You are on page 1of 15

Nuclear Medicine in Acute and Chronic Renal Failure

Richard A. Sherman and K w a n g J. Byun

The diagnostic value of renal scintiscans in patients in t h e diagnosis and management of t h e patient w i t h
w i t h acute or chronic renal failure has not been obstructive or reflux nephropathy may be obtained.
emphasized o t h e r than for the estimation of renal Radionuclide studies in patients w i t h chronic renal
size. 13~10IH, eTgallium. ~ ' T c D T P A . glucoheptonate failure m a y help make apparent such causes as renal
and DMSA all may be valuable in a v a r i e t y of specific artery stenosis, chronic pyelonephritis or lymphoma-
settings. Acute renal failure due to acute tubular tous kidney infiltration. Future correlation of scan-
necrosis, hepatorenal syndrome, acute interstitial ning results w i t h renal pathology promises to further
nephritis, cortical necrosis, renal artery embolism, or expand nuclear m e d i c i n e ' s utility in t h e noninvasive
acute pyelonephritis may be recognized. Data useful diagnosis of renal disease.

ENERALLY recognized uses for nuclear (mean BUN 96 mg/dl, creatinine 7.6 mg/dl)
G medicine in nephrology include the assess- and inadequate visualization with ~97Hg chlo-
ment of renal blood flow, glomerular filtration romerodrin, s While renal size was often inexplic-
rate, separate kidney function and the evaluation ably large despite chronic parenchymal disease,
of patients who have undergone renal transplan- there was confirmation of this finding by high
tation or have hypertension. These topics have dose urography. Other reports confirm the value
received considerable attention in the literature of 131l OIH in demonstrating renal size despite
(including the current volume of this journal) severe renal impairment.6-8 Renal concentration
and will not be the subject of this review. Nuclear of OIH occurs with as little as 3% of normal
medicine has less widely appreciated (and less function?
well documented) uses in the evaluation of acute Because of the excellent imaging characteris-
and chronic renal failure. Only a limited and tics of 99mTC,its various chelates are quite useful
largely anecdotal literature written (not surpris- in renal failure. '~ This accounts for the superior-
ingly) from a radiologic rather than a clinical ity of 99mTCdiethylenetriamine pentaacetic acid
perspective is available in this area to guide thee (DTPA) over 197Hg chloromerodrin in imaging
nephrologist. This report critically reviews the the failing kidney~ despite excretion of the for-
use of various renal scanning procedures in the mer wholely by glomerular filtration and the
adult patient with acute or chronic renal failure progressive renal uptake with minimal excretion
in an effort to increase awareness of nuclear of the latter, lz-~4 Reba estimated that renal size
medicine's value and perhaps stimulate further could be determined with 99mTCDTPA in 75% of
studies in this area. patients with BUN over 65 mg/dl.'
In addition to the advantages of carrying the
ASSESSMENT OF RENAL SIZE 99mTCmoiety, glucoheptonate (GH) and dimer-
The determination of renal size is of consider- captosuccinic acid (DMSA) are both taken up
able importance to the nephrologist evaluating a and retained by the renal tubules. Although
patient with renal insufficiency. Normal size substantially less GH is retained compared with
suggests recent onset (and potential reversibility) DMSA, kidney to background activity is compa-
of the renal disease while small kidneys point rable for the two agents and they provide renal
toward chronicity and irreversibility. Large kid- images of similar quality. ~2-'4 The significant
neys suggest specific diagnoses such as amyloido- urinary excretion of GH makes possible collect-
sis or polycystic disease. ing system visualization, an advantage over
Radionuclide imaging has been recommended DMSA. Both chelates appear superior to 99mTc
for use in determining kidney size '-3 particularly
when plain films are not revealing and intrave-
nous urography is unsuccessful or contraindi- From the Division of Nephrology, Department of Medi-
cated. Because of the delayed transit time of 13'I cine, University of Medicine and Dentistry--Rutgers Medi-
cal School, Piscataway, New Jersey and the Department of
orthoiodohippurate (OIH) in renal failure,4
Nuclear Medicine, Albert Einstein College of Medicine,
Freeman et al. were successful in using this agent Bronx, N. Y.
to obtain a renal image by rectilinear scanning in 9 1982 by Grune & Stratton. Inc.
18 of 19 patients with advanced renal failure 0001-2998/82/1203-0005502.00/0

Seminars in Nuclear Medicine, VoL XII, No. 3 (July), 1982 265


266 SHERMAN AND BYUN

DTPA for renal imaging in uremia. Studies under or over estimates of more than 15% in 4 of
comparing GH and DMSA with each other in 9 patients. Ultrasound estimates of renal size in
renal failure are not available. this study differed from true renal size by more
GH scanning produces renal visualization in than 15% in only one often cases. ~8
all but "very extreme" renal failure. ~5 Assess- Routine scanning techniques also may under-
ment of renal size with DMSA was successful in estimate renal size because of angulation of the
four of five patients with BUN exceeding 100 kidney found in 24 of 62 patients with unilateral
mg/dl. Scanning frequently needed to be delayed diminution of renal size on 99mTc DTPA or
for 6-10 hr after injection to allow sufficient DMSA imaging. ~9 Lateral scanning of the kid-
blood clearance to permit renal imaging. 16 neys has been recommended when this possibility
A limiting factor in achieving optimal renal exists. Renal scanning, while not the procedure
images with 99mTC DMSA in renal failure is of choice, can provide a reasonable estimate of
DMSA's slow renal uptake compared with the kidney size despite advanced renal failure. The
short halffife of 99mTc.97Ru DMSA, a long lived 99mTC chelates, GH and DMSA, and ]31I OIH
chelate, may eventually offer better renal imag- seem best able to produce good renal images
ing in patients with advanced renal failure. ~7 despite minimal kidney function. I23IOIH which
Successful renal imaging in uremic patients has been reported to be superior to '3'I OIH may,
may be more likely following hemodialysis when when generally available, prove to be the most
radionuclides which are concentrated in the useful agent in renal failure. 2~
urine are used. 7,s Another factor, particularly for
ACUTE RENAL FAILURE
OIH, is increased renal uptake of radionuclides
possibly due to removal by dialysis of competing Acute Tubular Necrosis
organic anio'as. ~'7"8Renal imaging may be better The diagnosis of acute tubular necrosis
shortly after an acute reduction in renal function (ATN) usually is based on the clinical picture,
(as with acute tubular necrosis) than later after urinalysis and blood and urine chemistries with-
uremic solutes have accumulated.~'8 out the necessity for any radiologic or nuclear
Despite considerable success in renal imaging procedure. Nuclear medicine procedures have,
in patients with azotemia, questions remain as to however, been reported to be of value in provid-
the accuracy of size estimates. When isotopic ing supporting evidence for the diagnosis of
renal size assessments were compared with surgi- ATN, in recognizing disorders mimicking ATN
cal nephrectomy specimens Timmermans found and in providing useful prognostic information.

