Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Code-named Blue Tooth for the 10th century Danish king who unified
Denmark, the companies have created a single synchronization protocol to
address end-user problems arising from the proliferation of various mobile
devices -- including smart phones, smart pagers, PDAs, handheld PCs,
copiers, printers, notebooks, and many future digital appliances at home --
that need to keep data consistent from one device to another.
Since the start of this initiative in 1998, interest in Bluetooth has grown
tremendously - signified by 1800 members of Bluetooth consortium by mid
2000.While Bluetooth consortium demonstrated prototype products in the
1999-2000, there are no production-quality enduser products using blue tooth
technology as of now, as far as we know. Component products (radios and
chips) that can be integrated into finished products have started becoming
available from Ericsson and others. However, here is an opportunity for more
start-up companies. irDA is a competing technology and has been
implemented in many products for over 6-7 years now but BlueTooth has a
few distinct advantages - with Ericsson/Microsoft/Intel team behind it. In our
opinion, there are relative benefits with several competing technologies - there
is some overlap too. Let competitive products thrive so that we the users get
the best solutions.
What is Bluetooth?
"Think of a connected world of electronic devices and appliances around you!
You click on an icon for a device and you are linked to it, automatically and
transparently"
Each device has a unique 48-bit address from the IEEE 802 standard.
Connections can be point-to-point or multipoint. The maximum range is 10
meters but can be extended to 100 meters by increasing the power. Bluetooth
devices are protected from radio interference by changing their frequencies
arbitrarily upto a maximum of 1600 times a second, a technique known as
frequency hopping. They also use three different but complimentary error
correction schemes. Built-in encryption and verification is provided.
Moreover, Bluetooth devices won't drain precious battery life. The Bluetooth
specification targets power consumption of the device from a "hold" mode
consuming 30 micro amps to the active transmitting range of 8-30 milliamps
(or less than 1/10th of a watt). The radio chip consumers only 0.3mA in
standby mode, which is less than 3 % of the power used by a standard mobile
phone. The chips also have excellent power-saving features, as they will
automatically shift to a low-power mode as soon as traffic volume lessens or
stops.
Modes of operation
An interesting aspect of the technology is the instant formation of networks
once the bluetooth devices come in range to each other. A piconet is a
collection of devices connected via Bluetooth technology in an ad hoc fashion.
A Piconet can be a simple connection between two devices or more than two
devices. Multiple independent and non-synchronized piconets can form a
scatternet. Any of the devices in a piconet can also be a member of another
by means of time multiplexing. i.e a device can be a part of more than one
piconet by suitably sharing the time. The Bluetooth system supports both
point-to-point and point-to-multi-point connections. When a device is
connected to another device it is a point to point connection. If it is connected
to more that one (upto 7 ) it is a point to multipoint connection. Several
piconets can be established and linked together ad hoc, where each piconet
is identified by a different frequency hopping sequence. All users participating
on the same piconet are synchronized to this hopping sequence. If a device is
connected to more than one piconet it communicates in each piconet using a
different hopping sequence. A piconet starts with two connected devices,
such as a portable PC and cellular phone, and may grow to eight connected
devices. All Bluetooth devices are peer units and have identical
implementations. However, when establishing a piconet, one unit will act as a
master and the other(s) as slave(s) for the duration of the piconet connection.
In a piconet there is a master unit whose clock and hopping sequence are
used to synchronize all other devices in the piconet. All the other devices in a
piconet that are not the master are slave units. A 3-bit MAC address is used
to distinguish between units participating in the piconet. Devices synchronized
to a piconet can enter power-saving modes called Sniff and hold mode, in
which device activity is lowered. Also there can be parked units which are
synchronized but do not have a MAC addresses. These parked units have a 8
bit address, therefore there can be a maximum of 256 parked devices.
