Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Incident Mitigation
Editor’s Note: This supplement is taken from the 2002 edition of this handbook. In that
handbook, the full text of the 2002 edition of NFPA 471, Recommended Practice for Re-
sponding to Hazardous Materials Incidents, was included. Since then, NFPA 471 has
been withdrawn. This supplement is a reprint of Chapter 8, including both the standard
and commentary text. All text is now considered commentary text, as the standard no
longer exists. The material can still be useful to the reader, so it is included as a supple-
ment in this handbook.
587
588 Supplement 7 ● Incident Mitigation
materials that are hazardous are those whose packaging (37.8°C) tends to give off vapor at ambient temperatures.
requires an “Etiologic Agents” label. Biological hazards Similarly, a gas with a vapor density that is substantially
include toxins or microorganisms that cause diseases, such heavier than the surrounding air can collect in ditches and
as anthrax, botulism, cholera, and typhus. Disease-causing other low points at the scene and migrate along the ground
organisms are also likely to be found in waste from hospi- as it mixes with air. Although in many cases gas cannot be
tals, laboratories, and research institutions. Medical waste, seen, it acts like water that has been poured on the ground.
such as used needles, hospital dressing gauze, and band- If the gas is a flammable gas such as propane, a fire or ex-
ages, should be disposed of in red bags with medical waste plosion occurs if the gas finds an ignition source at ground
and biohazard warnings printed on the plastic bag. level.
Biological warfare and terrorist devices and the illegal
disposal of medical waste are all biological hazards. Such
METHODS FOR MITIGATION
materials are often not labeled and might be packaged in
unmarked containers or not packaged at all. There are two basic methods for mitigation of hazardous
materials incidents: physical and chemical. Table S7.1 lists
Radioactive Materials many physical methods for mitigation of hazardous mate-
rials incidents, and Table S7.2 lists many chemical meth-
Radioactive materials are those materials that emit ioniz- ods. Recommended practices should be implemented only
ing radiation. Ionizing radiation is radiation that has suffi- by personnel prepared by training, education, or experi-
cient energy to remove electrons from atoms. One source ence.
of radiation is the nuclei of unstable atoms. For these ra- Many of the methods listed for mitigating an incident
dioactive atoms to become more stable, the nuclei eject or require a high degree of specialized training and the use of
emit subatomic particles and high-energy photons (gamma sophisticated technical equipment, whereas other methods
rays). This process is called radioactive decay. The major might be carried out by personnel at the first responder op-
types of radiation emitted as a result of spontaneous decay erational level. For example, diking or blanketing a liquid
are alpha and beta particles and gamma rays. X-rays, an- spill of diesel fuel can often be accomplished easily by the
other major type of radiation, arise from processes outside first responder operations. Plugging a hole in a damaged
of the nucleus. tank truck to stop a leak, however, would require special-
Radioactive materials can be generated through nu- ized training and equipment that only a technician would
clear processes. These materials also exist naturally in possess. Other operations, such as vent and burn tech-
things such as uranium ore, thorium rock, and some forms niques, should be attempted only by technicians with a
of potassium. Some commonly used and transported ra- tank car specialty. In every case, the incident commander
dioactive materials include radiopharmaceuticals, radi- should be the primary decision maker on which personnel
ographic sources, radioactive waste, and uranium ores. In are assigned to deal with each specific incident.
transportation, radioactive materials can be identified by
markings on the exterior of the package, warning labels at- Physical Methods
tached to the package, or by vehicle placards.
Physical methods of control involve any of several
processes or procedures to reduce the area of the spill,
PHYSICAL STATES OF HAZARDOUS leak, or other release mechanism. In all cases, methods
MATERIALS used should be approved by the incident commander. The
selection of personal protective clothing should be based
Hazardous materials can be classified into three states:
on the hazardous materials and/or conditions present and
gases, solids, and liquids. They can be stored and con-
should be appropriate for the hazards encountered.
tained at a high or low pressure. All three states can be af-
The venting of low-vapor-pressure radiological gases
fected by the environment in which the incident occurs.
is allowed after consultation with a radiation protection
The emergency responder needs to take into account such
technologist and a hazardous materials technician with a
conditions as heat, cold, rain, or wind, each of which can
radioactive material specialty.
have a significant effect on the methods used to accom-
plish a safe operation. Absorption. Absorption is the process in which materials
All matter exists as a gas, a solid, or a liquid. Each hold liquids through the process of wetting. Absorption is
state has specific properties that have a bearing on how a accompanied by an increase in the volume of the sorbate/
particular material appears or behaves in the environment. sorbent system through the process of swelling. Some of
For example, a liquid with a boiling point below 100°F the materials typically used as absorbents are sawdust,
Method LVP* HVP** Liq. Sol. LVP HVP Liq. Sol. LVP HVP Liq. Sol.
