You are on page 1of 6

Lane Asset Management

July 2010
A Special Focus on “Fixed” Income Investing

Special points of interest:


This special focus is on ―fixed‖ in- any type, carry a risk of gain or leading and should be taken with a
 Global bonds have per- come investing. Generally speaking, loss in principal value as a result of grain of salt.
formed admirably com- there are several types of invest- a shift in interest rates since the
For example, according to stock-
pared to U.S stocks ments considered fixed income. security was purchased.
charts.com, the S&P 500 index had a
over the last 30 years The most common of these are
There are many considerations to compound annual rate of return be-
 By paying attention to U.S. and foreign government bonds,
take into account when investing tween January 1, 1980, and Septem-
relative performance municipal bonds, corporate bonds,
in fixed income securities. While ber 30, 2010 (30 3/4 years), of about
trends, it appears possi- and preferred stocks.
it is not my plan to go into all the 7.3%. If, however, the measurement
ble to shift between eq- Fixed income investments may be considerations here, they are im- date ended September 30, 2010 (at
uities and fixed income used on an individual security basis portant and should be reviewed about the time the current recession
to one’s advantage or bought through an exchange- with one’s investment advisor. started), the annualized return for
 While individual bonds traded fund, a closed-end fund or Rather, I will use this Focus to the 27 3/4 year period is about9.5%.
have their place in a an open-end (conventional) mutual shed light on historical returns and
Stating this another way. $1,000 in-
portfolio, funds provide fund. selected investment strategies.
vested at the beginning of 1980
distinct advantages I put the word ―fixed‖ in quotation Examining Fixed Income Returns would have grown to about $12,400
 Weakness in the dollar marks since very few specific in- by September 30, 2007, but if left
Before discussing return analysis,
and low domestic inter- vestments in this category actually invested three years longer, would
let me point out that the perform-
est rates at present fa- produce a fixed total return with a amount to only about $8,700 by
ance figures of such analyses are
vor unhedged interna- high degree of certainty. Those September 30, 2010, almost 30%
always subject to their starting and
tional and emerging that do would be individual bonds less.
ending points. Since the period
market bonds over do- held to maturity (assuming no de-
over which the returns are ana- As you can tell, the ending point
mestic bonds fault).
lyzed and compared to alternative made quite a bit of difference!
Other fixed income investments, if investments can greatly affect the
Given the growth the S&P 500 over
sold prior to maturity, or funds of results, such analyses may be mis-
Lane Asset Management Page 2

the 27– and 30-year periods indicated, you ture results; able moving average, in this case, the 30-
might be surprised to discover that global week moving average.
 The two ―bubbles‖ that occurred in the
bonds as represented by the Barclay Capital
equity markets make it more difficult to Putting Historical Performance Knowl-
Global Bond Index (previously the Lehman
establish a reliable long-term expected edge to Work
Global Bond Index — see comments on page
rate of return for domestic equities; my
6) annualized returns were about 9% for both Before describing possible investment
own suspicion, however, is that the
measurement periods! strategies, the following should be noted:
bubbles represent extraordinary results
The graph on page 4 illustrates the total re- and that ―true‖ long-term returns from  The S&P 500 equity index shown is
turn for both indexes from January 1, 1980 to U.S. equities, broadly speaking, are not necessarily representative of all
June 30, 2010. The following observations more likely to be closer to the 30-year equity sectors, and especially not in-

and comments can be made: trend ending in mid-2010 than the 28- ternational equities;
year trend ending in 2007.  While there are a number of invest-
 The Global Bond Index not only had
comparable or better returns for the ob- The graph on page 5 shows the ratio of the ment choices (funds) that will mirror
served period, but was much less volatile; monthly performance of the S&P 500 Index the performance of the S&P 500 in-

to the Barclay Capital Global Bond Index. dex at low cost, in my research,
 Starting and ending points are critical as
Here we see, for the measurement period, there were none that came close to
the S&P 500 easily outperformed the
the general outperformance of the bond reproducing the performance of the
bonds in the 1995-2000 and 2003-2008
index interrupted by spikes in the outper- Barclay Capital Global Bond Index
periods, roughly speaking;
formance of the equities. What I think is over the 25-30 year period.
 The relative stability of the bond index noteworthy here is that this graph shows it Having said that, here are a few strategies
returns over the measurement period is possible do well and still ignore the that make use of this analysis:
would suggest a more reliable pattern of spikes in relative over– and under-
return even though past performance  In a balanced portfolio, weightings
performance IF one takes advantage of the
should not be used as a predictor of fu- between equities and bonds might
longer term pattern as provided by a suit-
Lane Asset Management Page 3

