Proceedings of the ASME 2016 International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition
IMECE2016 November 11-17, 2016, Phoenix, Arizona, USA
IMECE2016-67949
COMPUTATIONAL MODELING OF ANTERIOR AND POSTERIOR PELVIC ORGAN
PROLAPSE (POP)
Arnab Chanda Vinu Unnikrishnan
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Department of Aerospace Engineering, University of Alabama University of Alabama Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA
Holly E. Richter Mark E. Lockhart
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Department of Radiology, University of Alabama at Division of Urogynecology and Pelvic Birmingham Reconstructive Surgery, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Alabama, USA Birmingham Birmingham, Alabama, USA
ABSTRACT were estimated in terms of the induced stresses, strains and
displacements. The degree of bladder filling was found to be a Pelvic Organ Prolapse (POP) is a condition of the female strong indicator of stress build-up on the AVW. Also, vaginal pelvic system suffered by a significant proportion of women in tissue stiffening was found to increase the size of the high stress the U.S. and more across the globe, every year. POP is caused zone on the AVW. The second simulation consisted of modeling by the weakening of the pelvic floor muscles and musculo- the different degrees of posterior vaginal wall (PVW) prolapse, connective tissues due to child birth, menopause and morbid in the presence of an average abdominal pressure. The vaginal obesity. Prolapse of the pelvic organs namely the urinary length was segmented into four sections to study the localized bladder, uterus, and rectum into the vaginal canal can cause stresses and strains. Also, a clinically well-known phenomena vaginal discomfort, strained urination or defecation, and sexual known as the kneeling effect was observed with the PVW in dysfunction. To date, success rates of native tissue POP which the vaginal wall displaces away from the rectum and surgeries vary from 50-70% depending on the definition of cure downward towards the vaginal hiatus. All of these results have and time-point of assessment. A better understanding of the relevant clinical implications and may provide important mechanics of prolapse may lead to improvement in surgical perspective for better understanding the mechanics of POP outcomes. In the current work, the mechanics of progression of pathophysiology. anterior and posterior vaginal prolapse were modeled to understand the effect of bladder fill and posterior vaginal INTRODUCTION stresses using computational approaches. A realistic and full- scale female pelvic system model, comprised of the urinary The female pelvic floor is a complex system that goes bladder, vaginal canal, uterus, rectum, and fascial connective through drastic changes during puberty, labor with vaginal tissue, was developed using image segmentation methods. All of delivery and menopause. Pelvic organ prolapse (POP) [1, 2] is a the relevant loads and boundary conditions were applied based condition in which the pelvic floor muscles and connective on a comprehensive study of the anatomy and functional tissue weaken progressively causing prolapse of the pelvic morphology of the female pelvis. Hyperelastic material models organs namely the urinary bladder, uterus or rectum into the were adopted to characterize all pelvic tissues, and a non-linear vaginal walls or vagina, and consequently may lead to vaginal analysis was invoked. In the first set of simulations, a realistic discomfort, strained urination or defection, and sexual bladder filling and vaginal tissue stiffening in prolapse were dysfunction. A cystocele or prolapse of the Anterior Vaginal modeled and their effects on the anterior vaginal wall (AVW) Wall (AVW), is the most common type of POP suffered by over
Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/conferences/asmep/90996/ on 05/01/2017 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/abo
300,000 women in the US [3]. Figure 1 depicts the AVW prolapse conditions compared to normal female pelvis anatomy. Posterior vaginal wall (PVW) prolapse occurs in the form of a rectocele (the distal portion of the rectum pushes against and moves the back wall of the vagina) or enterocele (the small bowel presses against and moves the upper wall of the vagina or dissects between the rectum and vagina).
