Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Summer 2013
Instructor: Dr. Norris Bruce, phD
Meeting Time: Tuesday 1 0:30AM-2:30pm
Class Room: SOM 1.117
Office Hours: Tuesday 4:00pm*6:00pm, by appointment
Office: SOM 3.220
Phone: 972-883-6293
Email: norris.bruce@utdaiias.edu
TA: Abhishek Rishabh
Course Description
This is an advanced PhD seminar that introduces you to Bayesian dynamic models. Its
objective
is to help you learn how to develop, estimate, and assess these dynamidEodels; and how
to add
to the marketing dynamics literature.
Recommended Textbooks
Bayesian Statistics and Marketing (2005). Peter E. Rossi, Greg M. Allenby, Rob
McCulloch.
Petris, Petrone and campagnoli (2009). Dynamic Linear Models witht. Springer.
West and Han'ison (1999). Bayesian Forecasting and Dynamic Models. 2nd Edition,
Springer.
D.ynamic N o n- Line ar Mo de I s :
Branko Ristic, Sanjeev Arulampalam Neil Gordon(2004). Beyond. the Kalman Filter: particle
Filters for Tracking Applications. Artech House Radar Library.
Other readings including joumal articles andlor book chapters are referenced in the ,,Class
Schedule, Topics and Readings" section below.
Course Requirements:
Course Proiect: For this project students are encouraged to work in pairs. The purpose of the
project is to have you appiy some of the techniques covered in the course to a substantive
marketing problem. My hope is that some of your ideas will eventually be publishable. please
submit a two page repqrl by June 25th containing detailed explanation of the potential problem
you want to work on, the plans for collecting the data, and the modeling approach you hope to
Page 1 of4
l,lil
€n
take. The project consists of two deliverables: 1) a copy of your code (properly documented and
preferably wdtten in Matlab); and2) a 30-minutes presentation which should include a
description of your problem, data, model, estimation and results.
Frank M. Bass, Noris Bruce, Sumit Majumdar, and B. P. S. Murthi (2007). Wearout Effects of
Different Adverlising Themes: A Dynamic Bayesian Model of the Advertising-Sales
Reiationship. Marketing Science, vol.26, issue 2, pages 179-195.
Non'is i. Bruce, Natasha Zhang Foutz, Ceren KplSarrci (2012). Dynamic Effectiveness of
aaGrtising and Word of Mouth in Sequential Distribution of New Products. Journal of
Marketing Research: Vol. 49, No. 4, pp.469-486.
Lopes, Hedibert F., Esther Salazar, and Dani Gamerman (2008), "Spatial Dynamic Factor
Analysis," Bayesian Anaiysis, 3 (4),759-92.
;i.,f.;. I
,\'-- O Ngn"ULftuce, Kay Peters, Prasad A. Naik (2012). Discovering How Advertising Grows Sales
-. and Builds Brands. Journal of Marketing Research: Vol. 49, No. 6, pp.793-806.
Page 2 of 4
Meeting 5, July 2: Dynamic GLMS and Conditional Linear Models
+Fen'eira and Gamerman (2000). Dynamic Generalized Linear Models: in GeneralizedLinear
Models: A Bayesian Perspective, CRC.
*Claudia Cargnoni, Peter Mriller & Mike West (1997). Bayesian Forecasting of Multinomial
Time Series through Conditionally Gaussian Dynamic Models. Journal of the American
Statistical Association. Volume 92, Issue 438, pages 640-647.
Oliver J.; Sonnier, Garrett P. (2011). The Evolution of Internal Market Structure.
- 7, Rutz,
L' Marketing Science. MarlAprZ}l 1, Vol. 30 Issue 2, p274.
Gamerman (1998). Markov Chain Monte Carlo for Dynamic Generalized Linear Models.
Biometrika, 85, 275-227 .
Bayesian instrumental variables pp183-1 87: Bayesian Statistics and Markeflng, Rossi et al.
Ngik, Prasad A.; Tsai, Chih-Ling (2000). Controlling Measurement Errors in Models of
Advertising Competition. Joumal of Marketing Research (JMR);Feb2000, Vo1. 37 Issue 1, p113.
