COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF DELAY IN VOICE TRANSMISSION

AND CONGESTION INFLUENCE IN LTE NETWORK

Zholdasuly M., Nurbayev S. S., Shelkovnikov B. N.

National Technical University of Ukraine "Kyiv Polytechnic Institute"
Institute of Telecommunication Systems
2, Industrial Lane, Kyiv, 03056, Ukraine
Ph.: (063) 1566491, e-mail: manas07@list.ru

Abstract - The present paper concerns the comparative analysis of voice transmission delay in LTE network at incoming and
outgoing calls in Almaty. Channel congestion influence to the delay was also studied.

CPABH�TEIlbHbl� AHAIl�3 3A.QEP>KK� np� nEPE.QA4E rOIlOCA

� BIl�flH�E 3ArpY>KEHHOCT� B CET� LTE

}i{on,ll,acynbl M., Hyp6aeB C. C., WenKOBHI!1KOB 6. H.

Hau,uoHanbHblD TexHullecKuD YHueepcumem YKpauHbl «KueecKuD nonumexHullecKuD uHcmumym»
/!1Hcmumym TeneKoMMYHuKau,uoHHblx CucmeM
nepeynoK /!1HoycmpuanbHbID, 2, Kuee, 03056, YKpauHa
men.: (063) 1566491, e-mail: manas07@list.ru

AHHomal.lUf/ - B ,lIaHHoi1 pa60Te 6blIl C,lleIlaH cpaBH�TeIlbHbllii aHaIl�3 3a,llep>KK� nepe,lla4� rOIloca B ceT� LTE np� BXO,llS114�X
� �CXO,llS114�X Bbl30Bax B ropO,lle AIlMaTbl. TaK>Ke 6blIl �CCIle,llOBaHO BIl�S1H�e 3arpy>KeHHOCT� KaHaIla Ha 3a,llep>KKy.

I. BBeAeHMe TpaCCl!1pOBKY KaHanbl Cl!1rHanl!13al.\l!1l!1. TaKI!1M 06pa30M,

nonHOCTblO OTCne}l{I!1BaeTCs:! np0l.\e,[lypa
CSFB - 3TO TeXHonon1s:!, KOTopas:! ,[IaeT B03MO}l{­
YCTaHOBneHI!1s:! ronOCOBoro COe,[lI!1HeHI!1s:!.
HOCTb OpraHI!130BbiBaTb 3BOHKI!1 C LTE-YCTpoLilcTB 1!1 Ha
Ha OCHOBaHl!11!1 ,[IaHHbIX [2], 6blnl!1 nonY4eHbi pe3ynb­
HI!1X 4epe3 CTaH,[IapTHble M061!1nbHbie CeTI!1 C KOMMYTa­
TaTbl, npl!1Be,[leHHble HI!1}1{e.
l.\l!1eLil KaHanOB. CYTb MeXaHI!13Ma CSFB [1] COCTOI!1T B
TOM, 4TO a60HeHTCKoe YCTpoLilcTBO, pa60TalOLl\ee B CeTI!1 Ta6n. 1. Pe3ynbTaTbi paC4eTa BpeMeHI!1 YCTaHoBneHI!1s:!
LTE, Ha BpeMs:! OCYLl\eCTBneHI!1s:! I!1CXO,[ls:!Ll\ero I!1nl!1 npl!1e­ I!1CXO,[ls:!Ll\ero Bbl30Ba
Ma BXO,[ls:!Ll\ero ronocoBoro Bbl30Ba nepeKnl04aeTCs:! B
Table 1. Calculation results for time required
Tpa,[ll!1l.\1!10HHYIO ceTb GSM I!1nl!1 UMTS A ceccl!1s:! nepe­
to establish an outgoing call
,[Ia41!1 ,[IaHHbIX 4epe3 LTE Ha 3TO BpeMs:! nl!160 npl!10CTa­
HaBnI!1BaeTCs:! C BOCCTaHOBneHl!1eM nocne 3aBepWeHI!1s:! T�n ceT� UMTS GSM
Bb130Ba, nl!160 TaK}l{e nepeXO,[lI!1T B GSM/UMTS. 06b14Hbli1 Bbl30B 4000 MC 3900 MC
04eBI!1,[1HO, 4TO ,[Ins:! pa60Tbi CSFB 06s:!3aTenbHo ne­ Bbl30B c CSFB 6530 MC 6460 MC
peKpblTl!1e pa,[ll!1oceTeLii LTE 1!1 GSM/UMTS. TaK}l{e He06-
XO,[lI!1Ma nO,[l,[lep}l{Ka CSFB Ha a60HeHTcKoM 060PY,[IOBa­
HI!1I!1 1!1 Ha KOMMYTaTopax M061!1nbHOLII CBs:!31!1 (MSC). Ha 7000 ,---

