Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Objective. The aim of this study was to compare dogs’ pulp response to capping with calcium hydroxide cement
(Dycal), mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA), and a novel endodontic cement (NEC).
Study design. Twenty-four canine teeth in 6 beagle dogs were buccocervically exposed and capped with MTA, Dycal,
or NEC. Eight weeks later, retrieved samples were observed by optical microscope to grade inflammation, formation of
dentinal bridge, calcification, necrosis, and presence of odontoblast cells.
Results. No inflammation was observed in MTA and NEC groups, and in 75% of each, dentinal bridge was
completely formed. In the Dycal group, inflammation and incomplete dentinal bridge were detected in all cases.
Although MTA and NEC groups had no significant difference between them in each measure, the difference between
all 3 groups was significant (P ⬍ .001).
Conclusion. MTA and NEC showed similar favorable biologic response in pulp cap treatment, better than Dycal,
especially in inducing the formation of dentinal bridge. (Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 2008;
106:609-14)
Direct pulp capping is covering the exposed surface of compared with various Ca(OH)2 preparations.5-7 Al-
the pulp to maintain its vitality and preserve its func- though MTA has superior biocompatibility compared
tional and biologic activities.1 Inducing hard tissue with the conventional root-end filling materials, it has a
formation by pulp cells as an ultimate goal of capping delayed setting time,8 poor handling characteristics,9
material use has been widely accepted.2 and off-white color, and it is in comparison an expen-
Because of its low-grade irritation of the traumatized sive material. To decrease the expenses, Portland ce-
pulp tissue, calcium hydroxide [Ca(OH)2] has been the ment (PC) has been compared with MTA in recent
material of choice for pulp capping.3 Known disadvan- studies, revealing that PC is compositionally similar to
tages for this material include gradual degradation, MTA.10-11 The advantages and disadvantages of differ-
tunnel defects in dentinal bridge, and poor sealing ent commercial types of MTA and PC have also been
well documented.11-13 Considering these facts, the
properties.4
present authors designed a project to evaluate a new
Mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) has been intro-
dental material that combines reasonable biocompat-
duced as a suitable material for direct pulp capping
ibility of MTA with appropriate setting time, handling
treatment, demonstrating a remarkable success rate
characteristics, chemical properties, and color. The
novel endodontic cement (NEC*) contains several cal-
Supported in part by Iran Center for Dental Research, Shahid Be- cium compounds and has been evaluated in several
heshti University M.C., Tehran, Iran. research projects.14-15
a
Professor of Endodontics, Iranian Center for Endodontic Research, The purpose of the present investigation was to evalu-
Dental Research Center, Shahid Beheshti University M.C.
b
ate the histomorphologic response of dental pulp to cap-
Professor of Endodontics, Kerman School of Dentistry and Iran
Research Center for Oral and Dental Diseases. ping with calcium hydroxide cement (Dycal), MTA, and
c
Research Assistant, Dental Research Center, Shahid Beheshti Uni- NEC, using dogs’ canine teeth in an 8-week follow-up.
versity M.C.
d
Orthodontics Program, Department of Oral and Developmental Bi-
MATERIAL AND METHODS
ology, Harvard School of Dental Medicine.
Received for publication May 9, 2008; returned for revision May 9, In this prospective randomized controlled trial, 24
2008; accepted for publication Jun 3, 2008. intact canine teeth in 6 18- to 24-month-old healthy
1079-2104/$ - see front matter
© 2008 Mosby, Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.tripleo.2008.06.006 *Patent pending as Endodontic Filling Material (ENDOFILMAT).
609
OOOOE
610 Asgary et al. October 2008
Table I. Histologic features and the grading method used in the present study to evaluate the samples
Grading
Feature Category I (worst) II III (best)
Hard tissue (dentinal Continuity Severe communication of the capping Moderate communication of the capping Complete
bridge) material with dental pulp material with dental pulp
Morphology No tubules present Irregular pattern of tubules Regular pattern of
tubules
Thickness ⬍0.1 mm 0.1-0.25 mm ⬎0.25 mm
Pulp inflammation Type Acute and chronic inflammation Chronic inflammation No inflammation
Intensity Severe inflammation or abscess formation Minimal to moderate inflammation No inflammation
Extension All coronal pulp Under exposure area or calcified bridge Absent
Other histologic Calcification Diffuse calcification Pulp stone Absent
features Necrosis Complete Partial Absent
Odontoblastic Absent Presence of odontoblast cells Palisade pattern
layer of cells
male beagle dogs were randomly divided into 3 groups Tehran Veterinary School, Tehran, Iran, with a special
for Dycal, MTA, and NEC (n ⫽ 8 for each). The soft diet and supporting analgesics and other medica-
maxillary and mandibular canine teeth from each ani- ments (i.e., vitamin and minerals).
