Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ELIZA LOPEZ
G.R. No. 178055, 2 July 2014, SECOND DIVISION, (Del Castillo, J.)
Under Article 217(a)(4) of the Labor Code, claims for actual, moral, exemplary and
other forms of damages arising from employer-employee relationship are under the jurisdiction of the
Labor Arbiters or the National Labor Relations Commission.
Lopez did not heed the demands of Amecos, thus, the latter filed a
complaint for sum of money and damages against Lopez before the Regional Trial
Court (RTC). Amecos claimed that because of Lopez’s misrepresentation, they
suffered actual damages by way of settlement and payment of its obligations with
the SSS. Amecos’ contention is that the employer-employee relationship between
Amecos and Lopez is merely incidental, and does not necessarily place their dispute
within the exclusive jurisdiction of the labor tribunals but the true source of Lopez’s
obligation is derived from Articles 19, 22, and 2154 of the Civil Code.
ISSUE:
Do the regular civil court have the jurisdiction over claim(s) for
reimbursement arising from employer-employee relation?
RULING:
At the same time, it cannot be assumed that since the dispute concerns the
payment of SSS premiums, Amecos’ claim should be referred to the Social Security
Commission (SSC) pursuant to Republic Act No. 1161, as amended by Republic Act