Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No. 17-50641
Plaintiffs-Appellants,
v.
Defendants-Appellees.
i
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 2 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
addition to those persons listed in the parties’ statements, the following listed
persons have an interest in this amicus curiae brief. These representations are made
in order that the judges of this Court may evaluate possible disqualification or
recusal.
this case;
i
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 3 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS…………………..............................................................ii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES………………...........................................................iii
ARGUMENT.............................................................................................................3
Effect.........................................................................................10
CONCLUSION.......................................................................................................14
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE.......................................................................16
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE................................................................................17
ii
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 4 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases
Statutes
Legislative Materials
Senate Bill 11, 84th Regular Session of the Texas Legislature (2015)...............3, 13
Rules
iii
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 5 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
Other Authorities
http://www.denverpost.com/2010/05/13/colo-community-colleges-to-allow-
guns-on-campus/ ..........................................................................................10
https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2006/08/31/stretching-definition-
academic-freedom ..........................................................................................5
Jaschik, Scott, "Gun Rights vs. College Rights", Inside Higher Ed, September 11,
Kessler, Glenn, "Do concealed weapon laws result in less crime?", The Washington
checker/post/do-concealed-weapon-laws-result-in-less-
crime/2012/12/16/e80a5d7e-47c9-11e2-ad54-
580638ede391_blog.html?utm_term=.0ca6afe18b8a...................................12
iv
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 6 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
Lewis, W. Scott, "Empty Holsters on Campus, The Washington Times, October 24,
2007, https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2007/oct/24/empty-holsters-
on-campus/......................................................................................................2
https://www.scribd.com/document/338806665/SCC-Reaches-Out-to-the-
NRA ...............................................................................................................2
National Rifle Association, "The New Campus Revolt: Empty Holsters", America's
https://www.nraila.org/articles/20071213/the-new-campus-revolt-empty-
holsters............................................................................................................2
Olson, Gary A., "The Limits of Academic Freedom", The Chronicle of Higher
Limits-of-Academic-Freedom/49354 .............................................................5
https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/opinions/opinions/51paxton/op/2015/
kp0051.pdf ......................................................................................................7
SCC, "January 1, 2017, Texas License to Carry (LTC) Licensure Among Persons
Texas-LTCs-CHLs-Age-18-23-01-01-17-01-01-16-01-01-15 ....................13
v
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 7 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
2016, http://concealedcampus.org/2016/11/johns-hopkins-report-on-campus-
carry-is-seriously-flawed/ .............................................................................12
SCC, "A Refresher on the Case for Campus Carry in Texas", May 28, 2016,
http://concealedcampus.org/2016/05/a-refresher-on-the-case-for-campus-
carry-in-texas/ ...............................................................................................2
SCC, "Locations Where Concealed Carry is Prohibited in the State of Texas" and
https://www.scribd.com/document/254073403/Locations-Where-Concealed-
Carry-is-Prohibited-in-Texas..........................................................................8
https://www.scribd.com/document/255815743/SCC-s-2015-Texas-
Legislative-Handout ......................................................................................2
SCC, SCC’s Oct. 2, 2015 – Aug. 1, 2017, Texas press releases and op-eds,
https://www.scribd.com/document/319141232/Texas-Students-for-
Concealed-Carry-Campus-Carry-Press-Releases-Op-Eds-Oct-2-2015-Aug-
1-2017 ...........................................................................................................2
vi
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 8 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
https://www.scribd.com/document/258967177/Texas-LTC-CHL-Crime-
Statistics-1996-2015 .....................................................................................13