Voice channels use either a 64 kbps log PCM or the Continuous Variable
Slope Delta Modulation (CVSD) voice coding scheme, and never retransmit
voice packets. The voice quality on the line interface should be better than or
equal to the 64 kbps log PCM. The CVSD method was chosen for its
robustness in handling dropped and damaged voice samples. Rising
interference levels are experienced as increased background noise: even at
bit error rates up 4%, the CVSD coded voice is quite audible.
• If your digital cameras in Bluetooth enabled, you can send still or video
images from any location to any location without the hassle of
connecting your camera to the mobile phone on the wireline phone.
• Upon arriving at your home, the door automatically unlocks for you, the
entry way lights come on, and the heat is adjusted to your pre-set
preferences.
• With the momentum going at this speed and R&D dollars committed,
we should expect during 2001 a reasonable set of products at silicon
level, chip level and device adapter level that the systems integrators
can utilize in the finished products for enduser devices - from smart
phones to laptops.
• The prices of Bluetooth-enabled components will remain high during
first part of 2001and this will delay widespread adoption. By December,
the prices had come down both as a result of ramp of production but
also due to single chip implementations and general downturn in the
economy.
• Increased competition and production will bring the prices down in
2002.
• Distance limitation of Bluetooth in the first version will limit its use to
close-range applications only. From systems engineering perspective,
we do not see much conflict with wireless LAN applications and
Bluetooth. The former is well-tested technology spanning much longer
distances and higher speed. Let us not get into fruitless arguments and
use appropriate technology where its core applications are. Also,
expect 802.11 wireless LAN adapters to decrease in prices.
• Bluetooth will inevitably go through a phase where real experience will
fall short of the promise it held.
• The number of 1000 plus vendors will shrink to, may be, 100 plus who
will survive the rationalization that will follow in 2002-2003 time frame.
Therefore, stay with vendors who have holding power or those who
have great alliances. Otherwise you will have to say goodbye to your
initial Bluetooth experimentation.
• Security standards for Bluetooth are still in a formative stage. Which
devices talks to which and how do users allow or deny access to other
Bluetooth devices as they approach them is still not clear - it is still
being discussed at SIG level in 802.15 subgroup of IEEE. Therefore,
there is still a gap between the cup that holds Bluetooth Elixir and the
lip that must sip it to reach short-distance connectivity salvation.
Besides Bluetooth many other technologies exist like IrDA, Home RF (SWAP)
that provide similar or related services. A quick glance into their scope and
properties would help putting all of these into perspective. Lets look at the
features of Bluetooth first (for the sake of comparison)
IrDA
IrDA is an international organization that creates and promotes interoperable,
low-cost infrared data interconnection standards. IrDA has a set of protocols
covering all layers of data transfer and in addition has some network
management and interoperability designs. IrDA protocols have IrDA DATA as
the vehicle for data delivery and IrDA CONTROL for sending the control
information. [Feng99] [Williams00] IrDA DATA defines a standard for an
interoperable universal two way cordless infrared light transmission data port.
Adapters now include the traditional upgrades to serial and parallel ports
Features:
• Range: From contact to at least 1metre. Can be extended to 2 meters.
A low power version relaxes the range objective for operation from
contact through at least 20 cm between low power devices and 30 cm
between low power and standard power devices. This implementation
affords 10 times less power consumption. These parameters are
termed the required maximum ranges by certain classes of IrDA
featured devices and sets the end user expectation for discovery,
recognition and performance.
• Bi-directional communication is the basis of all specifications
• Data transmission from 9600 b/s with primary speed/cost steps of 115
kb/s and maximum speed up to 4 Mb/s
• Data packets are protected using a CRC (CRC-16 for speeds up to
1.152Mb/s and CRC-32 at 4 Mb/s).
IrDA vs Bluetooth
If you examine the benefits of each technology, you can see that Bluetooth
and IrDA are both critical to the marketplace. Each technology has
advantages and drawbacks and neither can meet all users' needs. Bluetooth's
ability to penetrate solid objects and its capability for maximum mobility within
the piconet allows for data exchange applications that are very difficult or
impossible with IrDA. For example, with Bluetooth a person could synchronize
their phone with a PC without taking the phone out of their pocket or purse
(this is not possible with IrDA). The omni-directional capability of Bluetooth
allows synchronization to start when the phone is brought into range of the
PC.