Note: For substances involving more than one type, the most restrictive control measure should be used.
*Low Vapor Pressure
**High Vapor Pressure
1
Venting of low-vapor-pressure gases is recommended only when an understanding of the biological system is known. Venting is al-
lowed when the bacteriological system is known to be nonpathogenic, or if methods can be employed to make the environment hostile
to pathogenic bacteria.
2
Venting of low-vapor-pressure radiological gases is allowed when the gas(es) is/are known to be alpha or beta emitters with short half-
lives. Further, this venting is only allowed after careful consultation with a radiation protection technologist, the technician with a radioac-
tive material specialty, or certified health physicist.
3
Covering should be done only after consultation with experts.
4
Absorption of liquids containing bacteria is permitted where the absorption medium or environment is hostile to the medium.
5
Water dispersion on certain vapors and gases only.
Method LVP* HVP** Liq. Sol. LVP HVP Liq. Sol. LVP HVP Liq. Sol.
clays, charcoal, and polyolefin-type fibers. These materials Flammable metals could require a covering of an appropriate
can be used for confinement, but it should be noted that the dry powder agent. Any covering should be accompanied by
sorbed liquid can be desorbed under mechanical or thermal an effective sealing mechanism to prevent the cover from
stress. When absorbents become contaminated, they retain blowing away or the covered material from escaping freely.
the properties of the absorbed hazardous liquids and are,
Dikes, Dams, Diversions, and Retention. Dikes, dams,
therefore, considered to be hazardous materials and must
diversions, and retention refer to the use of physical barri-
be treated and disposed of accordingly.
ers to prevent or reduce the quantity of liquid flowing into
Many commercially available products are suitable for
the environment. Dikes or dams usually refer to concrete,
use as absorbents. Different types of absorbents are de-
earth, or other barriers temporarily or permanently con-
signed for different types of spilled materials so labels
structed to hold back a spill or leak. Vapors from certain
should be carefully checked prior to each use. Absorbents
materials, such as liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), can be
can help reduce vapor generation and can facilitate cleanup
dispersed by means of a water spray.
procedures.
These techniques are the most commonly employed
Absorbents saturated with volatile liquid chemicals
methods of controlling releases because responders can al-
can create a more severe vapor hazard than the spill alone
ways improvise, and simple methods of confinement can
because of severely enlarged surface area for vapor release.
be devised with a little ingenuity. In the case of substantial
Covering. Covering is a temporary form of mitigation for liquid spills, hazardous materials can pose significant chal-
radioactive, biological, and some chemical substances, lenges and, in some rare cases, insurmountable problems
such as magnesium. It should be done after consultation for the first hazardous materials response team to arrive on
with a certified health physicist (in the case of radioactive the scene.
materials) or other experts. In addition to the techniques listed, trenches can be
Covering might be used for solids or liquids. The form used to collect spilled liquids, and pumps can transfer ma-
of covering to be used is influenced by the type of incident. terials to containers or to a containment system. Earthen
The responder needs to make sure that the hazardous mate- dikes or dams can be erected quickly under favorable con-
rial does not permeate the covering material. At a spill of dust ditions, and even sandbags can be used in the damming ef-
or powder, the cover may be a plastic cover or tarp. Where fort. Commercial booms, such as the one shown in Exhibit
alpha or beta radioactive materials are involved, a thicker S7.1, are available and are widely used to control spills, es-
cover might be needed to reduce the radiation emission. pecially spills on waterways.
Dilution. Dilution is the application of water to water- A leaking container can be put into an overpack drum
miscible hazardous materials. The goal is to reduce the or container by placing the overpack on its side and sliding
hazards to safe levels. Responders should not use water in- the smaller container into it, by lowering the overpack over
discriminately or without knowing what effect it has on the the leaking container and then tipping it upright as demon-
hazardous material involved in a hazardous materials inci- strated in Exhibit S7.3, or by using mechanical equipment
dent. Even if a hazardous material is water-soluble, the to raise and lower the leaking container into the overpack
amount of water necessary to achieve a safe level could container. The overpack container must be labeled in ac-
render dilution an impractical approach. Adding water to a cordance with DOT regulations for the particular product
liquid spill can also increase confinement problems. Un- carried inside.
confined diluted hazardous materials have the potential to
cause widespread, long-lasting environmental problems.