Table 1. Causes of Renal Failure in Which Nuclear Medicine Studies May Be of Value
Disorder Nuclear Medicine Study Typical Findings
Acute tubular necrosis 1311OIH Prompt uptake, delayed excretion
Hepatorenal syndrome 99mTcPertechnetate or DTPA Markedly diminished RBF
Cortical necrosis 9s~l'c Pertechnetate or DTPA Markedly diminished RBF
1311OIH Poor or no visualization
Acute pyelonephritis STGallium Unilateral or bilateral uptake
99"i'c DMSA or GH Cortical defects
Acute interstitial nephritis 67Gallium Bilateral intense uptake
Renal artery embolism 99~-I'c Pertechnetate or DTPA Unilateral or bilateral absence of RBF
98"~1"cDMSA, GH or DTPA Unilateral or bilateral absence of up-
take, diffuse or segmental
Obstructive nephropathy 13~10IH, ~9~i-c DTPA Delayed uptake, prolonged excretion,
pelvic accumulation
Chronic pyelonephritis gg"l'c DMSA, GH Cortical defects
Reflux nephropathy 99"~1"cDMSA, GH Cortical defects
Radionuclide VCU Ureteropelvic reflux
Renal lymphoma eTGallium Bilateral uptake, often nodular
Renal artery stenosis sg"~l'c Pertechnetate, DTPA Markedly diminished RRF, often
asymmetric
~3;IOIH. s ~ ' c DTPA, GH, DMSA Asymmetric renal size
NUCLEAR MEDICINE IN RENAL FAILURE 267

Only rarely is there difficulty distinguishing the clearance of seven patients with a "faint"
ATN from chronic parenchymal renal disease in uptake was 39 ml/min and that of seven with no
patients with advanced renal failure. On occa- renal image apparent was 25 ml/min. Three
sion, however, the prompt uptake of 131I OIH patients in the no renal image group required
seen in most patients with ATN compared with chronic hemodialysis while none did so in the
the poor, delayed uptake found with advanced prominent renal image group. The prognosis of
chronic renal failure is a useful diagnostic the three groups could not be determined fully
point 2'21 (Fig. 1). from clinical and laboratory data alone (Fig. 3).
Schoutens et al. studied ~3~I OIH scanning in Cortical necrosis has been suggested as a likely
67 patients with severe renal failure, 35 of whom explanation for the absence of renal OIH uptake
had the clinical picture of ATN. 6 The kidneys of in patients with the clinical diagnosis of ATN. 6
all but 2 of the 35 were adequately visualized. This was indeed the finding in 2 of 3 autopsy
Both of these patients recovered though one was studies in such patients with this finding on renal
left with moderate renal insufficiency. Among 41 scanning. 23The hepatorenal syndrome 6 and renal
patients with "acute or rapidly progressing" arterial occlusion 6"s also have been found in
renal failure studied by Staab et al., 14 probably patients with acute renal failure and no kidney
had ATN. s Only one of the 14 had no renal uptake of ~3~IOIH.
uptake of 131IOIH; this patient subsequently had Acute renal failure in the patient with a dis-
a "good" recovery. Overall, the absence of renal secting aneurysm of the aorta may result from
uptake in 24 patients in the 2 studies was asso- renal arterial involvement or from A T N due to
ciated in 20 instances with end stage renal dis- renal ischemia or the use of radiocontrast agents.
ease or death. It was suggested that the assess- Substantial renal blood flow apparent with 99roTe
ment of renal uptake of ~mI OIH in patients with DTPA or pertechnetate scanning, or prompt
severe renal failure helped predict recovery of uptake of 13tI OIH with delayed excretion sug-
renal function. 6,s gest ATN and obviates the need for more inva-
Further review of the data suggest that the sive studies.
assessment of renal OIH uptake did not add to Renal blood flow in ATN has been shown by
the prognosis based on the clinical diagnosis-- Hollenberg et al. (using a 133Xe washout tech-
patients with acute renal failure did well while nique) to be reduced to approximately one-third
those with chronic renal failure or renovascular of normal. 24The hepatorenal syndrome, zS"z6corti-
occlusion did poorly. The poor prognosis of cal necrosis z4"27and renal arterial occlusion z8 may
patients with chronic renal failure and non- be confused with ATN clinically but differ
visualization on )a~I OIH scanning was con- pathophysiologically in that extreme reduction in
firmed by Sherman and B[aufox who reported renal blood flow is characteristic. This difference
that all 16 patients with this finding required in blood flow may be recognized by qualitative
chronic dialysis within 6 mo of the scan. 22'23 radionuclide determination of renal blood
Caution in the interpretation of the O I H scan flow:9'3~or with a noninvasive 3t-33 or invasive 34'3s
in patients with no significant renal function is quantitative evaluation.
necessary. Early images may show splenic activ- The "nuclear filtration fraction" has been
ity while somewhat later images may demon- advocated by Schlegel and Lang as a diagnostic
strate hepatic activity which can be mistaken for aid in acute renal failure. 36 The glomerular fil-
left and right renal uptake respectively. Early tration rate (using 99mTC DTPA or 99roTe iron
uptake i s based largely on organ blood flow; ascorbate) and renal blood flow (using ~3q OIH)
maximum uptake in poorly visualized kidneys were estimated based on 1-2 min renal uptake of
would be expected to be a late occurrence22 (Fig. the radionuclides) 7"3s The "nuclear filtration
2). fraction" (glomerular filtration rate divided by
Harwood et al. confined their study of the renal blood flow) was found to be increased in
predictive value of ~31I OIH imaging to patients ATN, decreased in "pre-renal" states and nor-
with a clinical diagnosis of ATN. 7 After 6 mo the mal with postrenal obstruction. Though using
10 patients with a "prominent" renal uptake had this pseudo-filtration fraction is an intriguing
a mean creatinine clearance of 80 ml/min while approach felt by these workers to have a "high
268 SHERMAN AND BYUN

