Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Study on Ship Speed Loss of Non Ballast-Water Crude Oil Carrier in High Winds
Tsutomu Momoki, Seiki Onishi, Yoshiho Ikeda
Graduate school of Engineering, Osaka Prefecture University
Sakai, Osaka, Japan
863
crude oil carrier. One of the authors proposed a non-ballast tanker with calculations for the ballast condition are carried out by assuming the
vertically deployable podded propulsors to keep enough propeller depth same conditions as in the full loaded condition mentioned above.
Fujiwara’s equation (2005) is used to calculate the wind forces on the
in the condition. vessel.
Calculation Results
Fig. 3 shows the speed of the vessel at true wind speeds of 10 and 20
m/s when the ship keeps a constant engine power for 15 knots in calm
water. Under 10 m/s winds, there is little change from the windless
condition. Under a 20 m/s headwind, however, the ship speed decreases
by approximately 3 knots. This is caused by the relative wind speed of
approximately 27 m/s and by the large frontal projected areas of the
bridge, funnel and other superstructures. On the contrary, ship speed
Fig. 1 Schematic view of the VLCC and drafts in three load conditions increases about 1 knot in following winds.
Coordinate System 18
The coordinate system used in this study is shown in Fig. 2. All force 16
wind 12
αS Wind speed 0m/s
rudder Mz ψ 10 Wind speed 10m/s
Wind speed 20m/s
δ sail β Fx 8
0 30 60 90 120 150 180
Wind direction [deg.]
Fy traveling direction
Fig. 3 Ship speed in full load condition in wind
Fig. 2 Coordinate system
10
CALCULATION OF SHIP SPEED Wind speed 0m/s
Oblique angle [deg.]
864
large resistance to sway and yaw motions. Since the horsepower of a main engine is usually determined to be
balanced with the hull resistance in a full load condition, the propulsion
Fig. 5 shows the variation of counter rudder angle. This is only about 1 power of a VLCC can be almost maintain the service speed in a
degree even under the high 20 m/s winds. It can be safely said that no ballasted condition. Therefore propulsion powers for the VLCC to sail
significant effect on vessel handling can be seen. with the service speed can be calculated. In the calculations, however,
the maximum propulsion power is assumed to be the power for which
Speed, oblique angle, rudder angle in ballast condition the ship in full load condition keeps the service speed in calm water.
Figs. 7~8 show the calculated speed and the propulsion power of the
Fig. 6 shows the speed of the vessel at true wind speeds of 10 and 20 vessel. The results demonstrate that the VLCC can maintain a service
m/s when the ship keeps a constant engine power for 15 knots in calm speed for almost all wind direction except in head wind conditions.
water at ballast condition. Although speed variation in a ballast Under a 20 m/s headwind, however, the ship can not sail in the service
condition shows the same tendency as a full load condition, the amount speed and the ship speed decreases by approximately 2.5 knots.
of speed variation in a light condition is larger than that of a full load
condition. It should be noted that the main engine of a VLCC in a Fig. 9 shows the calculated results of lee angle due to oblique sailing,
ballast condition has remaining power because the resistance acting on which is a maximum of about 5 degree even under 20 m/s winds. These
the hull in the condition is much lower than that in a full load condition. results are much larger than those in a full load condition shown in Fig.
4. This may be because the project area above the waterline of the
18 VLCC becomes large and a volume beneath the waterline of the hull
becomes small in ballast condition.
16
Ship speed [knot]
18 2
16 0
Ship speed [knot]
865
condition. These results show that a decrease of hull resistance is larger oblique angle reaches up to 35 degree when the wind speed and
than the wind resistance under 20 m/s winds. direction are 20 m/s and 35 degree, respectively. Also, the rudder angle
is the maximum to be about 4.5 degree. These results warn that the
18 existing VLCC in non-ballast-water condition would severely degrade
the course stability and maneuverability performances.
16
Ship speed [knot]
30 Wind speed 20m/s Performance of the new non-ballast-water VLCC in high winds is
25 investigated. Fig. 16 shows the estimated power necessary to cruise at
20 15 knots and ship speed. Under a 20 m/s headwind, the ship speed
15 reduction of a new ship becomes smaller 1 knot than that of a
conventional ship. At relative wind angles of about 20~60 degrees, the
10
required propulsion power reduces. The required propulsion power is
5 increased, however, under winds from further behind, at angles above
0 70 degree. This result shows that the advantage conferred by following
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 winds has been reduced. These may be because the influence of winds
Wind direction [deg.] becomes small when a bridge structure becomes low.
Fig. 13 Calculated oblique angle under winds in non-ballast condition
180000 20
5 conventional ship (thrust)
160000 19
4 Wind speed 0m/s new ship (thrust)
Wind speed 10m/s 140000 convetional ship (speed)
Rudder angle [deg.]
