Professional Documents
Culture Documents
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282953566
CITATIONS READS
3 242
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Kenneth J.D. Mackenzie on 01 December 2015.
Abstract
The evolution of fibre-matrix interactions in basalt-fibre-reinforced geopolymer matrix composites after heating to
600, 800 and 1000 °C was investigated by means of SEM, EDS and XRD analyses. The basalt fibres showed no significant
interfacial interaction up to 600 °C. The appearance of the fracture surfaces also remained largely unchanged. At
higher temperatures, crystallisation reactions within the fibres and the Na-geopolymer matrix, respectively, could
be observed along with an increasing embrittlement of the composite. Softening of the fibres and the development of
several distinct reaction zones within the fibres was clearly evident after heating to 800 °C and 1000 °C. The formation
of an iron-rich outer reaction zone within the fibre was observed above 800 °C. The interaction between fibre and
matrix resulted in the formation of a crystalline albite phase after heating to 1000 °C. It is suggested that basalt fibres
have great potential as reinforcements for the development of cost-efficient geopolymer-matrix composites and may
be used for applications up to 600 °C.
Keywords: Geopolymer-matrix composites, fibre-matrix interaction, interface, basalt fibre
I. Introduction itation for their widespread use. Whereas the high costs
Recent advances in technological development have seen may be justified in some highly demanding applications,
an ever-growing commercial relevance of fibre-reinforced their use for less demanding applications at temperatures
composite materials in all fields of applications. In par- below around 600 – 800 °C becomes increasingly uneco-
ticular, polymer-matrix composites (PMCs) have found nomical. This essentially only leaves metal-based materi-
widespread use due to their excellent properties at room als for applications in the temperature range from about
temperature and their comparatively easy and cost-effec- 200 – 800 °C. However, several factors such as higher den-
tive fabrication methods at moderate temperatures. How- sity, insufficient corrosion resistance, electrical conduc-
ever, the main drawback of PMCs is the limited tempera- tivity or costs may make the use of metals unfavourable.
ture stability of the organic matrices, typically restricting Thus, the development of new inorganic, non-metal ma-
their use to operating temperatures below 200 °C. Thus, terials that can essentially combine the advantages of both
metal- or ceramic-based materials must be used for appli- CMCs and PMCs, i.e. high strength, low density and rea-
cations at higher temperatures. Ceramics generally exhib- sonably high temperature stability, in a cost-effective way
it very desirable properties such as relatively low density, for applications in this mid-temperature range would be
high strength and stiffness, chemical stability and superi- highly desirable.
or high-temperature properties. However, the inherently In this regard, inorganic aluminosilicate polymers, al-
brittle nature of ceramic materials is a major limitation for so called geopolymers, may offer an alternative to com-
their widespread use in structural and engineering appli- mon polymer and ceramic matrix materials. The attraction
cations. This problem can be largely overcome by the in- of geopolymers as matrix materials for composites aris-
corporation of inorganic fibres to increase the toughness es from the combination of properties, most noteworthy
of the matrix, introducing a quasi-ductile, graceful failure their temperature stability up to 800 – 1000 °C, and the
behaviour. Despite extensive research efforts over the past relatively easy processing and fabrication methods simi-
decades, however, fibre-reinforced ceramic matrix com- lar to those of PMCs. These aspects essentially combine
posites (CMCs) have only recently come to a point of ac- two of the main advantages of polymer and ceramic com-
tual commercial relevance. Nevertheless, the much high- posites, respectively. Therefore, geopolymer-matrix com-
er overall costs of CMCs due to more complex process- posites (GMCs) possess significant potential as economi-
ing requirements, higher material costs and much high- cal alternatives to conventional CMCs for applications in
er manufacturing temperatures are still a significant lim- a mid-temperature range up to ∼ 800 °C, effectively bridg-
* Corresponding author: michael.welter@dlr.de ing the gap between existing PMC and CMC materials.