Fig. 1A. See caption on t h e following page.

sensitivity (95%) for identification of A T N " data be present. A typical setting in which this deter-
adequate to evaluate this claim are not avail- mination may be valuable is in the patient with
able. chronic renal failure and an indwelling bladder
catheter who develops fever and an acute decline
in renal function. Nuclear medicine studies may
Acute Pyelonephritis help differentiate upper from lower tract infec-
Impaired renal function due to acute pyelo- tion. Preliminary evidence suggests that renal
nephritis is unusual but may be found if the imaging with 99mTCDMSA or GH may be useful
infection is severe, 39 is associated with necrotiz- for this problem 41 but 67Gahas been more exten-
ing papillitis, or if it complicates underlying sively studied.
chronic renal disease. 4~ Before one can attribute Hurwitz et al. used 24-hr gallium imaging in 49
an acute decline in renal function to a urinary patients who had pyelonephritis confirmed or
tract infection evidence of renal involvement excluded by conventional testing (including 26
(rather than infection of the bladder alone) must examined by invasive methods). 42Among 25 with
NUCLEAR MEDICINE IN RENAL FAILURE 269

0-3 rain. 131I-Hippuran 6'9 m-rn.

Fig. 1. The typical con-


trasting pattern of 1311 OIH
uptake in ATN and chronic par-
enchymal renal disease is illus-
trated. In ATN, uptake is rapid
and excretion is delayed or
absent. In chronic renal dis-
ease, uptake is poor but defi-
nite urinary activity is usually
present in the bladder. (A}
Acute tubular necrosis in a
renal transplant. ~ T c - D T P A
and 1311OIH studies are shown.
Initially, on day 1, perfusion and
uptake of the radiolabeled or-
thoiodohippurate are both
somewhat diminished but still
present. No significant excre-
tion of the radiolabeled or-
thoiodohippurate into the blad-
der is noted. During the subse-
quent days of study, improve-
ment in perfusion, uptake and
excretion of ~31101H are demon-
strated, suggesting recovery
from acute tubular necrosis. (B)
A 42-yr-old hypertensive male
patient with history of chronic
renal failure (BUN 79 mg/dl,
creatinine 5.3 mg/dl). 1311 OIH
renal scan demonstrates dimin-
ished renal function in both kid-
neys. Four hour delayed study
excludes the evidence of signif-
icant postrenal obstruction.
Note that both kidneys are
smaller than normal and blad-
der activity is definitely pres-
ent.

demonstrated upper tract infection 22 had renal technology renal images may normally be seen as
uptake of gallium while 4 of 24 with lower tract late as 48 hr after injection. 47 Regardless of
infection had falsely positive exams. Renal gal- technique, renal gallium uptake which increases
lium uptake was not normally found at 24 hr by from the 24 to the 48 hr scan, 43is unilateral, focal
these workers; this contradicted other reports. 43-45 or as intense as that of the liver is abnormal. 47
Differences in imaging techniques are the Gallium scanning is a promising, noninvasive
most likely explanation for this discrepancy. method that may aid in the recognition of renal
Detection of the multiple photopeaks of 67Ga, use functional deterioration due to pyelonephritis. In
of multiple windows with thick septa, middle or addition, the procedure appears useful in localiz-
high-energy collimator and tomographic capa- ing renal infection in patients with chronic renal
bilities all enhance 67Gaimaging. 46 With current failure due to polycystic kidney disease. ~5Its use
270 SHERMAN AND BYUN

Fig. 2. (A) Liver and spleen uptake of 13~101H and m"Tc labeled renal agents in advanced renal failure. Posterior scan of the
kidney w i t h ~1 OIH (top and b o t t o m left) and of the liver w i t h m"Tc-suIfur colloid (bottom right). Renal scan obtained after the
administration of 200 uCi of 13~1OIH and a liver scan after the administration of 2 mCi SS'Tc-Sc. In the 0-3-min exposure
(bottom left), a significant accumulation of radioactivity is apparent in the right upper quadrant, corresponding to the area
occupied by the liver. Some activity can be noted on the left which approximates the region of the spleen and could easily be
mistaken for the left kidney. On the 12-15-min view (top), the activity on the left is essentially cleared but there is still some
suggestion of residual activity on the right which could be mistaken for a right kidney. (From Nephron 25:82-86, 1980.)
( B - - P a r t 1 ) A 70-yr-old w o m a n w i t h history of breast carcinoma became azotemic (BUN 70 mg/dl, creatinine 10 mg/dl). The
patient complained of bilateral flank pain. To assess renal function and evaluate the possibility of obstructive uropathy,
m"Tc-DTPA renal perfusion study and ~311OIH renal scan w e r e performed. Sequential 2-sec images of renal perfusion study
demonstrated early m"TC-DTPA activity in the left renal area (arrow) which subsequently was proven to be a spleen. ( B - - P a r t
2) The spleen (arrow) could be easily mistaken for the left kidney. S'~Tc-DTPA activity in the upper quadrant on dynamic and
early static phase (1-2-rain bottom left) was liver activity which could be mistaken for the right kidney. One hour delayed
S~Tc-DTPA study (top left) reveals somewhat enlarged right kidney. Organ identification is aided by the accompanying sulfur
colloid scan (bottom right). ( B - - P a r t 3) ~S~lOIH renal function study (A-C) reveals no left renal activity and very poor right renal
function. A, right upper quadrant activity is from liver. B and C, liver activity cleared and delayed right renal uptake seen. One
hour delayed m"Tc-DTPA renal scan also demonstrates poor right renal function (D). Within 48 hours, ultrasonographic study
of the kidneys confirmed atrophic left kidney and right hydronephrosis with 2-cm renal cortical thickness.
NUCLEAR MEDICINE IN RENAL FAILURE 271

Scan

Nonvisualization

Ultrasound Study

Obstruction No Obstruction
J
J
J
Bilateral Bilateral Asymmetric
Normal Size Small Size Size

potential recovery substantial dialysis potential


of renal function to total im- needed within reversibility -
with surgical pairment of 6 months exclude vascular
relief renal function occlusion
at 6 months

Fig. 3. Evaluation and prognosis of renal nonvisualization with lall OIH.

