Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Impact
Report
Summary
Since
2015,
the
Navajo
Nation
Chapters
of
Counselor,
Torreon-‐Star
Lake,
and
Ojo
Encino,
have
experienced
increasing
levels
of
health
and
safety
impacts
from
the
development
of
over
400
oil
wells
on
thousands
of
acres
of
lands,
leased
by
the
Farmington
Field
Office
(FFO)
of
Bureau
of
Land
Management
(BLM),
and
in
close
proximity
to
Chapter
facilities,
schools
and
homes.
Currently,
the
FFO
is
conducting
an
Environmental
Impact
Study
(EIS)
on
hydraulic
fracturing
impacts
in
the
Mancos
Shale/Gallup
formation
scheduled
to
be
completed
in
2018.
In
the
2003
Resource
Management
Plan,
the
FFO
reported
that
horizontal
fracturing
in
the
region
was
“technologically
and
economically
infeasible”.
In
2014,
FFO
agreed
it
needed
to
update
the
EIS
to
analyze
the
impacts
of
hydraulic
fracturing
and
allowed
hundreds
of
“exploratory”
wells
to
be
drilled
near
Counselor,
Torreon-‐Star
Lake
and
Ojo
Encino.
Counselor
Chapter
has
taken
steps
to
hold
meetings
for
members
and
the
general
public
to
inform
them
about
the
potential
risks
of
exposure
to
oil
and
gas
operations
as
well
as
documented
health
impacts
from
contaminated
air
and
water
to
both
humans
and
livestock.
Chapter
Resolutions
Safety Related
Road
Damage
from
oversize
vehicles
-‐
25
Traffic
Safety
(Accidents,
Speeding,
Dust,
Unsafe
driving)
-‐
12
Odor
from
Well
Sites
(Air
quality)
-‐
6
Wastewater
from
Wells
(Water
quality
&
Livestock
illness)
-‐
3
Noise
from
Well
Sites
-‐
1
Light
Pollution
from
Well
Sites
-‐
1
Lack
of
Education
on
Hydraulic
Fracturing
Risks-‐
2
Health Concerns over High Ozone levels in San Juan Basin
High
ozone
(O3)
and
methane
levels
reported
in
2016
in
the
San
Juan
Basin
are
an
ongoing
source
of
public
concern.
Tropospheric
or
ground
level
ozone
–
what
we
breathe
–
is
formed
primarily
from
photochemical
reactions
between
two
major
classes
of
air
pollutants,
volatile
organic
compounds
(VOC)
and
nitrogen
oxides
(NOx).
When
inhaled,
ozone
can
damage
the
lungs.
Relatively
low
amounts
of
ozone
can
cause
chest
pain,
coughing,
shortness
of
breath
and,
throat
irritation.
It
may
also
worsen
chronic
respiratory
diseases
such
as
asthma
as
well
as
compromise
the
ability
of
the
body
to
fight
respiratory
infections.
(“Health
Effects
of
Ozone
in
the
General
Population”,
US
EPA)
Health impacts of BTEX and other Oil and Gas Emissions
Repeated
exposure
to
Benzene,
Toluene,
Ethyl
benzene
and
Xylene
(BTEX)
emissions
have
been
shown
to
have
negative
health
outcomes.
BTEX
emissions
are
released
during
the
flaring
period
of
gases
from
oil
wells
that
can
last
up
to
75
days
in
San
Juan
Basin.
BTEX
emission
exposure
has
been
repeatedly
cited1
as
a
leading
cause
of
life-‐threatening
birth
defects
in
infants
born
to
mothers
exposed
to
benzene
in
their
first
trimester
of
pregnancy.
Birth
defects
include
congenital
heart
defects
(CHDs),
neural
tube
defects
(NTDs),
and
pre-‐term
and
low
weight
birth.
Health
&
Safety
Concerns
reported
at
BLM
Meeting
in
Counselor
-
September
28,
2016
Farmington
Field
Office
Manager,
Richard
Fields,
and
Realty
Specialist,
Mark
Ames,
heard
dozens
of
residents,
organization
representatives
and
chapter
officials
speak
in
opposition
to
more
leasing
of
Tribal
land
or
BLM
land
for
oil
development
citing
contaminated
water,
air
pollution,
speeding
traffic,
dangerous
road
conditions,
accidents,
and
public
health
and
safety
problems:
• WPX
new
storage
facility
explosion
and
fire
that
destroyed
36
storage
tanks
and
caused
the
evacuation
of
55
local
residents
and
extensive
damage
to
private
property
located
closest
to
the
accident
site,
as
well
as
release
of
chemicals
and
pollutants,
as
yet
unidentified,
into
the
Tri-‐
Chapter
communities’
air
and
water
over
a
5
day
period
while
the
fire
burned
out
of
control.
• Danger
from
speeding
over-‐sized
oil
company
tankers
and
trucks
to
local
drivers,
to
children
getting
off
school
buses
and
walking
home
and
to
local
livestock
near
or
crossing
rural
roads.
