You are on page 1of 55

Chapter 1

INTRODUCTION

Rationale of the Study

Nowadays, people are generating business through street vending and had helped
people to create an investment. Street Vendors has also added contributions to the growth of
economy around the world. According to nasvinet.org, street vendor defined as: “A street
vendor is a person who offers goods or services for sale to the public without having a
permanently built structure but with a temporary static structure or mobile stall (or head-
load).” Aside from being a source of self-employment, Street vendors are also in demand for
range of services by informal workers, transport workers, tea sellers, market porters, security
guards, recyclers and more (Roever & Skinner, 2016). Although street vending is a form of
an illegal activity because they are not permitted by the authorities yet street vendors are
considered as beneficiary towards middle class group since they offer low range prices
(Bhowmik, 2005).

A study conducted by Morales (2009) states that street vendors boosts the quality of
life to urban areas and promote social interaction in which street vendors stimulate and
approach customers to purchase their goods. Street vending is also advantageous in endorsing
our culture and tradition other than being a profitable to the growth of economy.

Forthwith, in Portland, Oregon, cooking school graduates start their business in a chain
store with the exception of constructing expensive building that would create only a huge cost
for the expenses compared to street vending which a food cart is only being used and later,
their business expanded and now they have upgraded it into a restaurant (Deleye, 2010).

Lastly, Deleye (2010) claims that vendors can help to allure buyers because there have
been a boost of sales earned by shopfront businesses closeness to the number of street vendors.
Street vendors tend to compliment with the same business with their other fellow street
vendors to encourage customers that they can be in favour with other various businesses. We
can observe that there is an economic cooperation in which they can benefit with each other.

Many people became successful because of street vending, although it is an illegal


activity since they are not authorized by any form of agency in government yet they give
contributions in terms of raising the economy and offering low cost food for the urban people.
Overall the case study titled as “Vendor Management Strategies and its Benefit” which are

1
ABM students covers one of their major which is ABM. The outcome of this study will be
harnessed as a basis for the students and the street vendors who can read of their study to have
knowledge and to know what are outstanding strategies in vendor management to improve a
business.

2
Theoretical Background of the Study

To survive, business needs to plan carefully their strategic approaches. Therefore,


strategic plans have to be prepared purposefully for effective and efficient implementation of
their set objectives. The benefits of designing and putting into effect a strategic plan cannot
be overemphasized.

The researcher's theory for the study is the Vendor Management Theory which is the
possible and coherent set of tested principles, practices or propositions that act as an abstract
but scientific baseline for teaching, learning, implementing, and practicing the discipline
known as vendor management in what is generally considered to be acceptable, predictable
and appropriate manner.

The first theory in strategic management of vendors is the contingency theory: this
theory states that managing a small business has no best way as it has external and internal
factors that will affect the business. Usually, small business subjected to this theory because
their environment and their competitors frequently changes. This will affect small businesses
severely and quickly than of the large organization. Market change, regulations, customer's
needs and competitors are factors that managers of small firms should deal every day and set
management strategy to current situation (Rodriguez, 2010)

The second theory is the Chaos theory: this theory is mainly about the small firm's
certain changes in its operating cycle and its progress. Small business managers can use chaos
theory as they are more sensitive to changes in environment. In small firms, managers make
changes in their roles more often than large businesses to adopt new environment. When a
small firm faces a new challenge, manager should use his/ her limited resources to solve the
problem or change the roles (Mason, 2016)

The researchers also include Strategic Management Models that the end result of each model
is the strategy used up by vendor’s business owners.

The Rayport and Jaworski model considers setting goals premised on a business goals.
Driven by the need to do internal and external (industry) analysis, strategies are formulated
zeroing in on business strategies then down to a particular business unit. The set of strategies
is then implemented or executed followed by control and monitoring tasks to determine the
level of effectiveness of the strategies.

3
The model advocated by Pitts and Lei (2000) resembles that of Rayport and Jaworski
model that also considers the importance of analysis of external and internal environment
before missions and policies are set. The model comes in four tasks commencing with analysis
of the external/ internal environment as the first task followed by formation of strategy as the
second task. The model has implementation as its third task, followed by adjustment and
evaluation as the fourth task. In this model, feedback is encouraged at each level or task just
like the other models discussed.

Whichever of the strategic management models is used or looked upon, the end result
in going through the model is the strategy. More appropriately, the end result of a strategic
planning is often referred to as the strategic plan which is a must for all believers of strategic
management principles as part of the culture of the business organization.

Strategic management is a continuous process of strategy creation like strategic


analysis, decision-making, strategy formulation and implementation and strategy control with
the primary objectives of achieving and maintaining better alignment of corporate policies,
priorities and success. Strategic analysis consists of a systematic evaluation of variables
currently existing in the external and internal environments while strategic decision- making
is deliberately bringing together the right resources for the right time. Strategy formulation is
designing strategies on the business and corporate levels. Strategy implementation is
employing these crafted strategies to achieve organizational set goals and objectives while
strategic control is the application of an appropriate monitoring and feedback system. (Young,
2015).

4
Problem Statement

The purpose of this narrative case study is to explore what strategies have been
performed in order to succeed in business starting from a small vendor chain to a big store
from a renounce vendor and see how strategic planning can affect the growth of your
business. Specifically, it answers the following problems:

1. How do the respondents describe their experience as a street hawker?

2. What are vendor management strategies of the respondent?

3. How do the respondents practice consistency?

Significance of the Study

The study “Vendor Management strategies and its benefits” is significant to the
following beneficiaries.

First students will have an additional knowledge on how to start their future
businesses by knowing the strategies. This will serve as guide for students when they will
have an upcoming business.

Second, Business owners will be informed on how to sustain consistency in a


particular business by knowing the strategies. This study might be helpful in improving their
business.

Third, street Vendors especially those who failed in their business. And by knowing
these strategies, they will be aware on how to professionally handle their business again.

Last but not the least, the future researchers, through this study they will have more
knowledge in the course of business specifically the vendor management strategies. By this
study, they will create more improvements when in it comes to the process of conducting their
next study.

Scope and Limitations

The study “Vendor Management strategies and its benefits” only focuses on a street
vendor who successfully managed his/her business. The renounce street vendor will explain

5
what strategies have been performed. The gathered data are analysed in a narrative way in
order to determine what management strategies is being performed in that particular business.
The primary data gathering method will be in depth-interviews and participatory observation.

Definition of Terms

Competitive - relating to or characterized by competition.

Informal Sector - A sector which encompasses all jobs which are not recognized as normal
income sources, and on which taxes are not paid

Inventory - a complete list of items such as property, goods in stock, or the contents of
building.

Management - the process of dealing with or controlling things or people.

Mediating - intervene between people in a dispute in order to bring about an agreement or


reconciliation.

Offshore - made, situated, or conducting business abroad, especially in order to take


advantage of lower costs or less stringent regulation.

Retailer - a person or business that sells goods to the public in relatively small quantities for
use or consumption rather than for resale.

Strategic - relating to the identification of long-term or overall aims and interests and the
means of achieving them.

Supplier- a person or organization that provides something needed such as a product or


service.

Vendor- a person or company offering something for sale, especially a trader in the street.

6
Chapter 2

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND RELATED STUDIES

For Vendor’s Business owners having a strategic management utilizes resources


efficiently of one’s business and achieves a stated goal at a minimum cost and maximum goal.
To survive, business needs to plan carefully their strategic approaches. Therefore, strategic
plans have to be prepared purposefully for effective and efficient implementation of their set
objectives. The benefits of designing and putting into effect a strategic plan cannot be
overemphasized.

Street vendors, according to Bhowmik (2005), are business owners without stable
economic structure. Though there are many sellers who sell products, there are still street
vendors who sell products, as well as provide service (Bromley, 2000).