is discussed more fully elsewhere in this issue in were renal transplant patients) 2 The extent and
the article by Handmaker. intensity of the renal uptake was not described in
either report. Though ATN is frequently listed as
Acute Interstitial Nephritis a cause of renal gallium uptake 15'44other reports
Recognition of acute interstitial nephritis of this observation in patients other than recip-
(noninfectious) may be easy when the character- ients of a renal transplant are scarce. 43
istic features are present but more difficult when Impaired renal function has also been sug-
many of these features are absent and ATN is gested as a cause of delayed (beyond 24 hr) renal
easily misdiagnosed. 49 Wood et al. first noted the visualization with gallium 43 but evidence to sup-
intense, diffuse 48-hr uptake of gallium in three port this contention is lacking. The evidence to
patients with biopsy evidence of this disorder: ~ date suggests that gallium scanning is a useful
Linton et al., reporting on nine patients with means of differentiating acute interstitial nephri-
acute interstitial nephritis due to drugs, tis from ATN, particularly when urinary tract
described the same finding on gallium scanning. infection is absent and renal uptake is diffuse and
In addition, they studied patients with other intense (Fig. 4).
renal disorders including six patients with ATN
in whom there was no uptake of the isotope. They Renal Artery Embolism
suggested that gallium scanning may help distin- Renal artery embolism should be considered
guish patients with acute interstitial nephritis as a cause of acute renal failure particularly in
from those with ATN.49 patients with atrial fibrillation or acute myocar-
Renal gallium uptake is not uniformly absent dial infarction. Radionuclide studies can play a
in ATN. George et al. described 12 patients with major diagnostic role in this disorder.
renal transplants and ATN whose kidneys accu- Early reports on patients with renal artery
mulated the isotope# l Kumar and Coleman embolism noted the good correlation of 99rnTc
reported three patients with ATN two of whom pertechnetate flow studies with renal arteriogra-
272 SHERMAN AND 5YUN

] .............. .....

Fig. 4. (A) A 45-yr-old female patient presented with an acutely rising BUN (71 mg/dl) and creatinine (5.5 mg/dl), Clinical
diagnosis was strongly suspicious for acute interstitial nephritis. Slightly delayed lSll OIH concentration and markedly delayed
excretion is noted in both kidneys. Twenty-four hour renal scan demonstrates significant tracer excretion from the kidneys
making obstruction unlikely. Each view illustrates 3-min sclntiphoto. Renal ultrasonogram showed normal renal size without
obstruction. (B) Posterior view of STGallium-citrate renal scan at 48 hr. reveals substantial radiogallium concentration in both
kidneys.

phy. 29'53Lessman et al. reported on 17 cases with recognizing as well as excluding the diagnosis.6"53
renal artery embolism 15 of whom had acute Arteriography may not be necessary unless there
renal failure.54 99mTc pertechnetate perfusion are plans for surgical intervention3'54'56 (Fig. 5).
scanning showed unilateral or bilateral absence
of renal blood flow in nine of ten cases studied OBSTRUCTIVE NEPHROPATHY
and the remaining patient had bilateral perfusion Isotopic scanning techniques appear suitable
defects. In the eight patients who also underwent for demonstrating urinary tract obstruction in
angiography the findings were virtually identi- patients with relatively normal renal function,s7
cal. Since visualization of the collecting system
Even when renal artery embolism does not depends on glomerular filtration and/or tubular
completely interrupt renal blood flow, renal fail- secretion renal insufficiency must, to a varying
ure may occur in association with multiple par- extent, impair the sensitivity of kidney scanning
enchymal infarcts. 13zI OIH was diagnostic in for recognition of hydronephrosis. Despite this
this situation in a patient with endocarditis and basic difficulty scanning may be useful in
renal failure.6 More recently 99mTC DTPA, 55 patients with renal insufficiency and urinary
99mTCGH 15and 99mTcDMSA 12'13have been used tract obstruction and has been advocated for
and advocated for recognition of this problem. diagnostic use in this setting} '57
When the diagnosis of acute renal failure due When routine studies are inconclusive in the
to renal artery embolism is under consideration, patient with possible obstructive nephropathy
renal scanning may be of considerable value in delayed imaging will often produce useful mor-
NUCLEAR MEDICINE IN RENAL FAILURE 273

Fig. 5. (A) A 74-yr-old man was admitted to the hospi-


tal with a pulsatile abdominal mass. The patient had history
of right nephrectomy for renal calculi performed 24 yr ago.
Retrograde femoral aortogram reveals large aneurysm of
lower abdominal aorta. Solitary left renal artery is visible
(arrow). (B) Scintiphotographic studies w e r e performed for
oliguria which developed after placement of an aorto-iliac
by-pass graft. A, posterior lSTHg chlormerodrin study fails
to reveal any renal activity. S-D, m"Tc-pertechnetate study
fails to show any kidney perfusion. Aortic surgical site is
seen as defect in isotope column (arrow). E-F, 131101H study
fails to reveal renal concentration, suggesting renal artery
occlusion rather than ATN or dehydration, other diagnosis
which were considered. (C) Repeat aortogram shows occlu-
sion of solitary left renal artery (arrow). Surgical clips from
by-pass graft aortic operation are apparent. An embolic
atheromatous plaque was removed at surgery. (From J Urol
105:473-481, 1971.)

phological information. 2'6'57 When substantial impaired renal function but was useful regard-
renal insufficiency is present and imaging less of the degree of renal impairment in follow-
beyond 24 hr is contemplated, 1311OIH may be ing interval changes in the function of the
superior to 99mTC chelates 57 due to its longer obstructed kidney.
halflife. Absence of renal uptake of 131IOIH in patients
Malave et al. studied 56 patients with sus- with obstructive nephropathy does not preclude
pected hydronephrosis, half with renal failure, substantial recovery of kidney function. This
using 131IOIH and 99mTc DTPA. 5s Images were applies to both unilateral 59'6~ and bilateral
not obtained beyond one hour for DTPA or 30 obstructive disease. 61
min for OIH. In 1 I% a false positive diagnosis of The use of ultrasound to detect urinary tract
hydronephrosis was made while in 26% the obstruction has increased dramatically in recent
results were inconclusive as a result of poor renal years. While highly sensitive in the detection of
uptake of the isotopes. Scanning was felt to be hydronephrosis a substantial false positive rate
accurate only with normal or moderately (26%) has been reported. 62 With improving
274 SHERMAN AND BYUN