, .. : Garrett P Sjpntsl, Leigh McAlister, and Oiiver J. Rutz (201 1). A Dynamic Model of the Effect
(",-::1" of Oniine Communications on Firm Sales. Marketing Science. Vol. 30, No. 4, 702-716.
Jinhong Xie, X. Michael Song, Marvin Sirbu, Qiong Wang (1997). Kalman Filter Estimation of
New Product Diffusion Models. Joumal of Marketing Research, Vol. 34, No. 3 (Aug., 1997),pp.
318-393.
Prasad a
ryuih arhutosh Prasad, Suresh P. Sethi (2208). Building Brand Awareness in
Dynamic Oligopoly Markets. Management Science, Vol. 54, No. 1, pp.129-138.
Page 3 of 4
Meeting 9, July 30: The Ensemble Kalman Filter
Jonathan R. Strouda, Michael L. Steina, Burry M. Leshta, David J. Schwaba & Dmitry Beletskya
(2010). An Ensemble Kalman Filter and Smoother for Satellite Data Assimilation. Joumal of the
American Statistical Association. Volume 105, Issue 49I,2010.
C@g-Gao, Han Wang, Ensheng Weng, S. Lakshmivarahan, Yanfen Zhang,and Yiqi Luo (2011).
Assimilation of multiple data sets with the ensemble Kalman filter to improve forecasts of forest
barbon dynamics. Ecologicai Applications. Volume 21, Issue 5.
Page 4 of 4
ar: $f..rr- .+ /rerr".,e. ",0;;;.:;*; ftRLt, r^*.rnu|;i*',^oo
- -;;- ,,Rt.re*ca ll'1Y--,).^"LG*$r-,,d1)
\, . fr&>+ *,N+ 7'.t tt iol vrt .j ,..,tn* ,t'a*,)"vaspu{h+-.G*rltt-,
),ly )
lterl%
c-tqknr
u2r44g..,3 T ., ,-f&p;t{or*qt&.b) <=>F*tc*r^Gn'du*,)
ua ot= Gt0t +t)"+ /t,icltxn)
D"L r" &icy lf dain
t*.^.." t*;,Jraatct'
-:.., It t^AL."{ | 't - 1g-F76,tal!r*
rcfitbcJtll * \ ' I
t'')1' qr?tvivu'v''-"*,lnu_,{rf%:l
fltpu*7ay\u,Jbo , n,),.-;L.d_ l-[3''i*'':'-'-l-i \filtlt- *,.",r1
Yr-, -1
,{ -t*,i "',t\, )
fb-'-t{ Y.tL-l't'L*2t -tr' ,*ui-i:"i":- +,!.w;ts\t5 ltq*tt1 t
e'(h.F'u"'r
l.-t.., ", fur,cto"r'S Sjj--::'"::.:L-:1;;J-J
trv\t'rf-{\r
'oou'-,._ Lrr,w yi,ret
n po4f"tt' ::::::*-! Ltin'- t'l ,vrhttr)
[0r-,lvr-)rrri&u-,, t"',:;*. rn:.re-n.r e4 w^..-,,;;-
T'3'iet' ri''tt"
fit,f,t,
fi* {i, Sf".,t $ rro,, ff"Jt*tf;i '"i
i
Gt.,v,u..n .,la+r;x rel<.GJ
I { lar tiT !o*.t<t &r-':i'J {'}'^^}':
r"r'"lii-;
-Jfro.n-i ;O'
te''rr
*--1 r
e"lYr).1 gvt chs,r*,\
,L
t,a o *',
^,1 . t'
, rA.Vr_?={li.
