Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ADS Commentary
_-
PART IX: LAGSCREWS
strength properties. In the 1991 edition, the designer A lag screw subjected to both combined withdrawal
isresponsible for specifyingthemetal strength of the and lateral loading may be considered loaded primarily
lagscrews that are to be used. Bendingyield strength in withdrawal when the axis of the screw is at angle of
of the lagscrewis a required input variable to the 75" or more to the grain of the wood member holding
lateral designvalueyield mode equations of 9.3.1. the threaded portion ofthescrew. The requirement
Additionally, the actual tensile stress in thelagscrew that unusual splitting be avoided whenleadholes are
at the root diameter must be checkedwhendesigning not used is to be considered a performance requirement
lag
screw connections for withdrawal (see
9.2.3
of that (i) is related to the ability of the screw to hold the
Specification). cleat or side member to the main or foundation
9.1 -2-Fabrication and Assembly member, and (ii)is applicable to both membersbeing
c
joined.
9.1.2.1 Provisions relating to the clearance hole of
the shank and the leadholesize for thethreaded 9.1.2.3 The provision that lagscrewsbeinserted
portion of the lag screw have been part of the Specifi- by turning with a wrench and not by drivingwith a
legendof Equation C9.3-1were used from the1971 unaffected as long as the total length of penetration
through the 1986 editions. (shank as well as threaded depth) of thescrewinthe
main member was at least five times the shank diame-
The foregoing procedures were included as part of ter, or 5D (1 14,117). In view of the fact that previous
the Specification until the 1960 edition whentheywere designvalueswerekeyed to proportional limit rather
replacedwitha table ofdesignvalues for arange of than ultimate joint loads, the positionwastaken that
lagscrewsizes for each of the four lagscrew groups. the yield mode equations would be implemented in the
This
change in presentation, whichwas made to 1991 edition and compared withpreviouslydeveloped
facilitate design and use of lag screw connections, was designvaluesassuming that the fulldesignvalue is
continued through the 1986 edition. In accordance developed if the length of the screw (shank plus
with recommendations based on the originalresearch threaded portion less length of tapered tip) in the main
(134), tabulated designvaluesin the 1960 through the memberis at least 8D, regardlessofspecies specific
1986 editions were considered directly applicable to lag gravity; and that proportionate design values are
screwshavingayield strength of45,000psi. For lag achieved for penetrations betweenaminimumof 40
screwshaving other yield strengths, adjustment of and 8 0 . These criteria are in agreementwiththe
tabulated values in proportion to the square root of the penetration requirementin the 1988 draft standard of
ratio of the yield strength of the metal to45,000was Eurocode No. 5 (45,114).
allowed.
To establish adjustment factors which would reduce
1991 Edition. As with bolts and other doweltype yield mode equation values to the designvaluelevels
fasteners, lateral design values for lag screw connections used in previous editions of the Specification, the ratios
in the 1991 edition are based on application of the ofyieldmodedesignvalue to designvaluebasedon
yield limit model (see Commentary for 7.2.1 and 8.2.1). previous methodology (modified by the new penetration
In thecase of lagscrews,threegeneralmodesof criteria) were determined for a wide range of lag screw
yielding can occur:bearingin the sidemember or joint configurations made with both wood and steel
cleat (Mode I, ), development of a plastic hinge in the sidemembers. An average ratio was developed for -
screw in the main member (Mode 111) and development each of the seven yield mode conditions, one for Mode
of plastichingesin the screwin both main and side I, and threeeach for Modes I11 and IV. Rather than
members (Mode IV).However, three possiblecondi- includethree equations for each of the latter two
tions may exist within both Modes I11 and IV depend- modesin the Specification, it wasassumed that Mode
ing upon whether the maximum bending occurs in the I11 consistedonlyofyieldingofthe threaded portion
shank or threaded portion of the screw or bending ofthescrewinthemainmember and that Mode IV
occurs at a location other than at the point of maxi- consisted only of yielding of the shank portion of the
mum moment (1 14,117). screw in the side member and of the threaded portion
Behavioral equations for each of the seven possible of thescrewin the mainmember(117). It was found
conditions were developed (1 14,117)and used to predict that thissimplificationcould be accomplished, while
the joint designvaluesofall configurations testedin obtaining approximately the same overall average ratio
the
original
research
(134).
Values of percent
5 ofyield mode design value to previous design value as
diameter offsetdowelbearing strength (Fe) required that resulting from use of three equations for each
for these equations were estimated from thespecific Mode, by assuminga constant ratio ofyield moment
gravityvalues of the test material using equations of the threaded portion to yield moment of the shank
approximately equivalent to thoseused for bolts (see of0.75(114,117). The yield moment ratio (Rm) for
Commentary for 8.2.1 - Yield Mode Equations). Yield thescrew appears intheselectedbehavioral equations
modedesignvalues for the test configurations were for Modes 111, and IV (1 14,117) as shown below.
compared to those obtained from the original method- Mode I
ology (equations C9.3-1 and C9.3-2) to verify there was
a reasonably stable relationship between the two for the P = D tsF,, (C9.3-3)
range of joint configurations available (1 14).