equipment and diagnostic criteria better specific- McAfee reported on 31 patients with chronic
ity has been noted58'63 but the further evaluation pyelonephritis (seven with renal insufficiency)
of patients with dilated collecting systems may who underwent urography and renal scans with
present problems if, as with chronic renal fail- 99mTc GH and 131I OIH and had abnormalities in
ure, 64 avoidance of intravenous contrast media is one of these studies. 73Although the overall sensi-
desirable. tivity to renal morphologic abnormalities was
Diuretic radionuclide renography may help greater with urography than with scanning, focal
differentiate a dilated obstructed collecting sys- parenchymal damage was better seen with
tem from one which is dilated but has no nuclear imaging in eight patients and GH was
mechanical obstruction.65~8 Renal retention of more useful than OIH. As might be expected
the administered radionuclide occurs with 99mTc DMSA also has been reported to facilitate
hydronephrosis regardless of the presence or assessment of cortical scarring in pyelonephri-
absence of mechanical obstruction due to dilu- tis.9,15,16
tion of the isotope in the large collecting system Unlike urography, renal scans can demon-
volume with a lower isotopic concentration per strate intraparenchymal abnormalities which do
unit volume of urine passed into the bladder. The not deform the collecting system or renal outline.
unobstructed hydronephrotic kidney should Nuclear imaging may therefore be a useful sup-
respond to diuretics with an increased urine plement to urography for detection of renal dam-
volume and radioisotope clearance; the mechani- age due to chronic pyelonephritis. Active renal
cally obstructed kidney is unlikely to respond. 66 infection may, however, result in scanning
This methodology is discussed in detail in the defects which resolve with timefl '72
article on obstructive uropathy in this issue. Chronic pyelonephritis (as well as renovascu-
In patients with renal failure66this method can lar disease and unilateral obstruction) may result
be applied successfully if the collecting system is in asymmetric renal damage unlike glomerular
adequately visualized and a diuresis achieved. disease or nephrosclerosis which tend to cause
Measurement of urine volume following the symmetrical dysfunction. Recognition of differ-
diuretic injection may be helpful69 as may ences in radioisotope uptake may, to a minor
increasing the dose of furosemide. While an extent, aid in recognition of these disorders. 74
obstructive pattern may reflect poor renal func-
tion, a dilated, nonobstructive pattern will still
effectively rule out mechanical urinary tract Reflux Nephropathy
obstruction .66 Reflux nephropathy, recognized as an impor-
CHRONIC RENAL FAILURE tent renal disorder in children, has been increas-
ingly recognized in adults as a cause of hyperten-
Chronic Pyelonephritis sion, proteinuria, and renal failure that may
Recognition of chronic nonobstructive pyelo- progress to end-stage renal disease. 75'v6 The
nephritis in the adult may be difficult since a direct radionuclide voiding cystourethrogram
positive urine culture and pyuria are nonspecific (VCU) (using suprapubic puncture or bladder
and the "classical" changes on urography (caly- catheterization) is useful for the detection and
ceal blunting and deformity with depression of follow-up of patients with clinically significant
the overlying cortex) are seen most commonly in vesicoureteric reflux, vv'v8 Though it is often used
childhood as a result of vesicoureteral reflux, v~ in children to minimize radiation exposure it may
Adults with pyelonephritis may have advanced be used in adults.
histologic damage without apparent abnormality The intravenous radionuclide VCU is an
on urography.7! Davies et al. used 19VHg chloro- attractive noninvasive method for detecting
merodrin to study 50 patients with the clinical reflux v9 but, because of the prolonged excretion
diagnosis of chronic pyelonephritis and normal of the isotope, is not recommended for use in
urography.72 Despite the poor image resolution patients with renal insufficiency, s~ Recognition
that was possible with the agent and equipment of reflux despite renal failure may be possible
used, localized renal defects were seen in 10 using the computer analysis described for
patients. diuretic radionuclide renography.66
Fig. 6. (A) A 30-yr-old female with hypertension. Phys- Angiographic study reveals normal left renal artery but
ical examination revealed bruit in right flank. IVP was right renal artery demonstrates flbromusuclar dysplasia
normal and digital radiographic study of the kidneys (arrow). (B) Transluminal angioplasty was done. Note pre-
appeared normal, m"Tc-GH and 13~1OIH renal scan w e r e operative lS~l OIH renal scan with delayed right renal tracer
done because of persistent hypertension which was refrac- concentration and excretion. Cross-over sign compatible
tory to therapy. An early dynamic renal study (m"Tc-GH 6 - 8 w i t h renovascular disease is seen on renogram curves
sec.) demonstrates asymmetry of renal perfusion w i t h between right and left kidney prior to angioplasty. Postop-
diminished right renal blood f l o w and 2 hr static image erative seventh day :Sll OIH renal scan shows improvement
shows reduced right renal size with some segmental loss of of right renal function.
cortex while left kidney shows normal size and contour.
276 SHERMAN AND BYUN

