Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Management
May 2017
sm.britsafe.org
A platform
to speak
Government is reviewing
protections for insecure
workers. But what do
they want? We find out.
— 18 to 21
Bo FR n n
r a a ti
ns
ok EE ow
30
99
o
9
84
84
The wise choice for lone worker protection
Choose the lone worker device that best suits each employee.
Choose or mix and match the right response for your lone workers.
your
control
room
mix &
match
our your
ARC staff
999
AMBULANCE
POLICE
News
Opinion
11 L
ouise Ward: design takes
the driver’s seat
12 Richard Bryne: getting the
right insight
14 Letters
Features
This product is
from sustainably
managed forests and
controlled sources
Alarm over ‘Henry VIII’ 9from Davis) that he will face down
those on his own side who will not be
BAM in dock after for Network Rail. workers. Construction work in the
Mark Bradley was seriously injured vicinity of live conductors must
worker electrocuted when the fifth lamp post touched the be properly planned, managed
BAM Construction Limited has 11kV overhead power lines as it was and monitored to ensure the risks
been fined £260,000 after a worker being lifted into position. A colleague are controlled.”
was electrocuted by an overhead rushed to his aid and managed to use BAM Construction Limited, of
power line at a railway operating a piece of timber to push him away Breakspear Way, Hemel Hempstead,
centre in Basingstoke. Shoreland from the lamp column. pleaded guilty to breaching regulation
Projects Limited, the groundworks Investigating HSE inspector 14 of the Electricity at Work
contractor BAM appointed for the William Christie said: “This entirely Regulations 1989 and was ordered to
work, was also fined. preventable incident has had a pay costs of £9,415.13.
Winchester Crown Court heard permanent and very substantial effect Shoreland Projects Limited was
that on 26 January 2015, workers had on Mark’s life. fined £22,000 after pleading guilty to
been installing lamp posts on the site “Overhead power lines pose a the same breach and ordered to pay
entrance road for a project undertaken significant threat to the safety of costs of £8,442.53.
US trade deal would regulation: companies have to prove their because it relies on the collaboration
products are safe. That basic approach of experts in each of the EU member
be ‘disaster’ for simply isn’t recognised in the US.” states to run it.
chemicals safety He said it would be a ‘disaster’ if An enquiry into REACH’s future after
we adopt a UK-US trade deal without Brexit is underway in Parliament with
A UK-US trade deal out of REACH’s
REACH because of the ‘toothless the Environmental Audit Committee.
umbrella would be a “health and
safety disaster”, a Labour MP tiger’ of US equivalent rules. The US Davies, a committee member, told
has warned. Toxic Substances Control Act (TOSCA) a hearing on 7 March: “To provide
Writing for the Guardian, Geraint allows asbestos to be sold in the US. It business certainty, wouldn’t it be
Davies said: “If we leave the EU we also allows chemicals to be sold which sensible simply to say, “We will
step out of the protective umbrella of have been outlawed by the EU, he said. adopt REACH”? It is all very well
REACH, the EU directive that requires Registration, Evaluation, saying we might have a difference of
companies to prove their chemicals Authorisation and Restriction of opinion on ethanol in alcohol or with
are safe to human health and the Chemicals (REACH) is thought to be Poland or whatever, but what we are
environment before they can be sold. one of the most difficult aspects of talking about here are thousands and
“The process works on the environmental regulation to preserve in thousands of jobs and billions and
“precautionary principle” central to EU UK law once the country leaves the EU billions of pounds of industry.”
Safety 2.0: speaking the consult during the rest of 2017, our 60th
anniversary year.
Many workers in the garment industry are subject to labour exploitation. Photograph: iStock/track5
To work out what your safety climate What they don’t mention, gives you
is like, you need to build a picture the insights you need — again the
Richard based on three dimensions. pros and cons of this approach are
Byrne • Physical safety —how well are obvious; or
occupational health and safety • You develop your own questionnaire
risks managed locally across the based around the key ‘what it will
organisation. This can be measured feel like’ measures in your safety
using an audit or a series of them strategy, these are the statements
• Colleague perceptions — what that any good strategy aiming to
do your workforce think of how deliver cultural change will have.
you manage health and safety. Whatever you do, you need to make
This is often measured using a sure the questions are valid; in other
questionnaire or by interviews words they test what you think they
• External perceptions — what do
will test. The results are reliable, so if
your external stakeholders think of
Health & safety director you repeat the survey you will get a
how you manage safety relative to
Contract Merchanting & similar result. Just as important is to
your competitors, legal standards,
Plumbing & Heating Divisions pay attention to the response rate.
customer expectations and best in
Travis Perkins Plc A poor response rate, or low
class. This can be measured via a
uptake for the interviews actually
range of key business metrics.
tells you as much as a high response
rate or great uptake on interviews.
Though, ideally, the rate will be
representative of the workforce,
the results are questionable.
Measuring the safety climate
The results of a climate survey are
Safety culture is one of those is not as easy as simply doing
the results, you can’t change them.
phrases that is banded about by an audit and having a chat
All you can do —even if the results
lots of people in the profession with a few people
are beyond your wildest dreams—
and industry, but the more I hear
is to celebrate success where you
people talk about it the less sure
can and then focus on a handful of
I am they know what they are
improvement actions. Those actions
talking about.
Building a picture of the physical will make a real difference. If you
One of the main areas of confusion,
safety and external perceptions is keep referencing back to the climate
it seems, is how you actually measure
relatively straight forward, however assessment as to why you doing what
it. Back in 2005 my first ever article
colleague perceptions isn’t. You have you are, it makes colleagues realise
for a safety magazine was on this
a number of decisions to make: they are being listened too.
very subject. As it happened 12 years
• You include a handful of health Measuring the safety climate is not
ago, I thought it would worth dusting
and safety-related questions in a as easy as simply doing an audit and
it off and refreshing a few of the
bigger employee attitude survey. having a chat with a few people while
key points.
