Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kadam
Environmental Consultants
www.kadamenviro.com
Environmentfor Development
PROPOSED SPECIALITY CHEMICALS
MANUFACTURING FACILITY AT GIDC
CRODA INDIA COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED DAHEJ, PHASE II QUALITY CONTROL
This report is released for the use of the Croda India Company Private Limited, Regulators and relevant
stakeholders solely as part of the subject project’s Environmental Clearance process. Information provided
(unless attributed to referenced third parties) is otherwise copyrighted and shall not be used for any other
purpose without the written consent of Kadam.
QUALITY CONTROL
Name of EIA/EMP & RA/DMP Report for Proposed Speciality Chemicals Manufacturing Facility at Plot No.
Publication D2/CH/21, GIDC Dahej, PhaseII, Taluka Vagra, District Bharuch
Revision
Project Number 1417382110 Issue No. 1 1 Released June,2017
No.
DISCLAIMER
Kadam has taken all reasonable precautions in the preparation of this report as per its auditable quality plan. Kadam
also believes that the facts presented in the report are accurate as on the date it was written. However, it is impossible
to dismiss absolutely, the possibility of errors or omissions. Kadam therefore specifically disclaims any liability resulting
from the use or application of the information contained in this report. The information is not intended to serve as legal
advice related to the individual situation.
CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND ...................................................... 26
LIST OF ANNEXURES
Annexure 1: Copy of ToR Letter issued by SEAC, Gujarat ....................................................... 245
Annexure 12: Croda India Safety Health and Environment Policy Statement ............................ 318
Annexure 14 : Public Hearing Advertisemnet in Local & English News paper ............................ 320
Annexure 15: Proof for Distribution of Executive summary in study village .............................. 322
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1-1: Production Capacity .............................................................................................. 27
Table 2-3: Mass Balance for Alkoxylates (Ethoxylated/ Propoxylated Products) .......................... 45
Table 2-16: Design Inlet & Outlet Characteristics of Proposed ETP ............................................ 65
Table 2-19: Details of Flue Gas Stacks and Fuel Consumption .................................................. 72
Table 3-1: Synopsis of Landuse / Landcover Classification Used for the Project.......................... 78
Table 3-2: Area Statistics for Land Use / Land Cover Categories in the Study Area ..................... 82
Table 3-4: Important Features and Sensitive Ecological Locations in the Study Area .................. 83
Table 3-7: Mean Meteorological Data for Winter Season 2014-15 ............................................. 85
Table 3-9: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Results (Winter Season: December 2014 – February
2015) ................................................................................................................................... 90
Table 3-10: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Results (June 2015) ............................................... 92
Table 3-11: Ambient Air Quality Standards in respect of Noise for Different Areas/Zones ............ 94
Table 3-18: Analysis Result of River (Estuary) Water Sample .................................................. 101
Table 3-35- Water Facilities with in the Study area ................................................................ 117
Table 3-39-Type of Livelihood Activity in the Core Impact area ............................................... 119
Table 4-1: Overall Impact Scoring System due to the Proposed Project – Consequence Assessment
......................................................................................................................................... 123
Table 4-7: Stacks Details and Gas Emission Details from Flue Gas Stacks ................................ 138
Table 4-8: Stack Details and Gas Emission Details from Process Vents .................................... 139
Table 4-20: Impact Scoring of Occupational Health, Community Health and Safety .................. 156
Table 7-2: Environment Related Key Issue for proposed Plants and Commitement by Croda ..... 172
Table 7-10: Radiation Level and Effect Distance due to Release of Benzyl Chloride .................. 181
Table 7-11: Overpressure Effect Distance due to Release of Benzyl Chloride............................ 182
Table 7-12: Radiation Level and Effect Distance due to Release of Ethylene Oxide ................... 183
Table 7-13: Overpressure Effect Distance due to Release of Ethylene Oxide ............................ 184
Table 7-14: Distance to Equivalent Toxic Dose due to Release of Ethylene Oxide ..................... 184
Table 7-15: Radiation Level and Effect Distance due to Release of Isopropyl Alcohol ................ 187
Table 7-16: Overpressure Effect Distance due to Release of Isopropyl Alcohol ......................... 188
Table 7-17: Radiation Level and Effect Distance due to Release of Methanol ........................... 190
Table 7-18: Overpressure Effect Distance due to Release of Methanol .................................... 190
Table 7-19: Radiation Level and Effect Distance due to Release of N-Butanol .......................... 192
Table 7-20: Radiation Level and Effect Distance due to Release of Propylene Oxide ................. 194
Table 7-21: Overpressure Effect Distance due to Release of Propylene Oxide .......................... 194
Table 7-22: Distance to Equivalent Toxic Dose due to Release of Propylene Oxide ................... 194
Table 10-2: Environment Management Plan for Air Environment ............................................. 218
Table 10-3: Details of Activities responsible for Impact on Water Environment and Management
Plan ................................................................................................................................... 220
Table 10-4: Environmental Management Plan for Noise Environment ...................................... 222
Table 10-8: Costing for green beltdevelopment (Five years plan) ............................................ 225
Table 10-11: Capital & Recurring Cost for Environmental Pollution Control Measures on Yearly
basis .................................................................................................................................. 230
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2-1: Site Location Map ................................................................................................ 39
Figure 2-4: Flow diagram for Alkoxylates (Ethoxylated/ Propoxylated Products) ......................... 45
Figure 2-11: Agreement Letter with GIDC for Treated Wastewater Discharged into GIDC drain for
Phase-I ................................................................................................................................ 63
Figure 2-12: Process Block diagram of Proposed ETP- 250 KLD capacity ................................... 69
Figure 2-15: Copy of Acceptance Letter from M/s. Ambuja Cement for Co-processing of Haz.
Wastes ................................................................................................................................. 76
Figure 7-1: Photographs of Public Hearing Publicity through Auto Rickshaw ............................ 170
Figure 7-3: Late Pool Fire Risk Consequence Contour of Benzyl Chloride due to 10 mm leak at
Weather Condition 3.0/E...................................................................................................... 182
Figure 7-4: Late Pool Fire Risk Consequence Contour of Benzyl Chloride due to 25 mm leak at
Weather Condition 3.0/E...................................................................................................... 183
Figure 7-5: Late Pool Fire Risk Consequence Contour of Benzyl Chloride due to Catastrophic
Rupture at Weather Condition 3.0/E ..................................................................................... 183
Figure 7-6: Jet Fire Risk Consequence Contour of Ethylene Oxide due to 10mm at Weather
Condition 3.0/B ................................................................................................................... 185
Figure 7-7: Late Pool Fire Risk Consequence Contour of Ethylene Oxide due to 10 mm at Weather
Condition 4.0/D .................................................................................................................. 185
Figure 7-8: Jet Fire Consequence Contour of Ethylene Oxide due to 25mm at Weather Condition
3.0/B ................................................................................................................................. 186
Figure 7-9: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Ethylene Oxide due to 25mm at Weather
Condition 4.0/D .................................................................................................................. 186
Figure 7-10: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Ethylene Oxide due to Catastrophic Rupture at
Weather Condition 3.0/E...................................................................................................... 187
Figure 7-11: Late Explosion Consequence Contour of Ethylene Oxide due to Catastrophic Rupture
at Weather Condition 3.0/B.................................................................................................. 187
Figure 7-12: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Isopropyl Alcohol due to 10mm leak at
Weather Condition 4.0/D ..................................................................................................... 188
Figure 7-13: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Isopropyl Alcohol due to 25mm leak at
Weather Condition 3.0/E...................................................................................................... 189
Figure 7-14: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Isopropyl Alcohol due to Catastrophic Rupture
at Weather Condition 3.0/E .................................................................................................. 189
Figure 7-15: Late Explosion Consequence Contour of Isopropyl Alcohol due to Catastrophic
Rupture at Weather Condition 4.0/D ..................................................................................... 189
Figure 7-16: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Methanol due to 10mm Leak at Weather
Condition 3.0/E ................................................................................................................... 191
Figure 7-17: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Methanol due to 25mm Leak at Weather
Condition 3.0/E ................................................................................................................... 191
Figure 7-18: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Methanol due to Catastrophic Rupture at
Weather Condition 3.0/E...................................................................................................... 191
Figure 7-19: Late Explosion Consequence Contour of Methanol due to Catastrophic Rupture at
Weather Condition 3.0/E...................................................................................................... 192
Figure 7-20: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of N- Butanol due to 10mm Leak at Weather
Condition 3.0/B ................................................................................................................... 193
Figure 7-21: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of N- Butanol due to 25mm Leak at Weather
Condition 3.0/E ................................................................................................................... 193
Figure 7-22: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of N- Butanol due to Catastrophic Rupture at
Weather Condition 3.0/E...................................................................................................... 193
Figure 7-23: Jet Fire Consequence Contour of Propylene Oxide due to 10mm Leak at Weather
Condition 3.0/B ................................................................................................................... 195
Figure 7-24: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Propylene Oxide due to 10mm Leak at
Weather Condition 4.0/D ..................................................................................................... 195
Figure 7-25: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Propylene Oxide due to 25mm Leak at
Weather Condition 3.0/B ..................................................................................................... 196
Figure 7-26: Late Explosion Consequence Contour of Propylene Oxide due to 25mm Leak at
Weather Condition 3.0/E...................................................................................................... 196
Figure 7-27: Late Pool Fire Consequence Contour of Propylene Oxide due to Catastrophic Rupture
at Weather Condition 3.0/E .................................................................................................. 196
Figure 7-28: Emergency Preparedness Organization Chart during General Shift ....................... 200
Figure 7-29: Emergency Preparedness Organization Chart during Silent Hours......................... 201
LIST OF PHOTOGRAPHS
Photograph 1-1: Photographs Showing to the Project Site ........................................................ 28
Photograph 12-2: Data logger to collect Site Specific Meteorological Data ............................... 266
ABBREVIATIONS
AAQM Ambient Air Quality Monitoring
AERMOD Atmospheric Dispersion Modelling System
BEIL Bharuch Enviro Infrastructure Limited
BOD Biological Oxygen Demand
CPCB Central Pollution Control Board
COD Chemical Oxygen Demand
CO Carbon Monoxide
DGVCL Dakshin Gujarat Vij Corporation Limited
DISH Department of Industrial Safety Health
DMP Disaster Management Plan
EC EnvironmentalClearance
EIA Environmental Impact Assessment
ESMPs Environmental and Social Management Plans
EHS Environment, Health and Safety
EER Evacuate, Escape and Rescue Plan
EPRG Emergency Response Planning Guidelines
ECC Emergency Control Center
FMECA Failure Modes Effects and Criticality Analysis
GIDC Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation
GOI Government of India
GPCB Gujarat Pollution Control Board
GLC Ground Level Concentration
HAZOP Hazard and Operability Study
IAA Impact Assessment Authority
IMD Indian Meteorological Department
ICUN International Union for Conservation of Nature
IDLH Immediately Dangerous to Life or Health
KLD Kilo Liters per Day
LFT Liver Function Test
LEL Lower Flammability Limits
LCLo Lethal Concentration Low
MSIHC Manufacture, Storage, Import & Hazardous Chemical Rules
MoEF Ministry of Environment and Forests
MCLs’ Maximum Credible Loss Scenarios
MSDS Material Safety Data Sheet
NOC No Objection Certificate
NDT Non Destructive Testing
NIOSH National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
NOx Oxides of Nitrogen
OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PEL Permissible Exposure Limits
PM Particulate Matter
PPEs Personnel Protective Equipment
PDCR Plan, Do, Check, Act
SEIAA State Level Environmental Impact Assessment Authorities
SS SuspendedSolid
SOx Oxides of Sulphur
SPL Sound Pressure Level
SMC Site Main Controller
STEL Short Time Exposure Limit
ToR Terms of References
TCLo Toxic Concentration Low
TLV Threshold Limit Value
TDS Total Dissolved Solid
TSDF Treatment, Storage and Disposal Facility
USEPA United States Environment Protection Agency
UFL Upper Flammable Limits
VOC Volatile Inorganic Carbon
ZSI Zoological Survey of India
AN INCIDENT:An incident is emergent situation of any critical deviation in the process control or
otherwise that may lead to a major accident / potential emergency and disaster.
ANEMOMETER: A device used to measure speed of wind or any other moving gas.
Neutral stability occurs typically, when there is total cloud cover and is designed by category D
(The temperature gradient = adiabatic lapse rate) Unstable conditions occur when the sun is
shining. The unstable conditions are designated by the letters A-C with A is the least stable
condition stable conditions occur on clear, calm nights, when the air near the ground is stratified
and free from turbulence and are designated by the letter E &F. Sometimes an additional category
G is used for exceptionally stable conditions. Neutral conditions correspond to a rate of decrease in
temperature with height of about 1°C per meters, vertically. For the dispersion study D & C
stability class has been considered.
BLEVE (BOILING LIQUID EXPANDING VAPOUR CLOUD EXPLOSION):The event may have
two folds, one; flammable liquid under pressure rapidly spread in to the open area in form of
vapour cloud, two; if this spreading vapour cloud gets any source of ignition, then violently
explosion took place produce missiles effect with secondary fires and create heavy damages to the
surrounding area. The phenomenon is called as BLEVE.
BUND/DYKE:Raised ground or a wall built around a tank or tank farm, to retain spills and
prevent their spread, thus reducing hazards.
BURNING RATE:The value is the rate (in millimeters per minute) at which the depth of a pool of
liquid decreases as the liquid burns.
CHRONIC:Of long duration or having frequent recurrence. Chronic health effects are those that
become apparent or continue for some time after exposure to hazardous chemicals.
Class ‘A’: Means petroleum having a flash point below 23°C. (e.g. Petrol, Hexane, Toluene,
Naphtha)
Class ‘B’: Means petroleum having a flash point of23°C and above but below 65°C. (e.g. HSD,
SKO, MTO etc.)
Class ‘C’: Means petroleum having a flash point of 65° C and above but below 93° C.
DISASTER:A disaster is catastrophic consequence of a major emergency / accident that leads to,
not only extensive damage to life and property but also disrupts all normal human activity for a
pretty long time and requires a major national and international effort for rescue and rehabilitation
of those affected.
DISTRICT CRISIS GROUP (DCG):The District Crisis Group is the apex body in the district to
deal with major chemical accidents and to provide expert guidance for handling chemical
accidents.
DOMINO EFFECT:An effect by which a small hazardous incidence in a unit can escalate to
surrounding area causing heavy damages to man, properties &environment.
FIRE BALL:The burning of a flammable gas cloud, the bulk of which is initially over-rich i.e.
(UFL). The whole cloud appears to be on fire as combustion is taking place at eddy boundaries,
when air is entrained.
FLAMMABILITY LIMITS (UFL- LFL):In fuel-air system a range of composition exists outside
which a flame will not propagate a substantial distance from an ignition source. The limiting fuel
concentrations are termed the upper flammable limit (UFL) and lower Flammable Limit (LFL)
FLASH FIRE:A burning of a flammable vapour cloud at very low flame propagation speed.
FLASH POINT:This is defined as the lowest temperature at which vapours above a combustible
substance will ignite in air when exposed to a flame.
Depending on the test method used, the values given are either Tag closed cup (C. C.) or
Cleveland open cup (O, C.) The values, along with those in 6.2 and 6.5 give an indication of the
relative flammability of the chemical. In general, the open cup value is about 10o to 15oF higher
than the closed cup value.
HAZARD:Hazard may be defined as “the potential of an accident.” Hazard exists in man and the
system of materials and machines.
Any Chemical, which satisfies any of the criteria, laid down in Part I of Schedule I and is listed
in column 2 of Part II of the schedule.
Any Chemical listed in Column 2 of Schedule 2.
Any Chemical listed in Column 2 of Schedule 3, as per provisions given below;
HAZCHEM CODES:The HAZCHEM code system was developed by the British Fire Service for use
on vehicles transporting dangerous substances. It consists or either two or three characters. The
first character is a numeral in the range of 1 to 4.
Personnel Protection – 1The letter P, R, W or X indicate that a full chemical suit and breathing
apparatus should be warn. 2. The letters S, T, Y & Z indicate that breathing apparatus need only
be warn if the substances are involved in a fire.
Contain or dilute – The letters P, R, S, & T indicate dilution while W X Y & Z indicate containment.
The third character when appearing is E indicates that evacuation of persons in the neighboring
areas must be taken into consideration.
IGNITION TEMPERATURE:This is the minimum temperature at which the material will ignite
without a spark or flame being present. Along with the values in 6.1 and 6.2 above, it gives an
indication of the relative flammability of the chemical. It is sometimes called “auto ignition
temperature”.
LC50 (LETHAL CONCENTRATION):Lethal Concentration level for air Bourne toxic substance.
LD50 (LETHAL DOSE):The term LD50 signifies that about 50% of the animals given the specified
dose by mouth will die. Thus for a grade 4 chemical (below 50 mg/kg) the toxic dose for 50% of
animals weighting 70 kg (150 lb) is 70 50 = 3, 500 mg=3.5 gr or less than 1 tea spoonful, it might
be as little as a few drops. For a Grade 1 chemical (5 to 15 g/kg) the LD50 would be between a
pint and a quart for a 150 lb man.
LOCAL CRISIS GROUP (LCG):It is body constituted by Government, in the industrial pocked to
deal with chemical accidents and co-ordinate efforts in planning, preparedness and mitigation of
chemical accidents.
MAJOR ACCIDENT:Major Accident means an incident involving loss of the life inside or outside
the site or ten or more injuries inside and/or one or more injuries outside or release of toxic
chemical or explosion or fire of spillage of hazardous chemical result in ‘On Site’ or ‘Off Site’
emergencies or damage too equipment leading to stoppage of process or adverse effects to the
environment. (Ref. 1Rule 68(J)(1)(d) of Gujarat Factories Rules 1963(2004), 2. Rule 2(j) of
Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989. 3. Rule 2(f) of Chemical
Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness & Response) Rule, 1996).
MAJOR ACCIDENT HAZARDOUS (MAH) INSTALL ION:Isolated storage and industrial activity
at a site, handling (including transport through carrier or pipeline) of hazardous chemicals equal to
or in excess of the threshold quantities specified in column 3 of Schedule 2 and 3 respectively.
Ref:Rule 2(g) of Chemical Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness & Response) Rule1996.
OFF-SITE EMERGENCY PLAN:The objective of an Off Site Emergency Plan is to protect the life
and property of the neighborhood areas of the industrial unit. Off Site Emergency Plan shall be
prepared by Government Authorities as per Rule 14 of MSIHC Rules 1989 and follow the
instruction under provision of CA(EPPR) Rules 1996.
POOL FIRE:A pool of flammable liquid burning with a stationary diffusion flame
RESPONSE:The efforts to minimize the risks created in an emergency by protecting the people,
the environment and the property, and the efforts to return the scene to normal pre-emergency
conditions. Persons who perform the various response functions are termed “RESPONDERS”.
SENSITIVE POPULATIONS:Groups of people that may be more susceptible than the general
population to the toxic effects of the release due to pre-existing health condition (patients in
hospitals, pregnant women etc.) or age (elderly people infants, handicaps).
SMC (SITE MAN CONTROLLER): He is overall responsible for directing operations & decides the
actions, consulting with incident controller &seniors, and handle &control the emergency.
SHORT – TERM INHALATION LIMIT (STEL):The parts of vapour (gas) per million parts of
contaminated air by volume at 25OC (77OF) and at one atmosphere of pressure is given. The limits
are given in milligrams per cubic meter for chemical that form a fine mist or dust. The values given
are the maximum permissible average exposures for the time periods specified.
SPECIFIC GRAVITY:The specific Gravity of a chemicals is the ratio of the weight of the solid or
liquid to the weight of an equal volume of water at 4OC (or at some other specified temperature) If
the specific gravity is less than 1.0 (or less than 1.03 in sea water) the chemical will float, if higher
it will sink.
TLV (THRESHOLD LIMIT VALUE):TLV refer to airborne concentration of substances. There are
three categories of TLV.
TLV – for gases and vapour is usually expressed in PPM. (Part of the gas/vapour/million parts of
air)
TOXIC CLOUD:Air borne mass of gases, vapours, fumes, dust or aerosols of toxic materials.
TOXICITY:The ability of a substance to cause damage to living tissue, impairment of the central
nervous system, serve illness or death when ingested, inhaled or absorbed by the skin.
VAPOUR CLOUD:Air borne dispersing hazardous vapours, which may or may not be visible as a
“Cloud”
As per the EIA Notification dated September 14th 2006, the proposed project falls in Schedule 5(f)
and B category.
Although the project is of Category “B”, requires public hearing as GIDC Dahej is declared Notified
Industrial Estate in 2009 and as per circular number J-11013/36/2014- IA-I dated 10th December,
2014 from MoEF, public hearing is required in those industrial area which are notified after
September 14th 2006.
The purpose of this Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report for Croda to:
The contents of EIA report are based on the latest applicable rules and regulation, notification and
final Terms of Reference (ToR) prescribed for the project by the SEIAA, Gujarat.
The EIA report has been prepared based on the field studies and relevant analysis carried out by
Kadam Environmental Consultants (‘Kadam”). Details about Kadam’s accreditations and team
members are provided in Chapter 12 of this report.
Croda International is a global leader in speciality chemicals. Croda was formed in Yorkshire,
England in 1925 to make lanolin, effective rust preventive. Croda is firmly established as a global
leader in natural based speciality chemicals and well placed to meet the challenges of the twenty
first century.Croda has a number of manufacturing facilities around the world, notably in countries
like the UK, USA, Singapore, Brazil, Japan, India and France.
Croda India Company Pvt. Ltd. is 100% subsidiary of Croda International Plc and is responsible
for sales and marketing of all Croda products in the Indian subcontinent.
Croda India Company Pvt. Ltd.is an ISO 9001, ISO14001 & OHSAS 18001 certified company and is
located at Plot No. 1/1 Part, TTC Industrial area, Koparkhairne, Navi Mumbai 400 710.
Croda India is responsible for manufacturing as well as sales & marketing of Croda products in the
Indian subcontinent, servicing a range of industries, including personal care, health
care/nutritional, home care, polymer additives, textiles, fibers, polymers & coatings,
agrochemicals, lubricants and general industrial applications. The product range also includes
specialty products made by group companies Sederma and Crodarom, which are mainly used in
personal care applications.
