Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Myeong S. Yu, MD, PhD; Na R. Jung, MD, PhD; Kyoung H. Choi, MD, PhD; Kuiwon Choi, PhD;
Bong-Jae Lee, MD, PhD; Yoo-Sam Chung, MD, PhD
Objectives/Hypothesis: An animal model of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) may help to investigate the pathophysiology
of this disorder and develop appropriate treatments. We investigated the feasibility of a rabbit model of OSA.
Study Design: Animal study.
Methods: Twelve New Zealand white rabbits were injected at the base of their tongues under endoscopic guidance with
liquid silicone (experimental group, n 5 6) or normal saline (control group, n 5 6). Polysomnography was performed before
and after injection. The development of OSA and changes in sleep parameters were compared between the two groups.
Results: Before injection, all rabbits showed normal breathing during sleep without hypopnea. In the silicone group, the
rabbits had a mean of 29.9 6 6.9 hypopneas/hour and a mean of 10.4 6 3.1 apneas/hour 1 month after silicone injection and
28.4 6 6.9 hypopneas/hour and 10.0 6 3.3 apneas/hour 3 months after silicone injection (P < 0.05). Mean total sleep time
decreased from 260.3 6 70.2 minutes at baseline to 152.5 6 38.8 minutes 1 month and 206.8 6 60.3 minutes 3 months after
injection, with a decrease in stage II sleep. In the saline group, however, there were no breathing events during sleep.
Conclusions: These results show that silicone injections into the tongue base of rabbits can result in OSA.
Key Words: Rabbit, animal model, obstructive sleep apnea, sleep.
Level of Evidence: N/A
Laryngoscope, 124:789–796, 2014
Laryngoscope 124: March 2014 Yu et al.: Rabbit Model of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
789
Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of the site of liquid silicone injections at the tongue base (left). Endoscopic view of oral cavity of a rabbit in which
silicone was injected at the tongue base (asterisk) between the circumvallate papillae. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which
is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
Medical Center (AMC) was obtained prior to the study. All ani- 1.5 Hz to 100 Hz for EEG, 0.5 Hz to 35 Hz for EOG, and 7 Hz
mal procedures were conducted in accordance with guidelines to 150 Hz for EMG recordings. Nasal and oral airflows were
published by the National Institutes of Health.16 Rabbits were recorded through an adapted ventilation face mask connected to
anesthetized with zolazepam (35 mg/kg, IM) and xylazine a pressure transducer system (Breabon, Ultima Pressure Sen-
hydrochloride (5 mg/kg, IM). After midline scalp incision, the sor; Kanata, Ontario, Canada). The flexible shell of the mask
periosteum was divided over the frontoparietal region on both was molded to conform to the rabbit’s mouth and nose. Respira-
sides of the head. Electroencephalogram (EEG)-recording elec- tory efforts were monitored by respiratory inductance plethys-
trodes (Teflon-coated, multistranded stainless steel wire) were mography; and blood oxygen saturation (SaO2) was measured
placed over the frontal and parietal areas of the skull with using a pulse oximeter with a probe attached to the shaved
stainless steel screws (F3/P3–F4/P4). A reference electrode (Pz) foreleg of each rabbit. Sleep stages were classified as awake,
was implanted in the midline of the frontoparietal suture line. stage I, and stage II sleep stages, and were identified as
Electrooculogram (EOG) recording electrodes (Teflon-coated, described previously.17 In the present study, respiratory events
multistranded stainless steel wire) were implanted extraorbi- were scored as hypopnea when there was a reduction of 50% to
tally in the horizontal plane on both sides of the eyes. All elec- 90% in the nasal flow signal, recorded via an oronasal mask for
trodes were secured to the skull with dental acryl cement and at least two breaths. Apnea was defined by a >90% reduction in
connected to a nine-pin stainless steel connector (DE-9P, AMP). airflow at the nose and mouth for at least two breaths. Total
Electromyography (EMG) electrodes (a pair of monopolar needle sleep time (TST) refers to the time a rabbit spent asleep in any
electrodes) were inserted into the biceps femoris muscles. The sleep stage.