Mode 111,
Reexamination of the originallagscrewresearch
(134)showed that although the F 3 factor (the adjust-
ment for length of lagscrewin the mainmember)in
the original lag screw equations was related to ultimate
load or strength of the joint, the proportional limit
load (approximately one-fourth the ultimate) was
118 Lagsmws
NDS Commentmy
(Z,,); andonefor aconnectionwithmainmember Table C9.3-1- Comparison of 1991 and 1986 NDS
loadedperpendicular to grain and thesidemember Wood-to-Wood Single ShearLag Screw Lateral
loaded parallel to grain (Zm, ). Design Values
Comparison of 1991 and
Earlier Edition
Pent
Values. Lagscrewdesignvaluesgiveninthe1991
edition cover a greater range of side membertration geometries Side
thanthosegiveninearliereditions.Becauseofthe Member Lag Screw Depth Lag Screw Lateral DesignValue, lbs
Thickness Factor
simplifications made inthe yield mode equations and in. L D cd zll
the averaging procedures used to adjust yield mode lag in. in. (1991) 1991 1986 Ratio. 1991 1986 Ratio
screw design values to design values previously tabulat-
Southern Dinq:
ed, newdesignvalues are both higher and lowerthan
thosegiven for thesame joint configurations in the 1-ln 4 114
1.OOO
230
170 1.35 180 170 1.06
earliereditions. This isshown by thecomparisons in 318 0.760 3 19 250 1.28 228 190 1.20
TableC9.3-1. The penetration depth factor, c d , 1/2 0.516 366 290 1.26 217 190 1.14
showninthistable,applicable to the 1991 tabulated 6 114 1.OOO 230 230 1.00 180 220 0.82
values, is the adjustment for less than full design value 318 1.OOO 420 420 1.00 300 320 0.94
penetration ( 8 0 ) of the screw in the main member (see 112 1.OOO 710 600 1.18 500 390 1.28
9.3.3
of
Specification and foregoing Commentary). 2-112 7 112 1.ooO 750 650 1.15 520 420 1.24
Washerthicknessof1/8inch for 1/2inch and larger 3140.64610858501.28 704 470 1.50
diametersscrews and 0 inch for smallerdiameters 9 112 1.OOO 750 830 0.90 520 540 0.96
screwswereassumedincalculatingvaluesof cd . 314 0.979 1645 1350 1.22 1067 740 1.44
Adjustments for penetration depth are embedded in the 1 0.711 1820 1660 1.10 1180 830 1.42
values tabulated inpreviouseditions (see Equations SDruce-Pine-Fir:
C9.3-1 and C9.3-2).
1-ln 4 114
1.OOO
200
130
1.54 150 130 1.15
In termsof the designvalue ratios for the joint 318 0.760 281 180 1.56 198 140 1.41
configurations compared, lag screwdesignvalues for 112 0.516 294 210 1.40 206 140 1.47
wood-to-wood connections
based on 1991 edition 6 114 1.OOO 200 210 0.95 150 200 0.75
provisions average 22 percent and 25 percent higher for 318 1.OOO 370 370 1.00 260 280 0.93
parallel to grain loading and perpendicular to grain ln 1.OOO 570 430 1.33 400 280 1.43
loading,respectively, than those tabulated inthe1986 2-112 7 112 1.OOO 650 460
1.41 430 300 1.43
edition. The overallhigherdesignvalues for parallel 3140.6468796101.44 575 330 1.74
to grain loading (2 ) are aresultoftheprocedure 9 112 1.OOO 650 740 0.88 430 480 0.90
used to translate yie!h limitdesignvalues to the level 314 0.979 1331 960 1.39 871 530 1.64
of proportional limitbaseddesignvaluestabulatedin 1 0.711 190 1190 1.26 939 590 1.59
previous editions and to the equations used to establish
dowel bearing strength values. This procedure included
considering ratios ofyieldlimit and previousdesign member bearing strength, member thicknesses, fastener
diameter and fastener strength.
values forboth joints withwood and withsteelside
members when establishing a uniform conversion factor For joints made with two different species, tabulat-
for eachyield mode equation (see Commentary for eddesignvalues for thespecieswiththelowerdowel
9.3.1 - Yield Mode Equations). In thecaseofperpen- bearing strength may be used in lieu of using the yield
dicular to grain loading (2' ), the overallhigherlevel mode equations of9.3.1withthe appropriate dowel
ofdesignvaluesinthe1991editionreflectstheeffect bearing strength for eachspecies.