18 Journal of Ceramic Science and Technology —M. Welter et al. Vol. 6, No. 1
A number of different fibre-reinforced geopolymer-ma- perature up to 1000 °C. The results give an indication up
trix composites using a variety of short and continuous to which temperature the use of basalt fibres as reinforce-
fibres such as carbon, silicon carbide (SiC), alumina, alu- ments for geopolymers may be feasible.
minosilicate, basalt and glass fibres have been investigated
since geopolymer composites were first proposed in the II. Experimental
1980s 1 – 29. In particular for continuous fibre-reinforced The geopolymer matrix (M1) with a calculated com-
composites, the main contributor to the overall cost of the position of SiO 2/Al 2O 3 = 3.0, Na 2O/SiO 2 = 3.6 and
composites are the fibre costs. Whereas CMCs typically H 2O/Na 2O = 10.1 was prepared from a dehydroxylat-
demand the use of advanced inorganic fibres such as SiC ed halloysite and a pre-dissolved alkali activator solution.
and alumina owing to their high processing temperatures, The halloysite (Imerys Tableware, NZCC Halloysite Pre-
the low-temperature processing of geopolymers (typically mium, Grade: Ultrafine – H; d 50 ∼ 0.3 μm) was dehydrox-
< 100 °C) also allows the use of cheaper and less advanced ylated at 600 °C overnight. The chemical composition
fibres. Even the use of (synthetic) organic and natural fi- of the dehydroxylated halloysite is given in Table 1. The
bres may be feasible for certain applications and a num- main phase of the dehydroxylated halloysite was x-ray
ber of studies have been carried out on this subject 2, 30 – 36. amorphous with minor crystalline phases of quartz and
However, the limited temperature stability of these fibres cristobalite. The alkali activator solution was made by
militates against their application at elevated temperatures. mixing a 12.5M NaOH solution with a commercially
One of the most inexpensive and commonly used inor- available sodium silicate solution (Orica Chemnet, Grade
ganic fibre types in PMCs are E-glass fibres. However, D, SiO 2/Na 2O ∼ 2, 29.4 wt% SiO 2) in a 3:2 weight ratio.
the highly alkaline conditions during the geopolymer pro- The dehydroxylated halloysite was slowly added to the al-
cessing restrict their usability in GMCs due to the limit- kali solution under constant stirring at about 250 rpm. The
ed alkali stability of E-glass fibres resulting in significant- mixture was further homogenised for about five minutes
ly degraded fibres in the composite. The alkali stability of before use.
the glass fibres depends on the overall glass composition, The basalt fibres used in this study had a diameter ∼ 13 μm
mainly the alkali, SiO 2 and B 2O 3 contents. The detrimen- and were used in form of continuous fibre tows (R&G
tal effect of a highly alkaline geopolymer binder on the sta- Faserverbundwerkstoffe, 2400 tex). The chemical compo-
bility of an aluminosilicate fibre with high B 2O 3 content sition of the basalt fibres is shown in Table 2. The fibres
was shown by Foerster 2. were used as-received, i.e. the fibre sizing was not removed
An alternative to common glass fibres are basalt fibres. prior to composite fabrication, since preliminary investi-
Although very similar to glass fibres, the combination of gations revealed that the fibre sizing was removed under
better alkali resistance and better mechanical properties the highly alkaline conditions. Unidirectional fibre-rein-
compared to E-glass fibres and the significantly lower cost forced geopolymer-matrix composite bars with a size of
compared to carbon or alumina fibres make basalt fibres approximately 3 x 10 x 120 mm (h x w x l) were fabricated
a very interesting candidate for the fabrication of cost- by the hand lay-up of ten impregnated fibre tapes in plas-
effective composites. tic moulds. To prepare the fibre tapes, the continuous fi-
The use of basalt fibres as reinforcements for GMCs, bre tow was first stretched over a large-diameter glass tube
mostly in form of short fibres, has been reported by sever- in a small sideward motion to loosen the individual fibres
al authors 15, 22 – 27. These studies mostly address the me- and to improve fibre alignment. The continuous tow was
chanical properties of the respective composites. Howev- then fixed with adhesive tape at lengths of around 150 mm
er, the microstructural interaction between fibre and ma- and cut across the taped areas to produce individual fibre
trix in GMCs, in particular the evolution of the fibre-ma- tapes. Each fibre tape was impregnated with the geopoly-
trix interactions of basalt-fibre GMCs with temperature, mer binder from both sides with a roller. The moulds were
has so far not been investigated in any detail. Therefore, the sealed and cured in an oven at 40 °C for 48 hours. All spec-
present study investigates the microstructural evolution imens were subsequently dried under ambient conditions
of the fibre-matrix interactions in unidirectional basalt-fi- for a minimum of seven days before further testing and
bre-reinforced GMCs as a function of heat treatment tem- analysis. The fibre volume content was about 30 vol%.