The Bluetooth standard defines the layers 1 and 2 of the OSI model. The
application framework of Bluetooth is aimed to achieve interoperability with
IrDA and WAP. In addition, a host of other applications will be able to use the
Bluetooth technology and protocols.
APPLICATION PROGRAMS
IrDA Interoperability Application Programs WAP Interoperability
TCP / IP
LINK MANAGER
BASEBAND
RADIO
HOME RF
The HomeRF is a subset of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU)
who is working on the development of a standard for inexpensive RF voice
and data communication. Currently, the HomeRF Working Group specification
provides for wireless Ethernet transmission.
The HomeRF Working Group has also developed the Shared Wireless
Access Protocol (SWAP). SWAP is a industry specification that permits PCs,
peripherals, cordless telephones and other devices to communicate voice and
data without the usage of cables. SWAP is similar to the CSMA/CA protocol of
IEEE 802.11 but with an extension to voice traffic. The SWAP system can
either operate as an adhoc network or as a infrastructure network under the
control of a connection point. In an adhoc network, all stations are peers and
control is distributed between the stations and supports only data. In an
infrastructure network, a connection Point is required so as to coordinate the
system and it provides the gateway to the PSTN (Public Switched Telephone
Network). Walls and floors don't cause any problem in its functionality and
some security is also provided through the use of unique network IDs. It is
robust, reliable and minimizes the impact of radio interference.
Features:
• operates in the 2.45 GHz range of the unlicensed ISM band
• Range: upto 150 feet
• employs frequency hopping at 50 hops per second
• It supports both a TDMA service to provide delivery of interactive voice
and CSMA/CA service for delivery of high speed data packets
• The network is capable of supporting upto 127 nodes
• Transmission Power : 100mW
• Data Rate : 1Mbps using 2FSK modulation and 2 Mbps using 4 FSK
modulation
• Voice connections : upto 6 full duplex conversations
• Data Security : Blowfish encryption algorithm (over 1 trillion codes)
• Data Compression : LZRW3-A algorithm
SWAP vs Bluetooth
Currently SWAP has more installed base compared to Bluetooth but it is
believed that Bluetooth is eventually going to prevail. Bluetooth is a
technology to connect devices without cables. The intended use is to provide
short-range connections between mobile devices and to the Internet via
bridging devices to different networks (wired and wireless) that provide
Internet capability. HomeRF SWAP is a wireless technology optimized for the
home environment. Its primary use is to provide data networking and dial
tones between devices such as PCs, cordless phones, Web Tablets and a
broadband cable or DSL modem. Both technologies share the same
frequency spectrum but do not interfere when operating in the same space.
[Derfler00]
Data
Peak Data Relative Voice network
Range network
Rate Cost support
support
IEEE
2 Mbps 50m Medium Via IP TCP / IP
802.11
IrDA 16 Mbps < 2m Low Via IP Via PPP
Via IP and
Bluetooth 1 Mbps < 10m Medium Via PPP
cellular
Via IP and
HomeRF 1.6 Mbps 50m Medium TCP / IP
PSTN
What’s the future for Bluetooth
Bluetooth has a good future ahead because it meets a basic need of
connectivity in close proximity, is the result of initiatives of nine leading
communications and computer industry vendors including companies like 3-
COM, Ericsson, Lucent, IBM, Intel, Microsoft, Nokia, Toshiba etc. Since the
formation of the original group, more than 1800 manufacturers worldwide
have joined the initiative worldwide. According to one market research report,
Bluetooth technology is expected to be built into over 100 millions devices
before the end of 2002. According to still another report from market research
firm Cahners In-Stat Group, there will be over 670 million Bluetooth enabled
devices worldwide by 2005.