Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop “Metrology for LNG” | June 2016 2
ship’s LNG cargo discharge pumping rate is lower
than a preset value, e.g. 70% of nominal rate,
9.2. DENSITY CALCULATION
LNG Density Calculation Methods
other criteria particular to the analyses. – cf. CTH
METHODS
_________________________________
After performing this data processing step, a subset of A variety of calculation methods exists [6], such as:
acceptable LNG compositions is ready for data
treatment.
GIIGNL
state equations in their integral form,
method of extended corresponding states,
_________________________________
8.2.2. Data treatment hard sphere model method,
The aim of the data treatment is to obtain, from a WATSON method,
statistical point of view, a robust and consistent result
that best reflects the quality of the whole transferred ELFAQUITAINE method,
LNG CUSTODY TRANSFER
LNG. graphic method of RC MILLER,
This step consists of:
HANDBOOK HIZA method,
performing a statistical test for each analysis and
each LNG component in order to determine the revised KLOSEKMcKINLEY method (k1 and k2
FOURTH EDITION version 4.00
presence of outliers, tables in Kelvin: K),
evaluating the elimination or not of the detected
ISO 6578, also using the revised KLOSEK
outliers (the whole analysis must be eliminated), McKINLEY method (k1, k2 tables in degrees
Celsius: °C).
calculating the average composition from the
analyses not being rejected, Validation of these density models by experimentation
normalizing the final LNG composition. is ongoing (Ref [18]). In this handbook, the preferred
method is the revised KLOSEKMcKINLEY method,
There are different approaches to determine the as described in N.B.S. Technical note 1030
presence of individual values in a set of data that may December 1980 [9] or in ISO 6578. It is easy to apply
be inconsistent and may change the final result: and only requires the LNG temperature and
graphical consistency technique and numerical outlier composition to be taken into account. The limits of the
tests. These techniques are explained in ISO 57252 method also encompass the composition of most
standard. One of the numerical tests recommended in
LNG produced. Its uncertainty is ±0.1%, when either
this standard for dealing with
outliers is the Grubbs’ the nitrogen or butane content does not exceed 5%.
test. Appendix 8 shows the procedure to apply this For these density calculations an electronic
test as well as a numerical example.
GIIGNL 2015
spreadsheet or a computer programme is often used.
This data treatment step results in a final LNG molar Comparison between the revised KLOSEK-
Richter th
et al. | 4 representative
International for Workshop “Metrology for LNG”
McKINLEY| June 2016using tables in Kelvin (NBS) and
method
composition, the whole LNG 3
LNG Density Calculation
'5'=-/35'3
Methods – cf. McCarty
ft-/-ZV7
7. CONCLUSIONS
On the basis of the performance of the four models given here and subject to
given the pressure, temperature and composition of LNG, any one of the four
models may be used to predict the density to within 0.1% of the true value. As
has already been mentioned (see section I) the above accuracy statement is
dependent entirely upon the accuracy of the experimental data in Haynes, et al.
[11], Haynes, et al. [13], Hiza, et al. [14], Haynes [g], Hiza and Haynes [15],
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop “Metrology for LNG” | June 2016 4
perimental data represent different com- property models have a crucial impact on the accuracy of process
ourse considered when deviations to the simulations, which makes an implementation of the GERG-2008
LNG Density Calculation Methods – Wide Range
re calculated. The LNG densities were equation of state inevitable.
Applied Energy 97 (2012) 822–827
Bureau of Standards in the USA (today:
dards and Technology, NIST) by Haynes Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect
uncertainty of Dq0 /q0 6 0.1%. However, 3. The GERG-2008 Applied Property EnergyPackage
uncertainty of the composition, the total
ounts to approx. 0.3%. The experimental Since the GERG-2008 equation of state describes the whole fluid
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/apenergy
capacities of a LNG mixture were mea- region of natural gases and similar mixtures with an accuracy that
Shell-Laboratory in Amsterdam, Nether- is beyond those of industrially used equations of state, smaller
Modelling liquefied-natural-gas processes using highly accurate property models
nd Zeldenrust [11]. The uncertainty is ⇑ uncertainties for process simulation can be expected as well. An
Florian Dauber , Roland Span
with Dcp/cp 6 1%. implementation of the GERG-2008 equation into simulation envi-
Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Thermodynamics, Universitätsstr. 150, 44780 Bochum, Germany
es calculated with the equation of Peng– ronments enables a consistent and stable calculation in the scien-
than 10% from results of the GERG-2008.