fibre areas, the fibre deformation was accompanied by a ronment around each fibre also has to be considered. That
marked shape accommodation of the surrounding fibres. is, fibres in high fibre density regions may show a some-
However, the consolidation of two neighbouring fibres, as what different crystallisation and reaction behaviour from
can be seen in Fig. 7, was hardly observed to occur. Fig. 6 fibres that are surrounded by larger amounts of matrix.
indicates the formation of at least three distinct reaction
zones within the basalt fibres. The formation of an ap-
proximately 200-nm-wide outer reaction zone along the
inner fibre edge which appeared as a bright line in the
backscattered electron micrographs was common to all fi-
bres. Crystallisation was evident in the centre of the fibres.
However, Fig. 6(b) clearly shows that the size and shape
of crystallites forming in the inner reaction zone varied
to considerable degrees. The size of the crystallites in this
zone ranged from the low nanometre scale up to around
1 μm. The inner and outer reaction zones were separated
by a ∼ 2-μm-wide band which forms the intermediate re-
action zone. A fine distribution of tiny bright spots was re-
vealed by high-resolution backscattered electron imaging,
indicating that this zone was also subject to some form of
precipitation or crystallisation reaction. However, in con-
trast to the inner fibre zone, this zone showed similar ap-
pearance in all fibres. Fig. 6: BSE-SEM images and corresponding EDS line scan profile
across the fibre-matrix interface of the polished surface of the
M1-Basalt composite after heating to 1000 °C. The micrographs
show the marked fibre deformation, shape accommodation and
crystallisation within the fibre.
According to the EDS line scan profile in Fig. 6 a signif- Fig. 7: BSE-SEM image of the fibre-matrix interface of the M1-
icant percentage of the present calcium diffused into the Basalt composite after heating to 1000 °C at higher magnification
matrix. The sodium, on the other hand, diffused from the with overlay of EDS line scan profile for Fe and Mg.
matrix into the outer parts of the fibre up to about ∼ 4 μm
from the fibre edge whereas the potassium content was Since most of the reactions in the heated basalt compos-
lower in that area compared to the fibre centre. The be- ites seemed to occur within the fibre, a bundle of loose
haviour of the iron and magnesium profiles was relatively basalt fibres was heated to 1000 °C in order to compare the
similar to the one observed at 800 °C, at least for the fibre reaction in the fibre without any surrounding geopolymer
on the right-hand side of the line scan, indicating a higher matrix. A micrograph of the cross-section of the fractured
concentration of iron around the fibre edges. EDS line scan fibre bundle is shown in Fig. 8. The image shows that on-
analysis at higher magnification confirmed a peak concen- ly a very small number of fibres resembled the approxi-
tration of iron in the outermost reaction zone of the fibre, mate reaction pattern of the fibres in the composite sam-
as shown in Fig. 7. ple. Although the formation of nano-precipitates especial-
Some variation to the described ion diffusion transport ly along the fibre edges was evident at higher magnification
was observed in some areas of the sample, in particular for for all fibres, the formation of a distinct outer reaction zone
the alkali and calcium ions. These differences may be at- similar to the one observed in the composite sample was
tributed in some degree to slight variations in the chemi- indicative at best. A slight deformation of the fibre cross-
cal composition of the individual basalt fibres. However, section and the formation of sinter-necks between fibres
a pronounced influence of the immediate chemical envi- were also clearly visible.