Gt'Yr)'i 'f'\'W t7):r -::r'*
| ' lbll{',(.l dry', '''*'- ,,
"oir':,''rt'l
tte.1..t+}
tu 5"t+
W( *Fr*r'lu-, 'r"r';u,,'u;i;,i;#*+.*t1""1)
pa1 6.rtct.uo t+,tr-Y o rl*
{' - rt:; lu."* +' 'n'r'i r 'Ui::f":"tr
| ,;"w:,:;:,"ir-,).y,4te,,;-r-,)d
' F(?rtt+..,rb+7^fL+/t-;l
-i-rlf,I'"*'J
i *' ;&'n'k'fg silpr''ni
L-- O 1o ' 4a *'"
***n -,
ev ({e*lt fi*)fiitLr
r'r''t)n, tur-Gr%-, )
wilfi' - ] - r;r** .i* t; c-:y2,;fu f",,.1. JiJ+,, ":f,r
'* @ut l/r) '*' {e. Isry*-,; r,t[Fr{b**Gr6;1,vr'1, ":*,;-" -a .t,rd!-
s;..ra-.+ r*r z{:.5nr}re-{^,.J
'"m rj E ftb+t V", fo*, > {"rlYW*Ll'l)i
r't ,s F"oiie,'. in ntq;
"- $s:re7a,7apa)v,
#r*Lt^*''1
! Dr-G+8t-,r#+ ,1.-,i
i,{*, (o, t 4,+),4P ir'tuYf''J'-
rtt{*:?L , ,,_ rnfrDu); **::)_._. -
Epl;ezl
+: i ( "rlDo)*t,L*rl*J
@JS i,ss>* €?iir* f,rubte''t'tiv I ,u;r;; ,7.,tc,",r; nr,el ,dar€o , tff',?,1{rr&*rul }
'-t)L,'' L"c4"L$n"'t-' a t
tn*lL{1$rrtuu') f r.rrn*" G.*= lrFr'RJft
o ('{* ior\ tv tv Lt:ro*, v) r = tzl r't l Gi
rp^.r@r,),v, L.+t\on,w") 7-.,
..,Ajcl..l.
*J;Y:ffrf# :'::S -[t*l e e' i-r''4
;';,'-:_-( . c i' - 4,4"e I
:;"+ r;g;g:*rt ?* "' ;: ;::
E'l*
.\ + ; r. . *, : {l.u
-,
)
{?;',:::';,:.;' :::':.:il#;*; Lkr rh'|es
* setiur,hi.'$ a"t\r.i ctri., fr c.nqt. ,e '"-{ r,r}b c*ri.aa ,udi P'e,,ft, tw\) Calc gi;a; #rl&-,,trVi{," t &t)
5? cfc*J fznuar: p(t{rrQ,;>.-,) to"icr (6*i1:"-, ) e (&rt D.-,)-o* =G"*.-,
{c:if*;itt*, lr{ 6r iyr, p+", ) V,rr St I Dr*,), R, = G" Co-,G" t r,it,
- S,.ngl s .*, ( s.iie.: e,
Frl*c. .$ ,rruo. t,!rqt.*Chu"j.
/t
\i,'
;.4 t,n19,
f,rrJ. elsrr yt lD*-,.-,r,ifrrCL*)
Ji .4r + {3, K, t ZS_n \rva} i*, y)
E (\rlDr-,), fr. liao v.,. ( Y" /Pa-,).t\. f-i1.r1rr*,
fit . 4t-1 r 64,', -'rrfo rti I D- - D*-, tr) 36
(r'Pr q " IR
It .* r1rtl1..fi (Will;)
-hha,, k'>)Y racf*,,l{d11
{ragt*.!y G*t4 *jyvr,, b;u?
7) s) p^, 3 J*-J;. nois.y yc.. (i,..,."f
Jr,J.,llr,';:,.r]ffi,,
itar, , ) lz-r,r,.rg
,..r inh c"rrl".r, t grlfit-q+>
= tYls-t
*:,u:i",* f*-, la.1'-u''(6t{*-,1*intP*-,)lD*) rE(u'orf"f;?"
,itu-tuii <{ytqb-, t::lY L '.'t
(o1r!. 6.i,1 ,,,1.,i*r")J^r,,4#---g=q t]*::
I p;- €'.-, 'F.Rr Fr t Biqrr--c+,* tn.,<.r 8.
{d1''{i,rt+'+,u,1 - 4
i Y,,L*iu,uurt
-l,t lfi,i-",1"",
t?ff*?"*r, I ot-s i"r+'-" r'iLc"q*"1
-
(;.;) " , o,r.,u.-, J,,ra+1i,,{,. b tr,.i.