The proposed project is green field project for installation of facilities for manufacturing of
varieties of speciality products. The proposed project will be located at Plot No. D2/ CH 21, Dahej
Phase II,GIDC, Taluka Vagra, Dist Bharuch. The estimated cost of the proposed project is INR 250
Crores. Total plot area is 1,00,000 m2. The detailed production capacities are given as below
inTable 1-1.
1.3 Brief Description of Nature, Size, Location of the Project and its
Importance to Country, Region
The proposed project is plans to set up a new plant for manufacturing 60,000 MT/annum of
manufacturing of varieties of specialty products at the new site in Dahej. The estimated cost of
the proposed project is INR ~ 250 crores, to be implemented in a phase wise manner.
The proposed project will cover a plot area of 1,00,000 m2. The Production capacities are as
mentioned inTable 1-1.
1.3.3 Location
The proposed project is located at plot no. D2/CH 21 of GIDC Dahej, Phase II in Bharuch District
of Gujarat state. Photographs showing the project site are presented inPhotograph 1-1.
Railway line adjacent to project site in North Photo showing distance of project boundary
direction from railway track
Croda India offers its customers a unique combination of various technology platforms, product
development skills and applications expertise and market knowledge. Company has developed
application expertise and an underlying diversified portfolio of products that cut across virtually all
types of industries varying from textiles, fibre processing, health and personal care, lubricants,
polymerization, resin emulsification, crop protection and others. Supported by an application
research and manufacturing facilities, the business has established an image of quality supplier
and is the market leader in the above segments.
Croda manufactures a uniquely broad portfolio of speciality chemical products. These provide
enhanced functionality when used as ingredients or processing aids for a cross section of
industries which includes consumer care manufacturing personal care products for Skin care, sun
care, hair care, baby care, colour cosmetics, male grooming, bath and shower and antiperspirants
etc.
Croda also markets the industrial specialties products used in home care like ingredients for
laundry, household, industrial and institutional cleaning applications, as well as for wipes, tissues,
nappies and hygiene articles. The products marketed as process additives include ingredients for
use in a range of market applications including rubber, candles, textiles, and surfactants. The
Polymer Additives are the products used for specialty effects for industrial and consumer plastics,
packaging and rubber applications.
Croda also markets environmentally friendly, high performance solutions to paint formulators,
resin manufacturers and additive producers that include a range of speciality surfactants.
The products marketed as lubricant additives includes ingredients based on renewable materials to
automotive and industrial markets that have multi-functional esters, polyalkylene glycols and
speciality lubricant additive products deliver high performance, energy efficient solutions to meet
the challenging demands of the lubricant industry.
The Indian economy is currently the eighth largest in the world with a GDP of approximately £1
trillion. It has been growing at an average of 8% for the past 5 years and is forecast to continue
to grow at 5 to 6% over the next few years across all sectors. Though there are some concerns
like inflation, rising costs and infrastructure constraints, the growth momentum is expected to
continue.
The economic buoyancy is expected to generate opportunities across segments for Croda India.
There is a growing middle class and a small but even more rapidly growing higher income group.
A shift towards premium and efficacious products makes the opportunity for speciality ingredients
even more attractive. Alkoxylates and Esters categories are particularly growing fast in current
market.
For reasons such as- lack of space for future expansion at Thane, proximity to EO source etc, it is
important to develop Dahej site for future capacity expansion.
1.4.1 Investment
Around ~ 500 jobs will be direct and contractual employees created by the setting up of the
project during its operational lifecycle.
During the construction and Execution phase of the project, it is estimated that about ~300
workers will be involved. In addition, ancillary job creation will take place, as happens in all
industries including for: transportation, facilities management, testing and calibration, security and
similar services.
2 Presentation for Terms of References (ToR) for EIA study at SEAC, Gujarat 12th May 2015
4 Receipt of ToR Letter from SEAC, Gujarat 7th July 2015
As per the ToR letter issued by the SEAC, attached asAnnexure 1.The scope of work for this EIA
included collection of baseline data with respect to major environmental components, viz. air,
noise, water, land, biological and socio-economic components for one season.
This EIA report complies with the Terms of Reference issued by the Expert Appraisal Committee
(EAC), SEAC Gujarat. Summarized details of the same are provided inTable 1-3.
S.
ToR Point ToR Action Plan
No.
Waste water generation, Treatment and disposal
Segregation of waste streams and details on
12 details are given in Chapter 2, Section 2.13.2
specific treatment and disposal of each stream.
to 2.13.4, Page 61 to 64
Submit action Plan for minimization of waste
Water conservation measures are given in
13 water discharge by maximum reuse / recycle of
Chapter 2, Section 2.13.5, Page 68
treated waste water.
Details of ETP including dimensions of each unit
along with schematic flow diagram. Inlet,
transitional and treated effluent qualities with
specific efficiency of each treatment unit in
reduction in respect of all concerned/regulated Details of ETP are given in Chapter 2, Section
14
environmental parameters. Inlet effluent quality 2.13.4, Page 64
should be based on worst case scenario
considering production of most polluting products
that can be manufactured in the plant
concurrently.
Copy of permission letter with quantity from the Copy of permission letter with quantity from the
authority of GIDC drainage -network, Dahej authority of GIDC drainage for disposal of treated
15
regarding confirmation for spare capacity available water is giving in Chapter 2, Figure 2-11,
to take additional effluent load in GlDC drainage. Page 63
Proposal to provide and maintain separate electric
Noted and will be provided separate electrical
meter, operational logbook for effluent treatment
16 meter, flow meter and maintain separate logbook
systems, online meters for monitoring of flow, pH,
for ETP.
TOC/COD, etc. of effluent discharge.
Application wise break-up of effluent quantity to
be recycled / reused in various application Like
Water balance diagram is given in Chapter 2,
sprinkling for dust control and green belt
Figure 2-10, Page 62
development etc. ln case of land application,
Also Separate line for effluent drains with side
17 details on availability of sufficient open land for
barriers will be provided to avoid any
utilizing effluent for plantation / gardening. How it
contamination of surface water sources during
will be ensured that treated effluent won't flow
rainy season.
outside the premises linked with storm water
during high rainy days.
The ETP scheme is suggested by setting best
Economical and technical viability of the effluent techno commercial option of treatment and
18
treatment system. which is covered under Section 2.13.4 of
Chapter 2 on Page 64
Plans for management, collection and disposal of
Adequate storage will be provided to store
waste streams to be generates from spillage,
effluent generated from the various areas during
19 leakages, vessel washing, used container washing
any unavoidable circumstances. Also plant shall
etc. Measures proposed for preventing effluent
be shut down during this type of situation
discharge during unforeseen circumstances.
Separate electric meter will be provided at ETP.
Undertaking stating that a separate electric meter
20 Undertaking is given in Annexure 13, Page
will be provided for the ETP.
319
One season Site-specific micro-meteorological
data using temperature, relative humidity, hourly Site specific micro-meteorological data are given
21
wind speed and direction and rainfall should be in Chapter 3, Section 3.7, Page 84
incorporated.
Anticipated environmental impacts due to the Anticipated environment impacts due to
22
proposed project/production may be evaluated for proposed project are given in Chapter 4, Page
S.
ToR Point ToR Action Plan
No.
significance and based on corresponding likely 121
impacts VECs (valued Environmental Components)
may be identified. Baseline studies may be
conducted within the study area of 5 km for all
the concerned/identified VECs and likely impacts,
likely impacts have to be assessed for their
magnitude in order to identify mitigation
measures.
Monitoring has been carried out in Winter Season
One complete season base line ambient air 2014-15.
quantity data (except monsoon) to be given along We have done additional one month ambient air
with the dates of monitoring. The parameters to monitoring at all location in June 2015.
be covered shall be in accordance with the revised Sampling locations of AAQ is given in Chapter
National Ambient Air Quality Standards as well as 3,Table 3-8, Page 88
project specific parameters Like NH3, HCI etc. Analysis results of AAQ monitoring are given in
Locations of the monitoring stations should be so Table 3-9, Page 90 and Table 3-10, Page 92
23 decided so as to take into consideration the pre- Detailed base line ambient air quality data is
dominant downwind direction. Population zone given in Annexure 6along with the dates of
and sensitive receptors. There should be at least monitoring.
one monitoring station in the upwind direction. Wind-rose diagram is given in Figure 3-2, Page
There should be at least one monitoring station in 87
the pre dominant downwind direction at a location IMD data of Bharuch District are given
where maximum ground level concentration is inAnnexure 7, Page 277
likely to occur. National Ambient Air Quality Standards are given
in Annexure 9, Page 312
Modeling indicating the likely impact on ambient
air quality due to proposed activities. The details
of model used and input parameters used for
Modeling indicating the likely impact on ambient
modelling should be provided. The air quality
air quality due to proposed activities and details
contours may be shown on location map clearly
of model used and input parameters used for
indicating the location of sensitive receptors, if
modeling is provided in Chapter 4, Section
24 any, and the habitation. The wind rose showing
4.4.3, Page 140
pre-dominant wind direction should also be
Dispersion modelling results and Isopleths for
indicated on the map. Impact due to vehicular
PM, SO2, NOx and NH3 are given in Annexure
movement shall also be included into the
8, Page 287
prediction using suitable model. Results of Air
dispersion modeling should be superimposed on
google map / geographical area map.
Baseline monitoring for noise environment is
Base line status of the noise environment, impact given in Chapter 3, Section 3.9, Page 94 and
of noise on present environment due to the impact of noise on present environment due to
25
project and proposed measures for noise the project and proposed measures for noise
reduction including engineering controls. reduction including engineering controls are
given in chapter 4, Section 4.5, Page 144
26 Specific details of
Process gas emission from each unit process with Details of process gas emission are given in
i
its quantification, Chapter 2, Section 2.15.2, Page 72
Air pollution control Measures proposed for
Air pollution control Measures proposed for
ii process gas emission are given in Chapter 2,
process gas emission,
Section 2.15.3, Page 73
iii Adequacy of the air pollution control measures for SufficientAir Pollution Control measures systems
S.
ToR Point ToR Action Plan
No.
process gas emission, measures to achieve the are provided on process vents and adequate
GPCB norms stack height is provided at flue gas stacks to
meet GPCB norms.
Utilities are given in Chapter 2, Section 2.12,
iv Details of the utilities required
Page 58
Type and quantity of fuel to be used for each Fuel details are given in Chapter 2, Section
v
utility 2.14, Page 72
Flue gas emission rate is given in Chapter 4,
vi Flue gas emission rate from each utility
Table 4-7, Page 139
Air Pollution Control Measures proposed to each
Air Pollution Control Measures proposed to each
vii of the utility are given in Chapter 2, Section
of the utility along with its adequacy
2.15.3, Page 73
As there will be closed system from storage of
raw material to packing of products, there will be
List the sources of fugitive emission along with its minimal chances of fugitive emission. At the
viii quantification and proposed measures to control same, minor fugitive emission will be connected
it. to different scrubber. At the detectors will be
provided in processing and storage area for key
pollutants.
Fuel (Natural Gas) will be sourced from M/s.
A confirmed fuel linkage along with the supportive
Gujarat State Petroleum Corporation Limited
27 documents of long term supply of fuel for the
(GSPCL). Agreement between Croda and GSPCL
project requirements should be provided
is given in Annexure 10, Page 314
Details on management the hazardous wastes be
generated from the project stating detail of
storage area for each type of waste, its handling.
Its utilization and disposal-etc. How the manual Details of solid and hazardous waste are given in
28
handling of the hazardous wastes will be Chapter 2, Section 2.16, Page 74
minimized. Methodology of de-contamination and
disposal of discarded containers and its record
keeping.
Croda has also explored Explore the possibilities
for Co-processing of the hazardous waste prior to
Explore the possibilities for Co-processing of the disposal into TSDF/CHWIF and has taken
29 hazardous waste prior to disposal into acceptance letter from M/s. Ambuja Cement for
TSDF/CHWIF. co-processing the hazardous waste. Copy of
acceptance letter is given in Chapter 2, Figure
2-15, Page 76
Membership of Common Environmental
Membership of BEIL is given in Chapter 2,
30 Infrastructure including the TSDF/ Common
Figure 2-14, Page 76
Incineration Facility, If any.
Complete management plan of the byproducts &
spent acids which are recyclable/reusable within
Not applicable as there will be no generation of
31 the premises and all the relevant details of by
byproducts & spent acids.
products & spent acids which are not recyclable /
reusable within the premises.
Name and address of end consumers to whom
any hazardous waste / by-product will be sold.
Not applicable as there will not be generation of
32 Copies of agreement / MoU Letter of intent from
by-production.
them, showing their willingness to purchase said
waste / by-produce from the proposed project.
S.
ToR Point ToR Action Plan
No.
Name and quantity of each type of solvents to be Solvents used such as Calcium salt of Alkyl
used for proposed production. Details of solvent Benzene Sulphonate (CABS), Iso Propyl Alcohol
33 recovery system including mass balance solvent (IPA), N-Butanol are part of formulation and
loss, recovery efficiency feasibility of reusing the spent solvent will not be generated. Hence
recovered solvents etc. for each type of solvent. solvent recovery is not given.
A detailed EMP including the Protection and
Detailed EMP including protection and mitigation
Mitigation measures for Impact on human health
measures are given in Chapter 10.
and environment as well as detailed monitoring
Environmental Monitoring Programme is given in
plan and environmental management cell
Chapter 6.
proposed for implementation and monitoring of
Water conservation method is given Chapter 2,
34 EMP. The EMP should also include the concept of
Section 2.13.5, Page 68
waste-minimization, recycle/reuse/recover
Total capital cost and recurring cost/annum
techniques, energy conservation, and natural
earmarked for environment pollution control
resource conservation. Total capital cost and
measures are given in Chapter 10, Section
recurring cost/annum earmarked for environment
10.10, Page 229
pollution control measures.
Permission from PESO for EO & PO storage are
Permission from PESO, Nagpur tor storage of
35 attached as Annexure 3&Annexure 4
solvents, other toxic chemicals, if any.
respectively.
Occupational health impacts on the workers and
Required safety measures will be taken to ensure
mitigation measures proposed to avoid the human
that chemicals will remain well within the
health hazards along with the personal protective
PEL/TLV. Regular medical checkup will be carried
equipment to be provided. Provision of industrial
out to monitor the health.
hygienist and monitoring of the occupational
36 Detailed occupational health management plan is
injury to workers as well as impact on the
provided in Chapter 7, Section 7.5.2, Page
workers. Plan for periodic medical checkup of the
211
workers exposed. Details of work place ambient
Disaster Management Plan is given in Chapter
air quality monitoring plan as per Gujarat
7, Section 7.4, Page 198
Factories Rules.
Out of the processes under consideration,
following chemicals Methylamines and
Acetonitrile can be considered as VOC.
However, all of these chemicals are extremely
soluble in water. All the plants will be operated
as a closed system and will be completely
Details on volatile organic compounds (VOCs) automated with different layers of protection and
37 from the plant operations safety interlocks. Because of this, fugitive
safety and health protection measures. emissions will be very unlikely. Still, each plant
will have a dedicated vent header connected to a
well-designed two stage Water Scrubber
designed to completely absorb any VOC. Since all
the VOCs are completely soluble in water, there
will minimum fugitive emission to atmosphere
within permissible limit.
Risk assessment including prediction of the worst-
List of hazardous chemicals along with quantity
case scenario and maximum credible accident
and properties is given in Chapter 2, Table
Scenarios should be carried out. The worst-case
2-9, Page 53
scenario should take into account the maximum
38 Storage details is given Chapter 2, Table 2-10
inventory of storage at site at any point of time.
and Table 2-11, Page 54
The risk contours should be plotted on the plant
Onsite emergency plan for same chemical unit is
layout map clearly showing which of the facilities
given in Chapter 7, Section 7.4, Page 198
would be affected in case of an accident taking
S.
ToR Point ToR Action Plan
No.
place. Based on the same proposed safeguard
measures including On-
Site / Off-Site Emergency Plan should be
provided.
Properties of all the chemicals are given in
Chapter 2, Table 2-9, Page 53
39 MSDS of all the products and raw materials.
MSDS of all the products and raw materials are
given in soft copy (CD).
Details of hazardous characteristics and toxicity of
raw materials and products to be handled and the Characteristics of raw material and products will
40 control measures proposed to ensure safety and identified from MSDS is given in Chapter 2,
avoid the human health impacts. This shall include Table 2-9, Page 53
the details of Antidotes also.
Details of quantity of each hazardous chemical
(including solvents) to be stored, Material of
Construction of major hazardous chemical storage
Details of hazardous chemical or solvent stored
tanks, dyke details, threshold storage quantity as
with MOC of storage tanks, dyke details,
per schedules of the Manufacture, Storage &
41 threshold storage quantity, size of the biggest
import of hazardous Chemicals Rules of major
storage are given in Chapter 7, Table 7-6,
hazardous chemicals, size of the biggest storage
Page 180
tank to be provided for each raw material &
product etc. How the manual handling of the
hazardous chemicals will be minimized?
Details of the separate isolated storage area for
flammable chemicals. Details of flame proof Separate storage of raw materials and hazardous
electrical fittings, DCP extinguishers and other chemicals are provided in area 947 m2
safety measures proposed. Detailed fire control Flame proof electrical fittings will be provided.
42
plan for flammable substances and processes Details of extinguishers and other safety
showing hydrant pipeline network, provision of DG measures are provided in Chapter 7, Section
Sets, fire pumps, jockey pump, toxic gas detectors 7.4.5, Page 208
etc.
Submit checklist in the form of Do's & Don'ts of
preventive maintenance strengthening of HSE, Checklists of Do’s & Don’ts are given in Chapter
43
manufacturing utility staff for safety related 7, Table 7-25, Page 211
measures.
Detailed five year greenbelt development program
including annual budget, types &number of trees Detailed five year greenbelt development
to be planted, area under green belt development program including annual budget, types
(with map), budgetary outlay; along with &number of trees to be planted, area under
44
commitment of the management to carry out the green belt development [with map], budgetary
tree plantation activities outside the premises at outlay are given in Chapter 10, Section
appropriate places in the nearby areas and 10.6.1, Page 224
elsewhere.
Detailed socio-economic development measures
Detailed socio-economic development measures
including community welfare program most
including community welfare program most useful
useful in the project area for the overall
in the project area for the overall improvement of
improvement of the environment are given in
the environment. Submit a detailed plan for social
45 Chapter 4, Section 4.11, Page 161
corporate responsibilities, with appropriate
Detailed plan for social corporate responsibilities,
budgetary provisions for the next five years and
with appropriate budgetary provisions for the
activities proposed to be carried out, specific to
next five years and activities proposed to be
the current demographic status of the area.
carried out are given in Chapter 4, Section
S.
ToR Point ToR Action Plan
No.
4.11.1, Page 163
A tabular chart for the issues raised and
addressed during public hearing/consultation and
commitment of the project proponent on the
46 same should be provided. An action plan to Will be incorporated after public hearing
address the issues to be raised during public
hearing and the necessary allocation of funds for
the same should be provided.
(a) Does the company have a well laid down
Environment Policy approved by its Board of
Directors? if so, it may be detailed in the IA
report. (b). Does the Environment Policy prescribe Policy of Croda is given in Annexure 12, Page
47
for standard operating process / procedures to 318
bring into focus any infringement / deviation /
violation of the environmental or forest norms /
conditions ? lf so, it may be detailed in the EIA.
What is the hierarchical system or administrative
order of the company to deal with the Environment management cell will be provided
48 environmental issues and for ensuring compliance and details are given in Chapter 10, Section
with the EC conditions? Details of this system may 10.9, Page 229
be given.
Does the company have a system of reporting of
non-compliances / violations of environmental
Environment management cell will be provided
norms lo the Board of Directors of the company
49 and details are given in Chapter 10, Section
and / or shareholders or stakeholders at large?
10.9, Page 229
This reporting mechanism should be detailed in
the EIA Report.
Certificate of accreditation issued by the NABET, Certificate of accreditation issued by the NABET,
50 QCI to the environmental consultant should be QCI to the environmental consultant is attached
incorporated in the EIA Report. as Annexure 17, Page 405
A tabular chart with index for point-wise
51 Provided in Chapter 1, Table 1-3, Page 31
compliance of above-ToRs.
2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION
As customers continue to invest in new capacities, with current market demand projections, Croda
Thane site capacities will be running full in coming 3-5 years. Any disruption in material supply due
to capacity constraint will be business detrimental.
It is therefore proposed to expand manufacturing capacities at Dahej site. This will cater to the
increasing needs of our customers.
2.2.1 Location (maps showing general location, specific location, project boundary &
project site layout)
Proposed project is located at Plot No. D-2/CH 21 of GIDC Dahej, Phase II in District Bharuch of
Gujarat State. The general location of the proposed project in India is presented inFigure 2-1.
Map showing the project boundary is shown asFigure 2-2, whereas the site co-ordinates are
shown inTable 2-1. Similarly the site layout map is presented as Figure 2-3and area breakup at
site is given inTable 2-2.
By Road
SH 6 is the main approach road from Bharuch to Project site. It is six lane state highway from
Bharuch up to Dahej, lies at an aerial distance of 2.66 km towards S direction. It further goes
towards Amod via Dahej &Gandhar, commonly known as Dahej-Amod road lies at aerial distance
of 2.55 km towards WNW direction. Site is located between two village roads. One connects SH6
to Vadadla – Vav and Kadodra villages passing from E direction of the site and SH-6 crossing at
Jolva to Vav and Kadodra villages passing from W direction of the proposed site location. Dahej
Village is main center of this industrial region, at an aerial distance of about 6.0 km towards SW
direction from proposed project site. Vagra is a Taluka HQ village at an aerial distance of about
23.0 km towards NE direction from site. Dahej is well connected to Bharuch by State Transport
Buses and Private vehicles.
By Rail
Site is also approachable by railway which connected Bharuch and Dahej via Samni& Vagra. This
railway line passing through NW to SW direction from project site. Dahej is nearest railway station
at an aerial distance of about 6.10 km towards SW direction from project site. District Head
Quarter Bharuch is a Major railway station lies on Mumbai-Vadodara mainline, at an aerial distance
of about 37.0 km towards ESE direction from projects site. Bharuch is well connected with various
parts of the country.
By Air
Nearest domestic airport from proposed project site is located at Vadodara, at an aerial distance of
about 95 km towards NE direction. Vadodara is well connected with Mumbai and Delhi with daily
multiple flights.
