Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Performance
indicators
ID reference guide
Version 2
Date: 10 February 2016
Changes since last version (i.e. version 1.1a)
Changes Pages
Table of contents 3
- page numbers have changed
Balanced Scorecard 4
- new
General Information
Introduction 4
Balanced Scorecard 5
Guiding objectives for the Key Performance Indicators 6
Glossary of terms 7-9
Customer/Market
Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI) 10
Loyalty Index (LI) 11
Market share new vehicles (%) 12
Our Employees
Employee Satisfaction Index (ESI) 13
Competence fulfilment (%) 14
Operational Performance
Delivery precision – new vehicles 15
Stock turnover rate – used vehicles (days) 16
Stock turnover rate – new vehicles (days) 17
Labour utilisation (%) 18
Labour efficiency (%) 19
Work in progress (days) 20
Workshop hours sold 21
Stock turnover rate – parts (times) 22
Service index – parts 23
DOS assessment 24
Financial
Operating income in % of sales 25
GP total truck sales (%) 26
GP workshop (%) 27
GP parts (%) 28
Aftersales receivable days 29
Return on operating capital ROC (%) 30
Sales and Administration (S & A) in % of turnover 31
Cash flow 32
Total sales revenue (against budget) [Skip this measurement] 33
Aftermarket absorption (%) 34
Other Indicators
Workshop, Parts and Sales 35-36
Why is it important?
The company agenda sets challenging new performance objectives for the organisation,
from the delivery of service & results to customer & stakeholders to doing more within the
constraints of available resources through continuous improvement. Performance
management strengthens the operations and processes through proactive activities to
achieve performance improvement.
Who is involved?
Business and operation managers are responsible to establish objectives and Key
Performance Indicators (KPIs), set targets and manage the performance against the targets.
The Balanced Scorecard was established to cover Key Performance Indicators from:
Customer / Market
Our Employees
Operational Performance
Financial
Purpose
To serve as early warnings to all the KPIs listed on the Balanced Scorecard. The
performance value is as follows:
Low
Below the acceptable range of performance.
Attention is needed e.g. activities to improve need to be planned and put in to action
Medium
Within the acceptable range of performance.
Preventive actions to be taken to improve the performance.
High
On and above expected performance.
Needs to be maintained.
Customer / Market
Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI) <70% 70-80% >80%
Loyalty Index (LI) <70% 70-80% >80%
Market share new vehicles (%) <5% 5-10% >10%
Our Employees
Employee Satisfaction Index (ESI) <45% 46-85% >85%
Competence fulfilment % <50% 50-79% >79%
Operational Performance
Delivery precision - new vehicles <80% 80-90% >90%
Stock turnover rate - used vehicles (days) >40 23 to 40 <23
Stock turnover rate - new vehicles (days) >120 60 to 120 <60
Labour utilisation % <80% 80-90% >90%
Labour efficiency % <100% 100-115% >115%
Work in progress (days) >5 3 to 5 <3
Workshop hours sold No performance range
Stock turnover rate - parts (times) <4 4 to 5 >5
Service index - parts <85% 85-92% >92%
DOS assessment <1.5 1.6-2.5 >2.5
Financial
Operating income in % of sales <2% 2-5% >5%
GP total truck sales (%) <3% 3-5% >5%
GP workshop (%) <50% 50-60% >60%
GP parts (%) <23% 23-28% >28%
Aftersales receivables days >35 days 25-35 days <25 days
Return on Operating Capital ROC (%) <15% 15-25% >25%
Sales and Administration (S & A) in % of turnover >16% 13-16% <13%
Cash flow No performance range
Total sales revenue (against budget) Skip thi s measurement
Aftermarket absorption (%) <100% 100-120% >120%
Financial terms
External Sales Sales made to customers, which are not part of the
company.
Total Sales The sum of all the External and Internal Sales
made by a dealer or department of a dealer.
Workshop operation
Actual time taken for The number of hours that the mechanics are
productive work (clocked clocked-in for a job or jobs. These are the number
hours/time) of hours considered as utilised for productive work.
Allocated time for productive The standard time required to complete a repair or
work (i.e. VST and DAT) service operation.
Available hours for The number of hours that the mechanics are
productive work available for productive work. These are the hours
when the mechanics are physically present in the
workshop.
Invoiced Hours / Sold hours The number of hours that were invoiced to internal
and/or external customers. Invoiced hours would
usually follow the Standard Time e.g. Volvo
Standard Time (VST). Other times used for
invoicing can be Dealer Allocated Time (only when
VST is not available and Straight Time (usually
applicable for service work done as field service)
Cost of Sales (COS) When calculating the workshop’s gross profit, the
cost of sales is the mechanic’s salary for productive
time (no social costs involved).
Additional notes
These are three key performance indicators normally reviewed in a workshop operation.
