Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review Article
Majority of Ethiopian farmers have been using traditional way of agricultural practices which
persist to low productivity. To solve these problems, governmental and non-governmental
organizations have made efforts to bring about change through Agricultural extension strategy.
But these efforts notwithstanding, the rural population still practices subsistence. The
agricultural extension service is one of the institutional support services that has a central role
to play in the transformation process, but facing new extension challenge. There were many
studies conducted to identify role and challenges of extension service in Ethiopia in different
regions, but there is limitation of summarization of current state of understanding. However;
governments of developing countries are confronting new extension challenges: on the one
hand, there is a need to increase production to provide food for all citizens, raising the income
of the rural population and reducing poverty; on the other, hand there is a need to manage the
natural resources in a sustainable way with new technologies developed . The mandate of
extension services, whether public or private, has always been rural human resources
development with an aim to increase food production. The major challenge currently facing
agricultural extension service delivery in Ethiopia has its impact on the development of country.
INTRODUCTION
Eighty-three percent of the population depends directly on farmers. But these efforts notwithstanding, the rural
agriculture for their livelihoods, while many others depend population still practices subsistence (Birhanu et al.,
on agriculture-related cottage industries such as textiles, 2016).
leather, and food oil processing (IFPRI, 2009). Agriculture
contributes 43 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), Agricultural extension has a role to play in agricultural
85% of employment and up to 90 percent of total export development through support and facilitate people
earnings (MoADR, 2010). In spite of the vast agricultural engaged in agricultural production to solve problems and
potential, Ethiopia has been under the state of widespread to obtain information, skills, and technologies to improve
and persistent food insecurity since the 1970. People in their livelihoods and well-being. Agricultural extension
different parts of the country receive food aid (Birhanu et service could be the government agency or ministry
al., 2016) responsible for promoting the adoption and utilization
of new scientific farming practices through educational
Majority of Ethiopian farmers have been using traditional procedures (Asiabaka et al., 2012; Christoplos, 2010;
way of agricultural practices. This has contributed for low Birner et al., 2006 and Dragic et al., 2009).
productivity of the agricultural sector (Yishak and Punjabi,
2011). To solve these problems, governmental and non- However; criticism was also created with regards to the
governmental organizations have made efforts to bring roles of agricultural extension service delivery due to a
about change in agricultural production system of peasant lack of national framework for extension, but in this 21st
Review on Role and Challenges of Agricultural Extension Service on Farm Productivity in Ethiopia
Asfaw Albore 094
century, extension and advisory services needs to been remarkably successful at emphasizing external
reinvents itself and clearly articulates its roles in the rapidly inputs as the means to increase food production (FAO,
changing rural and agricultural context in order to improve 1998). This has led to growth in global consumption of
their relevancy (Magoro and Hlungwani, 2014). Extension pesticides, inorganic fertilizer, animal feed-stuffs, and
services needs staff with good understanding of technical tractors and other machinery. However, agricultural
knowledge and skills to manage social processes extension has value as policy instruments to achieve
government goal of increasing food production, stimulating
The public extension services in developing country economic growth, increasing the welfare of farm families
started experiencing some challenges in the last decade and promoting sustainable agriculture (Van den Ban and
due to socio-economic changes and agricultural sector Hawkins, 1998). The basic challenge for sustainable
reforms taking place (Zwane, 2012).According to Rivera agriculture is to make better use of internal resources. This
et al (2001) and Biratu (2008), governments of developing can be done by minimizing the external inputs used, by
countries are confronting new extension challenges: on regenerating internal resources more effectively, or by
the one hand, there is a need to increase production combinations of both. Evidence is now emerging that
to provide food for all citizens, raising the income of the regenerative and resource-conserving technologies and
rural population and reducing poverty; on the other hand practices can bring both environmental and economic
there is a need to manage the natural resources in a benefits for farmers, communities, and nations (FAO,
sustainable way in a rapidly changing world with new 1998).
technologies developed all the time. The mandate of
extension services, whether public or private, has always Increased reliance on chemicals may have negative
been rural human resources development with an aim to consequences for the environment and raises the question
increase food production through the introduction of of both economic and environmental sustainability, and the
improved agricultural technology. The need to increase consequences of such inputs on the quality of livelihoods.