22 Journal of Ceramic Science and Technology —M. Welter et al. Vol. 6, No. 1
The early softening of the fibres in the composite is also technology, Ed. Gartner, E.M., Uchikawa, U., Ceram. Trans.,
evident from the pore diffusion. With increasing densifi- 40, 247 – 256, (1994).
cation of the matrix the accumulation of pores along the 4 Foerster S.C., Graule, T., Gauckler, L.J.: Thermal and mechan-
fibre-matrix interface and their subsequent diffusion into ical properties of alkali-activated alumino-silicate based, high
performance composites In: Advanced structural fiber com-
the fibres was observed at temperatures above 600 °C. The
posites, Ed. Vincenzini, P., Adv. Sci. Technol., 7, 117 – 124,
accumulation of small pores around the fibre edges that (1995).
are starting to penetrate the fibres was clearly evident in 5 Lyon, R.E., Sorathia, U., Balaguru, P., Foden, A., Davidovits,
the 800 °C sample as can be seen in Fig. 5. With increas- J., Davidovics, M.: Fire response of geopolymer structural
ing temperature and time the smaller pores continued to composites, Proceedings of the 1 st International conference on
diffuse into the centre of the fibres combining into single composites in infrastructure ICCI, 1996
larger pores inside the fibres as shown in Fig. 6. 6 Lyon, R.E., Balaguru, P.N., Foden, A., Sorathia, U., Davi-
dovits, J., Davidovics, M.: Fire resistant aluminosilicate com-
IV. Conclusions posites, Fire. Mater., 21, 67 – 73, (1997).
7 Foden, A., Lyon, R., Balaguru, P.N., Davidovits, J.: High tem-
The basalt fibre showed no significant degradation or
microstructural interaction with the geopolymer matrix perature inorganic resin for use in fibre reinforced composites,
Proceedings of the 1 st International conference on composites in
up to 600 °C. In combination with their good mechanical
infrastructure ICCI, 1996.
properties (r flex, max = 194 MPa for the unheated compos- 8 Foden, A.: Mechanical properties and material characterization
ite 37) and comparatively low fibre cost, this makes basalt of polysialate structural composites, PhD Thesis, Rutgers State
fibre a great alternative as reinforcement for the fabrication University, USA, (1999).
of cost-efficient geopolymer-matrix composites. Howev- 9 Hammell, J., Balaguru, P.N., Lyon, R.: Influence of reinforce-
er, increasing crystallisation and melting of the fibre oc- ment types on the flexural properties of geopolymer compos-
curred at higher temperatures, resulting in an increasingly ites, Proceedings of the 43 rd International SAMPE Symposium,
brittle failure of the fibre and the composite, respective- 1998.
10 Hammell, J.A., The influence of matrix composition and re-
ly. A number of different diffusion processes within the
fibre itself and between the fibre and the matrix could be inforcement type on the properties of polysialate composites,
PhD Thesis, Rutgers State University, USA, (2000).
observed. Most notably, the iron in the basalt fibre started
11 Hammell, J.A., Balaguru, P.N., Lyon, R.E.: Strength retention
to diffuse towards the fibre edges above 600 °C resulting
of fire resistant aluminosilicate-carbon composites under wet-
in the formation of a ∼ 2-μm-wide reaction zone, charac- dry conditions, Compos. Part. B, 31, 107 – 111, (2000).