According to Cross (2000), informal economy deals with people without any legal
backing, illegal occupation of place in business, absence of tax returns, no employment
contract and no legal contract among suppliers and clients. In the same vein, Baumann and
Kaiser (2012, pp. 3-4), have catalogued features associated with informal sector: Lack of legal
protection, limited access to formal/ regulated markets and subsidies, high interest rates for
loans, no separation of person and business entity, contracts are not written and earnings are
consumed directly.

Competitive advantage is an instance wherein the business gain certain benefits,


attracting customers and have increase profit as well. In addition to this, Besanko, Dranove,
and Shamley (2000), asserts that a firm gains competitive advantage when it obtains profit
higher than its average profit in the operation. Also, Bateman and Snell (2011) suggests that,
to survive and win, you have to gain advantage over your competitors and earn a profit. You
gain competitive advantage by being better than your competitors at doing valuable things for
your customers.

Vendor's business are sometimes engaged in networking as it helps them to access


financial resources, knowledge/ skills and to source physical capital or information, as well as
defend market position, profit and risk and benefits (Great LA Former, Botta, Grenoula &
Campagne, 2007). As of Reddy (2015), engaged in networking will be open to opportunities
for new relationship, link or markets and access to new or complimentary competencies.

7
Street vendors uses multiple undifferentiated market strategy in where the vendors sell
two or more goods at the same time using the same promotional package like advertising. Its
targeted buyer is everybody as they think that all customers need their goods or they have
similar needs (Amoah-Mensah, 2016). However, according to Bateman and Snell (2011),
customers can demand lower prices, higher quality, unique product specifications or better
service. They also can play competitors against one another, as occurs when a buyer collects
different offer and negotiates for the best price.

The results revealed in the study of Amoah-Mensah (2016) that vendors sell
convenient products. These are goods that are less expensive and readily available to purchase.
The vendors sell these convenient goods for two main reasons- as a strategic reason because
goods can be easily sold and has a low capital. Selling convenient products also suggest that
street vendors want to meet the needs of a customer. But, as years pass by, the importance of
quality and the standards for acceptance quality have increased. Customers now demand high
quality goods and services and often they will accept nothing less. Historically, quality
pertained primarily to the physical goods that customers bought, and it referred to
attractiveness, lack of defects, reliability and long-term dependability (Bateman and Snell,
2011).

In the study entitled "Street vending and Competitive Advantage towards building a
theoretical framework" by Amoah-Mensah (2016), vendors cease up the operation, depending
on the circumstances in which may force to engage in "dying and resurrecting". They are also
indicated that they normally come back to business after some time. The span of time during
break gives the owner an opportunity to plan strategies and to get back to business with
renewed energy and vigour. It emerged from the study that some vendors genuinely exhilarate
business because of management reasons, economic hardships or competition. This supports
the assertion of Kamunge, Njeru and Tirimba (2014) that management is always the main
factor in business failure. However, this is not always the case, as study finds the vendors do
business for specific purpose after which they told up.

One strategy of street vendors is employing changes of goods and services sold. The
shift to a new product selling or both items depends on the occasions. Similarly, Dharma and
Sushi (2010) also infer that in order for the business to compete efficiently, they have to be
productive and develop strategies to adopt the prevailing conditions. In the same vein,

8
Walsh (2010) asserts that some vendors are flexible and therefore vary their products
and location of doing business. The business must adopt to change in customers’ demands and
to new competitors at doing valuable things for your customers. Products don’t sell forever;
in fact, they don’t sell for nearly as long as they used to, because so many competitors are
introducing so many new products all the time. Business must innovate, or it will die.
Likewise, you have to be ready with new ways to communicate with customers and deliver
product to them. Sometimes the most important innovation isn’t in the product itself but the
way it is delivered (Bateman and Snell, 2011).

Vendors noted one major strategy they adopt is the exploitation of flexible operating
hours. Thus, they do not have specific hours of working, rather, they decide to work long or
short depending on the circumstances. In addition, owners should be more flexible than large
firms in order to be able to responds customer's needs and develop strategic planning to adopt
prevailing conditions (Sharma and Sushi, 2010). This supports the assertion of Bateman and
Snell (2011), that rapid execution, response, and delivery of results – often separates the
winners from the losers. Business cannot get sloppy in your quest to be first. But other things
being equal, faster companies are more likely to be the winners, slow ones the losers. Speed
is no longer just a goal of some companies; it is a strategic imperative.

Another strategy adopted by vendors is the cost-based pricing strategy in which case
determines the selling price of the items. These include the expenses, made in purchasing
goods, the profit margin, and the type of good sold (Amoah-Mensah, 2016). But according to
Bateman (2011), it is not only for the profit margin and type of good sold but offer a desirable
product at a lower price that it is more likely to sell. Managing your costs and keeping it down
requires being efficient: accomplishing your goals by using your resources wisely and
minimizing waste.

Street vendors embark upon sales promotion as a strategic mechanism. This suggests
that sales promotion is a profitable venture for street vendors. According to Kotler and
Armstrong (2008), firms conducted sales promotion so that more goods are sold and disposed
of faster.

Street vendors get their goods either from retailers or wholesalers and pay at a future
date as agreed upon by both parties. This strategy is called Trade Credit which basically based
on trust. This claims that vendor has cheaper sources which are from retailers and wholesalers.
According to Demirguc-Kunt and Maksimovic (2002) defines trade credit as an alternative to

9
bank credit and is important source of finance in business. Similarly, Miwa and Ramseyer
(2005) asserts that vendors or business owners choose trade credit strategy as it easily secure
the money of operation.

According to Walsh (2010), some street vendors are flexible and so vary their products
and location of transacting business to new places where business may be booming. It emerged
that the vendors situate themselves in strategic location in order to attract people to buy more.
The street vendors, especially the mobile one, immediately relocate themselves to new places
where they think would be best.

Street vendors should continue to adopt situations and the environment, to enable them
serve their customer better. As stated by Golden and Powell (2000), flexibility as strategy and
operation procedures will react efficiently to known and unknown changes in the market.

Having multiple undifferentiated products strategy will be a big help assisting vendors
to cut down cost as the same advertising strategy. According to Mcdaniel, Lam Jr., & Hair, Jr.
(2007), that in the marketing literature, the term undifferentiated strategy is used to denote the
practice where a firm targets everybody and sells one product with marketing mix.

Katz and Green (2009) states that the strategy may be for planning or a standard to
compete action against. Either way, strategy defines you, your customers and your
competition how your business operates. Strategy in small businesses is special because most
small businesses are more than innovative.

A study entitled: 'Exploring the benefits of vendor managed inventory' considers the
concept of vendor managed inventory (VMI). It shows the implementation of vendor
managed inventory program has the capacity restriction of suppliers that should be taken into
consider even though they have not participated in the planning. There is a condition that if
the retailer does not provide additional information to the distributer to resolve doubts in the
firm, it would create reductions in the savings of market demand realized by VMI. Overall,
VMI provides nearly the same level of performance increase as long as the ratio of the
retailers lead time to that of the suppliers remains constant (Sari, 2007)

A study of Liu and Benhard (2005) examines the customer value perceptions when
sourcing from multiple vendors. The study is entitled 'Vendor managed inventory: a fashion
fad or important supply chain strategy?'. This shows that there are sourcing behaviour
proposing that customer value, customer satisfaction, and perceived switching cost influence

10
these share of business purchase decisions. Asserts that valuing customer for business service
has three dimensions: economical value, value of core services and value of support services.
It suggest that in newer relationship, the most critical factor, influencing share allocation is
the customer value. In older relationships, customer value are all important in allocating small
businesses.

According to Palvia et. al. (2010), vendor's perspective is equally important as


offshore IS vendors need to make necessary decisions in terms of the operation and strategic
planning and the aligning of resources and processes in order to meet or exceed targeted
goals. The study claimed that there are three levels of capability-quality-performance
theoretical framework to understand vendor outcomes and their antecedents. First level
represent three vendor capabilities: relationship management, contract management and
information technology management. The second has three mediating variables representing
quantity: partnership, service, and deliverable quality. The third level has dependent variables
corresponding vendor outcomes: operational performance, strategic performance and
satisfaction. Results supports that CQP framework; vendor capabilities are significant
predictors’ of intermediate quality measures, which in term affect vendor outcomes.