a r t i c l e i n f o tifically aand b s t rindustrially
a c t most often used process modelling
Article history: Accurate simulations are important for efficient design and operation of a process. Therefore, a precise
Received 27 June 2011 representation of thermophysical properties using an adequate property model is necessary. The
Received in revised form 13 November 2011 GERG-2008 by Kunz and Wagner [1] is the new reference equation of state for natural gases consisting
Accepted 14 November 2011
of up to 21 specific compounds. It describes the gas and liquid phase as well as the super-critical region
Available online 7 December 2011
and the vapour–liquid equilibrium. In order to model LNG processes with the highest accuracy available,
software available for the new equation is implemented into various common simulation tools. To ensure
Keywords:
stable and consistent simulations, the GERG-2008 Property Package has been developed, which meets the
GERG-2008
Vapourisation
CAPE-OPEN standard. The influence of property models on the simulation of the most important pro-
CAPE-OPEN cesses of the LNG value chain is investigated. Results show the expected advantages in accuracy for sim-
Liquefied natural gas ulations using the new property model.
Liquefaction ! 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Transport
αo(ρ , T , x ̅ ) = xi[αooigas
(ρ ,—TCalculation
) + ln xofi]
To meetfüpipeline-quality specifications or for commercial use vapor−liquid equilibrium (VLE) states. These data can be
Lehrstuhl r Thermodynamik, Ruhr-Universitä t Bochum, D-44780 Bochum,
calculatedGermany
in a very convenient way from equations of state.
as a fuel, natural gas in its raw form in general needs to be
The GERG-2004 wide-range equation of state for natural
processed ahead of the feed into gas-pipeline systems or
ABSTRACT:
liquefaction A new
facilities. Thisequation
involvesofthestate for the of
separation thermodynamic
a number gases and ofother
properties mixtures developed by Kunz et al.1 is the only
natural thermodynamic properties —
of gases,
in this
water,
similar that
components
andwork.
gases,areand
hydrogenThissulfide)
other
either
equation
mixtures, the
undesirable
is anmore
or have
(e.g.,GERG-2008
expanded
value onversion
their ofown
equation
applications
the GERG-2004
of state
equation of state, is presented
carbon dioxide, that is appropriate for nearly all of the technical
described above and that satisfies the demands on
equation.
i = 1Part 2:
the accuracy in the calculation of thermodynamic properties over
GERG-2008
than when left isin explicit in thegasHelmholtz
the natural free energy
(e.g., ethane, propane,as butane,
a function of density, temperature,
the entire fluid region. Similar to other recent developments, the Single-phase properties (gas, liquid,
where N is the number of components in the mixture, αoo
andandheavier hydrocarbons
composition. The and also helium).
equation is based on 21 natural gas components: methane,
The processed
nitrogen, carbonnatural
dioxide,gas is transported
ethane, in gaseous
propane, n-butane, GERG-2004
form n-pentane,
isobutane, equation of state is based on a multi-fluid
isopentane, Natural gasfluid)
and dense
Article — Calculation of ranges
for extended
through
n-hexane,pipelines at pressures
n-heptane, n-octane, up to 12 MPa.n-decane,
n-nonane, Compressor hydrogen,approximation.
oxygen, carbon The mixture model uses accurate equations of
stations placedwater,
monoxide, periodically
hydrogen along the pipeline
sulfide, helium, ensure the the state
that Over
and argon. entireincomposition
the form of fundamental equations for each mixture thermodynamic
of application properties —
natural
range,gas
allow
remains pressurized.
GERG-2008
for equilibrium
liquid monitoring and dimensionless form ofPart
covers the gas
managing
states
In addition,
the natural
for mixtures
metering
phase, liquid
the2:Helmholtz free energy in the id
supercritical component
phase,stations
gas incomponents.
of these
region, and vapor−
the pipes. Themixtures normalofrange
along with functions developed for the binary
the components
of to take into account the residual
Gaz naturel — Calcul des propriétés thermodynamiques —
4.1. Numerical Description
Small
scale
differences
validity
metering can introduce stateofofGERG-2008.
in methodsincludes
of GERG-2008
large cost component The
used to temperatures
calculate flow rates
uncertainties. To GERG-
from in(90
match
to 450) mixture
large
iSingle-phase
(see eq 12),
properties
K and behavior.