FIGURE 2: MRI IMAGE SEGMENTATION IN
TURTLESEG SOFTWARE
FINITE ELEMENT MODELING
True 1:1 scale MRI Images of the female pelvis were
obtained from the Korean Female database [5], and converted into Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) format. These images were loaded into an image segmentation software, TurtleSeg [6] and contoured in the transverse, coronal and sagittal planes to obtain the crude outer surfaces for the urinary bladder, vaginal canal (and uterus) and the rectum (See Figure 2). The outer surfaces were exported as stereolithographic (STL) files and imported in Meshlab FIGURE 1: NORMAL PELVIC ANATOMY COMPARED software for smoothening. The smooth surfaces from Meshlab WITH VARIOUS PROLAPSE CONDITIONS were taken into Hypermesh software (Altair Inc.) and corrected appropriately to begin meshing. An iterative process of surface Finite element modeling (FEM) has been used to simulate correction followed by meshing was carried out over 50 times complex mechanisms of the female pelvic floor observed to ensure a good mesh with no failing elements. The surface through imaging techniques such as the Magnetic Resonance meshes of all the pelvic organs in true 1:1 scale (Figure 3) were Imaging (MRI), ultrasound and Diffusion Tensor MRI (DT- converted into tetrahedral volume meshes. A higher order 3D MRI) [3]. The effect of abdominal pressure on the vaginal canal 20-node Solid 186 type quadratic tetrahedral element type was has been studied under varying pelvic floor conditions. used generating 15851, 5658, and 21477 elements in number Additionally, POP conditions have been investigated using for the urinary bladder, vaginal canal (and uterus) and the various phenomenological numerical modeling techniques [3]. rectum respectively. The FE meshes were imported into ANSYS In most such computational models, unrealistic and APDL software, and a non-linear analysis was invoked. oversimplified loads and boundary conditions, and material models (for tissues) have been assumed. Further studies have to be conducted to realistically model the interaction between the pelvic organs and actual loading conditions such as urine filling, or rectal bulging into the vagina due to prolapse.
In the current work, a full scale computational model of the
female pelvic system comprising the urinary bladder, vaginal canal, uterus and the rectum has been developed using an MRI based image segmentation from the visible Korean human database [4]. The assignment of realistic loads and boundary conditions are discussed in the upcoming sections. The current numerical models would be indispensable for better understanding of the mechanics of anterior and posterior FIGURE 3: COMPUTATIONAL MODELS OF PELVIC vaginal wall prolapse, and may provide important guidelines to ORGANS IN 1:1 SCALE urogynecologic surgeons for improved surgical planning.
Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/conferences/asmep/90996/ on 05/01/2017 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/abo
NONLINEAR MATERIAL MODELING muscles and ligaments have been neglected to simplify Non-linear mechanical behavior of soft tissues are precisely computations, however their effects have been considered characterized using hyperelastic constitutive equations such as appropriately in choosing the loads and boundary conditions. Mooney-Rivlin, Yeoh, Neo-Hookean, and Ogden models [7]. In The fascial contacts between the pelvic organs were modeled an isotropic hyperelastic model, the strain-energy density with a flexible and bonded contact pair in the FE framework. function (ψ) is a linear function of strain invariants I1, I2 and I3 Based on prior works by DeLancey et al. [10] on the functional along the three principal directions (see Equation 1). anatomy of the pelvic floor, the fundus of the uterus, urethra, the vaginal and rectal hiatus were constrained in all degrees of ( I1 , I 2 , I3 ) (1) freedom. Also, for the first set of simulations involving the 3 urinary bladder and the vaginal canal, the posterior vaginal wall I1 i2 (2) was constrained to assume absolutely no posterior prolapse i 1 3 effects. In the second set of simulations involving the vaginal I2 i , j 1 i 2 2 j (3) canal and the rectum, the posterior rectal wall was constrained in all degrees of freedom to simulate its strong attachment with I 3 i 1 i2 the pelvis through