https://www.scribd.com/document/337897014/Texas-LTC-Revocations-
2014-2016 .....................................................................................................12
SCC, "What ‘Rolling Stone’ Got Wrong About the 'Fight Over Guns on Campus'",
got-wrong-about-the-fight-over-guns-on-campus/ .......................................12
https://youtu.be/XtpJuhAjMoI ..................................................................................2
Stirgus, Eric, "How does Georgia’s campus carry bill work?", The Atlanta Journal-
does-georgia-campus-carry-bill-work/jXPXe6pEngAA1pm6AEP14K/ .....11
Stripling, Jack, "Gun Fight", Inside Higher Ed, April 17, 2009,
https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2009/04/17/gun-fight .....................10
https://www.dps.texas.gov/rsd/LTC/reports/ActLicAndInstr/ActiveLicandIn
str2016.pdf ....................................................................................................13
vii
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 9 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
https://www.dps.texas.gov/RSD/LTC/Reports/ConvictionRatesReport2016.p
df ...................................................................................................................13
http://www.dshs.texas.gov/CHS/Popdat/Dtl/Dtl2016p.xls ..........................13
Texas State Rifle Association, "Mock Mass Shooting on UT Campus, Texas" press
release, https://www.ammoland.com/2015/12/mock-mass-shooting-on-ut-
campus-texas/#axzz4xyrP1a8M .....................................................................2
Tripp, Alice, Legislative Director for the Texas State Rifle Association, Testimony
before the Texas Senate Committee on State Affairs, January 26, 2016,
https://youtu.be/rp7B_TCIpYY ......................................................................2
carry ................................................................................................................3
https://policies.utexas.edu/policies/consensual-relationships ........................6
viii
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 10 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
.........................................................................................................................6
Whaley, Monte, "Colorado Supreme Court affirms that CU students with permits
can carry concealed guns on campus", The Denver Post, March 5, 2012,
http://www.denverpost.com/2012/03/05colorado-supreme-court-affirms-
that-cu-students-with-permits-can-carry-concealed-guns-on-campus/ ........10
Wymer, Garrett, "Some Students Want to Bring Back Concealed Carry", WHSV,
Concealed-Weapons-on-Campus-223526681.html .....................................11
Zuckerman, Laura, "Idaho lawmakers pass bill allowing concealed guns on college
usa-idaho-guns/idaho-lawmakers-pass-bill-allowing-concealed-guns-on-
college-campuses-idUSBREA2605U20140307 ..........................................10
ix
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 11 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
29(a)(4)(E), Amici aver that: (i) no party’s counsel authored this brief in whole or
preparation or submission of the brief; and (iii) no person—other than the amici
1
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 12 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
concerned citizens who believe that individuals who possess a state-issued license
public college campuses, for personal protection. SCC, which is not affiliated with
national "campus carry" movement 2 and bringing the issue to the political
forefront3 in both Texas and across the country. SCC lobbied 4 extensively for the
1
Testimony of Texas State Rifle Association Legislative Director Alice Tripp, before the Texas
Senate Committee on State Affairs, explaining the history of the movement to allow the licensed,
concealed carry of handguns on Texas college campuses; January 26, 2016;
https://youtu.be/rp7B_TCIpYY.
2
Letter from SCC National Media Coordinator W. Scott Lewis to National Rifle Association
Institute for Legislative Action Executive Director Chris Cox, December 3, 2007,
https://www.scribd.com/document/338806665/SCC-Reaches-Out-to-the-NRA.
3
W. Scott Lewis, "Empty Holsters on Campus", The Washington Times, October 24, 2007,
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2007/oct/24/empty-holsters-on-campus/;
National Rifle Association, "The New Campus Revolt: Empty Holsters", America's First
Freedom, December 13, 2007, https://www.nraila.org/articles/20071213/the-new-campus-revolt-
empty-holsters.
4
"SCC's 2015 Texas Legislative Handout", a collection of op-eds and essays written by SCC and
distributed to Texas legislators during the 2015 Texas Legislative Session,
https://www.scribd.com/document/255815743/SCC-s-2015-Texas-Legislative-Handout,
"Why Campus Carry?"; a 30-second television commercial produced by SCC and aired in
Austin, Texas, during the 2015 Texas Legislative Session; https://youtu.be/XtpJuhAjMoI; SCC’s
Oct. 2, 2015 – Aug. 1, 2017, Texas press releases and op-eds:
https://www.scribd.com/document/319141232/Texas-Students-for-Concealed-Carry-Campus-
Carry-Press-Releases-Op-Eds-Oct-2-2015-Aug-1-2017; "A Refresher on the Case for Campus
Carry in Texas": http://concealedcampus.org/2016/05/a-refresher-on-the-case-for-campus-carry-
in-texas/.