The downside of doing this is that you are there. It’s multi dimensional
The facts when you get the results you often and best considered when you’ve
You cannot measure culture. The need more insights to identify focus cracked the obvious stuff and want
phrase ‘safety culture’ means the areas, hence another more detailed to get more insights into what
collection of people’s attitudes and survey; or will give you the next leap in your
beliefs towards how health and safety • You use an off-the-shelf organisation’s safety performance.
is managed in an organisation. It is questionnaire with all the pros and
widely agreed upon by academics that cons associated with them; or
it is difficult to measure in absolute • You use a face-to-face interview HSE guide to measuring health
terms. What you can do is take a approach like appreciative enquiry, & safety performance at:
snapshot in time. This is often called where you ask people to tell you hse.gov.uk/opsunit/perfmeas.
the ‘safety climate’. what’s good or what they like. pdf
OUT OF
ORDER
As detailed in the Equality Act (2010) places of employment, schools, clubs, shops, offices
and public buildings must provide adequate access and egress facilities for all persons with
disabilities who may enter or exit a building.
Come together
Join the debate:
Process safety performance in
What do you think about
the high hazard industry is being
topical health, safety or
threatened by the interminable
environmental issues?
rise of the silo factor – an inability
E publications@britsafe.org
within process safety management
@britsafe
(PSM) circles to collaborate and be
consistent across all departments
in an organisation.
Letter of the month The silo factor occurs when different
parties think more about optimising their
The human factor own area of responsibility and less about
optimising the overall organisation’s PSM
ethical standards.
performance. Effective performance
Historically, human factors
of the PSM system, however, can only
(ergonomics), which provides a
be achieved through integrated and
scientific approach to human-
collaborative thinking and processes
centred design, applying
that encourage a constant focus on
physiological and psychological
major accident hazards (MAHs).
principles to optimise the balance of
This is the principal finding of a
people’s strengths and limitations,
research project carried out by ABB’s
has played an important part in
global engineering and consultancy
the design of human-centred
group. In the study (tinyurl.com/
systems but its contribution has
Photograph: iStock/muratsenel kk3cp2t), we identified common
often been too limited and too
PSM weaknesses which include
Automation, informatics, robotics, late in the design process to have
factors such as inadequate testing of
sensors and mobile devices are a real impact. The CIEHF believes
safeguards and poor understanding of
transforming our workplaces and that now is the time to bring this
hazards. In most cases the weaknesses
it’s exciting to consider the potential approach to the fore. Suggestions
identified were in some way a result of
these technologies have to improve from MEPs, for example, that
silo approaches to PSM with different
our world. robot designers could include ‘kill’
departments not integrating effectively.
However, we must advance switches so that robots can be
The process safety implications of
with care; there are significant turned off in emergencies would be
the weaknesses identified are clear
challenges emerging around a step in the right direction.
instances of people performing safety
human interaction with robots Humans come in all shapes and
critical tasks without understanding
and robot design, which need our sizes and, unlike machines, bring
the significance of the tasks and
attention, particularly in terms of high levels of unpredictability in
hazards they are protecting against;
health and safety. It is important their responses and behaviour.
protective systems not designed with
to remember that human skills Humans are able to respond to
an adequate understanding of the scale
will remain essential for many unusual or unexpected situations,
of consequences they need to protect
tasks, necessitating a harmonious and contribute towards the
against; and management systems not
marriage between humans resilience of a system. So, as
identifying and rectifying shortcomings.
and machines. workforces become more mobile,
To avoid silo thinking, the process
The Chartered Institute of diverse, and dependent on
industry must address three main areas.
Ergonomics and Human Factors technology, human factors can
Accountability and oversight – who in
(CIEHF) agrees with Members in ensure inclusive design of robots
the organisation is accountable for the
the European Parliament (MEPs) and intelligent systems to improve
overall management of process safety?
who have recently suggested that their capability for interpreting
Communication – what needs to be
a robust European legal framework and responding to human operator
communicated to and by each party?
around the development of requirements.
Simplification – how to simplify PSM and
Robotics and Artificial Intelligence The application of human
pass on the information everyone needs
is urgently needed (tinyurl.com/ factors in design activities must
in ways that they can understand?
z52gp4h). MEPs are calling for therefore be prioritised to ensure
PSM can be complex and some
a European Agency for robotics we are creating robots that can
elements of it technically challenging,
and a Code of Ethical Content to effectively and safely work and
but many functions and people within an
regulate who should be accountable interact with people.
organisation need only simple messages.
for the social, environmental and —
—
human health impacts of robotics Sarah Sharples
Conrad Ellison
and ensure that they operate in Past president
Principal EHS consultant
accordance with legal, safety and CIEHF
ABB Consulting
If you have good safety management system in place and want to achieve the next
level of excellence then let us be your partner in your next Organisaonal Culture
and Individual Development programme.
We are
with a swing
which society creates for us. It made
me think of health and safety as a much
broader issue than just following specific
procedures. It’s much more complex,
“The British Safety Council has a Mark Kermode and British Safety especially when related to mental health.
great spirit,” said Mike Robinson, Council members and friends, enjoyed Everyone should be aware of their own
chief executive, speaking at a splendid evening of history and health and safety.”
the gala film night held on 23 thought-provoking debate. Finalists from around the world
Five films by young people made also spoke of the value of exchanging
March to celebrate 60 years of
to address the British Safety Council culturally-formed ideas on the nature of
the organisation’s rich history.
competition brief on ‘Risk’ were risk. Nikhil Sudersanan, a finalist for his
“The night’s celebrations clearly
screened. Winners, selected out of film Inertia, set in an Indian marketplace,
demonstrate that we have a lot
nearly 50 entries, expressed their said people approached him on the night
to feel proud of, as well as many
delight at the opportunity as well as the to say they had been amazed to see
challenges and opportunities to
chance to shape discussions around animals being slaughtered on film. “They
address as we look forward to
what health and safety means today. said they hadn’t seen how chickens
the next 60 years.”
