Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SPECIFICATION WRITERS
GUIDE
Michael E. Parsons
June 24, 2004
INTRODUCTION
This guide written with structural fabrication in mind and is therefore confined to carbon
and low alloy steels.
The material is organized in a natural sequence, such that we proceed from the general to
the specific and we proceed in the same order that the writer is likely to need the material
while preparing the welding procedure specification (WPS).
Additional material is presented about issues that are closely related to the WPS creation
process. For instance the subject of welder certification is briefly addressed, as is non
destructive testing (NDT), and general welding shop procedure.
The appendix contains several time-tested welding procedures that will serve as examples
for practice and study.
The following is presented for use as a reference and guide only. Ultimately, an
engineering writer or welding engineer must accept responsibility for the procedures he
develops.
Michael Parsons
June 24, 2004
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ii
1. Safety procedures:
a) Hazard: electric shock can be fatal. Don’t touch surfaces that are
electrically live.
b) Hazard: Fumes and gases are toxic. Ventilate, avoid plume, don’t breath
gases.
c) Hazard: arc rays can injure eyes and burn skin. Wear protective eyewear,
gloves, hood and other protective gear.
d) Hazard: lifting injury. Use appropriate lifting technique to safely handle
heavy objects.
2. Select joint design and fit up.
a) Butt joint
b) Corner joint
c) Edge joint
d) Lap joint
e) Tee joint
3. Choose the welding process.
a) SMAW (ARC)
b) GTAW (TIG)
c) GMAW (MIG)
d) FCAW (Flux Core)
e) SAW (Submerged Arc)
4. Select the applicable filler metal for base metal(s) and process
a) Material specification
b) Coating, if applicable
c) Wire size
5. Select shielding method(s):
a) Coated electrode (ARC)
b) Gas (TIG, MIG, and sometimes Flux Core)
c) Granulated flux (SAW)
Deposition rate data was obtained at various current loadings for different wire
diameters and including tubular welding wires. A method is outlined to optimise
selection of the welding parameters and consumables to obtain maximum deposition
rates.
The object of the investigation was to determine the deposition rate (kg/hr); under
conventional welding conditions, of wires of different cross-sections, and to explain the results
with fundamental energy dissipation theory.
Introduction
A basic question which arises in any production situation is `what welding para-
meters; process and consumables need to be used, to deposit the maximum amount of weld
metal in the shortest time?'
Comparing processes is only of interest if the deposition rates are to be compared at the
same energy dissipation. Throughout this report, when two systems are considered these will
always be at the same power consumption, and the comments made will apply in these
circumstances. Little is gained by comparing plasma MIG at 1000A (600A MIG + 400A
plasma) with, for example, a 500A MIG weld. At the same power dissipation the MIG process
with correctly chosen materials exceeds, in deposition rate, the plasma-MIG.
Addressing the question of process selection, the first split is the division into directly
heated consumable, e.g., MIG, sub arc, etc and the indirectly heated proces ses such as TIG;
plasma-powder, etc. It will not be shown here, only stated that all the directly heated
processes should be considered when maximisation of deposition rate is to be obtained - only
the situation where the electrode is both the source of power and weld metal.
The other major process variables are: the metal used, (usually predetermined by the
application); the polarity (negative polarity gives a higher burn-off rate, but this factor is
usually determined by the manufacturer of the consumable) and finally the gas or flux used,
both of which have a minor role.
The choice, therefore, is largely res tricted to the wire diameter, solid or tubular wire and
current used. The latter is often limited by available equipment and single- or multiple-arc
systems.
The mechanism of transfer and additional details on burn-off has been covered in a review
where the physics of the arc is discussed.
Welding energy dissipation
The energy consumed when welding a wire or a stick electrode can be divided into the
voltage drop across the arc (Va) and the voltage drop along the wire (Vr). These voltage
drops correspond to the power necessary to maintain the arc and heat the electrode at a
given welding current (I). Figure l illustrates the situation for wires and stick electrodes.
Considering the resistance heated portion, it is clear that the hotter the metal is upon
reaching the arc, the faster the burn off will be.
The stick-out or electrode extension L is, for experimental purposes, constant; hence:
Kg/hr = K6 x I² / mm²
Fig 1. Energy distribution during welding (top, wire and bottom, electrode).
Fig 2. Effect of current increase on deposition rate for left effect
of arc only and right effect of resistance only.
On reviewing the above equation, it can be seen that a plot of deposition rate (kg/hr) against
current would generate, on the first term, a straight line, and, on the second term, a typical
geometric curve, fig 2. .