mal were randomly allocated to 1 of the 3 groups. The animals were sacrificed after 8 weeks, vital
Four intact incisor teeth were selected in 4 dogs as perfusion fixation was performed with 10% buffered
the control group. The protocol of the study was ap- formalin solution, and block sections were retrieved
proved by the Ethics Committee of Shahid Beheshti using cutting discs. The teeth and their surrounding
University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, in 2005. tissues were placed in 10% buffered formalin solution
General anesthesia was achieved by IM injection of 10 for 2 weeks. The specimens were then demineralized
mg/kg ketamine HCl (Alfasan, Woerden, the Nether- for 4 weeks in 10% formic acid. After decalcification of
lands) and 1 mg/kg xylazine (Bayer, Munich, Ger- the samples, the specimens were rinsed with running
many). The oral cavity was rinsed with 0.2% chlorhexi- tap water for 2 h, followed by dehydration in ascending
dine glucunate (Shahrdaru, Tehran, Iran) to disinfect concentrations of alcohol (70%, 90%, and 100%), and
the area. An infiltration injection with mepivacaine were then embedded in paraffin. The glass ionomer
(Espe Dental, Seefeld, Germany) was used for local restoration (with a part of the capping material) was
anesthesia. A rubber dam was then installed to isolate
gently removed from every sample before embedding.
the teeth.
Six-micrometer labiolingual sections were prepared
Class V cavities were prepared on the buccal surface
through the exposure site and were stained with hema-
of the teeth using buccocervical access by a no. 1
toxylin and eosin (H&E). The labiolingual section pass-
high-speed round bur with copious water spray. The
ing through the center of the exposure site was used for
preparations were cut 0.5-1 mm above the free gingiva,
histologic observations. Using an optical microscope
parallel to the cementoenamel junction. Pulp exposure
was performed in the middle of the cavity floor. The (Zeiss, Goettingen, Germany), samples were evaluated
pulp exposures produced were about the same size (1 by an experienced oral pathologist who was not aware
mm). Following exposure of the pulp, the access cavity of the types of capping material. Coded samples were
was rinsed with sterile saline solution and dried with used throughout the study to avoid possible bias. The
sterile cotton pellets with a light pressure to control the amount of pulp inflammation (type, intensity, and ex-
bleeding. The pulp was covered with each material tension), hard tissue formation at the interface of the
depending on the group to which it belonged. Tooth- capping material (continuity, morphology, and thick-
colored ProRoot MTA (Dentsply, Tulsa Dental, Tulsa, ness), and other histologic features of the pulp tissue,
OK) and Dycal (LD Caulk, Milford, DE) were prepared including calcification of the pulp, necrosis, and the
according to the manufacturers’ directions, and NEC odontoblast cell layer were graded from I to III by the
was mixed with its liquid to provide a dense creamy oral pathologist (Table I) according to the standards
mixture. The coronal opening of every tooth was then defined by several earlier observers.16-18
restored immediately with Fuji II glass ionomer (GC The data were analysed with Kruskal-Wallis and
International Corp., Tokyo, Japan). After the operation, Mann-Whitney tests. Statistically significant differ-
animals were supervised according to the protocol of ences were set at P ⬍ .05.
