You are on page 1of 18

Islas et al: Lesión severa causada por la penetración traumática de un cepillo dental

SPECIAL GUEST LITERATURE REVIEW


Color Selection and Reproduction in Dentistry
Part 2: Light Dynamics in Natural Teeth
Reproducción y selección del color en Odontología
Parte 2: Dinámica de la luz sobre las piezas dentales
Received: 12-V-2016 Accepted: 19-V-2016 Published Online First: 24-V-2016

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15517/ijds.v0i0.24493

ABSTRACT

In the first article of this trilogy, it was demonstrated the great importance of the light source in
the chromatic procedures and also the chromatic characteristics of color communication proposed by
Munsell. In this second article, the focus is in Geometric Attributes and Optical Properties of natural
teeth. The main features of translucency, opalescence and fluorescence will be described. According to
the interaction of light with natural dental tissues, the desired optical qualities of the esthetic restorative
materials will be associated.

KEYWORDS

Color; Translucency; Chroma; Opalescense; Fluorescense.

RESUMEN

En el primer artículo de esta trilogía, se demostró la gran importancia de la fuente de luz en los
procedimientos cromáticos y también sobre las características cromáticas del color propuestas por
Munsell. En este segundo artículo, la atención se centra en los atributos geométricos y las propiedades
ópticas de los dientes naturales. Se describirán las principales características de translucidez,
opalescencia y fluorescencia. Según la interacción de la luz con los tejidos dentales naturales se pueden
asociar las cualidades ópticas deseadas de los materiales de restauración estética.

PALABRAS CLAVE

Color; Croma; Translucidez, Opalescencia; Fluorescencia.

SCHMELING M., 2016: Color Selection and Reproduction in Dentistry. Part 2: Light Dynamics in Natural Teeth.-ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dental Sc., 18-2
(May-August): 23-40.
ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 15-22,
23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 23
TRANSLUCENCY OF NATURAL TEETH results in a decrease of its translucency (Fig. 5). It
is very important to discover what is the thickness
Enamel and dentin have different structural required by each material to block the influence of
characteristics and, consequently, they exhibit the background contrast, an essential condition to
different light wave interaction characteristics. evaluate the inherent color of the material (2,5-7).
Due to its highly mineralized prismatic structure,
low organic content and a small amount of water, The maximum thickness of 4.0 mm was
enamel has a higher transmission of light than described on a study by Kamishima and colleagues,
dentin; dentin has the less mineral content, who reported that enamel composite resins were
an organic tubular structure, higher water not influenced by the background contrast at this
content and is less translucent (Figs. 1 e 2) (1). thickness (5). To match tooth color, various shades
Differences in translucency of dental tissues can of yellow and gray pigments are blended to white
be better understanding with the aid of polarizing base material of traditional resin composites. In
filters (Fig. 3 e 4). darker shades (low lightness or high chroma shade),
more pigments might be incorporated, which may
Defined as the relative amount of light influence the translucency of the shade. Yu and Lee
transmitted through a material, the translucency analyzed the influence of color parameters of resin
can be understood as an intermediate situation composites on their translucency using a reflection
between total blockage of light rays (opacity) spectrophotometer. The results indicated a high
and overall transmission of rays (transparency). correlation between translucency and Value, with
Therefore, the translucent objects allow light to darker shades presenting lower translucency (7).
pass through, varying this passage to a greater
or lesser degree (2-3). The chromatic evaluation Besides the thickness, another factor that
in translucent bodies is more complex than influences the translucency of the teeth is the
in opaque bodies. Hue, chroma and value are surface texture. It relates to the appearance of the
parameters considered insufficient to accurately surface of objects, and in general, we can define it
describe the optical effects observed in objects into macro-and micro-textures. The macro-textures
that allow light transmission. For this reason, the are topographical variations found on the surface of
translucency is considered the fourth chromatic the enamel, such as the grooves of development.
dimension applied in restorative dentistry. In this The macro-textures are responsible for large areas
four-dimensional concept, the value is the most of light reflection. The micro-textures are formed
important dimension of color with the translucency by tiny changes of enamel surface, occurring
coming in second place (4). by deposition of hydroxyapatite crystals by
ameloblasts during tooth germ formation, resulting
Generally, the translucency of resin in small oriented parallel grooves. A rich parallel
composites and ceramic systems is directly related groove surface is responsible for the creation of
to its thickness. Several authors described that areas of diffuse reflection on the tooth surface,
the increase of thickness of restorative materials thereby, decreasing the translucency (Fig. 6) (8-9).