Another literature on supply chain management entitled 'A contingent approach to the
design of vendor selection systems from different types of cooperative customer/supplier
relationship'. Masella and Rangone (2000) integrates about the stressingly needing for the
cooperation and integration among suppliers and customers, highlighting the role of the
supplier to the overall performance of the purchaser. The paper proposes four different
vendor systems depending on the time span it takes (short term or long term) and the content
(logistical or strategic) of the relation between customer and supplier. The suggested vendor
systems consider, hierarchy process framework, sets of measure, depravity from a
nonconventional/model of the supplier based on the dynamic systems and on the resource-
based approach.

Study examines the strategies adopted by street vendors or hawked in Ghana in a bid
to gain competitive advantage. This study is entitled ' Street Vending and Competitive
Advantage: towards building a theoretical framework' finds that 10 strategies were adopted
by the street vendors- networking, multiple undifferentiated market strategy, the sale of
convenient products, "dying and resurrecting" (strategic exit and return into business),
regular changing of goods and services, exploitation of flexible operating hours, cost-based

11
pricing strategy, sales promotion, trade credit and vocational advantage- to gain the desirable
competitive advantage. Using the different strategies, theories of street vendor's competitive
strategies are developed (Mensah, 2016)

Another was of a study entitled 'Towards a Design theory for customer satisfaction-
oriented IT vendor management'. The study asserts that positive customer experienced with
supplied products and service rendered to achieve customer satisfaction is important.
Customer's experience refers to the viewpoint and feelings towards a product, system or
service as a result of direct interaction (McCarthy and Wright, 2004). Customer experience
is influenced by subjective antecedents such as sensual and emotional factors, customer
expectations and perceptions, experiences, and product or service quality (Bitner 1990; Brady
and Cronim Jr., 2001). The study suggest that in order to address customer satisfaction
challenges related to in the action planning phase- a vendor management system (VEMS)
which is a competitive set of principles that seek to enhance customer satisfaction by
addressing customer experience.

A study entitled: 'Exploring the benefits of vendor managed inventory' considers the
concept of vendor managed inventory (VMI). It shows the implementation of vendor
managed inventory program has the capacity restriction of suppliers that should be taken into
consider even though they have not participated in the planning. There is a condition that if
the retailer does not provide additional information to the distributer to resolve doubts in the
firm, it would create reductions in the savings of market demand realized by VMI. Overall,
VMI provides nearly the same level of performance increase as long as the ratio of the
retailers lead time to that of the suppliers remains constant (Sari, 2007)

A study conducted by Liu and Benhard (2005) examines the customer value
perceptions when sourcing from multiple vendors. The study is entitled 'Vendor managed
inventory: a fashion fad or important supply chain strategy?'. This shows that there are
sourcing behaviour proposing that customer value, customer satisfaction, and perceived
switching cost influence these share of business purchase decisions. Asserts that valuing
customer for business service has three dimensions: economical value, value of core services
and value of support services. It suggests that in newer relationship, the most critical factor,
influencing share allocation is the customer value. In older relationships, customer value are
all important in allocating small businesses.

12
A research conducted by Palvia et. al (2010) a study about 'The capability, Quality and
Performance of offshore IS vendors: A theoretical Framework on Empirical Investigation'.
The study talks about having information systems (IS) offshoring for some business firms
that becomes a practice strategic choice for many firms. The vendor's perspective is equally
important as offshore IS vendors need to make necessary decisions in terms of the operation
and strategic planning and the aligning of resources and processes in order to meet or exceed
targeted goals. The study claimed that there are three levels of capability-quality-performance
theoretical framework to understand vendor outcomes and their antecedents. First level
represent three vendor capabilities: relationship management, contract management and
information technology management. The second has three mediating variables representing
quantity: partnership, service, and deliverable quality. The third level has dependent variables
corresponding vend outcomes: operational performance, strategic performance and
satisfaction. Results supports that CQP framework; vendor capabilities are significant
predictors of intermediate quality measures, which in term affect vendor outcomes

Masella and Rangone (2000) states that there is another literature on supply chain
management entitled 'A contingent approach to the design of vendor selection systems from
different types of cooperative customer/supplier relationship'. The study integrates about the
stressingly needing for the cooperation and integration among suppliers and customers,
highlighting the role of the supplier to the overall performance of the purchaser. The paper
proposes four different vendor systems depending on the time span it takes (short term or
long term) and the content (logistical or strategic) of the relation between customer and
supplier. The suggested vendor systems consider, hierarchy process framework, sets of
measure, derivate from a nonconventional/model of the supplier based on the dynamic
systems and on the resource-based approach.

A study examines the strategies adopted by street vendors or hawked in Ghana in a bid
to gain competitive advantage. This study is entitled ' Street Vending and Competitive
Advantage: towards building a theoretical framework' finds that 10 strategies were adopted
by the street vendors- networking, multiple undifferentiated market strategy, the sale of
convenient products, "dying and resurrecting" (strategic exit and return into business),
regular changing of goods and services, exploitation of flexible operating hours, cost-based
pricing strategy, sales promotion, trade credit and vocational advantage- to gain the desirable
competitive advantage. Using the different strategies, theories of street vendor's competitive
strategies are developed (Mensah, 2016)

13
Sixth, the study entitled 'Towards a Design theory for customer satisfaction-oriented
IT vendor management'. The study asserts that positive customer experienced with supplied
products and service rendered to achieve customer satisfaction is important. Customer's
experience refers to the viewpoint and feelings towards a product, system or service as a
result of direct interaction (McCarthy and Wright, 2004).

Raj (2017) in his case study titled “Indigenous Management Practices- A Case Study
on Street Vendor” he mentioned seven successful practices of a substinence vendor which
are the following: network, providing value propositions, effective word of mouth,
adaptivity, critical need identification, localized productions or sourcing, and proximity and
flexible terms of purchase. Network refers to have a close knit relationship between the
sellers and buyers. Interaction between a buyer and seller plays a bigger role compared to
product and service because there is a significance of mixing the economic and social
relationships. Second is Providing value propositions, which is to identify the customer’s
need and satisfaction. Third is effective word of mouth, which refers to having a good
communication skill in promoting your product or service. Fourth is adaptivity, which refers
to be tolerant in accepting for a change in assessing the customer’s need. Fifth is to examine
the customer’s critical needs which refers to adjusting the cost of the product to your
customer’s income that will offer them a reasonable price. Sixth is localized productions or
sourcing that refers to purchase your products by a wholesaler or manufacturer to offer low
prices to your customers and lastly which is proximity and flexible terms of purchase, An
ability and the will to offer credit-short term and long terms to your customers .

Similar to the study of Rupolia and et. al., (n.d.) they also mentioned strategies that
street vendors from Mumbai, India have used in promoting their products which are the
following: attractive display, pamphlets, calling-out, attractive offers, word of mouth and
personal selling. Among all the strategies, the most effective one for street vendors in Mumbai,
India is the ‘word of mouth’ that means a customer is urged to buy your products that a story
expands exponentially.

Another strategy conducted by Milgram (2011) that street vendors have used to
maintain a space for business is to expect the schedules of regulars. In the northern
Philippines, Baguio City, street vendors during the morning will start from 6 a.m. to 9 a.m.
while in the afternoon will start at 12 p.m. until 1 p.m. and in the evening, 5 p.m. to 8 p.m.
and will only close when regulars are not to be expected.

