Name UK

Scores In GSL
Caucus-wise Scoring 12
Caucus-1
Caucus-2 10

Caucus-3
8
Caucus-4
Caucus-5
6
Caucus-6
Caucus-7 4
Caucus-8
Scores Through Chits 2
Scores Through POIs
Scores through Research 0
Scores Through Lobbying
Scores Through Procedural Accuracy

Scores for Oratory

 Caucus-wise scoring
12

10

Rank
Overall Disbursement of Scores
Names General Speakers List Mod Caucs. Chits POIs Research Lobbying
Afghanistan 6.5 20 0 0 4 3
Argentina 11.5 20 0 1 5 5
China 14.5 23 0 0 4 4
Germany 0 0 0 0 0 0
India 6.5 16 0 0 3 2
Iran 8.5 13.5 0 0 3 2
Iraq 0 0 0 0 0 0
Japan 7.5 14.5 0 0 3 2
Nigeria 8 16.5 0 0 3 3
Pakistan 0 9 0 0 1 1
Palestine 6 15.5 0 0 3 2
Russia 10.25 15.5 0 3 3 3
Saudi Arabia 0 0 0 0 0 0
Somalia 0 0 0 0 0 0
South Korea 0 2 0 0 1 1
Syria 6.5 15 1 0 3 3
Turkey 5.5 15.5 0 0 3 3
UK 8 8 0 0 2 2
USA 12.75 14.5 1 2 3 4
ProceduralPoints of OTotal Rank
4 0 37.5 5
5 3 50.5 1
4 0 49.5 2
0 0 0 16
3 0 30.5 8
3 0 30 9
0 0 0 16
3 0 30 9
3 0 33.5 6
1 0 12 14
2 0 28.5 12
3 0 37.75 4
0 0 0 16
0 0 0 16
1 0 5 15
3 0 31.5 7
3 0 30 9
3 0 23 13
1 0 38.25 3
Name
China
India
Japan
USA
Iran
Palestine
Turkey
Argentina
Russia
Nigeria
Syria
Afghanistan
USA
China
Iran
UK
Japan
USA
Nigeria
Afghanistan
Turkey
Argentina
UK
USA
China
Russia
Japan
Nigeria
Syria
Turkey
Afghanistan
Palestine
Argentina
Russia
USA
India
China
UK
Nigeria
Japan
Syria
Iran
Turkey
Afghanistan
China
Argentina
USA
Russia
Nigeria
Iran
Palestine
Verbatim
Understanding the terms, Defines Extradition, Defines Rendition,Talks about backdrop in own country,
Acknowledges Chinas address, Talks of India and Extradition, How the world is more connected and the need of such treaties h
Talks about Japans attitude, How it supports extradition, Against Rendition and Human rights' violation
How solutions to problems of rendition need to be addressed, How US complies with Geneva Convention, How committee nee
How war against terrorism by US has changed the way rendition is being used, Extradition be encouraged and rendition be red
Subjectivity of the term "Terrorist", About Palestine-Israel extradition arrangement,
Expresses favor towards extradition treaties,
Extradition leads to equity, Rendition hurts Equality, The reason we exist is to not descend into eye-for-an-eye attitude, No extr
Violent delights have violent ends, aggressive approach necessary at times, how can we prevent next 9/11,
About gravity of terrorism, About how having intense measures taken against terrorists, people fear the idea of being termed a
About how Rendition and Extradition both are a fruit of agreements, About how intelligence agencies are involved, How CIA op
About brainwashed terrorists, About how rendition has theory of deterrance in its backdrop which is wrong
Talks about how enough discussion has happened on the topic, acknowledges the points made by other delegates, acknowled
About extradition treaties of China, Bilateral and multilateral treaties to control crime,
Rendition takes away the right of having a trial in the nation a person is a resident of, Laws should be more focused on human
Defines rendition, about how extradition needs to exist devoid of political agendas and with full transparency, howthe governm