OOOOE
Volume 106, Number 4 Asgary et al. 611
Table II. Number (%) of different categories of the histologic features for each group according to the scores (see
Table I) received during histopathologic evaluations (n ⫽ 8 for each group)
Dycal MTA NEC
Feature Category I II III I II III I II III
Hard tissue (dentinal Continuity 0 (0%) 8 (100%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (25%) 6 (75%) 0 (0%) 2 (25%) 6 (75%)
bridge) Morphology 7 (87.5%) 1 (12.5%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (62.5%) 3 (37.5%) 0 (0%) 4 (50%) 4 (50%)
Thickness 2 (25%) 5 (62.5%) 1 (12.5%) 0 (0%) 4 (50%) 4 (50%) 0 (0%) 2 (25%) 6 (75%)
Pulp inflammation Type 1 (12.5%) 7 (87.5%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%)
Intensity 1 (12.5%) 7 (87.5%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%)
Extension 4 (50%) 4 (50%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%)
Other histologic Calcification 0 (0%) 4 (50%) 4 (50%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%) 0 (0%) 2 (25%) 6 (75%)
features Necrosis 0 (0%) 2 (25%) 6 (75%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 8 (100%)
Odontoblastic 7 (87.5%) 1 (12.5%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (62.5%) 3 (37.5%) 0 (0%) 4 (50%) 4 (50%)
layer
Dycal, Calcium hydroxide cement; MTA, mineral trioxide aggregate; NEC, novel endodontic cement.
RESULTS
Specimens of control sound teeth showed normal
pulp tissue with palisade columnar odontoblast cells at
the coronal portion of the pulp. No inflammatory cell
could be observed.
A summary of the observed criteria is presented in
Table II. In the Dycal group, a complete calcified
bridge was not detected (Fig. 1). As shown in Fig. 1, a
great deal of material had been pushed into the pulp
space and dystrophic calcification observed around
them. Although partial necrosis was observed in 2
samples, all pulps were vital. In 100% of the samples,
mild to severe chronic inflammation was observed
around the exposure site and the calcified bridge. It was
also scattered throughout the coronal pulp chamber. In
one of the samples in this group, an odontoblast-like
cell layer with irregular tubular dentin was observed
adjacent to the dentinal bridge. The remaining 87.5% of
the samples showed amorphous and nontubular calci-
fied bridge, exhibiting a dense structure. In some cases,
the appearance of cellular inclusions was similar to that
of lacunae found in the bone. Also, only 1 sample
demonstrated a bridge formation with adequate thick-
ness (⬎0.25 mm). In addition, in 50% of the samples,
pulp stones were detected in the pulp tissue.
In the MTA group, complete dentin bridge formation
was detected in 75% of the samples (Fig. 2). None of
the samples showed inflammation, and in all samples
the pulp was vital. In this group, 37.5% of the samples Fig. 1. Pulp cap with Dycal (CH). Top, Formation of a thin
had well organized odontoblast cell layer in close rela- calcified bridge at pulp-Dycal interface (⫻100); bottom
tion to a dentinal bridge composed of tubular dentin. In right, communication path between pulp and Dycal (arrow)
the remainder, odontoblast-like cells were discovered (⫻400); bottom left, phagocyte cell containing particles (ar-
adjacent to a dentinal bridge with irregular tubules. rowhead) (⫻1,000).
Also, in one-half of the samples, the dentinal bridge had
sufficient thickness (⬎0.25 mm).
In the NEC group, complete dentin bridge formation
was reported in 75% of the cases (Fig. 3). None of the
OOOOE
612 Asgary et al. October 2008
Fig. 2. Pulp cap with mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA). Fig. 3. Pulp cap with novel endodontic cement (NEC). Top,
Top, Formation of a thick dentinal bridge at pulp-MTA Formation of a thick dentinal bridge at pulp-NEC interface
interface (⫻100); bottom, formation of odontoblast-like (⫻100); bottom, formation of multilayer odontoblast-like
cells, dentin, and dentinal tubules (⫻1,000). cells, dentin, and dentinal tubules (⫻1,000).
In the present study, a period of 8 weeks was used to of the samples. Mean thickness of the dentinal bridge in
evaluate the effect of capping materials on pulp tissues. the NEC group was higher than MTA, and the presence
Briso et al.,16 in a recently published study on dogs, of a layer of odontoblast-like cells could be observed
used the same time interval. Although similar time more frequently in the NEC group. This new cement
intervals were used in many studies,7,21-23 several other contains several calcium compounds that result in a rich
studies evaluated pulp tissue at different time intervals pool of calcium and phosphorus ions. These elements
up to 150 days.20,24-27 are used in the process of hydroxyapatite production,
Various studies have reported excellent results for which is a natural product of dental pulp cells.35 This
MTA when used as a pulp capping material.5,25 The feature is hypothetically responsible for its biocompat-
results of the present study confirmed the favorable ibility and its other optimum specifications.
