Individualism By political system we mean the system of - refers to the philosophy that an individual government in a nation. should have freedom in his or her economic and political pursuits. Political systems can be assessed according to two - Stresses that the interests of the individual dimensions. should take precedence over the interests of - The First is the degree to which they the state. emphasize collectivism as opposed to - Can be traced to an ancient Greek individualism. philosopher, Aristotle which argued that - The Second is the degree to which they are individual diversity and private ownership democratic or totalitarian. are desirable o Argued that private property is more These dimensions are interrelated highly productive than communal property and will this stimulate Collectivism progress. - refers to a political system that stresses the - Is built on two central tenets; primacy of collective goals over individual o The first is an emphasis on the goals. importance of guaranteeing - When collectivism is emphasized, the needs individual freedom and self- of society as a whole are generally viewed as expression. being more important than individual o The second tenet is that the welfare freedoms. of society is best served by letting - Advocacy of collectivism can be traced to the people pursue their own economic ancient Greek philosopher Plato. self-interest, as opposed to some Socialism collective body dictating what is in - trace their intellectual roots to Karl Marx. society’s best interest. - few benefit at the expense of the many in a - The central message of individualism, capitalist society where individual freedoms therefore, is that individual economic and are not restricted. political freedoms are the ground rules on - Marx postulated that the wages earned by which a society should be based the majority of workers in a capitalist society - Collectivism asserts the primacy of the would be forced down to subsistence levels. collective over the individual; individualism - He argued that capitalists expropriate for asserts the opposite their own use the value created by workers, Democracy and Totalitarianism while paying workers only subsistence - Democracy and totalitarianism are at wages in return. different ends of a political dimension. - Democracy and individualism go hand in - Socialist ideology split into two broad hand – however, gray areas exist; it is camps. possible to have a democratic state in which - The communists believed that socialism collective values predominate, and it is could be achieved only through violent possible to have a totalitarian state that is revolution and hostile to collectivism and in which some - totalitarian dictatorship, whereas the social degree of individualism democrats committed themselves to Democracy achieving socialism by democratic means, - Refers to a political system in which turning their backs on violent revolution government is by the people, exercised and dictatorship. either directly or through elected - Citizens are denied all the constitutional representatives. guarantees on which representative - Pure form is based on a belief that citizens democracies are built should be directly involved in decision - Political repression is widespread, free and making. fair elections are lacking, media are heavily - Representative Democracy – citizens censored, basic civil liberties are denied, and periodically elect individuals to represent those who question the right of the rulers them are imprisoned, or worse. o These elected representatives then form a gov’t. whose function is to Four Major Forms of Totalitarianism make decisions on behave of the - most widespread was Communist electorate. Totalitarianism o Elected representatives who fail to - Theocratic totalitarianism – found in states perform this job adequately will be where a party, group or individual that voted out of office at the next governs according to religious principles election. monopolized political power o To guarantee that elected o Most common form is based on Islam representatives can be held and is exemplified by states such as accountable for their actions by the Iran and Saudi Arabia. electorate, ideal representative o This states limit freedom of political democracy has a number of and religious expression with laws safeguards that are typically based on Islamic principles enshrined in constitutional law. - Tribal totalitarianism – occurs when a Individual’s right to freedom political party that represents the interests of expression, opinion and of a particular tribe (and not always the organization majority tribe) monopolizes power. Free media - Right-wing totalitarianism – generally Regular elections in which all permits some individual economic freedom eligible citizens are allowed but restricts individual political freedom, on to vote the grounds that it would lead to the rise of Universal adult suffrage communism Limited terms for elected o Common feature of many right-wing representatives dictatorships is an overt hostility to Fair court system that is socialist or communist ideas independent from political o Many right-wing totalitarian gov’ts. system are backed by the military, and in Nonpolitical state some cases the government may be bureaucracy made up of military officers. Nonpolitical police force and Economic Systems armed serves - In countries where collective goals are given Relatively free access to state preeminence, the state may have taken information control over many enterprises; markets in Totalitarianism such countries are likely to be restricted - form of government in which one person or rather than free. political party exercises absolute control - Market Economy – all productive activities over all spheres of human life and prohibits are privately owned, as opposed to being opposing political parties. owned by the state o Good and services that a country produces are not planned