Many hazardous materials can also react with water, thus
increasing the intensity of the incident. Water is nonethe-
less a viable option for mitigation in many instances and
should be considered when appropriate.
Overpacking. The most common form of overpacking is
accomplished by the use of an oversized container. Over-
pack containers should be compatible with the hazards of
the materials involved. If the material is to be shipped,
DOT specification overpack containers need to be used.
The spilled materials should still be treated or disposed of
properly.
A leaking drum or container should be temporarily re-
paired, if possible, to reduce spillage before the container
is placed in an overpack container. Reducing a leak can
EXHIBIT S7.3 One method of overpacking involves
sometimes be accomplished by repositioning the original lowering the overpack over the leaking container and then
container. Holes can be covered, and temporary patches tipping it upright.
can be applied. See Exhibit S7.2 for examples of overpack
containers.
Responders should make sure that other containers
without visible leaks or punctures that might be weakened
by deterioration or impact do not fail. Responders should
also try to avoid physical injury when lifting or moving
large or heavy containers. Based on the hazards that are
present, personnel should wear the appropriate chemical-
protective clothing and respiratory protection.
Plug and Patch. Plugging and patching is the use of com-
patible plugs and patches to reduce or temporarily stop the
flow of materials from small holes, rips, tears, or gashes in
containers. The repaired container should not be reused
without inspection and certification.
Limiting or restricting a leak is an important condition
of the mitigation process, so it is essential that responders
master the skill of plugging and patching. At all times,
however, the safety of the responder must be paramount.
Plugging involves putting something into a container
hole to reduce both the size of the hole and the flow from
the hole. Tapered wooden plugs are often used. See Exhibit
S7.4 for examples of plugs and wedges. Regardless of the
EXHIBIT S7.2 Overpack containers are shown here. plug’s material, however, it must be compatible with both
(Photo courtesy of WYK Sorbents, LLC, St. Louis, MO) the product and the container. For example, soft pine might
EXHIBIT S7.5 Commercially available patching kits Vapor Suppression (Blanketing). Vapor suppression is
provide a variety of tools and patching materials to stop the reduction or elimination of vapors emanating from a
leaks in pipes and containers. (Photo courtesy of Edwards spilled or released material through the most efficient
and Cromwell Spill Control) method or application of specially designed agents. A rec-
Chemical Methods
Chemical methods of control involve the application of
chemicals to treat spills of hazardous materials. Chemical
methods can involve any one of several actions to reduce
EXHIBIT S7.6 A fine water spray can be used to disperse
the involved area affected by the release of a hazardous
some hazardous vapors.
material. In all cases, methods used should be acceptable
to the incident commander. The selection of personal pro-
ommended vapor suppression agent is an aqueous foam tective clothing should be based on the hazardous materi-
blanket. als and/or conditions present and should be appropriate for
While vapor suppression, or blanketing, does not the hazards encountered.
change the nature of a hazardous material, it can greatly re-
duce the immediate hazard and danger associated with the Adsorption. Adsorption is the process in which a sorbate
presence of uncontrolled vapor. In addition, this method (hazardous liquid) interacts with a solid sorbent surface.
buys additional time to use other measures that can control See ASTM F 726, Standard Test Method for Sorbent Per-
and resolve the incident under safer circumstances. See formance of Adsorbents, for further information [4]. The
Exhibit 7.7 for an example of a free-standing foam extin- principal characteristics of this interaction are as follows:
guisher. Hazmat response training should include informa-
tion on how to identify when to use foam and which type 1. The sorbent surface, unlike absorbents, is rigid and no
of foam is the most appropriate to use. volume increase occurs.
2. The adsorption process is accompanied by heat of ad-
sorption whereas absorption is not.
3. Adsorption occurs only with activated surfaces, for
example, activated carbon, alumina, and so forth.
