Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Randall Cloke
Definition of Multiculturalism
Multiculturalism does not mean the same thing everywhere to everyone. Indeed, from
organization to organization, from office to office, and from person to person, that term can
include many identities and exclude many identities, whether intentionally or unwittingly. And at
Rowan College at Burlington County’s Tutoring and Testing Centers, no such definition exists.
It was not explicitly stated on either office’s website, part of the job description for positions in
either office, nor did the office promote or include text that one should reference the college’s
definition of the term. Moreover, there was little discussion of the term informally from the
departmental leadership in a top-down perspective, nor discussion from the lower-level staff
amongst themselves.
what multicultural meant in regard to the work done in both Tutoring and Testing, it is clear that
image to students that the office is not inclusive to the populations it aims to serve.
Though the college itself has a mission statement, at no point does it include—nor
diversity is (Rowan College at Burlington County, n.d.). At no point does the college’s written
definition of diversity actually delineate what groups are included with such a term; the webpage
devoted to the college’s commitment to diversity only speaks to the institution’s commitment to
diversity, whatever that might mean. Unfortunately, the officially-published statements of the
college never explicitly state the inclusion of underserved or minoritized groups in the work it
Certainly, the department specifically and the college generally would have been best
have allowed for not only greater multicultural competence on the part of the either the smaller
or broader organization, but would have been a specific phrase and language that could have
been included in the development of multicultural competence in other areas. Given the seeming
emphasis placed on the definition of multiculturalism in the MCOD, it is logical to think that
crafting such a definition could well permeate into the other areas included within the template.
Mission Statement
Mission statements provide an organization to detail what exactly the organization aims
to do, how it plans to carry out completing those aims, and the people it expects to be included in
accomplishing the stated goals. While institutions of higher learning almost universally have
common for individual divisions and offices within those institutions to have their own mission
While Rowan College at Burlington County does have a clearly stated mission statement,
many of the departments that are part of the college do not. One combined office in particular,
Tutoring and Testing, is among these offices without a self-developed mission statement that
describes the work that they do, how they do it, and who is included in the process of
successfully completing that work (Rowan College at Burlington County, n.d.). Given the nature
of the college’s location and student populations, it seems like it would have been helpful to
As the office lacked a mission statement, the many postings it had around campus
regarding the services it offered did not include it, and thus lacked the promotion of defining
values that were central to the work it aimed to do in the college’s student affairs programming.
The offices of Tutoring and Testing might have been well served to create and include on
their website and published documents a mission statement that included the use of words like
multiculturalism or diversity. Given the nature of the work done at the two respective offices,
describing the important nature of the work they did and how they served all of the students of
the diverse study body could create a more welcoming environment when students came to the
One of the driving forces in multicultural competence in an organization comes from the
leadership of that organization. Given the positional power they almost universally have over
other levels of staff, they can often create and implement strategies or initiatives in the
At Rowan College at Burlington County’s Tutoring and Testing Centers, leadership did
not have such drive or impetus to implement multicultural competency goals for their sphere of
oversight. While the leadership staff was small, none were agents of change in establishing and
expecting there to be greater multicultural competence at any level of the office, whether in
And this extended beyond the intra-office staff, too, as leadership did not leverage their
connections on campus and within the higher reaches of the organization to lobby for
multicultural training at the college or for a formal office committed to seeing that multicultural
Leadership would have set an example for their staff if they had, at their directive, held
the staff and offices to the expectation of meeting outlined goals in the area of multicultural
competence. The office directors could have leveraged their powerful positions to invite
multiculturally-competent staff to the office to help implement these strategies and goals.
Perhaps more personally, the leadership could have discussed with staff, individually, the
importance of being multiculturally competent their student affairs practice, and offered any
assistance that could help the staff member develop their multicultural competencies.