By Water
Dahej is a port Village lies on the Bay of Cambay, having a small jetty under maritime board. It is
situated 10.2 km towards W direction from project site. There are several other private jetties
developed by industries.
These are manufactured in different batch plants - processes and technologies for which are
based on in-house designs and know-how. These are optimized for safety, productivity and energy
efficiency, wherever possible. In addition, there are in compliance with Croda Group's internal
stringent RGP (relevant good practices) and Directives in various areas - which are adaptation of
Best Available Technology in relevant areas. Design, implementation and maintenance of these are
audit by Croda Group periodically in addition to audit by third party against OHSAS 18001, ISO
14001 and ISO 9001.
Few examples of Best Available Technologies are Storage and Transpiration of Ethylene Oxide,
used of renewable energy for water heating, process optimization, washing matrix for waste
reduction without compromising washing efficacy.
Process Description
Ethylene Oxide (EO) and / or Propylene Oxide (PO), react with compounds containing a labile
hydrogen atom to form nonionic surfactants containing a hydroxy ethyl and / or a 2-Hydroxy
propyl group.
Reaction Chemistry
Oxide (Catalyst)
CH3 CH3
/ /
Oxide (Catalyst)
Product (B)
Process Description
Esterification is the general name for a chemical reaction in which two reactants (typically an
alcohol and an acid) form an ester as the reaction product.
Since esterification is highly reversible, the yield of the ester can be improved using Le Chatelier's
principle:
Using a dehydrating agent: sulfuric acid not only catalyzes the reaction but sequesters water (a
reaction product).
Removal of water by physical means such as distillation as a low-boiling azeotrope with toluene, in
conjunction with a Dean-Stark apparatus.
Based on different reacting alcohols and acid groups, a range of Esters with different applications
can be produced.
Process Description
The chemistry of sulphation involves the reaction of fatty alcohols with Sulphating agent (such as
chlorosulphonic acid) and the resulting alcohol sulphate gets neutralised with sodium hydroxide
yielding the desired surfactant which is anionic. The hydrochloric acid generated in the reaction is
neutralised with caustic solution in the scrubber.
Sulphonation involve a different sulphating agent (such as Sulphuric acid). A typical reaction takes
place in multiple phases namely- Sulphonation, condensation with agent like Formaldehyde
solution, neutralization with ammonia/caustic. Final product is then filtered and filled for sale.
A range of these products are blended with other ingredients to produce finished goods with
specific application. A few of these are dried to supply final product in powder form.
4 Water 0.570
7 Additives 0.001
Total 1.000
Output/MT of Product
S.
Liquid Air Solid Remarks
No. Product Recovery
Effluent Emission Waste
1 Sulphonation Product - - 0.981 - Product
2 Sox and HCl - 0.016 - - To caustic Scrubber
3 Solid Waste - - - 0.003 To TSDF / CHWIF
0 0.016 0.981 0.003
Total
1.000
Phosphorous pentoxide (P2O5) is a commonly used phosphating agent for long chain fatty
alcohols/esters and their ethoxylates resulting in almost equimolecular amounts of mono- and
diesters and only a very small amount of orthophosphoric acid is produced. Some unreacted
stearyl alcohol is also present. The reaction mass is neutralized with caustic potash to give the
final product as the potassium salt of the phosphate esters.
OH
OH
Etoxylated fatty
Phosphorous Pentoxide Phosphated fatty glyceride ethoxylate +
glyceride
OH
OH
O O
// //
P2O5 + 3 ROH HO – P – OH + HO – P - OR
\ \
OR OR
Process Description
1. Liquid blends
2. Paste blends, and
3. Blends for crop emulsions
All the blended products are made by mixing various raw materials with / without incorporation of
intermediate/s in the composition. As far as chemistry is concerned, there may or may not be any
chemical reaction but method of mixing is very important. Apart from the quantities of the
ingredients, their mode of incorporation and sequence of addition play a decisive role in the
quality of the product.
Based on blends of anionics e.g., calcium salt of linear alkylbenzene sulphonate (CABS) and
nonionics, e.g., nonylphenol ethoxylates (Lubrol NPs), the latter presumably acting as a
hydrophile. The hydrophobe, also known as the emulsifiable concentrate (EC), is an water-in-oil
emulsion.
Lubricant Esters
Croda has various lubricant esters developed from renewable resources. Renewable starting
materials like Neopentyl glycol, Pentaerythritol. Various factors have been considered while
developing these products like Biodegradability, Clean burn, Good lubricity, high renewable
content, high thermal and oxidative stability, hydrolytic stability.
Process technology used in manufacturing of those esters uses catalysts which needs no or
low downstream processing, lower energy consumption. Thus it generates very less amount
of waste and lesser carbon foot print.
Personal Care
Croda has broad range of speciality ingredients used in personal care segment. As stated
above starting point of most of the ingredients are fatty acids, fatty alcohols from natural oils.
For e.g. Croda has developed phosphate esters based moisturizing agent.
It is believed that phosphate esters are naturally substantive and mild to skin due to the
similarity of their chemical configuration to phospholipids which are important constituents of
cell membranes.
The use of a phosphate ester based emulsion as a vehicle for this type of moisturizing active
has already been documented. The product has been developed has characteristics like
phospholipid-like structure, naturally substantive to skin, conditioned after feel, versatile oil-in-
water emulsifier, exhibits shear thinning (thixotropic), greater oil phase deposition, phase
inversion contributes to greater stability, Greater stability at high pH.
The manufacturing process used in the manufacture of above phosphate ester has no by-
product, no downstream processing is required hence zero waste.
Proposed Mode of
S. No. Name Source
(Kg/Year) Transport
2.12.1 Power
The power requirement for the proposed facility will be met through Gujarat State Electricity
Corporation Limited (GSECL). Total estimated electrical load for the proposed manufacturing unit is
around 2000 kVA.
Emergency Power:
2 Nos. ofDG Sets having capacity of1000 kVA will be installed as power back up during grid failure.
Fresh water will be sourced from GIDC water supply system. Total water consumption for the
proposed manufacturing facility will be 459 KLD out of which 158 KLD will be recycled water and 301
KLD will be fresh water consumption.
GIDC has laid down a pipeline for disposal of treated waste water up to deep sea. Croda has taken
membership of that drainage line for disposal of 69 KLD treated waste water.
Source of water supply is surface water i.e. Narmada water which is available from GIDC Dahej. GIDC
will supply required water to Croda India Company Pvt. Ltd. Letter from GIDC for water supply is
shown in Figure 2-9.
2.13.2 Water Consumption and Waste Water Generation for Proposed Unit
In the proposed specialty chemicals manufacturing unit, the water will be mainly used for following
areas:
Process
Utilities
Domestic Usage
Washing, Scrubbing and
Gardening
Total water consumption will be 459 KLD for the entire plant. Out of which 301 KLD will be sourced
from GIDC water supply and 158 KLD will be recycled and reused as RO permeate.
Waste water generation will be 227 KLD which will be sent to ETP for treatment and further subjected
to recycling RO. RO reject of 69 KLD would be disposed through GIDC effluent drainage system.
Domestic wastewater of 25 KLD will be treated separately in STP and treated sewage will be used for
on land irrigation.
The breakup of water consumption and wastewater generation from the proposed unit is described
inTable 2-14and water balance diagram is shown in Figure 2-10.
1 Domestic 30 25 To STP
2 Softener 120 10
i Cooling Tower 110 8
3 DM Plant 119 10
i Boiler 75 75
To ETP
ii Process 34 9
4 Washings (Vessel, Drum, floor etc.) 100 100
6 Scrubbing 13 13
7 QC Lab 2 2
To GIDC Drain for Sea
8 RO Reject - 69
Disposal
9 Gardening 75 0 -
The treated effluent (RO Reject) form the ETP followed by RO will be discharged into GIDC
drain ultimately meet to sea. GIDC has given permission to CRODA for effluent discharged
into GIDC drain up to 120 KLD. The permission letter from the GIDC for effluent discharge
into drain is shown in Figure 2-11.
The sewage generated from the domestic use will be treated in STP at site and treated
sewage water will be reused for greenbelt development.
Figure 2-11: Agreement Letter with GIDC for Treated Wastewater Discharged into GIDC
drain for Phase-I
The effluents generation will take place from various areas such as:
Process
Domestic use
Utility Blow downs
Washings, scrubbing etc.
The total wastewater generation from the plant premises will be about 252 KLD including
industrial effluent and domestic sewage.
The effluent generated from the various areas such as process, utilities blow downs, washings and
scrubbing water will be treated in the proposed ETP (Design flow 300 KLD) at site followed by RO
while the domestic sewage will be separately treated in proposed STP (Design Flow of 30 KLD).
The wastewater generated from the manufacturing process and other utility areas are described
below.
+ backwashes
at Inlet of ETP
Process Water
Cooling Tower
Regeneration
DM Rejects +
Waste water
+ Washing+
Blow downs
Boiler Blow
Blow down
Particulars
Scrubbing
Combined
Softener
down
S. No
Unit
Lab
The design base inlet and outlet characteristics of the wastewater are presented in below table.
The ETP of 250 KLD capacity will be proposed for treatment of wastewater coming from the
various areas of project site.
Equalization Tank
Flash Mixer
Primary Treatment
Flocculator
Primary Clarifier
Feed Tank
1st Stage Aeration Tank
Secondary Clarifier Secondary Biological Treatment
2nd Stage Aeration Tank
Final Clarifier
Intermediate Collection Tank
Pressure Sand Filter
Tertiary Treatment
Activated Carbon Filter
Final Collection Tank
Sludge Collection Sump
Sludge Handling Unit
Filter Press
RO Feed Tank
RO Permeate Tank RO System/Advance Tertiary Treatment
RO Reject Tank
Collection tank
MBBR Tank
Secondary settling Tank
Intermediate Collection Tank
Final Collection Tank
Sludge Drying Bed
Equalization Tank
Equalization tank is provided to maintain pH & to ensure constant load on further treatment units.
Lime and alum dosing will be carried out in equalization tank to maintain alkaline pH and for better
floc formation. Blower with course bubble aeration will be provided in the equalization tanks for
mixing and equalization. From these tanks the effluents will be further transferred to flash mixer
by pumping.
Flash Mixer
Wastewater from equalization tank flows to a flash mixer where polyelectrolyte will be added for
agglomeration and flocculation. From flash mixer the wastewater will go to primary settling tank
under gravity.
Flocculator
Wastewater from Flash mixer overflows to a flocculator where polyelectrolyte will be added for
agglomeration and flocculation. Slow speed paddle type flocculator mechanism will be provided in
this tank for gentle mixing and flocc formation. Flocculated effluent will go to primary settling tank
under gravity.
The process block diagram of proposed wastewater treatment systems is presented in Figure 2-12.
Adequate measures shall be taken to reduce fresh water demand by following measures.
1. Explore the possibility of condensate recovery from the boiler which will reduce the overall
water demand.
2. Use of equipment washing water for further cleaning.
3. Use of treated sewage for gardening in plant premises.
4. Use high pressure wash systems.
Figure 2-12: Process Block diagram of Proposed ETP- 250 KLD capacity
The adequacy of the proposed Effluent Treatment Units is presented in below table.
There will be 10 nos. of flue gas stacks, attached to Boilers (3 nos. working 1 standby), Thermic
fluid heater (4 nos.), DG Set (2 no.) and Air heater (1 Nos.). Details of flue gas stacks are given in
Table 2-20.
Table 2-20: Details of Flue Gas Stacks
Nos. of Stack Top
Stack Attached to Sources Capacity Stack Height, m
Stacks Dia, m
Boiler (3 Nos. Working and 1
5 T/Hr each 3 40 0.8
No. Stand by)
Thermic Fluid Heater (4 Nos.) 10 Lac Kcal each 4 30 0.3
Diesel Generator (2 Nos.) 1000 kVA each 2 15 0.3
Air Heater 25000 kcal/hr. 1 15 0.3
There will be 16 nos. of process vents. Details are given in below table.
Nos.
S. Stack Pollutants APCM
of Details & Efficiency
No. Attached to Emitted Attached
Stacks
POCl3 Storage HCl generated during reaction will be
8 Tank/Reaction 1 HCl Scrubber neutralised in a basic scrubber before
Vessel discharging the neutralised effluent to ETP.
Epichlorohydrin HCl generated during reaction will be
9 Storage and 1 HCl Scrubber neutralised in a basic scrubber before
Reactor Vessel discharging the neutralised effluent to ETP.
The solid / Hazardous Waste will be collected and temporarily stored in Hazardous Waste Storage
Area as per hazardous waste rules within the plant premises. The details of the solid and
hazardous waste generation, quantification, classification, collection, transportation and disposal
facility as per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 and its amendment are mentioned in Table 2-23.
One month storage with impervious flooring will be provided for hazardous waste storage to avoid
leakage problem.
Occupational Health Center is provided at site. It is managed by qualified Doctor and Nursing staff
round the clock. Very small quantity of waste comprises of discarded medicines, soiled waste such
as dressing, bandages and material contaminated with blood will be generated. The generated
waste will be periodically handed over to authorized vendors as per SPCB regulations and
biomedical waste management rules 1998.
E-waste/ Electronic waste will mainly be generated from the computer lab and administrative
buildings. E-Waste comprises of discarded computers, copiers, fax machines, inverters, cell
phones, CD’s, LAN Cables, Keyboards, Mouse, SMPS, Fuses, Data cables, mobile/laptop peripherals
like earphones, chargers, circuit boards, printer cartridges etc. Electronic wastes will be handled as
per the provisions of the E-Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 2011.
Croda has also explored Explore the possibilities for Co-processing of the hazardous waste prior to
disposal into TSDF/CHWIF and has taken acceptance letter from M/s. Ambuja Cement for co-
processing the hazardous waste. Copy of acceptance letter is given in Figure 2-15.
Figure 2-15: Copy of Acceptance Letter from M/s. Ambuja Cement for Co-processing of Haz.
Wastes
3.1 General
This chapter illustrates the description of the existing environmental status of the study area with
reference to the prominent environmental attributes. The study area covers 10 km radius around
the project site. The landuse and socio-economic aspects were studied with respect to 10 km
radius around the site.
The existing environmental setting is considered to adjudge the baseline conditions which are
described with respect to climate, atmospheric conditions, water quality, soil quality, ecology,
socio-economic profile, landuse and places of archaeological importance.
3.2 Methodology
The methodology for conducting the baseline environmental survey obtained from the guidelines
given in the EIA Manual of the MoEF. Baseline information with respect to air, noise, water and
land quality in the study area was collected by conducting primary sampling/field studies during
the winter season i.e. December, 2014-February, 2015.
The land use and land cover of the study area comprises of various categories. The features
identified have been presented, considering the discussion provided inTable 3-1.
Table 3-1: Synopsis of Landuse / Landcover Classification Used for the Project
S. No. Primary Classification Secondary Classification
Residential / Commercial
1. Built-up Land or Habitation
Industrial
Crop/Fallow Land1
2. Agricultural Land
Plantation
Land without Scrub
3. Wastelands
Mudflat
4. Water Bodies Reservoir / Lakes / Ponds / Tanks
1
Fallow land was not separately identified owing to its seasonal nature.
The images classified into the above-mentioned classes for different regions of interest are given
in Figure 3-1.It was observed that the landuses generally exhibit similar characteristics across the
region, whilst certain land uses differs. All landuses are discussed in the subsequent sub-sections.
Built-up Land
Residential / Commercial
The study area habitation are given in map, it has Dahej city within 10 km radius.
Industrial Area
The main Industrial area in study area was of Dahej GIDC region.
34230437ural Land
Plantation was mainly within the industrial boundary to increase green cover of the area.
Wastelands
The class Land without Scrub was 9.15 per cent of the study area. Also Along the coast there was
big stretch of Mudflat region.
Water Bodies
There were few ponds/reservoirs/lakes/tanks in the region having 1.11 per cent of the study area.
Narmada river bed flows through the southern region of the study area.
Vegetation Cover
The scrub region was second most observed category in the region covering 17.72 per cent of the
area. Open and Close vegetation region includes Prosopis juliflora dominated vegetation cover.
Marshy vegetation was seen on the bet area along the Narmada river. This area on the western
side had big stretch of Mangroves.
Forest Area
There were reserve forests on the western side of the study area. According to the canopy cover
of the study area it was segregated to scrub (forest), open forest, close forest.
Others
Salt pans
Salt pans covers 13.47 per cent of area which is along the coast.
Grass Cover
This was along the waterbody where grass had been dried up.
Table 3-2: Area Statistics for Land Use / Land Cover Categories in the Study Area
Area, Secondary
S. Primary Area, Primacy Class
Secondary Classification Class
No. Classification
km2 Ha. ~% km2 Ha. ~%
The most observed category in the region was agriculture followed by Scrub, as per area covered.
This concludes the land use identification and description component of study. Photographs
showing ground truth survey done at project site and within study area is given inAnnexure 5.
Details of the important features along with other sensitive ecological locations in the study area
are provided in Table 3-4.
Table 3-4: Important Features and Sensitive Ecological Locations in the Study Area2
S. Distance
Sensitive Ecological Features Location Direction
No. (km)
1. National Park/Wildlife Sanctuary No - -
Tiger Reserve/Elephant Reserve /
2. No - -
Turtle Nesting Ground
3. Core Zone of Biosphere Reserve No - -
4. Habitat for migratory birds No - -
Vadadala Village Pond ~1.19 SW
Lakes / Reservoir / Dams / Canals Vav Village Pond ~1.60 N
5.
/ Ponds Jolva Village Pond ~2.71 SSE
Galenda Village Pond ~2.85 E
6. Stream/Rivers/Drains - - -
7. Estuary/Sea/Mangroves - - -
8. Mountains/Hills No - -
9. Notified Archaeological sites No - -
10. Any other Archaeological sites No - -
11. Defense Installations No - -
12. Airports - - -
13. Railway Station Dahej Railway Station ~6.10 SW
3.6.1 Weather
3.6.2 Temperature
3.6.3 Wind
The first, second and third predominant wind direction are shown in Table 3-5.It shows that
Northwest (NW) is predominant wind direction during daytime and during nighttime/evening time.
2
All information is based on satellite imagery and ground truth survey, Source of Table: Questionnaire by MoEF
3
Indian Meteorological Department (IMD), Long Term Climatological Tables, 1961-90, Broach (Bharuch)
3.6.4 Rainfall
The total rainfall in year is observed to be 912.1 mm. Distribution of rainfall by season is 2.8 mm
in winter (December, January, February), 9.9 mm in summer (March, April, May), 860.7 mm in
monsoons (June, July, August, September) and 38.7 mm in post-monsoons (October - November).
The area remains cloudy between June - September, which is the active period of the monsoon
season. Generally cloud cover ranges up-to 8 OKTAS during this monsoon season. During post-
monsoon season, cloud cover almost becomes 0 OKTAS occasionally going to 3-5 OKTAS. In the
summer season cloud cover is predominantly 0 OKTAS.
3.6.6 Humidity
Most humid conditions are found in the monsoons, followed by summer, post-monsoons, and
winter in that order. Mornings are more humid than evenings and humidity ranges from a high of
81-90% in monsoon mornings to a low of 34-44% in winter evenings. During post-monsoon
season, in morning humidity remains between 73-76 % and in the evening it remains between 42-
46%.
Wind Speed
Wind direction
Temperature
Relative Humidity
Cloud Cover
S. Env.
Location Parameters Period Frequency Methodology
No. Component
As per manufacturer’s
manual. Instruments
Wind speed, December,
At Hourly for are calibrated
wind direction, 2014 –
1. Meteorology Vadadla all Cloud cover is done by
temperature and February,
village parameters visual interpretation of
rainfall 2015
the sky by the
observer.
Site specific meteorological data shows that average wind speed in winter season of year
2014-15 is 2.9 m/s and maximum wind speed of 20.8 m/s.
Wind rose diagram prepared for the same is shown asFigure 3-2.
It can be observed that in winter season, wind blows mostly from North-East sector. Calm
wind contributes to about 9.58%.
Average temperature recorded for winter season was 23.6°C with maximum temperature of
36.7°C and minimum of 12.2°C which is a characteristic of this study area.
The data obtained has been complied to obtain average data. Complied mean meteorological data
is represented in Table 3-7.
Site specific meteorological data collection at Vadadla village is shown in Photograph 12-2 of
Annexure 5.
3.7.2 Justification of Using Baseline Data of M/s. PPG Asian Paints Pvt. Ltd.
M/s. Kadam Environmental Consultants had carried out baseline environmental data collection for
M/s. PPG Asian Paints Pvt. Ltd., Plot No.2/CH/21/A, Vadadla, Dahej, Bharuch during December
2014 to February 2015 for the preparation of the EIA report which is located adjacent to M/s.
Croda India Company Private Limited. We have proposed to use these data to prepare EIA report
and committee has allowed the same in ToR Letter with additional one month monitoring including
project specific parameters. Copy of ToR letter is attached as Annexure 1.We have done
additional one month ambient air monitoring at all location in June 2015.
The ambient air monitoring work was carried out in month of from December, 2014 to February,
2015 and in June 2015.
Depending upon the purpose of the study IS: 5184 (Part XIV) lays down various criteria for
selecting sampling stations. For this EIA, the purpose is to ascertain the baseline pollutant
concentrations in ambient air. Accordingly, the criterion was selected to ascertain quality of air at
important human settlement. The annual wind direction has been considered for selecting AAQM
stations. The annual first predominant wind direction would be from NE to SW, second would be
from SE to NW, third would be NW to SE, fourth would be from SW to NE. Locations selected for
ambient air quality monitoring are presented in Table 3-8 and shown inFigure 3-3.
The ambient air quality monitoring has been shown inPhotograph 12-2.
The frequency of monitoring was 24 hours twice a week at each station spread over the entire
season with grab sampling for gaseous parameters like HCl, Cl2, NH3, HB2, VOC, HC (Methane and
Non-methane) & CO taken thrice a month.
Detailed result of AAQM are given in Complied average data are represented inTable 3-9.Detailed
results are given in Annexure 6.
Table 3-9: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Results (Winter Season: December 2014 –
February 2015)
Parameters & Results
Note: All units are in µg/m3 except VOCs which are in ppm.