ofthe equation used to establishthedowelbearing
strengthvalues for perpendicular to grain loading in 9.3.2-Wood-to-Metal Connections
Table 9A. It is to be noted that lag screw perpendicu-
9.3.2.1 In previouseditions,designvalues for lag
lar to graindesignvalues tabulated inearliereditions
screw joints made withmetalsideplates were estab-
of the Specification were
based on application of
lished as 1.25 times the value for a wood-to-wood joint
procedures originally developed for bolts rather than on
ofequivalentconfiguration as determinedfromEqua-
I
For thickersideplates, tabulated designvalueswere Table C9.3-2 - Comparison of 1991 and 1986 NDS
required to be reduced for the lesser penetration of the Wood-to-Metal SingleShear Lag Screw Lateral
lagscrew. Design Values
Under the methodology of the 1991 edition, lag
screwdesignvalues for joints made withmetalside Stccl Pene
tration Side
plates are determinedusingthe Mode IIIs and Mode
IV equations for wood-to-wood joints in 9.3.1 using a Member Lag Screw Depth Lag Screw Lateral Design Value, Ibs
Thickness Factor
dowelbearing strength, Fcs , applicable to themetal in. L D cd zil Zrnl
used in the side plates (see Appendix I) and the actual in.
in. (1991) 1991 1986 Ratio 19911986 Ratio
thicknessoftheplate as thesidememberthickness.
As previously noted (see Commentary for 9.3.1 -
Background),the factors used to relate yield mode 1/4 4 1/4
1.OOO
310
240
1.29 230 180 1.28
design values to proportional limit based design values 318
1.OOO
510
4801.06 350 290 1.21
tabulated in previous editions were based on lag screw 1/20.8596976101.14 447 320 1.40
joints madewith both wood and metalsideplates. 6 3/8 1O
.OO 510 550 0.93 350 330 1.06
Thus Equations 9.3-2 and 9.3-3apply to joints with 1/2 1.OOO 810 950 0.85 520 490 1.06
metal as well as wood side plate when the appropriate 314 0.875 1452 ls00 0.97 840 660 1.27
input variables are used. 8 1/2 1.OOO 810 980 0.83 5205101.02
3/4 1.OOO 1660 2130 0.78 9609401.02
The lag screwdesignvalues for joints madewith 7/8 1.OOO 2220 2480 0.90 1240 1030 1.20
steelsideplatesgivenin Table 9.3Bassumethesame
strength lag screws as thoseused for Table 9.3A,a 10
5/8 1.OOO 1190 1550 0.77 7207400.97
dowelbearing strength of58,000psi for 1/4inchsteel 3/4 1O
. OO 1660 2200 0.75 9609700.99
1 1.OOO 2870 3680 0.78 1540 1470 1.05
(ASTM A36) side plates, and a dowel bearing strength
- of
45,000psi for steelplateslessthan1/4inch. The Spruce-Pine-Fir:
latter valueis the tensile strength for ASTMA446, 114 4 1/4 1.OOO 280
210 1.33 190 160 1.19
Grade A galvanized sheet steel. It is to be noted from 3/8 1.OOO 4503401.32 290 210 1.38
Table 9.3B that, for constant screw diameter and steel 1/20.859619 440 1.41 369 230 1.60
strength, designvaluesbased on the yield mode equa- 6 3/8 1.OOO 450 490 0.92 290 300 0.97
tions
decrease as steelplate
thickness decreases. 1/2 1.OOO 720 760 0.95 430 400 1.08
Previousmethodologyrecognized no effectof plate 314 0.875 1295 1070 1.21 709 470 1.51
thicknessbelow1/2inch. 8 1/2 1.OOO 720 880 0.82 430 460 0.93
Comparison of 1991 and Earlier Edition 314 1.OOO 1480 1560 0.95 810 690 1.17
7/8 1.OOO 1980 1770 1.12 1030 740 1.39
Values. Differencesin 1991 and earliereditiondesign
values for wood-to-metal lag screw joints are illustrated 10
5/8 1.OOO 1060 1380 0.77 6106600.92
in Table C9.3-2. The 1991designvalues are for joints 314 1.OOO 1480 1970 0.75 8108700.93
madewith1/4inchsideplates. The 1986values apply 1 1.OOO 2550 2640 0.97 1300 1050 1.24
to joints made with1/2inch or thinnersideplates.
The valuesof Cd less than 1.000in Table C9.3-2 are Commentary for 9.3.1 - Yield Mode Equations, Com-
the adjustments applied to 1991 tabulated design values parison).
when thereisless than fulldesignvaluepenetration
( 8 0 ) of thescrewin the mainmember(see9.3.3 of 9.3.2.2 (See Commentary for 7.2.3)
Specification and foregoingCommentary). Joints were 9.3.3-Penetration DepthFactor, Cd
assumed made without washers.