2
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 13 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
passage of the law challenged by Plaintiffs and is credited with being one of three5
ARGUMENT
classrooms?
5
Texas State Rifle Association; "Mock Mass Shooting on UT Campus, Texas"; press release
stating, "SB 11, CHL on Campus, took 4 legislative sessions to pass, 8 years. Besides Texas
State Rifle Association the major stakeholders were NRA and Students for Concealed Carry on
Campus, a national group organized post Virginia Tech",
https://www.ammoland.com/2015/12/mock-mass-shooting-on-ut-campus-
texas/#axzz4xyrP1a8M.
3
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 14 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
styles)?
subject of debate since the Supreme Court affirmed the existence of said right in
Sweezy v. New Hampshire, 354 U.S. 234, 250 (1957). Since then, the Supreme
Court has offered little guidance on the matter; however, lower courts have held
that the right is primarily an institutional right and that any similar right enjoyed by
by all citizens.
The Fourth Circuit's ruling in Urofsky v. Gilmore, 216 F.3d 401, 410 (4th
Cir. 2000), states, "[to] the extent the Constitution recognizes any right of
‘academic freedom’ above and beyond the First Amendment rights to which every
citizen is entitled, the right inheres in the university, not in individual professors."
Southeastern Mass. Univ., 793 F.2d 419, 426 (1st Cir. 1986), which states, "The
first amendment does not require that each nontenured professor be made a
4
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 15 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
precedent, such claims are common among U.S. professors displeased with
August 31, 2006, edition of Inside Higher Ed, John Friedl—professor in the
the growing gap in the understanding of the concept of academic freedom shared—
Higher Education, Gary A. Olson—provost and vice president for academic affairs
at Idaho State University and co-editor, with John W. Presley, of The Future of
afforded by academic freedom, but too many are unclear as to its limits. I have
known colleagues who believed that academic freedom allows them to say
6
John Friedl, "Stretching the Definition of Academic Freedom", Inside Higher Ed, August 31,
2006, https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2006/08/31/stretching-definition-academic-
freedom.
7
Gary A. Olson, "The Limits of Academic Freedom", The Chronicle of Higher Education,
December 9, 2009, https://www.chronicle.com/article/The-Limits-of-Academic-Freedom/49354.
5
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 16 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
anything they want, to anyone, in any venue, or to engage in behavior that most
Plaintiffs argue that academic freedom affords them the right to bar adults
whom the State of Texas has vetted and licensed to carry handguns, from entering
their classrooms with concealed handguns. By this same flawed logic, academic
freedom would afford Plaintiffs the right to bar campus police officers, who have
also been vetted and licensed by the State of Texas, from entering their classrooms
with handguns.
to nullify virtually any university policy with which they disagree. They could
make an equally valid case that the university's policy8 against the on-campus use
8
University Policy Office, The University of Texas at Austin, Handbook of Operating
Procedures 8-1040, "Tobacco-Free Campus", https://policies.utexas.edu/policies/tobacco-free-
campus.
9
University Policy Office, The University of Texas at Austin, Handbook of Operating
Procedures 3-3050, "Consensual Relationships", https://policies.utexas.edu/policies/consensual-
relationships.
6
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 17 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
of classrooms, a court would likely conclude that the effect would be to 'generally
the Legislature's express requirements." The opinion also states, "[A] court would
likely conclude that S.B. 11 does not authorize a president or chief executive
If this opinion of the Texas attorney general is correct, Texas state law,
barring license to carry ("LTC") holders from carrying concealed handguns in the
professors' classrooms. If that is the case, the Court cannot offer Plaintiffs relief
state law declaring that an action and/or object that is allowed in almost all other
10
Ken Paxton, Attorney General of Texas, Opinion No. KP-0051,
https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/opinions/opinions/51paxton/op/2015/kp0051.pdf.