24 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


Figure 1 and 2. Note the different structural characteristics between enamel (left image) and dentin (right image).

Figure 3 and 4. The translucency differences of dental tissues can be better understanding with the aid of polarized filters.
Note that enamels acts like an optical fiber transmitting the light energy to dentin.

ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 25


Figure 5. The opacity of esthetic dental materials is directly related to its thickness where a larger thickness corresponds to high opacity.

In a study of the translucency of enamel, present enamel thicker than older individuals, and
some authors have shown that this property is consequently lighter teeth. As wear is accentuated
strongly influenced by the degree of hydration and the thickness of the enamel layer decreases,
of this tissue. In this study, the dehydration of the translucency of the enamel increase, enabling
the enamel was evaluated instrumentally after chroma and hue, characteristics concerning the
applying a jet of air for 10 seconds and resulted in dentine, become more obvious. Thus, during
82% decrease in the values of translucency. This the process of interaction of light with the dental
decrease was due to the increase of the refractive tissues, enamel plays an important role in acting as
index of enamel caused by the water outflow and a filter, whose greater or less thickness accounts
air intake on the outskirts of the prisms (Fig. 7) (10). for teeth brighter or less bright (Fig. 8) (12-13).

In aesthetic dentistry, the importance of These characteristics can also be proven


translucency becomes evident when we observe by observing the color variation that exists in a
the variation of the color of teeth according to single tooth. Thus, at the cervical region, where
background contrast (11). The same tooth observed enamel is thin, the color is only attenuated and
in a white background and a dark background, chroma is high. In the middle third, which is more
will show different colors to due to absorption thick, the enamel is able to filter significantly
and selective reflection of certain wavelengths. the characteristics of dentin, making this region
Throughout this chapter we demonstrate the with high brightness and low saturation in the
influence of the background contrast in the color incisor region where there is little or even absent
of natural teeth with special attention in the incisal dentine, hue and chroma are replaced by tooth
region of the anterior teeth. translucency and opalescence effect that will be
discussed below.
THE DYNAMICS OF COLOR IN RELATED TO AGE
OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF DENTAL TISSUES
A basic factor when studying tooth color is
the variation in thickness of these tissues due to In addition to presenting different degrees
aging. In natural teeth, the value is characteristic for of translucency, enamel and dentin also have
the enamel, while the chroma and hue characterize different optical properties that give teeth unique
dentine. The younger individuals, less exposed to the beauty, highlighting respectively the opalescence
wear caused by the acids in the diet and brushing, and fluorescence.