by anyone; production is determined by the then direct them to make interaction of supply and demand investments that are in the best and signaled to producers through interests if the nation as a whole the price system. rather than in the interests of private o If demand for a product exceeds individuals. supply, prices will rise, signaling o The opposite seems to have produces to produce more – vice occurred. In a command economy, versa. state-owned enterprises have little o In this system, consumers are incentive to control costs to be sovereign. The purchasing patterns efficient because they cannot go out of consumers, as signaled to of business. producers through the mechanism of Also, abolition of private the price system, determine what is ownership means there is no produced and in what quantity. incentive for individuals to o For market to work, supply must not look for better ways to serve be restricted. consumer needs; hence, Supply restriction occurs dynamism and innovation are when a single firm absent from command monopolizes a market. economies Rather than increase output Instead of growing and in response to increased becoming more prosperous, demand, a monopolist might such economies tend to restrict output and let prices stagnate rise. - Mixed Economy – certain sectors of the This allows monopolist to economy are left to private ownership and take a greater profit margin free market mechanisms while other sectors on each unit it sells. have significant state ownership and gov’t the net result is that the planning. monopolist is likely to o Gov’ts also tend to take over become increasingly troubled firms they consider to be inefficient, producing high- vital to national interests. priced, low-quality goods, and society suffers as a Legal Systems consequence. - Refers to the rules, or laws, that regulate o The role of gov’t. is to encourage behavior along with the process by which vigorous free and fair competition the laws are enforced and though which between private producers – by redress for grievances is obtained. outlawing monopolies and restrictive - Is of immense importance to international business practices designed to business – country’s laws regulate business monopolize a market. practice, define the manner in which - Command Economy – gov’t plans the goods business transactions are to be executed, and services that a country produces, the and set down the rights and obligations of quantity in which they are produced, and the those involved in business transactions. prices at which they are sold. - Legal environments of countries differ in o Objective is for government to significant ways. allocate resources for “the good of - Influenced by the prevailing political system society” – gov’t of a country defines the legal o All business are state owned, the framework within which firms do business – rationale being that the gov’t can and often the laws that regulate business reflect the rulers’ dominant political The foundation for Islamic ideology. law is the holy book of Islam, Different Legal Systems the Koran, along with the Sunnah, or decisions and - Common Law – based on tradition, saying of the Prophet precedent and custom. Muhammad, and the writings o Tradition refers to a country’s legal of Islamic scholars who have history, Precedent to cases that have derived rules by analogy from come before the courts in the past, the principles established in and Custom to the ways in which the Koran and the Sunnah. laws are applied in specific situations. Because Koran and Sunnah o When law courts interpret common are holy documents, the basic law, they do so with regard to these foundations of Islamic law characteristics – giving a common cannot be changed law system a degree of flexibility Differences in Contract Law that other systems lack. - The difference between common law and o Judges in common law system have civil law can be illustrated by the approach of the power to interpret the law so each to contract law (most theocratic legal that it applies to the unique systems also have elements of common or circumstances of an individual case. civil law) In turn, each new - Contract – document that specifies the interpretation sets a conditions under which an exchange is to precedent that may be occur and details the rights and obligations followed in future cases. of the parties involved As new precedents arise, laws - Contract Law – body of law that governs may be altered, clarified or contract enforcement. amended to deal with new o The parties to an agreement situations. normally resort to contract law when - Civil Law – based on detailed set of laws one party feels the other has violated organized into codes. either the letter or the spirit of an o when law courts interpret civil law, agreement. they do so with regard to those - Because common law tends to be relatively codes.(Germany, France, Japan and ill specified, contracts drafted under a Russia) common law framework tend to be very o tends to be less adversarial than a detailed with all contingencies spelled out. common law system, since the - In civil law systems, contracts tend to be judges rely upon detailed legal codes much shorter and less specific because many rather than interpreting traditions, of the issues are already covered in a civil precedent and custom. code o Judges under civil law have less - Thus, it is more expensive to draw up flexibility than those under common contracts in a common law jurisdiction, and law system. Have the power only to resolving contract disputes can be very apply the law. adversarial in common law systems. - Theocratic Law – based on religious o But common law have the advantage teachings. of greater flexibility and allow for o Islamic law is the most widely judges to interpret a contract dispute practiced theocratic legal system in in light of prevailing situation. the modern world. - International businesses need to be sensitive