EXHIBIT S7.7 Chemical methods of hazardous materials Controlled Burning. Controlled combustion is consid-
mitigation include the use of foam, available in free- ered a chemical method of control. However, it should be
standing foam extinguishers as shown here, or in used only by qualified personnel trained specifically in this
specialized compartments on other vehicles. procedure. In some emergency situations, where extin-
guishing a fire will result in large, uncontrolled volumes of moved through a separation process that takes place in a
contaminated water or threaten the safety of responders or specially designed sand separator.
the public, controlled burning is used as a technique. It is Biological additives can be used to degrade a haz-
recommended that consultation be made with the environ- ardous material by biochemical oxidation. Biochemical
mental authorities when this method is used. The deliber- accelerators are useful for mitigation of certain hazardous
ate burning of a hazardous material should be attempted materials spilled on land or in water.
only by personnel at a technician level with appropriate
Flaring. Flaring is a process that is used with high-vapor-
specialty training or by a specialist employee A.
pressure liquids or liquefied compressed gases for the safe
Some occasions exist when extinguishing a fire is not
disposal of the product. Flaring is the controlled burning of
the proper approach because of the large amount of con-
material in order to reduce or control pressure and/or dis-
taminated runoff that is generated by fire fighting. A Swiss
pose of a product.
pharmaceutical company fire, for example, was responsi-
Flaring is the controlled destruction and/or consump-
ble for years of pollution to the Rhine River that was
tion by fire of a hazardous material. When this process is
caused by the water runoff from the extinguishment of that
chosen, flaring, like any other de-inventory process, has
fire. However, a similar fire in a paint factory in the United
advantages and disadvantages. This technique must be un-
States was allowed to burn out without applying the large
derstood, used, and/or controlled to ensure a safe opera-
quantity of water that would have been necessary to extin-
tion. Other factors that play a part in the decision-making
guish the fire. The air and area water supply were thus pro-
process involved in using this type of physical control
tected from pollution.
method include the following:
Controlled burning can also be used to incinerate the
spilled hazardous material. Transportable incinerators are 1. Conditions of the environment
designed to promote combustion of spilled materials, es- 2. Topography
pecially oil. 3. Materials to be burned
4. Area demographics
Dispersants, Surface Agents, and Biological Additives.
5. Local authorities (i.e., Incident Command System)
Certain chemical and biological agents can be used to dis-
6. Applicable regulations
perse or break up the materials involved in liquid spills.
7. Equipment availability
The use of these agents results in a lack of containment and
generally results in spreading the liquid over a much larger
Gelation. Gelation is the process of forming a gel. A gel
area. Dispersants are most often applied to spills of liquids
is a colloidal system consisting of two phases, a solid and
on water. The dispersant breaks down a liquid spill into
a liquid. The resulting gel is considered to be a hazardous
many fine droplets, thereby diluting the material. Use of
material and needs to be disposed of properly.
this method can require prior approval of the environmen-
Gelling agents used on hazardous chemicals produce
tal authority.
a gel that is more easily cleaned up by either mechanical or
Dispersants are chemical formulations with surfac-
physical methods. Gelling agents can be used on liquids
tants, which are chemicals designed to blend oil and water.
spilled in water and, to a lesser degree, liquid spilled on
Surfactants reduce the surface tension of oil and water and
land.
result in smaller oil droplets. Smaller droplets result in
more oil surface area exposed to the water. These oil Neutralization. Neutralization is the process of applying
droplets can better move into the water, helping to speed acids or bases to a spill to form a neutral salt. The applica-
the natural biological breakdown and dispersion of the oil. tion of solids for neutralizing can often result in confine-
Dispersants generally result in oil-in-water emulsions ment of the spilled material. Special formulations are
because chemicals are used to reduce the surface tension of available that do not result in violent reactions or local heat
water so it can mix with oil. Chemical dispersants should generation during the neutralization process. In cases
not be used in situations where they might produce in- where special neutralizing formulations are not available,
creased biological damage. Environmental authorities special consideration should be given to protecting persons
should/must be consulted prior to the use of these agents. applying the neutralizing agent because heat is generated
Surface-active agents also increase emulsification and dis- and violent reactions can occur. One of the advantages of
persion of a spill. neutralization is that a hazardous material can be rendered
Surface cleaning equipment is available for soil sur- nonhazardous.
face cleaning. This equipment agitates the soil’s surface The pH scale is used to categorize compounds as acids
with water to form a slurry. The contamination is then re- or bases. A value of 7 on the scale is neutral, while de-