follow the relative performance charac-  As the selection and management of preferred stocks which are also offered
teristics of the indexes rather than adopt- individual bonds is time-consuming and through funds.
ing a buy-and-hold approach; complex, I suggest limiting individual
 Think of preferred stocks as perpet-
bonds to a smaller portion of one’s to-
 A combination of exchange-traded and ual bonds with higher risk than bonds
tal portfolio. Individual bonds should
other funds may be used to approximate (but less than common stocks).
be purchased with the anticipation of
the performance of the Barclay Capital
holding to maturity and, in today’s envi-  Preferred stocks are usually concen-
Global Bond Index using the same tech-
ronment, kept to durations of under 5 trated in the financial and utility sec-
niques to select among domestic and in-
years or so. tors.
ternational hedged and unhedged funds as
is used to adjust the balance between  Bond funds provide flexibility, diversifi-  Preferred stocks may have tax-

fixed income and equities; cation and securities management at advantaged distributions, but this is
low cost. For non-U.S. bonds, such subject to change.
 In view of very low U.S. interest rates and
funds are essential. A good source of information on fixed
the growing potential for increases in the
not-too-distant future, caution is advised  Closed-end funds may employ leverage income investments can be found at

about long maturities on domestic debt; (borrowing) to enhance returns. http://www.quantumonline.com.


in fact, a focus on shorter maturities and Should short-term interest rates turn ** *** **
a laddered approach would be very sensi- upward in any significant way, fund total
ble; and return may be severely impacted.

 By the same token, a weakening dollar  Closed-end funds may sell at a discount
enhances the role of foreign debt even or premium to net asset value (NAV)
though this adds a complicating wrinkle of which can impact long term returns.
sovereign and currency risk.
Regarding other types of fixed income in-
Regarding individual bonds vs. bond funds: vestments, the most common of which are
Lane Asset Management Page 4
Lane Asset Management Page 5
Lane Asset Management Page 6

Disclosures
Lane Asset Management is a Registered Investment Adviser with the States of NY, CT and NJ. Advisory services are only offered to clients or
prospective clients where Lane Asset Management and its representatives are properly licensed or exempted.

No advice may be rendered by Lane Asset Management unless a client service agreement is in place.

Stock investing involves risk including loss of principal. Investing in international and emerging markets may entail additional risks such as cur-
rency fluctuation and political instability. Investing in small-cap stocks includes specific risks such as greater volatility and potentially less liquid-
ity. Small-cap stocks may be subject to higher degree of risk than more established companies’ securities. The illiquidity of the small-cap mar-
ket may adversely affect the value of these investments.

Investors should consider the investment objectives, risks, and charges and expenses of mutual funds and exchange-traded funds carefully for a
full background on the possibility that a more suitable securities transaction may exist. The prospectus contains this and other information. A
prospectus for all funds is available from Lane Asset Management or your financial advisor and should be read carefully before investing.

Note that indexes cannot be invested in directly and their performance may or may not correspond to securities intended to represent these
sectors. It should be noted that the Barclay Capital Global Bond Index shows a lack of volatility that, in my research, was not achieved in any
single fund over the 25-plus year period used in this presentation. Achieving comparable results in terms of ―smoothness‖ or performance on
a prospective basis through a combination of funds cannot be guaranteed.

Investors should carefully review their financial situation, making sure their cash flow needs for the next 3-5 years are secure with a margin for
error. Beyond that, the degree of risk taken in a portfolio should be commensurate with one’s overall risk tolerance and financial objectives.

Periodically, I will prepare analysis focused on a specific investment issue. Please let me know if there is one of
interest to you. As always, I appreciate your feedback and look forward to addressing any questions you may
have. You can find me at:
www.LaneAssetManagement.com
Edward.Lane@LaneAssetManagement.com

Lane Asset Management


P.O. Box 666
Stone Ridge, NY 12484

You might also like