to these differences; approaching a contract dispute in a state with a civil law system as if - However, in many countries the authorities it had a common law system may backfire, do not enforce these laws and property and vice versa. rights are violated - When contract disputes arise in - Property rights can be violated in two ways – international trade, there is always the through private action and public action question of which country’s laws to apply – - Private Action – refers to theft, piracy, to resolve this issue, a number of countries, blackmail and the like by private individuals including the United States, have ratified the or groups. United Nations Convention on Contracts for o Although theft occurs in all countries, the International Sale of Goods (CIGS) a weak legal system allows for a o Establishes a uniform set of rules much higher level of criminal action governing certain aspects of making in some than in others. and performing everyday - Public Action – occurs when public officials, commercial contracts between such as politicians and government sellers and buyers who have their bureaucrats, extort income, resources, or places of business in different the property itself from property holders. nations. o Can be done through legal o By adopting the CIGS, a nation signals mechanisms such as levying to other adopters that it will treat the excessive taxation, requiring convention’s rules as part of its law. expensive licenses or permits from o Applies automatically to all contracts property holders, taking assets into for the sale of goods between state ownership without different firms based in countries compensating the owners, or that have ratified the convention, redistributing assets without unless the parties to the contract compensating the prior owners. explicitly opt out. o Can be done through illegal means, o One problem with CIGS is that fewer or corruption, by demanding bribes than 70 nations have ratified the from businesses in return for the convention. rights to operate in a country, o When firms do not wish to accept the industry or location. CIGS, they often opt for arbitration o Corruption is so endemic in some by a recognized arbitration court to countries that politicians and settle contract disputes. bureaucrats regard it as a perk of o The most well-known of these courts office and openly flout law against is the International Court of corruption. Arbitration of the International o According to Transparency Chamber of Commerce in Paris. International. An independent nonprofit organization dedicated to Property Rights and Corruption exposing and fighting corruption, - In legal sense, property refers to a resource businesses and individuals spend over which an individual or business holds a some $400 billion a year worldwide legal title; that is a resource that it owns. on bribes related to gov’t - Property Rights – refer to the legal rights procurement contracts alone. over the use to which a resource is put and o Economic evidence suggests that over the use made of any income that may high levels of corruption significantly be derived from that resource. reduce the foreign direct investment, - Countries differ in the extent to which their level of international trade, and legal systems define and protect property economic growth rate in a country rights. o By siphoning off profits, corrupt - Intellectual Property refers to property that politicians and bureaucrats reduce is the product of intellectual activity, such as the returns to business investment, computer software, a screenplay, a music and hence, reduce the incentive of score, or the chemical formula for a new both domestic and foreign business drug to invest in that country. - Patents, copyrights, and trademarks Foreign Corrupt Practices Act establish ownership rights over intellectual - Law that makes it illegal to bribe a foreign property government official to obtain or maintain o Patent grants the inventor of a new business over which that foreign official has product or process exclusive rights authority, and it requires all publicly traded for a defined period to the companies (whether or not they are involved manufacture, use, or sale of that in international trade)to keep detailed invention. records that would reveal whether a o Copyrights are exclusive legal rights violation of the act has occurred. of authors, composers, playwrights, artists, and publishers to publish and - In 1997, trade and finance ministers from disperse their works as they see fit. the member state of the Organization for o Trademarks are designs and names, Economic Cooperation and Development often officially registered, by which (OECD), an association of the world’s 30 merchants or manufacturers most powerful economies, adopted the designate and differentiate their Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign products Public Officials in International Business - Protecting intellectual property has also Transactions. become increasingly problematic, o The convention obliges member particularly if it can be rendered in a digital states to make the bribery of foreign form and then copied and distributed at very public officials a criminal offense low cost via pirated CDs or over the internet. - However, both the U.S. law and OECD - The philosophy behind intellectual property convention include language that allows for laws is to reward the originator of a new exceptions known as facilitating or invention, book, musical record, clothes expediting payments(also called grease design, restaurant chain, and the like, for his payments or speed money) or her idea and effort. o The purpose of which is to expedite o Such law stimulate innovation and or to secure the performance of a creative work; provide incentive for routine governmental action people to search for novel way of o The explanation for this exception to doing things and they reward general antibribery