Professional Documents
Culture Documents
their writing.)
2. Simile and Metaphor: Both compare two distinct objects and draws
similarity between them. The difference is that Simile uses “as” or “like” and
Metaphor does not.
7. Irony: It is use of the words in such a way in which the intended meaning is
completely opposite to their literal meaning. For example:
Considering that "There is another sky" speaks of a worldly place (Amherst, Dickinson's
home) and an otherworldly place, heaven, the main poetic device is metaphor. The
speaker describes a worldly place with natural imagery but with otherworldly qualities.
"Another sky" directly means a sky that is not the sky of the Earth. This "other" sky would
have to be in another place. Presumably, this would be heaven because only a perfect
sky could be "Ever serene and fair." The same could be said for "another sunshine." So,
the speaker describes this "other" place but uses natural things to do so. In this other
place, the leaves are always green, there is no frost, and flowers never fade. This perfect
forest (and/or garden) is a metaphor for heaven.
But we can turn this metaphor around. As it becomes clear that Dickinson is describing a
heaven-like place, we could also say that she is using hyperbole to describe a worldly
place such as Amherst. In other words, in order to convince her brother, Austin, to come
to Amherst, she exaggerates (hyperbole) its qualities (to heaven-like levels) in order to
evoke some nostalgia and entice him to come to Amherst.
The adjective "whose" can be the possessive form of "who" or "which." That is to say that
"whose" can mean a "thing's" or a "person's." So, the little forest "Whose leaf is ever
green" can refer to heaven's (God's) place or the forest's place. Thus, the metaphor works
both ways: a description of heaven as a metaphor for Amherst, and a description of
Amherst as a metaphor for heaven. Therefore, you could say that the imagery used
describes either heaven or the natural world. It depends on how you read the poem. Is it
a poem describing the landscape of Amherst as a metaphor for heaven? Or, is the poem
describing heaven as a metaphor for Amherst?
About There is Another Sky: This poem was written by Emily Dickinson to her brother,
Austin, the eldest of the Dickinson’ children, who was in Boston at the time. It was sent
to him along with her letters. Different people interpret this poem in different ways, and
the real truth behind this piece of poetry can be said to be known only to the persons
involved.
Setting of the Poem: The poem is inside a letter sent to her beloved brother Austin.
Hence the setting is just that; a letter. But contained within, are fair skies, light and
darkness, forests and fields and many other elements of nature.
The poem was not a stand-alone piece of work, but rather was included with a letter to
her brother encouraging him to come home from Boston to Amherst, where she lived. [1]
At face value it’s extolling the values of Amherst, comparing it to a vision of heaven
where nothing changes and everything is comforting and familiar. The rhythm and style
are somewhat like a hymn or religious chant, so I suppose it’s possible that Dickinson
has some deeper religious connotations she is trying to put across, but given the context
my guess is that it’s really just an appeal to Austin to remember that no matter the time
and distance, home remains home.