(c,r.[,tc'r",(5
i..,,1,{reaJui ,"i.Lip"a,L*t
..taro;.,r" ttr*nf6r, tsioc. tr-
W **fs;.L, .,t" l'', z (\{1rn 't 'tc'u
.-;--7ok+je uy6ts,zi,fu*,n =
L'r-#iarrt iorrul,
eb. t:iiv' x.ol*'tl
,*-
L"t'sr:,!!fil':,
f:,:;::' i
#t, :': i:r,';;,Hilt#':;*.7
"Lit^rt,
grc;{tt.l'r +. @ft-*,,J xrrt"ia3 b",st-u;.nol stL,rytpL'n.t (ft'otl:
- N; d+ta ? ,vlcnr*rrl 1a,'* z,lcol?lr|r$t1eJ CDg,' nuil..q*t. Lpt lr>().-N(mrrLt)
-) 4y,r-
rllfir,,1;,1t1 d,In f.*( "tr
u"J,$n,
tLt: ,*tr-1..a; lsqrht ;''(rl'Jiir'a
':,':1:l^ ] ,; A)",- , 3
':1.,:i***'l: *{,;1-.";;:J :i'":.d G)*,,'u,';:;;},.",i'l:'i:;',!;)cah,*.d*, h.r ,LLi.
_ 1t6t c{"$ !qrr\1o1s p.{r-L.*5t ,' breaitr i00
!.irnfte i,rto gltsi 6f,,t"UnOr,'J 'ra,l,-iterrJ*rt:
..n s.,fiFre 3 F;r a*t'r$" tr15r;i:rq i t t'{fs,{,, tr, ',&l
rytf
- l4 - ctef' ,.lta*d
i r t*rt\).f t*.rtryl'7't'ir-,1f ,,F1-,) " 'f{'f'tt'*$!ra
fB"?-;;;l
L- _. S r'; i.{ l< *, iJ t} ,. F( "c r L\.'fll". I
{a,ah 6
+.itrgcr'..t flr*'h,r: {1 . JZ.f?"r Z=(frr,4e,-i
$) fln "l"*,un br"*] qrornf^ho.:
+tZ'-
tts*.UC.l.)
et "6rqrqg. .fr;,rt f,csfearier sct/,tfie: rr?riarl {u fu,') tati, qtl rclr*Jrg,;OO, {j,,rnd4, ff.. m,att)m€!(.t
/;\ - t
\ilSr
".
t+ 7'111at l'tf
19 ,".rq (yue.. rf i3t
e 'ea P,j u atJ t0, Cc ) *t +, , t t
$ fir5.r Aa (F ., ?-t 4 r 4 . ls , " ^t lv tar (.,)-) I tP,. >it ) *pf * ,lyg 'r! ,oi|n* ,r,n.,
@ De ltw i";t}flta-s I ctttlefi
tr;,L ,J,rr:J1rq.+ti u-r,.qn(i q-l 6t3, r ia,Lp ( ?/{.2;"Zss/D
y'-\ olr+b ianr I q:rnx b+,t,"liti F"i*r.tO. &O* *?:,.eo J
u_' fl. ,' 4 , , t)fi'qj ilcru ri-e &hiil'r
fiwn ,* r*rn.'r*J rn bw
&t --i' '$1
w, ttrC'L)cx l- -L
lleyuwA f.::are,_ (te*4
ftir:*+,)
(0 ;f nr, biqw.r"..i*^,.ta , r6)fr"..,i-qj,piif. ta.tt< (.'!sr.h"^"J "o,Zrc,?blS;ngd.i5
G) F-,,r Gi F)r,,,r..
fu j
@ ;,..\ur,or.br"*r="7) *.,**L 3;';t'-i"^ i'n*Y.I'u"'
enf,'rt'& €ot-h L il N ( tt, , f't' I 'i r'W r{ron pi'p), 1
vt{tcrvt*,- rrlr,/:Ltl\,j ri; 2"v
161 ((z.tr'tr)/* r fi)sLie;)12. ) 4 -{c; -l/Fi)"lt; .tfi;)
\g'tjcn*trs e f eoul efr.{;*_, Q'[u, QnJ, ri r l3;,! NU11;, Ci)l( li,t>t )
o,r.J . =. * k ,
p-r":;;ffi7*'-..