The dealer management system would most likely be able to calculate all three indicators.
The use of these performance figures ensure that the workshop is utilised in an efficient
way that improves the overall operating profitability. Suggested frequency to check these
figures would depend on the line manager’s management routines.
Meaning
The NTS target group is a customer who has bought our vehicle within the past 2 years.
The TAS target group is a customer who has been to our workshop during the past 12
months. (Some markets use random sampling.)
Some Areas are conducting a monthly survey at dealers which is a proactive action to
improve CSI.
Source:
GFK the appointed survey consultant for International Division.
Calculation
System generated from the consultant after completion of telephone surveys with the
customers
Dealers need to ensure that the submission of customer data has accurate information
Standard
Possible actions
1. Sharing the customer satisfaction result with all dealer staff members
2. Discussing and acting on improvement plans
3. Empowering dealer staff members to be involved
4. Area/Market and Private Importers to support with coaching where required
5. Feedback & acknowledge the improvements
Meaning
Loyalty index is part of the total customer satisfaction study from the section on New Truck
Sales (NTS). It measures the loyalty of the customers toward our new vehicle sales.
The target group for this survey is a customer who has brought our vehicle within the past 2
years.
Source:
GFK the appointed survey consultant for International Division.
Calculation
System generated from the consultant after completion of telephone surveys with the
customers
Dealers need to ensure that the submission of customer data has accurate information
Standard
The suggestion of >80% in Loyalty Index would secure a positive outcome for the company.
It is good to review this index annually.
Possible actions
1. Inform and spread the awareness of customer loyalty to all dealer staff members
2. Involve everyone to do all things right the first time all the time
3. Be proactive and responsive to customers needs and expectations
4. Be actively involved with activities that enhances customer loyalty
5. Establish a process that is consistent on focused on customer satisfaction
Meaning
This is the indicator that shows the number of our vehicles sold in proportion to the total
number of vehicle sold in a market.
Source:
Report generated from Market Intelligence department.
Calculation
Standard
Aspire to be >10%
Recommended to benchmark with the high image competitors e.g. Mercedes and Scania
Possible actions
1. Maintain and ensure a good way of working that focuses on customer satisfaction
2. Secure a high level of customer loyalty
Meaning
This is an annual survey in which an employee has the opportunity to express his/her
opinion on a wide range of issues affecting his/her working life.
The result is an input to improve and develop Volvo Group’s working climate.
The tool is Volvo Group Attitude Survey (VGAS) and is available for Volvo’s wholly owned
dealers. There are similar tool available in the market for Volvo’s private dealers.
Calculation
Employee Satisfaction Index (ESI) is a figure for the working climate in each working
group/team.
ESI is based on the eleven core (C) questions. It shows, in percent how many of these
questions are on or above the norm.
Standard
Possible actions
1. Involve the employees in improving the working climate. There is a proven link
between improved working climate and improved profitability
2. The survey report leads to a feedback session where employees discuss
improvements ideas and create action plans to make things happen
3. Implement “The Volvo Way” which is a global guide for the behaviour of leaders and
team members within our company
Meaning
Source:
The competence portal is made available to both Volvo wholly owned and private dealers
Calculation
Competence Portal
The % is system generated through data input & updates following the Competence Platform process
Standard
Some Areas have set a different standard to ID’s minimum of 79% fulfilment.
Frequency to report:
Every 12 months
Possible actions
Meaning
This is a measure of how well we keep the promises made to the customers with regard to
the specification of their new vehicle and the delivery time
It is vital that the customer experience on receiving their new vehicle is as positive as it can
be, and ensuring we deliver the right vehicle, on the date promised is the key component of
this.
It should be noted that sometimes this could be outside of the dealers’ control, due to
changes in the production schedules.
Calculation
Standard
We should aim for 100% but also accept that due to changes in the production schedules,
transportation issues, customs issues etc this may not always be possible.
As a minimum we must aim for no errors on issues within the dealers control such as
ordering errors, delays in PDI etc
Possible actions
1. Control the order pipeline – monitor the vehicle at each stage in the process
2. Ensure realistic promises are given at the time of sale.
3. Involve all relevant people as early as realistic in the process – ordering parts, booking
workshop time etc
4. Ensure someone has responsibility for ensuring the promises are met.
5. Develop professional relationships with body builders, paint shops etc if you are using
suppliers for this work.
6. Ensure all sales people can use the relevant truck order system correctly.
7. Encourage sales people to double check with the customer before finally placing the
order.
8. At the very least, if something does go wrong communicate this immediately to the
customer.
Meaning
It reports the average number of days for which a vehicle is in stock on your premises before
being sold.
In cases where there is a consistent increase to this figure, reviews need to be taken to
check whether the costs of keeping the vehicles in stock are in relation to the profit
eventually achieved on the sale of these vehicles.