agricultural productivity to enhance food security and Pretty et al. (1996) called for greater emphasis to be
reduce poverty in Africa is widely acknowledged (World placed on ‘sustainable agriculture’ noting that ‘a massive
Bank, 2007). increase in inorganic fertilizers and pesticides is not a
necessary condition for feeding the world [although] in
There were many studies conducted to identify role and certain agro-ecological systems, moderate applications of
challenges of extension service in Ethiopia in different fertilizers will be necessary to ensure the appropriate
region (Belay and Degnet, 2004; Belay, 2002; Belay & De balance of plant nutrients and minerals in the soils.’ A more
missie, 2014), but there is limitation of summarization of sustainable agriculture pursues a number of goals - the
current state of understanding on challenges and role of incorporation of natural processes such as nutrient cycling;
agricultural extension service or previously published minimization of the use of external and non-renewable
studies on topic. Review of challenges and prospectus for inputs; the participation of farmers and rural people in all
a particular region is crucial for future policy formulation. processes of problem analysis and a greater use of local
This study has identified some of the challenges and knowledge (Shah, 1994; SWCB, 1994; Pretty, 1995).
prospectus of agricultural extension service.
According to Rivera et al (2001), governments of
developing countries are confronting new extension
METHODOLOGY challenges: on the one hand, there is a need to increase
production to provide food for all citizens, raising the
Data were obtained from document analysis. It was income of the rural population and reducing poverty; on the
undertaken using in-depth review of related literature from other hand, there is a need to manage the natural
the Internet and up to-date extension service challenges resources in a sustainable way in a rapidly changing world
reports of Ethiopian government. Published articles and with new technologies developed all the time. Therefore,
books, reports from government and non-government it is important that policy-makers are aware of the key role
organizations, archives of stakeholders’ organizations and that extension plays in the national economy development
some media reports (print and electronic) were also before modernizing and reforming the existing agricultural
explored. system (Qamar 2005). Though achievements in crop
improvement in the last 20 years are undeniable, poor
farming families’ needs are unaddressed. On the other
RESULT AND DISCUSSION hand, exotic cultivars can give better yields under selected
demonstration sites with good management, but under
Emerging challenges for sustainable agricultural conditions that prevail in most peasant farms, where there
development is low inputs and varying climatic conditions, local
landraces usually perform better than exotic ones (Lakew
Emerging challenges for sustainable agriculture during the et al., 1997).
past fifty years was agricultural development policies have
Review on Role and Challenges of Agricultural Extension Service on Farm Productivity in Ethiopia
Int. J. Agric. Educ. Ext. 095
Extension agent gives timely advice to make them aware Farmers and communities have little urged to conserve
of a problem and helps farmers to decide most important resources unless they are forced by legislation (Zwane,
goals (Van den Ban and Hawkins ,1998). 2012). An extensionist does not use force but known
strategies of persuasion to assist farmers and
communities to conserve natural resources.
Review on Role and Challenges of Agricultural Extension Service on Farm Productivity in Ethiopia
Asfaw Albore 096
Challenges of agricultural extension service in According to Biratu (2008) a good agricultural extension
Ethiopia system accepts and incorporates farmers’ traditional
knowledge in research processes and sees farmers as
The major challenges of the past and current agricultural partners during decision making. However, in most cases
extension service delivery in Ethiopia are :absence of the the problem with science in agriculture and extension is
national framework of agricultural extension policy that has that it has a poor understanding of the knowledge from
been developed in a participatory manner, top down, very poor, indigenous rural people. For many scientists, in
Review on Role and Challenges of Agricultural Extension Service on Farm Productivity in Ethiopia
Int. J. Agric. Educ. Ext. 097
order to develop those rural people, formal research and as it affects both staff and clientele and involves human
extension has to transform their knowledge into another emotions to a depressing degree, that is, in addition to
knowledge system, because their knowledge is technical aspects. The spread of HIV/AIDS is
considered as unscientific and primitive (Röling and Pretty, counteracting gains in human development and has the
1997). This is true when it comes to the case of agricultural potential for serious social dislocation especially in rural
extension in Ethiopia. In most cases, the approach is top- areas (Vince, 2005; Kalim , 2003). From nature of
down, whereby technologies are developed somewhere extension work most of the extension staff themselves
and the farmers are told what to do by the development have their genetic roots in rural families. They travel
agents (EEA, 2006; Belay, 2002; Belay, 2003; Abesha et frequently in rural areas, many times spending nights away
al, 2000; Wale and Yalew, 2007) and as it was indicated from home, and being offered “hospitality” in villages due
by Simane. (2004), much of the agricultural inputs to their status. Also, they are in touch with so many widows
imported and distributed are supply driven, without giving forced into farming because of their husbands’ death, who
due consideration to the demand from the farmers’ side. need extension advice. Thus, the extension workers have
ample opportunities of getting involved with multiple sex
Weak research-extension linkage partners (Kalim, 2003). All these factors expose the
extension staff to the maximum risk of HIV infection,
According to Belay and Dawit (2017) earlier empirical especially with their very limited knowledge of the
studies in developing countries have identified weak epidemic. Reductions and disruptions in staff is the other
links between research and extension as the major factor dimension of challenges extension service. According to
limiting the flow of information, knowledge, useful new Kalim (2003) discussions made with government
technologies, and resources among actors in the extension service officials reveal that their capacity for
technology-delivery utilization system and recommend delivering satisfactory services is being affected by
measures to overcome the widely acknowledged HIV/AIDS. This is due to disruption in their programmes
weaknesses (Agbamu, 2000; Anderson and Feder, 2004; caused by deaths, protracted sickness and frequent
Asiabaka, 2002; Belay, 2002, 2003). Under normal absences of staff.