MSC peanl!13yeTcs:! cnel.\l!1anbHblLii I!1HTepcpeLilc B CTOPOHY 6000

060PY,[IOBaHI!1s:! LTE/EPC, KOTOPblLil npe,[lHa3Ha4eH ,[Ins:!
neLil,[l}l{I!1Hra a60HeHTcKI!1x YCTpoLilcTB 1!1 ynpaBneHI!1s:! I!1X 5000 --

nepeKnlO4eHI!1eM Me}l{,[lY ceTs:!MI!1 LTE 1!1 GSM/UMTS, a 4000 --

DUMTS
u
TaK}I{e ,[Ins:! ,[IOCTaBKI!1 BXO,[ls:!Ll\I!1X 1!1 I!1CXO,[ls:!Ll\I!1X SMS. :i! 6530 ....6.4.60..
=- 3000 r-
---
DGSM
II. OCHOBHa� l.JaCTb :i! 4000 3900
\II - --
c. 2000
III
B pa60Te paCCMaTpl!1BanaCb ceTb LTE onepaTopa
1000
AO «AJlTEJl», OpraH1!130BaHHas:! B ,[IBYX perl!10HaX Pec­
ny6nl!1KI!1 Ka3axcTaH - B r. AnMaTbl 1!1 r. ACTaHa. CeTb 0 ---,-

COCTOI!1T 1!13 60nee 350 6a30Bbix CTaHl.\l!1Li1 B AnMaTbl, 1!1 06b1YHbl� Bbl30B Bbl30B c CSFB
60nee 210 - B ACTaHe. fnaBHas:! 4aCTb (EPC -
Evolved Packet Core) HaXO,[lI!1TCs:! B AnMaTbl 1!1 CBs:!3aHa Puc. 1. BpeMR ycmaH06neHuR UCXOORl.1..4eaO 6b1306a.

co CTaHl.\l!1s:!MI!1 nOCpe,[lCTBOM CeTI!1 MBH (Mobile Back­ Fig. 1. Time to establish an outgoing call
haul) KOMnaHl!11!1 AO «Ka3axTeneKoM».
3KCnepl!1MeHT 3aKnlO4ancs:! B 1!13MepeHI!11!1 BpeMeHI!1
YCTaHOBneHI!1s:! ronocoBoro COe,[lI!1HeHI!1s:! Me}l{,[lY a60- Ta6n. 2. Pe3ynbTaTbi pac4eTa BpeMeHI!1 YCTaHoBneHI!1s:!
HeHTCKI!1M TepMI!1HanOM, nO,[lKnI04eHHbIM K CeTI!1 LTE 1!1 BXO,[ls:!Ll\ero Bbl30Ba
a60HeHTCKI!1M TepMI!1HanOM, nO,[lKnI04eHHbIM K CeTI!1
Table 2. Calculation results for time required
npe,[lbl,[lYLl\erO nOKOneHI!1s:! (GSM, UMTS).
to establish an incoming call
npl!1 npOBe,[leHI!1I!1 3KCnepl!1MeHTa I!1CnOnb30BanaCb
I!1MI!1Tal.\I!10HHas:! MO,[lenb, B OCHOBe KOTOpoLii ne}l{ano npo­ T�n ceT� UMTS GSM
06b14Hbli1 Bbl30B 2640 MC 2500 MC
rpaMMHoe 06ecne4eHI!1e «HUAWEI Local Maintenance
Bbl30B C CSFB 5170 MC 5060 MC
Terminal». ,[\aHHas:! nporpaMMa n03Bons:!eT CTaBI!1Tb Ha

& Telecommunication Technology" (CriMiCo'2014). 7-13 September, Sevastopol, Crimea, Russia

2014 24th Int. Crimean Conference "Microwave
370 © 2014: CriMiCo'2014 Organizing Committee; CrSTC. ISBN: 978-966-335-412-5. IEEE Catalog Number: CFP14788
 6000 2�5 r------,-,--,---,-,-,

,....--
5000 �----_+_4--�,------- �----��-+_4�

rn=
2540

u
:z
=
4000

3000
E- -- []UMTS
u
:I:
ri
'"
2535 �----_+_4--�y"'''-----�---------+_4�

:E
:!;
5170 5060
CI>
CL
a:l 2000

1000
-I

-I
2640 2500
-

--
DGSM
i : :: = t t

2520 +-L----r--�--r---'--___r------__r_-_--r--"---__i
0 _. � ----, 0.50 0.75 2.00 2.50 2.90 3.20 3.70 4.1 Gb/s
06bl'lHbll1 Bbl30B Bbl30B c CSFB 3arpY)f(eHHOCTb CelM, Gb/s

Puc. 2. 8peMfI ycmaHoBneHufI BXOOfl/Lle20 Bb130Ba. Puc. 4. 3aBucUMocmb 3aOep)/(KU ycmaHoBneHUfI