v'
re_* QJt r-'qlYul* * tem.t':i:,1
(7) cle1'dtt;\"tt*-*" I *lsak +"1;f"l:i
'"tr."*.lf 1"7ur.[t"'- -- Fi;{f'/ {eo"rt'r5 lt|*t'o
{'lrz"'J'.i€c-5ti"'J'fI)
sfath)
a ,rr^firh,t * ffi" '
S) w - fiwt r nt,,trt!* .\' t3h' 4 t::1,i *llr!,'r, Cre.\r1&- e+r1ie r, r"5 1
..h,nL $rrld:; ($*ln$
ie {'16 r irtt-rtrr<3
t iEt
sf"k'
L,"rct.J rl,.glu.!, ..,r0-,,1) *l @ nc r*Y
dynai;" fr*?o,. n*Lt)1
.fl ,'' V i-Sulo) : V t5u I f,L) i. py'+ t t€" r**":o.:.^':
," t{..61P}--ci - G.ltyprrgrflf)=o g'rtJil )'Zl,$i{n, *r," *lr'.Ytr' + ffu ur* tv{at L)
ffi'*.:T.;
,$Y";
n"a Y,'irl,*,o Nt.
- t ''-'
(, , (15,r t lit): A[., f;t" Ftt "' A1- 1'-1' titl*' rY car'
9r:L')rir"'t\P< '
to c-fi g, sr ,"-..,!a,
,"...a..* S. ' ' =,r5&
"''> PT(
\'f.lt'+t' "n J
&,,'
Ui*rn1- LrvEJ -ir - i
S1,: r'r ue*r" *+#r,, i^-r'J;' "*^,
7-' "kit:si.,'r" ..,*** ) JL' 4iq5 Ll rr "' t 2*)
tl:{nr.rrir cvciuJi* + $"*r*, "f
* p \t \Y,2).{ lJt \--v' e.rt( -'s -?-'s'y) .,t"trrtf,,--r1(h)
Qadta*,,.r1s,
,if,:.H""* f*'P?' , fl""?'h fl k;lt rrc4+.i G]
-- tr'{1 cr-trt' n,tryta &..t, d,'.1 l-ql i*- t N Gr,wt, trn
f, * i.t.t,
(_ Ltqwtatn ",
i:iceti [cr*'s' fric'*.]-'/ttL'Y," I 1 pat) t t* *m, tW. "t rt,tkrr l:,eirl GRf. ) ntr
;cLe#,'6i,3;n , tJ' wu-:...ai I fi"',rr''eh'fil" fr, t * (fj F', ,ri (T 1,, r, .iR+, ) (fi',
k"*.1'a"t -Gtu-
t*n= f4; (lgz-sxi) g1^i-r,.-.,nt rt =
L,..c!.',rpj ,*"ot+,s t{e.lrrri,}S, 'r= '"ll'( - L*:' 1:; r.--m
ffi Dt6j6-'*t'"*c G'
@rt**t tuncrou " 1 1.'lt /"')tr,',|' r'\
lg*Ffi* lytyo'e
G)*u* tu-i *fl .u&- &, ty<t*-r,r,ttt (rc$* .nfria,rt:n I l(p''l:o)' Jy(p'lfo'a
c",,elr;t ,*', t-, **y' fr*=!' v t 'ltf"' flo'*)' nP'f tpit'l pf;"y;P'rltt*';)
ii"'ui''lilr^J" I
i:t!;t tn)-' ri':l')'!:'; ('{.i'".^30)l
iti) 63,7u,n,,-
*.: :i-"
6-q{ 4"&r
, ? ti,* u.,),lrq G..