conditions, agricultural extension service serves as a
farmer organization that expresses the concern and Technical
feeling of farmers to the public and conveys information
from research institute to farmers and from the farmers Lack of suitable adaptation of technology packages to
back to research institutes (Birkhaeuser, et al 1991). local conditions
Contrary to this fact, agricultural research in Ethiopia is
Available evidence shows that yields of major crops under
poorly linked to extension (Belay, 2003; EEA, 2006; Wale
farmers’ management are still far lower than what can be
and Yalew, 2007) because of the fact that extension and
obtained under research managed plots (Abate, 2006;
research activities have been carried out under different
EIAR, 2007). This is the result of research and extensions
institutions with zero or minimal coordination between
that were put in place used one size-fits for all types of
them (Belay, 2002).
extension methods and there is no extension that suits
for all categories of adopters (EEA, 2006). Inadequate
Gender biased service
research outputs on the felt needs of
Gender issues should be afforded the highest priority in farmers/pastoralists factors limit the contribution of
Ethiopian extension. Failure to take into account gender agricultural extension to the growth of agricultural
relationships leads to unsuccessful extension activities, output and productivity (Birhanu G. et al, 2016; Tilahun,
the marginalization of the disadvantaged sector of society 2008). To summarize, research process and agricultural
and a large part of the agricultural workforce (Vince, 2005; extension services in Ethiopia lack preferences, criteria
Olawoye, 2005 and Odebode, 2008). It includes focusing and conditions of the farmers (Wale and Yalew, 2007)
on the relationship between men and women, their roles, and a well-articulated national research and extension
access to and control over resources, the division of policy is not yet developed in the country (Demese, 2004
labour, and other needs. Thus, understanding gender as cited in Wale and Yalew, 2007).
relationships and adjusting methods and messages to
them is crucial. A holistic approach to research and Financial
extension that considers the total socio-economic system Inadequate public funding
is more likely to result in technology solutions being more
family and women friendly One generic problem confronting the extension service is
inadequate public funding. The problem is especially acute
HIV/AIDS epidemic with regard to operational budget. Operating costs are
usually liable to budget cuts. Shortages of operating costs
Challenge of an HIV/AIDS epidemic on agricultural seriously affect the effectiveness of the extension service
extension services in sub-Saharan Africa is quite unusual (Berhanu et al, 2006 and Axinn, 1988).
Review on Role and Challenges of Agricultural Extension Service on Farm Productivity in Ethiopia
Asfaw Albore 098
Asiabaka C, Nnadi F, Ajaero J, Aja O, Ugwoke F, (2006). From best practice to best fit: A framework for
Ukpongson M, Onweagba A (2012).The role of designing and analyzing agricultural advisory services.
extension officers and extension services in the ISNAR Discussion Paper No. 5. Washington, D.C.:
development of agriculture in Nigeria. Anaeto .Vol. IFPRI.