Note: Vehicle stock turn can also be calculated by using vehicle units where the result does
not reflect on the inventory value.
Calculation
Convert the result to days => 360 divided by the above result
Standard
Possible actions
Meaning
It reports the average number of days for which a vehicle is in stock on your premises before
being sold.
In cases where there is a consistent increase to this figure, reviews need to be taken to
check whether the costs of keeping the vehicles in stock are in relation to the profit
eventually achieved on the sale of these vehicles.
Note: Vehicle stock turn can also be calculated by using vehicle units where the result does
not reflect on the inventory value.
Calculation
Convert the result to days => 360 divided by the above result
Standard
The guiding objectives states <60 days as meeting the performance range.
Possible actions
Meaning
This indicator shows how much of the mechanics available hours for work in the workshop
are used on productive work. Productive work can be invoiced which becomes income to the
workshop department.
The missing proportion of these hours represents the ‘non-productive’ hours.
Calculation
Convert result to %
Standard
A level of 90% is suggested as there will always be a loss of at least 5 to 10% from time
taken to locate the vehicle at the parking lot, wait for available work-bay, toilet breaks,
smoke breaks and etc.
Possible actions
Meaning
This measures the ability of the mechanics to complete work within the allocated time. The
allocated time could come from the Volvo Standard Time (VST), local/regional time or dealer
standard time.
It is useful to calculate this indicator on a mechanic-by-mechanic basis in order to check who
works more or less efficiently. This analysis should extend to the type of productive work
e.g. a mechanic can usually have a better efficiency level on maintenance work as
compared to an electronic work.
Calculation
Convert result to %
Standard
Labour efficiency can easily be raised to at least 115% given today’s focus on competence
development, improved workshop tools & equipment and parts ordering.
Possible actions
1. Ensure that correct allocation of jobs to mechanics i.e. competence based job allocation.
2. Mechanics to have their own tool-box and work-bay.
3. Easy accessibility to special tools when required.
4. Parts runner/”waiter” for a large workshop or at least observe that parts support to the
workshop is measured through order fulfilment and delivery precision.
5. Use of Volvo Standard Time (VST) on repair orders (mechanics can benchmark their
actual time with the allocated time).
6. Observe clocking in and out of jobs to ensure accuracy of measurement.
7. Proper information on repair order e.g. correct operation numbers symptom
description/code used by service reception
Meaning
This shows the number of productive work hours completed by mechanics but not invoiced
to customers due to repair orders still opened from situations like:
1. Additional work required, waiting for parts, complication with the repair or approval
for work not received.
2. Delay or lack of sufficient documents to confirm a customer invoice.
Calculation
Standard
That means that the work in progress is equivalent to 3 full days of work with the whole
workshop capacity. Consider its impact on cash flow.
If at all possible, the objective would be to invoice all completed jobs on the day of
completion.
Possible actions
1. A good process with the flow of the repair order i.e. once it is created till all the jobs
completed on it.
2. Roles and responsibilities of (a) service advisor to follow up on all repair orders created
by him/her (b) foreman or team leader to ensure that the mechanic is managing to do the
job right and complete it on time (c) parts personnel to support with parts availability
3. Service advisor to provide repair status information with the customer regularly during the
period of repair.
4. Service advisor to ensure that all required documents from the customer are in order so
that delay to invoice is avoided.
5. Parts department’s timely update on dealer management system on parts taken for the
repair.
6. Foreman/team leader to ensure that quality of work is done
7. Streamline the invoicing process e.g. invoicing by service advisor who is the contact
person with the customer and foreman.
Meaning
This figure shows the total number of hours sold from productive work completed by the
mechanics in a given period. Invoicing the work done (hours) and minimising work-in-
progress (days & value) would be the main activities to ensure a high level of total workshop
hours sold.
It is important to ensure that we record the hours sold as well as the value on the invoices.
Calculation
Standard
It can be useful to reflect workshop hours as % of total available hours (in order words,
labour productivity %). In this case, the KPI will show if we are selling a sufficient % of hours
we buy.
Possible actions
Meaning
This indicator shows the number of times the stock will turn in a year.
The average number of turns reflects the effectiveness of the parts ordering and delivery
process established between the dealer and the supplier.
Calculation
Standard
This is not enough to analyse the parts service level to the customer. Other performance
indicators to review are parts availability through first pick availability and the average
purchase discount.
Possible actions
1. Manage the purchase quantities and the maximum/minimum stock levels to maintain for
an optimal stock balance
2. Ensure that stocking policies are observed
3. Review and manage emergency orders
4. Improve stock management in areas such as
▪ Fast moving parts
▪ Level of buffer stocks
▪ Level of slow moving parts
▪ Review and manage Back Orders
5. Pre-plan with the workshop to ensure that parts required are available.
Meaning
This ratio indicates the extent to which the customer demands are met immediately from
stock. It can be difficult to measure as manual records of non-available parts are required.