The penetration depth factor provides for reduced
The averagedesignvalue ratios for theconfigura- design values when the length of penetration of the lag
tionscomparedshow 1991designvalues for metal-to- screwinthemainmember, bothshankand threaded
wood connections were 2 percent lower and 16 percent portion, isless than eighttimesthe shank diameter
higher for the parallel and perpendicular to grain ( 8 0 ) . The full proportional limitdesignvalue of lag
.- loading
cases,
respectively,
than
the
comparable 1986 screw joints of anyspeciesisconsidereddeveloped
designvalues. The higheroveralldesignvalues for the whenthispenetration depth occurs (seeCommentary
perpendicular to grain comparisons reflect the effects of for 9.3.1 - Background, 1991 Edition).Penetrations
the equation used to establishdowelbearingstrengths
down to 50 percent or 4 0 ofthefulldesignvalue
for perpendicular to grain loads in Table 9A (see
penetration depth are allowed if tabulated design values and 4.167 are the adjustments used to convert the two
or yield mode equation design values are reduced types of test values to allowable levels (see Commentary
proportionately. for 9.2.1 and 9.3.1 - Background).
The penetration depth of the lag screw in the main To account for the interaction observed in the new
member is calculated as the length of the lag screw (P) lag screwtests, Equation 9.3-6 has been introduced in
minus the sum of the thicknessof the sidemember the 1991 edition for determining the allowabledesign
(t- ), the thicknessof any washer used (w) and the value of lag screwssubject to combined lateral and
lengthof the tapered tip of the screw ( E ) , or withdrawal loads. This equation, a form of the bearing
[P- (t- + w+E)J. Lag screw dimensions, including thread angle to grain equation (see Appendix J), is
and tapered tip lengths, are giveninAppendixL.
Consistentwith the basisoflagscrewdesignvalues 2; = ( W'P)Z' (C9.3-6)
publishedinprevious editions, awasherthicknessof ( W' p ) cos2 a +z'sin2a
1/8 inch for screw diameters of 112 inch and larger and
0 inch for smaller diameter screwsmaybeassumed. where:
Examplesof the use of the Cd factor to adjust Za' = allowabledesignvalue for lagscrewloaded
designvalues for less than full penetration are shown at angle to the surface of mainmember
in Tables C9.3-1 and C9.3-2 and related Commentary.
2' = lateral designvalue for lagscrewconnec-
9.3.4-End Grain Factor, CCg tion
Use of two-thirds the perpendicular to grain lag W' = withdrawal
design
value for lagscrew
screw lateral design value for screws inserted in the end connection per inch of penetration
grain of the main member (62) has been a provision of
theSpecificationsince the 1944 edition. Whendesign p = length of thread penetration in
the
main
values for this case are based on the yield mode equa- member
tions of 9.3. l, the dowel bearing strength of the main a = anglebetweenwoodsurface and direction
member is assumed equal to the perpendicular to grain
of applied load
bearing strength of the species from Table 9A.
The length of penetration ofthe threaded portion
Because of the tendencyof the member to split of the screwin the mainmemberexcludesthelength
under lateral loading, structural lagscrewconnections
of the taperedtip and includes the reductioninpene-
inend grain surfaces should beavoided(62,66).Lag
tration resulting from the use of awasherunderthe
screws in end grain surfaces particularly should not be
screw head.
subjected to combined withdrawal and lateral loading.
Equation C9.3-6 will give
generally conservative
9.3.5-Combined Lateral and Withdrawal Loads
designvalues for load angles greater than 45". Equa-
In the 1977 through the 1986 editions, the Specifi- tion C9.3-6 can also be used to determine the allowable
cation provided that lagscrewssubjected to combined designvalueoflagscrewsembedded at an angleto
lateral and withdrawal loads be analyzed separately for grain inthewoodmember and loaded inadirection
theresistance of the screw to each load. The results normal to the woodmember. For thiscondition a
ofrecent lag screw tests (115) showed that withdrawal would be defined as the angle between
thewood
load components did not reduce lateral load capacity surface and thelagscrew as shownin Figure C9.3-1.
when maximum joint loads are considered.However,
when joint resistance was evaluated at the design load
levelby expressing the strength of the joint loaded at
any angle to the surface as the lesser of the proportion-
al limit load divided by 1.875(2.25/1.2) or themaxi-
mum load divided by 4.167 (5/1.2), an interaction of
the load components was observed with larger diameter
screws at load angles less than 45" (1 15). Use of these
alternative design load basesisrequiredbecauselag
screw lateral designvalues are basedon proportional
limit joint loads whereas withdrawal design values are Fzgure 0 . 3 - 1 Combined Lateraland Withdra walLoadforLag
based on maximum joint loads. The factors of 1.875 Screwlnsertedat an Angle to Wood Surfcz
122 Lag h w s
MJS Commentary