outcome of this material compared with Dycal in terms Anyhow, NEC contains calcium oxide and hydrox-
of lack of inflammation, thicker and more complete ide which ultimately produce Ca(OH)2 through the
dentinal bridge formation, and presence of odontoblast- hydration process. As explained before, Ca(OH)2 if
like cell layer in most samples. These results also leached out in sufficient quantities may stimulate cal-
confirm the studies carried out by others on these ma- cific bridge formation.28
terials as pulp-capping agents.6,24 It should be emphasized that the present experiment
Although MTA does not have Ca(OH)2 in its com- was carried out in ideal controlled conditions with
position, calcium oxide is one of its components, which artificially exposed healthy pulp tissue. The use of
can form Ca(OH)2 in reaction with water.5 On the other direct pulp capping is an attempt to maintain the vitality
hand, Ca(OH)2 has been described as a compound with of an exposed dental pulp. The effects of various dental
direct effect on microvasculature resulting in less materials on the prognosis of pulp exposure have been
plasma outflow, which in turn favors a calcific response evaluated in several studies.2-7,15,17,20 It is generally
in the adjacent pulp tissue.28 Holland et al.29 observed accepted that accidental pulpal exposure offers more
granulations nearest to the opening of dentinal tubules favorable prognosis compared with carious pulp expo-
that were filled with MTA in an animal model. They sure for continuing pulp vitality with direct capping
reported that these structures were similar to the calcite techniques. There is not general agreement whether the
crystals observed in Ca(OH)2. According to Seux et toxicity of medicaments and materials placed on vital
al.30 calcite crystals attract fibronectin, which is respon- pulp tissues determines outcome or the material’s abil-
sible for cellular adhesion and differentiation. There- ity to seal the cavity from further bacterial ingress is the
fore, they hypothesized that MTA and Ca(OH)2 have a key to success. Possibly it is a combination of both
similar mechanism for hard-tissue formation. The fa- factors. Most of the previously published studies for
vorable properties of MTA reported by several authors evaluation of pulp-capping agents were performed on
have high alkalinity (that has been related to its bacte- healthy intact teeth of animals.7,24-26 In the present
ricidal properties),31 excellent tight seal,8,14,32 and bio- investigation, to compare the effect of the testing ma-
compatibility.33,34 On the other hand, it has also been terials on pulp tissues, a small pulp exposure was made
reported to have disappointing properties, such as de- and restored by glass ionomer after direct pulp-capping
layed setting time8 and poor handling characteristics.9 procedure. Therefore, although this study is an in vivo
As has been reported, formation of hard tissue at the evaluation, careful consideration is essential to adapt
interface of the pulp and the foreign material is a these favorable results with clinical situations.
controversial issue, because dentinal bridge presence In conclusion, the results of the present in vivo study
does not necessarily prove a healthy status of the pulp demonstrated that MTA and NEC showed similar fa-
or establishment of an optimum seal, but it can be vorable results, better than Dycal, when used as pulp-
interpreted as a sign of healing or a reaction to irrita- capping materials. The pulp response indicated similar
tion.2 In the present study, formation of the dentinal biocompatibility for NEC, compared with MTA, by
bridge was interpreted as a sign of healing and a pos- inducing the formation of a complete dentinal bridge at
itive reaction to stimulation. its interface with the pulp tissue. These results led to the
According to the results of this study and parallel conclusion that NEC could be considered as an alter-
research being performed,14,15 the authors introduced native to MTA in pulp cap treatment. In addition, the
NEC as a material that has similar biologic features to authors believe that further assessment is required for
MTA but lacks its disadvantages to an extent. In the better understanding of biologic characteristics of NEC.
present study, NEC resulted in a better pulpal response The authors wish to thank Dr. Davood Sharifi from Tehran
compared with MTA when used as pulp-capping agent Veterinary School, Dr. Sanam Kheirieh, and Dr. Majid
(Table II), although the difference was not statistically Akbarzadeh from Iran Center for Dental Research, Tehran,
significant. The NEC group had no inflammation in any Iran, for their assistance and contribution to this project.
OOOOE
614 Asgary et al. October 2008
A comparative study of histologic response to different pulp capping materials and a novel endodontic
3168780 6
cement
http://fulltext.study/journal/2860
http://FullText.Study