terised by the formation of nano-sized Fe 3O 4 crystallites, 12 He, P., Jia, D., Lin, T., Wang, M., Zhou, Y.: Effects of high-
around the inner fibre edge after heating to 800 °C. Other temperature heat treatment on the mechanical properties of
main diffusion processes that were evident were the dif- unidirectional carbon fibre reinforced geopolymer composites,
fusion of sodium from the matrix into the outer area of Ceram. Int., 36, 1447 – 53, (2010).
the fibre as well as the diffusion of calcium from the fi- 13 He, P., Jia, D., Wang, M., Zhou, Y.: Improvement of high-tem-
bre into the matrix. Comparison between the heated fibres perature mechanical properties of heat treated C f/geopolymer
alone and the heated composite showed that the presence composites by sol-SiO 2 impregnation, J. Eur. Ceram. Soc., 30,
3053 – 61, (2010).
and chemical nature of the matrix had a strong influence
14 He. P., Jia, D., Interface evolution of the C f/leucite compos-
on the degree of crystallisation and phase formation in the
ites derived from C f/geopolymer composites, Ceram. Int., 39,
basalt fibres and the composite, respectively. The various 1203 – 08, (2013).
processes resulted in the formation of at least three dis- 15 Bortnovsky, O., Bezucha, P., Dedecek, J., Sobalik, Z., Vodick-
tinct reaction zones within the basalt fibre after heating to ova, V., Kroisova, D., Roubicek, P., Urbanova, M.: Properties
1000 °C. A direct consequence of the fibre-matrix interac- of phosphorus-containing geopolymer matrix and fibre rein-
tion after heating to 1000 °C was the formation of albite forced composites, In: Mechanical Properties and Performance
which is believed to form within the fibre. of Engineering Ceramics and Composites IV, Eds. Singh, D.,
This study indicates that basalt fibres have great poten- Kriven, W.M., Salem, J., 283 – 299, (2009).
16 Tran, D.H., Kroisova, D., Louda, P., Bortnovsky, O., Bezucha,
tial as reinforcements for the development of cost-effec-
tive GMCs for applications up to 600 °C. Nonetheless, P.: Effect of curing temperature on the flexural properties
of silica-based geopolymer carbon reinforced composites,
further investigations of the high-temperature mechani- J. Achievements Mater. Manufact. Eng., 37, 492 – 7, (2009).
cal properties of these composites are necessary to validate 17 Pernica, D., Reis, P.N.B., Ferreira, J.A.M., Louda, P.: Effect
these results. of test conditions on the bending strength of a geopolymer-
reinforced composite, J. Mater. Sci., 45, 744 – 9, (2007).
Acknowledgements 18 Radford, D.W., Grabher, A., Bridge, J.: Inorganic polymer ma-
This work was funded by the MacDiarmid Institute of trix composite strength related to interface condition, Materi-
Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology. als, 2, 2216 – 27, (2009).
19 Lin, T., Jia, D., He, P., Wang, M.: Liang, D.: effects of fiber
References length on mechanical properties and fracture behaviour of
1 Davidovits, J.: Geopolymer chemistry and applications, Insti- short carbon fiber reinforced geopolymer matrix composites,
tut Géopolymère, Saint-Quentin, 2008. Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 497, 181 – 5, (2008).
2 Foerster, S.C.: Alkali-activated aluminosilicate composites, (in 20 Lin, T., Jia, D., Wang, M., He, P., Liang, D.: Effects of fibre
German), PhD Thesis, ETH Zürich, Switzerland, (1994). content on mechanical properties and fracture behaviour of
3 Foerster S.C., Graule, T., Gauckler, L.J.: Strength and tough- short carbon fibre reinforced geopolymer matrix composites,
ness of reinforced chemically bonded ceramics, In: Cement Bull. Mater. Sci.. 32, 77 – 81, (2009).