14
Alice Escalante de Cruz (2002) in her article "The Street Food Sector in Asia and the
Pacific" reported on the growth of the Street vendors and the growing number of urban poor
and the mobilization of women into the work force. Street foods are not only far cheaper than
restaurants or fast food joints, but actually much more cost-effective than even home prepared
food. Many women are participating in the economy and this has constrained their ability to
prepare elaborate meals for their families at home, this necessitating them to procure street
foods as a supplement to other home cooked food. The street food trade provides numerous
employment opportunities. Street food vending has been known to generate income a few
times above those on the poverty line in many developing countries. The street foods trade
has provided income to many small farmers who supply these food vendors with local
produce thus stimulating and generating employment in the agricultural sector. The consumer
generally welcomed street vended foods as a source of easy accessibility, relatively safe,
affordable, nutritious and delicious, be it snacks, supplement or full meal.3'

Overall, the literatures and related studies provide information related to the strategic
management of vendors. Also, it gives the business and researcher the opportunity to assess
the mille and specify strategies to achieve their goals. Strategic planning helps organization
to stay focused. Furthermore, strategic planning helps reduce the chances of committing
mistakes, thus, increasing the business’ efficiency. While strategic planning has its
advantages, it also has its limitation. Although conducted yearly or even more after, the
strategic plans prepared in some instances are good only “in paper”. Some businesses fail to
follow faithfully their prepared strategic plans. If in cases these strategic plans are followed
religiously, some business’ may not be flexible enough to make the needed adjustments and
realignments due to inevitable or forthcoming external and internal challenges.

15
Chapter 3

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Research Design

The research design of the researcher’s study “Vendor Management and its strategies
and benefits” is a qualitative research. Qualitative research interprets and analyze the
particular encounters of the respondents in a study. In collecting the data, we use in-depth
interviews and participatory observation as our instruments to distinguish the street vendor’
strategies and benefits on managing the business. The data collected will come from the
answers of the respondent.

This type of study is narrative study because it illustrates the respondent’s knowledge
and their awareness about the topic. Narrative study gathers information that is written or
spoken by someone that expresses opinion about a certain topic. The researchers choose this
type of study to deliver and to know more of the things that this study seeks to answer and to
only rely to the information coming from the persons who are responsible for this study.

Research Setting

Research setting is the location where the respondents correspond to the interview.
This research was conducted outside the University of Cebu namely: Brgy Apas, Cebu CIty.
In which the street vendors in Apas were chosen because the respondents were used to be
street vendors and now owns a legal and permanent business. The chosen research setting
contributes and fits our study since the environment of this location is filled with business
establishments.

Research Participant

The research participant are the person who are involved who are capable of answering
the questions. According The University of Arizona Human Subjects Protection Program
(HSPP) A research participant is also called a human subject or study participant. It is a person
who participates in human subject research by being the target of observation by researchers
(n.d., para. 2).

These participants are renounce street vendor and eventually has their own formal
business. The participants of this study are three street vendors who are business owners

16
located in the Brgy. Apas, Cebu City. The respondents are chosen because they have the ability
to answer and impart knowledge to this study,

Research Instrument

This study of Vendor Management Strategies and its Benefits uses the following
instrument: observation and interview or survey.

First, observation in which the researchers gather data in the act of carefully watching
and listening to the respondent's activities. The researchers will be conducting an observation
to oversee the actions of a vendor business owner during the transaction to distinguish and to
be aware to the strategies done by the owner.

Lastly, interview is a formal consultation usually to evaluate qualifications from the


respondent. The researchers will going to have an interview to obtain and evaluate information
from the owner about the strategies and benefits of managing his/her own business.

The research instruments aids the researcher the data and information to fullfil the
study and make it reliable, credible and satisfactorily to the people and community.

Interview Questions

1. What were your previous businesses?


2. What additional services would you add?
3. How do you manage conflict
4. What is your greatest accomplishment?
5. How did you start your business
6. What is your management style?
7. How would your past experiences translate into success in this job
8. How would you tackle the first 90 days
9. What is the process of you typically follow to make a decision about a plan of
action?
10. When giving two or three equally viable paths to achieve an object, how do you
decide which path to follow?
11. Have you ever delayed a decision making? then what were the consequences for
your business?

17
12. Do you make decisions on your own without input from others? When do you seek
advice from others when making decisions.
13. How do you ensure that task are successfully completed? Are they any steps to you
take?
14. How do you remain consistency as a business woman/man
15. What specific strategies have you used in running the business
16. What methods do you utilize to resolve problem?

Research Procedure

The Study’s proposal components will be drafted and undergo initial submission early
in semester. The team wants to acquire approbation of the research topic and the proposed
methodology after the semi-final of second (2nd semester). The data for this research were
collected through interview. The interview was created using a formal and realistic questions
formed by the researchers. The questions were composed of different thoughts and opinions
that are related to the statement problem. After the research teacher approved the interview
questionnaires, the researchers began to interview the Business owner regarding to their
strategies towards service failure. The researchers assured open conference to the business
owner since it is important to make the interview results factual and reliable. The researchers
also understood that business may encounter such typical problems according to its service
failure.

Data Analysis

Data Analysis is the process of bringing order, structure and meaning to the mass of
collected data. It is a messy, ambiguous, time-consuming, creative and fascinating process. It
does not proceed in a linear fashion; it is not neat. Qualitative Data Analysis is a search for
general statement about relationship among categories of data.

After conducting the interview, the researcher would analyse data answered by the
respondents by interpreting or summarizing the information given by the respondents. The
researcher would only state the management strategies and benefits contributed by the
respondents according to their experiences as a vendor business owner. The researchers would
want to know the how they executed their business that it maintains consistency. Also the
researcher would like to know the answers of the sub-problems stated in this study.

18
Chapter 4

DATA PRESENTATION, RESULTS AND INTERPRETATION

Management styles and strategies are the principles that bridge business owners even
vendors to cope and comprehend with the nature and challenges acquired by the business.
With the choses respondents of the researchers, the stated expectations are for the vendor
business owner to lay out different management strategies. The questions presented will help
the researchers to know more of the things that they study seek to answer.

Table 1: Interpretation of Data


1. What were your previous businesses?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Impoverishment “We sell Successfull
Magazine and business owners
Newspaper along started from selling
the road/ along the road as
sidewalk” vendors that earned
“We first started only a little profit
selling candies
and water along
the streets”
Extensions "Our business Business owners
started from a started from a
small shop and small firm until
now we had such time it grows.
extensions in our
business"

2. What additional services would you add?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Customer-oriented “We Added a little Business owners
grocery in our added additional
business eatery services to their
and added tables business to gain
and chairs for customers and
customers outside satisfies customers'
in our big grocery need
store.”
“ We add cool
ventilation and
free WiFi for
customers’
convenient”

19
Flexion " now we have Most business
branches here in owners produce
cebu" branches to
promote their
business more to
customers in other
locations.

3. How do you manage conflict?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Capitalization “When I encounter Business owner
conflict especially decreases their
in the number of capital to avoid
sales, I decrease losses in profit
the money for especially when
capital I use for a they encounter
certain period to conflict in
avoid losses in business.
profit”

Tranquillity “I closed the Business owner


business to have makes a plan on
them cool down how to manage
first and for me to and find solution
decide a solution regarding with the
for this conflict.” conflict of their
business.
Abatement " To manage Business owners
conflict, we offer offer discounts to
discount prices to the customers to
our customers manage their
when we do not conflict when it
have enough comes to their
customers" business.

4. What is your greatest accomplishment?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Eminence “Our business The business
gains its progress. owners were able
We we’re able to to help their
send our kids to families when it
school and have comes financial
them graduated. problems and also
Also, we we’re

20
able to buy house they have provided
and lots because of all of their needs.
this business.”
“I able to have
more branches
throughout Cebu
City and houses
for my parents”
" I was able to
save money to buy
house for myself
and my parents"

5. How did you start your business?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Accommodate “We borrow a The business
money from owners borrowed
someone to have a money to have a
stating capital for capital in starting
our business” up their business.
"We started in
November, 2016.
the place in our
business was still
a small space and
we just borrowed
money from other
as a capital"
Employment “I worked first to The business
established a owner used her
starting capital for salary in starting
this business” up her business.