Figures in brackets indicate CPCB limits. Minimum Reportable
Station
Location Readings are 8 µg/m3 for SO2 and 10 µg/m3 for NOX
code
PM2.5 (60) SO2 (80) NOX (80)
PM10 (100) VOCs (NS)
[24 [24 [24
[24 Hours] [15 mins]
Hours] Hours] Hours]
AA 1 At PPG Asian Paint Site [Adjacent Site, Base Station]
Maximum 110 33 10.3 24.6 <1
Minimum 26 9 8.0 14.4 <1
Average 58 18 8.9 18.9 <1
98% tile 106 32 10.2 24.0 <1
AA 2 At Vav Village [3.12 Km, NE]
Maximum 107 27 10.4 25.3 <1
Minimum 26 6 8.0 14.7 <1
Average 68 16 8.8 19.4 <1
98% tile 105 27 10.2 25.1 <1
AA 3 At Vadadla Village [1.38 Km, East]
Maximum 106 46 10.3 26.9 <1
Minimum 23 7 8.0 13.9 <1
Average 67 23 9.0 18.6 <1
98% tile 106 44 10.3 24.3 <1
AA 4 At Jolwa Village [3.93 Km, SE]
Maximum 102 25 10.3 23.4 <1
Minimum 17 8 8.0 14.7 <1
Average 61 18 8.9 18.6 <1
98% tile 102 25 10.3 23.3 <1
AA 5 At Radha-Madhav site [1.0 Km, South]
Maximum 102 32 10.2 27.5 <1
Minimum 24 12 8.0 11.3 <1
Average 63 20 9.1 18.5 <1
98% tile 99 32 10.2 26.1 <1
AA 6 At Labour colony [1.37 Km, NNW]
µg/m3 for NOX, 1.0 µg/m3 for Cl2, 1.0 µg/m3 for HCl, 20.0 µg/m3 for NH3, 1.0 µg/m3 for HBr, 1.0 PPM for VOC, 800 µg/m3 for
All stations are in
HC, 10 µg/m3 for NMHC & 1,145 µg/m3 for CO.
Station Industrial, Residential,
code Rural & Other Areas PM10 PM2.5 SO2 NOX Cl2 HCl NH3 HBr VOC HC NMHC's CO
(CPCB)
100 60 80 80 400 4,000
[24 [24 [24 [24 NS NS [24 NS NS NS NS [1
Hours] Hours] Hours] Hours] Hours] Hour]
AA1 At Proposed Project Site [0.0 Km, Base Station] (Industrial, Residential, Rural & Other Areas)
Maximum 89 38 17.5 27.0 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,556 157 1,146
Minimum 40 21 8.0 10.5 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,063 < 10 < 1145
Average 67 31 12.1 20.6 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,393 101 < 1145
98% tile 88 38 17.0 26.6 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,554 157 < 1145
AA2 At Vav Village [3.25 Km, NE] (Industrial, Residential, Rural & Other Areas)
Maximum 81 30 7.4 19.5 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1205 45 982
Minimum 46 11 6.2 13.0 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 998 17 692
Average 64 21 6.8 17.3 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1060 29 841
98% tile 81 30 7.4 19.5 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1195 44 975
AA3 At Vadadla Village [1.38 Km, East] (Industrial, Residential, Rural & Other Areas)
Maximum 136 59 17.0 32.1 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 2,033 177 1,839
Minimum 51 19 8.0 11.5 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,263 < 10 < 1145
Average 92 38 9.5 20.7 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,561 89 1,547
98% tile 130 58 15.6 30.9 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,965 171 1,829
AA4 At Jolwa Village [3.93 Km, SE] (Industrial, Residential, Rural & Other Areas)
Maximum 146 87 10.4 35.7 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,831 144 1,607
Minimum 63 21 8.0 12.0 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,246 < 10 < 1145
µg/m3 for NOX, 1.0 µg/m3 for Cl2, 1.0 µg/m3 for HCl, 20.0 µg/m3 for NH3, 1.0 µg/m3 for HBr, 1.0 PPM for VOC, 800 µg/m3 for
All stations are in
HC, 10 µg/m3 for NMHC & 1,145 µg/m3 for CO.
Station Industrial, Residential,
code Rural & Other Areas PM10 PM2.5 SO2 NOX Cl2 HCl NH3 HBr VOC HC NMHC's CO
(CPCB)
100 60 80 80 400 4,000
[24 [24 [24 [24 NS NS [24 NS NS NS NS [1
Hours] Hours] Hours] Hours] Hours] Hour]
Average 95 40 8.3 22.4 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,512 89 1,361
98% tile 146 87 10.4 35.7 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1,831 144 1,607
AA5 At Radha-Madhav site [1.0 Km, South] (Industrial, Residential, Rural & Other Areas)
Maximum 87 34 9.6 20.3 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1445 57 971
Minimum 41 16 6.1 15.7 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1074 25 398
Average 67 23 7.8 17.8 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1214 44 677
98% tile 86 34 9.5 20.3 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1435 57 950
AA6 At Labour colony [1.37 Km, NNW] (Industrial, Residential, Rural & Other Areas)
Maximum 108 28 10.1 24.4 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1205 45 982
Minimum 29 8 8.0 13.9 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 998 17 692
Average 76 21 8.9 18.8 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1060 29 841
98% tile 107 28 10.0 24.0 <1 <1 < 20 < 1.0 < 1 ppm 1195 44 975
Observations
A comparison of the above results with the value range indicators provided by CPCB for Industrial,
residential, rural & other area indicates:
In winter season an average concentration of PM10 was observed to be varying from 58 to 76 µg/Nm3.
An average concentration of PM10 levels are well within the permissible limits for all locations.
In winter season an average concentration of PM2.5 levels was observed to be in range of 16 to 23
µg/Nm3 which is less than the permissible limits for all locations.
In winter season an average concentration of SO2 and NOX is observed to be within the specified limit
of CPCB.
In winter season an average concentration of VOC is observed below 1 ppm.
During monitoring in June 2015 average results of all parameters are within the specified limit.
Monitoring of noise is done by identifying suitable number of noise quality monitoring locations.
Background noise quality is monitored in dB (A) Leq (d) and dB (A) Leq (n) at the selected locations.
Monitoring methodology and photographs of Noise level monitoring are given inAnnexure 5.
The standard for monitoring ambient noise level as per CPCB guidelines is as given in Table 3-11.
Table 3-11: Ambient Air Quality Standards in respect of Noise for Different Areas/Zones
Ambient Air Quality Standards Area Limits in dB(A) Leq*
Category
in Respect of NOISE Code Day Time Night Time
A Industrial 75.0 70.0
THE NOISE POLLUTION
B Commercial 65.0 55.0
(REGULATION AND CONTROL)
C Residential 55.0 45.0
RULES, 2000
D Silence 50.0 40.0
Note: Day Time: 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM; Night Time: 10:00 PM to 6:00 AM
dB (A) Leq*: denotes the time weighted average of the level of sound in decibels on scale A which is
relatable to human hearing.
Locations for noise monitoring were selected by doing preliminary analysis of site visit and using SoundPlan
essential 3.0 software. The equipment’s that would be present in the project area were considered as
source of noise for undertaking noise modeling. Further, receivers were placed within the project site as
this is existing site, at a distance of 500 m from the source of noise generation and at sensitive location i.e.
village for ambient noise monitoring. The locations selected for noise monitoring are presented inFigure
3-3.
NL5 Vav village 21° 45' 3. 53"N 72° 38' 39. 61"E 3.12 NE
Noise readings were taken at five different locations within the study area. The average noise levels are
presented in Table 3-13.
Observation
Noise level during daytime & during nighttime, in Industrial area & Residential area, were observed within
CPCB standards i.e. Industrial area [75 dBA (d) & 70 dBA (n)] and residential area [55 dBA (d) & 45 dBA
(n)].
Monitoring methodology for groundwater is given in Annexure 5.The grab samples were manually
collected and analyzed as per APHA Standard Methods (20th Edition, 1998) for the parameters given in the
EIA Manual of MoEFCC (January 2001).
Groundwater sampling was carried out in the month of February 2015 (Winter season)from four different
locations. Location Map of the same is shown in Figure 3-3and locations are given in Table 3-14. Photo
documentation of groundwater monitoring is presented in Photograph 12-5.
Observations
The formation is having low storability since it is made up of fine sand and silt thus supply will always be
limited.
Surface Water Quality monitoring is carried out in the study area of 10 km based on the land use pattern
and ground truth of nearby villages (Monitoring Period: Dec’2014- Feb’2015).
Methodology Adopted
Methodology adopted for sampling and analysis & photo documentation are given inAnnexure 5.
Surface water sampling locations are selected based on review of land use plan, surface drainage
pattern/ground water flow direction & nearby site habitation village /locations in 10 km radius of project.
The details of surface water sampling locations are presented in Table 3-16.
Analytical results of the surface water /Pond /River (Estuary) water samples are presented in Table
3-17&Table 3-18.
The baseline quality of water based on the results of the surface water quality monitoring within
the study area, it is observed that
1. The COD and BOD value observed slightly high at all locations due to anthropogenic sources
such as washing, bathing etc.
2. All other parameters are within the permissible limits as per drinking water standards at all
locations except total coliform and faecal coliform which is found high at all locations in pond
water.
3. The Quality of Narmada estuary is nearly matching with class SW-II as per causal water
marine standards.
Topographically, the entire area is almost flat with gentle dipping toward west. Geomorphologic
ally, coastal area is covered by tidal and mud flats. Drainages have acquired a pattern of deltaic
condition.
A concise description of Geology for Bharuch district given by Geological Survey of India is given
below:
3.12.1 Objectives
3.12.2 Methodology
This was done by different parameters, mentioned as follows by collection of secondary data:
The location for soil sample collection were randomly selected at the project site as well as from
the surrounding areas namely Soil-01 to Soil-08. The soil samples from 0-15 cm depth were
collected by using spade and pawada. The samples were homogenized and about 1 Kg soil sample
was collected in the polyethylene bag. Labeled with sample ID which includes site numbers and
project name. The samples were brought to the laboratory for analysis of physical (porosity, water
holding capacity, permeability, particle size distribution) and chemical properties (cation exchange,
electrical conductivity, sodium adsorption ratio, pH, Ca, Mg, Na, K).
The site visit was carried out for monitoring the proposed project site. The GIDC area is barren
and soils are of trap origin and highly expanding type and are called Vertisols taxonomically. The
soils are having very low permeability on account of clay texture. The depth of water table is 6-7
meter. The annual average rain fall is around 900 mm. The soil depth is < 100 cm. The upper soil
layer is clayey and at lower depths yellow soils are observed this indicates that upper clay layer is
transported one. The soils are saline/alkaline due to proximity of sea. Although in GIDC, we found
Prosopis julifera trees but in the adjoining areas cultivation of cotton, castor, pigeon pea, sorghum
and wal is being practiced.
Soil sampling was carried out at 08 locations in the study area and they are presented in Table
3-20.
Table 3-20: Soil Sampling Locations
Sample Distance from Direction Date of
Sampling Location
Code Project Site in Km w.r.tProject Site Sampling
ST 1 At project site - - 23.01.2015
ST 2 Jolwa village 3.93 SE 23.01.2015
ST 3 Vav Village 3.12 NE 23.01.2015
ST 4 Vadadala Village 1.38 E 23.01.2015
Methodology of soil sample monitoring is given in Annexure 5and the soil sampling analysis
results are given in Table 3-21.Photograph 12-7in Annexure 5shows soil sampling at project
site and within study area.
For monitoring soil quality four (At site, Jolwa, Vav and Vadadala villages) soil samples were
collected including the project site. The samples were assessed for physical and chemical
properties.
The porosity ranged from 56% (Jolwa and Vav villages) to 59% (Vadadala village) and WHC
varied from 45.10% (Jolwa village) to 62.30 % (Vadadala village).
The soil permeability was low to medium which ranged from 7.4 mm/hr (Jolwa village) to 10.7
mm/hr (Vadadala village), however soil texture in all the soil samples was clay loam, hence
whatever variation observed was mainly due to variation in organic matter content of soils.
The EC of soil ranged from 0.140 dS/m (Vav village) to 0.294 dS/m (Vadadala village), while
ESP varied from 0.31 (Vav village) to 1.28 (Vadadala village).
These soils are neither saline nor sodic as EC and ESP are < 0.8 dS/m and 5.0, respectively.
The pH of soil ranged from 7.86 (Vav village) to 8.36 (Vadadala village), which indicates that
soils are neutral to slightly alkaline.
Environmental Site Assessment (Phase I and II) of a site was conducted April-May 2014. Three
piezometric wells were drilled and installed during site assessment. Lithology of one of the well is
represented in Table 3-22.
Groundwater level was encountered at 8 m bgl during site assessment. As per discussion with
local people and well owners, depth to water level, within study area is 8 to 10 m and total depth
of wells ranging from 15 to 20 m. Owing to geological conditions, the Groundwater is salty and
only used for general purpose. At some places, post monsoon water, shows slight improvement in
terms of quality. However with passage of time it turns saline. Drinking water is supplied by
tankers or pipe lines in most of the villages at vicinity of GIDC and SEZ area.
3.14 Seismicity
Gujarat is categorized in the seismic zone III, which is classified as having a fairly high probability
of earthquake shocks measuring 5 or 6 on the Richter scale, low probability of shocks of 6 or 7 on
the Richter scale.
Proposed Site
Conference of parties to the Convention on Biological diversity (CBD) held at Curitiba, Brazil on
March 20th-31st,2006 suggested biodiversity to be considered in impact assessment by providing
voluntary guidelines on biodiversity inclusive Environmental Impact Assessment. CBD provides a
strong international platform for applying impact assessment techniques to biodiversity
conservation. It specifically calls for impact assessment measures to ensure that biodiversity is
addressed in projects, plan and policy decision (Article14). An underlying justification for the
application of impact assessment is also given in Article -8 which is for promoting the protection of
ecosystems, natural habitats, promoting environmentally sound and sustainable development in
areas next to the protected areas.
The variety and variability of organisms and ecosystems is referred to as biological diversity or Bio
diversity. Biodiversity is a term which has gained enormous importance in the past few years.
Technically, it is a contraction of 'biological diversity'. For the purposes of the CBD (Article 2. Use
of Terms), 'Biological Diversity' is "the variability among living organisms from all sources
including, inter alia, terrestrial, marine and other aquatic ecosystems and the ecological complexes
of which they are part; this includes diversity within species, between species and of ecosystems".
In practice, 'biodiversity' is most often used as a collective noun synonymous with nature or 'Life
on Earth' (WCMC Biodiversity Series No 5, 1996).
The biodiversity, we see today is the result of billions of years of evolution, shaped by natural
processes. The vast array of interactions among the various components of biodiversity makes the
planet habitable for all species, including humans. There is a growing recognition that, biological
diversity is a global asset of tremendous value to present and future generations. At the same
time, the threat to species and ecosystems has never been as great as it is today. Species
extinction caused by human activities continues at an alarming rate. Protecting biodiversity is for
our self-interest and also for the future generation.
Ecological impact assessment (EcIA) is used to predict and evaluate the impacts of development
activities on ecosystems and their components, thereby providing the information needed to
ensure that ecological issues are given full and proper consideration in development planning.
Environmental impact assessment (EIA) has emerged as a key to sustainable development by
integrating social, economic and environmental issues in many countries. EcIA has a major part to
play as a component of EIA but also has other potential applications in environmental planning
and management. Ecological Impact Assessment provides a comprehensive review of the EcIA
process and summarizes the ecological theories and tools that can be used to understand, explain
and evaluate the ecological consequences of development proposals.
Environmental impact assessments have become an integral part of development projects in India
ever since 1994, to formulate policies and guidelines for environmentally sound economic
development. Proper assessment of biological environment and compilation of its taxonomical data
is essential for the impact prediction.
Consistent and regularly updated data on regional and local taxonomy and floristic and faunal
diversity of the areas are almost non-existent in country as diverse as India. Instant information
on biodiversity profiles of the area, where the proposed project is setting up, is an essential part of
the baseline studies of EIA. In such a situation, good primary baseline biodiversity survey is a pre-
requisite for the collection of reliable data. The professional ethic of the EIA practitioners should
be their will and skill to conduct scientific field surveys. These contributions towards biodiversity
surveys may sometimes recognized as the actual value additions in terms of new records or a new
data base but are more often recognized in the validation and updating of the existing information
base.
The baseline study was conducted for the evaluation of floral and faunal biodiversity of the
terrestrial environment within 10 Km radius from the proposed project in the Bharuch district
during June, 2015.
Mangroves
Area Distance from Project Site (km.) Direction
Dahej 6.56 NE
Dahej 8.25 WSW
3.15.6 Methodology
The primary objective of survey was to describe the floristic and faunal communities within the
study area. The sampling plots for floral inventory were selected randomly in the suitable habitats
within the 10 km radius from the project location. The methodology adopted for faunal survey
involve; faunal habitat assessment, random intensive survey, opportunistic observations, diurnal
bird observation, active search for reptiles, active search for scats and foot prints and review of
previous studies. The aim was to set baselines in order to monitor and identify trends after the
commencement of expansion activity. Emphasis has been placed on presence of rare, endemic,
migratory and threatened species, if any present in the study area. Desktop literature review was
conducted to identify the representative spectrum of threatened species, population and ecological
communities as listed by IUCN, ZSI, BSI and in Indian wild Life Protection act, 1972. The status of
individual species was assessed using the revised IUCN category system.
Structure in the study area for formulating effective management and conservation measures. The
climatic, edaphic and biotic variations with their complex interrelationship and composition of
species, which are adapted to these variations, have resulted in different vegetation cover,
characteristic of each region. The following account of floral inventory has been based on the field
survey conducted for a short duration in theJune 2015, is not very comprehensive data and is
aimed only to give a general pattern of vegetation of this region during the study period as a
baseline data in absence of available secondary data. Listing of the endangered, threatened and
endemic species of flora in a locality and drawing the attention to the occurrence of such species,
would aid in creating awareness amongst the local people as a whole to protect such species from
extinction, and to take necessary measures for their conservation. These type of floristic study is
an inventory for such purpose and hence a necessity.The dominant tree species, herbs, shrubs
and major crops, were documented during this base line study.
The list of floral species is prepared based on visual observation during site visit and through
review of site literatures and secondary data available with various government offices is referred
for identifying rare or endangered species in the region.
In core zone, the vegetation mostly comprises of open scrub vegetation. Prosopis juliflora (Jangali
Babul) is observed to be dominant in the study area. No forest land comes under study area. The
vegetation type is subtropical coastal thorny scrub jungles with trees predominantly moist
deciduous type but rarely evergreen. The natural vegetation is scarce, scattered and open. In all
other areas, the trees are dominated by Acacia nilotica and Prosopis juliflora. The plants growing
are Acacia nilotica, Prosopis juliflora, Salvadora sp. along with wide variety of herb species.
The coastal bed confined to seashores have mangrove ecosystem is in Dahej where mangrove
forest with Avicenia and Rhizophora species found on the seaward side. Density in these areas
varies from open forest to dense.
In buffer zone, total of 31 plant species were observed in the study area. Out of which 17 tree
species, 5 shrubs species and 3herbs species, 1 climber species, 1 twiner species, 2 species of
grass and 2 species mangroves were observed. Details pertaining to flora observed in the study
area have been collected from District Forest Department, District Gazetteer and Field Observation
is presented in a tabular format as inTable 3-23.
TREES
1. Pongomia pinnata Karanj Fabaceae
2. Prosopis cineraria Khijado Mimosaceae
3. Acacia catechu Khair Mimosaceae
4. Acacia nilotica Desi Baval Mimosaceae
5. Acacia Senegal Gorad Mimosaceae
6. Azardirachta indica Limdo Meliaceae
7. Butea monosperma Khakhro Fabaceae
The main crops observed in the study area are Cotton. Other crops grown are Wheat, Groundnut,
Castor, Bajra, Mustard. Major crops grown in the area are Bajra (Pennisetum typhoides), jowar
(Sorghum species), Til (Sessamum), Cotton (Gossipium sp.) Soyabean (Glycine max).
Among the enumerated flora in the study area, no rare and endangered or rare flora was
observed.
For the documentation of the faunal diversity of the study area with respect to birds, reptiles and
mammals species a baseline survey had been conducted in June, 2015 and also used reference
from review of site literatures and secondary data available with various government offices.
List of bird species in the study area with the status of occurrence is given in Table 3-24.
Reptiles
= Not sighted but included as per the information provided by villagers,during the interaction
with them with pictorial presentation.
Mammals
The wild mammals observed other than domesticated ones from study area is documented in
Table 3-26.
Table 3-26: List of Mammals in study area
S. Common Name Scientific name Local Status IWPA -1972
No (Schedule I - VI)
1 Indian field mouse Mus booduga (Gray) Abundant V
2 Wild Boar Sus Scrofa Abundant III
3 Five striped Palm Funambulus pennanti Common IV
squirrel (Wroughton)
4 Nilgai Boselaphus tragocamelus (Pallas) Abundant III
5 Common Mongoose Herpestes edwardsi (Geoffroy) Common II
6 Jackal Canis aureus(Linnaeus) Common II
None of the sighted animal species can be assigned endemic species category of the study area.
Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972, amended on 17thJanuary 2003, is an Act to provide for the
protection of wild animals, birds and plants and for matters connected therewith or ancillary or
incidental thereto with a view to ensuring the ecological and environmental security of the
country.
Some of the sighted fauna was given protection by the Indian Wild Life (Protection)Act, 1972 by
including them in different schedules.
None of the reported animals are fall in Schedule I. Among reptile only Indian Cobra (Naja naja)
are provided protection as per Schedule-II of Wild life protection act, (1972) which was reported
in the study area.
Among mammals; Common Mongoose (Herpestes edwardsi) and Jackal (Canis aureus (Linnaeus)
are schedule –II animals. Nilgai (Boselaphus tragocamelus) is protected as Schedule-III animal as
per Wild Life Protection act 1972.
Population Distribution
The project study area consists of 22 villages /habtation falling in Vagra taluka of Bharuch district.
Due to rapid industrialization and outcome of Dahej GIDC there is sharp fall in the agricultural
activity in the study area.The people have started working as daily wage or contractual labours to
carve out their livelihood. Fishermen community also exists in the study area villages who lives on
a daily earn basis to fulfill their basic needs.
From the above table it can be inferred that there has been an increase of 28.6% in the
population of study area since the last decade. The bulk increase can be seen in the Dahej Village
where the population just got doubled in 2011. There is increase of 35.7% in the grand total
households numbers since 2001 The study area has attracted large number of population of
migrants from rural areas of Gujarat & Maharashtra, U. P, Bihar, Orissa, Andhra Pradesh, Tamil
Nadu, and Kerala etc. due to job avenues in the prominent industries like
IPCL,ADANI,OPAL,TORRENT, GACL,GCPTCL, IOCL & GIDC etc.
