Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The variables that affect the market-to-book ratio are (1) the excess of ROCE over
the cost of equity capital; (2) the growth in common shareholders’ equity, which
is positively related to ROCE and negatively related to the dividend payout per-
centage; and (3) the number of years during which a firm is expected to earn an
excess return over its cost of equity capital. Summary data in the table below help
in interpreting the market-to-book ratios for these seven firms. The growth in
common shareholders’ equity equals one minus the dividend payout percentage
times ROCE.
Wyeth—The market-to-book ratio of Wyeth is 6.9, the lowest of the seven firms.
Its price-earnings ratio is lowest of the seven firms, and its historical growth rate
in earnings is also on the low side. This suggests that Wyeth’s recent earnings re-
flect positive transitory items and that future earnings and ROCE will be lower,
which leads to a lower market-to-book ratio. The low market-to-book ratio results
in part from the somewhat higher dividend payout percentage and the slower
growth in shareholders’ equity.
You might ask the class why the market-to-book ratios in the pharmaceutical in-
dustry exceed 1.0 to such a significant extent. Pharmaceutical companies must
expense R&D costs in the year incurred, which reduces net income for the ex-
penditures made each year but reduces shareholders’ equity for cumulative R&D
expenditures. Because of the significant lag between making R&D expenditures and
generating revenues and positive earnings from those expenditures, the mar- ket values
the expected benefits several years before the accounting records rec- ognize those
benefits. Thus, market values of equity will exceed book values.