1(6), pp. 180 – 185 Christoplos,I.(2010). Mobilizing the potential of rural and
Axinn GH. (1988). Guide on alternative extension Agricultural extension. Rome:FAO
approaches. FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization Dragic Z, Sreten J, Zoran R (2009). The role of
of the United Nations), Rome, Italy. knowledge, innovation and human capital in
Belay Demisse and et al (----) Creating Extension Service multifunctional agriculture and territorial rural
Delivery Through Public-Private Partnerships development, Belgrade, Republic of Serbia.pp2
Belay Demissie (2014) Agricultural Extension System of EEA(2006). Evaluation of the Ethiopian Agricultural
Ethiopia: A Case from Amhara region Practice, Extension With Particular Emphasis on the
Challenges, Way forward; Presented at Participatory Participatory Demonstration and Training Extension
Research Workshop and Project Meeting, 11-12 System (PADETS). Ethiopian Economic
August 2014,AA, Ethiopia Extension Service in Ethiopia Association/Ethiopian Economic Policy research
Belay Kassa (2003). Agricultural Extension in Ethiopia: Institute, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
The Case of Participatory Demonstration and Training EIAR (Ethiopian Institute of Agricultural Research) (2007),
Extension System. Journal of social Development in The Contribution of Agricultural Research in the Eve of
Africa, 18(1): 49-83 the Ethiopian Millennium (in Amharic), Mimeograph,
Belay Kassa and Dawit Alemu 2017.Agricultural Research Addis Ababa.
and Extension Linkages: Challenges and Intervention FAO (1998), Improving agricultural extension: A reference
Options. Ethiopian Journal Agricultural Scienc. 27(1) manual, FAO, Rome.
55-76 (2017) FAO (M. Kalim Qamar) , (2003). Facing The Challenge Of
Belay Kassa (2002), Constraints to Extension Work in An HIV/AIDS Epidemic: agricultural extension services
Ethiopia: The Insiders' View, South African Journal of in sub-Saharan Africa. Extension, Education and
Agricultural Extension, 31: 63-79. Communication Service Research, Extension and
BelayKassa. and Degnet, A. (2004), Challenges Facing Training Division Sustainable Development
Agricultural Extension Agents: A Case Study from Department. Food And Agriculture Organization Of The
South Western Ethiopia, African Development Review, United Nations ,Rome
16 (1): 139-168. Howard, JA, Kelly, v., Stepanek, J., Crawford, E.W., Mulat,
Berhanu Gebremedhin, Hoekstra D and AzageTegegne. D. and Maredia, M. (1999). Green Revolution
(2006). Commercialization of Ethiopian agriculture: Technology Takes Root in Africa: The Promise and
Extension service from input supplier to knowledge Challenges of the Ministry of Agriculture! SG 2000
broker and facilitator. IPMS (Improving Productivity and Experiment with Improved Cereals Technology in
Market Success) of Ethiopian Farmers Project Working Ethiopia, Michigan State University International
Paper 1. ILRI (International Livestock Research Development Working Paper No 76, East Lansing,
Institute), Nairobi, Kenya. 36 pp. Michigan State University
Biratu, GizachewKebede (2008) Agricultural Extension IFPRI (2009). Review and Recommendations for
and Its Impact on Food Crop Diversity and the Strengthening the Agricultural Extension System in
Livelihood of Farmers in Guduru, Eastern Wollega, Ethiopia.IFPRI, Addis Ababa
Ethiopia. A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the Lakew, L., Semeane, Y., Alemayehu, F., Gebre, H.,
requirement for the degree of Master of Science in Grando, S., Van Leur, J. A. G., and Ceccarlli, S. (1997).
Management of Natural Resources and Sustainable Exploiting the Diversity of Barley Landraces in Ethiopia.
Agriculture (MNRSA). Norwegian University of Life Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution 44:109-116
Sciences (UMB), Ås, Norway Magoro M. David and Hlungwani S. Samuel (2014) The
Birhanu Gedif, Tegegn Molla, Solomon Addisu and Role Of Agriculture Extension In The 21 Century:
YibeltalAyenew (2016). Status of Agricultural Reflections From Africa.International Journal
Innovations, Innovation Platforms, and Innovations Agricultural Extension. 02(01) 2014. 89-93
Investment. 2015 PARI project country report: Federal Mengistie Mossie and Belete Meseret (2015) A review on
Democratic Republic of Ethiopia. Forum for Agricultural the role of extension service for agricultural
Research in Africa (FARA), Accra Ghana transformation with particular Emphasis on Ethiopia.
Birkhaeuser, D., Evenson, R. E., and Feder, G. (1991). Journal of Agricultural Economics, Extension and Rural
The Economic Impact of Agricultural Extension: A Development: ISSN-2360-798X Vol. 2(1): pp 224-228,
Review. Economic Development and Cultural Change January, 2015.
39(3): 607-650. MoARD. (2010). Ethiopia’s Agricultural Sector Policy and
Birner, R., K. Davis, J. Pender, E. Nkonya, P. Investment Framework (PIF) 2010-2020. Ministry of
Anandajayasekeram, J. Ekboir, A. Mbabu, D. Agriculture and Rural Development, Addis Ababa,
Spielman, D. Horna, S. Benin, W. Kisamba-Mugerwa. Ethiopia.