26 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


OPALESCENCE the incisal edge. It kind of opalescence presented
by 4% of subjects (Fig. 15).
Opalescence is an optical property that • Type 4: In this type of opalescence opalescent
gets its name because it was first observed in halo presents mixed with some kind of
opal stones (Fig. 9) (14). It happens by scattering pigmentation or characterization. It kind of
of smaller wavelengths of the visible spectrum, opalescence presented by 25% of subjects.
making the opalescent objects more bluish when
viewed under reflected light and more orange Baratieri, Araujo, Monteiro JR (2005),
when viewed in transmitted light (15). All teeth demonstrated that removing the vestibular enamel
that are naturally covered by the enamel present of central incisors extracted, the of mamelon
opalescence (Figs. 10 e 11). However, this property tip showed white opaque color than the original
can be better observed in the upper central orange color, showing the influence of the counter-
incisors, in the form of a blue band, located near opalescence in the appearance of the tooth (19).
to the incisal edge called opalescent halo (16- By understanding the role and importance of
17). Besides opalescent halo, the opalescence opalescence and counter-opalescent we realize
also gives rise to another optical phenomenon that the enamel contributes decisively in the
called counter-opalescence, (17-18) responsible expression of subtle variations of hue observed in
for orange appearance that can be observed in natural teeth.
the region of the mamelons tip of anterior teeth.
It happens when the greater wavelengths, which In ceramic systems, opalescence has been
are usually transmitted through the enamel, reach responsible to solve aesthetic problems related
structures capable to reflect them. When the light to value and translucency, making possible to
performs inverse path through the enamel, the produce unnoticeable restorations (20-21). It has
blue wavelength still being spread while larger been demonstrated that the opalescence helps
lengths are transmitted, making the dentin more on the masking effect when the resins present
orange (Fig. 12). similar translucencies. However, when the
composite resins present different translucency
Due to its great aesthetic importance, the degrees, the translucency is predominant (22).
opalescence was considered by some authors When these results are extrapolated to enamel, it
as a chromatic scale can be recognized by four means that in spite of the opalescence decrease,
different types of presentation (18). it is more important to evaluate changes of
translucency than of opalescence to determine
• Type 1: Found in incisal edges that have the potential of masking effect of this tissue.
opalescent halo closely related to the dentinal The correct reproduction of opalescence with
mamelons. It kind of opalescence presented by composite resins involves careful observation of
58% of individuals (Fig. 13). adjacent teeth and the selection and application
• Type 2: In this type of opalescent halo mamelons of opalescent resins in appropriate locations. The
not penetrate between the dentin, extending correct reproduction of opalescence with ceramic
over the incisal edge. It kind of opalescence systems also involves careful observation and
presented por17% of individuals (Fig.14). the use of opalescent ceramic, however, this
• Type 3: Found in incisal edges showing diffuse information should be forwarded to the technician
halo opalescent, distributed randomly throughout who performs the restoration.

ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 27


Figure 6. Surface texture of the upper central incisors. Note the large vertical elevations and depressions that are present on the tooth
surface as well as the smaller horizontal grooves that can be observed, mainly in younger individuals.

Figure 7. The enamel is strongly influenced by the degree of hydration. The left incisors were dehydrated allong 24 hours and became with
an white-opaque color (note that we can't see the black background contrast through it). The right incisors are observed after 5 minutes
under the water. Note the increase of translucency and the influence of the background contrast through hydrated enamel.

28 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


Figure 8. The dynamics of color natural teeth related to age.

Figure 9. Opal stone observed under direct reflected light (left) and transmitted light. Note the blue shade
under reflected light and the orange shade under transmitted light.

ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 29


Figure 10. Central incisor slices observed under reflected and transmitted light in black background.. Under reflected light (left) we could
see bluish shades on enamel. Under transmitted light, enamel also shows an orange color.

Figure 11. For esthetic reasons, the anterior teeth are the most used examples to present opalescence. Nevertheless, opalescence is
present in all teeth. Observe that under transmitted light dentin also shows an orange color. This fact confirms the influence of translucency
on opalescence. Clinically we can confirm this affirmation observing the oranfe effect on tips of mamellons.

30 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


Figure 12. Schematic image of opaque halo (in the edge of incisal board- Orange color), opalescent halo (between opaque
halo and dentin mamelons -blue color ) and dentin mamelons At the center of tooth -yellow color.

Figure 13. Opalesccnce type 1. Figure 14. Opalescenve type 2.

Figure 15. Opalescence type 3. Figure 16. Opalescence type 4.

ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 31


Figure 17. Influence of background contrast on opalescence and counter-opalescence.

Figure 18. Removing the vestibular enamel of central incisors extracted, the of mamelon tip showed white opaque color than the original
orange color, showing the influence of the counter-opalescence.