Measured deposition rates
The results obtained on submerged arc welding are plotted in fig 3, and cover kg/ hr of
weld metal, measured as wire burnt off, with all wires containing only metals, with estimated
deposit efficiency above 95% in all cases. Precise measurement instrumentation was used,
with current measured as total charge over a given welding period.
The results for open arc welding on identical composition tubular wires are plotted in fig 4. It
is clear that any other consumable directly-heated welding elec trode would produce similar
curves.
Discussion of results
The lines for 3.2mm and, 4.Omm diameter solid wires are virtually straight, suggesting that
the resistance portion is not signifi cant when compared to the current density element. As the
cross section of the wire decreases, and this can be accelerated by using a tubular wire, the
curve is seen -to rise geometrically until close to the vertical. In effect the wire, at this stage, is
reaching the arc in a molten state and virtually no more current can be passed through the
wire even with continuously increasing wire feed speed. The limiting condition is that the total
available energy is consumed in resistance heating and no energy remains to support an arc -
conditions under which it is impossible to obtain a satisfactory bead and no bonding can take
place to the base metal.
Fig 3. Deposition rate. Comparison of tubular with solid wire with variation of wire diameter
conditions: electrode positive; voltage at mean of usable range; 30mm wire stick out, WAF
350 sub arc flux; oscillated bead; low alloy steels.
A single wire is always preferable due to the simplicity, of the operation, and an ideal area
for initial trials on maximising deposition rates is the section about half way through the
usable range of currents. Wire feed speed can be increased thereafter to the suitable
conditions for the combination wire type, item to be welded, pre-heat parameters, etc.
Should the deposition rate required under these conditions not suffice, a twinwire system
will be required; which will normally yield precisely double the optimum values previously
determined. It would theoretically be possible to load a 3.2mm tubular wire to deposit 20
kg/hr with sufficiently high current. In practice this is undesirable due to the need to transfer
a very large current into the wire; and the surface area on which current transfer depends is
not doubled by doubling the cross-section. Two 2.Omm or 2.4mm tubular wires can deposit
the required 20 kg/hr without necessarily overloading any component of the system.
Conclusions
To optimise deposition rate, the effective wire diameter should be decreased, possibly by the
use of tubular wires, and current increased, ensuring at all times that bead shape is adequate.
Energy considerations are a reasonable approximation to experimental data and should be
considered when evaluating deposition rate.
References
Objectives:
To claculate a Carbon Equivalency (CE) for the base metals being considered for joining by welding.
Method:
we wll use a standard formula to calculate CE from the chemical composition of the base metal. This composition
may be taken from the ASTM or other standard for the steel being considered. The weldability of steel is indicated
by the CE, with higher values being associated with greated welding difficulty.
Steel Specification and Composition:
Specification of steel to be investigated: ASTM, A572 Grade 50
Calculations:
Recommendations:
If the CE is 0.60% or greater then use low hydrogen electrodes, increase welding heat inputs, pre-heating,
post heating and/or slow cooling rates.
Values of CE greater than 0.80% indicates steels that may not be readily weldable, that may exhibit inferior
weld properties, or may crack when welded.
CarbonEquivalency.mcd 1 of 1 6/28/04
QW-482 SUGGESTED FORMAT FOR WELDING PROCEDURE SPECIFICATIONS (WPS)
(See QW-200.1, Section IX, ASME Boiler and Pressure Co d e )
Welding Process(es):
*JOINTS(QW-402) Details
Backing Material NA
Metal Nonfusing Metal
Nonmetallic Other
(At the option of the Mfgr., sketeches may be attached to illustrate joint
design, weld layers and bead sequence, e.g. for notch toughness
procedures, for multiple process procedures, etc.
*BASE METALS (QW-403)
A-No.
Size of Filler Materials
Weld Metal:
Thickness Range:
Groove:
Fillet:
Electrode Flux (Class)
Flux Trade Name
Consumable Insert
Other
QW-482 (Back)
WPS No. DATE:
Position(s) of Fillet
GAS (QW-408)
PREHEAT (QW-406) Percent Composition
Preheat Temp. Min. Shielding
Interpass Temp. Max
Trailiing
Preheat Maintenance
Backing
Amps and volts range should be recorded for each electrode size, position, and thickness, etc. This information may be listed
in a tabular form similar to that shown below.