20nOCOB020 coeouHeHufI om 3a2py)/(eHHOCmu cemu.
Fig. 2. Time to establish an incoming call
Fig. 4. Dependence between voice connection
[...13 PIllCYHKOB 1, 2 BIIl,[lHO, 4TO C nplilMeHeHlIleM Tex­ establishment delay and network congestion
Honorllllll CSFB YCTaHoBKa ronocoBoro COe,[lIllHeHIIls:!
npOIllCXO,[lIilT ,[IOnbWe Ha 2.5 ceKYH,[Ibl, BHe 3aBIIlClilMOCTlil [...13 plllCYHKa 4 BIIl,[lHO, 4TO C YBenlll4eHIIleM 3arpY}f{eH­
OT HanpaBneHIIls:! Bbl30Ba 111 Tlilna ceTIIl, Ha KOTOPYto npo­ HOCTIIl, YBenlll4l1lBaeTcs:! 111 3a,[lep}f{Ka. BpeMs:!, KOTopoe
IIICXO,[lIilT nepeKnto4eHIIle Bb130Ba. He06xo,[lIilMO [3] ,[Ins:! YCTaHoBneHIIls:! ronOCOBoro Coe,[llll­
Ha plllcYHKe 3 1Il306pa}f{eHa 3arpY}f{eHHOCTb O,[lHOrO HeHIIls:! YBenlll4l1lBaeTcs:! (MeHbwe 1%), HO 1Il3MeHeHIIls:!
1113 KaHanOB ceTIil LTE onepaTopa AO «AllTEll» 3a CYT­ HaCTonbKO Manbl, 4TO He3aMeTHbi ,[Ins:! a60HeHTa. [...13
Kill. :noro Cne,[lyeT, 4TO TaKO� cpaKTOp, KaK 3arPY}f{eHHOCTIil
ceTIIl, He3Ha411lTenbHO Bnllls:!eT Ha 3a,[lep}f{KY.
• 0 G
BpeMs:! YCTaHOBneHIIls:! ronocoBoro COe,[lIllHeHIIls:! C
1 30G nplilMeHeHlIleM TeXHonorlll1ll CSFB YBenlll411lnOCb C 4 ,[10

:. 2.0 G
6,5 ceKYH,[I, BHe 3aBIIlClilMOCTlil OT Tlilna ceTIIl, Ha KOTOpyto
npOIllCXO,[lIilT nepeKnto4eHIIle Bb130Ba. HeT HIilKaKIIlX ,[IaH­
lOG
.

.J>
HbIX, ,[IOCTaBIilT nlll 3TIIl 2,5 ceKYH,[Ibl 3a,[lep}f{KIil HeY,[I06-
00 CTBa ,[Ins:! a60HeHToB. Ho 111 ,[Ins:! 3TOro B03MO}f{HOro He,[lO­
eG-eo 01.00 10:08 12:00 104:(10 U.OG 18:00 20.08 22:00 00.00 82.00 04.00