and(gas,the
other
pressures The
quantities
liquid,
up GERG-2004
to 35 MPa where
experimental data of the thermal and caloric properties are represented to within their accuracy. The extended validitygases
calculation of thermal
mixtures consisting
and
(including of
caloric
all18
equation
properties
ofcomponents:
theof most
for
state enables
accuratethe
natural
methane,
rangeand
nitrogen,
Partie 2: Propriétés des phases uniques (gaz, liquide, fluide dense)
pour une gamme étendue d’applications
supply
reachesandfrom
demand,
(60 tonatural
700) Kgas andis up
injected
to 70 at MPa.
and dense fluid) for extended ranges
pressures
The givenup tonumerical information the sophisticated derivatives)
2008 equation of state for natural
30enables
MPa into
reservoirs,
other
theunderground
aquifers,
equations
and salt the mole
caverns.
the economics
of state, for example,
gasesfractions
storage facilities,
use of GERG-2008
and other
for all ofsuch
of AGA8-DC92
mixtures
of the
theasvarious
of mixture
depleted
of constituents. The term
gas
technical
application
carbon dioxide,
applications. ethane,are
Examples propane,
pipelines or by shipping, storage and liquefaction of natural gas, and processes to separate gas components. Comparisons with
In situations where major gas-transmission
and Peng−Robinson Received:
equation June(P-R),
17, 2012
n-butane,
processing, isobutane, n-pentane,
transportation through
r
use mixtures of natural gas components as refrigerants in
Helmholtz free
natural gases and other mixtures consisting of natural gas
o r energy of
α(δ , τ , x ̅ ) = α (ρ , T , x ̅ ) + α (δ , τ , x ̅ ) general structure(8)
components is of indispensable importance for the basic
engineering and performance of technical processes. The
the mixture α is given by:
precooling, liquefaction, and subcooling cycles.
of multi-fluid approx.
For the applications described above, the design of
processing, transportation, storage, and liquefaction of natural fractionation units, compressors, heat exchangers, and storage
gas are examples for technical applications where the facilities requires property calculations over wide ranges of
thermodynamic properties of a variety of mixtures of natural N mixture compositions and operating conditions in the
o
part à α (δ , τ , x ̅ ) = ∑ xiαoi(δ , τ ) + Δα (δ , τ , x ̅ )
where the α part residual
gas components are required.
represents ther properties of the ideal-gas
To meet pipeline-quality specifications or for commercial use
as a fuel, natural gas in its raw form in general needs to be
r
homogeneous gas, liquid, and supercritical regions and for
r
vapor−liquid equilibrium (VLE) states. These data can be
calculated in a very convenient way from equations of state.
composition x̅ according to
water, and hydrogen sulfide) or have more value on their own
than when left in the natural gas (e.g., ethane, propane, butane,
applications described above and that satisfies the demands on
the accuracy in the calculation of thermodynamic properties over
r the entire fluid region. Similar to other recent developments, the
where
and heavier hydrocarbons and also helium).
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop αoi is
“Metrology for the
The processed natural gas is transported in gaseous form
N
through pipelines at pressures up to 12 MPa. Compressor
LNG”residual
| June 2016 part of the reduced Helmhol
GERG-2004 equation of state is based on a multi-fluid
6
approximation. The mixture model uses accurate equations of
LNG Density Calculation Methods – Wide Range
• Cubic EOS of Redling <'= B
𝑝 = >?@ − =C,D '>' >E@
and Kwong (1949)
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop “Metrology for LNG” | June 2016 7
LNG Density Calculation Methods – Wide Range
• COSTALD 1 − 𝐶 ln(𝐵 + 𝑝)
𝑣 = 𝑣′ '
(corresponding states 𝐵 + 𝑝s
liquid density) by
𝑣n = 𝑣∗ ' 𝑣r ' 1 − 𝜔 ' 𝑣r
P p
Hankinson and
Thomson (1979) B and C are calculated by means of the critical
parameters and the acentric factor (as a function
of the composition and pure substance parameter
à without specific mixture parameter)
J. Chem. Thermodynamics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jct
0.3
Development of a special single-sinker densimeter for cryogenic liquid
mixtures and first results for a liquefied natural gas (LNG)
0.2 Markus Richter ⇑, Reiner Kleinrahm, Rafael Lentner, Roland Span
Lehrstuhl für Thermodynamik, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, D-44780 Bochum, Germany
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
0.1 Article history: A special densimeter has been developed for accurate density measurements of liquid mixtures at
Received 9 August 2015 cryogenic temperatures, e.g., liquefied natural gas (LNG). It covers the density range from (10 to 1000)
Received in revised form 22 September 2015 kg ! m"3, thus enabling density measurements in the supercritical region, in the homogeneous liquid
Accepted 29 September 2015
region, along the saturated liquid line as well as in the homogeneous gas region. The apparatus is
Available online 8 October 2015
designed for measurements over a temperature range from (90 to 300) K at pressures up to 12 MPa.
