABOR RELATIONS (Pros. Florence Marie A. Gacad-Ulep) This three-uit course ims to introduce the students 10 th field of labo relations. | Besides trong te dst OO ore ‘and collective bargaining, it shall also tackle the concopts emnateg oieg fecal relationship. Sate ts shot be vexed resdngs on selected Supreme Cout decor oseagon the undo introduce them to labor procedure. Pe equate sal arinre check on undtandng and corenenion A Introdtion 4. State Poicy (Art. 218) ‘Azucona’s Basic Principles upon which ou Labor Code provisions on LR are founded Stato Policy regarding Trpartsm (At. 200) Employer (Art 21) Employee (Art. 2199, Labor Dispute (Art. 2181) “Two kinds of labor disputes Remedies in tor disputes Applcabilty of Katarungang Pambarangay 0. Fourfld test ofan employerempoyee relationship 1. Types of employees ‘According to nature of functions (Art. 219) 'b. According to permanency of employmenttenure (a, 295) 8. Structures 4. The Bureau of Labor Relatons and its regional counterpart (At. 232) 2 Subpoena power ofthe DOLE Seoretary (Art. 235) 3. Appointment power ofthe Secretary of Labor (At 236) Union-elated documents that BLR is mandated to maintain (At. 237) Privileged communication ue (Art. 228) ‘Compromise Agreements 1. Itassisted by the BLR or DOLE Regional Offices (Art. 233) 2 DOLE Administrative Order No. 105 5 1995 3, Ifthe Compromise Agreements violated (New Civil Code Art. 2041) 8, Labor Organizations (as amended by RAGA8! and DO40-.s.08) 1. Registration of Labor Organizations Right to se-organization Purpose for registration of labor unions Logiimate labor organization (At. 240) RRequistes for registration (At. 240, 244) Fights granted to local chapter ofa federation (Ar. 241) C. Cancel of Union Registration 1. Grounds for canceling Labor Union Registration (Ar. 247) 2 Voluntary dsslutin (Art. 248, DOLE Dept Order No.40+-15) Reports requited of legitimate labor organization (At. 252) Right to self-organization 1. Elemens ofthe right to sel-orgaizatio (At. 250) Magna Carta of Union Members (At 250) Statutory rights of legitimate labor urions (At. 251) Who are granted the right ose organization? (At. 253-257) Employees excluded from union membership Mixed membership in a union (Art. 256) F. Tie 7. Employee representaton and participation (rt. 255-258) ‘Statutory rights of workers (At, 267) Concept of excusive bargaining epresentaive “Two kinds of establishments in tems of representation (At. 268-269) Employer fles CE patton: (At. 270) Bystander Rue (Art 271) Modes of choosing bargaining representative: Concept of @ Bargaining Unit Efiec ofa Cancelaion Paiton(At. 246) ‘Appeals on the order ofthe Mediator Arbiter (Art.272) jective bargaining Collective bargaining duty (Art 263) Procedure tobe flowed (Art, 261) Difference of At. 262 and Art, 263 mo moo ° ona genvemsenep COURSE OUTLINE labor relations JAN2018 2 ‘Two aspects ofthe duty to bargain collectively (CBA ratification and registration (A237) ‘The terms of CBA (At. 265) ‘The Substtutonary Doctrine Prohibition on injunction (Art. 266) fina: Grievance Machinery and VA Requirements fo Grievance Machinery and Voluntary Arbitration (Af. 273) Grievance procedure: DOO, s. 03 Voluntary arbitration ‘Jurisdiction ofthe VA (Art 274-275) . Procedure in VA (Art 276) cc Expenses incured for resorting to VA (Art. 27 ) | Unfair Labor Practice 1, Unfair labor practice: (Art. 259) 2 Norrabridgment of right to sett organization (Ar. 257) 3. Why and how ULP is prosecuted? (At. 258) 4. Various foms of ULP (At 259-260) 4. Strikes and Lockouts 1. National Conciliation and Mediation Board (E0292) ‘State Policy (Art. 278) Procedure in strike o lock-out (At. 278) National Interest Cases (Art. 278; DOLE Dept. Order No. 40-036) Protection o a vad strke(art. 266 278,279) ‘Acs prohibited while pursuing the strike? (Art. 279) Remedy towards ending a stike peacefuly(Art. 280) Penal provisions affecting union activites (Ar. 281) Penalesimposabl( Art 287 ‘Other Trade Union- Related Concems (Art. 282-289, 292) # enafenoee Termination of Employment Modes of termination Coverage of policy regarding termination of employment (At. 283) Secunty of tenure (Art-294) Employee terminating the employer-employee relationship (At 300) Employer terminating the employe-employee relationship 1 ‘Just causes for termination (Art. 297) 2 Authorized causes of teinaton (Art, 298-288) Proper procedure for terminating an employee: 1. Twofacets ofa val termination 2. Standards of due process 3. Twootce rule “Temporary suspension of Operations (Art. 301) Preventive suspension Entitlements ofthe unjusty-dismissed worker (Art 254) Constructive dismissal Retirement: (Art. 302) Labor Bodies and Procedure Jurisdiction of various labor bodies: Fiing a complaint for ilegal dismissal NLRC. Composition ofthe Commission (At. 220) The labor judge (Art 224) Jurisdiction and venue Nature of the procedure before the NLRC: (At. 227-228) The Ang Thay case ‘Nonawyers appearing belore the Commission or RAB (Art. 228) ‘Atomey’s fos (At.228) ‘Appeal (A. 228) Who are held abe for wrongful ismissal Piercing the Corporate Vei Labilty ofthe indirect employer How awards are cared out (At 230) D. Penal provisions ofthe Labor Code (Art 303) & Prescription (Art. 305-307) F Transitory and fnal provisions (Art. 308-317) e90mrs x rerzD m omrs Baseen rae ag