rabbits were administered amoxicillin (10 mg/kg, SQ) for 5 days
after electrode implantation. After 1 week of recovery, the rab-
bits were trained to sleep in the restraining apparatus for 2 Injection of Silicone and Saline/Postinjection
weeks. During the first week of habituation, the rabbits were Polysomnography
trained to sleep in the prone position. During the second week, Using endoscopic guidance, rabbits were injected with 1.5
the rabbits were habituated to sleep while they wore an mL to 3.0 mL liquid silicone (Dow Corning, Q7–9120 Silicone
adapted mask, thoraco-abdominal bands (Protech, Velcro Strap; Fluid; experimental group, n 5 6) or normal saline (control
Redmond, WA), and a foreleg pulse oximeter (Nonin, 2000SA group, n 5 6) into the base of the tongue once weekly (Fig.1).
Wrap Sensor; Plymouth, MN). The rabbits were considered to Polysomnography was performed every week after injection to
be habituated to the experimental conditions when they dis- evaluate the effect of injections on respiratory effort, apnea-
played normal sleep-wake cycles in the apparatus. Thereafter, hypopnea index (AHI), TST, sleep stage, and SaO2. Silicone
daily data recordings were taken for 1 month to test the stabil- injections were stopped when chronic regular hypopnea or
ity of sleep architecture. apnea developed; this was observed after a mean of three
injections (range, 2–4) with a mean cumulative injected vol-
ume of 5.6 6 1.9 mL liquid silicone. Saline was injected into
Baseline Polysomnography the base of the tongue in the same way as silicone injection.
Polysomnography was performed on rabbits before induc- The mean amount of saline injected into control rabbits was
tion of OSA using four EEG, two EOG, two EMG electrodes, 5.0 6 1.2 mL.
one abdominal belt sensor (inductance plethysmography), one Rabbits in the silicone group underwent postinjection poly-
air flow sensor, and one oximeter. Polysomnography was per- somnography 1 and 3 months after induction of OSA, and rabbits
formed from 9 am to 7 pm using a polygraph (B&TEK, Stellate in the saline group underwent postinjection polysomnography
Harmonie System; San Carlos, CA) with frequency ranges of 1 month after injection of saline.
Laryngoscope 124: March 2014 Yu et al.: Rabbit Model of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
790
Fig. 2. Example of a baseline poly-
somnography recording. air-
flow 5 nasal pressure transducer;
effort 5 abdominal strain gauges;
EMG 5 electromyogram; F3/Pz, F4/Pz,
P3/Pz, P4/Pz 5 electroencephalogra-
phy leads; LOC and ROC 5 left and
right electrooculogram; SaO2 5 oxy-
gen saturation. [Color figure can be
viewed in the online issue, which is
available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
Laryngoscope 124: March 2014 Yu et al.: Rabbit Model of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
791
Fig. 3. The effect of injection of silicone (w) and saline (•) on total sleep time (TST), sleep stage, apnea/hypopnea index (AHI), and minimal
blood oxygen saturation (SaO2). Values are means 6 SD.
after 1 month and 206.8 6 60.3 minutes after 3 months after injection, the AHIs in the silicone and saline
(P 5 0.054). The mean percentage of sleep stage I at the groups were 40.3 6 14.0 and 0.0, respectively (P 5 0.002).
baseline was 21.8 6 4.1%, whereas the mean percentage The TST of the silicone group at 1 month after injection
of sleep stage I in the silicon group at 1 and 3 months was 152.5 6 38.8, whereas that of the saline group was
after injection were 31.5 6 5.3 and 26.9 6 8.1%, respec- 210.8 6 21.9 (P 5 0.025). The minimal SaO2 was
tively (P 5 0.097). Although the percentage of sleep stage 81.5 6 6.7 and 93.5 6 3.0 in silicone and control groups,
I tended to increase and the percentage of sleep stage II respectively (P 5 0.004). There was no significant differ-
tended to decrease 1 month after silicone injection com- ence in the proportions of sleep stages between the sili-
pared to that of the baseline, these changes were not cone and saline groups (P > 0.05) (Fig 3). Significant
statistically significant (P > 0.05) (Fig 3). Minimal SaO2 narrowing of the oropharynx was noted 3 months after
during sleep was lower after silicone injection than at silicone injection. Injection-associated histologic changes
baseline. The minimal SaO2 at baseline and at 1 month in the tongue base are shown in Figure 6. Liquid silicone
and 3 months after injection were 94.7 6 2.1, 81.5 6 6.7, occupied the subepithelial and intramuscular spaces 3
and 82.7 6 6.9, respectively (P 5 0.016) (Fig 3). months after silicone injection. There was no evidence of
Rabbits in the control group showed obstructive inflammation or fibrosis. No definite histologic changes
breathing events immediately the after injection of were noted in animals from the saline group.
