Professional Documents
Culture Documents
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/271196885
CITATIONS READS
14 1,444
1 author:
Doru M. Stefanescu
The Ohio State University
363 PUBLICATIONS 4,223 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Doru M. Stefanescu on 21 January 2015.
Doru M. Stefanescu
The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA
The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL, USA
Abstract
Monitoring and adjusting the chemical composition and technique evolved then into Differential Thermal Analysis
the nucleation potential of casting alloys melts is critical (DTA) without a reference sample. With this tool in hand
to the production of castings of consistent high quality. the metallurgist ventured to predict not only the chemis-
While other methods such as fractured test samples (e.g., try of the melt but also the nucleation potential (degree of
the wedge test for gray iron) and spectrographic chemi- inoculation), the shrinkage propensity, the dendrite arm
cal analysis deliver useful information, thermal analysis spacing and the grain size, the graphite shape, the solidi-
(TA) (also called cooling curve analysis, CCA) can pro- fication microstructure, and even the room temperature
vide a more complete insight in the dynamic changes oc- microstructure. Currently, different TA techniques are
curring upon melting and during melt treatment of cast- used worldwide in the daily production of all grades of
ing alloys. Initially TA was used for the rapid evaluation cast iron, as well as in monitoring the melting of alumi-
of the carbon equivalent (CE) in cast iron, or the silicon num and steel alloys.
content in Al-Si alloys. Extensive research then extended
the capabilities of TA to the understanding of the solidifi- From this short introduction it should be obvious that the
cation changes induced by compositional variations such story of DTA/CCA is a long and exciting one. This paper will
as the Mn/S ratio, Ce and Mg additions. With the advent try to summarize the fascinating development and extraordi-
of ever faster computers, the first derivative of the cooling nary success of this technique in the casting industry.
curve, which is the cooling rate, was added to the arsenal
of data provided by TA, and a new technique, Computer Keywords: thermal analysis, cooling curve analysis, differ-
Aided Cooling Curve Analysis (CA-CCA), was born. This ential thermal analysis, cast iron, aluminum alloys
Background Cooling curve analysis has evolved over the years becom-
ing a powerful tool for casting process control. The appli-
Thermal Analysis (TA) is the recording and interpreta- cation of CCA to cast iron appears to have started in 1931
tion of the temperature variation in time of a cooling or by Esser and Lautenbusch5 who showed that increasing
heated material. In its simplest form, as applied to met- the superheating of gray iron depresses the eutectic arrest
alcasting, the cooling curve of a metal solidifying in a (Fig. 1). Qualitative observations were also made by Pi-
mold is recorded and analyzed (CCA). Its interpretation wowarski,6 who noticed that higher silicon decreases the
is based on the belief that all the events occurring during undercooling (Fig. 2), by Loper et al.,7 who observed the
solidification leave their mark on the shape of the cooling effect of the Mn/S ratio on the eutectic undercooling (Fig.
curve. It appears that Le Chatelier was the first scientist 3), and by Naro and Wallace8 who revealed the effect of
that recorded temperature as a function of time in heating cerium and sulfur additions (Fig. 4). De Sy and Vidts9
curves in 1887.1 pointed out that cooling curves contain information on
graphite shape.
Differential Thermal Analysis (DTA), which consists of
time, temperature and temperature difference measure- Today, TA can be used to predict alloy composition, grain
ments, appears to have been performed first by Roberts- refining in steel, aluminum, magnesium and other alloys,
Austen2 in 1899, with equipment developments by Kurna- eutectic morphology (e.g., graphite morphology in cast
kov3 and Saladin.4 Differential Thermal Analysis can be irons or degree of modification in Al alloys) and shrinkage
conducted with or without a reference body and using one propensity. Computer analysis of the cooling curve can
or two thermocouples in the same test mold. The refer- provide quantitative information on solidification, such as
ence body is a material, real or virtual (computer-generat- latent heat of solidification, evolution of fraction solid,
ed) that has no phase transformation over the temperature amounts of phases, dendrite coherency and dendrite arm
interval of interest. spacing.
Figure 3. Effect of the Mn/S ratio on gray iron cooling Figure 4. Effect of the Ce and S additions on gray iron
curves.7 cooling curves.8
No Te With Te With Te + S
Eqn. 4
b) mottled iron
c) white iron
Figure 11. An interpretation of cooling curves to predict
stable or metastable solidification in cast iron. Figure 12. Effect of Bi inoculation on SG iron.18
Figure 14. Correlation between the eutectic graphitization ability, type of lamellar graphite
and chilling tendency in lamellar graphite iron.19
Prediction of Graphite Shape ite shape (e.g. Ref. 10, 25, 26). A second derivative of the
T-t curve was then calculated and studied27,28 (see example
One of the early objectives of TA as applied to cast iron in Fig. 18), and then higher order derivatives, as high as the
was prediction of nodularity in ductile iron, with work 5th derivative by Sparkman,29,30 were interpreted with more
being done both in industry (e.g., Ref. 20, 21 and in aca- or less success. While the physical meaning of the first and
demia22). One direction of research focused on the shape second derivatives is clear, that of the higher order deriva-
of the cooling curve (Fig. 15). Another approach was tives is not.