Renal Lymphoma tative assessment of renal blood flow 31-33 also


Renal insufficiency is a common complication may be of value in this setting.
of malignant lymphomas and results from hyper- Percutaneous transluminal angioplasty is cur-
calcemia, uric acid nephropathy, glomerulopa- rently felt to be indicated for renal failure due to
thies, dehydration, urinary tract obstruction, renal artery stenosis s8 and has been successfully
amyloidosis, or, in 12%-14% of patients, 81 lym- used in patients with this disorder. 89'9~Radionu-
phomatous infiltration of the kidneys. Gallium clide studies may be of benefit in evaluating the
scanning will detect lymphomatous organ success of "balloon" angioplasty as well in recog-
involvement, including that of the kidney, 82 with nizing complications from the procedures (Fig.
a sensitivity of from 30 to more than 75% 6). Born et al. 91 used 99mTCpertechnetate, 131I
depending upon the imaging equipment used OIH and 99mTCDTPA to demonstrate improved
and, possibly, the histologic class of the lympho- renal function in three patients following angio-
ma.83 plasty.
Gallium scanning may be of value in evaluat- Kuhlmann et al. studied eight patients with
ing the patient with lymphoma and renal failure. renal artery stenosis, hypertension and, in half
A multinodular pattern of renal involvement, the cases, renal insufficiency who were treated
detectable on scanning, 84 is 10 times more com- with percutaneous transluminal angioplasty. 92
mon at autopsy than diffuse involvement,8~ mak- All those with impaired kidney function
ing the pattern of gallium uptake useful. Urogra- improved with restoration of renal blood flow.
phy and ultrasound may be unable to differen- Measurement of renal plasma flow using 13tI
tiate renal cysts from lymphomatous nodules. 84 OIH clearances with determination of individual
More studies of gallium scanning in renal lym- kidney components utilizing a computer-linked
phoma are needed before the actual value of the gamma camera were undertaken prior to and
exam can be assessed. every 2 mo during the 6-month follow-up period.
Both vascular complications of the angioplasty
(occlusion of a renal artery and the development
Renal Artery Stenosis of a slight renal artery restenosis) were suspected
Renal artery stenosis, in addition to its role in on the basis of the isotope studies and confirmed
hypertension, is an important, potentially treat- angiographically. Serial isotopic measurements
able cause of renal failure. It has become increas- of renal plasma flow were felt to provide a good,
ingly recognized that even prolonged vascular noninvasive method for evaluating the effects of
occlusion does not preclude successful repair of the vascular procedure.
the stenosis with recovery of renal function, ss A thorough understanding of the wide variety
As with renal artery embolism, radioisotope of conditions in which radionuclide imaging can
scanning with 99mTCpertechnetate or DTPA has be achieved is essential to its use. In the patient
been used to assess renovascular patency with a presenting with renal failure, a planned logical
high degree of accuracy. 2s,86 The absence of approach may prove of considerable value to the
perfusion on flow studies is not diagnostic of clinician in the differential diagnosis and progno-
complete vascular occlusion but the additional sis of the patients' illness.
observation of no uptake of OIH indicates an ACKNOWLEDGMENT
essentially nonperfused kidney, g7 More sophisti- The excellentsecretarial assistance of Donna MacGregor
cated techniques that allow noninvasive, quanti- is gratefullyacknowledged.

REFERENCES
1. Reba RC, Poulose KP, Kirchner PT: Radiolabeled 3. Atkins HL, Freeman LM: The investigation of renal
chelates for visualization of kidney function and structure disease using radionuclides. Postgrad Med J 49:503-516,
with emphasison their use in renal insufficiency.SeminNucl 1973
Med 4:151-168, 1974
2. JacobsRP, Laing FC, KorobkinM, et al: Renal failure, 4. BlaufoxMD, Conroy M: Measurement of renal mean
in RosenfieldAT, GlickmanMG, HodsonJ (eds): Diagnostic transit time of hippuran ~3~Iwith external counting. J Nucl
Imaging in Renal Disease. New York, Appleton-Century- Biol Med 12:107-116, 1968
Crofts, 1979,pp 299-325 5. Freeman LM, Goldman SM, Shaw RK, et al: Kidney
NUCLEAR MEDICINE IN RENAL FAILURE 277