Wars of past and notion of sovereignty, The concept of sovereignty prime in understanding military intervention, How internati
Military intervention usually in terror ridden nations, how various militaries try to fight terrorism, example of india and surgical
USA now feels different than it used to, it accepts how it needs to reduce its efforts, how the sentiment is not reciprocated by o
How it can lead to creation of non state actors, eg. ISIS, China is a supporter of dialogue and peace talks, Talks of how they crea
How military intervention and making peace would have been absurd some years ago, its necessary however sometimes the si
International bodies can intervene when nations need help, direct the flow of the use
Nigeria has a conflict with Africa due to suicide bomber, boko haram etc
Abandons
Turkey is facing ISIS etc so they take allied help from NATO, UN and USA, reiterating the need to take the nations' right into acco
Right to protect the sovereignty,how US attacked Al qaeda despite having backed it in past, Doubts intentions of US, How Thes
How USA's interventions have always led to disasters, How full scale interventions cause problem, how it paves way for radical
Intervenor is looked at as an intruder, A revenge sentiment is incited in countries hosting intervention, how these interventions
What defines success of an intervention, The aim of these are to get short term peace, We need to determine the scale of the
Acknowledges some points mad eprior to him, appreciates the attempts made by nations to bring peace, saving even one pers
Interventions can not be pegged by any thumb rule, India helped east pakistan, also the role played by India in Peacekeeping fo
referring to speech given by USA,about US operations,US' wa ragainst terrorism in itself is a terrorism, operation deser storm- s
How military intervention is harmful,
About consequencies in WW2, How the wartime caused problems, How Nigeria has also faced many wars
Disarmament being the key word in todays discussion, how people's interest paramount
Where intervention has worked and where not, About the Korean war and tensions in the peninsula,
Intervention affects a country's sovereignty, How it shouldnt be done against the will of the home nation, about the situation in
EU, brics, etc regional organizations
Score SubstantivSubstantiv Substantive POI
7
7
5
8 Russia Argentina
5
5
2
7
6 USA
6
7 USA
5
4
7
6
5