to correlate various temperature data with elements of
the microstructure (Fig. 16). This last method was later Elements of the second derivatives have been used to pre-
extended to the prediction of compacted graphite iron dict microstructure in cast iron and aluminum alloys. For
structure by correlating the eutectic temperature and the example, the following relationship was derived through
recalescence to the graphite morphology, as summa- statistical analysis of the experimental data28 for hypereu-
rized in Fig. 17.10,23 None of these early approaches were tectic (CE = 4.5-4.9) thin wall LG and CG irons with Mg =
deemed accurate enough for process implementation on 0.006-0.031%:
the foundry floor.
Eqn. 6
As early as 1972, a new technique became available for TA
interpretation when Rabus and Polten24 used computer gen-
Where; SN sphericity nodularity defined by:
erated cooling rates from cooling curve data (first derivative
of the temperature-time curve). Derivative calculus permits
the study of the rate of change, and thus of the beginning and
end of transformations. Researchers used combinations of
critical temperature and cooling rate to try to predict graph-
Bäckerud et al.38 suggested the use of the maximum of the minum alloys, and the area under it, for the estimation of the
first derivative in the region of primary solidification of alu- efficiency of grain refinement (Fig. 19).
The use of the first derivative of the T-t curve allows es-
Figure 18. Cooling curve, first derivative and second timation of the time at which various solidification events
derivative.28 are occurring. According to Larrañaga et al.,32 the ratio
Prediction of Degree O Oxidation of the Melt These three equations were plotted in Fig. 22. It was confirmed
that the oxygen increases TLA. This effect may be understood
Increased oxygen in the range of 11-101 ppm in an iron melt on the basis of thermodynamics. Oxygen lowers carbon activ-
of composition 3.39-3.46%C and 1.38-1.58%Si has been re- ity, which is equivalent to a decrease in carbon in terms of
ported to raise the liquidus temperature by as much as 10°C solidification behaviour. This implies an increase in the tem-
(18°F).33 Inoculation lowered the TLA. Similar effects were perature. Superheating decreases the liquidus, most probably
noticed for steel where dissolved oxygen raised TLA and de- because it decreases the nucleation potential of the melt.
oxidation with Al depressed TLA.34
Prediction of Mechanical Properties
Heine and Henschel14,35 conducted experiments on a large num-
ber of melts to find the effect of oxygen on the TLA of iron Attempts have also been made to predict mechanical prop-
melts. For melts deoxidized under argon they derived Eqn. 2. erties using TA data by Kano et al. 19 (Eqn. 5) as already
For melts under oxidizing atmosphere the equation was: discussed in this paper. Earlier, Glover et al.36 performed re-
gression analysis on a large number of samples and obtained
the following correlation between tensile strength (TS in psi)
and the liquidus arrest (in °C):
Figure 21. Suggested correlation between times and areas from Figure 22. Effect of oxygen and
the cooling and cooling rates curves to microporosity propensity superheating on the liquidus temperature
in cast iron.32 (Heine).
Where;
Qf is the solidification latent heat;
t is the time;
v is the sample volume;
ρ is the metal density;
cp is the specific heat of the metal;
T is the average temperature in the sample;
h is the effective heat transfer coefficient;
A is the surface area of the sample;
To is the furnace temperature;
ε is the emissivity of the surface sample;
σ is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant.
It can be shown that, after some manipulations, the time evo- a) equipment for DTA
lution of the latent heat can be calculated as:
Eqn. 12
The total latent heat evolved during solidification, Qf, can
be obtained from the time integration of this equation. The
reaction rate (rate of fraction of solid evolution) can then be
calculated through the numerical integration of:
Eqn. 13
Figure 25. Calculation of the amount of phases from the Figure 26. The use of the 2nd derivative to establish the
areas under the cooling rate and the zero curves. beginning and the end of eutectic solidification.
Fourier Analysis
Eqn. 21
Figure 27. Three methods of generation of the zero Figure 29. Cooling curve, cooling rate and Fourier zero
curve.51 curve for an aluminum alloy.49
An important issue that directly impacts the accuracy and in- Thermal analysis of casting alloys in its direct form or as
terpretation of the DTA is the smoothing of the temperature- differential thermal analysis can provide information about
time data. While there are many smoothing techniques, some the composition of the alloy, the latent heat of solidifica-
of them proprietary, the most common ones are data averag- tion, the evolution of the fraction solid, the amounts and
ing, Gaussian smoothing, and polynomial interpolation.
Figure 30. Comparison between the raw data(dotted Figure 32. Comparison between the raw data(dotted
lines) and data smoothed by averaging over 9 points lines) and data smoothed by 10th order polynomial
(full lines). interpolation (full lines).