Policy Review
Policy allows for organizations to formalize their processes and procedures for how daily
work is carried out both generally and specifically. At the Tutoring and Testing Centers,
however, few policies were clearly outlined, written down, and explicitly detailed anywhere in
an employee’s training or within the spaces in which student affairs work was done. As such, it
would be difficult for one to even analyze how such policies could either promote or inhibit the
Starting first by actually formalizing the policies of the office, instead of having it be
assumed, one can begin to explore how the processes in place can, potentially, affect more
students other than others. While such formal policies were few and far between, one such
example is the hours of the tutoring office, which were often 9:30AM to 7:30PM and frequent
weekend morning hours. While the office could have increased the hours it was open to allow for
more students to take advantage of the services available, including those students who may be
“non-traditional” and have availability outside of the hours available. While itself not necessarily
multicultural in nature, a review of formal policies like the office’s hours could reveal potential
One area where an organization can develop its multicultural competence is through its
hiring processes and the working environments it creates. For the offices of Tutoring and Testing
at Rowan College at Burlington County, there was little in these areas that would lead to such
development. The job listings for the two offices did not include any mentions of
multiculturalism or diversity, and thus lacked the outward expression of the department’s belief
in the importance of competence in these areas. That said, the office did have a fairly diverse
staff, at least compared to those housed in other areas of the college in terms of gender, race, age,
etc. Whether that was intentional or not, it is something that seemed to be a potential place to
cultivate for developing multicultural competence. However, including specific language about
potential applicants’ expected commitment to these ideas could help to improve the diversity of
the staff and hiring staff with a development in multicultural competence that is further along
Even with that diverse staff, there was no effort made to understand whether there was a
working environment that was inclusive to those varying identities in as equal measures as could
be possible. There was not, at least formally, any type of assessment of the working culture in the
the structure of the office was or could lead to possible issues in retaining staff of different
identities. To look at the culture of the working environment to see if they disproportionately
affect the retention of employees in any way would be helpful to assessing, later in an
diverse staff.
As there was a lack of overall multicultural competence from the structure to the
leadership of the offices of Tutoring and Testing, there was little effort made to develop such
competence in the wide staff ranks. Professional development was hardly available for any topic
or interest area, and so it goes without saying that formal professional development in diversity
or multiculturalism was also not available. The college should have offered such development to
all staff, and leadership of the department should have promoted such opportunities that might
have been available off campus to help the staff develop its multicultural competence.
Similarly, training was often light for a lot of staff in the respective offices. Staff
frequently learned new things on the job that similar positions at other institutions might have
likely covered in a training or onboarding program. Given the leadership’s own lack of training
in multicultural competence, it prevented the possibility for them to supervise the staff on their
own development. If one were to make suggestions to improve this, first improving leadership’s
own commitment to this development would spur the possibility for training other staff in
developing, too.
Scholarly Activities
Given the limitations of the staffing in the offices, which consisted mostly of part-time
employees who held jobs, the availability for scholarly research or conference presentations were
limited. Full time staff, however, may have a greater ability and latitude to conduct research that
could have furthered their own, and by extension the department’s, development of multicultural
competence.
The office did not utilize many forms or programs during the course of their student
affairs practice outside of their daily work. However, one such example of a “form” was the
MCOD AT ROWAN COLLEGE AT BURLINGTON COUNTY 8
TutorTrac system that logged student appointments and employee working hours. This system
was very detailed and could hold lots of information, but often when new students would come
to the Tutoring Center, specifically, they would have to have an account created for them. The
system would require the staff member to select the students’ gender—itself a problem—but
only had a binary option available. Leadership could lobby the creator of TutorTrac to
implement a greater diversity of options in something like this, or possibly look at other vendors
Physical Environment
The physical environment of the two offices were on second floor of a three-story
building. Due to limited physical space, being housed in a different area often proved difficult
equipment did not always work, and thus would prevent issues for students with physical
disabilities to come to the offices for support services. As an institution, the college should have
done whatever it could to ensure a better physical position in the college’s buildings so that both
The offices had a distinct lack of any materials on any surfaces, and so there was limited
opportunity for items of an insensitive nature to be posted or displayed. So while the offices lack
offensive material, they also lacked images or other media that could have been welcoming to
students of diverse backgrounds. The offices certainly could have made an effort to do this and
Assessment
nature of assessing the work it does. For the department that housed the offices of both Tutoring
MCOD AT ROWAN COLLEGE AT BURLINGTON COUNTY 9
and Testing, a culture of assessment was lacking. Had it existed, modes of assessment could have
been implemented that would have helped leadership and staff understand their collective and
practice.
If such a culture existed, both management and lower levels of staff could assess their
practices by surveying students about how they felt the office’s multicultural competence was.
Employees could also consider if their strategies for outreaching the programming they produced
were as inviting to all students as it could be, and then determining strategies that could help
Discussion
I spent nearly two years working in the department that housed these two offices. While
experience there. And I must say that I learned a lot there. As I reflect on my time spent there
and the areas of the template that focused my writing on specific areas, it is only further evident
about the near fact that the entire organization in which I was a part, including the institution
competence. At no point in the organization’s structure that I experienced was there a belief in
the need for recognizing multiculturalism or diversity, let alone implementing any such
understanding of it into practice. It’s almost difficult to have a real discussion of what should
have been done to improve the organization’s multicultural competence, as, quite honestly, doing
anything in any way in any aspect of the organization’s structure would have been an
improvement.