Vulnerable Groups
SC/ST population in the study area has been shown in the table below.
% SC % ST % SC % ST
Distance
Female
Female
Female
Female
Total
Total
Total
Total
Male
Male
Male
Male
0-3 Kms 9.90 51.67 48.33 52.81 48.13 51.9 9.25 48.68 51.32 41.48 48.68 51.32
2001 2011
% SC % ST % SC % ST
Distance
Female
Female
Female
Female
Total
Total
Total
Total
Male
Male
Male
Male
3 - 5 Kms 5.32 50.40 49.60 21.71 52.87 47.1 4.90 52.96 47.04 16.54 51.89 48.11
5 - 7 Kms 4.43 52.74 47.26 16.45 51.76 48.2 3.73 50.00 50.00 16.66 51.67 48.33
7 - 10 Kms 4.18 54.00 46.00 26.17 52.29 47.7 3.91 52.64 47.36 28.88 45.45 42.64
Total 4.73 52.30 47.70 21.24 52.29 47.7 4.39 52.14 47.86 21.45 48.65 45.65
Educational Facility
The statistics regarding the educational facilities within the study area is given in table below.
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Primary
Primary
College
College
Distance
School
School
School
School
School
School
Senior
Senior
0-3 Kms 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
3-5 Kms 4 2 1 1 1 0 0 0
5-7 Kms 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
7- 10 Kms 10 2 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 24 4 1 1 1 0 0 0
A important parameter to evaluate the situation of the society is literacy rate. It has been shown
in the table below.
2001 2011
Distance % Literacy % Literacy
Total Male Female Total Male Female
7 - 10 Kms 60.38 64.55 35.45 74.65 60.76 39.24
Total 61.86 62.51 37.49 74.40 61.47 38.53
The literacy rate of the study area in 2001 and 2011 is approximately 62 and 74 percent
respectively. The males have higher literacy rate than the females. The female literacy rate has
improved in 2011 in comparison to 2001 Census data in all the villages of the study area.
The above table reflects 3.8% of the students in Aanganwadi/Balwadi, 29.5% are those who have
studied between 1-6th standard and 25.2% between 7-9th standard. The SSC qualified counts to
be 10% whereas the SSC passed are 1%. For attaining higher studies students travel to Bharuch
and nearby cities.
Around 20.4% of the total population are those students who are presently pursuing their studies
in schools, colleges and technical institutes.
Health Facilities
From the above table it can be inferred that the medical facilities are limited in the study area
villages. Apart from Dahej most of the villages are devoid of the health facilities. Primary Health
Centre is present only in the Dahej village.
Due to the absence of government medical facilities in the study area the villagers visits Bharuch
for treatment. Dahej and some village are having private medical facilities but due to high fees
people prefer to go to the city itself.
Water Resources
Tank/Pond/La
Covered Well
River/Canal
Hand Pump
Tap Water-
Tube Wells
Uncovered
Tap Water
/Borehole
Untreated
Treated
Others
Spring
Well
Distance
ke
0-3 Kms × √ × √ × × × × √ √
3-5 Kms × √ × √ √ × × × √ ×
5-7 Kms × √ × √ √ √ x √ √ √
7- 10 Kms × √ × √ √ √ x √ √ √
Housing Condition
The housing condition of the surveyed households has been shown below:
Open Defecation 25
Agriculture
Agriculture is totally dependent on monsoon. The major crops grown are Wheat, Cotton, Pulses
and Bajri. Agriculture provides employment in the form of daily wage labour during the harvesting
season. People who have less or no land do labour in others field on daily wage basis. The
average wage for the male is Rs. 200 per day and for the female is Rs. 150 per day.
Industries/Factories
PCPIR located at Dahej, is spread over the blocks of Vagra and Bharuch, South Gujarat. This
region has been specifically delineated Investment Region planned for the establishment of
production facilities for petroleum, chemicals and petrochemicals. Vagra Taluka is the place where
the proposed project is coming. The major company that are there in GIDC Dahej Phase II are the
following Gujarat Narmada Valley Fertilizer Company, Adani Power Dahej Ltd., First Carbon
Technologies Pvt. Ltd., GACL, SRF Limited, Narmada Bio Chem Pvt. Ltd., Indofil Chemicals
Company, BOC, Meghmani Organics Ltd. etc.
Employment Status
Agricultural
Cultivators
Cultivators
Household
Household
Marginal
Marginal
Workers
Workers
Workers
Workers
Distance
Others
Others
Labor
Labor
0-3 Kms 21.05 24.44 0.00 43.23 11.28 8.01 22.55 0.59 58.75 10.09
3-5 Kms 13.78 21.51 0.57 46.35 17.79 5.83 2.73 0.30 74.89 16.24
5-7 Kms 24.93 11.54 0.15 21.69 41.69 22.80 10.21 2.44 34.53 30.01
7- 10 Kms 18.94 10.96 0.48 54.06 15.55 10.52 8.65 0.43 57.71 22.69
Total 18.93 14.59 0.41 43.34 22.74 10.60 6.78 0.72 60.89 21.01
Kilometers) is the only village having the tube well facility so agriculture here is not dependent on
the monsoon season.
Means of Transportation
The transportation facilities with in the study area are shown in the below mentioned table.
Sea/River/Ferry
Railway Station
Carts Driven by
Auto/Modified
Cycle-pulled
Rickshaws
Tractors
Animals
Service
Autos
Vans
Taxi
Distance
0-3 Kms √ x x √ x √ x x x x
3-5 Kms √ x √ √ √ √ √ x √
5-7 Kms √ x X √ x √ √ x √ x
7- 10 Kms √ x X √ x √ √ x √ x
The Government of Gujarat supplies power to all the households in the study area villages.
Means of Communication
The table below shows the means of communication in the study area.
Common Service
Internet Cafes /
Sub Post Office
Private Courier
/Mobile (PCO)
Mobile Phone
Centre (CSC)
Post Office
(landlines)
Telephone
Coverage
Facility
Distance
0-3 Kms x √ √ x √ √ x
3-5 Kms √ √ √ √ √ √ √
5-7 Kms x √ √ √ √ √ x
7- 10 Kms x √ √ √ √ √ x
The villages have adequate communication facilities in form of post office, post & telegraph and
phone. The post office is available in only 3-5 Kms of the aerial distance from the project site. The
Landline phones and mobile phones are readily available in all the villages of the study area. It has
become a necessity, for quick and easy communication.
Lifestyle
Village life has always been the resemblance of simple society, informal relations, traditional
livelihood patterns and contented lives. The socio-economic changes are evident in progressive
industrial development. The coming of the industries, creation of SEZ, SIR has made changes in
the rural life of Gujarat.
The maximum population of villages lies in the SEZ area of Dahej. This has impacted the lifestyle
of the villagers to some extent. The in-migration of population due to the industries has led way
for the apartment system that can be easily seen in the Jolwa and Dahej. The scope for civic
nuisance emerges with the coming of the migrant population. Local population has started renting
their houses for secondary source of income.
Majority of the people in the study area are vegetarian. A traditional ‘Gujarati Thali’ consisting of
dal (lentils), roti, rice and vegetables apart from salads, farsan and sweet dish followed by chaas,
forms the staple diet. Evening food consist of ‘bhakhri-shaak’ or ‘khichdi-kadhi. A variety of cuisine
sub-ordinates like pickles, chutney, papad, yoghurt, etc serve as fillings on main menu. However,
non-vegetarian food is also available in certain Muslim dominated and ST community areas like
Jolva village etc.
Due to the coming of the industries now there can be seen hotel/restaurant facilities available in
the study area serving all Indian cuisines like Punjabi, South Indian etc. along with traditional
Gujarati Thali with ‘chaas’ and ‘papad’.The local language spoken is ‘Gujarati’ followed by Hindi in
some rural and urban areas.
4.1 Introduction
Objective of this chapter is to:
Identify project activities that could beneficially or adversely impact the environment
Predict and assess the environmental impacts of such activities
Examine each environmental aspect-impact relationship in detail and identify its degree of
significance
Identify possible mitigation measures for these project activities and select the most
appropriate mitigation measure, based on the reduction in significance achieved and
practicality in implementation.
Key Definitions
Environmental Aspects
These are elements of an organization’s activities or products or services that can interact with the
environment. Environmental aspects could include activities that occur during normal, abnormal
and emergency operations.
Environmental aspects selected for further study should be large enough for meaningful
examination and small enough to be easily understood.
Environmental Impacts
Environmental impacts are defined as any change to the environment, whether adverse or
beneficial, wholly or partially resulting from an organization’s environmental aspects.
Environmental Indices
The environment includes surroundings in which an organization operates such as air, water, land,
natural resources, flora, fauna, humans and their interrelation.
The environmental indices (or parts of the receiving environment on which impacts are being
assessed) include: Land use/land cover, air quality, noise quality, surface water environment,
ground water environment, soil, ecology and bio diversity, socio economics, occupational health,
community health and safety
After the identification of impacting activities, impacts require to be assessed based on subjective /
objective criteria to assess the impacting activities. This is done in the following steps.
Identification of Impacts
1. Listing of environmental aspects (i.e. activities or parts thereof that can cause environmental
impacts)
2. Identifying applicable components of the environment on which the environmental aspects
can cause an environmental impact
3. Making notes of the reason / possible inter-relationships that lead to environmental impact
creation
4. Listing the environmental components likely to receive impacts, along with the key impacting
activities on each component.
A component wise approach to environmental risk assessment and mitigation is now applied. For
each environmental component this is carried through a series of steps as follows.
Step 1: Review and Assessment of the Specific Aspects Generating Environmental Risk
Several scientific techniques and methodologies are also used to predict impacts on the
environment. Mathematical models are useful tools (where applicable) to quantitatively describe
the cause and effect relationships between sources of pollution and different components of
environment. In cases where it is not possible to identify and validate a model for a particular
situation, predictions have been arrived based on logical reasoning / consultation / extrapolation
or overlay methods. In any case, for each component of the environment, the methods used to
arrive at the likely impacts require to be described.
Severity / consequence: The resultant effect of an activity and its interaction with the physical,
biological and/or socio-economic environments
Probability: The likelihood that an impact may occur due to the project activity/aspect
The consequences on various environmental receptors have been ranked into 5 levels ranging
from insignificant to catastrophic consequence and are given inTable 4-1.
Table 4-1: Overall Impact Scoring System due to the Proposed Project – Consequence Assessment
Impact and Score4
Environmental
S. Insignificant Major Catastrophic
Component Minor Consequence Moderate Consequence
No. Consequence Consequence Consequence
Impacted (+/-) 2 points (+/-) 3 points
(+/-) 1 point (+/-) 4 points (+/-) 5 points
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7
Very short term (< 3 Short term (3 months – 1
Medium term (1 - 3 years) Long term (>3 years) Permanent and irreversible
months) and reversible year) and reversible change
1 Landuse / Landcover and reversible change in irreversible change in adverse change in landuse
change in landuse and / or in landuse and / or
landuse and / or landcover landuse and / or landcover and / or landcover
landcover landcover
Moderate environmental
Minor environmental impact Unacceptable
impact due to Significant environmental
Temporary nuisance due to due to environmental impact due
controlled/uncontrolled impact due to release of air
controlled/uncontrolled controlled/uncontrolled to release of air emissions,
release of air emissions, emissions, odor / dust or
2 Air Quality release of air emissions, release of air emissions, odor / dust leading to
odor / dust or greenhouse greenhouse gases leading
odor / dust or greenhouse odor / dust or greenhouse possibility of chronic / acute
gases leading to visual to exceedance of limits
gases gases with no lasting health issues, injuries or
impacts, at significant specified in EP Rules’
detrimental effects fatalities
nuisance levels
Background Noise Levels, with respect to Applicable Limit5 as per The Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000, as Measured at Boundary of
Ambient Noise - give Relevant Noise Generating Unit
the mean score from <10% or more Between <10 to <5% Between <5% or the limit Up to 5% above the limit >5% above the limit
3 the three categories,
Incremental Noise Levels, as Predicted at Boundary of Relevant Noise Generating Unit
rounded to the
nearest decimal 1 dB(A) or less 1 dB(A) – 2 dB(A) 2 dB(A) – 3 dB(A) 3 dB(A) – 4 dB(A) 4 dB(A) or more
Incremental Noise Levels, as Predicted at Boundary of Nearest Human Settlement / Sensitive Receptor from Boundary of Relevant Noise Generating Unit
4
In case none of the impacts are applicable, then Not Applicable (NA) is written in the appropriate cell
5
For leq (day) or leq (night), whichever is higher
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7
0.5 dB(A) or less 0.5 dB(A) – 1 dB(A) 1 dB(A) – 1.5 dB(A) 1.5 dB(A) – 2 dB(A) 2 dB(A) or more
Water Consumption (KL/D)
< 50 51 – 100 101 - 250 250 – 500 501 and more
Surface Water - give
Water Consumption, Duration
the mean score from
< 1 year 1 – 3 years 3 – 5 years 5 – 10 years 10 years or more
4 the three categories,
rounded to the Wastewater Discharge Quality
nearest decimal Other discharge within Other discharge, outside
Discharge to an authorized,
No wastewater generation Zero Discharge 6
limits specified by the EP limits specified by the EP
functional CETP
Rules Rules
Location of Drawl, as per CGWA / CGWB Regulations
Safe Semi-critical Critical Over-exploited Notified
6
Meaning that any wastewater generated is recycled and any non-recycled water is disposed without discharge, through an appropriate means such as thermal destruction
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7
Rules Rules
Accidental Discharge
Negligible leakages of Moderate leakages of Major leakages of Heavy leakage that can
Minor but frequent leakages
chemicals/oil that only chemicals/oil that may chemicals/oil that adversely contaminate
of chemicals/oil that require
require periodic contaminate groundwater if contaminate groundwater groundwater and must
provision safety measures
maintenance for both proper safety measures not if safety measures not require urgent remediation
and proper maintenance
storage / transport routes provided provided actions
Loss up to 80% topsoil, or Loss up to 100% topsoil, or
Loss of up to 20% topsoil,
Loss of up to 40% topsoil, Loss of up to 60% topsoil, actual or possible actual or possible
or minor contamination of
or actual or possible or actual or possible contamination of soil contamination of soil
soil that can be easily
6 Soil Quality contamination of soil contamination of soil volume >25 m3 and above volume >25 m3 and above
restored close to original
volume <25 m3 but below volume <25 m3 but above Dutch Intervention Values, Dutch Intervention Values7,
condition for volume <10
Dutch Intervention Values Dutch Intervention Values but not deemed to require and deemed to require
m3
urgent remediation urgent remediation
Minor impact on flora/fauna Significant changes in floral Some loss or widespread Long term and significant
Insignificant Environmental
and habitats, but no and faunal diversity. destruction to significant change in population or
Impact. Occasional damage
Ecology and Bio- negative impacts on Population and habitat area of land. habitat with negative
7.1 of flora and fauna. Some
diversity: Terrestrial ecosystem function. Disruption to, or some Destruction of rare flora impact on ecosystem
disturbance to flora and
Temporary impact impact on rare flora or and its habitat or function.
fauna habitats.
(< 1 month or site fauna, but not resulting in ecosystem. Widespread destruction to a
7
Source: Ministry of Housing Spatial Planning and the Environment, Netherlands; Soil Remediation Circular 2009, Annex A.
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7
preparation phase) to floral eradication of rare species. Long term and significant significant area of land, rare
habitats. Non persistent but possibly change in population or flora and fauna.
Destruction of local species widespread damage to land. habitat with negative
density during clearance of Disturbance to bird impact on ecosystem
site. habitation, damage that can function.
be remediated without long Continuous and serious
term loss. damage by erosion or to
Localized persistent flora or fauna.
damage; or significant The project activity within
temporary damage to 10km of NP/WS/RF/PF and
ecosystem. other eco-sensitive area).
Rare, endangered or any
scheduled species present
within 10km of the project
area.
Significant localized impacts
but without long term Significant widespread
Impact on aquatic impact on Phytoplankton, impact on protected Damage to an extensive
ecosystem, including flora, zooplankton habitat. wildlife portion of aquatic
Occasional short term fauna and habitat but not Temporary impact on (corals/mangroves/turtles/ ecosystem resulting in
Ecology and Bio-
7.2 impact and / or disruption destruction to species benthos ecosystem or any marine mammals). severe impacts on aquatic
diversity: Aquatic
to aquatic flora and fauna. diversity or density. fisheries ecosystem. Significant impact on population and habitats and
Some loss of fisheries mangroves habitat or long term impact on
Presence of Fish< 5 species. ecosystem. Presence of Fish > 10 aquatic habitat.
Presence of Fish 6 – 10 species.
species.
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7
Possible Temporary or Permanent Migration, Persons as a % of Population of Study Area
Socio-economic <0.5% <1% <1.5% <2% 2.5%
Environment: Social Possible Change in Ethnicity, vis-à-vis Major Existing Ethnicities Present in Study Area
Aspects - give the
Not Likely Possible Limited Significant Severe
8.1 mean score from the
Gender Imbalance, as a Proportion to Existing Sex-Ratio
categories, rounded
to the nearest Not Likely Possible Limited Significant Severe
decimal Possibility of Return to Original Status in Terms of Any or All of the Above Changes
<1 year <2 years <3 years <5 years Permanent Change
No of Jobs Gained or Lost
Socio-economic <50 Up to 75 Up to 100 Up to 250 Up to 500 or more
Environment: Persons Having Loss or Gain in Income
Economic Aspects -
<50 100 250 500 1000 or more
8.2 give the mean score
Land Losers
from the categories,
rounded to the <10 <20 <50 <100 >100
nearest decimal Losers of Homesteads
<5 <10 <25 <50 >50
Major damage to
Minor repairable damage to Moderate damage to
structures/ items of Irreparable damage to
structures/ items of cultural structures/ items of cultural
Socio-economic Minor repairable damage to cultural significance, or highly valued structures/
8.3 significance, or minor significance, or significant,
Aspects: Cultural commonplace structures major infringement of items/ locations of cultural
infringements of cultural infringement of cultural
cultural values/sacred significance or sacred value
values values/ sacred location
locations
Consequence Distance
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7
Major injury of health
Minor injury or health effects (including permanent
Slight injury or health effects- Affecting work disability) - Affecting work
effects (including first aid performance, e.g. restriction performance in the longer Single fatality or
Multiple Fatalities-From an
case and medical treatment to activities, or need to take term. e.g. prolonged permanent total disability-
9.1 Risk to People accident of occupational
case). Not affecting work a time off work to recover. absence from work. from an accident or
illness
performance or causing Limited, reversible health Irreversible health damage occupational illness
disability effects e.g. skin irritation, without loss of life, e.g.
food poisoning noise induced hearing loss,
chronic back injuries
Massive effect-Persistent
Major effect- Severe severe environmental
Minor effect- contamination. Localized effect- Limited
environmental damage. damage or severe nuisance
Damage sufficiently large to loss of discharges of known
Slight Effect- Local The company is required to extending over a large
attack the environment. toxicity. Repeated exceeding
Environment damage. take extensive measures to area. In terms of
Single exceeding of of statutory or prescribed
9.2 Risk to Environment Within the fence and within restore polluted or commercial or recreational
statutory or prescribed limit. Affecting
system. Negligible financial damaged environment to use or nature conservation,
criterion. Single complaint. neighborhood. Spontaneous
consequences its original state. Extended a major economic loss for
No permanent effect on the recovery of limited damage
exceeding of statutory or the company. Constant,
environment within one year
prescribed limits high exceeding of statutory
or prescribed limits
After identifying the consequence severity as shown inTable 4-1, the probability of occurrence
also needs to be estimated to arrive at a complete picture of environmental impact risk. Table
4-2 provides probability / likelihood ratings on a scale of 1-5. These ratings are used for
estimating the likelihood of each occurrence.
The level of environmental impact risk is calculated by multiplying the consequence score and the
probability of occurrence together. Thus
The final score is in relative point score, rather than actual impact.Table 4-3 below assigns
significance criteria, based on the scale of 1-25, used for prioritizing mitigation measures for
reducing the environmental impact risks and thereafter, formulating and implementing
Environmental Management Plans (EMPs).
To do this, environmental impact risk levels are first scored and identified as mentioned earlier and
then evaluated on the evaluation scale that follows in Table 4-3.
8
Based on published failure data, per recognized failure unit (such as km-years, unit of operation or others).
Environmental risks are now clubbed into four levels from extreme risk to low risk activities.
Extreme risk activities are unacceptable and therefore need to be either stopped or modified such
that they are brought to a lower level of environmental risk.
High and moderate risk activities, although acceptable, require being evaluated and mitigated in a
manner that their consequences / probabilities are lowered, with more focus on high risk activities
vis-à-vis moderate risk activities. Low risk activities do not require further mitigation. This is
summarized in Table 4-4.
5. Mitigation Measures
Mitigation measures require being formulated and implemented for all high risk and moderate risk
activities. A programme to implement all mitigation measures is then prepared and presented as
an Environmental Management Program.
Based on this above identification of impacts, environmental indices that are likely to be impacted
due to the project are:
4.3 Landuse
There will be no change in landuse/landcover of the area as the land is allotted by GIDC, which is
already an industrial land.
Clearance of land
Potential Environmental Impacts on
S. No. Project Activities / Aspects
Landuse/ Landcover (LU/LC)
1 Land Acquisition
1.1 Land lease or purchase Brown field project within GIDC area
2 Preparation of Site
2.1 Clearance of site and preparing for approach road Change in land use
Construction Phase Construction Phase
Excavation and paving of site Excavation and paving of site
The project site covers total 9 hectares of land. There will be change in land use/cover pattern
typically from scrub and agricultural land to built-up land i.e. industrial area as given in Table 5-4.
The project site approach roads are developed so there will be no land acquisition. But the internal
roads within the project boundary will be developed, this aspect is being considered in
construction of site.
Construction Phase
The excavation work and filling of foundation activity will alter the topology of the site which will
have minor impact on land use.
Considering the above impact as well as the operating and other conditions mentioned above, the
likely impact scores on land environment are mentioned in Table 4-6.
The impact scoring results shows that only one activity comes under moderate severe wherein
activity can operate subject to management and or modification.