6. What is your management style?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Inscribed “You need to have The business
an inventory in owners' strategy
which you can inidentifying the
manage and control gain and loss of
the gain and loss in their businessare
the transactions of through making
your business” inventories and
“I have managed encoding
inventory which is transactions.
encoded in my
computer in where I
can look after to any
gain and losses”

21
Pursuance "our The business
strategy/management owner's strategy is
style is to convince through
customers through convincing her
building relationship customers to buy
with the customers their products.
until they become
our wholesaler"

7. How would your past experiences translate into success in this job?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Learnedness “It gives me the the business
knowledge in more owners are
things related to persistent in
business and learn managing their
not to give up” businesses and
“It makes me learn they never give up
to not give up and so that they will
strive more after have a successful
learning mistakes business.
in the past for the
better future”
"I have learned
that this business
is going to be
stable as much as
possible and
always maintain
consistency"

8. How would you tackle the first 90 days?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Difficulty “ It was really The business
difficult at first but owners tried their
I still manage to best in advertising
adjust in the their businesses.
environment and
people surrounds
me. We strive hard
that time so that
people notice us.”
“I still need to
advertise my
business to
everyone which is
really difficult to
do as a beginner”

22
"It does not matter.
It depends if the
customer likes to
buy"

9. What is the process of you typically followed to make a decision about a plan of
action?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Assistance “I first talk to my The business
husband and then owners need to be
to my people. accompanied and
Lastly, I rationalize cooperation from
things up to come others before they
up a better make a final
decision” desicion. They go
“I talk to people through a thorough
whom are credible process.
and knowledgeable
enough that will
help me decide
things up”
"I will increase the
stocks by
contacting our
supplier if there is
an increase of
demand"

10. When giving two or three equally viable paths to achieve an object, how do you decide
which path to follow?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Decisions “I rationalize They go to a long
things up in which process of thinking
things will do in which they think
good or bad to my of possible
business” consequences of
“I first think of that certain
what that thing decision.
will do to my
business before
having a final
choice”
"I will choose the
right path"

23
11. Have you ever delayed a decision making? Then what were the consequences for your
business?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Procrastination ”Yes, and it Sometimes,
causes decrease of owners make a bad
our profit” decision and
“Yes, it causes further affect their
bankruptcy in our business. But still
business but still manage to revive
manage to revive and come up with
it” a solution for the
" Whenever I have consistency of the
a delayed decision business.
making. My
strategy is to sale
the products
through our social
sites"

12. Do you make decisions on your own without input from others? When do you seek
advice from others when making decisions?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Consultation “I take advice owners can't
from my husband decide by
which is my themselves but
partner in this tends to seek help
business and from from others in
my people all the where they will be
time to make a guided to the better
better decision” decision.
“I always take
advice from
people that can
help me in making
decisions.”
Self-involved "yes, since i am Sometimes, owner
the only one likes to decide
manage this their own to avoid
business" complicacy to any
decisions she will
be making.

13. How do you ensure those tasks are successfully completed? Are they any steps to you
take?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern

24
Assurance “ We have Owners manage
inventory in which and control their
we can see the supply of product
inflow and outflow and service
of product as well through making an
as the gain and inventory.
losses”
“I ensure task by
controlling and
regulating the
product I invest in
the business which
I can easily access
to my inventories”
" i do inventory so
that I will know
what account is
lacking"

14. How do you remain consistency as a business woman/man?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Hardwork “Strive hard and They are goal
have a specific oriented and have a
goal in your specific purpose in
business. Also doing the business.
remain consistent They strive hard to
in knowing the meet the goal and
needs and wants of profit expectations.
a customer”
“Learn not to give
up even if things
doesn’t work out
the way you
wanted”
"Just continue
with the business"

15. What specific strategies have you used in running the business?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Direction “Know the needs Business owner
and wants of the prioritize
customer in the customers'
specific area” necessities in that
“I specifically certain location
target customers’ and occasion.
needs”

25
Accessible “Sell convenient They sell products
products that are and services in an
readily and affordable and
available to sell” convenient to
“I sell cheap customer.
products but high
quality that are
convenient to
customers”
Alterability “We sometimes The owner have to
change the product change or add
depending on the products to
occasions” increase sales
“I change or add occasionally.
menu/ product in
my eatery
depending on what
the customers need
during that certain
period”
Flexibility “Need to be They work from
flexible during time to time to
working hours” entertain and
“Work flexibly satisfy customers
because people with their service.
need to be
entertain all the
time”
Elevation “Promote/ They advertise
advertise sales their product
through internet” through internet in
“I uploads photos which a lot of
and updates in our people will be
Facebook page to inform about the
promote our business.
business”

16. What methods do you utilize to resolve problem?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Cautious “Careful decision They go through a
making” long step by step
“Decide step by process to come up
step to avoid with a better
mistakes” decision.

26
Thematic Analysis

Along the course of researchers’ interpreting the date from the renounce street vendors
they are able to come up with these themes

Impoverishment

This occurs when street vendors started from doing small businesses such as selling
along the streets and road. This is the way that they could earn a living by starting from a small
business.

Extension

This means when a business started from small until eventually there are additional
extensions of the business and services for the customers.

Customer-Oriented

In order to gain customer satisfaction, by knowing the needs and wants of a customer.
It is one of the strategy in businesses to maintain sales.

Flexion

A strategy that a business utilize is to promote their business by expanding their


operations.

Capitalization

A strategy that a business applies is to lessen the amount of capital to lower the cost.
This technique is used when a cost is not predicted to be entirely consumed in the current
duration, but rather over an extended time frame.

Tranquillity

It the state of being calm and in peace. In order to fully focus on the marketing strategies
is to propose solutions in making improvements for the business

Abatement

Another strategy that a business applies is through lessening, reducting, and decreasing
the prices of the product or service. This will business owners to earn sales and to promote
their business.

27
Eminence

Business owners was able to attain their financial means and needs of their family
because of the progress that their business has made.

Accommodate

Borrowing money is another way to start up a capital for their business. This is another
technique for business owners to start their own business.

Employment

Before a business owner can earn a capital for their business is to start being an
employee until they can have a start-up capital for their business.

Inscribed

In order to identify losses and gain of their business, business owners tend to record their
transactions and by providing inventories so that they will be aware if there is an net loss or
net income.

Pursuance

A strategy of a business is through persuasion. A practice of a business which is by


building relationship to your customers.

Learnedness

This means that there will always be failures and achievement in every businesses. They
use their past experiences to recover and still be persistent from the catastrophes they had as
a business owner.

Difficulty

There are complication in starting a business because as a business owner you still have
to inspect if the business will be effective and there will be an additional expense for
advertisements and promoting the business.

Assistance

In making a decision, business owners tend to be accompanied while planning. This


method will help business owners to have an in-depth collaborative decision and also to create
decisions and plans on which is appropriate so no one will be affected.

28
Decisions

To decide is a complex part of a business owner because whatever decision they may
propose will have possible consequences. Business owners tend to have a long process in
planning a decision to be aware of what consequence they will be faced as much as possible

Procrastination

This occurs that business owners will also be delayed in making a decision. It is
inevitable to make bad decisions and thus will affect their business in spite of their decision
but eventually manages the business effectively.

Consultation

Some business owners do not fully rely on their own decisions. They tend to seek help
or be consulted by others to be guided in order to come up with a suitable decision.

Self-Involved

It happens when a business owner can decide a choice on their own without depending
others. They do not necessary need help from anyone to be guided in their decision because
they can make up a decision by their selves.

Assurance

This means to secure an inventory of the business to know gain and losses of the
business. This will help business owners to control and manage the supply of product and
service by proving an inventory.

Hard work

This happens when a business owner has goals for his or her business. This will
motivate them to work hard and meet their specific objectives.

Direction

This happens when a business owner aims to target the necessities of customers. This
will help the business owners to attract customer by knowing their needs.