TECHNIQUE (QW-410)
String or Weave Bead
Orifice or Gas Cup Size
Initial and Interpass Cleaning (Brushing, Grinding, etc.
Method of Back Gouging
Oscillation
Each base metal-filler combination should be recorded individually. This form modified for information and typing purposes.(QW-200.1(d)
QW - 482 (Back)
POSITION (QW - 405) POSTWELD HEAT TREATMENT (QW - 407)
ANSI B31.3 Table 331.1.1
Position of Test Groove: 6G
Weld Progression (UP, Down, Flat) Root Down Temperature None Required
Hotpass Up Filler Up Cap Up Time
Other: Other:
Mode of Metal Transfer for GMAW: Low voltage short circuit Wire Feed Speed Range:
(Spray Arc, Short Circuiting Arc, etc.)
Contractor's Specification
TECHNIQUE (QW - 410)
Process(es) GMAW SMAW
String or Weave Bead: Stringer Weave
Orifice or Gas Cup Size: 1/2" - 1.0" N/A
Method of Back Gouging: None None
Oscillation: Minimum Minimum
Contact Tube to Work Distance: 1/4" - 1.0" N/A
Multiple or Single Pass (per side) Single Multiple
Multiple or Single Electrodes: Single Single
Travel Speed (Range) -- --
Peening: N/A N/A
Initial and Interpass Cleaning: Yes Yes
(a) The surfaces of the parts to be welded shall be clean and free of scale, rust, oil, grease, and other deleterious foreign
material for a distance of at least 1/2" from the welding joint preparation for ferrous materials and at least 2" for
Non-ferrous materials. Detrimental oxide shall be removed from the weld metal contact area when weld metal is to
be deposited over a previously welded surface, all slag shall be removed by a roughing tool, chisel, air chipping
hammer, or other suitable means so as to prevent inclusion of impurities in the weld metal.
Other:
affording as much safety as possible. Drive system mechanisms and elec- revolved, regardless of the load. Preston-Eastin positioners are standard
trical controls are completely enclosed for the operator's protection. with a four-post base for vertical adjustment.
Precision spur gears, driven by self-locking worm gear In addition to the standard models, Preston-
reducers, provide minimum backlash with maximum Eastin will custom design positioners to
POSITIONER MODEL Load Capacity INH. OH. ROTAT. TORQUE TILT TORQUE R.P.M. TABLE SIZE
PA-5 MT 500 Lbs.@ 4.0" 3.81" 2,000 N/A .12-3.7 22 Dia.
PA-15 HD4 1,500 Lbs.@ 4.0" 4.25" 6,000 12,375 .12-3.6 24 Dia.
PA-10 HD12 1,000 Lbs.@ 12" 5.25" 12,000 17,250 .05-2.0 30 x 30
PA-20 HD6 2,000 Lbs.@ 6.0" 5.25" 12,000 22,500 .05-2.0 30 x 30
PA-25 HD6 2,500 Lbs.@ 6.0" 5.56" 15,000 28,750 .05-2.0 30 x 30
PA-30 FB 3,000 Lbs.@ 6.0" 6.06" 18,000 36,000 .05-2.0 36 Dia.
PA-30 HD6 3,000 Lbs.@ 6.0" 6.0" 18,000 36,000 .05-2.0 36 x 36
PA-30 HD12 3,000 Lbs.@ 12" 7.0" 36,000 56,250 .032-1.3 42 x 42
PA-45 HD12 4,500 Lbs.@ 12" 7.0" 54,000 85,500 .032-1.3 42 x 42
PA-60 HD6 6,000 Lbs.@ 6.0" 7.0" 36,000 78,000 .032-1.3 42 x 42
PA-60 HD12 6,000 Lbs.@ 12" 8.75" 72,000 124,500 .032-1.3 54 x 54
PA-100 HD12 10,000 Lbs.@ 12" 9.00" 120,000 207,500 .025-1.0 54 x 54
PA-160 HD12 16,000 Lbs.@ 12" 9.50" 192,000 344,000 .015-.60 60 x 60
PA-240 HD12 24,000 Lbs.@ 12" 9.25" 288,000 510,000 .016-.66 66 x 66
PA-300 HD12 30,000 Lbs.@ 12" 12.0" 360,000 720,000 .012-.48 66 x 66
PA-400 HD12 40,000 Lbs.@ 12" 12.0" 480,000 960,000 .003-.30 84 x 84
PA-500 HD12 50,000 Lbs.@ 12" 12.0" 600,000 1,200,000 .003-.30 84 x 84
Selecting the proper positioner
1. Determine the total weight you will be A B
positioning, including fixtures. Positioner Rotating Capacity Positioner Tilt Capacity
2. Calculate the center of gravity of the work.
A. Distance from rotational center. Load C.G.
B. Distance from face of table.
Table
3. Using the distance found in step 2-A, calculate the Center Distance
Load C.G.
rotational torque required. (Illustration A)
4. Using the distance found in step 2-B, calculate the Distance INH.
tilt torque required. (Illustration B) OH.