2 17
100000
1
80000 16
0
60000
-1 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 15
40000
-2 14
20000
-3
Wind direction [deg.] 0 13
Fig. 14 Calculated rudder angle under winds in non-ballast condition 0 30 60 90 120 150 180
Wind direction [deg.]
Figs. 13~14 show the calculated oblique angle and the rudder angle, Fig. 16 Propulsion power and ship speed for conventional/new tanker
respectively. Since the VLCC is in very shallow draft condition, the in non-ballast condition (at true wind speed of 20 m/s)
866
45 Conventional ship (oblique angle)
6 found to reduce the needed propulsion power by up to 30% at 20 m/s
New ship (oblique angle) wind. Fig. 20 shows the oblique angle and rudder angle. The rudder
40 5
Conventional ship (rudder angle) angle is almost unchanged, but the oblique angle increases somewhat,
35 4
Oblique angle [deg.]
New ship (rudder angle)
Top view
Fig. 18 Schematic view of the new crude oil carrier with sails
180000 20
160000 without sails
(thrust) 19
140000
with sails 18
Ship speed[knot]
120000 (thrust)
Thrust [kgf]
100000 17
80000 16 Fig. 21 Assumed course
60000
15 Figs. 22~23 show the ship speeds on the passage from BH to TK. And,
40000
14 Figs. 24~27 show both the speeds and the propulsion power require to
20000 maintain a speed of 15 knot on the passage from TK to BH. Table 3
0 13 shows the calculated navigation time.
0 30 60 90 120 150 180
Wind direction [deg.] Fig. 22 shows the ship speeds from BH to TK in winter. In the passage
Fig. 19 Propulsion power for new VLCC without/with sails in non- from Bahrain to the Strait of Malacca (101 degrees of east longitude),
ballast condition (wind speed=20 m/s) there is almost no benefit from using sails, except during the eastward
course past the southern tip of India. Since in the passage from the
The change in propulsion power due to the sails is calculated. Fig. 19 Strait of Malacca to Tokyo, the vessel mainly meets crosswinds, the
shows the propulsion power for new VLCC in non-ballast condition at sails increases speed. However, the benefit of the sail system is minor.
15 knot in a 20 m/s wind. Attaching the sail system to the new VLCC is This may be because the wind speed on the course never exceeds 15
867
m/s in the meteorological data used for these calculations. Figs. 24~27 show that a ship resistance of the non-ballast VLCC is
smaller than a ship resistance of the ballast VLCC. Moreover, the non-
Fig. 23 shows the ship speeds from BH to TK in the summer. Since it is ballast VLCC with the sail system obtains the big gain from the wind
quite unlikely that a real VLCC would deliberately sail through a forces.
tropical cyclone, the meteorological data that show little influence from
tropical cyclone are chosen for the simulation. Therefore, the speed is
lower than estimated for the winter passage; the fluctuations in speed winter (January) : ballast condition
160000 16.40
due to wind and the benefits of the sails are estimated to be quite small. 140000 16.20
Thrust [kgf]
100000 15.80
winter (January) : full load condition
16.00 80000 to ME without sails (thrust) 15.60
15.75 60000 to ME with sails (thrust) 15.40
to ME without sails (speed)
15.50 40000 to ME with sails (speed) 15.20
15.25 20000 15.00
V[knot]
15.00 0 14.80
14.75 60 80 100 120 140
14.50 to TK degree of longitude
14.25 to TK with sails Fig. 24 Ship speed in ballast condition in winter with and without sails
14.00
60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140
degree of longitude summer (July) : ballast condition
160000 16.40
Fig. 22 Ship speed in full load condition with and without sails (winter) 140000 16.20
Thrust [kgf]
100000 15.80
summer (July) : full load condition
16.00 80000 to ME without sails (thrust) 15.60
15.75 60000 to ME with sails (thrust) 15.40
to ME without sails (speed)
15.50 40000 to ME with sails (speed) 15.20
15.25 20000 15.00
V[knot]
15.00 0 14.80
14.75 60 80 100 120 140
14.50 to TK degree of longitude
14.25 to TK with sails Fig. 25 Ship speed in ballast condition in summer with and without
14.00 sails
60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140
degree of longitude
Fig. 23 Ship speed in full load condition with and without sails winter (January) : non-ballast condition
160000 16.40
to ME without sails (thrust)
(summer) 140000 16.20
to ME with sails (thrust)
Fig. 24 shows the ship speed and propulsion power during the passage 100000 to ME with sails (speed)
15.80
from TK to BH in the ballast condition in winter. The demand for 80000 15.60
propulsion power increases dramatically after the vessel entered the 60000 15.40
East Indian Ocean (around 90 degrees of east longitude), but it is able 40000 15.20
to maintain a speed of 15 knot. It can also be seen that, overall, the 20000 15.00
required propulsion power slightly decreases with the sail system. 0 14.80
60 80 100 120 140
Fig. 25 shows the ship speed and simultaneous propulsion power degree of longitude
during the passage from TK to BH in the ballast condition in summer. Fig. 26 Ship speed in non-ballast condition in winter with and without
The ship speed of 15 knot can’t be maintained, due to tropical low- sails
pressure systems around 65 degrees of east longitude. There is a very
slight benefit from the sail system, depending on the wind direction in
this case. summer (July) : non-ballast condition
160000 16.40
to ME without sails (thrust)
140000 16.20
to ME with sails (thrust)
Fig. 26 shows the ship speed and propulsion power during the passage
Ship speed [knot]
120000 16.00
to ME without sails (speed)
Thrust [kgf]
868
Table 3 shows that the benefit of the sails on the fully loaded VLCC is
extremely low, less than 1%. However, this increases to 1.8% in the 5. Attaching flat plates as sails enables the VLCC to obtain some
ballast condition and 5.2% in the non-ballast condition. This is because propulsion power from the wind. Ten plates 10 m high and 5 m wide
the draft is shallower, reducing the resistance of the water, and are estimated to reduce the needed propulsion power by up to 30% in a
magnifying the benefit of the sail system. wind speed of 20 m/s.