visualization with ~3q-ortho-iodohippurate in patients with 25. Epstein M, Berk DP, Hollenberg NK: Renal failure in
renal insufficiency. J Nucl Med 10:545-549, 1969 the patient with cirrhosis. Am J Med 49:175-185, 1970
6. Schoutens A, Dupuis F, Toussaint C: ~3q-Hippuran 26. Hollenberg NK, Mangel R, Fung HYM: Assessment
scanning in severe renal failure. Nephron 9:275-290, 1972 of intrarenal perfusion with radioxenon: A critical review of
7. Harwood TH, Hiesterman DR, Robinson RG, et al: analytical factors and their implications in man. Semin Nucl
Prognosis for recovery of function in acute renal failure. Arch Med 6:193-215, 1976
Intern Med 136:916-919, 1976 27. Kleinknecht D, Grunfeld JP, Gomez PC, et al: Diag-
8. Staab EV, Hopkins J, Patton DD, et al: The use of nostic procedures and long-term prognosis in bilateral renal
radionuclide studies in the prediction of function in renal cortical necrosis. Kidney lnt 4:390--400, 1973
failure. Radiology 106:141-146, 1973 28. Bell EG, McAfee JG, Makhuli ZN: Medical imaging
9. O'Reilly PH, Shields RA, Testa H J: Renovascular of renal diseases--Suggested indications for different modal-
hypertension and renal failure, in O'Reilly PH, Shields RA, ities. Semin Nucl Med 11:105-127, 1981
Testa HJ (eds): Nuclear Medicine in Urology and Nephrolo- 29. Freeman LM, Meng CH, Richter MW, et al: Patency
gy. London, Butterworths, 1979, pp 81-85 of major renal vascular pathways demonstrated by rapid
10. Chervu LR, Freeman LM, Blaufox MD: Radiophar- blood flow scintiphotography. J Urol 105:473-481, 1971
maceuticals for renal studies. Semin Nucl Med 4:3-22, 1974 30. Hennessy WT, Pollack HM, Banner MP, et al: Radio-
11. Jakubowski W, Graban W, Licinska I, et al: Compar- logic evaluation of anuric patient. Urology 18:435-445,
ative investigations of renal scanning agents. Eur J Nucl Med 1981
3:33-39, 1978 31. Smart R, Trew P, Burke 3, et al: Simplified estimation
12. Kirchner PT, Berman H: Radioisotopic imaging, in of glomerular filtration rate and effective renal plasma flow.
Rosenfield AT, Glickman MG, Hodson J (eds): Diagnostic Eur J Nucl Med 6:249-253, 1981
Imaging in Renal Disease. New York, Appleton-Century- 32. van Herk G, de Zeeuw D: Unilateral kidney blood
Crofts, 1979, pp 63-72 flow measurement using the S~Rb/8~mKrratio, in Bianchi C,
13. Arnold RW, Subramanian G, McAfee JG, et al: Blaufox MD (eds): Unilateral renal function studies. Basel,
Comparison of 99'~Tc complexes for renal imaging. J Nucl Karger, 1978, pp 67-72
Med 16:357-367, 1975 33. Constable AR, Hussein MM, Albrecht MP, et al.
14. O'Reilly PH, Shields RA, Testa H J: Radiopharma- Renal clearance determined from single plasma samples, in
ceuticals, in O'Reilly PH, Shields RA, Tests HJ (eds): Hollenberg NK, Lange S (eds): Radionuclides in Nephrolo-
Nuclear Medicine in Urology and Nephrology. London, gy. Stuttgart, Thieme, 1980, pp 62~i6
Butterworths, 1979, pp 148-152 34. Grunfeld JP, Sabto J, Bankir L, et al: Methods for
15. Kahn PC: Renal imaging with radionuclides, ultra- measurement of renal blood flow in man. Semin Nucl Med
sound, and computed tomography. Semin Nucl Med 9:43- 4:39-50, 1974
57, 1979 35. Heidenreich P, Oberdorfer M, Hor G, et al: Estima-
16. Handmaker H, Young BW, Lowenstein JM: Clinical tion of renal blood flow by means of technetium-99m and
experience with 99"Tc-DMSA (dimercaptosuccinic acid), a xenon-133, in zum Winkel K, Blaufox MD, Funck-Brentano
new renal-imaging agent. J Nucl Med 16:28-32, 1975 JL (eds): Radionuclides in Nephrology. Stuttgart, Thieme,
17. Oster ZH, Som P, Gil MC, et al: 97Ru-DMSA for 1974, pp 58-66
delayed renal imaging. Radiology 141 : 185-190, 1981 36. Schlegel JU, Lang EK: Computed radionuclide uro-
18. Timmermans L: A comparison of radioisotopic and gram for assessing acute renal failure. Am J Roentgenol
ultrasonic scanning of the kidney, in zum Winkel K, Blaufox 134:1029-1934, 1980
MD, Funck-Brentano JL (eds): Radionuclides in Nephrolo- 37. Schlegel JU, Hamway SA: Individual renal plasma
gy. Stuttgart, Thieme, 1975, pp 101-106 flow determination in 2 minutes. J Urol 116:282-285, 1976
19. Kohn HD, Mostbeck A: Value of additional lateral 38. Schlegel JU, Halikiopoulos HL, Prima R: Determina-
scans in renal scintigraphy. Eur J Nucl Med 4:21-25, 1979 tion of filtration fraction using the gamma scintillation
20. Herman H J, Lange D, Eisenhut M, et al: Radiation camera. J Urol 122:447-450, 1979
dose and labeling of hippuran, in Bianchi C, Blaufox MD 39. Cotran RS, Pennington JE: Urinary tract infection,
(eds): Unilateral Renal Function Studies. Basel, Karger, pyelonephritis, and reflux nephropathy, in Brenner BM,
1978, pp 100-104 Rector FC (eds): The Kidney. Philadelphia, Saunders, 1981,
21. Hattner RS, Maltz HE, Holliday MA: Differentiation pp 1571-1632
of reversible ischemia from end-stage renal failure in 40. Freedman LR: Interstitial renal inflammation, includ-
nephrotic children with ~3q-hippurate dynamic scintigraphy. ing pyelonephritis and urinary tract infection, in Earley LE,
J Nucl Med 18:438-440, 1977 Gottschalk CW (eds): Strauss and Welt's Diseases of the
22. Sherman RA, Blaufox MD: Clinical significance of Kidney. Boston, Little, Brown, 1979, pp 817-876
nonvisualization with 13tI-Hippuran renal scan, in Hollen- 41. Handmaker H, Young B, Fay R: Nuclear renal imag-
berg NK, Lange S (eds): Radionuclides in Nephrology. ing in acute pyelonephritis. J Nucl Med 20:623, 1979
Stuttgart, Thieme, 1980, pp 235-239
42. Hurwitz SR, Kessler WO, Alazraki NP, et al: Gal-
23. Sherman RA, Blaufox MD: Obstructive uropathy in
patients with non-visualization on renal scan. Nephron lium-67 imaging to localize urinary-tract infections. Br J
25:82-86, 1980 RadioI. 49:156-I 60, 1976
24. Hollenberg NK, Epstein M, Rosen SM, r al: Acute 43. Staab EV, McCartney WH: Role of gallium-67 in
oliguric renal failure in man: evidence for preferential renal inflammatory disease. Semin Nucl Med 8:219-234, 1978
cortical ischemia. Medicine 17:455-474, 1968 44. Henkin RE: Gallium-67 in the diagnosis of inflamma-
278 SHERMAN AND BYUN