provisions is that creativity. while grease payments are, - International businesses have a number of technically, bribes, they are possible responses to violations of their distinguishable from(and, intellectual property apparently, less offensive than) o They can lobby their respective bribes used to obtain or maintain gov’ts to push for international business because they merely agreements to ensure that facilitate performance of duties that intellectual property rights are the recipients are already obligated protected and that the law is to perform. enforced o Can file lawsuits on their own behalf The Protection of Intellectual Property o Choose to stay out of countries where intellectual property laws are lax, rather than risk having their ideas adjusted (up or down) depending stolen by local entrepreneurs. upon whether the cost of living is lower or higher than the US. - The GNI and PPP data give a static picture of development. They tell us, for example, that Product Safety and Product Liability China is much poorer than the US, but they - Product safety law set certain safety do not tell us if China is closing the gap. standards to which a product must adhere. o To assess this, we have to look at the - Product liability involves holding a firm and economic growth rates countries its officers responsible when a product achieve. causes injury, death or damage. Broader Conceptions of Development: Amartya Sen o Can be much greater if a product - Nobel Prize-winning economist Amartya Sen does not conform to required safety argued that development should be standards. assessed less by material output measures - Civil laws calls for payment and monetary such as GNI per capita and more by the damages capabilities and opportunities that people - Criminal liability laws result in fines and enjoy imprisonment. - Development should be seen as a process of - In addition to the competitiveness issue, expanding the real freedoms that people country difference in product safety and experience. Hence, development requires liability laws raise an important ethical issue the removal of major impediments to for firms doing business abroad. freedom: poverty as well as tyranny, poor Determinants of Economic Development economic opportunities as well as - The political, economic, and legal systems of systematic social deprivations, neglect of a country can have a profound impact on the public facilities as well as the intolerance of level of economic development and hence repressive states. on the attractiveness of a country as a - Development is not just an economic possible market or production location for a process, but a political one too, and it firm. requires the “democratization” of political - One common measure of economic communities to give citizens a voice in the development is a country’s gross national important decisions made for the income (GNI) per head of population community o Regarded as the yardstick for the o This perspective leads Sen to economic activity of a country; it emphasize basic health care, and measures the annual income basic education. received by residents of a nations o Not only are these factors desirable o Can be misleading because they for their instrumental value in don’t consider differences in the cost helping to achieve higher income of living levels, but they are also beneficial in - To account for the differences in the cost of their own right. living, one can adjust GNI per capita by o People cannot develop their purchasing power – referred to as capabilities if they are chronically ill purchasing power parity (PPP) adjustment or woefully ignorant o Allows for a more direct comparison - The United Nations has endorsed Sen’s of living standards in different influential thesis by developing the Human countries Development Index (HDI) to measure the o The base for the adjustment is the quality of human life in different nations cost of living in the United States. The o HDI is based on three measures: PPP for different countries is then Life expectancy at birth Educational attainment Innovation and Entrepreneurship Require a Market Whether average incomes, Economy based on PPP estimates, are - It has been argued that the economic sufficient to meet the basic freedom associated with a market economy need of life in a country creates greater incentives for innovation and o The HDI is scaled from 0 to 1. entrepreneurship than either a planned or a Countries scoring less than 0.5 are mixed economy. classified as having low human - In a market economy, any individual who has development (quality of life is poor) an innovative idea is free to try to make o Those scoring above 0.8 are classified money out of that idea by starting a as having high human development; business. Similarly, existing business are free and those that score above 0.8 are to improve their operations through classified as having high human innovations development. o Both individual entrepreneurs and Political Economy and Economic Progress established businesses can reap - It is often argued that a country’s economic rewards in the form of high profits. development is a function of its economic o Thus, market economies contain and political systems. enormous incentives to develop Innovations and Entrepreneurship Are the Engines of innovations. Growth - In a planned economy, the state owns all - There is wide agreement that innovation and means of production. Entrepreneurial entrepreneurial activity are the engines of individuals have few economic incentive to long-run economic growth. develop valuable innovations, because it is - Innovation – broadly to include not just new the state, rather than the individual, that products but also new processes, new captures most of the gains. organizations, new management practices o The lack of economic freedom and and new strategies. incentives for innovation was - Innovation and entrepreneurial activity help probably a