8
6
7.5
7
6.5
5
5
0
5 Russia
8
7
8
8
6 Russia
6
8
5
5
5
6
6
4
Name
Iran
USA
China
Syria
Japan
Nigeria
India
Pakistan
Palestine
Afghanistan
Verbatim
Condemns rendition, Talks about legality of rendition
Rhetoric about UN and Human Rights, How Human Rights are in place even for the non-state actors,
Guantanamo Bay, About how it was used for Interrogations, Universal Declaration of Human Rights
About the 9/11 attacks and Rendition, How rendition leads to arm-twisting people into admitting guilt, How it created ISIS
Rendition in any form requires fulll disclosure
Talks about how Terrorists need to be dealt with harshly, Talks of Boko Haram problem, Supports Rendition
Talks of Cases of Rendition in past and how Human rights are violated by the same,
Measures and reasons of terrorism, Defines Terrorism,
Israel-Bulgaria Nayaf Zaid rendition, How it was wrong
How Rendition violates so many conventions, Acknowledges Nigerias views, Explains how extradition should be used
Score
2
2
3
3
1
3
2
1
2
3
Name
Afghanistan
Turkey
Nigeria
DPRK
Iran
China
Japan
UK
Russia
Argentina
Verbatim
How the punishment need to be reformative and how its states role to make sure every individual faces a fair trial
There should be a centralized framework that determines how extradition and rendition can take place, the methods of renditi
Claims rendition to be fair, Talks about problems faced by Nigeria due to terrorism
Targets USA for its stand,
Against Rendition, About rules of extradition and uniformity at a global level
Preconception of Innocence, About how judgement should come from an international body and not from any state
Trial should happen at home country,
About how rendition is bad, about how it affects world peace
About how the people on whom suspision of bigger crimes exists- should be treated differently
About presumption of Innocence, About rights of the prisoner and suspects, About how we have precedents of ideal adherenc
Score
2
2
2
1
1
2.5
2
1
2
3
Name
Argentina
China
Iran
Japan
India
Turkey
Afghanistan
Palestine
USA
Syria
Nigeria
South Korea
Saudi Arabia
UK
Pakistan
Verbatim
About Dual Criminality, On how to solve the same,Even if the criminal activities as defined in the jurisdiction are slightly differe
If extradition is asked for by 2 or more nations- its discretion of the home country to decide where to send the criminal, Abolish
Mandatory grounds of refusal, about their vagueness, about how military law could also be stated for extradition
About the transportation of the extradited criminals
About how crimes of political nature need to be recognised, vagueness in Article 3, Possible classification of the crimes
About Dual criminality cross, About how the minimum imprisonment tenure can be raised
About how the clause on mandatory refusal can be vague, Similar clauses on same article
Points against the grounds for refusal, David Headley case,
Iran, India, Afghanistan acknowledged, About how the clause that meddles with the domestic jurisdiction of the requesting cou
on the Article 7 and 8,
Similar to point made by India, about how criminals can manipulate this clause
About how lack of extradition leads to immunity being granted to certain people,
Abandons
Similar to point made by India,
Acknowledegs points made by China, USA and Pakistan
Score
3
3
2
2
4
2
2.5
3
3
3
2.5
2
0
2
1
Name
China
Syria
Nigeria
UK
USA
Palestine
Iran
Russia
Japan
Argentina
Turkey
India
Afghanistan
Pakistan
South Korea
Verbatim
How consent of international agencies very necessary, How SC is entrusted with keeping peace, How ceasefire can happen whe
UNSC is run by countries whose interests may cause bad judgement, Countries like US have often been blamed for misdemean
UNSC decides whether military intervention shall take place or not, dominance of US (particularly in the middle eastern states)
Main aim of military interventions is to destroy terrorists, decision should be on the armies, third body not required
USA has the biggest 'influence' towards the responsiosblity towards peacekeeping in the UN
UN intervention=influential countries' interventions, Israel defied UN convention attacking Palestine, transparency is required
Unfocus on military interventions, focus on destroying terrorist organizations, help of international organizations to be taken an
Biased UN body, state needing help should have a right to ask/deny help, how can the conflicts be stopped
International force speacilizing in transnational conflicts, under the US
What to do if government itself is participating in HR violations, Zimbawe?
Required military interventions like NATO, US, Turkey bombing of Syria, UN can account for the interventions after the military
No action taken by UNSC over Syria
Sub agenda is situation dependent, US helped Afghanistan
US played a key role in MI through the UN, good & bad, eg. Iraq and Afghanistan
Abandons
Score
3
3
2
3
2.5
2
2
2.5
2
3
2
1
2
1
0
Names
Afghanistan
USA
Iran
Pakistan
India
China
Japan
Russia
Turkey
Palestine
Syria
Verbatim
How the intervention should be humanitarian, Peacekeeping necessary despite responsibility to protect, bombings in aghanist
Responsibility to protect has helped, how it needs to also help rebuild
R2P measures are exercised as a last resort,
How R2P was made to make sure no acts of major consequences come on the people, gives a background
If a country commits Human rights violation- they need to be punished, how timely responses necessary, how its hypocritical fo
Explains the consequence when the R2P is triggered, how UN is the budy to govern and judge, How rebuilding is hard
R2P meaning, protection of civilians and efficiency in intervention
Rhetoric against US, how US' idea of rebuild just makes the countries more vulnerable
Sometimes governments are against the good of people, About successful human intervention, about USA's actions and how it
Question whether military int. Falls within R2P, About vagueness in the treaty
how major powers use it as a tool to interfere with the affairs, examplescold war seems to have
Score
3
3
2
2
3
3
2.5
3
2.5
2.5
3
Names
Nigeria
China
Japan
Afghanistan
Iran
Argentina
USA
Turkey
India
Palestine
Russia
Pakistan
Verbatim
UN charter gives UNSC the power to intervene, how UNSC does it, First seek solution through peaceful methods then approach
Persons not taking a part in conflict shouldnt be harmed, use of force against territorial integrity not allowed in the name of pe
How we need to introspect, how countries that have less power are being ignored, no individual in this world is undermined,
proper classification should be made about the conditions, then some peaceful measures must be taken, bullying shouldnt be
how use of force is devious against territorial integrity, notion of defensive force , how its a violation of charter when interventi
defensive force notion,about reparations and compensations, how unfortunate events take place becaus eof loose connect, ho
acknowledges loopholes in intevrentions of USA, about some previous treaties
How peacekeeping forces fail to help with regards to troop allocation,
How treaties work and how do we measure them, Peace treaties dont work because they are badly drafted, repurcussions for
About interventions in Rwanda,
About pre-requisitesof peacekeeping forces, law of armed conflict, how it should be in the hands of individual governments ti d
Uniting for peace resolution,
Score
4
3.5
3
3
2.5
4
2
3
3
2
3.5
2
Names
Argentina
Nigeria
Afghanistan
China
Turkey
Syria
UK
India
Japan
Palestine
Iran
Russia
Argentina
USA
Russia
Afghanistan
Turkey
China
Pakistan
Palestine
Verbatim
How UNHCR determines the quantum of Human rights violations, similar kind of fact-finding missions must be put in place
How UNSC should be strengthened and given more power to intervene in conflicts
Right to protect and issues related to the same,about how declarations should be binding, about how how approach should be
Military interventions should not be preferred in the first place, if at all it takes place it should happen by the consent of intern
when the military interventions should take place, how the help of regional blocs be taken
Instead of military aid humanitarian aid should be sent, About the Fact finding missions
How can UN help in strengthening the capacity within the smaller nations to help themselves,
Humanitarian intervention is important, forming blocs of military powers not the solution, aim of conflict resolution is to stop f
We already have central organizations in place but we are not using them
support local groups, blocking weapon flow in the country, emphasising peace
How the measures should be directed at political stabilty, so militaries dont end up becoming more violent than the violence th
How military interventions are necessary, how NGOs can come together, NGOs to help in situation after the war
US-Uk intervention in Iraq failure, MI not suitable dur to its aftereffects, EG force as a constabalry force, more such forces are n
Need expertise of regional powers/ organizations, reiteration of Nigeria and Turkey's points
No time to assess MI, thus a framework is need, fact checking might make it too late
Defined actions of the military, check vested interest of the army sent, revamping of right to protect
Regional forces must give some military aid, permission of the UN is needed for the MI
How Military can be controlled, arms embargo, cease fire, block terrorist funds
Why nations choose to participate in UN PF
Peace talks between conflicting nations, aid to form a democratic govt in the states
Score
4
3
2.5
3
2
3
2
3
2
2
2
2.5
3
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
From To Score
USA China 1
Syria USA 1
Names Score
Argentina 1
Argentina 1
Argentina 1