During the construction phase the activities that can cause potential impacts on air quality are as
follows:
Dust and air emission particularly due to the excavation. Construction of production facility
and movement of vehicles.
Particulate emission due to machinery and instrument operation for cleaning and construction
works.
Fumes and gases near the work area due to welding & cutting activities.
Dust emission due to removal of scrap materials, remaining and waste construction materials,
construction machinery, dismantling and removal of temporary structures, site cleaning and
disposal of these materials.
Impacts on ambient air during operation phase would be due to emissions from flue gas stacks
(10 Nos) and process vents (16 Nos.).
Emissions were analyzed for their impacts on the GLC for various distances using the dispersion
modeling guidelines given by the Central Pollution Control Board, New Delhi and the dispersion
modeling software AREMOD of the United States Environment Protection Agency (USEPA).
Source of Emissions
The stack details and gas emission from Flue Gas stacks details are given inTable 4-7and from
Process vents are given in Table 4-8.
Table 4-7: Stacks Details and Gas Emission Details from Flue Gas Stacks
Stack
Required Proposed Stack Exit Stack Stack Stack SO2 PM10 NOx
Stack Stack Dia. Fuel
Stack Attached to Stack Stack Velocity, Exit Exhaust, Exhaust, Emitted, Emitted, Emitted,
No. Nos. (Top), Used
Ht., m Ht., m m/s Temp, oK m3/s Nm3/s gm/sec gm/sec gm/sec
m
When NG will be used as Fuel
Boiler (3 Nos.
1 Working and 1 No. 3 22.4 40 0.8 10 423 5.03 3.54 NG 0.0025 0.0001 0.3285
Stand by)
Thermic Fluid Heater
2 4 15.7 30 0.3 10 423 0.71 0.50 NG 0.0008 0.00004 0.0462
(4 Nos.)
Diesel Generator (2
3 2 9.2 15 0.3 10 423 0.08 0.06 NG 0.0006 0.00003 0.0055
Nos.)
Air Heater for Drying
4 1 1.9 15 0.3 5 423 0.08 0.06 NG 0.0008 0.00004 0.0055
Material
When FO/HSD will be used as Fuel
Boiler (3 Nos.
1 Working and 1 No. 3 22.4 40 0.8 10 423 5.03 3.54 FO 2.64 0.1181 0.3285
Stand by)
Thermic Fluid Heater
2 4 15.7 30 0.3 10 423 0.71 0.50 FO 0.81 0.0361 0.0462
(4 Nos.)
Diesel Generator (2
3 2 9.2 15 0.3 10 423 0.08 0.06 HSD 0.14 0.0028 0.0055
Nos.)
Table 4-8: Stack Details and Gas Emission Details from Process Vents
Stack Stack Exit Pollutant
Stack Stack Stack Exit
Stack Attached to Dia. Velocity, Emitted,
No. Ht., m Temp, oK
(Top), m m/s gm/sec
Hydro Carbon (HC)
Storage of ethylene
1 oxide/propylene oxide/Reaction 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0001
vessel
Storage of ethylene
2 oxide/propylene oxide/Reaction 23 0.125 250 377 0.0005
vessel
Ester Reactor/DMS Storage
3 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0001
Tank
4 Lab Fume Hood 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0005
5 Lab Fume Hood 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0005
6 Lab Fume Hood 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0005
7 Ester Reaction 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0005
Sulphur Oxides (SOx)
8 Sulphonation reaction vessel 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0003
Hydrogen Chloride (HCl)
9 Sulphation reaction vessel 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0001
POCl3 Storage Tank/Reaction
10 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0001
Vessel
Epichlorohydrin Storage and
11 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0001
Reactor Vessel
Ammonia (NH3)
12 Sulphation Neutralization Vessel 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0012
13 Ammonia Storage Tank 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0012
Particulate Matter (PM)
14 Spray Drier Bag Filter 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0011
15 Spray Drier Bag Filter 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0011
16 Spray Drier Bag Filter 15 0.20 1.20 318 0.0011
Assumptions
The emission rate for SO2 was calculated based on sulphur content in the fuel and emission
rate of NOx was calculated based on statutory limit of 50 ppm for all stacks.
Stability class was evaluated based on solar insulation and cloud cover.
The mathematical equations used for the dispersion modeling assumes that the earth surface
acts as a perfect reflector of plume and physic-chemical processes such as dry and wet
deposition and chemical transformation of pollutants are negligible.
Study has been conducted for Winter Season of year 2014-15. The stack emission concentrations
used for dispersion modeling were taken as per CPCB guidelines issued for conducting air quality
modeling. The meteorological data collected from IMD for winter Season was used for dispersion
modeling.
Results
The incremental increase in GLC of SOx, NOx, PM, HC, HCl & NH3 due to proposed manufacturing
activity is presented inTable 4-9. The worst combined environmental situation is predicted as the
sum of maximum monitored value of a parameter and the incremental GLC at the monitoring
location. This is a conservative estimate and probability of such occurrence is unlikely. The
predicted results are summarized below. Further detailed results and Isopleth in Annexure 8.
It is observed that:
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for SO2 when NG and HSD will be used as fuel is
observed to be 0.064 µg/m3. These GLC’s are expected to occur at a distance of 500m from
the source towards the SW direction.
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for SO2 when FO and HSD will be used as fuel is
observed to be 34.20 µg/m3. These GLC’s are expected to occur at a distance of 250 m from
the source towards the SW direction.
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for NOx when NG and HSD will be used as fuel is
observed to 1.37 µg/m3. These GLC’s are expected to occur at a distance of 250 m from the
source towards the SE direction.
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for NOx when FO and HSD will be used as fuel is
observed to 1.27 µg/m3. These GLC’s are expected to occur at a distance of 250 m from the
source towards the SE direction.
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for PM when NG and HSD will be used as fuel is
observed to be 0.148 µg/m3. These GLC’s are expected to occur at a distance of 250 m from
the source towards the SW direction.
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for PM when FO and HSD will be used as fuel is
observed to be 1.59 µg/m3. These GLC’s are expected to occur at a distance of 250 m from
the source towards the SW direction.
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for HC is observed to be 0.41 µg/m3. These GLC’s are
expected to occur at a distance of 250 m from the source towards the SW direction.
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for HCl is observed to be 0.06 µg/m3. These GLC’s are
expected to occur at a distance of 250 m from the source towards the SSE direction.
The maximum 24 hourly average GLC’s for NH3 is observed to be 0.074 µg/m3. These GLC’s
are expected to occur at a distance of 250 m from the source towards the SW direction.
Name of Village/ Average Monitored When NG and HSD will be used as Fuel When FO and HSD will be used as Fuel
S. Industry Baseline Total Total Predictive GLC Total Total Predictive GLC
Pollutant
No. (Distance in km/ Concentration Incremental GLC for proposed project Incremental GLC for proposed project
Direction) (µg/m3) (µg/m3) (µg/m3) (µg/m3) (µg/m3)
HCl <1 0.01 < 1.01 0.01 < 1.01
NH3 < 20 0.02 < 20.02 0.02 < 20.02
SOx 7.8 0.002 7.802 1.62 9.42
NOx 17.8 0.06 17.86 0.05 17.85
At Radha-Madhav Site PM 67 0.004 67.004 0.07 67.07
5
(1.0/S) HC 1214 0.01 1214.01 0.01 1214.01
HCl <1 0.001 < 1.001 0.001 < 1.001
NH3 < 20 0.001 < 20.001 0.001 < 20.001
SOx 8.9 0.003 8.903 1.18 10.08
NOx 18.8 0.04 18.84 0.04 18.84
At Labour Colony PM 76 0.006 76.006 0.05 76.05
6
(1.37/NNW) HC 1060 0.1 1060.1 0.1 1060.1
HCl <1 0.01 < 1.01 0.01 < 1.01
NH3 < 20 0.009 < 20.009 0.009 < 20.009
Considering the above mitigation measures as well as the operating and other conditions
mentioned in the above sections, the impact scores on air environment is presented in Table
4-10 as below:
Table 4-10: Impact Scoring of Air Environment
Impact Scoring
Code Impacting Activity Remarks
C P CxP
Preparation at Site
It is a Greenfield project, Road
Preparation of site and
1 1 3 3 Network is well maintained up-to
approach roads
the site; Low risk
Vehicle movement for
2 transportation of materials and 1 2 2 Low risk
equipment
Installation of Plant
3 Excavation work 1 2 2 Low Risk
4 Filling of foundation 1 2 2 Low Risk
Heavy fabrication work including
5 metal cutting (Gas cutting, 1 2 2 Low Risk
welding)
6 Painting 1 2 2 Low Risk
7 Final Clearing of site 1 2 2 Low Risk
8 Usage of Energy and Power 1 2 2 Low Risk
Operation Phase
Storage and Handling of
9 1 5 5 Moderate risk
Chemicals
Transportation of Raw Materials
10 1 5 5 Moderate risk
and Products
11 Production 1 5 5 Moderate risk as NG will be used
Operation of Boiler and Thermic as primary fuel and adequate
12 1 5 5 stack height will be provided to
Fluid heater
boilers, thermic fluid heaters, DG
13 Operation of DG Set& Air Heater 1 4 4 Sets and Air Heater. Scrubbers
and bag filter will be provided to
Impact Scoring
Code Impacting Activity Remarks
C P CxP
process vents
DG Sets
Pumps
Boiler
Vehicle
A list of all the impacting activities due to noise are presented earlier inTable 4-5.
The proposed project related activities will lead to emission of noise that may have moderate
impact on the surrounding communities in terms of minor increase in noise levels. The potential
impacts on noise level may arise out of the following:
For site preparation, during construction phase operation of equipment's like crane, dumper, roller,
bulldozers etc. will be used. Equipments will emit noise within permissible limits. Thus, there will
not be any adverse impact on nearby habitation due to proposed activity.
Vehicle movement for transportation of materials and work force to the site will cause minor noise
emission as the frequency of vehicular movement is few times in a week
Noise generated from Boiler, D.G. Set, etc. will have a permanent effect, if they will work for more
hours in a day.
Noise modeling study was done using the Software tool called “Sound Plan” which predicts the
Noise Map generated due to the sources present at the project site, and predicts the Noise Levels
at various receiver points due to the sources present at the project site.
To analyze the Noise Map of the project site, first, the geometrically coordinated Google Earth
images of the Project site were imported into the software. Various Sources of noise were added
with their approximate Sound Pressure Levels, and the “Receiver points” were added at various
locations where Noise Monitoring was conducted.
“SoundPlan” generates the Noise Map with colored pattern isopleths, which indicate whether or
not the SPL in that particular region is above the limits mentioned by CPCB or not. If the Limit for
Sound Pressure Level indicated by CPCB for that particular area is 75 dB during the day, and if the
predicted SPL is below that, the Noise Map will show Green Color for that area. But if the SPL is
above the “user set” allowable limit, the same will be shown in Red Color depending upon the
Difference between then Predicted SPL and the Allowable SPL, and the “Conflict” in SPL is
mentioned in the table if any conflict is predicted.
The sources considered at the project site for the analysis with their approximate SPL are
considered slightly on the higher side for more critical analysis. The sources of noise considered
are as Table 4-12.
Using above consideration the isopleths generated during daytime and nighttime are as given in
Figure 4-1 and Figure 4-2.
Observations
The SPL were predicted at different sources as mentioned above. The observations are:
1. The project site is located in a designated industrial area, where the CPCB limits defined for
Noise Levels are 75 dB during the day and 70 dB during the night. However, SPL are
considered on higher side for more critical analysis.
2. Since the sources of noise are present within the project site, near boundary wall of the
project site being present, increase beyond 75 dB at the site was not observed.
3. From Figure 4-1 and Figure 4-2, it can be observed at project site, noise is predicted in the
range of 50dB (A) -60 dB (A) which is within the permissible limit for industrial area.
The predicted noise levels along with the conflict are as given inTable 4-13.
As seen in the above table, during the day time and night time only 0.1 dB increase are noticed in
the nearby Residential area. i.e. No increase to maximum increase of 0.5 dB which is negligible
considering that the minimum increase noticeable by a human ear is 0.5 dB. Another factor to be
considered, is that SoundPlan analysis is carried out assuming that there are no obstructions (such
as trees, buildings, walls etc.) in between the receiver locations and the sources of sound, which is
not true in real conditions. Therefore, the actual results are going to be much lower than
SoundPlan’s predicted results, and hence increase of 0.1 to 0.6 dB is not likely to be noticed at any
of the noise monitoring locations.
Although there was no increase beyond the allowable limit predicted at any of the noise
monitoring locations outside the project site, the noise environment also includes the people who
are working within the project site, and who may face permanent hearing damage in case they
face the Noise Dosage beyond the allowable level of Noise. Therefore, it is important to implement
the following mitigations in order to avoid any permanent hearing damage to the people working
inside the project site.
Sound
S. Source of
Pressure Level Mitigations suggested
No. Noise
(dB)
The limit set by CPCB for DG Sets is 75 dBA for a spatial average of
16 readings taken surrounding the DG Set. It is often observed that
1 DG Sets 100 dB the Noise generated by the DG set exceeds the CPCB limit.
In the above case, Acoustical Enclosure with 30+ dB should be
implemented for the Acoustical Enclosure.
Depending upon capacity, Pumps have noise levels ranging in
75~95 dB
For pumps with noise levels below 85 dB, no mitigation measures
2 Pumps 75~95 dB are required.
For pumps with Noise Levels within 85~95 dB i.e. for Large capacity
pumps, Acoustical Enclosures with 10~15 dB Transmission Loss
Ratings are recommended.
All safety blow-off cocks should be installed with Safety-Valve
Silencers of Insertion Loss Rating of at least 25 dB.
All boiler Feed pumps should be installed with an Acoustical
3 Boiler 95 dB Enclosure of 30 dB Transmission Loss Rating for the pump and the
motor combined.
Silencers should be used anywhere and everywhere where there is
blow-off of high-pressure steam.
Vehicular The SPL for regular vehicle movement is below 70 dB and no
4 < 70 dB
Movement mitigations are necessary for this source of noise.
Trucks can get noisy and generate SPL up to 90 dB. The only
mitigation possible for this source is to do regular maintenance of
Trucks the trucks and keep their Sound Levels at lowest possible levels.
5 < 85 dB
Movement In case any kind of Loading/Unloading is involved, the
loading/unloading should not be done during the night time, during
which it may cause more disturbance to the surrounding.
4.5.4 Conclusion
From above, it can be concluded that, due to noise generated from the proposed project there will
not be any impact on the monitoring locations.
As seen in theTable 4-13, Predicted increase is maximum 0.6 dB during the day and 4.3 dB
during the night in Industrial area and 0.dB during the day and 0.6 dB during the night time in
Residential area according to SoundPlan analysis. This increase is negligible considering that the
minimum noticeable increase by a human ear is 0.5 dB.
Impact identification
No adverse impact on groundwater. However, use of surface water from Narmada River will
deplete water resource.
Impact on ground water due to Leakage during chemicals transportation, storage of chemicals and
storage of hazardous waste.
The impact scores on ground water environment are likely to be as mentioned in Table 4-14.
Mitigation measures
There in not any significant impact on groundwater due to proposed project activities.
For the proposed unit the required water will be sourced from GIDC, Dahej. The end source of
water is Narmada water. In proposed speciality chemicals manufacturing plant, fresh water
consumption will be 301 KLD. Water conservation plan will be carried out at site to reduce fresh
water demand and conserve water resources. So no major impact on water sources.
The effluent generation from the proposed unit will be treated in proposed ETP and treated water
will be disposed into GIDC drain meeting the norms for effluent discharge into sea. The domestic
sewage will be treated in STP at site and treated sewage will be used for gardening to reduce
fresh water requirements. No any untreated water will be disposed of outside the plant area to
avoid impact on surface water quality.
Likely impact scores on surface water environment and Hazardous waste management are
presented in Table 4-15.
Low impact.
1.3 Usage of Water 2 2 4
Adequate measures to be taken to
reduce fresh water demand.
2 Operation Phase
Low impact as proper care shall be
Transportation of Raw taken during raw material
2.1 2 2 4
Materials and Products transportation and handling to avoid
spillage and leakage.
Low impact as proper storage with
Storage and Handling of bundling will be provided to avoid
2.2 2 2 4
Chemicals runoff contamination and also to avoid
leakage and spillage problem.
Moderate impact as wastewater will be
treated in proposed ETP and STP and
Wastewater generation
2.3 4 3 12 reused in plant premises which will
during Production Activity
reduced the overall fresh water
demand.
Moderate impact as proper storage
Hazardous waste
facility will be provided at site and
2.4 generation during 3 4 12
disposed at approved TSDF site as per
Production Activity
hazardous waste management rules.
High impact. Adequate measures to be
taken to reduce the fresh water
2.5 Usage of Water 4 5 20 demand. Water conservation practice
shall be adopted to conserve natural
water resources.
Low impact as DG set will be operate
during power failure only and used oil
2.6 Operation of DG Set 2 2 4 generated from the DG set will store in
a drum and handed over to authorized
vendor.
Impact Scoring
S. No. Impacting Activity Remarks
C P CxP
Moderate impact as the wastewater
generated will be segregated at source
and treated in ETP followed by RO. The
permeate form RO will be recycled and
Wastewater Treatment & RO reject will be disposed into GIDC
2.7 3 4 12
disposal drain as per norms given by PCB. By
recycling and reuse of treated water,
overall fresh water requirement will
reduce and which will beneficial impact
as natural resource will conserve.
C Decommissioning Phase
Dismantling of structures
2.5 2 1 2 Minor impact
of the project components
C: Consequence; P: Probability; CxP: Final Score
Following mitigation measures will be implemented to reduce surface water related impacts:
Treated water will be recycled and reused in plant premises. Condensate recovery where ever
possible has been taken in to design.
Proper operation and maintenance of effluent treatment plant will be done to ensure meeting
specified disposal standards and also no discharge of untreated waste water on land, avoiding
leakages;
Independent storm water drainage from effluent drainage is suggested to avoid any contamination
of surface water sources;
All chemical and fuel storage and handling areas will be provided with proper bunds to avoid run-
off contamination.
Hazardous Wastes will be properly handled in containers and properly stored in hazardous waste
storage areas as per rules and also bunding will be provided to avoid overflow of spillage waters
which can contaminate the surroundings.
All solid and hazardous waste will be disposed as per the conditions /rules given by the SPCB.
Impact Scoring
Code Impacting Activity Basis of scoring
C P CxP
C: Consequence; P: Probability; C x P: Final Score
As far as soil quality is concern, it is clear that the proposed project will have only minimal impact
over it. Thus there are no mitigation measures suggested for this. However, Soil salinity (EC) and
pH need to be monitored for soil brought from outside and likely to be used for green belt.
Construction Phase
Operation Phase
Disturbance of herbs and shrubs due
Transportation of Raw
C2 to leakage or spillage of chemicals at ●
Materials and Products
hose connection
This includes,
Hazards Identification,
Selection of Potential Loss Scenarios,
Simulation of release source model, and
Plotting of contour maps
A detailed risk assessment and consequence analysis study is presented in chapter 7 i.e. Additional
Studies of this report (please refer Section 7.1).
On the basis of that study MLCs (as shown in Table 7-7) have been selected and studied. On the
basis of the outcomes of the study a detailed impact scoring was under taken and presented in
Table 4-20, including the following general safety measures and mitigation measures.
Table 4-20: Impact Scoring of Occupational Health, Community Health and Safety
Impact Scoring Basis of
Code Impacting Activity Mitigation Measures
C P C×P Scoring
Considering the various chemicals handled and stored at site; following safety measures will be
provided at the site.
Ecology and Biodiversity: Adverse impact on ecology and bio-diversity due to leakage
during chemicals transportation and storage. Beneficial impact on ecology as sufficient
greenbelt will be developed.
Socio – Economic: Positive impact due to creation of temporary jobs and increase in
indirect income.
Operational Phase
Transportation of (Activity has Minor Benefits)
2.1 Raw Materials and 1 4 4 Employment generation will be accompanied by
Products minor effect on existing roads.
Production of
(Activity has Minor Benefits)
Amines, Amines
2.2 1 4 4 Employment generation will be accompanied by
Derivatives and
minor effect on existing socio-economic condition.
Acetonitrile Plant
(Activity has Minor Benefits)
Social up-liftment
1 4 4 Employment generation will be accompanied by
2.3 activities
minor effect on existing socio-economic condition.
C: Consequence; P: Probability; C x P: Final Score
Note: The socio-economic impact scoring has been based on considering two assumptions which
are as follows:
Based on the socio-economic survey and stakeholders consultation the following social concerns
have been identified with respect to the general condition of the nearby residents/villages of study
area. The suggestive mitigation measures has been reflected in the undermentioned table. The
CSR activities with budgetary provisions has been shown in Table 4-23.
The project proponent has earmarked INR 25 Lacs per year with 10% increase in the amount each
year against the social corporate responsibility for the development of the villages at the project
site.
The activities has been identified under the following heads and budget has been allocated for the
five years.
As per the result of social survey, utmost care will be taken for the overall development of the
study area. The above budget breakup is the tentative plan for investment which may vary from
time to time depending upon the priority of the CSR activity.
* A list of identified activities location wise has been attached as Annexure 11.
5 ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES
Based on current market demand projections, plant at Thane site will be running to capacity in
coming years. To meet these demands, it is proposed to put up another manufacturing unit in
India. There is no adjacent land available to current site for this expansion. Below are some of the
key considerations for alternate site selection:
Ethylene Oxide (EO) is one of the key RM for Croda. EO is very hazardous, toxic, flammable and
explosive material. There are limited sources of EO in India and EO transportation is a significant
safety risks. Croda has evaluated various locations for alternate site (sites close to EO production
such as Nagothne, Dahej, Hazira, etc) and based on safety and environmental considerations have
chosen Dahej site to develop second manufacturing unit in India.
Proposed location is very close to Reliance Dahej unit, which is an EO supplying unit. Another EO
supplying unit at Reliance Hazira is also within close reach as a backup source.
Special attention has been given to area legacy issues before developing manufacturing site there.
Considering plot at Dahej has never been used for manufacturing activities before weighs positive
for selection. Croda has additionally conducted Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) to measure
possible contamination level at allotted plot to benchmark initial contamination level.
To minimize environmental impacts, special consideration was given for areas in organized
Industrial Estates. Since these areas will have shared infrastructures like CETP, utility supplies etc,
having a manufacturing unit in this area will have lesser negative impact.