Accessible

This means that by selling affordable services and products to the customers. It will
be convenient for customers by offering low-priced services and products

29
Alterability

This happens when there is an alteration of selling their services or products. They
tend to change or add something from their services and products to enlarge their sales
irregularly.

Flexibility

This means that you have to run the business according to the schedule of the
customers. They work from time to time to entertain and satisfy customers with their service.

Elevation

This means that business owners raise their services and products through the use of
social networking sites. They advertise their product through internet in which a lot of people
will be inform about the business.

Cautious

This happens when making a decision as a business owner is a crucial part of them.
They go through a long step by step process to come up with a better decision.

30
Chapter 5

SYNTHESIS

Summary of Findings

1. The responses of the successful street vendors describe their experiences as a street hawker
in different ways. Findings relate to the assumption of Amoah-Mensah (2016) that vendors
cease up the operation, depending on the circumstances in which may force to engage in
‘dying and resurrecting”. They indicate that they normally come back to business after some
time to decide a strategic plan after a conflict. According to Walsh (2010), some street vendors
are flexible and so vary their products and location of transacting business to new places where
business may be booming. Respondents situate themselves in strategic location in order to
attract people to buy more. Street vendors did not avoid difficulties and challenges in the first
90 days of selling along the street but still able to cope with it and gains progress afterwards.

2. Respondents performs different management styles and strategies to gain competitive


advantage wherein the business gain certain benefits, attract customers and have increase
profit as well. This strategies includes the making of inventory in which the owner can manage
and control the in and out flow of product and convincing customers through online. Results
relate to the literature written by Bateman and Snell (2011), that customers can demand lower
prices, higher quality, unique product specifications or better service. Responses shows that
customers’ demand should be targeted, and sells available and high quality product that is
convenient to customers. The vendors sell these convenient goods for two main reasons- as a
strategic reason because goods can be easily sold and has a low capital. Business owners
promote their products through internet to increase sales and production. In the same vein of
the findings and result, Walsh (2010) asserts that some vendors are flexible and therefore vary
their products and location of doing business. Respondents adopt to changes in customers’
demands and to new competitors at doing valuable things for customers.

3. Progress and accomplishments were developed through practicing and following faithfully
their prepared strategic plans. Respondents have gain benefits and consistency through
management styles and strategies that is being followed religiously and being flexible enough
to make the needed adjustments in the operation overcomes difficulties and challenges.

31
Conclusion
Theory proposed by Rodriguez (2010) was a support to the conclusions of the
researchers which is the contingency theory that a small business has its external and internal
factors that will affect the business because of the competitors and customers frequently
changes. Another theory is the Chaos theory by Mason (2016) that is mainly about the small
firm’s certain changes in its operating cycle and its progress.
The researchers concluded that preparing a management style and strategies is
important in the business. These strategies include making of inventory, target customers,
cost-based pricing strategy, flexibility, advertisement and promotion of product, and adaption
to changes in internal and external environment of the business. To remain consistence and
gain benefits from the business, business owners needs to plan carefully their strategic
approaches. Therefore, strategic plans have to be prepared purposefully for effective and
efficient implementation of their set objectives.

Recommendation

The researchers want to recommend the following:

1. Students to comprehend the nature of doing business. To be aware in the internal and
external factors in the business to effectively and efficiently cope with the business challenges
as a beginner.
2. Business owners to use the study as a guide to operative run of business. To understand
different types of situations and benefits in the business.
3. Vendors to recognize different strategies to be applied in the business to cope with the
different challenges from the business.
4. Future researchers should expand and improve knowledge possessed in this study. To add
more respondents and to look more theories for an efficient research study.

32
WORKS CITED

Books

Besanko, D., Dranove, D., & Shamley, M. (2000). Economics of Strategy (2nd edition).
NewYork, NY: Wiley and Sons.

Bhownik, S.K. (2005). Street Vendors in Asia: A review of Economics and Political Weekly.
40(22), 2256-2264

de Cruz, A. E. (2002). The Street Food Sector in Asia and the Pacific. In Consumer
International. Kuala Lumpur.

Demirgue-Kunt, A., & Maksimovic, V. (2002). Firms as financial intermediaries: Evidence


from the trade credit data. College Durk, MD: University of Maryland Working
Puper..

Kotler, P, & Armstrong, G. (2010). Principles of marketing (13th editorial). NewYork, NY:
Pearson Education Incorporated.

McCarthy. J., and Wright, P. (2004). “Technology of Experience”, Interactions (11:5), pp. 42-
43.

McDaniel, C., Lamo, C., & Hair, J.F., Jr. (2007). Marketing essential (5th edition)) Masoo,
OH: South Western.

Journals

Bitner, M.J. (1990). Evaluating service encounters: The effects of Physical Surrounding and
Employee Responses. The Journal Marketing (54:2), pp. 69-82.

Brady, M.K., and Cronin Jr, J.J (2001). Some New Thoughts on Conceptualizing Perceived
Service Quality: A Hierarchical Approach. The Journal of Marketing (65:3), pp. 34-
39.

Bromley, R. (2000). Street Vending and Public Policy: A global review. International Journal
of Sociology and Social Policy, 20 (1/2), 1-28.

Cross, C.J. (2000). Street Vendors and Post modernity: Conflicts and Compromise in the
global economy. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy. 20(1/2), 29-
51.

33
Deley, A. (2010). Public Markets, Street Vendors and. Downtownn Economics(162).
Kamunge, M.S., Njeru, A., & Kirimba, O.L. (2014). Factors affecting the performance of
small and micro enterprises in Limsutown market of Kariba country, Kenya.
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, 4(12), 1-20.

Morales, A., & Kettles, G. (2009). Zoning for Public Markets and Street Vendors. Zoning
Practice, 25(2), 1-8.
Milgram, B. L. (2011). Reconfiguring space, mobilizing livelihood: Street vending, legality,
and work in the Philippines. Journal of Developing Societies, 27, 261-293.
doi:10.1177/01697 96X1102700403

Reddy, R.S. (2015). Strategic management of small firms. International Journal in


Management and Social Science, 3(3), 51-68.

Rupolia, M., Richa, C., & Purohit, H. (n.d.). A Study on Promotional Strategies Adopted by
Apparel Street. IOSR Journal of Business Management (IOSR-JBM), 20-27.

Walsh, J. (2010). The street Vendors of Bangkok: Alternative to indoor retailers a time of
economic crisis. American Journal of Economics and Business Administration, 2(2).
185-188.

Online Sources

Amoah-Mensah, A. (2016). Street Vending and Competitive Advantage: Towards Building


Theoretical Framework. The Qualitative Report, 21(9), 1651-1673. Retrieved from
http://usuworks.nova.edu/tas/vol21/iss9/6.

Baumann, F.A., & Kaiser, J. (2012). International study vocational education and training
(VET) in the informal sector. RIPA- Resau Interregional pour Adaptation de la
Formation Bf2 gGmbH International Division. Retrieved from www.rifa-
eu.org/medialb/9392/20308/eudecomparativeInformel.eng.pdf.

Benhard, K., &Liu, A. (2005). Examining customers’ value perception of organization buyers
when sourcing from multiple vendors. Journal of Business Research, Vol. 58, Issue:
5, Retrieved from https://doi.org/101016/j.jburses.2003.09.010.

34
Keerthan Raj. (2017). Indigenous Management Practices- A Case Study on Street Vendors.
International Journal of Case Studies in Business, IT and Education (IJCSBE), 1(2),
29–36. http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.914458

Masella, C., Rangone, A. (2000). A contingent approach to the design of vendor selection
systems from different types of cooperative customer/supplier relationships.
International Journal of Operations and Production and Management, Vol. 20 Issue:
1, pp. 70-84. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.9108/01443570010287044.

Mason, W.H. (2016). Chaos Theory. Reference for Business. Retrieved from
http://www.referenceforbusiness.com/management/bun.lump/chaos.Theory.html.

Palvia, C., et.al. (2010). Capability, Quality and Performance of offshore IS vendors: A
theoretical Framework and Empirical Investigation. Wiley Online Library.
Retrieved from onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.111/j.1540-
5195.2010.00268.y/abstract.