main factor in the to increase economic activity by creating economic stagnation of many former new products and market that did not communist states and led ultimately previously exist. to their collapse at the end of the o Innovations in productions and 1980s. business processes lead to an Innovation and Entrepreneurship Require Strong increase in the productivity of labor Property Rights and capital, which further boosts - Strong legal protection of property rights is economic growth rates. another requirement for a business - Innovation is also seen as the product of environment to be conducive to innovation, entrepreneurial activity. Often, entrepreneurial activity, and hence entrepreneurs first commercialize economic growth. innovative new products and processes, and - Both individuals and businesses must be entrepreneurial activity provides much of given the opportunity to profit from the dynamism in an economy. innovative ideas. - Thus, one can conclude that if a country’s - Without strong property rights protection, economy is to sustain long-run economic businesses and individuals run the risk that growth, the business environment must be the profits from their innovative efforts will conducive to the consistent production of be expropriated, either by criminal elements product and process innovations and to or by the state. entrepreneurial activity. o State can expropriate profits from innovation through legal means, such as excessive taxation, or rights is capable of promoting through illegal means, such as economic growth. demands from state bureaucrats for o There is no guarantee that a kickbacks in return for granting an dictatorship will continue to pursue individual or firm a license to do such progressive policies. Dictators business in certain area. are rarely so benevolent. - “Inadequately enforced property rights o Therefore, it seems likely that reduce the incentives for innovation and democratic regimes are far more entrepreneurial activity – because the conducive to long-term economic profits from such activity are stolen –and growth than are dictatorships, even hence reduce the rate of economic growth” benevolent ones. Only in a well- – Douglass North, Nobel Prize-winning functioning, mature democracy are economist property rights truly secure. - “Much of the developing world will fail to o Totalitarian states, by limiting human reap the benefits of capitalism until property freedom, also suppress human rights are better defined and protected “ development and therefore are (Peruvian development economist detrimental to progress. Hernando de Soto) Economic Progress Begets Democracy o Claims that the key problem is not - Subsequent economic growth often leads to the risk of expropriation but the establishment of a democratic regime. chronic inability of property owners - Thus, although democracy may not always to establish legal title to the property be the cause of initial economic progress, it they own. seems to be one consequence of that Democratic Regimes are more Conducive to Long- progress Term Economic Growth Geography, Education and Economic Development - People in the West tend to associate a - While a country’s political and economic representative democracy with a market systems are probably the big engine driving economic system, strong property rights its rate of economic development, other protection and economic progress. factors are also important. o Building on this idea, we tend to - One that has received attention recently is argue that democracy is good for geography. growth - Jeffrey Sachs’s point is that by virtue of o Five of the fastest growing favorable geography, certain societies were economies of the past 30 years – more likely to engage in trade than others China, S.Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, and were thus more likely to be open to and and Hong Kong- had one thing in develop market-based economic systems, common at the start of their which in turn would promote faster economic growth: undemocratic economic growth. governments. o Adverse geographical conditions, At the same time, countries such as the high rate of disease, poor with stable democratic soils and hostile climate that afflict governments, such as India, many tropical countries, can have experienced sluggish negative impact on development. economic growth for long - Education emerges as another important periods. determinant of economic development o Only a totalitarian regime that is o General assertion is that nations that committed to a free market system invest more in education will have and strong protection of property higher growth rates because an educated population is a more - The shift toward a market-based economic productive population. system often entails a number of steps: States in Transition deregulation, privatization and creation of a - Two trends have been evident legal system to safeguard property rights. o First, a wave of democratic - Deregulation – involved removing legal revolutions swept the world – restrictions to the free play of markets, the totalitarian gov’ts collapsed and establishment of private enterprises and the were replaced by democratically manner in which private enterprises elected gov’ts that were typically operate. more committed to free market o Involved removing price controls, capitalism than their predecessors thereby allowing prices to be set by had been the interplay between demand and o Second, there has been a strong supply; abolishing laws regulating move away from centrally planned the establishment and operation of and mixed economies and toward a private enterprises and relaxing or more free market economic model removing restrictions on direct - The Spread of Democracy investment by foreign enterprises o “Free” countries, citizens enjoy a and international trade high degree of political and civil - Privatization – transfers the ownership of freedoms. the