ligaments. Additionally, a novel forced 3 (4) volume expansion technique was employed (based on previous work by Chanda et al. [11]) to simulate the varying degrees of The strain invariants are functions of the principal stretches bladder fill (Figure 4) and rectal prolapse into the vagina in the λ1, λ2 and λ3 given by equations 2-4. In the current work, the first and second set of simulations, respectively. The method rectal, bladder and vaginal tissues were modeled using Yeoh’s involves the specification of a hypothetical thermal expansion hyperelastic model [8]. Equation 5 gives the isotropic strain coefficient (k) of 10-4 for the volume mesh elements. Every energy functions of the Yeoh’s model, where C10, C20, and C30 mesh element was then assigned an initial reference are the three material constants. ‘K’ is the material specific bulk (hypothetical) temperature (To) of 0 C, and a final temperature modulus and ‘J’ is the Jacobian which accounts for the (T) to invoke volume expansion for every mesh element (and compressibility property of the material (J=1 in case of a thus the entire volume), given by equation 7. It should be completely incompressible material). Based on the experimental mentioned here that hypothetical temperatures have been used studies on pelvic tissues in literature [9], the Yeoh’s curve fitting just to simulate a forced volume expansion, and not to include parameters adopted (estimated using equation 6) in our study any thermal effects. Also, this forced thermal expansion is are listed in Table 1. independent of the material property of the tissue. Only the induced effect of this expansion has been utilized to simulate 3 K Yeoh Ci 0 ( I1 3)i ( J 1)2 (5) bladder filling or rectal bulging phenomena. i 1 2 1 Yeoh 2( 2 )(c10 2c20 ( I1 3) 3c30 ( I1 3)2 ) (6) % Volume Expansion 100 k T , T T To (7)
TABLE 1: YEOH’S HYPERELASTIC MATERIAL
MODEL PARAMETERS ADOPTED FOR PELVIC TISSUES IN THE ANALYSES
LOADS AND BOUNDARY CONDITIONS FIGURE 4: NOVEL FORCED VOLUME EXPANSION
TECHNIQUE USED TO SIMULATE URINE FILLING IN The female pelvic organs are connected to each other, with THE BLADDER pelvic floor muscles, and various connective tissue elements, For the first set of simulations, the stresses induced due to which are complex to visualize and recreate in a computational bladder filling on the AVW were estimated. Also, a novel model [3]. In the current work, only the urinary bladder, vaginal vaginal stiffening material model was developed to look at the canal, uterus and rectum have been modeled. Pelvic floor
Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/conferences/asmep/90996/ on 05/01/2017 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/abo
AVW changes due to vaginal tissue stiffening secondary to the Y-direction, and the changes in the vaginal cross-sections in prolapse. The model was comprised of defining vaginal tissue the four regions were tracked for different cases of rectal properties in normal, low and high degrees of prolapse (Figure prolapse. 5). Eight cases were simulated within the upper and lower bounds of prolapsed vaginal tissue conditions, in different bladder fill conditions (empty through full), to look at the combined effects of bladder filling and vaginal tissue stiffening
FIGURE 7: VAGINAL LENGTH DIVIDED INTO FOUR
EQUAL SECTIONS FOR ANALYSES
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The urinary bladder volume was forced to expand from 0
through 100 percent (based on assignment of different final temperatures T, and equation 6), to simulate varying degrees of bladder fill. Figure 8 shows the effects of an empty bladder and fully filled bladder conditions respectively on the AVW. Three main observations were recorded. First, bladder filling was found to cause a more uniform stress distribution at the AVW. FIGURE 5: VAGINAL TISSUE STIFFENING Second, despite a more uniform stress redistribution, at high MATERIAL MODEL WITH UPPER AND LOWER bladder fills, some small areas developed high stress BOUNDS USED IN OUR ANALYSES concentrations, which may potentially cause vaginal discomfort. in prolapse. Third, compared to a maximum stress value of 0.12 MPa at an empty bladder condition, a very high maximum stress build-up In the second part of the work, different degrees of rectal of 5.16 MPa was observed at the AVW fully filled bladder prolapse were simulated. Based