Rodriguez, P. F. (2010). Contingency Management Theory. Business.com. Retrieved from


https://www.business.com/management-theory/contingecy-management-theory/.

Sari, K. (2007). Exploring the benefits of vendor managed inventory. International Journal
of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, Vol. 37 Issue: 7, pp. 529-645,
https://doi.org/10.1108/0960003071070776464.

Skinner, C., & Roever, S. (2016). Street Vendors and Cities. Environment and Urbanization,
28(2). doi:. DOI: 10.1177/0956247816653898

The International Foundation for Information Technology (2004). Dictionary of terms and
Phrases. Retrieved from
https://www.if4it.com/SYNTHESIZED/GLOSSARY/v/vendor_mangement_Theo
ry.html

The University of Arizona Human Subjects Protection Program. (n.d.). Retrieved from
Research Getaway - University of Arizona:
https://rgw.arizona.edu/compliance/human-subjects-protection-program/research-
participants

35
Appendices
Appendix A: Letter of Permission to Conduct Research Interview
January 26, 2018

Ms. Maleen Grafilo – Ordiz


Principal, Senior High School Department
University of Cebu – Banilad
Banilad, Cebu City

RE: Permission to Conduct Research Interview

Madame:

We, the students of the Senior High School Department of University of Cebu – Banilad Campus are writing this letter to ask
permission to conduct a research interview in your department for our research Practical Research 1/ABM as a requirement
for graduation for the 2nd semester of the school year 2017-2018.
We hope that you will allow us to have three participants for this research. Due to the nature of the study, we hope to have
renounce street vendors for the said interview. Your approval to conduct this study will be greatly appreciated in your most
convenient time. Attached is the questionnaire for the interview.

Thank you and more power!

Sincerely,

Researchers:

Lead Researcher: Rose Anne Seballo - ____________________


Asst. Lead Researcher: Charwyne G. Mascarinas - _____________________
Research Associate/Member: Kirby Kent Pradilla- ____________________
Research Associate/Member: Megan Camille Florentino - ____________________
Research Associate/Member: Marissa Tan - ____________________

Noted by:

AIRIS KIM CODIÑERA


Research Instructor, Senior High School
University of Cebu – Banilad

Approved by:

MALEEN GRAFILO-ORDIZ
Principal, Senior High School Department
University of Cebu – Banilad

36
Appendix B: Research Interview Consent Form

RESEARCH INTERVIEW CONSENT FORM


Research Title: Vendor Management Strategies and its Benefits

Researchers’ Name and Contact Information:


Seballo, Rose-Anne 09227213577
Mascarinas, Charwyne 09481659833
Tan, Marissa 09266551422
Florentino, Megan
Pradilla Kirby Kent 09169747163

Please put a tick on the box.

I confirm that I have read and understand the information sheet for the above
study and have had the opportunity to ask questions and clarifications on the
matter of the interview/anything that concerns me.

I understand that my participation is voluntary and that I am free to withdraw


at any time, without giving reason.

I agree to take part in the above study and share everything I know to contribute
to the success of the said research.

Note for researchers:


Include the following statements if appropriate, or leave it blank if otherwise.

Please put a tick on the box.


YES NO

I agree to the interview/focus group/consultation being audio recorded.

I agree to the interview/focus group/consultation being video recorded.

I agree to the use of anonymized quotes in publications.

__________________________________ ______________ __________________


Name of Research Participant Date Signature

37
Research Title: Vendor Management Strategies and its Benefits

Researchers’ Name and Contact Information:


Seballo, Rose-Anne 09227213577
Mascarinas, Charwyne 09481659833
Tan, Marissa 09266551422
Florentino, Megan
Pradilla Kirby Kent 09169747163

Please put a tick on the box.

I confirm that I have read and understand the information sheet for the above
study and have had the opportunity to ask questions and clarifications on the
matter of the interview/anything that concerns me.

I understand that my participation is voluntary and that I am free to withdraw


at any time, without giving reason.

I agree to take part in the above study and share everything I know to contribute
to the success of the said research.

Note for researchers:


Include the following statements if appropriate, or leave it blank if otherwise.

Please put a tick on the box.


YES NO

I agree to the interview/focus group/consultation being audio recorded.

I agree to the interview/focus group/consultation being video recorded.

I agree to the use of anonymized quotes in publications.

__________________________________ ______________ __________________


Name of Research Participant Date Signature

38
Research Title: Vendor Management Strategies and its Benefits

Researchers’ Name and Contact Information:


Seballo, Rose-Anne 09227213577
Mascarinas, Charwyne 09481659833
Tan, Marissa 09266551422
Florentino, Megan
Pradilla Kirby Kent 09169747163

Please put a tick on the box.

I confirm that I have read and understand the information sheet for the above
study and have had the opportunity to ask questions and clarifications on the
matter of the interview/anything that concerns me.

I understand that my participation is voluntary and that I am free to withdraw


at any time, without giving reason.

I agree to take part in the above study and share everything I know to contribute
to the success of the said research.

Note for researchers:


Include the following statements if appropriate, or leave it blank if otherwise.

Please put a tick on the box.


YES NO

I agree to the interview/focus group/consultation being audio recorded.

I agree to the interview/focus group/consultation being video recorded.

I agree to the use of anonymized quotes in publications.

__________________________________ ______________ __________________


Name of Research Participant Date Signature

39
Appendix C: Survey-Interview Questionnaire

Interview Questions

1. What were your previous businesses?


2. What additional services would you add?
3. How do you manage conflict
4. What is your greatest accomplishment?
5. How did you start your business
6. What is your management style?
7. How would your past experiences translate into success in this job
8. How would you tackle the first 90 days
9. What is the process of you typically follow to make a decision about a plan of
action?
10. When giving two or three equally viable paths to achieve an object, how do you
decide which path to follow?
11. Have you ever delayed a decision making? then what were the consequences for
your business?
12. Do you make decisions on your own without input from others? When do you seek
advice from others when making decisions.
13. How do you ensure that task are successfully completed? Are they any steps to you
take?
14. How do you remain consistency as a business woman/man
15. What specific strategies have you used in running the business

16. What methods do you utilize to resolve problem?

40
Appendix D: Observation Schedule

OBSERVATION SCHEDULE
The owner’s performance in their respective business

Name of Respondent: ______________________________


Observer: ________________________
Age: ____________
Time started: __________
Grade: ________________
Time Ended: _____________
Gender: ______________________

Behavior/s Details Behavior/s Details Manners Details


Observed Triggered Conducted

41
Appendix E: Transcription of the Coded Data
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Impoverishment “We sell Successfull
Magazine and business owners
Newspaper along started from selling
the road/ along the road as
sidewalk” vendors that earned
“We first started only a little profit
selling candies
and water along
the streets”
Extensions "Our business Business owners
started from a started from a
small shop and small firm until
now we had such time it grows.
extensions in our
business"

1. What additional services would you add?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Customer-oriented “We Added a little Business owners
grocery in our added additional
business eatery services to their
and added tables business to gain
and chairs for customers and
customers outside satisfies customers'
in our big grocery need
store.”
“ We add cool
ventilation and
free WiFi for
customers’
convenient”
Flexion " now we have Most business
branches here in owners produce
cebu" branches to
promote their
business more to
customers in other
locations.

2. How do you manage conflict?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern

42
Capitalization “When I encounter Business owner
conflict especially decreases their
in the number of capital to avoid
sales, I decrease losses in profit
the money for especially when
capital I use for a they encounter
certain period to conflict in
avoid losses in business.
profit”

Tranquillity “I closed the Business owner


business to have makes a plan on
them cool down how to manage
first and for me to and find solution
decide a solution regarding with the
for this conflict.” conflict of their
business.
Abatement " To manage Business owners
conflict, we offer offer discounts to
discount prices to the customers to
our customers manage their
when we do not conflict when it
have enough comes to their
customers" business.