5. Compare the required rotational and tilt torque with
the chart below. Select a Positioner with a load
capacity equal to or greater than your requirements.
Model HS-45
Headstock
POSITIONER MODEL LOAD CAPACITY ROTAT. TORQUE MOTOR H.P. C.S. R.P.M. TABLE SIZE
HS-20 Headstock 2,000 Lbs. @ 6" 12,000 1/2 1.68 30 x 30
TS-20 Tailstock 2,000 Lbs. @ 6" -------- -- ---- 30 x 30
HS-45 Headstock 4,500 Lbs. @ 12" 54,000 2 1.68 42 x 42
TS-45 Tailstock 4,500 Lbs. @ 12" -------- -- ---- 42 x 42
HS-60 Headstock 6,000 Lbs. @ 12" 72,000 2 1.00 54 x 54
TS-60 Tailstock 6,000 Lbs. @ 12" -------- -- ---- 54 x 54
HS-100 Headstock 10,000 Lbs. @ 12" 120,000 3 1.00 54 x 54
TS-100 Tailstock 10,000 Lbs. @ 12" -------- -- ---- 54 x 54
HS-160 Headstock 6,000 Lbs. @ 12" 192,000 3 .50 54 x 54
TS-160 Tailstock 6,000 Lbs. @ 12" -------- -- ---- 54 x 54
HS-240 Headstock 24,000 Lbs. @ 12" 288,000 3 .40 60 x 60
TS-240 Tailstock 24,000 Lbs. @ 12" -------- -- ---- 60 x 60
For larger sizes, please consult your customer service representative.
Floor Turntables
Preston-Eastin. Your single source for high quality floor turntables.
Preston-Eastin floor turntables provide a high-precision, low-cost method of Pendant controls are labeled FORWARD, STOP, REVERSE, RAPID and
rotating a workpiece around a vertical axis. They provide powered rotation SET (for variable speed control). Table rotation is maintained until
in either direction at adjustable speeds controlled from a remote pendant stopped by the operator.
station, and are ideal for welding, flame cutting, grinding, X-ray, or drill Preston-Eastin floor turntables are rated for maximum work-
press positioning. piece weight and off-set from the axis of rotation. Normal primary
Table rotation is driven by an SCR-controlled DC vari- electrical input is 115/220/440, depending upon the size of
Model FT-25
MOTOR H.P.
MODEL VERTICAL TRAVEL HORIZONTAL TRAVEL LIFT RAM BOLT CIRCLE BASE X Y TRAVEL CAR
MA 44 LD 4 4 1/4 Manual – 97” 6’-6” STD.
MA 66 LD 6 6 1/4 1/4 or Manual – 121” 8’-6” STD.
MA 66 MD 6 6 1/2 1/2 13” 121” 9’-0” OPT.
MA 88 MD 8 8 1/2 1/2 13” 145” 11’-0” OPT.
MA 99 MD 9 9 1/2 1/2 13” 157” 12’-0” OPT.
MA 1212 HD 12 12 3/4 3/4 22-1/8” 205” 16’-0” OPT.
MA 1414 SHD 14 14 1-1/2 1 33-1/2” 241” 19’-0” OPT.
Turning Rolls
Preston-Eastin’s turning rolls help turn precision into productivity.
Preston-Eastin turning rolls are designed and constructed to afford the Final drive gearcase is totally enclosed and constructed entirely of steel.
customer many years of safe and dependable operation. Aluminum-Bronze worm gears provide maximum strength and durability to
To ensure precision alignment at any center-distance setting, these the final drive.
products have machined and jig-drilled frames. Rubber-tired rollers absorb Remote pendant with 20’ cord provides the operator with all
shock during loading and cushion the load during welding. A steel over- functions for welding, forward/reverse, start/stop, weld/rapid, and
load disc (Models TDRA-10 and larger) protects the rubber tires from potentiometer for precise speed adjustment.
excessive overloads.