24 Journal of Ceramic Science and Technology —M. Welter et al. Vol. 6, No. 1
21 Lin, T., Jia, D., He, P., Wang, M.: In situ crack growth ob- online from: http://cait.rutgers.edu/files/Ceram-RU9163.pdf
servation and fracture behaviour of short carbon fibre rein- (accessed: 6.11.2013).
forced geopolymer matrix composites, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 527, 30 Sun, P., Wu, H.: Transition from brittle to ductile behaviour of
2404 – 7, (2010). fly ash using PVA fibres, Cement Concrete Comp., 30, 29 – 36,
22 Kriven, W.M., Bell, J.B., Gordon, M.: Microstructure and mi- (2008).
crochemistry of fully-reacted geopolymers and geopolymer 31 Zhang, Y., Sun, W., Li, Z: Impact behaviour and microstruc-
matrix composites, In: advances in ceramic matrix composites tural characteristics of PVA fiber reinforced fly ash-geopoly-
IX, Ceram. Trans., 153, 227 – 50, (2003). mer boards prepared by extrusion technique, J. Mater. Sci., 41,
23 Rill, E., Lowry, D.R., Kriven, W.M.; Properties of basalt fibre 2787 – 2794, (2006).
reinforced geopolymer composites, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc., 31, 32 Zhang, Y., Sun, W., Li, Z., Zhou, X., Eddie, C.: Impact prop-
57 – 67, (2010). erties of geopolymer based extrudates incorporated with fly
24 Musil, S.S., Kutyla, G.P., Kriven, W.M.: The effect of basalt ash and PVA short fiber, Constr. Build. Mater., 22, 370 – 383,
chopped fibre reinforcement on the mechanical properties (2008).
33 Zhang, Z, Yao, X., Zhu, H., Hua, S., Chen, Y.: Preparation
of potassium based geopolymer, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc., 33,
31 – 42, (2012). and mechanical properties of polypropylene fiber reinforced
25 calcined kaolin-fly ash based geopolymer, J. Cent. South Univ.
Li, W., Xu, J.: Mechanical properties of basalt fibre reinforced
Technol., 16, 49 – 52, (2009).
geopolymeric concrete under impact load, Mater. Sci. Eng. A,
34 Lowry D.R., Kriven W.M.: Effect of high tensile strength
505, 178 – 186, (2009)
26
polypropylene chopped fibre reinforcements on the mechan-
Li, W., Xu, J.: Impact characterization of basalt fibre reinforced ical properties of sodium based geopolymer composites, Cer-
geopolymeric concrete using a 100 mm-diameter split hopkin- am. Eng. Sci. Proc., 31, 47 – 56, (2010).
son pressure bar, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 513 – 514, 145 – 15, (2009). 35 Alzeer, M., MacKenzie, K.J.D.: Synthesis and mechanical
27 ] Dias, D.P., Thaumaturgo, C.: Fracture toughness of geopoly- properties of new fibre-reinforced composites of inorganic
meric concretes reinforced with basalt fibres, Cement Concrete polymers with natural wool fibres, J. Mater. Sci., 47, 6958 – 65,
Comp., 27, 49 – 54, (2005). (2012).
28 [28] Comrie, D.C., Kriven, W.M.: Composite cold ceramic 36 Alzeer, M., MacKenzie, K.J.D.: Synthesis and mechani-
geopolymer in a refractory application, Ceram. Trans., 153, cal properties of novel composites of inorganic polymers
211 – 25, (2003). (geopolymers) with unidirectional natural flax fibres, Appl.
29 Defazio, C., Arafa, M.D., Balaguru, P.N.: Functional geopoly- Clay Sci., 75 – 6, 148 – 152, (2013).
mer composites for structural ceramic applications, Final Re- 37 Welter, M.: Unidirectional fibre reinforced geopolymer matrix
port, Ceram-RU9163, Center for Advanced Infrastructure and composites, PhD Thesis, Victoria University of Wellington,
Transportation, Rutgers State University, USA, 2006, Available New Zealand, (2013).