MCOD AT ROWAN COLLEGE AT BURLINGTON COUNTY 10
statement, and found it somewhat milquetoast. Perhaps that’s a reflection of an institution that is
finding itself or wishes to serve as broad an audience of constituents as it can, but I was even
more surprised by the college feeling it absolutely necessary to include a dedicated page to
diversity when the college’s rebranding and website was completed in late 2015. The much
lobbied for page would end up including, and still does, the least explicitly inclusive and
amorphous definition of diversity as one might possibly create. Maybe I could have taken it to
mean that at least they would play homage to the idea, but the almost willful ignorance of the
singular webpage leads me to be even more cynical than that. I personally saw examples of the
three previous concepts in my time there, and all could have been better understood and
addressed if the institution had, in my opinion, had any desire to do exactly that. I will recall a
few examples below, but they are by no means the only instances of multicultural incompetence
In my own office, there was a woman who had worked there for nearly a decade. She was
usually decent at the work and did not generally cause too many disruptions in completing that
work. Her outlandishly explicit biases and prejudices never failed to shock me, no matter how
frequently they were put on display. Due to her comfort with me as a white counterpart, she
never failed to mutter under her breath just loudly enough for me, and only me, to hear her usage
of truly disgusting terms to multiple identities of people. Whether they were hate-charged
epithets regarding Black colleagues, students of Asian descent, or those identified as transgender,
she left few identities excluded from the words leaving her scornful tongue. Clearly using such
MCOD AT ROWAN COLLEGE AT BURLINGTON COUNTY 11
terms is just blatant and outright hate, but when interacting with people whose identities she
disparaged, she instead used any number of microaggressions to leave anyone involved fairly
certain of her thoughts about such groups of people. Thanks to examples developed by Sue et. al
(2007), I have been able to better understand Whether explaining that she was colorblind (I, of
course, knew better), informing Asian students they would do extra well on their math tests she
handed them, or referring to a group of students she believed to be of the same race as “you
people,” she was a master of the microaggression. She was not the only one, however, as
A considerably older gentleman was a volunteer tutor in our office would often talk
politics with other volunteer tutors, and as I much as I tried to tamper the discussion, it often
carried on at will. I often felt it was not helpful for the work we did in the tutoring center, nor did
it leave a particularly positive impression with students who would come in for math help and
would give me looks that would ask “is there anyone else to help me?” This would have been left
at annoying, if not for when a highly-achieving black student, who would come in to do
homework—not even ask for help—would hear from this volunteer tutor that he was “surprised”
the student could be doing high level math work. It happened nearly every time the student came
into the office, and the student always brushed it off. The tutor knew nothing of the student, and
so I as always amazed by the outright bias he could show as consistently as he did. His implicit
biases were quite evident, and made the term much realer for me to understand, even though I
But unlike those two staff members, I had a colleague whom I was fortunate to befriend.
She was a black woman whose family was from Haiti, and she and I got to talk often. She helped
me develop my own multicultural competence and I thank her for helping me to do so in addition
MCOD AT ROWAN COLLEGE AT BURLINGTON COUNTY 12
to being my friend. She and I discussed the treatment she experienced in the culture at the
institution at which we both worked, and she would talk about how some things were specific to
being black, some specific to being a woman, and then how there were numerous examples of
how those two identities coincided in these experiences. While I had understood, conceptually,
the idea of intersectionality at that point in my life, she helped to give a face, along with a unique
means. How, for her, being a black woman presented unique challenges in her position in
working with students, with colleagues, and with superiors. While I know my understanding of
this concept, along with my own experience of it, is not done developing, I know that my former
colleague helped me through some formative development in my time in the office in which we
worked.
While I did not work there exceptionally long, I know I learned a lot during the time I
did. I also found the MCOD template developed by Pope, Reynolds, and Mueller (2003) to be
helpful in formally assessing the structural aspects of the student affairs practice that I personally
did there as part of a larger organization. It also helped me place my experiences of colleagues
and superiors into tool of assessment, and allowed me to more thoughtfully consider how those
experiences developed my own multicultural competence that has influenced my current, and
future, practice.
MCOD AT ROWAN COLLEGE AT BURLINGTON COUNTY 13
References
Pope, R. L., Reynolds, A. L., & Mueller, J. A. (2004). Multicultural competence in student
http://rcbc.edu/tutoring
Rowan College at Burlington County. (n.d.). Mission and goals. Retrieved from
http://rcbc.edu/mission
Sue, D. W., Capodilupo, C. M., Torino, G. C., Bucceri, J. M., Holder, A. M., Nadal, K. L., &