7
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 18 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
state facilities11 must also be allowed in college classrooms would set a dangerous
precedent.
any state law that a professor speculates might impact his or her classroom,
concealed carry of handguns on college campuses could have that law overturned,
on the basis that he or she only feels safe in the classroom while carrying a
handgun. Likewise, a professor could argue that state and federal laws against the
possession and/or recreational use of marijuana inhibit his or her ability to expand
preferred class among First Amendment rights is both dangerous and without legal
system. Simply put, nothing in Supreme Court precedent or lower court rulings
to allow licensed, vetted adults to engage in the same behavior in which those
11
Students for Concealed Carry, "Locations Where Concealed Carry is Prohibited in the State of
Texas" and "Clearing up Confusion about Where Licensed Concealed Carry is Prohibited in the
State of Texas", July 10, 2013, https://www.scribd.com/document/254073403/Locations-Where-
Concealed-Carry-is-Prohibited-in-Texas.
8
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 19 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
licensed, vetted adults are allowed to engage at most other locations throughout the
First Amendment rights stems from a challenge to a statute that directly restricted
overcorrecting (i.e., they restricted their own speech in excess of what was required
by the law, in order to avoid crossing a legal threshold that was not clearly
Some small measure of guidance may be gleaned from Laird v. Tatum, 408
U.S. 1, 13–14 (1972), which states, "Allegations of a subjective 'chill' are not an
specific future harm." This dismissal of allegations of a subjective chill raises the
evidence. In other words, do Plaintiffs have a factual basis for their belief that they
are likely to suffer harm at the hands of LTC holders if they do not alter their
9
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 20 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
• Since the fall semester of 200612, licensed individuals have been allowed to
public colleges (20 campuses) and one public technical college (10
campuses).
Colorado State University (Fort Collins, CO, and Pueblo, CO) since 200313
• As of July 1, 201416, all Idaho public colleges (30 campuses) allow licensed
concealed carry.
10
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 21 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
In total, more than 333 U.S. college campuses have allowed licensed
concealed carry for a combined total of almost 2,000 (biannual) college semesters,
campuses, Plaintiffs have not provided a single example of a faculty member, staff
which, after more than a decade of researching this issue, have not located a single
17
Eric Stirgus, "How does Georgia’s campus carry bill work?", The Atlanta Journal-
Constitution, May 5, 2017, http://www.ajc.com/news/local-education/how-does-georgia-campus-
carry-bill-work/jXPXe6pEngAA1pm6AEP14K/.
18
Garrett Wymer, "Some Students Want to Bring Back Concealed Carry", WHSV, September
12, 2013, http://www.whsv.com/news/headlines/Carrying-Concealed-Weapons-on-Campus-
223526681.html.
11
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 22 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
That analysis concluded, "Certainly, it appears such laws have not increased the
This lack of increase in the crime rate is in part attributable to the fact that
LTC holders tend to be scrupulously law abiding. From 2014 through 201620,
Texas LTC holders of typical undergraduate age (1821-23) had their licenses
revoked at a lower rate than did license holders twenty years older. From 1996
through 201622, Texas LTC holders were less than 14% as likely to be convicted of
19
Glenn Kessler, "Do concealed weapon laws result in less crime?", The Washington Post,
December 17, 2012, https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/fact-checker/post/do-concealed-
weapon-laws-result-in-less-crime/2012/12/16/e80a5d7e-47c9-11e2-ad54-
580638ede391_blog.html?utm_term=.0ca6afe18b8a; see also "Johns Hopkins Report on Campus
Carry Is Seriously Flawed": http://concealedcampus.org/2016/11/johns-hopkins-report-on-
campus-carry-is-seriously-flawed/; "What ‘Rolling Stone’ Got Wrong About the 'Fight Over
Guns on Campus'": http://concealedcampus.org/2017/03/what-rolling-stone-got-wrong-about-
the-fight-over-guns-on-campus/.