state property into the hands of private o “Partly-free” countries are individuals, frequently by the sale of state characterized by some restrictions assets through an auction. on political rights and civil liberties, o Seen as a way to stimulate gains in often in the context of corruption, economic efficiency by giving new weak rule of law, ethnic strife or civil private owners a powerful incentive war. – the reward of greater profits –to o “Not free” countries, the political search for increases in productivity, process is tightly controlled and basic to enter new markets, and to exit freedoms are denied. losing one. o Three main reasons account for the Legal Systems spread of democracy - A well-functioning market economy requires Many totalitarian regimes laws protecting private property rights and failed to deliver economic providing mechanisms for contract progress to the vast bulk of enforcement. their populations. - Without legal system the incentive to New information and engage in economic activity can be reduced communication technologies, substantially by private and public entities, have reduced the state’s including organized crime. ability to control access to Implications for Managers uncensored information - First, political, economic and legal systems of Economic advances of the a country raise important ethical issues that past quarter have led to the have implications for the practice of emergence of increasingly international business. prosperous middle and - Second, the political, economic and legal working classes who have environments of a country clearly influence pushed for democratic the attractiveness of that country as a reforms market of investment site. The Nature of Economic Transformation - The overall attractiveness of a country as a market or investment site depends on balancing the likely long-term benefits of the lack of infrastructure and doing business in that country against the supporting business. likely costs and risks. o As for legal factors, it can be more - Benefits – the long run monetary benefits of costly to do business in a country doing business in a country are a function of where local laws and regulations set the size of the market, the present wealth strict standards with regard to (purchasing power) of consumers in that product safety, safety in the market, and the likely future wealth of workplace, environment pollution consumers. and the like. o By identifying and investing early in a It can be more costly to do potential future economic star, business in a country that international firms may build brand lacks well-established laws loyalty and gain experience in that for regulating business country’s business practices. practice o In the language of business strategy, In the absence of a well- early entrants into potential future developed body of business economic stars may be able to reap contract law, international substantial first-mover advantages, firms may find no satisfactory while late entrants may fall victim to way to resolve contract late-mover disadvantages. (First- disputes and, consequently, mover advantages are the routinely face large losses advantages that accrue to early from contract violations. entrants into the market; Late-mover - Risks – the risks of doing business in a disadvantages are the handicaps that country are determined by a number of late entrants might suffer) political, economic and legal factors. o A country’s economic system and o Political risk – defined as the property rights regime are likelihood that political forces will reasonably good predictors of cause drastic changes in a country’s economic prospects. business environment that adversely - Cost – a number of political, economic and affect the profit and other goals of a legal factors determine the costs of doing business enterprise. business in a country. Tends to be greater in o With regard to political factors, a countries experiencing social company may have to pay off unrest and disorder or in politically powerful entities in a countries where the country before the gov’t allows it to underlying nature of a society do business there. increases the likelihood of Whether a company should social unrest (typically finds actually pay bribes in return expression in strikes, for market access should be demonstrations, terrorism determined on the basis of and violent conflict.) the legal and ethical o Economic risk – likelihood that implications of such action. economic mismanagement will o With regard to economic factors, one cause drastic changes in a country’s of the most important variables is the business environment that hurt the sophistication of a country’s profit and other goals of a particular economy – it may be more costly to business enterprise. do business in relatively primitive or Not independent of political undeveloped economies because of risk. One visible indicator of economic mismanagement tends to be a country’s inflation rate Another is the level of business and government debt in the country. o Legal risk – defined as the likelihood that a trading partner will opportunistically break a contract or expropriate property rights. When legal risks in a country are high, an international business might hesitate entering into a long-term contract or joint-venture agreement with a firm in that country. Overall Attractiveness - Depends on balancing the benefits, costs, and risks associated with doing business in that country. - The costs and risks associated with doing business in a foreign country are typically lower in economically advanced and politically stable democratic nations and greater in less developed and politically unstable nations. - Other things being equal, the benefit-cost- risk trade-off is likely to be most favorable in politically stable developed and developing nations that have free market systems and no dramatic upsurge in either inflation rates or private sector debt.