Kate Haley, student at Trinity College, are killed. Then I came to know about
The buzz at the Regents cinema, Dublin, Ireland, a finalist for her film Risk the frozen chicken culture in western
London showed how true Mike’s told in an ingenious first person style countries where meat is available in
words were, as young film competition poetry narrative, said: “I really thought supermarkets in its frozen form. I felt we
winners, the evening’s host, film critic about what you risk as a female and could exchange something culturally.”
He added: “We truly enjoyed the night, as a health and safety exemplar, but explored the big issues of the day
our first experience of entering an which this year reported more fatalities in film via interviews with thought
international competition. Making the by itself than in the whole of the UK leaders in health and safety. Sir Cary
final became news in Kerala, our state construction sector. He said: “Outside Cooper, Professor of organisational
in India and people were eagerly asking the UK the challenge is immense and psychology and health at Manchester
us to show it to them.” in some countries, it resembles the University provided refreshing views
position the UK was in 60 years ago. on topics including the gig economy,
Our work is far from complete.” mechanisation and stress. “We don’t
The night also included the have rest and recuperation away from
We truly enjoyed the night, our premiere of British Safety Council at technology. We’re on the smart phones
first experience of entering an 60, made by Matthew Holder, head of all the time,” he warned as one of the
international competition biggest issues. It took the audience
campaigns. It explored the history of
back to the winning young person’s
the organisation and safety’s changing
film, Me MiPhone and I, which showed
times through fascinating archive
the isolating and corrosive powers of
material; workmen tiptoeing along the
new technology.
The presence of a young Indian edge of buildings without hard hats
filmmaker had a greater relevance and fall protection, group activities
for the night. At the press conference for young people to think about safety To watch all the films shown
journalists heard of the British Safety and bold campaigning work to raise on the night, visit the British
Council’s aims to open an office in safety’s profile, including taking an Safety Council’s YouTube
India. Mike Robinson had expressed elephant to parliament. channel here:
his shock at visiting an Indian company The event also looked to the www.youtube.com/user/
recently, which locally was regarded future. Future Risk: the next 60 years britishsafetycouncil/videos
Insecure work has been linked to increased stress and undermining of dignity in the workplace. Photograph: iStock/Malombra76
A sense of
insecure workers in the UK are
unhappy, unhealthy or feel worse off
than their employee cohorts. As will
be seen in these testimonies from five
insecurity
individuals who fall into the category
of insecure worker, many relish the
freedoms of their unstructured working
life. Indeed, an-ex teacher describes
how as an employee he experienced
Insecure work is on the rise. We take a far more stress in that role than he
does today as a self-employed person.
look at what it feels like to be an insecure Equally, there is dissatisfaction.
worker through a series of interviews. An Uber driver explains how at first
he loved his job, but feels disillusioned
by issues over his self-employed status,
Gig work is thought to have been as insecure workers, an increase of showing how question marks over
coined in the 1920s by jazz club 25% since a decade ago according status and rights can eat into identity
musicians. Now, gig working and to the Trade Union Congress (TUC). and wellbeing.
other forms of insecure work have Its December 2016 report, Living on The TUC and Matthew Taylor, chief
less carefree associations. Anxiety, the Edge, identified three groups of executive of the Royal Society for the
exploitation and denial of basic precarious or insecure workers; those encouragement of Arts, Manufactures
rights such as holiday and sickness in low paid self-employment, ‘gig and Commerce are separately
pay are far from the freedoms of its workers’ (often defined as independent gathering testimonies to better
linguistic origins. contractors doing temporary, flexible understand the issues in order to make
Insecure work is also a big concern jobs) and zero hour-contract workers. proposals for changes in laws over
because it’s on the rise. Today, one Yet, despite the serious concerns, workers’ rights to government. These
in 10 working people are defined it cannot be said that all 3.2 million interviews aim to add to that insight.
Mick says confusion over his self-employed status has left him feeling stressed and powerless. Photograph: iStock/Geber86
Lara*, agency worker, education motivates them or what their skills are,
and slowly the young person will fade
I feel rather lonely most days. I miss the while confidence and anything that
I’m 28 and I work with an
interaction of meeting new people. person once stood for is near extinct.
agency to get teacher supply
The agency is great and keep me We start to close off.
work in schools. My ambition is
posted often, but working in two I’m getting support though the
to get a full time job as a school
schools a week can make it difficult to Young Women’s Trust, which represents
counsellor. I love working with
feel part of a community. If I’m lucky, I’ll women like me struggling to live on
children and the energy and
work with great teachers and we learn low or no pay. I’ve met similar women
positivity they exude – I learn
from each other. But, you are treated like myself and been able to talk about
something new every time I’m
differently from full time workers. When everything from how I feel to what I’ve
given the chance of a full day’s been through. Having people who want
work. But although I love the you come into the workplace you are
automatically eyed up because we to genuinely help is great and it has
field I’m in, I’m struggling to opened my eyes to feeling positive.
secure full time hours. wear different ID cards with different
coloured straps. You are not always *Not her real name.
Since moving from London to Norfolk, expected to go to certain meetings.
my agency has found me work at a When I was younger and starting
primary school and a special needs out in education as a nursery assistant,
school, which cover all school ages. I was paid way below what I should
I speak to the agency every few days. have been earning. Right now, even
On the very odd occasion I will get a call though I’m older, I’m still struggling
in the morning and I will be needed right – wondering when I’ll ever be able to
there and then. It’s not been easy but afford a mortgage or be able to start a
it has allowed me to gain full working family makes it even harder. It feels like
days and some good experience. I’m nowhere near being able to do that.