on literature [12] on functional condition. Additionally, it was found that the maximum anatomy of rectal prolapse, the degree of prolapse was displacement was induced on the AVW in the negative Y quantified based on the maximum distance estimated from the direction (pushing the AVW towards the vaginal hiatus). At a anorectal axis (line passing through the centroidal axis of rectal fully filled bladder condition, a 7.98 mm maximum negative Y hiatus or the anus in Figure 6) to the farthest point of the displacement was estimated. Also, a reasonably high [13, 14] prolapsed rectum [12]. The vaginal length was divided into four mechanical strain of 0.27 was found for the vaginal tissues at equal sections in the Y-Z plane as shown in Figure 7. The fully filled bladder condition, which was almost four times that average cross-sections of the vaginal canal (along the Y in case of an empty bladder condition. direction) were estimated in the four sections. An average abdominal pressure of 30 cm H2O (or 2.94 kPa) was applied in Eight cases of vaginal tissue stiffening were simulated for different bladder fill conditions. At a particular bladder fill condition (Figure 9 shows a 50% bladder fill situation), the stress distribution at AVW was observed to be uniform with a small zone of high stress concentration at the mid-vagina. With increasing vaginal tissue stiffening, the size of this high stress concentration zone was found to increase without any significant change in the stress value (1.98 ± 0.05 MPa), which may represent an etiology for progressive vaginal discomfort [15]. A 3D plot was generated for four of the ten bladder fill cases simulated (Figure 10), and five of the eight prolapse cases to study the combined effect of bladder fill and vaginal tissue FIGURE 6: EXAMPLE OF POSTERIOR VAGINAL stiffening due to prolapse on the maximum stress build-up at the WALL PROLAPSE SIMULATION AND QUANTIFICATION
Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/conferences/asmep/90996/ on 05/01/2017 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/abo
In the second set of simulations, a constrained expansion of the rectum (0-100%) was invoked in the presence of an average abdominal pressure on the AVW, and its effects on the vaginal walls were quantified. The 0% rectum expansion was considered to refer to a normal vaginal case (with no prolapse), and the 10% and 100% rectum expansions leading to low and high posterior prolapse cases respectively (Figure 11). Assuming as per Figure 7, all the positive displacements occur in positive Y direction (a posterior displacement) and the negative displacements occur in negative Y direction (an Empty Bladder Fully Filled Bladder anterior displacement), a negative Y (or anterior displacement) of the PVW was seen (Figure 11) in all cases of rectocele at FIGURE 8: STRESSES (MPA) INDUCED AT THE AVW sections 3 and 4 (as per Figure 7), indicating that rectocele has DUE TO AN EMPTY AND FULLY FILLED BLADDER more intense effect on the sections 3 and 4 compared to sections 1 and 2. In sections 1 and 2, the abdominal pressure on the AVW was seen to have a more pronounced effect on the Y displacement causing it to stay positive (a posterior displacement of vaginal wall) unless the case of rectocele was fairly intense (with over 60% bulge). Beyond the case with 60% rectal bulge into the vagina, the rectocele effect dominated over the abdominal pressure causing the AVW to displace towards Normal Case Prolapse Maximum Prolapse Minimum the negative Y direction. The maximum PVW displacements (up to 24 mm) were observed in section 3 and 4, which may to FIGURE 9: STRESS (MPA) INDUCED ON AVW FOR A 50% BLADDER FILL AND VARYING VAGINAL STIFFENING CONDITIONS AVW. Until a 60% bladder fill, the maximum stress at the AVW was found to gradually intensify without any significant effect of vaginal tissue stiffening. However, beyond 60% fill, a more rapid intensification of the maximum induced stresses at the AVW was observed. The maximum stress build-up due to the combined effect of bladder fill and vaginal tissue stiffening was estimated to occur for the upper bound prolapse case with a Anterior Vaginal Wall (PVW) fully filled bladder. Therefore, it was concluded that clinical examinations of prolapse may be carried out with at least 60 % bladder fill to quantify vaginal discomfort appropriately.