Using a periodic sample may be the best solution.
The index for the workshop is interesting as a good percentage indicates planning,
communication, teamwork and interest with customer satisfaction.
Calculation
Number of repair orders
with stocks fulfilled Number of lines supplied
Total number of repair orders Total lines ordered
Convert to % Convert to %
Standard
Note:
This is an external data. The source is from the Local Parts Agreement (LPA)
Possible actions
Meaning
Calculation
DOS tool
(The score is system generated through data input & updates following the DOS assessment process)
Standard
Scores of:
3 = according to standard
2 = passable
1 = minor non conformity
0 = major non conformity
Frequency of assessment:
Once every 2 years
Possible actions
Meaning
The Operating Income shows the profit which has been achieved in relation to sales. It is an
overall indicator of the balance between sales, margin and costs.
The calculation takes into account both the internal and external sales e.g. sales invoiced to
other departments (except parts sold to the workshop) are taken into account because the
realised profit comes from both internal and external activities.
Calculation
Operating income
Total net sales
Convert result to %
Standard
Possible actions
Meaning
The Gross Profit takes account of discounts and costs of the vehicle. It is what remains
before the deduction on wages, salaries and other direct costs.
This indicator can be analysed separately for new and used trucks.
Calculation
Convert result to %
Standard
Possible actions
Meaning
The percentage indicates the workshop’s profit position. Sales figures included in this
indicator are services & repairs, sub-contract work, oils, lubrications and other items. All
work needs to be completed and invoiced.
The cost of sales is the mechanic’s salary for productive time (no social costs involved).
Calculation
Convert result to %
Standard
Possible actions
Meaning
The percentage indicates the profit position of the parts department. It can be used to give
more insight to the Aftermarket Absorption.
Calculation
Convert result to %
Standard
In most cases, the dealer net is dependant on what the Market Company has set.
Possible actions
1. Increase the profit margin from different groups of sales channel (payment codes)
▪ Increase the parts sales per labour hour sold
▪ Revise or improve the discount policy for counter-sales
▪ Improve the Average Purchase Margin i.e. to observe the order classes during
procurement
▪ Have a good procurement routine that optimises stock order rather than daily orders.
Meaning
This indicator shows the average length of time taken to collect payment from customers.
Not collecting payment promptly is one of the reasons that the company needs to increase
short term borrowings. Such loans are usually higher with interest rates therefore cost.
Calculation
Standard
We recommend <25 days for the customers to the settle parts and service invoices.
Observe the guiding objectives range to either take preventive actions or to maintain the
performance.
Possible actions
1. Communicate the payment terms and conditions to the customer all the time.
2. Avoid invoice dispute through quality of information on the parts and workshop invoices.
3. Monitor the debtors ageing list monthly.
4. Review customer’s credit limits
Meaning
This is the indicator on the profit that the company can succeed in realising per 100 USD of
capital invested in the business.
It reflects the return on investments made.
When this ratio is low we are less likely to be able to attract new investment.
Calculation
Standard
The general rule is 3x higher than the average interest rate payable on short term debts.
Possible actions
Meaning
This indicator allows you to check whether the total costs borne in respect of your entire
workforce commensurate with the sales are achieved.
The selling & administration expenses are mainly “back-office” services (such as staff costs
that include salaries, commissions, employees’ and employers’ social security contributions,
and pension provisions for all the staff of the company) and “fixed-costs” sometimes known
as structural expenses (such as rental, electricity and phone bills).
Calculation
convert result to %
Standard
Possible actions
Meaning
The variance between incoming and outgoing cash over an established period.
Occasionally, the cash flow can be a negative due to most businesses usually have to pay
for goods before getting paid.
This measure cannot be obtained from the dealer operating system but is usually measured
from the administration area.
Calculation
Standard
Possible actions
Meaning
Calculation
Standard
Possible actions
Meaning
The Aftermarket Absorption indicates the extent to which the workshop and parts
departments are able to cover the administrative and structural expenses of the company.
The selling & administration expenses are mainly “back-office” services (such as staff costs
that include salaries, commissions, employees’ and employers’ social security contributions,
and pension provisions for all the staff of the company) and “fixed-costs” sometimes known
as structural expenses (such as rental, electricity and phone bills).
A dealership that achieves more than 100% in Aftermarket absorption is more likely to
withstand the high volatility of the new and used truck markets.
Calculation
Convert result to %
Standard
Possible actions
Note:
Definitions and calculations are not covered in this reference guide.
Workshop
▪ Balance of claims
(Non-credited percentage by importer in relation to total claims)
▪ Recovery rate
▪ VST usage
▪ Workshop contribution
▪ Labour productivity
Sales