Model TDRA-20
Model TIRA-20
Model TDRA-60
Model TIRA-60
MODEL LOAD CAPACITY DIAMETER RANGE ROLLER SPEED MOTOR H.P. TURNING CAPACITY TRACTIVE PULL
TDRA-5 5,000 6” - 12’ - 0” 1.2-46 IPM 1/2 15,000 2,000
TDRA-10 10,000 6” - 12’ - 0” 1.2-46 IPM 3/4 30,000 2,900
TDRA-15 15,000 6” - 12’ - 0” 1.6-50 IPM 1 45,000 4,000
TDRA-20 20,000 6” - 12’ - 0” 1.4-57 IPM 1-1/2 60,000 5,000
TDRA-30 30,000 8” - 15’ - 0” 1.1-44 IPM 2 90,000 8,300
TDRA-60 60,000 8” - 15’ - 0” 1.1-44 IPM 3 180,000 12,400
TDRA-90 90,000 8” - 15’ - 0” 1.1-44 IPM 3 270,000 12,400
TDRA-120 120,000 8” - 15’ - 0” 1.1-44 IPM 5 360,000 21,250
TDRA-200 200,000 8” - 15’ - 0” 1.0-40 IPM 5 600,000 28,000
TDSA-300 300,000 2’ - 15’ - 0” .64-64 IPM 10 900,000 38,000
Idler Model TIRA available for each model number.
Special Purpose Rolls Friction Drive Rolls
The final drive gearcase is all steel fabricated and totally enclosed, with cast
Model FIR-3
iron worm gears for maximum strength and durability. A remote pendant with
20-foot cord provides the operator with start/stop functions for welding, for-
Model FDR-3
MODEL WEIGHT CAP. TURNING CAP. TRACTIVE PULL DIA. RANGE SPEED RANGE MOTOR SIZE WHEEL DIA. WHEEL FACE
FDR-3 Drive/Idler 3 Tons 9,000 pounds 2,000 pounds 3.5” thru 30” diameter 1.2 to 46 IPM 1/4 H.P. DC 12” Diameter Rubber 3.5” Wide Rubber
Unit Frames
Preston-Eastin UFTR Series Unit Frame Pipe Turning Rolls are designed and con-
structed to afford the customer many years of safe and dependable operation, with
absorb shock during loading and cushion the load during welding. The final drive
gearcase is all steel fabricated and totally enclosed, with aluminum-bronze worm
gears for maximum strength and durability. A remote pendant with a 15-foot cord
Model UFTR4A-5/36
provides the operator with all functions for welding, forward/reverse, start/stop,
Unit Frame
weld/rapid, and potentiometer for precise speed adjustment.
MODEL WEIGHT CAPACITY DIAMETER RANGE SPEED RANGE MOTOR SIZE WHEEL DIAMETER WHEEL FACE
UFTRA-5/36 Driver 5,000 lbs. 3” thru 36” Diameter 1.6 to 64 IPM 1/2 H.P. DC 12” Diameter Rubber 4.5” Wide Rubber
UFTR4A-5/36 Driver 5,000 lbs. 3” thru 36” Diameter 1.6 to 64 IPM 1/2 H.P. DC 12” Diameter Rubber 4.5” Wide Rubber
UFTIA-Idler 5,000 lbs. 3” thru 36” Diameter 12” Diameter Rubber 4.5” Wide Rubber
UFTR4A-10/36 Driver 5,000 lbs. 3” thru 36” Diameter 1.6 to 64 IPM 1/2 H.P. DC 12” Diameter Rubber 4.5” Wide Rubber
UFTIA-10/36 Idler 5,000 lbs. 3” thru 36” Diameter 12” Diameter Rubber 4.5” Wide Rubber
Welding Head Cross Slides Body of Slide is fabricated from aluminum. Hardened and ground shafts guide the
traveling block on precision ball bushings. The slide can be mounted either vertically
Model WCS-100 and WCS-150 are manual versions with a 4-inch handwheel to
control travel. The WCS-100P and WCS-150P are powered by a DC motor, which
and slide comes standard with limit switches for overtravel protection.
of an Acme Screw and Nut. These Jack Stands are used as outboard
Jack Stands support with our Positioners for extra-long work.
MODEL DESCRIPTION
RPJS-20 Adjustable Pipe Dolly
Self-Centering
Welding Chuck
Foot Switches
MODEL DESCRIPTION
VFS-20 Variable Speed Footswitch
RFS-20 Forward/Reverse Footswitch
SFS-20 On/Off Footswitch