Table 3 Navigation time per passage and annual mean propulsion 6. Converting a VLCC to the non-ballast condition allows a reduction
power of propulsion power by about 25% from the ballast condition, on a
Full load condition passage from Tokyo to Bahrain. Adding sails to the non-ballast vessel
Total navigation time allows a further reduction of about 5% in the propulsion power on a
To TK without sails 414.56 hour single passage, due to power from the wind.
To TK with sails 411.57 hour
Ballast condition This study have been carried out in a research project on developing a
Total E.H.P. next generation tankers and bulk carriers with five Japanese shipyards
To BH without sails 109487.93 kgf and relating companies. The authors would like to appreciate these
To BH with sails 107506.90 kgf companies for their support to the research project.
Non-ballast condition
Total E.H.P. REFERENCES
To BH without sails 82459.48 kgf
Fujiwara, T, Ueno, M, and Ikeda, Y (2005). "A New Estimation
To BH with sails 78203.44 kgf
Method of Wind Forces and Moments acting on Ships on the basis of
Physical Component Models," Journal of the Japan Society of Naval
CONCLUSIONS Architects and Ocean Engineers, Vol 2, pp 243-255.
Fujii, H, and Tuda, T (1961). "Experimental Researches on Rudder
In this study, it is estimated how much wind reduces the speed of a Performance (2)," Journal of Zosen Kiokai, Vol 110, pp 31-42.
crude oil carrier and changes the oblique angle and rudder angle, and Inoue, S, Hirano M, Hirakawa, Y, and Mukai K (1979) "The
how much propulsion power is required in order to maintain the service Hydrodynamic Derivatives on Ship Maneuverability in Even Keel
speed. Based on these findings, a new ship concept was proposed and Condition," Journal of Seibu Zosen Kai Transactions of the West-
simulations of passages in open seas are carried out. The following Japan Society of Naval Architects, Vol 57, pp 13-15
results are obtained. Kijima, K, Katsuno, T, Nakiri, Y, and Furukawa, Y (1990) "On the
Manoeuvring Performance of a Ship with the Parameter of Loading
1. In a full load condition, there is almost no change in the oblique Condition," Journal of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan, Vol
angle or rudder angle under a strong wind. However, speed reduction of 168, pp 141-148.
the VLCC is 3knot under a 20 m/s headwind. Momoki, T, Onishi, S, Ikeda, Y, and Katayama T (2009) "A Study on
Wind Pressure Characteristics of Ships with Large Superstructures,"
2. There is a speed reduction due to wind at angles up to 45 degrees on Int J Offshore and Polar Eng, ISOPE, Vol 19, No 3, pp 563-569.
a VLCC in the ballast condition, but except for the case of direct Momoki, T, Fujiwara, H, Katayama, T, and Ikeda, Y (2009) "A Study on
headwinds, the ship speed can be maintained by increasing the main Developing a NextGeneration Vessel -Cruising Performance of Latest
engine output power. The oblique angle and rudder angle are greater Model of PCC in Strong Wimd-," Conference Proceedings of the
than in a fully loaded vessel, and both reach maximum angles of Japan Society of Naval Architects and Ocean Engineers, Osaka, Japan,
several degrees under high winds. Vol 8, pp 239-242.
Momoki, T, Onishi, S, Ikeda, Y, and Katayama, T (2008) "Study on
3. The non-ballast water VLCC can maintain a service speed even Wind Pressure Characteristics of PCC," Conference Proceedings of the
under a 20 m/s high wind because of lower resistance. Japan Society of Naval Architects and Ocean Engineers, Osaka, Japan,
Vol 7K, pp 53-56.
4. The ship speed reduction in head wind conditions decreases when the Tanaka, Y (2003). "Economical Speed and Life Cycle Value of Ships,"
bridge of a VLCC is reduced in height and moved to the bow. The Fourth JTTC Symposium on Ship Performance at Sea, pp 10-19.
869