saline (Fig. 4), but there were no significant changes in
breathing events during sleep after 1 month (Fig. 5).
Hypopnea (0 hypopnea/h), TST (221.8 6 27.1 vs. DISCUSSION
210.8 6 21.9 min.), and minimal SaO2 (94.3 6 2.2% vs. An animal model of OSA may help to investigate
93.5 6 3.0%) were similar at 1 month compared to the the pathophysiology of this disorder and develop appro-
baseline (P > 0.05). Furthermore, there were no signifi- priate treatments. The ideal animal for such a model
cant changes in the proportions of sleep stages I and II should be small, inexpensive, and easy to obstruct upper
and REM sleep after saline injection (P > 0.05) (Fig 3). airway. Here, we have shown that injecting silicone into
There was a significant difference in the AHI after the upper airways of rabbits significantly modified air-
injection between silicone and saline groups. One month way anatomy. All six silicone-injected rabbits developed
Laryngoscope 124: March 2014 Yu et al.: Rabbit Model of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
792
Fig. 4. Example of a polysomnogra-
phy recording immediately after injec-
tion under general anesthesia.
Airflow 5 nasal pressure transducer;
Effort 5 abdominal strain gauges;
EMG 5 electromyogram; F3/Pz, F4/Pz,
P3/Pz, P4/Pz 5 electroencephalogra-
phy leads; LOC and ROC 5 left and
right electrooculogram; SaO2 5 oxy-
gen saturation. [Color figure can be
viewed in the online issue, which is
available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
hypopnea, but not the six control saline-injected rabbits. with different oxygen concentrations has been used to
The silicone group also showed modifications in sleep study the effects of respiratory disturbances during
architecture, which may have been due to sleep frag- OSA.19 However, these models do not allow us to investi-
mentation induced by disturbed breathing events. These gate the potential consequences of strenuous breathing
findings suggest that injection of silicone into rabbits is against an obstructed airway.8 Thus far the monkey is
a good animal model for breathing disorders during the animal that best provides a model for human OSA.
sleep. In that model, OSA is induced by the injection of colla-
A number of animal models such as dogs, pigs, and gen into the soft palate, posterior pharyngeal wall, and
rats have been used to investigate the pathophysiology base of the tongue.13 However, this model is hard to
of OSA. In addition, spontaneously occurring OSA has manipulate, costly, and not suitable for studies requiring
been documented in the English bulldog and obese large numbers of subjects. The advantages of using rab-
pig.10,12,14,15 These animals developed OSA events, bits, as in our model, are their small size, low cost, and
which resulted from a remarkably similar pathogenesis relatively ease with which the upper airway can be
to that described in humans with OSA.18 The major limi- obstructed. Therefore, rabbits can be used in large stud-
tations in using these models have been the difficulty in ies on OSA.
