Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IS 363 I 01
18 October 2017
exertion and skill in which an individual or team competes against another or others for
definition it states, “team sports such as baseball and soccer” followed by, “athletics,
pastime”. So the question I purpose is what does that actually mean for baseball? Is it a
First I wanted to get some perspectives from some current college baseball
players and see what it means to them. Tyler Raymond is a senior at Avila University
and he said. “[Baseball] is a sport. It takes athleticism and above average coordination
makes it so: the clothing, the workouts, the body chemistry, the money, the love. If you
really play baseball it begins to become your entire life which makes it more than just a
sport.” I think both guys have interesting perspectives about baseball, ones that I don’t
always think about. When I asked my grandma about baseball she said, “[Baseball] is
generation and older. Baseball is still very much in style today, because my grandkids
play it all the time, but no one loves baseball more than my dad and my husband did.”
This I thought was the most important part of the discussion here. Coming from an older
generation who sees baseball as a pastime, but also knows what this generation has
been putting into baseball, speaks volumes. She is in the generation that has seen both
the “pastime” version of baseball and the “sport” version of baseball, which is exactly
On the first day of class, we discussed what is a sport and decided what is a
sport and what isn’t a sport. Things like dance and cheerleading were included while
cricket and water polo were crossed off. I am now asking myself, “What makes these
not sports and makes baseball a sport?” It takes agility and stamina to tread water and
swim for the entire length of a water polo game and it takes coordination to throw the
ball while doing both of those things; yet, we don’t consider water polo a sport? In an
article in Huffington Post, Jenna Garecht says that, “I believe that dance is a sport
because it has the same components as any other sport. To be able to dance well, one
needs to be flexible, strong, have stamina, have endurance and most importantly have
a love for what they do,”(Garecht, 2013). According to the definition reviewed online,
both water polo and cricket are sports. What makes them less of a sport than baseball?
The other question that is presented is the title of “Olympic Games” yet the language
baseball and dance are not included in the Olympics; so, are they sports and things that
are included in the Olympics, like snowboarding or basketball, considered games? What
is the line between one or the other? And who makes the line, decides where each
Between Game and Sport.” It states that a game includes more than one person and a
sport pertains to individuals’ skill and performance. The main takeaway I had is, “A
participates in a game is known as player.” The question I still have is, what do we call
them during practice? They wouldn’t be players because practice isn’t a game, so does
Now is when I really got curious if just baseball was the problem or if this kind of
debate occurred in other sports as well. I went back to the drawing board and decided
that the real problem isn’t in baseball. It’s not in football, or soccer, or basketball. The
problem arose when we began to distinguish certain activities not as sports. Dance and
cheerleading are two of the main sports that have been, and still are, the most debated
sports on the topic. As a dancer I used to hear things such as, “Dance isn’t a sport
because it’s individual.” And, “Dance doesn’t count as a sport because you don’t have
to rely on the others to perform your best.” Neither statement is anywhere near true.
Then this show called “Dance Moms” came along. It was a good show, don’t get me
wrong, and the dancers are good, but the show doesn’t depict normal dance life at all
whatsoever. Then the topic of discussion was that those on the show were athletes and
those who aren’t, were not. Even though we worked just as hard as they did, practiced
just as long as they did, and won just as many trophies as they did. If those who exert
physical exertion into an activity 6 days a week totaling almost 30 hours a week aren’t
the physical activity exerted by females is nowhere near equal to the exertion by males.
The media are the ones who tell us that women’s sports aren’t as exciting as men’s
sports. According to Eileen Kennedy & Laura Hills, “The gendering of the sport media—
the way that men’s sport dominates and women’s sport is sidelined—has attracted
much attention from scholars. Critics have argues that this is inequitable coverage has
exact statement is also true when it comes to athletes and the media in different
genders. Just like when Cam Newton said, ““It’s funny to hear a female talk about
routes. Like, it’s funny.” This happened when a female sideline reporter asked a
question specifically about the details of football (USA Today Sports). Why does the
media shape they way we think so well without anyone really knowing what they’re
doing? The media has a strange way of working its media magic.
Can we blame the media fully on why we call certain activities sports or not? As
much as I would like to, no we can’t. We, as students and athletes and humans, are
also to blame. We are the ones who also “chose to watch football and call it exciting but
call baseball boring until, ‘something exciting happens’. Soccer is ‘all around boring’ and
there’s nothing worse than getting a neck-ache while watching tennis.” These are only a
few of the things I have heard from my fellow classmates about sports in general. The
main thing I don’t quite understand is why we talk down on our classmates about the
sport they chose. Why should it matter if you play baseball or basketball or run track
and field; it should matter that everyone gets an education while continuing to play the
sport they are passionate about. In fact, at Division III schools, the graduation rate is
87% and around 21% of all students participate in one of the 18 teams on any given
(NCAA recruiting), but yet we still call these sports boring, worthless, and even classify
athlete or not. During high school I was practicing over 30 hours a week—not one
football player do I know to this day practices as much as I did. Between being on my
high school dance team and dancing outside of school at my studio, I was either asleep,
at dance, or at school. It forever will aggravate me when people say that what we do
isn’t a sport. I work as a team to achieve a common goal, such as a win, but also as a
solo player to better myself daily. I workout, I practice, and I train constantly. The only
thing different between my sport and other sports is I never experienced an off-season.
Dance is non-stop for 12 months, 365 days a year. I’m not sure any other athlete would
want anything else but this besides a dancer. I went back to Tyler and Sam and asked
them if they could handle the practice regimen I had in high school and both of them
agreed they would not be able to continue doing that for more than a short period of
time. In an article in Quartz Magazine Denise Pope from Stanford University states, “If
where we started to see some health issues,”(Quartz). It’s important to note that my
classmates and I, as well as current student athletes, did twice this and we turned out
fine.
The moral of the story here is that every athlete is different. Every sport is
different and we should not be comparing them to each other because it just isn’t fair.
Each sport deserves its own recognition and as an athlete you should respect that.
Works Cited
Anderson, Jenny. "This Is How Long Your Kids Should Be Spending on Extracurricular
Gantz, Walter, and Lawrence A. Wenner. "Men, Women, and Sports: Audience Experiences
and Effects." HeinOnline. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, Spring 1991.
Web.
Garecht, Jenna. "Is Dance a Sport or an Art?" The Huffington Post. TheHuffingtonPost.com,
Joseph, Andrew. "Cam Newton to Reporter: 'It's Funny to Hear a Female Talk about
Routes'." USA Today. Gannett Satellite Information Network, 08 Oct. 2017. Web.
Kennedy, Eileen, and Laura Hills. Sport, Media and Society. Berg, 2009.