• Lack
of
resident
protection
from
flaring
emissions
(flaring
average
75
days)
•
Impact
of
air
emissions
on
children,
teachers
and
staff
at
local
Lybrook
Community
School
on
Highway
550
(Enrollment:
116
children
K-‐8th
Grade)
• Lack
of
communication
to
the
public
regarding
air
pollution,
school
shut
downs
or
road
closures
due
to
oil
drilling
activities
or
breaking
a
waterline
• Lack
of
fencing
around
waste
water
pits
that
attract
livestock
and
wildlife
• Lack
of
resident
protection
from
flaring
that
continues
an
average
of
75
days
instead
of
14
days
in
BLM
regulations
1
EHP
Birth
Outcomes
and
Maternal
Residential
Proximity
to
Natural
Gas
Development
in
Rural
Colorado,
Part
Three:
Air
Quality
Monitoring
Data
Collection
Lab:
ALS
Environmental.
Additional
analysis:
Mark
Cherniak,
PhD.
Test
1:
Two
toxic
substances
were
detected
at
the
two
sites
collected
on
October
14,
2016,
relatively
modest
levels
of
ethyl
acetate
and
toluene.
The
levels
of
ethyl
acetate
in
the
two
samples
(21
µg/m3
and
24
µg/m3)
are
not
of
a
health
or
environmental
significance
because
of
the
low
toxicity
of
this
chemical.
The
levels
of
toluene
in
the
two
samples
(19
µg/m3
and
72
µg/m3)
are
under
relevant
health-‐based
standards
http://oehha.ca.gov/air/general-‐info/oehha-‐acute-‐8-‐hour-‐and-‐chronic-‐reference-‐
exposure-‐level-‐rel-‐summary
however;
these
two
toluene
levels
are
unusually
high.
A
2013
survey
of
air
quality
in
more
than
100
locations
across
the
United
States
found
daily
arithmetic
mean
concentrations
of
toluene
ranging
from
0.073
µg/m3
to
19.0
µg/m3.
https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxprofiles/tp56-‐c6.pdf).
Test
2:
Three
air
samples
were
collected
April
18,
2017
along
Highway
550.
One
sample
was
collected
at
mile
marker
100
north
of
the
Lybrook
School
(Report
P1701856);
a
second
sample
was
collected
along
Highway
550,
at
mile
marker
107.5,
approximately
½
mile
south
of
the
highway
near
the
San
Juan
and
Rio
Arriba
county
line
(Report
P1701857);
and
a
third
sample
was
collected
along
Highway
550
at
the
intersection
of
CR
7900
(Report
P17018568.)
Hydrogen
sulfide
was
detected
in
air
sample
#2
collected
on
Highway
550
at
mile
marker
100
north
of
the
Lybrook
School
at
a
level
of
7.6
µg/m3.
Hydrogen
sulfide
is
a
gas
that
possesses
a
potently
offensive
odor
of
rotten
eggs.
Long-‐term
exposure
to
hydrogen
sulfide
is
associated
with
an
elevated
incidence
of
respiratory
infections,
irritation
of
the
eye
and
nose,
cough,
breathlessness,
nausea,
headache,
and
mental
symptoms,
including
depression.
The
U.S.
EPA
reference
concentration
for
hydrogen
sulfide
is
2
μg/m3
(for
preventing
nasal
lesions
of
the
olfactory
mucosa).
The
level
of
hydrogen
sulfide
detected
in
the
sample
collected
north
of
the
Lybrook
School
exceeds
the
U.S.
EPA
reference
concentration
for
hydrogen
sulfide,
but
is
below
the
California
OEHHA
chronic
reference
exposure
level
for
hydrogen
sulfide.
If
hydrogen
sulfide
levels
of
7.6
µg/m3
north
of
Lybrook
School
generally
prevail,
then
these
levels
may
pose
risk
to
human
health.
Conclusion:
Residents
affected
by
the
fumes
and
odors
identified
in
the
air
samples,
should
notify
their
medical
providers
that
they
are
being
routinely
exposed
to
these
substances,
as
well
as
report
any
symptoms
they
may
be
experiencing.
NM
State
Land
Office
has
been
notified
of
the
leaking
well
and
requested
to
notify
the
oil
company
operating
the
well
to
lower
the
release
of
Hydrogen
Sulfide
to
regulatory
levels.
The
Counselor
Chapter
also
communicated
with
the
state
Oil
Conservation
Division
but
has
not
received
a
response
that
the
well
has
been
inspected.
Lab
data
and
analysis
are
available
upon
written
request.
Counselor
HIA
Committee
P.O.
Box
93
Counselor,
New
Mexico
87018
Contact:
Environmental
Testing
Oversight
Teresa
Seamster
tc.seamster@gmail.com
Miya
King-‐Flaherty
miya.king-‐flaherty@sierraclub.org