3. What is your greatest accomplishment?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Eminence “Our business The business
gains its progress. owners were able
We we’re able to to help their
send our kids to families when it
school and have comes financial
them graduated. problems and also
Also, we we’re they have provided
able to buy house all of their needs.
and lots because of
this business.”
“I able to have
more branches
throughout Cebu
City and houses
for my parents”
" I was able to
save money to buy

43
house for myself
and my parents"

4. How did you start your business?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Accommodate “We borrow a The business
money from owners borrowed
someone to have a money to have a
stating capital for capital in starting
our business” up their business.
"We started in
November, 2016.
the place in our
business was still
a small space and
we just borrowed
money from other
as a capital"
Employment “I worked first to The business
established a owner used her
starting capital for salary in starting
this business” up her business.

5. What is your management style?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Inscribed “You need to have The business
an inventory in owners' strategy
which you can inidentifying the
manage and control gain and loss of
the gain and loss in their businessare
the transactions of through making
your business” inventories and
“I have managed encoding
inventory which is transactions.
encoded in my
computer in where I
can look after to any
gain and losses”
Pursuance "our The business
strategy/management owner's strategy is
style is to convince through
customers through convincing her
building relationship customers to buy
with the customers their products.
until they become
our wholesaler"

6. How would your past experiences translate into success in this job?

44
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Learnedness “It gives me the the business
knowledge in more owners are
things related to persistent in
business and learn managing their
not to give up” businesses and
“It makes me learn they never give up
to not give up and so that they will
strive more after have a successful
learning mistakes business.
in the past for the
better future”
"I have learned
that this business
is going to be
stable as much as
possible and
always maintain
consistency"

7. How would you tackle the first 90 days?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Difficulty “ It was really The business
difficult at first but owners tried their
I still manage to best in advertising
adjust in the their businesses.
environment and
people surrounds
me. We strive hard
that time so that
people notice us.”
“I still need to
advertise my
business to
everyone which is
really difficult to
do as a beginner”
"It does not matter.
It depends if the
customer likes to
buy"

8. What is the process of you typically followed to make a decision about a plan of
action?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Assistance “I first talk to my The business
husband and then owners need to be

45
to my people. accompanied and
Lastly, I rationalize cooperation from
things up to come others before they
up a better make a final
decision” desicion. They go
“I talk to people through a thorough
whom are credible process.
and knowledgeable
enough that will
help me decide
things up”
"I will increase the
stocks by
contacting our
supplier if there is
an increase of
demand"

9. When giving two or three equally viable paths to achieve an object, how do you decide
which path to follow?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Decisions “I rationalize They go to a long
things up in which process of thinking
things will do in which they think
good or bad to my of possible
business” consequences of
“I first think of that certain
what that thing decision.
will do to my
business before
having a final
choice”
"I will choose the
right path"

10. Have you ever delayed a decision making? Then what were the consequences for your
business?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Procrastination ”Yes, and it Sometimes,
causes decrease of owners make a bad
our profit” decision and
“Yes, it causes further affect their
bankruptcy in our business. But still
business but still manage to revive
manage to revive and come up with
it” a solution for the

46
" Whenever I have consistency of the
a delayed decision business.
making. My
strategy is to sale
the products
through our social
sites"

11. Do you make decisions on your own without input from others? When do you seek
advice from others when making decisions?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Consultation “I take advice owners can't
from my husband decide by
which is my themselves but
partner in this tends to seek help
business and from from others in
my people all the where they will be
time to make a guided to the better
better decision” decision.
“I always take
advice from
people that can
help me in making
decisions.”
Self-involved "yes, since i am Sometimes, owner
the only one likes to decide
manage this their own to avoid
business" complicacy to any
decisions she will
be making.

12. How do you ensure those tasks are successfully completed? Are they any steps to you
take?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Assurance “ We have Owners manage
inventory in which and control their
we can see the supply of product
inflow and outflow and service
of product as well through making an
as the gain and inventory.
losses”
“I ensure task by
controlling and
regulating the
product I invest in
the business which

47
I can easily access
to my inventories”
" i do inventory so
that I will know
what account is
lacking"

13. How do you remain consistency as a business woman/man?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Hardwork “Strive hard and They are goal
have a specific oriented and have a
goal in your specific purpose in
business. Also doing the business.
remain consistent They strive hard to
in knowing the meet the goal and
needs and wants of profit expectations.
a customer”
“Learn not to give
up even if things
doesn’t work out
the way you
wanted”
"Just continue
with the business"

14. What specific strategies have you used in running the business?
Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Direction “Know the needs Business owner
and wants of the prioritize
customer in the customers'
specific area” necessities in that
“I specifically certain location
target customers’ and occasion.
needs”

Accessible “Sell convenient They sell products


products that are and services in an
readily and affordable and
available to sell” convenient to
“I sell cheap customer.
products but high
quality that are
convenient to
customers”
Alterability “We sometimes The owner have to
change the product change or add
depending on the products to
occasions”

48
“I change or add increase sales
menu/ product in occasionally.
my eatery
depending on what
the customers need
during that certain
period”
Flexibility “Need to be They work from
flexible during time to time to
working hours” entertain and
“Work flexibly satisfy customers
because people with their service.
need to be
entertain all the
time”
Elevation “Promote/ They advertise
advertise sales their product
through internet” through internet in
“I uploads photos which a lot of
and updates in our people will be
Facebook page to inform about the
promote our business.
business”

15. What methods do you utilize to resolve problem?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Cautious “Careful decision They go through a
making” long step by step
“Decide step by process to come up
step to avoid with a better
mistakes” decision.

16. What methods do you utilize to resolve problem?


Code Response Interpretation Coding Pattern
Cautious “Careful decision They go through a
making” long step by step
“Decide step by process to come up
step to avoid with a better
mistakes” decision.

49
Appendix F: Curriculum Vitae of Researchers

Personal Information
Name: Kirby Kent Pradilla
Age: 17
Birth date:
Religion: Roman Catholic
Status: Single

Educational Background
Senior High School: University of Cebu-Banilad
Strand: ABM
Junior High School:

Achievements and Awards

Poster Making Contest- 1st runner up

Skills
Computer Skills
Flexible
Artistic

50
Appendix F: Curriculum Vitae of Researchers

Personal Information
Name: Megan Camille Florentino
Age: 16
Birth date: May 3, 2001
Religion: Roman Catholic

Educational Background
Senior High School: University of Cebu-Banilad
Strand: ABM
Junior High School: Mandaue City Comprehensive Narional High School

Achievements and Awards

Top students during Junior High School

Skills

Computer Skills

51
Appendix F: Curriculum Vitae of Researchers

2x2 picture

Personal Information
Name: Mascarinas Charwyne
Age: 16
Birth date: August 10, 2001
Religion: Roman Catholic
Status: Single

Educational Background
Senior High School: University of Cebu-Banilad
Strand: ABM
Junior High School: Father Saturnino Urios University

Achievements and Awards


3rd placer in Radio Broadcasting

Skills

- Computer Skills
- Written and Verbal Communication

52
Appendix F: Curriculum Vitae of Researchers

2x2 picture

Personal Information
Name: Rose-Anne R. Seballo
Age: 17
Birth date: March 10, 2001
Religion: Roman Catholic
Status: Single

Educational Background
Senior High School: University of Cebu- Banilad Campus
Strand: ABM
Junior High School: Apas Integrated Senior High School

Achievements and Awards

With honor during Junior High School

Skills
Computer Skills
Communication Skills

53
Appendix F: Curriculum Vitae of Researchers

2x2 picture

Personal Information
Name: Marissa Tan
Age: 16
Birth date:
Religion: Roman Catholic
Status: Single

Educational Background
Senior High School: University of Cebu-Banilad
Strand: ABM
Junior High School: Oprra National High School

Achievements and Awards


Top student during Junior High School

Skills

Computer Skills
Writing Skills

54
55

You might also like