Based on current demand patterns, Thane site will be running out of capacity in coming 2-5 years.
There is not much scope to expand capacity further at Thane site. It is therefore planned to
develop a second manufacturing site to cater to market demand in near future and develop new
capabilities in long term.
Selection of location of new manufacturing site also depends on connectivity to suppliers and
customers. Considering Dahej is developed as a special investment region for Chemicals and
Petrochemicals, major chemical industries, including suppliers and customers to Croda, are also
developing their manufacturing units in this region. Proximity to those will not only optimize supply
chain but also will also bring other business and environmental benefits.
Below is a broad level comparative summary of various sites evaluated for expansion:
Based on above comparision project proponent had acquired a GIDC plot in Dahej Phase 2 for a
green field site.
Hazardous Quantity
S. Collection, Treatment
Type of Waste Waste MT per Source
No. / Disposal
Category Year
Croda has also explored the possibilities for Co-processing of the hazardous waste prior to disposal
into TSDF/CHWIF and has taken acceptance letter from M/s. Ambuja Cement for co-processing
the hazardous waste. Copy of acceptance letter is given in Figure 2-15.
8 PROJECT BENEFITS
Croda India Company Private Limited is a global supplier of speciality chemicals which includes
consumer care manufacturing personal care products for Skin care, sun care, hair care, baby care,
colour cosmetics, male grooming, bath and shower and antiperspirants etc, among others. M/s Croda
aims to expand its horizons further in India and abroad by expanding its capacities. These products
will serve to cut the supply of imports from foreign countries thus saving currency and at the same
time will earn valuable foreign currency by export of products.
Environmental cost benefit analysis has not been recommended at the scoping stage, and has
therefore not been carried out.
10.1 Purpose
The Environment Management Plan (EMP) is prepared with a view to facilitate effective
environmental management of the project, in general and implementation of the mitigation
measures in particular. The EMP provides a delivery mechanism to address potential adverse
impacts and to introduce standards of good practice to be adopted for all project works. For each
stage of the programme, the EMP lists all the requirements to ensure effective mitigation of every
potential biophysical and socio-economic impact identified in the EIA. For each impact or
operation, which could otherwise give rise to impact, the following information is presented:
Table 10-2.
Table 10-2: Environment Management Plan for Air Environment
Objective To ensure that air emissions due to the site preparation, installation of proposed project and operation phase will be minimum
Concern Site preparation, installation of manufacturing facility and operation phase can deteriorate air quality
Benefit of EMP Reduced air pollution and protection of health of workers and local community
Mitigation Implementation and Management
Impacting
Measures and Remarks
Activities Location Timing Responsibility Monitoring Records
Rationale
Once in a day
Sprinkling of water Random checks
Preparation of At the site during the Water consumption records
which lead to dust Contractor by Site -
Site only construction of Ambient air monitoring
suppression Engineer
plant
Vehicle
Ensure that vehicles Along the
movement for Checks by
have a Pollution vehicle
transportation of At all times Contractor security staff at PUC Certificate -
Under Control (PUC) movement
materials and the entry gate
Certificate track
equipment
Once a day
Sprinkling of water Random checks
during the Water consumption records
Excavation work which lead to dust At Site Contractor by Site -
excavation Ambient air monitoring
suppression Engineer
process
Sprinkling of water Once a day Random checks
Filling of Water consumption records
which lead to dust At site during the filling Contractor by Site -
foundation Ambient air monitoring
suppression of foundation Engineer
Adequate safety Once in a day Random checks Periodic Workplace air quality Proper personnel
Painting At site Contractor
measures along with during by Site monitoring& Analysis reports protective
Objective To ensure that air emissions due to the site preparation, installation of proposed project and operation phase will be minimum
Concern Site preparation, installation of manufacturing facility and operation phase can deteriorate air quality
Benefit of EMP Reduced air pollution and protection of health of workers and local community
Mitigation Implementation and Management
Impacting
Measures and Remarks
Activities Location Timing Responsibility Monitoring Records
Rationale
spill control installation of Engineer workplace monitoring equipment to be
mechanism plant worn by workers
at all times
Sprinkling of water Once a day Random checks
Final Clearing of
which lead to dust At site during the Final Contractor by Site Water consumption records -
site
suppression Clearing of site Engineer
Adequate safety
Proper personnel
measures, adequate At all time, EHS & Ambient air monitoring
Use of energy Periodic stack protective
stack height will be At site during the Maintenance records, stack monitoring
and power monitoring equipment to be
adopted while using operation department records
used
DG Set
Ensure that vehicles Along the
Checks by
have a Pollution vehicle Croda’s safety
At all times security staff at PUC Certificate
Under Control (PUC) movement department
the entry gate
Certificate track
Transportation of
Type of chemicals, operating
raw materials and Proper personnel
Adequate safety condition of chemicals
products protective
measures along with During EHS Periodic transported, Periodic
At site equipment to be
spill control Transportation Department monitoring Workplace air quality
worn by workers
mechanism monitoring
at all times
Record of leak detection
Production of Adequate safety
Proper personnel
Alkoxylates measures, adequate At all time, EHS & Ambient air monitoring
Periodic stack protective
(Ethoxylated / stack height and At site during the Maintenance records, stack monitoring
monitoring equipment to be
Propoxylated scrubbers will be operation department records
used
Products), Ester & provided
Objective To ensure that air emissions due to the site preparation, installation of proposed project and operation phase will be minimum
Concern Site preparation, installation of manufacturing facility and operation phase can deteriorate air quality
Benefit of EMP Reduced air pollution and protection of health of workers and local community
Mitigation Implementation and Management
Impacting
Measures and Remarks
Activities Location Timing Responsibility Monitoring Records
Rationale
Quats and
Sulphates &
Sulphonates
Proper personnel
Adequate safety At all time, EHS & Ambient air monitoring
Operation of DG Periodic stack protective
measures, adequate At site during the Maintenance records, stack monitoring
set monitoring equipment to be
stack height operation department records
used
Details of expected impact from various activities, and its management plan are given in Table 10-3.
Table 10-3: Details of Activities responsible for Impact on Water Environment and Management Plan
Objective To reduce surface water pollution
Concern Pollution to surface water
Benefit of EMP Surface water quality will not be impacted by the proposed activity
No forest area is being acquired for the project since it is an industrial area under development
hence, it is not mandatory for the project proponents to develop greenbelt. However, for
improvement of environment and as per ToR greenbelt development around the perimeter of
various project appurtenances be implemented.
Depending upon the topo-climatological conditions and regional ecological status, selection of the
appropriate plant species shall be made. The various criteria adopted for selecting the species for
greenbelt development are
Plant should be fast growing
Preferably perennial and evergreen
Indigenous
Resistant to NOx and dust pollution and
Should maintain the ecological and hydrological balance of the region
Trees growing up to 10 m or above in height with perennial foliage should be planted around
the proposed project.
Planting of trees should be undertaken in appropriate encircling rows around the project site.
Trees should also be planted along the road side in such a way that there is no direct sight to
inside premises and regasification plant when viewed from a point outside the foliage
perimeter
Generally fast growing trees should be planted.
Taking into consideration the above parameters, the greenbelt development plan has been
evolved for proposed site to reduce the pollution levels to the maximum possible extent. The
proposed green belt is depicted inTable 10-6.
The maintenance of the plantation area will also be done by the project proponents. The cost of
plantation is depicted in Table 10-8. The species recommended for greenbelt development are
listed inTable 10-6.
Roadside plantation plays a very important role for greening the area, increasing the shady area,
increasing aesthetic value and for eco-development of the area. The approach roads to project
site, hospitals, etc. can be planted with flowering trees. Project proponent should encourage
plantation outside the plant boundary.
Adequate care should be taken to encourage greenbelt development on the road side, however to
uplift the regional ecosystem of the area by greenbelt development, all the voluntary organizations
should take initiative to encourage massive plantation along the roadside. Trees can be planted
to increase aesthetic value as well as shady area along the roads. The selected plant species are
mentioned in Table 10-7for Roadside plantation.
10.6.3 Budget
A budgetary cost prepared for green belt development as shown inTable 10-8. Capital cost has
been calculated and the same time recurring cost per annum also mentioned which may continue
for subsequent four years.
10.7.1 Noise
Noise will be regularly monitored plant boundary for checking compliance against environmental
noise parameters as per CPCB norms. It will also be monitored near noise generating equipment
to ensure that all noise generating equipment do not emit noise in excess of the statutory norms.
All workmen will be provided with required set of PPEs like ear plug, ear muff etc. where noise
levels in excess of 80 db (A) are regularly generated.
Preventive maintenance of noise generating equipment shall be regularly carried out to ensure
that noise levels are minimized to the extent possible. To the extent feasible, equipment will be
purchased considering noise generation as one of the parameters.
10.7.2 Heat
The project does not envisage conditions that could lead to excess heating. Consequently, special
requirements for protection against heat stress are not anticipated. However, the following shall
be carried out:
The possibility of suspended particles going into the body of the workmen, either in the form of
inhalation, ingestion or through skin absorption are least and negligible as because the entire
operation at the plant will be performed under closed loop condition, right from charging till
discharging, hence it’s a rare possibility that the workmen will come in direct contact with raw
material or final goods.
At the same time the level of SPM and RPM will definitely be of least and nominal value. But even
though the same will be under closed monitoring and periodical surveillance as per EIA norms and
applicable legislations and any minor deviation from the same will be dealt immediately and will be
corrected.
Further to this all of the workmen will be provided with complete set of appropriate PPEs, like nose
musk / nose respirator, gloves, helmet, protective uniform and clothing, eye protections etc.
As per policy and norms all of the workmen are put to medical examination and testing periodically
and at set interval and based on the medical report actions are taken, if at all anything is
necessary and required. Even based on the medical examination report/feedback, workmen are
counseled and put in different area /job rotation kind of activities. Following are the periodic tests
conducted by Croda.
Physical examination
Vision
Color vision
Audiometry
Chest X-ray
ECG
Pulmonary function test
CBC
ESR
Blood sugar
Creatinine
Uric acid
Blood urea nitrogen
SGOT, SGPT, serum bilirubin,
Serum cholesterol
Urine routine microscopic
TSH
The Plant Manager will be responsible for environmental issues at plant. The responsibilities of the
various members of the environment management cell are given in Table 10-10.
Managing Director
1. Environmental policy and directions
/ Director
Overall responsibility for environmental management and decision making for all
2. Works Manager
environmental issues
Engineering Secondary responsibility for environmental management and decision making for
4.
Manager all environmental issues
Table 10-11: Capital & Recurring Cost for Environmental Pollution Control Measures on
Yearly basis
Approximate
Approximate
S. recurring cost
Head Capital cost Basis for cost estimates
No. per annum
(Rs. In Lacs)
(Rs. in lacs)
Capital Cost: 10 stacks attached to Boilers,
Thermic Fluid heaters, DG Set and air
heater. 20 lacs/stack
Cost of Scrubber: 20lacs/scrubber (9 nos.)
Air pollution
1 5.28 410 Cost of Bag filter: 15 lacs
control
Cost of steam assisted dispersion stack: 15
lacs
Recurring Cost for monitoring of stack:
2000 per stack
Capital Cost: Cost of Design, Engineering,
Water pollution Manufacture + Cost of Erection and
2 400 70
control commissioning
Recurring cost includes operating cost
Noise pollution Cost of noise monitoring : Rs. 1000 per
3 0.12 0
monitoring month
Membership fee of TSDF Site for Large
Solid and Scale industry: Rs. 0.5
hazardous Cost of providing storage area of hazardous
4 58.4 25.5
waste waste : 25 lacs
management Cost of Incinerable waste: 20000/ton
cost of Landfillable waste: 2000/ton
The recurring cost would be incurred on
Environment
hiring of consultants and payment of
5 monitoring and 2 0
various statutory fees to regulatory
management
agencies.
Croda India is responsible for manufacturing as well as sales & marketing of Croda products in the
Indian subcontinent, servicing a range of industries, including personal care, health
care/nutritional, home care, polymer additives, textiles, fibers, polymers & coatings,
agrochemicals, lubricants and general industrial applications. The product range also includes
specialty products made by group companies Sederma and Crodarom, which are mainly used in
personal care applications.
It is therefore proposed to expand manufacturing capacities at Dahej site. This will cater to the
increasing needs of our customers.
Although the project is of Category “B”, requires public hearing as GIDC Dahej is declared Notified
Industrial Estate in 2009 and as per circular number J-11013/36/2014- IA-I dated 10th December,
2014 from MoEF, public hearing is required in those industrial area which are notified after
September 14th 2006.
Total plot area for the proposed project is 1,00,039 m2, which includes 10430.76 m2 for greenbelt
development, 17715 m2 as road area, 30398 m2 as open and 23432.5 m2for future expansion.
Source
During the operation phase, the fresh water will be met from GIDC Dahej. GIDC will provide
required water to Croda India Chemicals Company Pvt. Ltd. The water conservation practice shall
be adopted to reduce fresh water demand by recycling and reuse of treated water in plant area
and by condensate recovery from the boiler. By adopting all these measures overall water demand
will be reduced so natural resource will be conserved and minimum water will be sourced from the
surface water body.
Waste Water
Waste water generation from the proposed project will be segregated at source. The effluent
generated will be treated in ETP followed by RO and permeate water from the RO will be reused in
plant area while the reject water from the RO will be discharged into GIDC drain meeting sea
discharge norms as per consent conditions.
For domestic sewage STP will be proposed and treated sewage will be recycled and reused for
greenbelt development. There will be no disposal of any untreated wastewater on land and hence
will have no adverse impact on surface water quality.
The power requirement for the proposed facility will be met through Gujarat State Electricity
Corporation Limited (GSECL). Total estimated electrical load for the proposed manufacturing unit
is around 2000 kVA.
There will be threeboiler stacks, four thermic fluid heaters stack, one air heater stack and two
other stacks attached to two different DG sets are also there. Apart from that, 16 process vents
which are attached with scrubber, steam and bag fliter as per requirement.
The hazardous waste generated except EPT Sludge and discarded containers will be sent for
incineration. The membership letter from the BEIL, Ankleshwar for hazardous waste disposal.
During the construction and Execution phase of the project, it is estimated that about ~300
workers will be involved. In addition, ancillary job creation will take place. Around ~ 500 jobs will
be direct and contractual employees created by the setting up of the project during its operational
lifecycle.
The study period for monitoring was the months of December, January and February of year
2014-15, i.e. the winter season.
The study area here is defined as the area under 10.00 km radius from the proposed plant
location.
11.6.3 Landuse
A recent satellite imagery, taken from National Remote Sensing Agency (NRSA) is being used in
the present study. After the interpretation of image a ground truth survey was conducted to check
the discrepancy of interpreted data. On the basis of that, final landuse map was prepared covering
10 km of the study area. The major portion of the land in the study area is covered by vegetation
cover i.e. ~29.13% with another ~23.77 % of land covered with agriculture land. ~6.15 % of the
land comes under the category of built-up land / habitation. Rest of the land is divided in
categories like water bodies and other wastelands.
11.6.4 Climatology
The climatological data presented on the basis of information collected by the meteorological
station set up in the study area for a period of three months.
Site specific meteorological data shows that average wind speed in winter season of year
2014-15 is 2.9 m/s and maximum wind speed of 20.8 m/s.
It can be observed that in winter season, wind blows mostly from North-East sector. Calm
wind contributes to about 9.58%.
Average temperature recorded for winter season was 23.6°C with maximum temperature of
36.7°C and minimum of 12.2°C which is a characteristic of this study area.
Ambient air monitoring was carried out at 6 locations in the study area in the month of December,
January and February of year 2014-15 i.e. the winter season. A comparison of results obtained
during monitoring with the range indicators provided by CPCB indicates the followings.
Distance in
PM2.5 (60) 24 hrs
Km from
Centre of
Project Site
Location Description
AAQM Station
At Radha-Madhav
AA 5 1.00 S 63 20 9.1 18.5 <1
Project site
At Labour colony /
AA 6 1.37 NNW 76 21 8.9 18.8 <1
Salt Pans
11.6.6 Noise
Noise levels were recorded at 5 different locations at and in the vicinity of the proposed site. The
details of ambient noise monitoring along with the results are presented in the following table.
Noise level during day time & during night time, in Industrial area & Residential area, were
observed within CPCB standards i.e. Industrial area [75 dBA (d) & 70 dBA (n)] and residential area
[55 dBA (d) & 45 dBA (n)].
Ground water samples were collected from 4 different locations covering the entire study area. On
comparison of analysis results with the limits specified following results was obtained.
Distance
Direction
from Date of Results Higher than
Code Location Source w.r.t
Project Sampling Permissible Limits
Project Site
Site in Km
TDS, Total Hardness, Total
GW 1 Jolwa Borewell 4.00 SE 20.02.2015
Alkalinity, Megnesium
GW 2 Vav Borewell 3.12 NE 20.02.2015 -
GW 3 Dahej Borewell 4.47 SW 20.02.2015 -
GW 4 Vadadla Borewell 1.38 E 20.02.2015 -
Similarly surface water samples are also collected from 6 different locations covering the entire
study area. Following observations were recorded after comparison of the analysis results with the
limits.
Distance Direction w.
Results Higher than
Code Location Source from Project r. t. Project
Permissible Limits
Site in Km Site
SW 1 Jolwa Pond 4.01 SE
SW 2 Vav Pond 3.12 NE
SW 3 Kadodara Pond 4.15 NE Total Coliform, Faecal Coliform
SW 4 Vadadla Pond 1.12 E
SW 5 Dahej Pond 4.47 SW
class SW-II as per causal water
Narmada River
marine standards i.e. Bathing,
SW 6 (D/s) nr. Estuary 6.08 SSW
Contact Water Sports and
Ambeta
Commercial Fishing
11.6.9 Soil
Soil samples were collected and analyzed observations of which are presented in following table.
Study of biological environment is one of the most important components for Environmental
Impact Assessment, in view of the need for conservation of environmental quality and biodiversity.
Ecological systems show complex inter-relationships between biotic and abiotic components
including dependence, competition and mutualism. Biotic components comprise of both plant and
animal communities which interact not only within and between themselves but also with the
abiotic components viz. physical and chemical components of the environment.
Biodiversity survey was carried out during June, 2015. Standard methodologies were followed to
assess biodiversity of Core Zone (project site) and Buffer Zone. Status of trees, herbs, shrubs,
grasses, climbers, reptiles, avifauna and mammals were assessed in the project study area.
In core zone, the vegetation mostly comprises of open scrub vegetation. Prosopis juliflora (Jangali
Babul) is observed to be dominant in the study area. In buffer zone, total of 31 plant species were
observed in the study area. Out of which 17 tree species, 5 shrubs species and 3 herbs species, 1
climber species, 1 twiner species, 2 species of grass and 2 species mangroves were observed.
There is no endemic plant observed in the study area. Since buffer zone encompasses Dahej
reserve forest. Among fauna, buffer zone was reported with 24 species of Birds, 3 species of
reptiles and 6 species of mammals. None of the reported animals are fall in Schedule I.
Impact assessment shows that there will be no major impact on the flora-fauna of the study area
except some likely impact on site specific species. Greenbelt has been designed with appropriate
plant species to mitigate this impact.
Impact Identification
During the construction phase of the project, the major activities will involve earth work
excavation, transport of construction materials, building of structures etc. These activities would
cause a general increase in levels of dust and suspended particulate matter in the ambient air.
Emission from the stacks attached to boiler, thermic fluid heater, dust collection system and
common venting system was analyzed for their impact on ground level concentration (GLC).
Dispersion modelling was carried out by using the software AERMOD.
Mitigation Measures
11.7.2 Noise
Impact Identification
Noise Modelling study was done using the Software tool called “Sound Plan” which predicts the
Noise Map generated due to the sources present at the project site, and predicts the Noise Levels
at various receiver points due to the sources present at the project site. On the basis of that it
becomes clears that, noise is predicted in the range of 55 dB(A) -65 dB(A) which is within the
permissible limit for industrial area. The predicted noise levels along with the conflict are given in
following table.
Mitigation Measures
Impact Identification
Ground water
No adverse impact on groundwater. However, use of surface water from Narmada River will
deplete water resource. Impact on ground water due to Leakage during chemicals transportation,
storage of chemicals and storage of hazardous waste.
Mitigation Measures
Ground Water
There in not any significant impact on groundwater due to proposed project activities.
Proper operation and maintenance of effluent treatment plant will be done to ensure meeting
specified disposal standards and also no discharge of untreated waste water on land, avoiding
leakages;
Independent storm water drainage from effluent drainage is suggested to avoid any contamination
of surface water sources;
All chemical and fuel storage and handling areas will be provided with proper bunds to avoid run-
off contamination.
Hazardous Wastes will be properly handled in containers and properly stored in hazardous waste
storage areas as per rules and also bunding will be provided to avoid overflow of spillage waters
which can contaminate the surroundings.
All solid and hazardous waste will be disposed as per the conditions /rules given by the SPCB.
11.7.4 Soil
As far as soil quality is concern, it is clear that the proposed project will have only minimal impact
over it. Thus there are no mitigation measures suggested for this. However, Soil salinity (EC) and
pH need to be monitored for soil brought from outside and likely to be used for green belt.
Impact Identification
The plant does not have any potential negative impact on the habitations. The Social Management
Plan (SMP) therefore concentrates on mitigation of perceived impacts during the running of plant.
Mitigation Measures
Health,
Hygiene,
Girl’s education issues.
Overall, the project would improve quality of life of the villages in the vicinity and also the
surroundings.
The project proponent has earmarked INR 25 Lacs per year with 10% increase in the amount each
year against the social corporate responsibility for the development of the villages at the project
site.
On the basis of the study of the chemical properties like flash point, phase of chemical, operating
conditions and total inventory etc following chemicals have been selected to carry out
consequence analysis.
Benzyl Chloride, Ethylene Oxide, Isopropyl alcohol, Methanol, N-Butanol and Propylene Oxide.
Major failures selected for the analysis are 10 mm& 25mm leak as maximum credible scenario and
catastrophic rupture as worst case.
Impact Identification
In case of benzyl chloride, methanol, n-butanol and isopropyl alcohol storage tanks, the effect of
pool (dyke) fire at radiation level 37.5 kW/m2 is not going out of the plant boundary.
For ethylene oxide & propylene oxide, the pool (dyke) fire at 37.5 kW/m2, explsion at 0.20 bar and
toxic dispersion at 800 ppm slightly coming out of the plant boundary.