My main worry is getting enough I think employers should nurture
hours to cover the rent and contribute young people in their work more.
towards living costs. Otherwise it’s So many young people suffer from
a real struggle and puts a strain on insecurities, and that first job affects
my relationship. your confidence in progressing
I have no family or friends where I live upwards. Managers want to squeeze
now, so I rely on work to give me that every bit of work out of a young person
social life. Despite having a great partner and not actually want to know what Photograph iStock/DGLimages
No excuse for
ignoring stress
Billy O’Brien part manufacturer £200,000 in fines counselling phone lines and onsite
Director of customer success and costs in November 2016. Mental massage are nice to have, providing
Effective Software wellbeing needs to be taken seriously. these as a first step is the equivalent of
According to HSE work-related providing dust-masks and gardening
We are all different, and all
stress is responsible for 45% of all gloves without considering the types of
respond differently to stressors;
working days lost to ill health, while respiratory or handling hazards people
some people thrive on high
it is estimated that the number of are facing, or whether there is a better
workloads, tight deadlines and
deaths from suicide in the construction way to control the hazards at source.
a busy work life, while others industry could be 10 times higher than While we, of course, are all different
will crumble. those from fatal accidents at work. in our response to stressors, HSE
However, using that as an excuse to The tried and tested approach to have identified six headings under
do nothing about it is like saying that stress recommended by HSE is one that which workplace stress hazards can
some people are stronger than others, traditional safety managers will recognise: be grouped. To make this personal,
or doing nothing about unreasonable identify the hazards and who will be we have considered this from the
manual handling requirements. That harmed, assess the risks, and control perspective of a health and safety
kind of thinking cost one car engine the causes of harm. While yoga classes, manager’s own stress levels.
Demands You are frequently required to work Your workload is achievable within
longer hours than contracted, and agreed hours of work, and you are
you are expected to carry out risk given time to develop your skills.
assessments for technical areas You have the resources to bring in
outside your expertise specialists for areas outside your
current skill set
Control You are not allowed to leave half- You can plan your work, and you are
an hour early for a school parents’ happy to work longer hours when
evening, but expected to work late it is needed, provided you can also
with no advance notice chose which days to leave early to
manage family commitments
Support You are expected to make a report You are expected to make a report
on accidents to the board, but on accidents to the board, and the
department heads ignore your departments send you their data in
requests for information and the plenty of time. IT provide proactive
IT system keeps crashing. You are support to make sure systems can
criticised by your line manager for cope with the extra workload
missing the deadline
Role As the safety advisor, you are made A line manager is asked to review the Photograph: iStock/Electra-K-Vasileiadou
responsible for the implementation of actions arising from a risk assessment
your recommendations, even though and to determine which can be
Excellent and free resources are
you have no control over the staff implemented and which might need
who must implement them further consideration or support available to help you carry out your
stress risk assessment, including a
Change You hear rumours of cost cutting, A company-wide meeting is held to
35-item questionnaire that can be
and assume that safety is likely to explain forthcoming changes, after
be the first area to suffer. You start which your line manager invites
distributed to all your staff. If you
looking at job advert websites in your you to discuss if you could take on haven’t considered stress at work yet,
lunch hour additional responsibilities this is a good place to start.
When it comes to
Training schemes designed by
experts for the qualified crane
specialists of tomorrow
training, follow
the world leader.
Based at its state-of-the-art UK headquarters in
Biggleswade, Bedfordshire, Liebherr Training Services offers
a wide range of statutory courses that ensure compliance
with Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations
(LOLER) 1998 and British Standards for the safe use of
cranes (BS 7121 range) including:
1 OR 2 DAY CRANE
LICCON PLANNER
APPRECIATION
sm.britsafe.org
My first proper
and cool job
Andy Slaughter as success and earned me a reprieve for
Labour MP for Hammersmith another week.
Once, with our brilliant graphic artist –
This article comes with a yes we had one of those too, in fact two I
health and safety warning. think– I designed a cartoon strip warning
It is recollecting events of 35 against the dangers of fireworks. James
years ago and, therefore, much suggested we expanded it to make direct
comparison with the Falklands War. It
that should be remembered is
worked. I think we made page two of
forgotten and much that should
some tabloids, but not in a good way. I
be forgotten is remembered. hid in Riverside for a couple of days, but
But it remains the truth that employment James was delighted.
as the British Safety Council’s press I only lasted just over a year at
officer was the first ‘proper’ job I ever the British Safety Council, though I
had. Leaving Exeter University in 1982 am still in contact with some of my
with an English degree was not perhaps contemporaries. It was not the polished
The British Safety Council office is located at and professional organisation it is now.
the best entry into the employment
Hammersmith, Andy’s borough.
market, then in the middle of one of But it was fun. I hope it still is.
Margaret Thatcher’s (this is hurting you First jobs leave a lasting impression,
The founder, guru and dominant and I will always be grateful to the
far more than it is hurting me) recessions.
personality in its four decades has organisation for introducing me to the
I was delighted to get a job almost
become a legend. Tye created the world of work, for knocking a little of
immediately when most of my
organisation and put it on the map. And the pretentiousness off and for paying
contemporaries were signing on or
crucial to that was his understanding me the sum of £4,500 a year.
working in pubs, and pleased also to
of what makes people sit up and pay I’m delighted the British Safety
have one that was local (my family not
attention. In a rather staid and formal Council has stayed in Hammersmith
having moved from the Borough of
world, James Tye, with his bow tie, and has grown in size and reputation
Hammersmith & Fulham for a century
Trumpesque management style and over the past 30 years. Its creation
or more) but still sounded quite cool,
love of the good life, was a revelation. marked the sea-change in culture
as we said then.
And when I said I was the press that led to safety in the workplace
officer, what I actually mean is that becoming a priority after the 1974 Act.