tory disease, in Hoffer PB, Bekerman C, Henkin RE (eds): 66. Thrall JH, Koff SA, Keyes JW: Diuretic radionuclide
Gallium-67 Imaging. New York, Wiley, 1978, pp 65-92 renography and scintigraphy in the differential diagnosis of
45. Larson SM, Hoffer PB: Normal patterns of localiza- hydroureteronephrosis. Semin Nucl Med 11:89-104, 1981
tion, in Hoffer PB, Bekerman C, Henkin RE (eds): Gallium- 67. O'Reilly PH, Testa H J, Lawson RS, et al: Diuresis
67 Imaging. New York, Wiley, 1978, pp 23-38 renography in equivocal urinary tract obstruction. Br J Urol
46. Hoffer PB: Imaging technique, in Hoffer PB, Beker- 50:76--80, 1978
man C, Henkin RE (eds): Gallium-67 Imaging. New York, 68. KoffSA, Thrall JH, Keyes JW: Diuretic radionuclide
WiIey, I978, pp 9-2I urography: A non-invasive method for evaluating nephroure-
47. Hauser MF, Alderson PO: Gallium-67 imaging in teral dilatation. J Urol 122:451~154, 1979
abdominal disease. Semin Nucl Med 8:251-270, 1978 69. Koff SA, Thrall JH, Keyes JW: Assessment of
48. Mendex G, Morillo G, Alonso M, et al: Gallium-67 hydroureteronephrosis in children using diuretic radionuelide
radionuclide imaging in acute pyelonephritis. Am J Roentge- urography. J Urol 123:531-534, 1980
nol 134:17-22, 1980 70. Hodson C J: The radiological contribution toward the
49. Linton AL, Clark WF, Driedger AA, et al: Acute diagnosis of chronic pyelonephritis. Radiology 88:857-871,
interstitial nephritis due to drugs. Ann Intern Med 93:735- 1967
741, 1980 71. Saunders CD, Corriere JN: The inability to diagnose
50. Wood BC, Sharma JN, Germann DR, et al: Gallium chronic pyelonephritis on the excretory urogram in adults. J
citrate Ga 67 imaging in noninfectious interstitial nephritis. Urol 111:560--562, 1974
Arch Intern Med 138:1665-1666, 1978 72. Davies ER, Roberts M, Roylance J, et al: The renal
51. George EA, Codd JE, Newton WT, et al: 67Ga citrate scintigram in pyelonephritis. Clin Radiol 23:370-376, 1972
in renal allograft rejection. Radiology 117:731-733, 1975 73. McAfee JG: Radionuclide imaging in the assessment
52. Kumar B, Coleman RE: Significance of delayed 67Ga of primary chronic pyelonephritis~ Radiology 133:203-206,
localization in the kidneys. J Nucl Med 17:872-875, 1976 1979
53. Hartenbower DL, Winston MA, Weiss ER, et al: The 74. Meldolesi U, Casucci R, Comotti L: An analysis of the
scintillation camera in embolic acute renal failure. J Urol diagnostic contribution of double-radiocompound renogra-
104:799-802, 1970 phy. Eur J Nucl Med 2:63-66, 1977
54. Lessman RK, Johnson SF, Coburn JW, et al: Renal 75. Kincaid-Smith P, Becket G J: Reflux nephropathy in
artery embolism. Ann Intern Med 89:477~,82, 1978 the adult, in Hodson J, Kincaid-Smith P (eds): Reflux
55. Sanders RC, Menon S, Sanders AD: The complemen- Nephropathy. New York, Masson, 1979, pp 21-28
tary uses of nuclear medicine and ultrasound in the kidney. J 76. Bailey RR: End-stage reflux nephropathy. Nephron
Urol 120:521-527, 1978 27:302-306, 1981
56. Freeman LM: Rapid blood flow scintiphotographic 77. Blaufox MD, Gurskin A, Sandier P, et al: Radionu-
studies of renal trauma and infarction, in Blaufox MD, clide scintigraphy for detection of vesicoureteral reflux in
Funck-Brentano JL (eds): Radionuclides in Nephrology. children. J Pediatr 79:239-246, 1971
New York, Grune & Stratton, 1972, pp 281-287 78. Conway J J, King LR, Belman AB, et al: Detection of
57. Kirchner PT, James AE, Reba RC, et al: Patterns of vesicoureteral reflux with radionuclide cystography. Am J
excretion of radioactive chelates in obstructive uropathy. Roentgenol 115:720-727, 1972
Radiology 114:655~161, 1975 79. Hedman JK, Kempi V, Voss H: Measurement of
58. Malave SR, Neiman HL, Spies SM, et al: Diagnosis of vesicoureteral reflux with intravenous 99mTc-DTPA com-
hydronephrosis: Comparison of radionuclide scanning and pared to radiographic cystography. Radiology 126:205-208,
sonography. Am J Roentgenot 135:1179-1185, 1980 1978
59. KatuI M J, Wax SH: Evaluation of renal function 80. Conway J J, Betman AB, King LR, et at: Direct and
during experimental hydronepbrosis by means of the radio- indirect radionuclide cyslography. J Urol 113:689--693,
isotope renogram. Surg Gynecol Obstet 126:563-571, 1968 1975
60. Joekes AM: Obstructive uropathy. Semin Nucl Med 81. Richmond J, Sherman RS, Diamond HD, et al: Renal
4:187-196, 1974 lesions associated with malignant lymphomas. Am J Med
61. Sherman RA, Blaufox MD: Obstructive uropathy in 32:184-206, 1962
patients with nonvisualization on renal scan. Nephron 25:82- 82. Frankel RS, Riehman SD, Levenson SM, et al: Renal
86, 1980 localization of gallium-67 citrate. Radiology 114:393-397,
62. Ellenbogen PH, Scheible FW, Talner LB, et al: Sensi- 1975
tivity of gray scale ultrasound in detecting urinary tract 83. Turner DA, Fordham EW, Ali A, et al: Gallium-67
obstruction. Am J Roentgenol 130:731-733, 1978 imaging in the management of Hodgkin's disease and other
63. Talner LB, Scheible W, Ellenbogen PH, et al: How malignant lymphomas. Semin Nucl Med 8:205-218, 1978
accurate is ultrasonography in detecting hydronephrosis in 84. Shirkhoda A, Staab EV, Mittelstaedt CA: Renal
azotemic patients ? Urol Radiol 3:1-6, 1981 lymphoma imaged by ultrasound and gallium-67. Radiology
64. Byrd L, Sherman RL: Radiocontrast-induced acute 137:175-180, 1980
renal failure: A clinical and pathophysiologic review. Medi- 85. Gulbrandson RN, Al-Bermani J, Gaspard D J: Suc-
cine 58:270-279, 1979 cessful renal revascularization after prolonged nonfunction.
65. O'Reilly PH, Lupton EW, Testa H J, et al: The JAMA 238:2522-2523, 1977
diuresis renogram, in Hollenberg NK, Lange S (eds): Radio- 86. Benedetti-Valentini F, Massa R, Fiorani P, et al:
nuclides in Nephrology. Stuttgart, Thieme, 1980, pp 216- Sequential scintigraphy in diagnosis and postoperative stud-
220 ies of renovascular hypertension, in Bianchi C, Blaufox MD
NUCLEAR MEDICINE IN RENAL FAILURE 279

(eds): Unilateral Renal Function Studies. Basel, Karger, tion by unilateral percutaneous transluminal dilatation of
1978, pp 89-91 stenosed renal artery. Can Med Assoc J 122:910-912, 1980
87. Koenigsberg M, Freeman LM, Blaufox MD: Radio- 90. Schwarten DE: Percutaneous transluminal angio-
nuclide and ultrasound evaluation of renal morphology and plasty of the renal artery. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol
function, in Edelman CM (ed): Pediatric Kidney Disease. 3:197-206, 1980
Boston, Little, Brown, 1978, pp 236-261 91. Born ML, Gerlock A J, Goncharenko V, et al: Radio-
nuclide evaluation of renal artery dilatation. Cardiovasc
88. Slater EE: Percutaneous transluminal angioplasty of Intervent Radiol 4:177-182, 1981
the renal artery: A hypertensiologist's view. Cardiovasc 92. Kuhlmann U, Vetter W, Furrer J, et al: Renovascular
Intervent Radiol 3:205-206, 1980 hypertension: treatment by percutaneous transluminal dila-
89. Logan AG, Steinhardt MI: Restoration of renal func- tation. Ann Intern Med 92:1-6, 1980

You might also like