20
Students for Concealed Carry, "Texas LTC Revocations (2014-2016)", a compilation of
statistics collected and released by the Texas Department of Public Safety,
https://www.scribd.com/document/337897014/Texas-LTC-Revocations-2014-2016.
21
Per Texas Government Code § 411.172(g), a person age 18-20 may only obtain a Texas
license to carry a handgun if the person is a member or honorably discharged veteran of the U.S.
armed forces: http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/Docs/GV/htm/GV.411.htm#411.172.
Texas's LTC reciprocity agreements dictate that a person who carries a handgun in Texas, under
the authority of a license issued by another state but recognized by Texas, must "comply with all
laws, rules, and regulations of the State of Texas governing concealed carry, including age
restrictions [emphasis added] and types of weapons permitted":
https://www.dps.texas.gov/RSD/LTC/legal/reciprocity/Indianaproclamation.pdf.
22
Students for Concealed Carry, "Texas LTC/CHL Crime Statistics (1996-2015)", a compilation
of statistics collected and released by the Texas Department of Public Safety,
https://www.scribd.com/document/258967177/Texas-LTC-CHL-Crime-Statistics-1996-2015;
12
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 23 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
aggravated assault with a deadly weapon as were unlicensed adults in the state of
Texas. As of January 1, 201723, the rate of LTC licensure among Texans of typical
undergraduate age (18-23) was approximately 1.03%, or one person out of every
97. Neither the Texas law nor the University of Texas at Austin policy at issue
As in the days before the 84th Texas Legislature legalized the licensed, concealed
controlled points of entry, metal detectors, and bag checks. As in the past, any
student unconcerned with following the rules can just as easily enter a classroom
only 1.03% of Texans age 18-23 are LTC holders, and if LTC holders are
Texas Department of Public Safety, "Conviction Rates for Handgun License Holders Reporting
Period : 01/01/2016 - 12/31/2016", April 25, 2017,
https://www.dps.texas.gov/RSD/LTC/Reports/ConvictionRatesReport2016.pdf;
Texas Department of Public Safety, "Active License/Certified Instructor Counts As of December
31, 2016", January 2, 2017,
https://www.dps.texas.gov/rsd/LTC/reports/ActLicAndInstr/ActiveLicandInstr2016.pdf;
Texas Health and Human Services, 2016 Population Projections,
http://www.dshs.texas.gov/CHS/Popdat/Dtl/Dtl2016p.xls.
23
Students for Concealed Carry, "January 1, 2017, Texas License to Carry (LTC) Licensure
Among Persons Age 18-23", a compilation of statistics collected and released by the Texas
Department of Public Safety, https://www.scribd.com/document/258967033/Statistics-on-Texas-
LTCs-CHLs-Age-18-23-01-01-17-01-01-16-01-01-15.
13
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 24 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
weapon, we can estimate that a professor teaching a classroom full of 18- to 23-
handgun.
be assaulted (with a weapon) by one of the 98.97% of his or her students who are
not authorized to carry a gun in class as by one of the 1.03% who are licensed to
carry a gun in class, the presence of students licensed to carry a gun in class creates
no factually defensible motivation for the professor to alter his or her curriculum or
pedagogical style.
CONCLUSION
classrooms and the logical fallacy that the presence of licensed, lawfully armed
changes to curriculum, course materials, and/or teaching style. The District Court
ruled correctly in dismissing the case on the grounds that Plaintiffs failed to "point
14
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 25 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
to a specific harm they have suffered or will suffer as a result of the law and
15
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 26 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE
Pursuant to FED. R. APP. P. 32(g)(1) and Fifth Circuit Local Rule 32.3, I
16
Case: 17-50641 Document: 00514326902 Page: 27 Date Filed: 01/29/2018
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of the
Court for the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit by using the
I certify that all participants in the case are registered CM/ECF users and
17