I was one of about 10 people in the When I was shadow justice minister,
British Safety Council communications I will always be grateful to for six years until last summer, I often
department. Others included Charlie
the British Safety Council for met insurers or policy wonks who tried to
Leadbeater and Michael Harrison,
introducing me to the world persuade me that we no longer needed
later leading journalists at the FT and
of work and for knocking a little or could afford the legal and institutional
Independent respectively. Mark Wheeler,
of the pretentiousness off protections against accidents at work or
who went on to be a senior press person elsewhere built up in the past 40 years.
I politely disagreed, and did so
at the HSE, ran the information ‘hotline’.
with the knowledge I had somehow
There were ex-Fleet Street pros, hustlers,
absorbed in the sometimes chaotic,
and the wonderful Colin Fletcher, the I lost count of the times my boss would
always stimulating environment of
in-house photographer with a view of say, make sure James doesn’t see
Chancellor’s Road circa 1982.
life that Raymond Chandler would have you today, as he wants to sack you.
I wish the British Safety Council a
found sardonic. Traumatic at first, this became routine. I
very happy 60th birthday.
Why, you may ask, did the British would disappear with Colin to the bar at
Safety Council need a comms Riverside Studios and wait – sometimes
department that was larger than many several hours – until the coast was clear. Andy Slaughter MP at the
of its other ‘proper’ functions, including The remedy was to get James into launch of our manifesto
sales, training and membership. The the national press – it didn’t matter Working Well in 2012:
answer to this question, and to almost any which paper, or even if the story was w ww.youtube.com/
other there in the 1980s was: James Tye. good or bad. Coverage is what counted watch?v=MZy5IFdyMGY
HOSP ITA LS
POWER
PUB LIC B UILDINGS
S CHOOLS
S HOPPING CENT RE S
SG4 FREESTANDING
GUARDRAIL SYSTEM
Unique patented lifting shoe
Safe, secure and cost effective flat roof edge protection
SERIOUS
NOISE
REDUCTION
TM
ON WHITE ON BLACK
EUROPEAN
MANUFACTURER
uksales@jsp.co.uk www.jsp.co.uk
KM 662534
BS EN 352-1
PAT
IN G
TED
PAT
D
DES
DES
DES
D
RE
RE
GN E GN
RE
E GN
REGIST REGIST E
I
REGIST
I
Feature
Post Brexit there may be some divergence in the laws applicable in the UK and EU, but the UK will be keen to maintain its profile as the standard
bearer for health and safety matters. Photograph: iStock/xavierarnau
Brexit: knowns
having one of the best combined
health and safety records in Europe
and the world. When the EU’s Health
and Safety Directive was introduced
and unknowns
in 1989, the UK had few alterations to
make to its national laws to bring it in
line. The Corporate Manslaughter and
Corporate Homicide Act 2007, another
Laura Cameron cornerstone of our system, is also
Partner wholly derived from the UK.
Pinsent Masons LLP Since achieving membership of the
EU, a series of individual directives
focusing on specific aspects of safety
By the end of March 2019 the UK will no and health at work have been issued
at European level and transposed into
longer be part of the European Union, that UK law. Until repealed or otherwise
much is clear. Beyond that, much remains amended, such legislation (as with
other legislation emanating from the
little more than speculation. UK Parliament) will remain unaffected
after withdrawal. Insofar as laws derive
from directly applicable EU regulations,
Unravelling the UK’s membership and safety regulation in the UK.
the UK government has promised a
of the EU will not be an end to the The foundation of the current health
Great Repeal Bill designed to ensure
matter of course. Perhaps more and safety regulatory system was
the status quo post exit.
significant will be the negotiations established totally independently of On the whole, the UK is seen as the
to agree new trading relationships, the EU by the Health and Safety at ‘gold standard’ in health and safety
customs controls, immigration etc. Work Act (HSWA) 1974. The legislation matters – witness the minimal impact
What effect, if any, could these has at its heart a simple but enduring of the imposition of the Offshore Safety
negotiations have on health and principle – those who create risks are Directive – with HSE generally agreed
safety law in the UK? best placed to control them. to be an effective regulator, whose
In previous publications we have The system has stood the test expertise is sought overseas.
pointed to the long tradition of health of time and has resulted in the UK As a result, UK workers and their
representatives have come to to protect workers’ rights. The detail of regulations and the stripping away
expect certain standards and, more this remains to be seen and some, for of others, a wholesale lowering of
importantly, that these standards will example the TUC, have voiced concern standards is unlikely. On the contrary,
be maintained and indeed improved. at the UK government’s apparent if we wish to continue to trade with
Over time, of course, certain laws may reluctance to give more guarantees the EU, the likelihood is that standards
well be looked at afresh but wholesale on workers’ rights, including those will at the very least require to be
change is dependent on political will in relation to health and safety, post maintained. Outside of the European
and is likely to prove unpopular. Nor Brexit, citing the fact that the EU’s trade structures, the UK will be free
is there credible evidence to support Health and Safety Framework Directive to regulate or deregulate as it sees fit;
contentions that there is material forces employers to assess and act to
however, the impact on health and
over-regulation in this area and reduce workplace risks. As we have
safety-related legislation is likely to
insofar as there can be a reduction, seen, however, many such duties
be limited due to political and social
without a lowering of standards, that here emanate not from EU legislation
realities and the UK government’s
is happening, not only in the UK via its but from our own HSWA. In so far as
white paper states that “this
Red tape challenge, but in the EU too they have their foundations in the EU,
Government has committed not only
via the ongoing Regulatory Fitness and many laws of significance are now so
to safeguard the rights of workers
Performance Programme. embedded here as it to be very difficult
set out in European legislation, but
While in the future there may be to see any real appetite for, or prospect
some divergence in the laws applicable of, their removal. to enhance them”.
in the UK and EU, the UK will be keen Will there be a race to the bottom as Moreover, businesses appreciate
to maintain its profile as the standard the UK scrambles to form alternative the value of a robust health and safety
bearer for health and safety matters. relationships with trading partners? management system. Not only does
In its white paper The United Kingdom’s While disengagement from the EU may it make sense from a reputational
exit from, and new partnership with, the well involve a process of determining perspective, but it also makes sense
European Union the UK government which primary and secondary health economically – increasingly hefty fines
has set out its guiding priorities as it and safety legislation remains socially for breaches of the HSWA look set
approaches negotiations to exit the EU. or economically useful to the UK, to continue and production days lost
Key among them is the commitment potentially leading to changes to some through ill health are difficult to recover.