32 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


Figure 19. The correct reproduction of opalescence with composite resins involves careful observation of adjacent teeth and
the selection and application of opalescent resins in appropriate locations.

ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 33


FLUORESCENCE for extensive Class III or IV restorations, offer the
potential for suitably fluorescent results. Based
on the fluorescence observed in natural teeth, the
Fluorescence is a luminescence phenomenon, fluorescence of composite resins can be classified
which means that it causes spontaneous light as low, suitable, or excessive (Fig.23) (29-30).
emission by a process other than heating (23). To When composite resin disks, of the same color
better understand fluorescence, clinicians must but different thicknesses, were compared they all
remember that all visible light is situated in a showed similar fluorescence (30, 37).
narrow band of the electromagnetic field, limited
at the lower end by ultraviolet (UV) radiation and The different fluorescent properties of
at the upper end by infrared (IR) radiation. Both composite resins can be better observed when
radiations are invisible to the human eye. This compared to a natural tooth (Fig 24). Observation
range is called the visible spectrum (24). While of the fluorescence of enamel has been described
most objects dissipate the absorbed light energy as an effective alternative method for the initial
as heat, fluorescent objects re-emit this energy diagnosis of caries due to the low fluorescence
in a longer, visible wavelength at a speed faster of decayed enamel compared to sound enamel.39
than 10-8 seconds (25-26). Although there is When human dentin was irradiated with light in the
evidence that dentin and cementum exhibit a red range of 365 nm, fluorescence was observed with
color when they intercept the incidence of green a peak located at 440 ± 10 nm. (38).
light, (27) tooth fluorescence is usually associated
with a blue-white chromatic appearance (Fig. 20) Although dentin is primarily responsible for
caused by the incidence of the UV wavelength, the fluorescence of natural teeth, several authors
as is emitted by the black light present in most have suggested that the enamel composite resin
nightclubs (28). layer is more responsible for fluorescence of a
restoration. Thus, if the dentin layer comprises
In this environment, the incidence of UV highly fluorescent resin and the enamel layer
wavelengths in a tooth restored with nonfluorescent comprises nonfluorescent resin, the result will be a
material causes metameric failure and is responsible nonfluorescent restoration. Conversely, if the enamel
for highlighting the restorative material (29-30). layer exhibits high fluorescence and the dentin
Fluorescence is present in both enamel and dentin; resin layer does not, the result will be a fluorescent
however, because it is associated with the amount restoration (Fig 25) (29-30, 38). The correct
of organic matter, it presents three times greater reproduction of fluorescence with composite resins
intensity in dentin than in enamel (Figs 21 e 22) involves the correct selection and application of
(31). This difference results from the presence fluorescent resins in appropriate layer technique.
of collagen fibers (32) and specifically the amino
acids that help to compose those fibers, including CONCLUSION
tryptophan, pyrimidine, (33-34) and pyridinoline
(35). Under natural light, fluorescence makes teeth After reading the second article of this trilogy
more luminous and shiny, giving them an internal we must comprehend the natural teeth as a dynamic
luminescence (36). Fluorescence must be present mosaic influenced by the interaction of different
in restorative materials to obtain natural-looking variables, resulting in a unique and inconstant
results. Indirect materials were the first to show beauty. Indeed, to obtain optimal esthetic results, the
fluorescence. Currently, direct composite resin restorative materials should present optical properties
and adhesive systems, which can be used even that are similar to those of the dental structure.

34 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


Figure 20. Natural teeth as observed in daylight and black light.

Figure 21. Fluorescence of central incisor slices under daylight and black light. Because it is associated with the amount of organic matter,
note (under black light) that it presents three times greater intensity in dentin than in enamel.

ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 35


Figure 22. For esthetic reasons, the anterior teeth are the most used examples of fluorescence. Nevertheless,
it is present the same characteristics in all teeth.