'' iI Pu",llt;,ro - N[ x,P'i' rF, ri,:"n*, '(fi,
-
r':"1;),
t..){>*-,.i-,,;('n^v;l'.:u::":o.,'.]d..to,.,\t,ffi'r?ffit
o<€ca"1 te1""1";"''
@f!r?1rt', '''1''"-n'5Y i
Ci ) v,'r!,ru b,,f fw;$et 7;i.ts
*yfe y;f r.,Wt*f ,if ), *r',-
Tu'tztb'4
(;" ) r"r,ieae,1.{-
(. j ntib"t"-t l, p t, $a/,t-) gy,7p,;--rl.iram *trn 2Sr,rl";l,r
-
t t;"'l';1 tr t;at i'Jt,""'4';T
@ ir,r*i f,f , ,f,f ;i ,
s:t
n ot 7;r
$,rty;fi e,i{'r): i
/.,
*1 tts} )
lt,i tv'i\ 't
t-
,,'
-S *- *-:',=Fa=; ;,x,s; *
ffiiloa*t's;*,,Xf'
Qit€,r*'*
^
* ^^':-::;r;;-8"'r"*;^e
t
.. ". :
fl::
>;:-
Air* r\'
'A.'n,'
E Lf r)D* -,)
4iw'' (]."tsi*n'rt
{unE,fi"wt* z*a?)
\L*---.:-*. *waa ." s. ,l'. ,\ ir{ h. Ai. ?c 1 I r7 " ' rrf,
* "{ a.l- ' r D-r. <,*.- I
- -r*r". ,i?it -ui' /t. .ar.ft)rrtrurrtul ,.- \rrn\ui,rrr* J*nd 't , t -"
ttc{o" ',.
'' -r(9r.lD.-')s"+'
q; rrL Yst Va 't 1
'*l 1g'9oLt-ffc , , r'.r- r:r-.,.*'/
tq)
* t
*",{.'Sl
- re.;.tiec"&'tpa t
-,,.r1 n/,a*4(tr.r.rJ
flsnh ("
Ci l-lcr,'.r I'{6<^f deren^"'c,+ait,
l-lc''"r Lr{$<of
, il^ "*:*:t.:y*;f[ #I
s4#c1
,.i ,..-rr,f #7 6'9,
: f)Aa,ntn,L
e)t-r<4rt;
,on 'n'c 'r+t+*fi1" *ty
'
ir .,, fl'?'Li.*s
,-r4rJ ry-*,.[iir]s
# ra/ruJ I
I
(}
O Hc*
Hr,; <ei,tihP-
"*t:"-'* -*f,:aru,tt:*
Y \1u llv't'*t:
7l'"'.r).i ,*ua 11a1,t r:
Jrt. itt 'o '5t 1'u>rt' . /; i Z
J) i/r,.
A :iry
ilt:tt 'r'1f'{q "* .. r.i ,,fc,ibJg+ t|
rtfi*t' r-€Jr{ lo,. ,u.lu
€*7 Hrr"w rrse*) -u'.,'
- &.,was gaittfi'rs auJ
DLm -
- se?&*iJ s!''vi,::'::;,,r*;
se.?u;",lr"u :. -'.- *o; tqltr {l.trz,t 'fi+' :*"
i';^* ni't* Pt-t'r4
h/C'11 !tit-{4
-. l,lctfr laLa '! .f;.&
r.^.,lrQ (' G.i*tt,.c\ ccl,
* relft:"$' titl'G ot'r u'rri' '/ " - ,. - *
Jir;b,,J-;e,4)
D3u1ero*ic f"th 'a&' ct tJe4 l.tw'w '
T;;-,r*'15
*'r - iecttlot*L '6lazllst+1 'vr'nlruwr - -- t
ib4po'-kb+
lYlo'U"l .- Srft+,tds g,;rlucl L.&e. LJc'e
Y"tt*"*'
6 ^."^ f*r
&) +
'
hlr-rt*, [i"r\'r^r^ add tov:'r"'ut @,r<-*" $'a '{*rc''lit*o us' h;{-ara
- t* 7+*;i1 "l f''{-'rgci\tl * o$e;fi*t
'tr<&d
l* *!:*'*r.,t tt*€.rr + ilara't qtt:'ost1t-vtaa LLt'Fn'+) * S/rfloi<,, .r-Jt*rf.l.',n,$ "'''' - ''fiit1'ta
*}\'als*t.idn3
L0) D;t4"1* .- t*t!"/t e {te&vs"vrt*";-Iy"tt" )'
it)::.,f3%, 4 &r..s dd._"r,a+i ^rr) (.kltt\w*t*
e t1rr-.l,wnt"tt 4c.,.,,s A"lr lttr
-.isn*,.*,rdw,r; \"t* i.f,iqc..--
';ff
k' " Y*;::fFr*:,- *itf '\.u'i -.F,r,rj,-
(G', 1.; .ilo-, 6rr
t, 5'9 trcr*
+.ifi..