Review on Role and Challenges of Agricultural Extension Service on Farm Productivity in Ethiopia
Asfaw Albore 100
Mohammad S. (2009). Agricultural sustainability: models and recent trends in organizing agricultural
Implications for extension systems. College of Extension. Food and Agriculture Organization of the
Agriculture, Islamic Azad University, Rasht Branch, United Nations. Rome.
Rasht, Iran. SWCB (1994). The impact of the catchment approach to
Neuchatel Group (1995). Common framework on soil and water conservation: A study of six catchments
agricultural extension. The environment of agricultural in Western, Rift Valley and Central provinces of Kenya.
extension is changing. Nairobi: Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock Development
Pretty, J. N. (1995). Regenerating agriculture: Policies and and Marketing.
practice for sustainability and self-reliance. London: Takele, G. (1997), ‘Sasakawa Global 2000 in the
Earthscan Publications. Qamar, M. K. (2005). Intensification of Agriculture in Ethiopia’, Paper
Modernizing National Agricultural Extension System: A Presented in the 13th International Conference of
proatical Guide for Policy Makers of Developing Ethiopian Studies, Koyoto, 12–17 December.
Countries. FAO, Research, Extension and Training Vince Ashworth, 2005. The challenges of change for
Division. agricultural extension in Ethiopia, A discussion paper,
Rivera, M. W., (1989). An overview of agricultural IPMS/ILRI , Addis Ababa.
extension systems. Extension definitions and systems Wale, E. and Yalew, A. 2007. Farmers’ Variety Attribute
in: Kesseba A.M. (ed.). Technology systems for small Preferences: Implication for Breeding Priority Settings
farmers: Issues and options. West view Press, Boulder, and Agricultural Extension Policy in Ethiopia. African
San Francisco and London. Development Bank, 379-396
Rivera, M. W., (1989). An overview of agricultural World Bank. 2007. World Development Report 2008:
extension systems. Extension definitions and systems Agriculture for development. WashingtonDC: World
in: Kesseba A.M. (ed.). Technology systems for small Bank
farmers: Issues and options. Westview Press, Boulder, Yishak G. and N. K. Punjabi (2011) Determinants Of
San Francisco and London Adoption Of Improved Maize Technology in Damot
Rivera, W. M., Qamar, M. K, and Crowder, L.V. (2001) Gale, Wolait A, Ethiopia.Raj. Journal Extension
.Agriculture and Rural Extension World Wide: Options Education. 19 : 1-9, 2011
for Institutional Reform in the Developing Countries. Zwane, E. M., (2012). Does Extension Have A Role To
FAO, Extension, Education and Communication Play In Rural Development? South African Journal
Service; Research, Extension and Training Division, Agricultural Extension .Vol. 40,: 24 16 – ISSN 0301-
Rome. 603X
Rohana P Mahaliyanaarachchi & R M A S Bandara (2006).
Commercialization of Agriculture and Role of
Agricultural Extension. Sabaragamuwa University,
Belihuloya. Sabaragamuwa University Journal
Röling, N. and Pretty, J. N. (1997). Extension’s role in Accepted 19 January 2018
sustainable agricultural development: Emerging
challenges for sustainable agriculture. In Swanson, Citation: Albore A. (2018). Review on Role and
B.E., Bentz, R.P., and Sofranko, A.J.(eds). Improving
agricultural extension. A reference manual. FAO, Challenges of Agricultural Extension Service on Farm
Rome, Italy. Productivity in Ethiopia. International Journal of
Röling, N. (1999). Sustainability as an outcome of human Agricultural Education and Extension, 4(1): 093-100.
interaction: implications for curricula in higher
agricultural education in industrialized countries, In:
Wout Van de Bor, P. Holen, A. Wals, and Leals W. eds.
Integrated concepts of sustainability into education for
agriculture and rural development. Frankfurt. Copyright: © 2018 Asfaw Albore. This is an open-access
Shah, P. (1994). Participatory watershed management in article distributed under the terms of the Creative
India: The experience of the Aga Khan Rural Support Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
Programme. In I. Scoones & J. Thompson (Eds.),
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
Beyond Farmer First. London: IT Publications.
Swanson, B. E. & Claar, J. B., 1984. Defining extension provided the original author and source are cited.
Agricultural extension: A reference manual. Alternative
Review on Role and Challenges of Agricultural Extension Service on Farm Productivity in Ethiopia