Figure 23. Based on the fluorescence observed in natural teeth, the fluorescence of composite resins can be classified as low, suitable,
or excessive.

36 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


Figure 24. Differences in resin composite fluorescence compared to an natural extracted teeth.

Figure 25. Schematic representation of the importance on the composite resin surface in fluorescence of restorations. Restoration A and
restoration B show fluorescence, while restoration C and D do not.

ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 37


Figure 26. The correct reproduction of fluorescence with composite resins involves the correct selection and application
of fluorescent resins in appropriate layer technique.

38 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


REFERENCES 12. Dietschi D., Ardhu S. & Krejci I. A new shading
concept based on natural tooth color applied
1. Vaarkamp J., ten Bosch J. J. & Verdonschot to direct composite restorations Quintessence
E. H. (1995) Propagation of light through International 2006; 37: 91-102.
human dental enamel and dentine. Caries 13. Schmeling M., Meyer-Filho A., Andrada MAC,
Research 29 (1) 8-13. Baratieri L. N. Chromatic influence of value
2. Schmeling M., Andrada MAC, Maia H. P., resin composites. Oper Dent 2010; 35: 45–9.
Araújo E. M. Translucency of Value Resin 14. Primus C. M., Chu C. C. Y., Shelby J. E.,
Composites Used to Replace Enamel in Buldrini E., Helcle C. E. Opalescence of dental
Stratified Composite Restoration Techniques. porcelains enamels. Quintessence International
Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry 2002; 36: 439–49.
2012; 24: 53-8. 15. Lee Y. K., Yu B. Measurement of opalescence
3. Johnston W. M. Review of Translucency of tooth enamel. Journal of Dentistry 2007;
Determinations and Applications to Dental 35: 690–4.
Materials.  Journal of Esthetic and Restorative 16. Sensi L. G., Araújo F. O., Marson F., Monteiro
Dentistry 2014; 26; 217-23. JRS. Reproducing opalescent and counter-
4. Yamamoto M. Metal ceramics principles and opalescent effects with direct resin composites.
methods. Chicago: Quintessence; 1985. Quintessence of Dental Technology 2007: 1–10.
5. Kamishima N., Ikeda T., Sano H. Color and 17. Schmeling M., Maia H. P., Baratieri L. N.
translucency of resin composites for layering Opalescence of bleached teeth. Journal of
techniques. Dent Mater J. 2005; 24: 428–32. dentistry 2012; 40 Suppl 1: e35-9.
6. Ikeda T., Sidhu S. K., Omata Y., Fujita M. & 18. Duarte J. R. S. Opalescence: the key to
Sano H. Colour and translucency of opaque- natural esthetics. Quintessence of Dental
shades and body-shades of resin composites Technology 2007: 7–20.
European Journal of Oral Sciences 2005; 19. Baratieri L. N., Araújo E. M. Jr.,Monteiro
113: 170-173. S. Jr. Color in natural teeth and direct resin
7. Yu B., Lee Y. K. Influence of color parameters composite restorations. Essential aspects. Eur
of resin composites on their translucency. J. Esthet Dent 2007; 2.
Dent Mater 2008; 24: 1236–42. 20. Yamamoto M. A newly developed ‘‘Opal’’
8. Fondriest J. Shade matching in restorative ceramic and its clinical use, with special attention
dentistry: the science and strategies. International to its relative refractive index. Quintessence
Journal of Periodontics and Restorative of Dental Technology 1989: 9–33.
Dentistry 2003; 23: 467–79. 21. Ward M. T., Tate W. H., Powers J. M. Surface
9. Baratieri L. N., Araújo E. M., Monteiro J. roughness of opalescent porcelains after
R. Composite restorations in anterior teeth. polishing. Operative Dentistry 1995; 20: 106–10.
Fundamentals and possibilities. New York: 22. Lee Y. K., Lu H., Powers J. M. Influence
Quintessence, 2005. of fluorescent and opalescent properties
10. Brodbelt R. H., O'Brien W. J., Fan P. L., of resin composites on the masking effect.
Frazer-Dib, J. G., Yu R. Translucency of Journal of Biomedical Materials Research
dental enamel 1981; 60: 1749-53. Part B Applied Biomaterials 2006; 76 (B):
11. Lee Y. K., Lim B. S., KIM C. W. Difference 26–32.
in colour and colour change in dental resin 23. Berns R.S. Billmeyer and Saltzman principles
composites by the background. Journal of of color technology -3rd ed. New York: John
Oral Rehabilitation 2005; 32: 227-233. Wiley & Sons; 2000.

ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046. 39


ODOVTOS-International Journal of Dental Sciences

24. Schmeling M. Color Selection and Reproduction 31. Monsengo G., Burdairon G., Clerjaud B.
in Dentistry. Part 1: Fundamentals of Color. Fluorescence of dental porcelains. J. Prosthet
Odovtos International Journal of Dental Dent 1993; 69: 106–113.
Sciences 2016, 18: 26-32. 32. Perry A., Biel M. A comparative study of
25. Wyszecki G., Stiles W. S. Color Science: the native fluorescence of human dentin and
Concepts and Methods, Quantitative Data bovine skin collagen. Arch Oral Biol 1969;
and Formulae, ed 2. New York: Wiley- 14: 1193–1211.
Interscience, 2000. 33. Hoerman K. C., Mancewicz S. A. Fluorometric
26. Lee Y. K., Lu H., Powers J. M. Influence of demonstration of tryotophane in dentin
fluorescent and opalescent properties of resin and bone protein. J. Dent Res 1964; 43:
composites on the masking effect. Journal 276–280.
of Biomedical Materials Research Part B 34. Foreman P. C. The excitation and emission
Applied Biomaterials 2006; 76 (B): 26–32. spectra of fluorescence components of human
27. Kvaal S., Solheim T. Fluorescence from dentine. Arch Oral Biol 1980; 25: 641–647.
dentin and cementum in human mandibular 35. Fukushima Y., Araki T., Yamada M. O.
second premolars and its relation to age. Topography of fluorescence and its possible
Scand J. Dent Res 1989; 97: 131–138. composites in human teeth. Cell Mol Biol
28. Miller M. B. The elusive nature of fluorescence. 1897; 3 3: 725–736.
Pract Proced Aesthet Dent 2003; 15: 84. 36. Magne P., Belser U. Bond porcelain restorations
29. Sensi L. G., Marson F. C., Roesner T. H., et in anterior dentition: a biomimetic approach.
al. Fluorescence of composite resins: Clinical Berlin: Quintessence; 2002.
considerations. Quintessence Dent Technol 37. Manauta J., Salat A. Layers: An Atlas of
2006; 29: 43–53. Composite Resin Stratification. Chicago:
30. Schmeling M., Sartori N., Peruchi L. D., Quintessence, 2012.
Baratieri L. N. Fluorescence of Natural Teeth 38. Lee Y. K., Lu H., Powers J. M. Effect of surface
and Direct Composite Resin Restorations: sealant and staining on the fluorescence of
Seeking Blue Esthetics. American Journal of resin composites. J. Prosthet Dent 2005; 93:
Esthetic Dentistry 2013; 3: 100-11. 260–266.

Max Schmeling DDS, MS, PhD¹

1. Federal University of Santa Catarina (UFSC), Brazil.


Collaborator Professor of Federal University of Santa Catarina (UFSC), Brazil.
Head of Operative Dentistry Department of Central Dental Clinics of Brazilian Army -
OCEx, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Email: bluemax@globo.com

Attribution (BY-NC) - (BY) You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were
made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggest the licensor endorses you or your
use. (NC) You may not use the material for commercial purposes.

41-49, 2016. ISSN:1659-1046.


40 ODOVTOS-Int. J. Dent. Sc. | No.18-2: 23-40,

You might also like