Posterior Vaginal Wall (AVW)
Low Posterior Prolapse High Posterior Prolapse
FIGURE 11: Y DISPLACEMENTS (mm) (ALONG THE
VAGINAL CROSS-SECTION) FOR THE AVW AND PVW IN LOW AND HIGH DEGREES OF RECTAL PROLAPSE FIGURE 10: INDUCED MAXIMUM STRESSES (MPA) AT THE AVW AT DIFFERENT PERCENTAGES OF be the “possible” regions causing vaginal discomfort. The most BLADDER FILL AND PROLAPSE CASES positive (posterior-anterior) vaginal wall displacement was in
Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/conferences/asmep/90996/ on 05/01/2017 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/abo
section 1 (along positive Y direction), mainly due to the The results from the analyses may have significant clinical significant effect of abdominal pressure. implications. From the AVW prolapse simulations, it was found A maximum of 4.6 mm (or 8.3 %), 0.6 mm (or 1.6 %), 9.0 that at a certain bladder fill, a stress concentration zone appears mm (or 39.6%), and 5.0 mm (or 32 %) decrease in vaginal on the AVW at the mid-vagina, which grows in size with an cross-section (along the Y direction) were estimated for sections increased vaginal tissue stiffening, but with a minimal change in 1 through 4, respectively for a 100 % (high prolapse) rectocele the value of the peak stress. This finding suggests that if a bulge condition (see Table 2 based on Figures 7 and 11) prolapse condition is not treated in a timely fashion (and the compared to the normal vaginal case with no prolapse (in Table vaginal tissue has progressive stiffening), the AVW discomfort 2). Thus, section 3 of the vaginal canal was noted as the most zone size (or area) will continue increasing without any deformed region due to rectocele prolapse, followed by section significant change in the intensity of discomfort. Thus, no 4, section 1 and section 2. The maximum PVW displacement prolapse based changes (stress or pressure) on the AVW may be reported at the high prolapse case (with 100% rectocele bulge) detected clinically using a vaginal probe or any other measuring was approximately 23 mm in the negative Y direction. device, while the AVW condition deteriorates. From the Additionally, a resultant “kneeling” effect was observed at the posterior POP simulations, it was observed that for larger PVW, which involved the negative Y displacement of PVW rectoceles, the posterior vaginal wall displacement is greater in (mainly at the deep blue colored region in Figure 10) the lower half of the vaginal canal. Also, in isolated rectoceles, the degree of anterior displacement of the PVW may contribute TABLE 2: CHANGES IN CROSS-SECTIONAL more to patient’s perception of vaginal discomfort compared to DIMENSIONS OF THE FOUR VAGINAL SECTIONS the stress measured in the vaginal wall. These relevant findings FROM NORMAL PELVIS CONDITION TO PROLAPSE can be only obtained from a subject-specific computational model and not by MRI or ultrasound image, which may help urogynecology surgeons decide whether a surgical intervention is necessary or not.
There are several limitations of the current model. First is
the non-inclusion of the geometrical models of the pelvic floor muscles, and ligaments. This was done to simplify computations, and focus only on studying the effect of accompanied with its downward displacement (along Z interaction between the pelvic organs through fascial contacts. direction with a maximum value of 7 mm). This effect has been Second, the current material model neglects tissue anisotropy reported previously in literature [16, 17] due to the simulation (like in most computational models) due lack of an of the impairment of pelvic floor muscles and connective tissues experimental test framework for multiaxial testing, and non- in PVP cases. availability of pelvic tissues due to biosafety and ethical issues. Third, the urethra, vaginal and recto-anal hiatus were CONCLUSIONS constrained which is an idealized case of strong connective tissue attachments. All these assumptions play an important role In the current work, a full-scale realistic computational in the POP mechanics, which will be considered in future model of the female pelvic anatomy was developed to look at studies to more realistically model prolapse conditions. the complex mechanics of anterior and posterior pelvic organ prolapse (POP). The various steps of geometrical and material modeling were discussed and appropriate loads and boundary ACKNOWLEDGMENTS conditions adopted from extensive study of the functional VU would like to acknowledge faculty start-up funds from anatomy of the pelvic floor were outlined. Two sets of novel The University of Alabama, and VU and HER acknowledge the simulations were conducted in the finite element software UA System Collaborative Research Initiation Grants from The ANSYS. In the first batch, the stand-alone and combined effects University of Alabama (UA), System. of realistic bladder filling and vaginal tissue stiffening on the anterior vaginal wall (AVW) were investigated thoroughly. In the second batch, varying degrees of rectocele prolapse REFERENCES conditions were simulated in presence of an average abdominal pressure on the AVW, and its effect on the vaginal walls were [1] Weber, A. M., and Richter, H. E., 2005, "Pelvic organ studied. An innovative forced volume expansion technique was prolapse," Obstetrics & Gynecology, 106(3), pp. 615-634. employed to simulate urine filling in the bladder and the [2] Jelovsek, J. E., Maher, C., and Barber, M. D., 2007, "Pelvic rectocele bulging in prolapse for the two batches of simulations organ prolapse," The Lancet, 369(9566), pp. 1027-1038. respectively.
Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/conferences/asmep/90996/ on 05/01/2017 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/abo
[3] Chanda, A., Unnikrishnan, V.U., Roy, S., and Richter, H.E., 2015, "Computational Modeling of the Female Pelvic Support Structures and Organs to Understand the Mechanism of Pelvic Organ Prolapse: A Review," ASME Applied Mechanics Reviews. [4] Park, J. S., Chung, M. S., Hwang, S. B., Shin, B. S., and Park, H. S., 2006, "Visible Korean Human: its techniques and applications," Clinical Anatomy, 19(3), pp. 216-224. [5] Park, J. S., Chung, M. S., Hwang, S. B., Lee, Y. S., Har, D.- H., and Park, H. S., 2005, "Visible Korean human: improved serially sectioned images of the entire body," IEEE transactions on medical imaging, 24(3), pp. 352-360. [6] Top, A., Hamarneh, G., and Abugharbieh, R., 2013, "Turtleseg." [7] Martins, P., Natal Jorge, R., and Ferreira, A., 2006, "A Comparative Study of Several Material Models for Prediction of Hyperelastic Properties: Application to Silicone‐Rubber and Soft Tissues," Strain, 42(3), pp. 135-147. [8] Chen, Z.-W., Joli, P., Feng, Z.-Q., Rahim, M., Pirró, N., and Bellemare, M.-E., 2015, "Female patient-specific finite element modeling of pelvic organ prolapse (POP)," Journal of biomechanics, 48(2), pp. 238-245. [9] !!! INVALID CITATION !!! [6-8]. [10] ASHTON‐MILLER, J. A., and DeLANCEY, J., 2007, "Functional anatomy of the female pelvic floor," Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1101(1), pp. 266-296. [11] Chanda, A., and Ghoneim, H., 2015, "Pumping potential of a two-layer left-ventricle-like flexible-matrix-composite structure," Composite Structures, 122, pp. 570-575. [12] Beck, D. E., and Allen, N. L., 2010, "Rectocele," Clinics in colon and rectal surgery, 23(2), p. 90. [13] Rubod, C., Boukerrou, M., Brieu, M., Jean-Charles, C., Dubois, P., and Cosson, M., 2008, "Biomechanical properties of vaginal tissue: preliminary results," International Urogynecology Journal, 19(6), pp. 811-816. [14] Calvo, B., Pena, E., Martins, P., Mascarenhas, T., Doblare, M., Natal Jorge, R., and Ferreira, A., 2009, "On modelling damage process in vaginal tissue," Journal of biomechanics, 42(5), pp. 642-651. [15] Bump, R. C., Mattiasson, A., Bø, K., Brubaker, L. P., DeLancey, J. O., Klarskov, P., Shull, B. L., and Smith, A. R., 1996, "The standardization of terminology of female pelvic organ prolapse and pelvic floor dysfunction," American journal of obstetrics and gynecology, 175(1), pp. 10-17. [16] Weber, A. M., Walters, M. D., Ballard, L. A., Booher, D. L., and Piedmonte, M. R., 1998, "Posterior vaginal prolapse and bowel function," American journal of obstetrics and gynecology, 179(6), pp. 1446-1450. [17] Luo, J., 2012, "BIOMECHANICAL ANALYSES OF POSTERIOR VAGINAL PROLAPSE: MR IMAGING AND COMPUTER MODELING STUDIES," The University of Michigan.
Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/conferences/asmep/90996/ on 05/01/2017 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/abo