,,-..,..*Y' *d*at
br'w\
,vrr+" r"'"ti'33/id-1^.rrr
{,"., (aitfY,i --
l_*r.1n".fu?
eeFe-tut*''l * 5fa'da$ 4'^,,
ct a'ttt) @ ,*"t" tht-i'.t'"k t
g! - *o;ntq
-(r- rr'+r)$(
d,t -!, r,Jl,'.!7' *t; ,, ' -"i *L*r f{e 4Lr'- ti.ttt,t ltw sfuitr q,h'rr'Frs"
dS,t,:, Ii (9re; " li Ij''
,"'")- ;fr
A(fr" fr;)) "
no"+",r, trtJ..
i osc'i'-JrJ €$k'l'*n/rt
lLD *rn."^,e AJ !6lar'";'rl"'
g_f !,,,_,,_. r ;lfitc'{
'l m D9"''"t'{'
trt/u ''fl
fttac udv' t*?n*.' Yl".'il':; *ul 6*l*;ll'!,b;li
16 nWV'h Drr'"ad
t,'
,,i' . c Y r f *? :i',!,,
^'Y. uii' - e;r oi',
bttu)-t'tr+S) 'lzrivt {"1'''i !'"r! il::,1"
*n -)d *, ^ro,
__X* Fcr'y-+tlvi r"';
{e&i ..--!:""i) i1
r i'\(kurk)) [
Tril,r, t 'l.M tt
t rltr* ft9;l)l
i1: ;' ;''' c..-'.i'-"
;'i''. +,'i*f'-g
) io, - i l:il,Si
S
-a(,+; )"$i i ,,
gharlt i' e.$slit*"P * ' e ;\1'Zi - ' 7 trt -
et,(fr;) tC'i fw'A*
,,t'i -, lo. r; i;-i " ".1*.*.s
rt-l-
r*tL*l 1g' fir"n'{le j"'#Y;}f",,r)"'rt'^ot i lt ); (it0) " A^''r'ni:t"''t'r rtsi<o
Dtn s*i -J\"'
zr, d'^
,:rlW;tti..b
L,'{fiFte' r';n''V}'i1 t' *+' fr 'ut,'-'
)
u*'i rr*,o-i ..u
rtn*,)\L h'-'l
1
Y;lar ]
. ,'.tn*fi'5L'l'
it
vr
f , cl
(,-
6;
If\1 i., &,ti1ttl, ) + ;' i!--!v',''*
' ltl--tc,itt) 1
1
)tj
L t , ,- rry,il) l'
t;lt-.. tfr j
t*ft 2, * p,la1€Ll
tt
F4/<*+'-e-"a;"
5+ 'F, *1+pxr+4
# r, //, * , -,r Qrtuc boi .n/ /'JLO/ b)1
'a.&- s"t\t"ii
dr
; La"t l \_4F
I r,,r" i.l'';t';l-r,1,-*:;,t'
[ " "'9;i',rf,;'i
tr-,'.,,,1 ;.____
r,-uJr'-rji'e
L
,
-1;;-.*
J :;;;;v.^I*-i
fiI",'rr
| .*--------=-
frkffifi' a**-P
(*.,n Cs:Hi iit'r'"
{"'i6J
-rh'lrt
zr t r) r
La-' 11
r-. Llr
I Q,c-i I ^t'r' I
- ,.,,11'- rL-.H')l I -/ :;..1,i ?