Contact us:
T +44 (0)20 3510 3510
sm.britsafe.org/level1-construction
/britishsafetycouncil
@britsafe
www.linkedin.com
MQ152
There is increasing pressure for businesses to face up to their responsibilities from both a moral and legal perspective. Photograph: iStock/Liuser
Slaves of
intentions, auditing a supply chain with
multiple suppliers can be so complex,
confidently identifying and eliminating
our times
the use of slave labour can present a
serious challenge.
The BBC Panorama programme
aired in October last year which
discovered Syrian refugees working
Danny Hobson illegally in Turkey for major brands,
Ethical and quality improvement manager many of whom were proponents of
Arco ethical trading, is a case in point. The
fact that slave labour has been found
so readily within the supply chain of
Modern day slavery is surprisingly prevalent companies who are proactive in trying
in the supply chain, that is why is crucial to to outlaw this kind of practice shows
just how inherent the problem is and
build a robust approach to ethical supply how much work is there to be done.
and inspire others to make a difference. Thankfully there is increasing
pressure for businesses to face up to
their responsibilities from both a moral
Tamil Nadu is the powerhouse of regular victims of bonded labour. and legal perspective. The Modern
India’s textile industry and accounts The women millworkers experience Slavery Act, which was introduced in
for 20% of the country’s total many forms of ill treatment, including 2015 to consolidate laws covering the
export of ready-made garments.
excessive working hours, poor living issue of slavery in the UK, now also
Housing 58% of India’s textile mills,
conditions in hostels, and illness includes provisions for supply chains.
the state of Tamil Nadu employs
caused by exposure to cotton dust. The Transparency in Supply Chain
over 1.02 million workers in the
Withholding wages and paying below Provisions require businesses which
garment sector, most of whom are
minimum wage is common practice, have an annual turnover above £36m
subject to severe labour exploitation
while workers have no access to to publish a statement which confirms
and dangerous conditions. As
grievance mechanisms. the steps taken to mitigate the risk that
the world’s second largest textile
The examples and figures make slavery and human trafficking are in
exporter, India’s garments find their
startling reading but unfortunately their business or supply chain.
way into supply chains around the
globe, including the UK. it is still too easy for companies
21m
Tamil Nadu, in the southernmost and consumers to turn a blind eye.
part of India, is just one example of Many consumers are unaware of the
the international crime of modern conditions under which the goods
victims of forced labour globally
day slavery. The workforce is they buy have been produced and
(ILO 2012)
predominantly female and many are even when businesses have good
A supply chain reaction to resolve breeches of national and • If your supplier has a turnover in
At Arco we pride ourselves on our local laws and the ETI Base Code. The the UK greater than £36m and falls
ethical supply policy and we are corrective action plans are managed by under the Modern Slavery Act,
committed to making a difference. As the Arco Product Assurance Team, Arco review their published statement
well as meeting our obligations in line Xiamen team (based in China) and the • Be sure about your own supply
with these provisions, we promote manufacturers themselves. chain by using suppliers that are
ethical trade within the supply of safety In the first instance it is always members of the Ethical Trading
products. In the same way as we drive preferable to try and help a supplier Initiative or equivalent organisations.
improvements in quality standards raise their standards. As well as The task of auditing a complex supply
across our industry through investment improving working conditions for chain with multiple suppliers can be
in product testing and assurance, Arco staff, this can benefit the supplier by arduous. By ensuring you only work
is also taking action to raise standards helping them to win more contracts with ethical suppliers it is peace of
throughout our supply chain when and compete more effectively for mind for procurement teams.
it comes to ethical trading; we call it international business. Examples of
starting a supply chain reaction. how Arco has helped its suppliers ETI Base Code (nine points)
Arco is a member of the Ethical improve employee wellbeing include 1. Employment is freely chosen
Trading Initiative (ETI), a leading helping them to provide better dining 2. Freedom of association and
alliance of companies, trade unions
and hygiene facilities and instigating the right to collective bargaining
and NGOs that promotes respect for
training programmes to improve are respected
workers’ rights around the globe. The
employee morale and engagement.
ETI’s aim is to improve the lives of 3. Working conditions are
Any supplier failing seriously or
workers by eradicating exploitation safe and hygienic
consistently to adhere to the standards
and discrimination. Arco joined the ETI 4. Child labour shall not be used
detailed in the Ethical Guide for
in 2007 and remains the first and only 5. Living wages are paid
Vendors document will be removed
safety distributor to be a member. 6. Working hours are not excessive
from the approved supplier list.
7. No discrimination is practiced
Supplier ethical compliance
What can you do? 8. Regular employment is provided
Arco has created a process to ensure
If you are concerned about unethical 9. No harsh or inhumane treatment
the ethical compliance and capabilities
practices or slave labour in your supply is allowed.
of all suppliers manufacturing products
chain there are a number of steps you
which carry an Arco brand. This is in
can take:
line with the ETI Base Code, which
• Ask your suppliers about their
is founded on the conventions of the
supply chain and the factories Film on modern slavery at:
International Labour Organisation (ILO)
providing your goods www.arco.co.uk/startyours
and is an internationally recognised
code of labour practice. • Ask your suppliers about their Transparency in supply chains.
Before any product is made, ethical assurance measures and Modern Slavery Act at:
suppliers must commit to Arco’s due diligence processes tinyurl.com/keaaqgf
Ethical Compliance Procedure which
ensures they have the capability and
systems to meet the requirements of the
ETI Base Code. When a supplier wishes
to use subcontractors or outworkers
for Arco production, then this must be
approved in advance by the company.