Fro. 2013/11/01 04:30:57 To 2013/11/0204:26:17 CTaTKa KOMnaHIIls:! HUAWEI pa3pa6aTbiBaeT HOBbl� CTaH­
,[IapT UL TA-flash CSFB. no 3as:!BneHltlto pa3pa60T41tlKOB,
• Inbound Curr.nt : 1. 27 G Av.rao.: 2.23 G "ui.u.: 4.02 G
• o.rtbcund Curtl!�nt: 141.99 M AVt.fiilOt: 243.86 H HaXiIllUII: 400.63 M CTaH,[IapT HaMHoro YMeHbWIIlT BpeMs:! YCTaHOBneHIIls:! ro­
nOCOBoro COe,[lIllHeHIIls:! (Ha 20% MeHbwe, 4eM B Tpa,[llll l..\l11-
Puc. 3. 3a2py)/(eHHOCmb KaHana cemu LTE onepamopa
OHHblX ceTs:!x) 6naro,[laps:! BBO,[lY HOBoro IIlHTepcpe�ca.
AO «AflTEfl».
Fig. 3. Channel congestion of LTE network of operator III. 3aKI1IOl.leHMe
«ALTEL» corporation 1. npOBe,[leHO 3KcneplllMeHTanbHoe IIlCCne,[lOBaHlile
Bbl6paHHoro CTaH,[IapTa nepe,[la411l ronoca CS Fallback.
[...13 plllcYHKa 3 BIIl,[lHO, 4TO 3arpY}f{eHHOCTb ceTIil 3aBIIl­
TLllaTenbHo 1Il3Y4eHbi He,[lOCTaTKIIl, a IIlMeHHO nO,[lC4eT
CIilT OT BpeMeHIIl CYTOK.
BpeMeHIIl 111 3a,[lep}f{eK, 06ycnoBneHHbie 3TO� TeXHono­
,[Ins:! nOCTpoeHIIls:! 3aBIIlCIilMOCTIIl, B MOMeHTbl MaKCIIl­
rllle�. npOBe,[leHbl IIlCCne,[lOBaHIIls:! Bnllls:!HIIls:! napaMeTpoB
ManbHo�, MIIlHIIlManbHO� 111 Cpe,[lHe� 3arPY}f{eHHOCTIil ce­
ceTIil 111 xapaKTepa nO,[lKnto4eHIIl� Ha 3a,[lep}f{KIil.
Till 6blnlll npOlll3Be,[leHbl 5 1Il3MepeHIIl� 111 paCC411lTaHa 3a­
,[Iep}f{Ka YCTaHoBneHIIls:! IIICXO,[ls:!Lllero ronocoBoro Coe,[llll­
2. Pe3ynbTaTbi IIlCCne,[lOBaHIIls:! nOKa3anlll, 4TO 3a­
,[Iep}f{KIil cYLllecTBytoT 111 MorYT nOBnllls:!Tb Ha Ka4eCTBO 06-
HeHIIlR
cnY}f{IIlBaHIIls:!. npe,[lnO}f{eH BaplilaHT C BHe,[lpeHlIleM Tex­
B Ta6nlll l..\e 4 oT06pa}f{eHbl pe3ynbTaTbi 1Il3MepeHIIl� 111
Honorllllll CSFB C nocne,[lYtoLllIllM 06HoBneHIIleM ,[10
pac4eTa 3a,[lep}f{KIIl, a TaK}f{e MaTeMaTIIl4eCKoro O}f{IIl,[la­
ULTRA-Flash CSFB.
Hills:! 111 OTKnOHeHIIlR
06na,[las:! pa3BepHYTO� ceTbto TpeTbero nOKoneHIIls:!,
Ta6n. 3. Pe3ynbTaTbi 1Il3MepeHIIls:! 111 pac4eTa 3a,[lep}f{KIil TeXHonorllls:! CS Fallback 06eCne411lT nnaBHbl� nepexo,[l K
B pa3nlll4Hoe BpeMs:! CYTOK ceTs:!M LTE C ycnyro� nepe,[la411l ronoca. A 06HoBneHIIle
Table 3. The results of measurement and calculation of n03BonlilT CHIIl311lTb Benlll411lHY 3a,[lep}f{eK 111 ynY4wIIlTb
delays in the different times of day ,[IPyrllle xapaKTeplilcTIIlKIil ceTIil.
3a'l'y"A<eH MaT. MaT.
Bpe". HOCTL, Pe:H'3T Pe3·'T3T Pe3·T3T Pe3·T3T Pe3>'TaT Ojlmn.,
IV. References
On':JI,
H3MCpeHlUi r6HT/e I. Me 2, Me 3, Me 4, Me 5, Me Me % [1] Youness J.,Zouhair G .. Circuit Switch Fallback Improvement
6:30 0,50 2530 2530 2531 2531 252 9 2530,2 0.84
and the Smarter Way for Implementation. AASRI Procedia,
8:30 0.75 2532 2530 2532 2531 2532 2531,4 0.89
10:30 2,00 2533 2532 2535 2533 2533,4 1.14
volume 4,2013,pp. 9-17.
2534
14:00 2,50 2535 2537 2536 2538 2534 2536 1.58 [2] Zholdasuly M., Nurbayev S., Shelkovnikov B.N. Voice
18:00 2,90 2538 2537 2539 2538 2537 2537,8 0,84 transmission in LTE. 2014 Bth Int. Scientific and Technical
1:00 3 ,20 2539 2538 2539 2538 2537 2538,2 0,84
Conf "PROBLEMS OF TELECOMMUNICA TlONS"
1:07 3.70 2540 2541 2540 2542 2540 2540 6 0.89
(PTU2014). Kyiv, 2014, pp. 206-20B.
1:15 4,10 2543 2545 2542 2544 2544 2543,6 1,14
[3] Felizhanko A. Peredacha golosa v setyah LTE. Available at:
Ha plllCYHKe 4 1Il306pa}f{eHa 3aBIIlClilMOCTb 3a,[lep}f{KIil OT hUp://ciscoexpo. ru/expo201 O/materials/service_providers/D3
3arPY}f{eHHOCTIil ceTIil Ha OCHOBaHlIl1il ,[IaHHbIX Ta6n111 I..\bl 3. -Voice_over_LTE-afelizha.pdf

& Telecommunication Technology" (CriMiCo'Z014). 7-13 September, Sevastopol, Crimea, Russia

Z014 Z4� Int. Crimean Conference "Microwave
© Z014: CriMiCo'Z014 Organizing Committee; CrSTC. ISBN: 978-966-335-41Z-5. IEEE Catalog Number: CFP14788 371