l*:tl-,
Lq'' I
| I
.ji^ !>
t r,Jzr (lrt
t I { Ln-. ,'j' I
J " -:r-t r tfrl {'i iJi.] ft;:J"[1*J'ii.J
'z,r-t
*tr J
*,.-!;t
hrf,
-;;r,Ft
Vft-,
),r"'|''r*1!t' p!"n,';'
, ii' q.'j'-''-"1'.,i
'l
dt. . tj) ., tit ,r;.t"^, ntiq u: "
o,rd) " ti ;!'g;y'tQ6 +4,1
i*tts d-'5]! "*fe,rs d:(ffur"ootl' uut r'i/vLOz ltr)
er'ao&l Q'art 11:/t
f
,ati
$*,n,:,*
lnjP :::5'jc'r<jr j:::i
tr[rs:{il;;. 'rf'.t 8r"^tr r'rcntF
OTt^r,*, .4L ,/,wril<,'^t i
"J.;
€*pc"i1,^n [rrJ d .* ^+ 5 ,' S :+ E )
l
. G:Pa'o 1 €, c, ,{ )
6) r&cc,T ncif a,{' Q L,,tutitw.tl c.cl .ia
b iL*-ant.r-rr.r.tl*; c1e[. @ Pr,,{n* 'td
rvt j -':fl rff
\D ppri.ni.|aircvr . o1rtr;n,l<- ,t * 5l;t 'l*'rttl
s"tle'
t"r f < 64rt;n
}*& !i;,rc/e
I { i $l{J;,,fi
&bw.r,,riri
{ Vrrrricri'-5 {o"
tB6;a6"Ls. S,$*, frfe'r, Alr:u'F- t'rla
cu\r"rti*r1b !}ro-'o
r'"'"1
fu=,1
() ?k,qL - fe*l- {o -ftn'r"rch. ,, ifYry.:l-'+ - o-'.|-l#
f...+., 4
m,.rt Se h
*rr crtr, I
o '\e"c:rl!:fl fu";
[] a)"rturi*; ,P :]r:&{-*3g1e '4tu'6"'l'{s
€t -l:
1
6 f.rte-,"r5 er*l- snErpn* n*ise t-f,ltt*lt &*-ts" l6a'cLt'*s
L -{aa
tIL
,i
J .5r5t
r,
;) t I
l
i1 tX
@ rra^,1 *l".".r.i'nq ho..q[a' +yl+,5t.t.t1 ['w,r
c.lri.-*+ c-rprraL .-r' 69n'"tio"" -+'"d*aii {--} S'lel
j I
| fi;'i5',Ti,i" ii: I
6 ft*l***|"f"a*'""* {^is< '&r 'lh I*;*,t
L!: tt:-'
6 .;-*- t;"".'+F'ct{E'-1]-tr'";";;* o 75auJ -r,
J
u't'f'$,,1,u,,
s, lt, f ,f.l- .:, :y"::Ty, i-ir,.r
\
i
fr{.*t"/ {c.#*,
L;,*if,*;'i'' '[5'rqrniu$ i.
ic''ri f:-'J-:'l'r:f (:fl vi'(*1&"i)
I
..i*' i
Jr'.r Y,lr:ryli{i -;
.r,t,r--j,r* rctt.,of ito5 Y-' o. ;:;:"ll
[-': :ri; ,*;);i ,'
& rll''trtei'* 's r{.1*, cr-lfre3:.:e{i'L .,aq'\t,rp*- tF*t=tltfJ
"urra"On
f,i ;zrc i.ig.it*nt: f* ''l;r'r-* *1
r #* 'l ''i*'**" r.* ii,l.* r ','a
W rt';i sc
_- -*i aS fi.rr^j I
f &'* y'-'ia' i
titc'J' t'{to'}uu'l j
<fi,r,.Je- '.tclalrii'c
He.ir.-. tel'niitt',a. Rtr '-Slt
tvtc * fi-a'ro '
u"rttett"u'f i
{* . . i
"6Cla'l
''r1*':wL
lL' $tal" '\'?'':'" I
tl*,r.r.t,rl*-.$ ;
""u*'
.--n
*((ifr w*h f'ch {:r'lrrrr\rr
,Xf$:*",,,i;i ;i,
byi reu, ** D*F i
Tatta'
@ u,oit- rr,,i: 1-4J*"Y r'4 ,,)tq,ra.
"^ re+}ta'ia'
{t* aa**hsin& t *')l'rnr "tf/rr'*at
: r^i; i"$'N
@ i-:f''qntt"'f ir
U-, rie* J erJu'"h r'"r"J flie'*''
6