It is the supplier’s obligation to provide
evidence that any subcontractor
or outworker used conforms to the
standards outlined in the Ethical Guide
for Vendors document.
Ethical auditing
Manufacturers of Arco own label
products are appraised using a risk
based approach. Factory assessments
are conducted by one of the world
leading social compliance audit
companies or by Arco employees
who have been trained by the ETI in
the application of the ETI Base Code.
Factories are assessed for ethical Asking your providers about their supply chain standards helps to promote ethical trading.
compliance and corrective plans agreed iStock/Photobos
Web-based permit to work systems can improve your management control. Photograph: iStock/lovro77
Expert Panel
• Simon Colvin, Partner and National Head
of Environment Team, Weightmans LLP
• Stephanie Taylor, Sustainability
Associate Director, Mace Group
• Tom Shields, Health and Safety
Coach, Mount Anvil
• British Safety Council experts. Find out more:
T +44 (0)20 3510 8355
The event includes a Q&A session E customer.service@britsafe.org
followed by a networking lunch www.britsafe.org/events
/britishsafetycouncil
to share best practice.
@britsafe
/company/british-safety-council
In his first year with the company, while working Ravi has joined the transportation infrastructure Ajay is playing a crucial role in the ocean
as an engineering apprentice, Ben sustained project as a diploma trainee almost two years tanker discharge and loading operations at
injuries to his hand. Following this incident, ago. Since then he has been very active in EHS Mangalore Terminal ensuring highest standards
Ben took a proactive approach to improving work, leading by example and encouraging his of safety and welfare of employees. He has
safety in his work environment and soon was colleagues to follow. He also initiated various implemented the following safety initiatives: no
asked to take a greater role within the SHE initiatives in the interest of internal and external entry to hazardous areas without safety shoe
function. Initially he became a SHE champion stakeholders. For example, he organised a blood and helmet, wearing of a full body harness
for the shop floor in one of the facilities. His donation, health check-up and eye check-up while working at height, carrying VHF while
responsibilities included implementing the camps for local villagers. He has also initiated on operational duty, job safety analysis for
HSL Safety Climate tool in the area, as well a road safety campaign to create awareness non-routine jobs and work permit for all jobs
as creating and delivering training sessions among the road users. He has also taken undertaken at hazardous area. His contribution
on improved workshop practices. Ben has theinitiative to conduct multiple awareness to housekeeping of the site made it one of
implemented a behavioural safety programme training programmes for school children’s and the best maintained sites in the company,
across the business and improved the educated them about traffic rules. benefitting the wellbeing of the employees and
communication of SHE across all functions. resulting in zero near miss incidents in that area.
Senior foreman Project engineering management, project leader Project director of Doha Festival City
Bachy Soletanche GlaxoSmithKline – Irvine Mace International, Qatar
Andrew, who has been employed by the Colin, Project Leader in charge of all projects On Qatar’s largest commercial development,
company for over 20 years, is heavily and construction activities at Irvine, looks after Doha Festival City, with a workforce of over
involved in the development and mentoring 250 staff. Using his safety knowledge of the 9,000, H&S was a priority for Innes. He
of new apprentices. Under his guidance new operation process, he has established a safety established a common set of health, safety
piling operatives gain experience in hazard culture with no RIDDOR lost time for the last and welfare standards and communicated
identification and safety operating techniques ten years. Colin has been leading the quarterly these to all stakeholders before anyone set
of high risk equipment. Andrew is also involved safety forums and inspired people to talk about foot on site. One of his biggest challenges
in the mentoring of new supervisors following their own health issues, such as stress in the was the different health and safety cultures
promotion, assisting them in learning their workplace. Colin led the behavioural safety and awareness levels on a site of this size
new responsibilities and planning of their review of the construction group, helping to and this region. He led two-way discussions
work. Andrew assists the group SHEQ team in identify needs and issues for the site that led that forged strong collaborative working
the development on new guidance notes and to the creation of the PEM 2017 safety plan. relationships with a shared goal and focus on
safe system of works and is involved in their One of its outcomes was the relocation of wellbeing. Innes conducts regular leadership
ongoing review. Throughout his career Andrew the contractor’s village, which will result in a tours, safety meetings and workshops that help
has submitted a variety of innovations which purpose-built site with safety meeting rooms him to engage with the team and reward best
have been implemented in the UK company and for personnel to use as stress-free zones. performance. Over three years, the project has
across the parent company worldwide. had zero lost time or reportable injuries and has
achieved 50 million safe man-hours.
Sector awards
The International Safety Awards scheme, now in its 59th year, celebrates organisations from
around the world that have demonstrated, to the satisfaction of the scheme’s independent judges,
their commitment to preventing work-related injuries and ill health during the 2016 calendar year.
The shortlisted organisations by sector are:
We do for
Health & Safety
what
Steve Jobs
did for mobile phones
We’ve taken Health & Safety and
re-engineered it using the latest technology,
making Safety PAL the only app that really
protects people and prevents fines.
Event round-up
Free SHE
webinars
planned
for 2017
The webinars will explore various SHE management issues. Photograph: iStock/anyaberkut
The British Safety Council is running safety performance. The webinar will be and Garry Cornell, environmental
a series of free webinars exploring presented by David Parr, head of audit auditors and consultants at the
important recent developments and technical services at the British British Safety Council. It will outline
around safety, health and Safety Council, who is a member of the some of the challenges and solutions
environmental (SHE) management HS1 committee which acts as the forum to carrying out an internal audit of
standards, legislation and policies for UK consultation on the ISO 45001 an organisation’s environmental
affecting UK businesses. standard. David says : “We will look management system. The webinar
The webinars will run for at the main requirements of the new is aimed at anyone responsible for
approximately one hour and will standard and outline how organisations undertaking internal audits to assess
be presented by the British Safety certificated under the existing OHSAS compliance with the international
Council’s own health, safety and 18001 standard can begin to prepare for environmental management standard
environmental experts and a guest the transition to ISO 45001.” ISO 14001:2015 – for example, prior
environmental lawyer. to a formal certification visit by an
Environmental policy update
SHE auditing services The third webinar, on Wednesday 7 June, independent auditor.