obtaining enough animals to establish a statistically In a preliminary study before developing an OSA
adequate sample for various types of studies; thus the model using rabbits, we performed a study on the natu-
use of English bulldog or obese pigs in nonsurvival ral sleep patterns of rabbits under the same conditions
research protocols is not possible. Intermittent airway as in the present study. In the preliminary study, no dis-
obstruction in tracheotomized dogs has also been studied ordered breathing developed more than two respiratory
in order to understand the pathophysiology of OSA.11 cycles during normal sleep in rabbit. Therefore, we
Although the long-term application of this model has defined hypopnea or apnea as a reduction in nasal flow
provided important insights into the effects of repeated signal recorded via a nasal mask for at least two breaths
airway occlusion during sleep, it does not account for in the present study. Additionally, in the preliminary
one major factor in the pathophysiology of human OSA, study, rabbits were injected with silicone into various
the upper airway. A rat model in which rats breathe air parts of oropharynx, including the soft palate, uvula,
Laryngoscope 124: March 2014 Yu et al.: Rabbit Model of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
793
Fig. 5. Example of a polysomnogra-
phy recording during sleep 1 month
after injection. Animals in the sili-
cone group showed hypopnea and
apnea. There were no significant
changes in breathing events in the
saline group. Airflow 5 nasal pres-
sure transducer; Effort 5 abdominal
strain gauges; EMG 5 electromyo-
gram; F3/Pz, F4/Pz, P3/Pz, P4/
Pz 5 electroencephalography leads;
LOC and ROC 5 left and right elec-
trooculogram; SaO2 5 oxygen satu-
ration. [Color figure can be viewed
in the online issue, which is avail-
able at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
tongue, and base of tongue. After several trials, we con- and unrestrained. In this respect, our model has a limi-
cluded that the tongue base between the circumvallate tation in that the experiments were performed with ani-
papillae was the most safe and effective injection site to mals under restraint. Nevertheless, the restraint was
develop sleep disordered breathings in rabbits. unavoidable in order to achieve high sensitivity and sta-
The present study has several limitations. First, the bility of sleep parameter recordings, especially airflow
REM sleep proportion to total sleep in our study appears status, which is necessary in order to detect abnormal
to be lower than that in natural sleep in rabbits, breathing during sleep. Also, the ventilation face mask
although previous studies showed wide variations in for recording nasal and oral airflow was difficult to keep
REM percentage during natural sleep that vary from in place under freely behaving conditions.
2.6% to 8.0%.17,20 In the present study, the identification At present, no single treatment exists for all OSA
of REM was somewhat less reliable due to the effects of patients. The most effective and commonly used treat-
phasic twitches on the amplitude of the integrated EMG ment for OSA is nasal continuous positive airway pres-
signal. Although the needle electrodes provided adequate sure, which requires patients to wear a mask through
signals, they were difficult to insert into awake rabbits which pressurized air is delivered to the nose during
and difficult to keep in place when an animal shook its sleep. Many patients, however, are unable to tolerate
trunk. Furthermore, sustained EMG inhibition, which is this therapy.24 There are no medications that are effec-
a common feature of REM in the rabbit, and extreme tive against OSA. Although surgical procedures such as
sensitivity to environmental stimuli and vulnerability to tracheostomy and mandibular advancement are effective
stress could be reasons for the low REM percentage.20 in most patients, they are either deforming or require a
Further evaluation of the differences in sleep disordered long surgical procedure with a painful postoperative
breathing between REM and non-REM in the rabbit course.25 Therefore, better treatments are clearly
model is warranted. Another problem in our study was needed. Animal models for sleep apnea may allow inves-
the difficulty in maintaining a continuous oximetry sig- tigators to perform pharmacological and surgical inter-
nal. Perhaps newer, more sensitive oximetry probes will ventions that are not possible in humans. These
eliminate this difficulty. Other studies have indicated interventions can be directed at understanding the
that pulse oximetry can accurately detect changes in mechanisms by which upper airway obstruction contrib-
SaO2 in pigs.21–23 Finally, the ideal animal model of utes to sleep apnea as well as to the development of bet-
OSA should involve an animal that is freely behaving ter and more widely available treatments.
Laryngoscope 124: March 2014 Yu et al.: Rabbit Model of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
794
Fig. 6. Microscopic view of the tongue base 3 months after silicone (upper) and saline (lower) injection. Liquid silicone (S) occupied the sub-
epithelial space and intramuscular space after injection. There was no evidence of inflammation or fibrosis in either group. Hematoxylin-
eosin stain, 310 (left), 3100 (right). E 5 stratified squamous epithelium; M 5 skeletal muscle fiber. [Color figure can be viewed in the online
issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
Laryngoscope 124: March 2014 Yu et al.: Rabbit Model of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
795
5. Tasali E, Ip MS. Obstructive sleep apnea and metabolic syndrome: altera- 16. National Institutes of Health (US). Office of Science and Health Reports.
tions in glucose metabolism and inflammation. Proc Am Thorac Soc In: Department of Health Education, and Welfare publication NIH, ed.