Mitigation Measures
A comprehensive listing of the mitigation measures (actions) that Croda shall implement;
The parameters that shall be monitored to ensure effective implementation of the action;
The timing for implementation of the action to ensure that the objectives of mitigation are
fully met.
Specifically project related management plans has been prepared for air, water, noise, soil,
ecology and biodiversity, occupational health and socio-economic conditions.
11.11 Conclusion
It can be concluded from overall assessment of the impacts in terms of positive and negative
effects on various environmental components that the project activities will not have any adverse
effect on the surrounding environment.
12 DISCLOSURE OF CONSULTANTS
The company has a dedicated and experienced team of more than 200 technical staff. The team
comprise of Environmental Planners and Engineers, Chemical and Civil Engineers, Geologist, Socio-
Economic Experts, Microbiologists, Zoologists, Botanists and Industrial/Analytical Chemists. The
company’s strength lies in Project Management, Performing Risk Assessment, Formulating
Environmental Disaster Plans, Use of Satellite Imagery in Impact Assessment, Use of Mathematical
Models for Air, Water and Soil Assessment and Expertise in Public Consultation.
The group has a varied industrial clientele encompassing Indian and Multinational Companies
covering the industrial and services spectrum viz. Bulk Drugs and Pharmaceuticals, Paints,
Chemicals, Oil and Gas, Real Estate, Hospitality and Infrastructure sectors. Whilst the heart of our
clientele encompasses the top 50/Blue Chip Indian companies ( Reliance Industries, ONGC,
Infosys, ITC, ICICI, Indian Oil, GAIL, GSPC/GSPL, Sun Pharma, NTPC, Reliance Energy/Reliance
Power, Welspun and many others) who have placed implicit trust in us over the decades. We are
increasingly working with several multinationals (such as : ABB, Alstom , Areva , GM, Hindustan
Lever, Honeywell, Kohler, Sabic and Tyco amongst others) who value our deep rooted general
domain and India centric functional knowledge, reasonable costs and comparable services as
those offered by our multinational competitors. Their continued patronage is our biggest
testimonial.
The Group has branch offices at Delhi and other places in Gujarat.
KEC has received ISO 9001:2008 certification for its Quality Management System.
The company is accredited EIA Consultant organization by NABET, Quality Council of India under
EIA accreditation scheme as per mandatory requirement of the MOEF, Govt. of India for carrying
out Environmental Clearance studies. It has approved EIA coordinators and Field Area Experts for
undertaking Environmental and related studies in eleven approved sectors.
Kadam’s laboratory is accredited with NABL and also gazette by MoEF under EP Act.
NABET
Name Areas Designation Involvement / Tasks
(if any)
Bijal Assistant to EIA Assisted EIA Co-ordinator, data collection, communication
FAE ‘B’ (RH)
Kothari Co-ordinator with FAEs, compilation of EIA report
Identification of impacting activities, identification and
finalization of monitoring locations, ensuring of monitoring
Air Pollution
at all locations, checking of air quality data, EIA
Monitoring &
documentation in chapter 3 includes checking and
Control (AP)
Bhavin FAE ‘B’ (AP & compiling of AAQ results, description of mitigation
Jambucha AQ) measures, description of climate, site specific data
Preparation of emission estimate for stacks, preparation of
Air Quality
MET file, preparation of windrose diagram, running
Modeling and
AERMOD for dispersion modelling, preparation of contour
Prediction (AQ)
maps, interpretation of results
Solid and
Identification of waste generated from the industry,
Kundan Hazardous Waste
FAE ‘B’ (WP) studying adequacy of mitigation measures for
Ajudia Management
management of hazardous waste
(SHW)
Hydrogeology
Assisted in FAE report, secondary data collection, site visit,
and Water
AFAE (HG) well inventory and groundwater sampling, assisting in
Conservation
Niraj identifying impacts and suggested mitigation
(HG)
Sharma
Assisted in FAE report, secondary data collection, site visit,
Geology (GEO)
AFAE (GEO) soil sampling, , assisting in identifying impacts and
Soil (SC)
suggested mitigation
Paresha Sample analysis of water, soil and air collected from the
Laboratory -
Patel study area as per MoEF requirements.
Krunal Preparation of landuse maps of study area using GIS /
Drafts Man -
Kharva related tools
ANNEXURES
Objectives
Kadam Environmental Consultants has entrusted the work, to carry out “Satellite Data
Interpretation and Ground Observations within 10 km radius of the project site located at Dahej”
to Dr. Jessica P. Karia. The objectives of work were as mentioned below:
Supervision of present land use/cover pattern studies using satellite data of 10 km radius of
project site.
The National Remote Sensing Center (NRSC), Government of India, conducted a land use survey
using Remote Sensing Techniques in the year 1988-89 at the behest of the Planning Commission
for classifying land by visual interpretation techniques and digital techniques. NRSC’s output
resulted in a two-level system of classification, comprising seven first level of classification of land
use / landcover categories. Some of these categories required further classification, leading to a
second level of classification that resulted in further sub-categories.
This system of classification has been the basis for Kadam’s landuse / landcover studies. Whilst
these categories are generally found relevant with respect to describing landuse and landcover
classes in the Indian context, sometimes modifications are required, and made, to include
additional sub-categories which are more relevant in describing the landuse and landcover for a
particular study. Such sub-categories are defined, in any case.
The definitions for the first and second level of classification are provided in Annexure 1. A
synopsis of the above discussion is summarized and presented in following table.
Data Collection
Downloading of satellite data through FTP from NRSC website.
Quick reconnaissance survey of the study area to get a feel of the entire ground area which
can aid in the preliminary interpretation of the data.
Satellite Data
The land use/land cover mapping was carried out using digital satellite imagery procured from
NRSA, Hyderabad. Details of the satellite data are as given in table as under:
It is defined as an area of human habitation developed due to non-agricultural use and that which
has a cover of buildings, transport, communication utilities in association with water vegetation
and vacant lands.
Kadam has chosen to further define this landuse category into additional categories, namely
residential and industrial.
Residential / Commercial
Structures used by humans for living and working, but not including structures used exclusively for
manufacturing.
Industrial
Structures used for manufacturing products.
2. Agricultural Land
It is defined as the land primarily used for farming and for production of food, fibre, and other
commercial and horticultural crops. It includes land under crops (irrigated and un-irrigated), fallow
land and plantations. These are further defined.
Crop Land
It includes those lands with standing crop (per se) as on the date of the satellite imagery. The
crops may be of either Kharif (June-September) or Rabi (October – March) or Kharif Rabi seasons.
Fallow Land
It is described as agricultural land which is taken up for cultivation but is temporarily allowed to
rest un-cropped for one or more seasons, but not less than one year. These lands are particularly
those which are seen devoid of crops at the time when the imagery is taken during Rabi and
Kharif.
Plantations
Plantations are described as an area under agricultural tree crops (for e.g. mango plantations)
planted adopting certain agricultural management techniques. It includes tea, coffee, rubber,
coconut, arecanut, citrus, orchards and other horticultural nurseries.
3. Forests
It is an area (within the notified forest boundary) bearing an association predominantly of trees
and other vegetation types capable of producing timber and other forest produce. Forests can be
further divided into sub-categories mentioned as follows.
Deciduous Forests
These are described as forests which predominantly comprise of deciduous species and where the
trees shed their leaves once in a year.
Forest Blank
A forest blank is an opening amidst forests without any tree cover. It includes openings of
assorted size and shapes as seen on the imagery.
Forest Plantations
It is described as an area of trees of species of forestry importance and raised on notified forest
lands. It includes eucalyptus, casuarinas, bamboo, etc.
Mangroves
Mangroves are described as a dense, thicker or woody, aquatic vegetation or forest cover
occurring in tidal waters near estuaries and along the confluence of delta in coastal areas.
Mangroves include species of the genera Rhizophora and Aviccunia.
4. Wastelands
Wastelands are described as degraded lands which can be brought under vegetative cover with
reasonable water and soil management or on account of natural causes. Wastelands can result
from internal / imposed constraints such as by location, environment, chemical and physical
prosperities of the soil or financial or management constraints.
Salt-Affected Land
The salt-affected land is generally characterized as the land that has adverse effects on the growth
of most plants due to the action or presence of excess soluble or high exchangeable sodium.
Alkaline land has an exchangeable sodium percentage (ESP) of about 15, which is generally
considered as the limit between normal and alkali soils. The predominant salts are carbonates and
bicarbonates of sodium. Coastal saline soils may be with or without ingress or inundation by
seawater.
Waterlogged Land
Waterlogged land is that land where the water is at/or near the surface and water stands for most
of the year. Such lands usually occupy topographically low-lying areas. It excludes lakes, ponds
and tanks or in the context of the Wetlands (Conservation and Management Rules, 2010) such
areas that could be considered as ‘protected wetlands’.
5. Water Bodies
It is an area of impounded water, areal in extent and often with a regulated flow of water. It
includes man-made reservoirs/lakes/tank/canals, besides natural lakes, rivers/streams and creeks.
River / Stream
It is a course of flowing water on the land along definite channels. It includes from a small stream
to a big river and its branches. It may be perennial or non-perennial.
6. Others
It includes all those landuse and landcover classes which can be treated as miscellaneous because
of their nature of occurrence, physical appearance and other characteristics.
Shifting Cultivation
It is the result of cyclic land use practice of felling of trees and burning of forest areas for growing
crops. Such lands are also known as jhoomlands and cultivation called jhoom cultivation.
Ports/ Harbours
A harbour is a place where ships may shelter from the weather or are stored. Harbors can be
man-made or natural. A man-made harbor will have sea walls or breakwaters and may require
dredging. A natural harbor is surrounded on most sides by land.
A port is a man-made coastal or riverine facility where boats and ships can load and unload. It
may consist of quays, wharfs, jetties, piers and slipways with cranes or ramps. A port may have
magazine buildings or warehouses for storage of goods and a transport system, such as railway,
road transport or pipeline transport facilities for relaying goods inland. In short a port is used
mainly for marine trading and a harbour is used as a parking space or a storage space for ships
7. Vegetation Cover
It is a land area predominantly covered with vegetation and is not part of Protected / Reserved
Forests. This includes scrub, open and close vegetations.
Scrub
It is described as a vegetative cover having density is less than 10% of the canopy cover. Scrub is
area covered by grasses or herbs and scattered tree or shrubs.
Open Vegetation
This is also categorized based on the vegetation cover having density between 10% to 20% of the
canopy cover.
Close Vegetation
This is also categorized based on the vegetation cover having density greater than 20% of the
canopy cover.
GROUND SURVEY
The field survey was carried out around radial distance of 10 km from the project site. The survey
consisted of traversing the study area, cross-checking of identified features with those represented
on the map. Field notes were kept in the form of log sheets that recorded information pertaining
to co-ordinates, photographs and identified landuses. Additional features identified or remarks
made against existing interpretation were also recorded.
Field visit dates by FAE (LU) Dr. Jessica Karia were as follows:
The field survey was carried out around radial distance of 10 km from the project site. Kadam’s
land use and land cover Functional Area Expert visited the site for quality check of the map.
GPS readings were taken during the surveys wherever it was felt that additional confirmation in
interpretation of the data and also observations of land features were noted. Additionally, spot
checks were also done to confirm the land use / land cover interpretation even where confidence
of interpretation was high. Table 2-3 enumerates the land features and its corresponding GPS
readings of all the ground truthing locations selected.
Project Site
Ambient Air
The parameters monitored were PM10, PM2.5, Sulphur Dioxide (SO2), Nitrogen Oxides (NOx),
HCl, Cl2, HB2, VOC, HC (Methane and Non-methane) & CO. Other parameter as unless specified in
ToR, i.e. NH3 was also analyzed as source for the same is envisaged from the project. Grab
samples of CO were taken and analyzed. The detailed monitoring methodology for ambient air is
given in table below.
Sensitivity/
Sampling Sampling equipment / Analytical
Detection Methodology
Parameters Solution used Equipment
Limit
Electronic
PM2.5 Fine Particulate Sampler 2 µg/m3 Gravimetric
Balance
Gaseous Flow (Impinger with Spectro Colorimetric IS:
SO2 3.7 µg/m3
TCM) with RDS photometer 5182: (Part II) 2001
Gaseous Flow (Impinger with
Sodium Spectro Colorimetric IS:
NOX 6 µg/m3
Hydroxide (0.1 N) photometer 5182: (Part VI) 2006
Media) with RDS
Gaseous Flow (Impinger with IS 5182 (Part 19):
Cl2 Colorimetric 1.0 µg/m3
Methyl Orange) with RDS 1982
Gaseous Flow (Impinger with Titrimetric Argentomentric
HCl 0.2 µg/m3
Distilled Water) with RDS Method Method
Gaseous Flow (0.1 N H2SO4) Spectro Indophenol Blue
NH3 10 µg/m3
attachment with RDS Sampler photometer method
APHA: 4500 – Br B_
Gaseous Flow (Impinger with Spectro
HBr 1.0 µg/m3 22nd Edition,
KOH) with RDS photometer
Colorometric Method
HC (Methane &
Bladder & Pump GC 1 ppm IS 5182 (Part 21)
Non Methane)
Bladder & Pump
VOC GC 1 ppm IS 5182 (Part 2)
(Charcoal adsorption/ analyzer)
CO analyzer/
CO Bladder & Pump 1,145 µg/m3 Sensor/ GC method
GC
Monitoring of noise is done by identifying suitable number of noise quality monitoring locations.
Background noise quality is monitored in dB (A) Leq (d) and dB (A) Leq (n) at the selected
locations.
Monitoring methodology
Sample collection
Env. Sampling Sampling Sampling
Methodology Sampling Detection
Component location Frequency Parameter
equipment Limit
Once during
the study
Sound Level
Ambient 5 (Hourly Noise Level Decibels –
Measurement 0.1 dB (A)
Noise Locations reading for 24 Meter dB (A)
(SLM)
hours at each
location)
Monitoring methodology for groundwater is given in table below. The grab samples were manually
collected and analyzed as per APHA Standard Methods (20th Edition, 1998) for the parameters
given in the EIA Manual of MoEF (January 2001).
Kadam Environmental Consultants has collected the surface water samples and carried out their
analysis in KEC laboratory to assess quality of Surface water within 10 km radius of the project
site.
Marking of tentative sampling location on Land Use map within 10 km radius of the
project site.
Actual Field visit and identification, marking of actual sampling location points based on
tentative location fixed on Land Use map.
Collection of surface water samples from marked points
Analysis of the collected samples
Locating actual sampling points in land use map
Baseline Environmental conditions assessment based on analysis results obtained.
The samples were further analyzed as per the APHA Standard Methods (22nd Edition). Table below
describes analytical methodology for parameters to be analyzed and with minimum detection limit
of the instruments available at KEC laboratory.
Parameters
Analyzed in Parameters
Minimum
S. Ground and Analyzed in
Parameters Methodology Detection
No. Surface River water
Limit
water samples
Samples
Gravimetric
Electrical APHA: 2510 B (22nd Edition),
6
conductivity Conductivity meter
1µmoh/cm
Parameters
Analyzed in Parameters
Minimum
S. Ground and Analyzed in
Parameters Methodology Detection
No. Surface River water
Limit
water samples
Samples
28 Heavy Metals
Arsenic APHA: 3500-As-A (22nd Edition)/
a
APHA: 3111-B(AAS)(22nd Edition)
<0.002 mg/l
(as As)
Cadmium APHA: 3500-Cd-A (22nd Edition)/
b
APHA: 3111-B(AAS) (22nd Edition)
<0.003 mg/l
(as Cd)
Chromium (as APHA: 3500-Cr-B (22nd Edition),
c
Cr) colorimetric
<0.003 mg/l
Soil Environment
Methodology of soil sample monitoring is given in following table. Photograph 12-8 shows soil
sampling at project site and within study area.
Socio-Economic Environment
To provide an accurate representation of the social, cultural and economic conditions of the
population surrounding the project site;
To identify the potential socio-economic positive and negative impacts during the construction,
operations and decommissioning phase of the proposed project;
To develop sustainable mitigation measures to enhance positive impacts and reduce or avoid
negative impacts; and
To develop proper monitoring and evaluation system with accountability to be implemented by the
project proponent.
Vadadala village in which the industry has been proposed has been considered as the core zone
village whereas the villages in the 10 kilometres aerial distance has been considered as the buffer
zone. A 20% household level survey was carried out in Vadadala village.The respondents were
selected from the various ’ falias’ to get a representative result. In the buffer zone villages were
selected by random sampling. In the selected villages focused group discussions, consultation with
people of various cross section of the society like teachers, fishermen etc., meetings with Village
Site visit
1 AA01 10-12-2014 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 110 21 8.0 14.8 <1
2 AA01 13-12-2014 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 63 17 8.0 18.1 <1
3 AA01 17-12-2014 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 53 11 8.6 21.1 <1
4 AA01 20-12-2014 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 76 9 9.6 17.5 <1
5 AA01 24-12-2014 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 58 11 8.0 17.8 <1
6 AA01 27-12-2014 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 96 14 9.4 21.7 <1
7 AA01 31-12-2014 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 61 22 8.0 22.1 <1
8 AA01 03-01-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 74 18 10.3 19.8 <1
9 AA01 07-01-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 101 12 8.5 17.1 <1
10 AA01 10-01-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 75 10 9.4 24.6 <1
11 AA01 18-01-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 59 22 10.1 14.4 <1
12 AA01 21-01-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 50 31 9.4 15.9 <1
13 AA01 24-01-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 56 20 8.0 17.2 <1
14 AA01 28-01-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 34 14 8.0 14.8 <1
15 AA01 31-01-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 51 23 9.4 23.1 <1
16 AA01 04-02-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 78 24 10.1 23.3 <1
17 AA01 07-02-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 27 18 8.0 22.4 <1
18 AA01 11-02-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 40 33 9.4 21.7 <1
19 AA01 14-02-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 50 14 8.6 19.3 <1
20 AA01 18-02-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 26 11 9.4 14.5 <1
21 AA01 21-02-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 27 12 9.4 17.6 <1
22 AA01 25-02-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 41 20 8.0 19.1 <1
23 AA01 28-02-2015 At PPG Asian Paint Site (Adjacent Site) Industrial 32 29 9.0 16.3 <1
Table 2: Incremental Increase in GLC of NOx (µg/m3) to Total Ambient Air NOx Concentration from Proposed Plant when NG and HSD will be used
as Fuel
Table 3: Incremental Increase in GLC of PM (µg/m3) to Total Ambient Air PM Concentration from Proposed Plant when NG and HSD will be used
as Fuel
Table 4: Incremental Increase in GLC of SO2 (µg/m3) to Total Ambient Air SO2 Concentration from Proposed Plant when FO and HSD will be used
as Fuel
Table 5: Incremental Increase in GLC of NOx (µg/m3) to Total Ambient Air NOx Concentration from Proposed Plant when FO and HSD will be used
as Fuel
Table 6: Incremental Increase in GLC of PM (µg/m3) to Total Ambient Air PM Concentration from Proposed Plant when FO and HSD will be used as
Fuel
Table 7: Incremental Increase in GLC of HC (µg/m3) to Total Ambient Air HC Concentration from Proposed Plant
Table 8: Incremental Increase in GLC of HCl (µg/m3) to Total Ambient Air HCl Concentration from Proposed Plant
Table 9: Incremental Increase in GLC of NH3 (µg/m3) to Total Ambient Air NH3 Concentration from Proposed Plant
Figure 1: Isopleth Concentration of SO2 when NG and HSD will be used as Fuel
Figure 2: Isopleth Concentration of NOx when NG and HSD will be used as Fuel
Figure 4: Isopleth Concentration of SO2 when FO and HSD will be used as Fuel
Figure 5: Isopleth Concentration of NOx when FO and HSD will be used as Fuel
Annexure 12: Croda India Safety Health and Environment Policy Statement
Croda India is a manufacturer of speciality chemicals for Healthcare, Personal Care, Textiles and
other Industrial applications.
In all of its activities, Croda is firmly committed to care for the safety, health and security of its
employees, customers and the community, and to protect the environment.
SHE Philosophy
All injuries and occupational illness, as well as process safety and environmental incidents, are
preventable and our goal for all of them is zero.
The design, manufacture and supply of products and product information from Croda’s
facilities is carried out in compliance with all relevant health and safety, environmental
management and resource efficiency standards.
The use of certified management systems which underpin all of our business activities drives
continual improvement in SHE performance.
SHE Principles
To have a senior management team that demonstrates strong SHE leadership and sets a very
good and visible example in its commitment to SHE.
To comply, as an absolute minimum with all national legal and other requirements, but in
addition, to strive to comply with Croda’ own demanding internal standards & sustainability
targets.
To define and communicate SHE responsibilities to all employees and contractors.
To provide appropriate information, training, coaching, supervision and assessment of
competence for all employees and contractors.
To identify the hazards and to assess, prioritise and control the risks associated with all
operations, including marketing, sales and the supply chain, with special attention to high
hazard chemical manufacturing and handling processes operated by the Company.
To provide and maintain a safe and healthy place of work, with safe plant, equipment and
processes.
To set demanding SHE improvement targets and monitor performance through a balanced set
of leading and lagging indicators.
To review compliance with the effectiveness of Croda’s SHE management systems, and use
incident investigations and audits to stimulate continual improvement.
To provide feedback and consult with employees and other stakeholders on SHE issues and
performance.
Through our SHE philosophy and the application of these SHE principles, we will realise our
commitment to the prevention of ill health, injury and damage to the environment.
It is my belief that aspiring to excellence in the management of safety, health and environment is
vital to ensuring the long term future of the company. I firmly believe that the adherence to these
principles will enable Croda India to meet its SHE performance targets and I am personally
committed to providing the leadership and resources to make it happen.
Reference: Croda International Plc Safety, Health and Environment Policy Statement dated March
2015.
Managing Director
Environmentfor Development
CONTACT DETAILS
Vadodara (Head Office)
871/B/3, GIDC Makarpura, Vadodara, India – 390 010.
E: kadamenviro@kadamenviro.com; T:+91-265-3001000
Delhi / NCR
Spaze IT Park, Unit No. 1124, 11th Floor, Tower B-3, Sector 49, Near Omaxe City Center Mall, Sohna Road,
Gurgaon, India – 122 002
E: delhi@kadamenviro.com; T: 0124-424 2430-436