The first webinar will take place on will provide an overview of some key Energy management
Monday 22 May and will provide an recent and possible developments to The final webinar in the schedule will
overview of the British Safety Council’s UK environmental policy and legislation take place on Wednesday 2 August
range of SHE auditing services. It will affecting UK businesses. It will be and will focus on the benefits of
explain how a British Safety Council delivered by Howard Dawes, senior implementing an energy management
best practice Five Star audit can environmental consultant at the British system to either comply with or mirror
help both to assess the effectiveness Safety Council, and Simon Colvin, partner the ISO 50001 international energy
of an organisation’s existing SHE and national head of the environment
management standard.
management systems and identify and team at Weightmans law firm.
Howard Dawes will present the
support improvements in overall SHE Howard says: “We will consider
webinar alongside Alistair Walker, an
performance. the potential implications of Brexit
environmental auditor and consultant
The second webinar will take place on the UK’s future environmental
at the British Safety Council.
on Tuesday 6 June and will explore laws, provide an update on recent
Howard says: “We will explain the
some of the likely requirements of environmental policy and legislative
benefits of an energy management
the forthcoming new international developments and give an overview
system and some of the key requirements
health and safety management system of the 2014 sentencing guidelines for
for managing energy usage in the context
standard, ISO 45001. The new standard environmental offences for England
of a changing regulatory landscape.”
will provide a single, internationally and Wales.”
agreed framework for organisations The fifth webinar will take place
of all types and sizes who wish to on Thursday 6 July and will be To register go to:
continually improve their health and presented by Keith Whitehead w ww.britsafe.org/webinars
required
casellasolutions.com
A range of water-
resistant, high
visibility clothing
for workers in
Take a break
industries such as Mobile staff welfare vehicles built
rail, infrastructure, upon the base chassis of commercial
civil engineering and utilities has been vehicles such as vans are available
launched by Pulsar. from Cartwright Conversions. jsp.co.uk
The Evolution range features Customers select their preferred
garments such as storm coats, over make and model of commercial vehicle
trousers and adjustable and removable and Cartwright designs and installs Eye like it
hoods that can be worn over safety the welfare facilities. The standard Specsavers has launched a range of JCB-
helmets. The garments are available layout typically includes a toilet cubicle, branded prescription safety eyewear.
in high visibility orange or yellow and hand-washing facilities, canteen area, The range offers a choice of 20
feature reflective tape to help ensure fire extinguisher, first aid kit, eye wash metal and polycarbonate frames in
the wearer can be seen more easily by station and secure storage for tools and a variety of styles, sizes and colour
colleagues, drivers and plant operators. other items. The conversion also normally combinations. The eyewear ranges
The Evotech three-layer laminate includes the provision of electrical from chunky, wraparound-style glasses
fabric is up to 13 times more water- services such as power supplies, side to more sleek and minimalist options
resistant than required by the relevant and reverse cameras, exterior lighting, and a wide choice of lens materials
standard and the material is completely USB charging points, internal motion- are available. The eyewear is available
wind-resistant. Some of the garments sensing LED lighting and the application through Specsavers’ e-voucher system
include concealed pockets for phones of customer-specific livery. and can be obtained from any of
and radio loops for securing headphone The vehicles overcome the need to Specsavers’ 785 stores across the UK.
wires safely. provide standalone welfare facilities.
s pecsavers.co.uk/corporate/
pulsaruk.com cartwrightconversions.co.uk safety-eyewear/jcb-glasses
ennyhydraulics.com
p
michael-smith-engineers.co.uk totalkare.co.uk
bevangroup.com
Topics include:
• Business benefits of audit
• Legislative trends
• Internal or external auditing
• Which audit product is right for you?
• ISO 45001 developments.
offers advice for those who receive them. at those responsible for the design,
concept
According to the Plant Safety Group, operation and maintenance of guide
the protocol aims to avoid the risk of interlocked guard systems on machines.
A short guide
incorrect, misleading or poorly written They will cover topics such as how to
designed to
safety alerts causing unnecessary ensure interlocks comply with relevant
aid people’s
confusion among MEWP users, European standards and ways of
understanding
manufacturers and hire companies. preventing workers from defeating the
of the basic ideas and principles
devices. They will take place at various
underpinning the discourse about the
locations in England during 2017.
It can be found at: management of health and safety risks
cpa.uk.net/sfpsgpublications has been published by RoSPA.
To register go to: The booklet explores the meaning
pilz.com/en-GB/company/ of commonly used but sometimes
Working time rights schedules misunderstood terms and concepts
such as hazard, risk, probability and
A short guide to staff rights under the
preventability. It examines topics such as
Working Time Regulations has been
published by TUC.
Roadworks film the ongoing debate on the appropriate
A short film reminding drivers of the extent of risk management and the
The booklet explains the legal limits
danger of speeding though roadworks benefits of firstly attempting to eliminate
on weekly working hours and night
has been produced by Dorset-based or reduce risks at source rather than
working, and workers’ rights to breaks,
rest periods and paid holiday. There charity SafeWise and Wessex Water. relying on training to aviod accidents.
is also guidance on the working time, The video reminds viewers of the According to RoSPA, the guide is a
rest break and holiday rights of young presence of road workers and the handy reference guide to essential terms
people aged under 18. consequences of vehicle accidents and concepts and a useful resource for
to both workers and their families. those teaching health and safety.
Diploma
*For full terms and conditions please visit:
www.britsafe.org/NGC-student-discount-
offer-terms-and-conditions