2008;5:207–217. Bethesda, Md: National Institutes of Health, 1996.
6. Fleisher KE, Krieger AC. Current trends in the treatment of obstructive 17. Miyara T. A study of EEG activities during sleep-wakefulness states in
sleep apnea. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2007;65:2056–2068. rabbits by autocorrelation and power spectrum analyses. Folia Psychiatr
7. Almendros I, Montserrat JM, Torres M, Gonzalez C, Navajas D, Farre R. Neurol Jpn 1985;39:571–580.
Changes in oxygen partial pressure of brain tissue in an animal model 18. Remmers JE, deGroot WJ, Sauerland EK, Anch AM. Pathogenesis of
of obstructive apnea. Respir Res 2010;11:3. upper airway occlusion during sleep. J Appl Physiol 1978;44:931–938.
8. Farre R, et al. Rat model of chronic recurrent airway obstructions to study 19. Fletcher EC. Invited review: Physiological consequences of intermittent
the sleep apnea syndrome. Sleep 2007;30:930–933. hypoxia: systemic blood pressure. J Appl Physiol 2001;90:1600–1605.
9. Farre R, Rotger M, Montserrat JM, Calero G, Navajas D. Collapsible 20. Pivik RT, Bylsma FW, Cooper P. Sleep-wakefulness rhythms in the rabbit.
upper airway segment to study the obstructive sleep apnea/hypopnea Behav Neural Biol 1986;45:275–286.
syndrome in rats. Respir Physiol Neurobiol 2003;136:199–209. 21. Erhardt W, Lendl C, Hipp R, Schindele M, Blumel G. Pulse oximetry—a
10. Hendricks JC, Kline LR, Kovalski RJ, O’Brien JA, Morrison AR, Pack AI. non-invasive method for direct and continuous monitoring of oxygen sat-
The English bulldog: a natural model of sleep-disordered breathing. J uration and pulse rate—comparative studies with blood gas analysis
Appl Physiol 1987;63:1344–1350. and hemoreflectometry in the dog, swine and sheep. Berl Munch Tier-
11. Kimoff RJ, et al. Canine model of obstructive sleep apnea: model descrip- arztl Wochenschr 1989;102:289–292.
tion and preliminary application. J Appl Physiol 1994;76:1810–1817. 22. Mendelson Y, Yocum BL. Noninvasive measurement of arterial oxyhemo-
12. Lonergan RP 3rd, Ware JC, Atkinson RL, Winter WC, Suratt PM. Sleep globin saturation with a heated and a non-heated skin reflectance pulse
apnea in obese miniature pigs. J Appl Physiol 1998;84:531–536. oximeter sensor. Biomed Instrum Technol 1991;25:472–80.
13. Philip P, Gross CE, Taillard J, Bioulac B, Guilleminault C. An animal 23. Petroianu GA, Maleck W, Bergler WF, Altmannsberger SH, Rufer R. Oxi-
model of a spontaneously reversible obstructive sleep apnea syndrome metry for amniotic fluid embolism detection in mini-pigs: tail or snout?
in the monkey. Neurobiol Dis 2005;20:428–431. Zentralbl Veterinarmed A 1996;43:415–421.
14. Pinto JM, Garpestad E, Weiss JW, Bergau DM, Kirby DA. Hemodynamic 24. Tonelli de Oliveira AC, et al. Diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnea syn-
changes associated with obstructive sleep apnea followed by arousal in a drome and its outcomes with home portable monitoring. Chest 2009;135:
porcine model. J Appl Physiol 1993;75:1439–1443. 330–336.
15. Tuck SA, Dort JC, Olson ME, Remmers JE. Monitoring respiratory func- 25. Schmidt-Nowara W, Lowe A, Wiegand L, Cartwright R, Perez-Guerra F,
tion and sleep in the obese Vietnamese pot-bellied pig. J Appl Physiol Menn S. Oral appliances for the treatment of snoring and obstructive
1999;87:444–451. sleep apnea: a review. Sleep 1995;18:501–510.
Laryngoscope 124: March 2014 Yu et al.: Rabbit Model of Obstructive Sleep Apnea
796