The densimeter is based on the Archimedes (buoyancy) principle and is a single-sinker system
0 Keywords:
Cryogenic liquid mixtures
incorporating a magnetic suspension coupling. The density can be obtained directly without the need
for calibration fluids. The relative combined expanded uncertainty (k = 2) for density measurements in
105 110 115 120 125 130 135 Density measurement
Single-sinker densimeter
Liquefied natural gas (LNG)
the homogeneous liquid region (including the contribution resulting from the uncertainty of the sample
gas analysis) was estimated to be 0.044%. First results for a synthetic five-component LNG mixture were
Magnetic suspension coupling obtained at the temperatures T = (105, 115, 120, 125, and 135) K with pressures up to 8.1 MPa. The results
T/K Synthetic gas mixtures were compared to the GERG-2008 reference equation of state for natural gases, which represents the
experimental values within 0.06%.
! 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop “Metrology for LNG” | June 2016 ‘‘demand for natural gas grows by more than half, the fastest rate
among the fossil fuels, and increasingly flexible global trade in
liquefied natural gas (LNG) offers some protection against the risk
to about 0.3%. Thus, it can be stated that an uncertainty of 0.1%,
given in Reference [3] for calculated densities, is probably
underestimated.
8
LNG Density Calculation Methods – ERKM
(ERKM = Enhanced Revised Klosek and McKinley Method)
~.••
𝑀rst ?[
𝑇}w
𝜌567 = ⋅ 1 + 𝑝 − 𝑝v,wxyy ⋅ 4.06 ⋅ 10 ⋅
𝑣rst 𝑇}w − 𝑇
𝑇}w = € 𝑥‚ ⋅ 𝑇w,‚
‚
A correction term for the saturation pressure:
𝑝v,wxyy = 𝑝v,†‡[ + 𝑥6W ⋅ 0.11 MPa ⋅ 𝑇 − 90 K − 𝑥†W‡Œ ⋅ 0.05 MPa ⋅ 𝑇 − 95 K
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop “Metrology for LNG” | June 2016 9
LNG Density Calculation Methods – Performance of ERKM
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop “Metrology for LNG” | June 2016 10
In order to use the ALLEOS routine, a range of 15 cells needs to be selected. A click on the fx button
atabase Structure after typing “ALLEOS(“opens the optional context menu (see Figure 1). After finishing the inputs
mentedappearsin thetheprogram.
indicating The
status. To stop the numerical
calculations, click the Cancelcoefficients to the
Clicking the OK button initiates the calculations. While the calculations are in progress, a small window
button. When the calculations are property models for each fluid are stored in
ate text files. The coefficients for the mixture departure functions are stored in a single text file.
complete, a table displaying the results appears.
onal files contain information specifying predefined or user-defined mixtures. This structure simplifies
dition of new fluids and additional models to future versions of the database and makes such additions
t totally transparent to the user.
se of the Database
he REFPROP program by double-clicking on its icon. A banner screen displays the title, credits, and a
disclaimer. Clicking the "Information" button calls up further details and credits through the help system.
ng the "Continue" button starts the program. The program is controlled, in the usual fashion of a
ows application, by the use of pull-down menus displayed across the top of the application window.
REFPROP 17
ile menu provides commands to save and print generated tables and plots. Individual items or entire
à In industry often individual in-house solutions are used!
ns with multiple windows can be saved or recalled. The standard Print, Print Setup, and Exit
ands are also present.
dit menu provides copy and paste commands, which allow selected data or plots to be exchanged with
applications.
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop “Metrology for LNG” | June 2016 12
Richter et al. | 4th International Workshop “Metrology for LNG” | June 2016 13